Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 12/11/2012 eottr City of Petaluma, CA 4) City Council Chambers A i' City Hall, 11 English Street 4";1:11,1.1r Petaluma, CA 94952 Telephone 707/778-4301 /Fax 707/778-4498 iiista E-Mail cdd @ci.petaluma.ca.us Web Page http://www.ci.petaluma.ca.us Planning Commission Minutes Tuesday, December 11, 2012 - Draft Minutes L ROLL CALL: (07:01 PM) Present: Gabe Kearney, Dennis Elias, Bill Wolpert, Jennifer Pierre,Ray Johnson,Joe Noriel, Terry Kosewic Absent: Melissa Abercrombie, Alicia Kae Herries 2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Approve the October 9, 2012 Historic and Cultural Preservation Committee Minutes,and the November 13, 2012 Planning Commission Minutes. (07:01 PM) Motion: Approve the October 9,2012 Historic and Cultural Preservation Committee Minutes Moved by Ray Johnson, seconded by Bill Wolpert. Vote: Motion carried 7-0. Yes: Gabe Kearney; Dennis Elias; Bill Wolpert; Jennifer Pierre; Ray Johnson;Joe Noriel;Terry Kosewic Absent: Melissa Abercrombie; Alicia Kae Herries Council Member Kearney Chair Pierre Heather Hines, Planning Manager Approval of the November 13, 2012 Planning Commission Minutes will be tabled due to a lack of quorum. 3. PUBLIC COMMENT: The Committee will hear public comments only on matters over which it has jurisdiction. There will be no Committee discussion or.action. The Chair will allot no more than three minutes to any individual. If more than three persons wish to speak,their time will be allotted so that the total amount of time allocated to this agenda item will be 15 minutes. (07:02 PM) Public Comment Opened Public Comment Closed 4. CORRESPONDENCE: Receive information from staff on Commission/Committee correspondence since the prior Planning Commission/Historic and Cultural Preservation Committee meeting. (07:03 PM) . Heather Hines; Planning Manager 5. PLANNING MANAGER'S REPORT: Receive Planning Manager's Report. (07:03 PM) Heather Hines,Planning Manager 6. COMMISSIONER/COMMITTEE MEMBER REPORTS/LIAISON REPORTS: Receive Commissioner/Committee Member Reports and Reports from standing Commission/Committee Liaisons. (07:04 PM) Council Member Kearney Chair Pierre Commissioner Elias Chair Pierre Commissioner Elias Chair Pierre 7. PUBLIC HEARING NEW BUSINESS - HISTORIC AND CULTURAL PRESERVATION COMMITTEE: Colleen Mahoney, architect, has submitted an application for Historic Site Plan and Architectural Review on behalf of Mark and Terese Thomas,property owners,to renovate the existing commercial building, formerly Carithers Department Store, located at the northwest corner of Kentucky Street and Western Avenue (109 Kentucky).within the Petaluma Historic Commercial District. TITLE: Carithers Building Renovation FILE: 12-SPC-0547 ADDRESS: 109 Kentucky Street STAFF: Tiffany Robbe, Senior Planner (07:07 PM) Staff Report- Attachment A Attachment B -Aerial Attachment C- Project Description Attachment D- Historical Evaluation Attachment E- Historic Building Specific Document. Attachment F- Plans Chair Pierre Tiffany Robbe, Senior Planner Chair Pierre Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Robbe Terese Thomas, Owner-Applicant Mark Thomas-Owner-Applicant Alice Carey, Historic Architect Carey and Company Commissioner Wolpert Ms. Carey Chair Pierre Ms. Carey Commissioner Johnson Ms. Carey Colleen Mahoney, Architect Chair Pierre Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Mahoney Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Mahoney Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Mahoney Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Mahoney Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Mahoney Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Mahoney Ms. Robbe Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Robbe Chair Pierre Ms. Robbe Commissioner Elias Ms. Robbe Ms. Mahoney Heather Hines,Planning Manager Commissioner Elias Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Elias Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Elias Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Elias Council Member Kearney Ms. Mahoney Council Member Kearney Ms. Mahoney Council Member Kearney Ms.Mahoney Chair Pierre Public Comment Opened Public Comment Closed Commissioner Elias Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Elias. Ms. Hines Ms. Carey Commissioner Elias Committee Member Kosewic Chair Pierre Ms. Carey Chair Pierre Ms. Carey Commissioner Elias Ms. Carey Commissioner Wolpert Ms. Carey Commissioner Wolpert Ms. Carey Commissioner Wolpert Ms.Mahoney Commissioner Wolpert Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Wolpert Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Wolpert Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Wolpert Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Wolpert Commissioner Elias Ms.Mahoney Commissioner Elias Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Elias Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Elias Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Elias Ms. Mahoney Commissioner Elias Committee Member Noriel Committee Member KoseWic Commissioner Johnson Commissioner Wolpert Council Member Kearney Commissioner.Elias Chair Pierre Committee Member Kosewic Motion: Approve Historic Site Plan and Architectual Review for renovation of the Carithers building and adding conditions that new windows are recessed, building name added as design element on facades, and that overall height of 47'2" but not including elevator. Moved by Gabe Kearney, seconded by Ray Johnson. Vote: Motion.carried 5-2. Yes: Gabe,Kearney; Dennis Elias; Ray Johnson;Joe Noriel;Terry Kosewic No: Bill Wolpert;Jennifer Pierre Absent: Melissa Abercrombie;Alicia Kae Herries Leslie Thomsen, Assistant City Attorney Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Hines Committee Member Kosewic Council Member Kearney Commissioner Elias Chair Pierre Committee Member Kosewic Ms. Thomsen Commissioner Elias Motion: Approve Historic Site Plan and Architectual Review for renovation of the Carithers building with a strong recommendation adding conditions that new windows are recessed,building name added as design element on facades, and that overall height of 47'2" but not including elevator. Moved by Terry Kosewic, seconded by Ray Johnson. Vote: Motion carried 5-2. Yes: Gabe Kearney; Dennis Elias; Ray Johnson;Terry Kosewic;Joe Noriel No: Bill Wolpert;Jennifer Pierre Absent:Melissa Abercrombie; Alicia Kae Herries Chair Pierre Chair Pierre 8. ADJOURN: Adjourn the Historic and Cultural Preservation Committee. (09:19 PM) 9. ROLL CALL: (09:20 PM) Present: Gabe Kearney, Dennis Elias, Bill Wolpert,Jennifer Pierre, Ray Johnson Absent: Melissa Abercrombie,Alicia Kae Henries 10. PUBLIC HEARING -NEW BUSINESS-PLANNING COMMISSION: Text Amendment to the City of Petaluma Implementing Zoning Ordinance Chapters 4,10, and 27 and Smart Code Sections 3 and 9. TITLE: Downtown Zoning Regulations STAFF: Scott Duiven, Senior Planner(09:21 PM) Staff Report- Attachments A-C Scott Duiven,Senior Planner Chair Pierre Council Member Kearney Mr. Duiven Council Member Kearney Heather Hines, Planning Manager Mr. Duiven Council Member Kearney Ms. Hines Commissioner Elias Leslie Thomsen,Assistant City Attorney Chair Pierre Commissioner Wolpert Mr. Duiven Commissioner Wolpert Mr. Duiven Commissioner Wolpert Mr. Duiven Ms. Thomsen Commissioner Wolpert Ms. Thomsen Commissioner Wolpert Mr. Duiven Ms. Thomsen Commissioner Johnson Mr. Duiven Chair Pierre Commissioner Elias Ms. Thomsen Commissioner Elias Chair Pierre Ms. Thomsen Chair Pierre Public Comment Opened Stacey DeGooyer, Massage Therapist James Bruce,Owner of Aces Over Eight Tattoo Constance Fitzgerald declined to speak Michelle Wellington, Owner of Soft Shell Devin Fleudujon ceded her time to Michelle Wellington Public Comment Closed Chair Pierre Motion: Table Discussion Moved by Dennis Elias. The motion did not receive a second and was lost. Chair Pierre Council Member Kearney Commissioner Johnson Commissioner Wolpert Chair Pierre Mr. Duiven Chair Pierre Mr. Duiven Chair Pierre Mr. Duiven Commissioner Wolpert Council Member Kearney Mr. Duiven Ms.Thomsen Council Member Kearney Mr.Duiven Chair Pierre Ms. Thomsen Ms. Hines Chair Pierre Council Member Kearney Chair Pierre Commissioner Elias Motion: Table item until directions and clarification is provided by City Council. Moved by Dennis Elias, seconded by Ray Johnson. Ms. Hines Chair Pierre Commissioner Elias Vote: Motion carried 7-0. Yes: Gabe Kearney; Dennis Elias; Bill Wolpert; Jennifer Pierre;Ray Johnson; Terry Kosewic; Joe Noriel Absent: Melissa Abercrombie; Alicia Kae Herries 11. ADJOURN: Adjourn to the next regularly scheduled Committee meeting.APPEAL STATEMENT: Within fourteen(14)days following the date of a decision of the HCPC/Planning Commission,the decision may be appealed to the City Council by the applicant or by any other interested party. If no appeal is made within that time, the decision shall be final. An appeal shall be addressed to the Council in writing and shall be filed with the City Clerk. Said appeal shall be accompanied by the appeal fee as specified by Resolution 2010-206-N.C.S. as adopted by the City Council. The appeal shall state specifically the grounds for the appeal and the relief sought by the appellant. (Zoning Ordinance.§24.070)