HomeMy WebLinkAboutStaff Report 4.C 07/01/2019p. L U Agenda Item
U0
Y85$
DATE: July 1, 2019
Lid
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council through City Manage
FROM: I Leonard C. Thompson, Fire Chief
SUBJECT: Resolution Authorizing the Purchase of One Demonstration Model Emergency
Type I Ambulance from Braun Northwest Inc., Chehalis, WA, and all Associated
Equipment, in the Amount of $375,000
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council adopt the attached Resolution Authorizing the Purchase
of One Demonstration Model Emergency Type I Ambulance from Braun Northwest Inc.,
Chehalis, WA, and all Associated Equipment, in the Amount of $375,000.
BACKGROUND
Emergency medical service requests have been on the steady rise for the past decade in
Petaluma. The Petaluma Fire Department (PFD) currently staffs two full-time 24/7 Advanced
Life Support (ALS) paramedic ambulances and one part-time Basic Life Support (BLS)
ambulance. The Department has two reserve ambulances that are placed into service when there
are anticipated increases in demand for large events, or when a front-line unit is placed out -of -
service for emergency repairs or routine maintenance. For Fiscal Year 2019-20, the City
budgeted the addition of a new firefighter -staffed paramedic ambulance with full cost recovery
to fulfill the increased demand for service. PFD now seeks Council approval to purchase a
demonstration model emergency Type I ambulance.
DISCUSSION
There are currently two PFD ambulances that are in the "reserve" fleet. Both have roughly
125,000 miles on them and are model years 2012 and 2013. Upstaffing the third ALS ambulance
will occur at the completion of our new -hire fire academy in mid-September. One of the current
reserve units will be placed into full-time service. This is a short-term solution due to the mileage
and condition of the reserve units. This also places one part-time ambulance and three full-time
ambulances into service with only one reserve to cover upstaffing or maintenance and repair of
front-line units.
To meet the immediate need, PFD recommends purchasing one base model demonstration
(demo) unit from Braun Northwest, Inc. The demonstration unit. is Braun's standard base model
that requires no additional customization or fabrication to meet PFD'S needs. This keeps the cost
1
ATTACHMENT 1
as low as possible and greatly reduces production time.. The last four fire department ambulance
purchases have been demonstration units from Braun Northwest, with a couple having been used
as actual demonstration units around the state prior to coming to Petaluma.
A new unit built to PFD'S specifications would typically be purchased through a formal,
competitive bidding process, require a fabrication -to -delivery time schedule of over a year, and
increase the proposed cost by thousands of dollars over the demonstration model ambulances.
The opportunity to take possession of a vehicle through a demo purchase is essential to getting
the unit in service in the shortest amount of time and at the most competitive price.
Purchase of the identified demo vehicle has been considered under Petaluma Municipal Code
Section 4.04.050: "The procedures set forth in Sections 4.04.080 and 4.04.090 may be
dispensed with only when an emergency requires that an order be placed with the nearest
available source of supply, when the commodity can be obtained from only one vendor or when
purchase is pursuant to Section 4.04.100. " This item meets the nearest available/sole source of
supply exception stated in the purchasing ordinance because of the factors stated below.
Utilizing a vendor that can provide very similar products to what is already in use provides
consistency to crew members who are not always assigned to the same apparatus. Similar
platforms, with similar configuration and tool locations, create a second -nature comfort and the
stress of moving between rigs is eliminated. Consistency in equipment parts and configuration
reduces maintenance costs and makes needed repairs quicker due to replacement part
redundancy/ availability and familiarity with the equipment.
The identified vendor for the quickest availability of a suitably equipped ambulance is Braun
Northwest, Inc. Their demonstrator model ambulances meet the dual Firefighter/Paramedic
specifications and are a direct match of size and type to the others already in use.
This proposal meets City Council's "Financial Stability - Improve and Enhance Fiscal Stability
and Sustainability" goal, by utilizing demonstration models that have no customization to
cabinet size or configuration and no change to the patient compartment layout.
PUBLIC OUTREACH
This agenda item appeared on the City's tentative agenda document on June 17, 2019, which was
a publicly -noticed meeting. It was also referenced on page 2, paragraph 2 of the 5/20/19 City
Council Resolution entitled "Preliminary FY 2019-2020 City of Petaluma Budget, Adoption of
City Budget Resolution and First Reading of FY 2019-2020 City Appropriations Ordinances"
(Item 4A). City fees for service, including ambulance and EMS rates, are authorized by the City
Council of Petaluma per resolution and adopted July 1 of each year.
FINANCIAL IMPACTS
The cost for this Braun Northwest ambulance is $228,837.02 and includes the base ambulance
cost and tax and some essential equipment (electronics, radios, etc.). The cost of the ambulance
itself is only slightly higher than past purchases of the same unit. The total cost of this purchase,
2
ATTACHMENT 1
which will include all necessary fire and EMS equipment, is $375,000. This amount is
significantly higher than past ambulance requests because a fully -stocked, new 24/7 ambulance
is being added to the fleet, not simply a replacement unit. This purchase will include all items
needed to completely outfit an ambulance including heart monitors, a patient gurney, medical
supplies, medical equipment, and fire -fighting gear that is normally transferred from the old
ambulance to the new one. The cost of the Braun ambulance will be $228,837.02 with 90%
($205,953.32) due upon delivery and the remaining 10% ($22,883.70) due and owing 30 days
after delivery. The additional equipment will be paid for in full or invoiced as it is purchased
and is estimated to be $146,162.98.
This requested purchasewill be funded via the Vehicle & Equipment Replacement Fund. The
necessary funding of $375,000 has already been budgeted for in the FY 2019-2020 City of
Petaluma Budget and will be offset by an increase in EMS fees for service.
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Resolution.
ATTACHMENT 1
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE PURCHASE OF
ONE DEMONSTRATION MODEL EMERGENCY TYPE I
AMBULANCE FROM BRAUN NORTHWEST, INC., CHEHALIS, WA, AND
ALL ASSOCIATED EQUIPMENT, IN THE AMOUNT OF $375,000
WHEREAS, to combat the steadily rising calls for medical service, the funding for the
purchase of a new ambulance and six new firefighter/paramedics to staff a third full-time
Advanced Life Support ambulance was included in the FY 19/20 budget; and
WHEREAS, due to high mileage and condition of the current reserve ambulances, one
can be temporarily used as the third ALS ambulance until the newly purchased ambulance is
put into service, a timeline of approximately six months; and
WHEREAS, the fastest and most cost-effective way to purchase a new ambulance is to
forgo a customized unit, and find one that immediately meets all fire department
specifications for dual role Firefighter/Paramedic emergency response; and
WHEREAS, the closest available. supplier of an ambulance which meets fire department
needs and can be delivered in the fastest timefiame in located at Braun Northwest Inc.,
Chehalis, WA; and
WHEREAS, Braun Northwest makes a demonstration base model that is always in
production, requires no costly customization or alterations and is identical to the last four
ambulances that the fire department has purchased, thereby meeting City Council's
"Financial Stability - Improve and Enhance Fiscal Stability and Sustainability" goal; and
WHEREAS, this item meets the nearest available/sole source of supply exception as
stated in Petaluma Municipal Code Section 4.04.050 as it provides that "The procedures set
forth in Sections 4.04.080 and 4.04.090 may be dispensed with only when an emergency
requires that an order be placed with the nearest available source of supply, when the
commodity can be obtained from only one vendor or when purchase is pursuant to Section
4.04.100".
4
ATTACHMENT 1
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council:
Authorizes the City Manager to execute all documents necessary to purchase one
demonstration model emergency type I ambulance from Braun Northwest Inc., Chehalis,
WA, and all associated equipment, in the amount of $375,000.
0
ff]
m
ewe
Attach
771
13
nt 2
OL 91 m IL Ar �m
AWN
f
10
a
Z7,
C�f
nz
Fit
LL
�gpII
P Q F
A
Iv
lh Vii'' m;' 1
p.
'000% w w Ai JOPON 0% 0 An 400%
ff Is
t
m m #off% WAS 1% 1 JIM AVA%L
Ik N
u curu u rusu ts
I
MR a
ANAL fA it
CNI IA
AA'
AP% AMA 9 oil
y
p 110
soft J^ ME 21
i utz')umwvNr1ry1 -'a -1. 4 0 t f 1 Z' J--4
4
�'j 771
A
-7
JS
1.
b
df
u
u
Na
�'j 771
A
JS
1.
b
df
u
u
77, 1,
:it
14
cl
r IL N
lex/
Lv y
a
Ar la AIF 11 A
EMMA
m d4om,6, 1 s u
op*
ILM; d: u ru u
'ONE% uur % m m u n itiv 6 4v:7'6
y
u r
un & A toi Avg% u w n /054%
*mI JIWL u *Am u A 5
u r q1L IL N
IL I
il"N u alm H:1 34"R4 t 00% r 7. U'
AIMPRAII,
as
LOIuur 3 oft A101i u Api m
U,
Aob%L A#N%k jow% do-% soft
u &off%
A X Ar 31
Ic cl rc; uu n u1c, I I
ff m
%
iw 0
uwth 29
A
s 4
141 it r t 12,%
0 WOMM
S 5 2
Ar
W coni 11( ao� b 1 4 6. 6"
• ME
Heat y 42.12%
• a 5 ra
ly
cutUIntegrated 36].351%
0
11
JOI f!
.0 -ft
It I
O-UM1 I lar 0
HPUL 1 H �O J u
y
1.
b
df
Na
11
JOI f!
.0 -ft
It I
O-UM1 I lar 0
HPUL 1 H �O J u
y
m
"I � --- , "'I'l �E- '�' 1,
Vxe
, x,
q: 4S
El
n
O� -, . "!� ''
eo
NA
Measure
is Building Codes,, Zoning,,
conb r UL ul I "UH t:mf= lt,3
"WI
EduLclti U jr i a, id U U t SrA or ( Of% II
, CON %I L h
A40% Apo% L#W% jpffi%� Lom%joft IlL Al 0 0 *A, L.#W& t W LO'%
is Ar
y d I u W
U
Cdl i S a A
tl N
IVA I
y
k
e-
,P-,& OWN
ru cl d w CUR J,
y
*1
IL a
IL Ar
H e d A Lr: t' %VAP L I lkvmi n
n
tIC:L VIf U LO 11
48 ml A 6 0
lv%l i,[LJ""l r i L""L a L04L c
va i e I I
• Identifiy sites
0 - V%
U
Ul
LO% iry fw% M r X
-
d
Om%
L I CPi l< b Us, *1:1 d *111• c: s i e
IL ff
IL I
b u 1 d lb a 'LY d U m t= E
r
I
U
A~
id Uv.;aaU 11 U L* I
wlef% 11*1 to rcl"Nduut
IL N
y
cdl t""r all U Z)t U
Ll
Ell
n
nput rceigurN 4 of 1
110
"I � --- , "'I'l �E- '�' 1,
Vxe
, x,
q: 4S
El
n
O� -, . "!� ''
eo
NA
Measure
is Building Codes,, Zoning,,
conb r UL ul I "UH t:mf= lt,3
"WI
EduLclti U jr i a, id U U t SrA or ( Of% II
, CON %I L h
A40% Apo% L#W% jpffi%� Lom%joft IlL Al 0 0 *A, L.#W& t W LO'%
is Ar
y d I u W
U
Cdl i S a A
tl N
IVA I
y
k
e-
,P-,& OWN
ru cl d w CUR J,
y
*1
IL a
IL Ar
H e d A Lr: t' %VAP L I lkvmi n
n
tIC:L VIf U LO 11
48 ml A 6 0
lv%l i,[LJ""l r i L""L a L04L c
va i e I I
• Identifiy sites
0 - V%
U
Ul
LO% iry fw% M r X
-
d
Om%
L I CPi l< b Us, *1:1 d *111• c: s i e
IL ff
IL I
b u 1 d lb a 'LY d U m t= E
r
I
U
A~
id Uv.;aaU 11 U L* I
wlef% 11*1 to rcl"Nduut
IL N
y
cdl t""r all U Z)t U
Ll
Ell
n
nput rceigurN 4 of 1
Zikit
it
till
it
tiA q '\:� m:re \, "# : 'R ,' 9a„ d LkPirr llA,W II,
it
7`: pit :i
Ol:
iIlk
ir
4,ij
L%
F]
Oil
AOM% I
F,
Ar IM IS d i
IL A A
1k I in AM
m m u n i tkYvU r V 1= A
ared with the community tro multiple
online c�annels
City social
m
channels
ol ELeia ----tta
L m
4-% L*-% 0% ML A, a em% AF 9L
tj t:flpp%lt I lu"Wolt:
IMMEMM
JON%
jr
• live: in Petaluma
• 31%live and work in Petaluma
• 1:
:
5% work in Peta�uma1
y Afmi a AN Loft Ami
Ar 'M. m is
U MUM c
U
t IL B mi
to y Lot
• 7 GfOUpS
• 1 IN Eac ro'lull leb a City CouncilMember
13
m
0
I.. � � iTiiai�a
Input Summary 1 -Page 5 of 191
n^
Mit
Wit
ared with the community tro multiple
online c�annels
City social
m
channels
ol ELeia ----tta
L m
4-% L*-% 0% ML A, a em% AF 9L
tj t:flpp%lt I lu"Wolt:
IMMEMM
JON%
jr
• live: in Petaluma
• 31%live and work in Petaluma
• 1:
:
5% work in Peta�uma1
y Afmi a AN Loft Ami
Ar 'M. m is
U MUM c
U
t IL B mi
to y Lot
• 7 GfOUpS
• 1 IN Eac ro'lull leb a City CouncilMember
13
m
0
I.. � � iTiiai�a
Input Summary 1 -Page 5 of 191
a
0
r -I
N
q
13
n
a
C
0
c
0
71
m
In
ub
VIlk pIguowk
jair1 " i ^ %
;i
mE
0
rn �-i LO
10
ew
Faii j
f7l
U
si
r1m
3
0
JtOw4'7`
U
row
�Iiii jw, OWL mm
%moo
FIG Ls:
Li �a
rii em, 4;1,
"Mat
71t,
C
,Now
13
07
lip omit c IF OF,
! Ilia
Ali
�7t
4 n f
P
A F
I It
Input 6' ul 1111 lao"r, ci �j 7 0 f 1
!D
JtOw4'7`
U
row
�Iiii jw, OWL mm
%moo
FIG Ls:
Li �a
rii em, 4;1,
"Mat
71t,
C
,Now
13
07
lip omit c IF OF,
! Ilia
Ali
�7t
4 n f
P
A F
I It
Input 6' ul 1111 lao"r, ci �j 7 0 f 1
Fil
TNI,
;.,.. � O�l� � "� ctt S��. � \S�}jvr�� ��'�t�`ti���7t1?'c4i\;s?} t \\ �b �ti `., \\�ti m`��1�.;
Pit
ISFIN I w
As
1441 1 t .0 1
Ell
I.
1.C 4
Miss a i ME $in
WE
to
.....................
—R,
am " 'n ^Jh wap n WWW �'', "a"'a�+ �wwa & �w� . ' "
12
.............
E
7
Y
f
le
U
i
Attachment 2
0
Ml! 111, "A"'ArNs
19
13
11
a
% 4
u
A
m.
xal
1al
13 Iloy
CT
F rl�
kw
In
C I
elta is a
eta ...:m a is a
eta uma is a c
eta uma i"' s a c I
ewe
'30W 4
LSI*0111]
t.i 911A
1,*
top i;lmi
tow
C4.
dr
3
Ali 2. 1
ti
rim
'em mom 1r,
00
Imi last Ai
Too
ME
-,Nb*
a 1"TNow
IM'011,
aw
"I'll", .................................
77 '
MW, am r .
JJ
m
U
04 t,
'Imam
t
:3
Attachment 2
ow AT 11
L*
c
1 IL -m 'oft
I I Oyu ut
In.ut 6wmiomry 1 r U
11
'30W 4
77 '
MW, am r .
JJ
m
U
04 t,
'Imam
t
:3
Attachment 2
ow AT 11
L*
c
1 IL -m 'oft
I I Oyu ut
In.ut 6wmiomry 1 r U
11
4
C� . �,, � �� =2hwl �tl) 117, f 7"- P: ! '
Flu4=3
47,
I J f i
u u m a r Avol F I!
Ij
-- ---1 1 0',4-', i� I: --l", , � , --7' -11 . 17", P,'� Z- � ;k �, ; �� " j
17 �� 4�
"Jm
jr
Av
71
Pi �:mv 'A
1, ro,
M4
Vq�z
7711 C7
Akl�l
.. . .. . ...
.... . .. .
"I' dr
. . . . .. . .
21,71
IN
%Mai,
New 1,
"I'll'I","","",,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,Ill"""",""""""I'll"� ........................
. . . . .... .
K:o
. . . .. .. . .
mg -
ML
Ai
a3z
Pill,
..........
"IF—Ell
Ai
. . . . . . . . .
Limp.
11 , � M470 lm gmaj
wo%o% Aff% ff &
V A
0 f 1
11L^,1aut 6,umflld r, Pid
yu
13
lit
el" n s u s ainin g
I,it
O\ enidorisrnent ordina
iariceryierlltl emphasis want'.
infrastructure n
9 long-literrn
divilderllt%ied 0 shaked 0 preservell
APOftt 4w 00% 0 LOW%L 00ft, IIAOOIF& l! I O&I;IL a
e C',jr
c n enn ic a i s
I Ul U I Vu! U 1, W %W11
Restorina.4 P
r� a r a, m 10 u in, t
: t
19 dedare citiels P
01 it le
chcIrgeno Vn
fa r rn I a n d
0 0 e,rTlission pit
: I :i Itop ut I I S� S u C
r o r ity Ca :o a
reles
'57
enera
II I U . ... . .. .
00 a i n0"
h Is
x ' 1Y
S C o o
C
r e
no b ral" n e r;
Source G)
I '� x '.,,.i ;;,
Ma
Ihv
teamId
r:,'tl
1'� i{,'I' m...
chcIrgeno Vn
fa r rn I a n d
0 0 e,rTlission pit
: I :i Itop ut I I S� S u C
r o r ity Ca :o a
reles
'57
enera
II I U . ... . .. .
00 a i n0"
li
r rri t (o r
C
r e
no b ral" n e r;
a 1 1�"iI'' I ( 'N' I,'�
I '� x '.,,.i ;;,
Ma
Ihv
teamId
r:,'tl
1'� i{,'I' m...
�'.r,dm'
v d",ii
�'a :w^ ��
�'�II IV '''� ry M� n^
"�i�^,wi..� ;
li
r rri t (o r
C
r e
no b ral" n e r;
a 1 1�"iI'' I ( 'N' I,'�
I '� x '.,,.i ;;,
FNY •;; 1 ','�,i, I V V
r:,'tl
.P till
Tue -tue,i,
fitordable
A
tsolultions trestle
IIJ
it
spaIII
ce-city
T
rbon
transport
AS1015-1 wil !(I I I C
Ut Slumiiidr.
P 17
M
L73
r
Attachment 2
NIIIly;
S.y u f 1 Z'7
rx„
I
r:,'tl
1'� i{,'I' m...
�'.r,dm'
v d",ii
�'a :w^ ��
�'�II IV '''� ry M� n^
"�i�^,wi..� ;
Ut Slumiiidr.
P 17
M
L73
r
Attachment 2
NIIIly;
S.y u f 1 Z'7
12
0"A
21P
m
441
AI" IsIr p
Oil
IV
�W
all
0"A
21P
m
441
AI" IsIr p
UIL U
0011-I
e
fiff c i e,n t
business
1111!i:
Coot 111: Police
Ik
ty
16�
nr
appi
agen, as' �:ec,tru mig I ... 1. 001
i c a ul
b,,I, e
C
ation
rO
t"i a x i m iz e
m as, u r el
L
act jaily
pre
WO, e
r
L,t 1 Ly I L L t� Z>:�s CJ
"t i c: a,ti o ri,
historic downtown Po
par 1,1
brown 1: 4xA
i B
i A dA follo:wing
0,
comt:nl
r ey e nu e
Ian 19 a! I s ex P e: cta t iwo n s ric r e al s e:
m ho s
� � � �. µ d.
*esign
me,et,in:gs
Offft
Li to&% jr
ut z)ummd**l4%r
11
01%1
payt
17
Oil
IV
UIL U
0011-I
e
fiff c i e,n t
business
1111!i:
Coot 111: Police
Ik
ty
16�
nr
appi
agen, as' �:ec,tru mig I ... 1. 001
i c a ul
b,,I, e
C
ation
rO
t"i a x i m iz e
m as, u r el
L
act jaily
pre
WO, e
r
L,t 1 Ly I L L t� Z>:�s CJ
"t i c: a,ti o ri,
historic downtown Po
par 1,1
brown 1: 4xA
i B
i A dA follo:wing
0,
comt:nl
r ey e nu e
Ian 19 a! I s ex P e: cta t iwo n s ric r e al s e:
m ho s
� � � �. µ d.
*esign
me,et,in:gs
Offft
Li to&% jr
ut z)ummd**l4%r
11
01%1
payt
17
il
0
"I
Ell. , it
W, I�Y7 77 �71
it
7-1
I is
P"f "I I � I
P, YV
E ri e r
6 e l, C Y
U t!] I IN Homeless toba:c�,
culryiinatin
liscetICC,
C u 1 11 v.,'i t ci
Pit' 1! 1 e %It Is
decision ['t
6 volunte,ers shares alichieve rel lia b I e
,lers intelgra
r
e n t
e pt 0 tion ple e S
C t 111,1119
rvstril
I co in, o rin I Ca
I � .1 9 0
0 tI'la i, S
Pro L", 5 If' e C It r u 11)
I
o
k� Z!
Y M. B. Y c e n t le s I I �� .tea
e,aVid e %if e I lo ed ii, er 11,1
Y
9
III 0'r e s
u`ti-ilfied
I biollogical
s s j vI 'k a t e iabtats
eI
ik e d s
enga,gement4-/6q-
Will Oily rogram own interriet
II
cl
old
de :V ess
please
g 0 ,a:: S
I
Isli I r t).w
ate( ay 4 itit
sense h a tv"i d 0 k "i
K-ALWAMA
lslcoroLm
IIiliuW r)
:Second
usi!n.Q I r, C
all
Tp %WF
.w 111"Il � �:::!�, �10� "i Street
heli
Alk�
Inn 5 0 111
system
a:
rk<?
spiritual 0)
5a,
float IC 10
MS v �,ox " ° b„ °., ....,, � .,. YS'. ° " „", a', �. '"` :I Po 'ti,l w,: � II ` ""'
Itilual r� keeP ivie:rse !c i
lolk Olill n e Cill:i: t
0 v (.4 r
t 10 e t he
eviery
j
0 e All
I t -ruck Ei t
,;'pIA
it
self
13CUve #z '' ]- 0, - '� i 5 1 iIII) ill
it :0 vh' ove�r
it
71
full mk
S �i mt e
QItiliIii cultural u
17
inch b ell a tifu,
towrl Curillect,
Q W
SO (r Lit
115 Cli
ir0- If
e
It
S
ouse,
'b r a f ull u
�r le oult.realchl
till)
semo Y
histur 4-1
ut: ra I CS
Y mall
ITO 1.111111 le to
140 LY
RaSIS e (o 1,11
xn
ty
Chattanoog7,a: s "Itive
IIx
u p
'brary
conneiction h d L" ke n t u c ky
11' ec I I dayi� i ivt ot I•e
n C u S, o ni r,t) ut ri c a I
�Rl
Healthy I
lig
I.
Compsi
I.
hyIpIe
r e
tree,s: L
muld I
f 10 ( u 5-1
13
•
% A*NWL
U U PAW0% M aill SA 11, ir
IL I
11
I
15
772 7:�
m
0
N,
2b—
R
Multiol,
P k
moor
n fri'a� s����
UF`. u
n
70Me.
"A
T IC I BLw I t =r"
1!0 10
Ilut n
I
W"A
L M -IR Lv- -OP'Sk
"�C
lP T
ON
AE�
�4
ves,, g e n,,,,,,:,
15
yr
All
al<,es
In
t
e S�
410,
ra
Ann
nn.
i, e 9
b I e
accessi
n nt" rn
re:asu:re
L
r A!
acS
Ok z
v at
ing
YN 'I I F 0 bOwtOl M Awl I I
Input 64�uilllljdry I
I
n
Hay,, 15
E
0
J
M
12
7 : ; �, �
Fl"�Mll Qj
LAI
r72F ==3
Id
11041:17
N
7�1
M
12
7 : ; �, �
Fl"�Mll Qj
LAI
r72F ==3
5
Id
11041:17
7�1
� V
�
:.,�
jr
\
� � .,
����
..��
rl
� U'
�i'
"���� ��'
gyp'
"� i
5
Id
11041:17
Pi
rl
�Ml
a
r Ta
w=
M
a Ali
. . .. .... ..
r1l
Lobi
I
of I 1,1 [ 1put 6'UMI"I^ldpm%r'yL pdyt�
11
0
Id
11041:17
r1l
Lobi
I
of I 1,1 [ 1put 6'UMI"I^ldpm%r'yL pdyt�
11
0
Pi
r1l
Lobi
I
of I 1,1 [ 1put 6'UMI"I^ldpm%r'yL pdyt�
11
0
=7 7 MT 19-!77A
2F
IF
0
1 N,
�6
'7- " ti. ,;.y -11, 1—j 11!�
"w m
II
I A
,Tl
L IS
eL. I C !a t 1, 0 f -it (.-'11" 110,
C IQ n
U je
d le s ti n a �t o n
agrilculturL3 ClOrridoi
I s, e n h a n ce me n,
M
# I ci a n u
standards, CJ:
trestle
m m u n
PIC
101P (:* 101, h 91
iU
0
vaked d: I "ti
Iii i,
C ci rb
Update
P le
orldinfcoelal
owigaict i i,o nru
l,�OY
gNi; in,
eve n
ts
ain
S i tt atde r l
U min
ay
mi
nka c inRII taP,'��,I-Clnlner ne
a'
Lt
On,
ec! tion
er t,c a n
nde,
School
far m 1, 3, n 111&,?I �I
iI
d o v v n r e er
(Y
Co. priority P tic
r:
eei a s, i 1i
t h r e a t
c h a �r, C eli
Y
Q S!�
iclsion adobe,
a t e ir I ne
SUe
B '' 1 x, � .a', r'^, 111 M1.1 ''.',',' I. � � ". „B,'f;' ! 1 /°�" � ` " ' Ir 1 "r :� 1',I I 'I '' . % .w.
"'1 ,,'r,l 11 ., \ 1+"';! N y^v,,,;lm+„ mm�';''.,/'' a;',!i'I n ly."„tr, 1.. wmu o, �;,,, .' v'w ” �I'', ".:vM, ,""rd,xi„w.,,,,,`I yv '+ .,
"' ` )"''„ �r"" .' a r'„( ” ! 1!1"t a r''t,',lop:', m a" I $I' " a._t „ ., �- .: 1
s �'u, rv" I. r q. !:� :, jll / 11 ! ° I:ar w, 6
IW!'� «x :, ,Y' "^�' I� � a
CD
declare
C I iii mrFaIC %C lim a te rest ilent
JIII'ti II N
trawsplort
b;: 6 t s
�, ",�.`� t :,.,, I"d,,,, ', ',,;!III, ''�',,;1 „ � III ,.1,, 1',. "[fs' Lt':I r6,;,.: ) .,;I^' ': :1'. ,'�d',��L. d; I 1...,"�. J,,. ,,, 1 1,., ,,,�.,� n��„'�, /' .ull,.,,yq.�”„ m ��, ;t! •ry: N, "'1
vl�
hool
,s c
P
tin
1„ " .N "1", „','„' �1„ ” .., 1;� lit:, 1°%.,� "," � :.,
t
Green�' e„ .."„V,v J ,In,. ”",u., ,,, \, ",,,,,, ,, " w,�,al, "�',;"� �� ,w ...rvg, ,v, W„ „�, 'il '^ , ,, yr .II �w.� ,, :,,. 11 �, P � 'll,. �, ,w ,�, "„ „d t...'n ,��". ;, ',. r,.
kof
d
d ivi
o n
e
teams ca, rSI
ry
%1l
open
e solar,
r 1"J,, I Y; „
"M�&
bj
P
a w n: s
UtenSfls pas's
d _ n d
41', "" m ' 1 11,,,1,'
o
111U o �,�O tn
fil C I -ftl 1
it A
C
fl I I, �, ) d ralw!
cals clxcetM. 16�
s o u rc:
t a n
e
e at i o n,
e P 10 Of R III r oba 1,
C. i G!
mandat
0 u n. m a nt a i� ri i n
Ote
P 1:k 1 0 f"! b u r
efelctricity S� �,Ut* p r
ol ions �o; n,, 1 u prome,
n ad C,
II
III
d
low-1carbon e v eilo r"I"I �e
,ge nerations
insecticuldCS
Alp^•"Ir e s s ve
k
rml A"% jPv
ff 2
n
a
a
13
11
11
r
I
I udu
a
Aable ,:ffoi
:1va b el 1!
acnie I 1 A.
1, 1 e ell,. S opping,
ij r le I pian snialler
it
b.�,locking
acceSsible rn al n
oad
I� NI:C. 'keable
bi i
C O,,rr a
als
is e lec, iric ho:usin,,
Sig! 9
O�k I i
M It I VYA,t,
MA
I IF
reguiar
A
%wo I I
O(Cm
A CY
4p
Oil
'trail
s+ bi ke
ev i s, t
El
"r IN
Iq
"A2
flow
Ail
eduic n
I TR,epa
113
Ix,
contact !sa e
�trap
0
r ,n
e^,„�' ^Nw ,.�':;„,w.y,','',; ,,.� I III ! I „il,,a.M'. � d P Y 1 I ' 4 ' I 1
C11tvrcarbon
a i
i"', o
„; ''�I; \P,,, ,'u"' ^ .... �•" . �'';�- y.. ',��, 1„ ''' 1"':' ^ IMw ", 1', Y,P .r. ."..' w,mAd":.
ra
I r i Ftp
e
,a id
ed,
t re st ,''" Y ..., ,:mc � ...:..a ''�,.> la '� "1:, Ip`,',u,� Au� w :,:�;' ;. '.a I „��',,
I e
time
0
Co n II
d n
0 a ne
-2 a
21
Y.
IT
MR �Mw
8
•``,el r rn�iiitenancc
�r
a
0
u
I
a
it I I t n I
jr .2
111ju OUM111arylboft of irv.
�9
�Nrl
n
a
a
13
11
11
r
I
I udu
a
Aable ,:ffoi
:1va b el 1!
acnie I 1 A.
1, 1 e ell,. S opping,
ij r le I pian snialler
it
b.�,locking
acceSsible rn al n
oad
I� NI:C. 'keable
bi i
C O,,rr a
als
is e lec, iric ho:usin,,
Sig! 9
O�k I i
M It I VYA,t,
MA
I IF
reguiar
A
%wo I I
O(Cm
A CY
4p
Oil
'trail
s+ bi ke
ev i s, t
El
"r IN
Iq
"A2
flow
Ail
eduic n
I TR,epa
113
Ix,
contact !sa e
�trap
0
r ,n
e^,„�' ^Nw ,.�':;„,w.y,','',; ,,.� I III ! I „il,,a.M'. � d P Y 1 I ' 4 ' I 1
C11tvrcarbon
a i
i"', o
„; ''�I; \P,,, ,'u"' ^ .... �•" . �'';�- y.. ',��, 1„ ''' 1"':' ^ IMw ", 1', Y,P .r. ."..' w,mAd":.
ra
I r i Ftp
e
,a id
ed,
t re st ,''" Y ..., ,:mc � ...:..a ''�,.> la '� "1:, Ip`,',u,� Au� w :,:�;' ;. '.a I „��',,
I e
time
0
Co n II
d n
0 a ne
-2 a
21
Y.
IT
MR �Mw
8
•``,el r rn�iiitenancc
�r
a
0
u
I
a
it I I t n I
jr .2
111ju OUM111arylboft of irv.
�9
T
kM�
n
I]
a
ri
13
a
W k
Input Summary 1 Pa-,--emJe 19 of 191
u
u
r T I , ! , - - - 1- - , -7-
A I
IN
'ZZ
WNW" r -i 'i
2.
L it cl: i I: U I a ug u
&7N
0
A
it Jr AM&
'91
"ft *Mi ui a" #V% LAMIL AWN 00%
W
or " �)
E %--a a w h1t:t= a a 4d P kvl.; IL 1 t
f"41 IL &A IL JV%,
IL I
Vff it: f u I I tf
It y dLct=%, lblei% to y
Accessibility (7) Two-way communication, feedback loo, (4)
i
cu Itcl ct 'S: CITI C C040, l"11 M u 11111
GJM�'111CALt���
Loft
WE�!b prisil
Ali
D A ic T1
VIP a
ic I tf CIZ) t= FOdftICkIPc1 lull ati nt
t d cl U u y
Ji pdok t-% j0% pi
,evtf rL #u i i e r(2 cli L u
e I Ij e
y
Li to"% F I
U�=Ve up UVI I Ila of e- ht'P%nsi%v1(fO'% a n
Committees,Commissions,
Boards
Report out
Engagement:
Empowering
Crosspollination between CCBs(4)
an
Tru 1% e rn: owe:: ed co:mmi, I
y
0 'h
commissions will address �many
ISSIUres dai
�Csl 1. 1
don to AM
J)LaT an*-
aij, tor less mo�ney tee: "4
y
"e zu
n1oit Summary
Ll
19
IN
�il,7 "MI
4
a
13
. . ....... .. 'M=3
46
k'Z
117 �c%s/cn i°'c/C/O
*Y cd�r��
. . ........ . . . .
z"i I
it
77101:
. A
I
0
zSs"
II
. . ........ . . . .
z"i I
it
77101:
. A
I
0
TOP:IDEAS: OBJECTIVES CONT:.
a abl'ic space (i.e. Dre ge River, Turning Basin an arina 40 Multiuse pu
c Cq: e s S a R1,441 Tr C1 tf
►i�:l� [�nl� �i�2:1�l.�li�
11
rbm%L 0 AOW%
MI(I I I I u I I I u I Co"%I u t 1 0% r un, 21 --oft]
,'..Cliuitable.
ure Be river 4U
Emergency dredging turning basin and
Marina
Rainier
and Caufield deep dive and
0
alternatives
uircu a! ion
Amoft
comLp'"Lre :ensive ranspol
APNOW&, 0 -MIX
ueem,phasize vehicles b')
a
:d me n rTm,aintenance 51
ft -a 0
:) r
o o
L
A P k
Illi triLP#% e. ottom
w ul r - s u Nc; t Ca i n a
Permitted parking/street sweeping
Corona station and access to fairgrounds
development (15)
a
Irn UtL Summary I Paye 22 of 19:1
E3
zSs"
TOP:IDEAS: OBJECTIVES CONT:.
a abl'ic space (i.e. Dre ge River, Turning Basin an arina 40 Multiuse pu
c Cq: e s S a R1,441 Tr C1 tf
►i�:l� [�nl� �i�2:1�l.�li�
11
rbm%L 0 AOW%
MI(I I I I u I I I u I Co"%I u t 1 0% r un, 21 --oft]
,'..Cliuitable.
ure Be river 4U
Emergency dredging turning basin and
Marina
Rainier
and Caufield deep dive and
0
alternatives
uircu a! ion
Amoft
comLp'"Lre :ensive ranspol
APNOW&, 0 -MIX
ueem,phasize vehicles b')
a
:d me n rTm,aintenance 51
ft -a 0
:) r
o o
L
A P k
Illi triLP#% e. ottom
w ul r - s u Nc; t Ca i n a
Permitted parking/street sweeping
Corona station and access to fairgrounds
development (15)
a
Irn UtL Summary I Paye 22 of 19:1
E3
I'd
z
Of
FT
a.',, Iii 7—T
777
Attachment 2
W Alk 11, A � W 0 mdr AkJw Ed K,W'M ''Off AMY Aft"M V M'
I VA.", ... . .... I ..
im
spook
.Wftk CIA ev
r It .1
"t I J C1r i S) i zs4
E All b: n C u p p Op, r tf d1"4al
IF
-A
Cift A~ 000% Emp r
v -JW% Ap% I ff Loft
AP"% t=PO f -A, %NJ S L+ u gtf I lu
y oft r : d [ V.;
dom I 10000k
t Mr 'k
R (6?4, e S ) t Codwil b 1 41 s h b d I I I] S-10 r,
S di i 1 54
"'u"' `'Q"`'' `1`'' Ysafety education (7)
HOST Program (54)
1
Establishcommittee (mobility justice)
Mental: Health Services (18) (5)
t • t
4
A Ifty W1111
A COMMun ree om o moverneni or
a
AL, commun'I'lly members w*lt,, p rt,icular
atten--1c-'i:o to marge-vinaleize, rou"s, repared
or emergencies of all t'orms and wl*th
eApNuatle resources.,
H
0 v
Owe n c re a I, I
e r g- y p redness cert cate jj
Del'ivery ot' Fire services J
Ak a
A ow t,4rrea eir
y
more iverst iy
to
,i zoning cre,a+Le
,coor. i no, e w i sc� 00 istricts to provi
es, rian ro tes to sch:Ool
safe b*1ke a:nd ped , bi)
Re-establish court (5)
Sale alternatives for ALL modes of
JAR,
trans! ot ion.(8)
treac to i COMMUn! ies un er-
y I I
NonvNol'ice resources tor crisis management
1�1
r
9
n, u 6ummary age/.,,, o
E]
�4,1
tzl.�Ml
.7m
Attachment 2
W Alk 11, A � W 0 mdr AkJw Ed K,W'M ''Off AMY Aft"M V M'
I VA.", ... . .... I ..
im
spook
.Wftk CIA ev
r It .1
"t I J C1r i S) i zs4
E All b: n C u p p Op, r tf d1"4al
IF
-A
Cift A~ 000% Emp r
v -JW% Ap% I ff Loft
AP"% t=PO f -A, %NJ S L+ u gtf I lu
y oft r : d [ V.;
dom I 10000k
t Mr 'k
R (6?4, e S ) t Codwil b 1 41 s h b d I I I] S-10 r,
S di i 1 54
"'u"' `'Q"`'' `1`'' Ysafety education (7)
HOST Program (54)
1
Establishcommittee (mobility justice)
Mental: Health Services (18) (5)
t • t
4
A Ifty W1111
A COMMun ree om o moverneni or
a
AL, commun'I'lly members w*lt,, p rt,icular
atten--1c-'i:o to marge-vinaleize, rou"s, repared
or emergencies of all t'orms and wl*th
eApNuatle resources.,
H
0 v
Owe n c re a I, I
e r g- y p redness cert cate jj
Del'ivery ot' Fire services J
Ak a
A ow t,4rrea eir
y
more iverst iy
to
,i zoning cre,a+Le
,coor. i no, e w i sc� 00 istricts to provi
es, rian ro tes to sch:Ool
safe b*1ke a:nd ped , bi)
Re-establish court (5)
Sale alternatives for ALL modes of
JAR,
trans! ot ion.(8)
treac to i COMMUn! ies un er-
y I I
NonvNol'ice resources tor crisis management
1�1
r
9
n, u 6ummary age/.,,, o
E]
4
V4'r,.<�� �.,„,:.,,,, �,,, I ”„ '.: c:, ii �e '� „,�,w^ "„ °s � III. »� .',.,,. �� M
m
u
m
0
13
m
13
Q
mmpn�
RIA -m
M.,
"Sw
Nli
rt
47
I
Owl
O
M
401,
it
"ON
Ar
Aw AWL
MPM.
r6I
F Xf
took 2 b
y ciyt
M
NO
9r,
741�
„!Y;»'iima
6=7
dl AW% a M A00% S 0F1 Ub / 7
tf d n 4L t b @ I * t: Ms u r
Y U
J001% a
ON LOW4L AWA%L Loft
13
ut
L 4 "
mt:ducatiuon and Reu I C C11
I it
I I M a t C3 n d u C#-11 r bup% rolll Ca rl (03% (l rn,r%,
/ P-7
Fisca reserves k /,�
?A S
,,,,.:vanced susiaina i 1tv 2
I 10
vis avis—
3 P's UMMOMMOR
APOMM-OM 3 ,1 Els OPPOPM
a
EU I t
Economic,
0
a ne t P ro
Pleop e,
-1
What does wpeltaluma want?.
a 0
Local climate ac 'ijon ow we co 'ro
e eci,riclt Y
in
S 4
mate cri dieclarat"ion
o,mmuni
13
t: •
AM"&
Rtfv%=,,u, ,eneicjtiu,,,
I COO& Al Apft L^
5L.1(21 ice
Attachment
2
JP%
e ubt= "Ob tcalLi,tts biastAd U1 i L.Jds
r 0—"A an: OIL 15 E) 5
JON 0 a Is
W% TO WO I -oft ew
t:CLI IL
CO a-, r b o t r te e e I it -Y o n
C rN
s i ru c i o n
Carbon""free wa-'cer tr::ea-"[-,m,en--'L-:
a Jill
ullma'lte ca,b"iwn:e"-L
tievenlue measure
Aqpm%
t
commulnn.y iscus,sion
t IL
urganizat'*i:o1nal sustainab'ili y
Charter atorespondto
current needs:
Housing, to attract, and retain employees
LA dol
:ur inance on one ime use o1ol containe
Establ:'Ish metrill."...S. for, C''Ilty elt, orts
ea 01W L le rs
a
2' of
In; ut �')um:,rnary 1 rage b
2
w
r,
0
E3
0
VN -7P VA;V, %-*AW
ki
a
5���b1 �yh
m
VON
1114, *
(11' III -t/ �t 5 c
w
F
3
oi riiiiiiiiiiiiii% I JIMM-9 do 1: 10% 1!
nPI it
cl y
u Z") U M M r 1-i e it ut
m.
11R
,
E3
0
VN -7P VA;V, %-*AW
ki
a
5���b1 �yh
m
VON
1114, *
(11' III -t/ �t 5 c
w
F
3
oi riiiiiiiiiiiiii% I JIMM-9 do 1: 10% 1!
nPI it
cl y
u Z") U M M r 1-i e it ut
Ej
PA
M�7
d 0%� u ulftl
e t 0i g &oft no d
lv�
M
I � A JON IOWW& LOW
-Nl��VU[Iue Illudziur,ea,
Safety (16):
E
P
awmaL n
f
B E2 COO] U U
S C1 [e I C1 Ix
U
O■
b,
r boar"] tdX
R
Udrboli 21
Ica
r tf n t a
P
e
porkltig me r,d
Art wo I, So
0 A
ic a rt cleai i
nOW
s -reel -s tOW: l L
Transportation (13)
Electric shuttles (7);
maintenance (6)
a
U IL 9
0 e uves
Inconooratv.; into all 1 c
,2c -ieve a,,,, o jecAves
H i toric keep hisi:oric 'ist:ri,c'.. Is,, or,ic i�j
'& S-1-
-L-o�wn
Cohes I "Ive Vision tor ihe ulawnt
Is a KAV"k An C
business, t,
mission s--L-'ai'-Iement y
zonin, dress vacancies: J c*
h
Lm--PL�W A W M
JF IL
U t"I f I C a t
'i
W ON, M
LO U
I I& Am& t
I gJ"P I 111,
U
PON rV
C3 3: 1
u r i b
U C oft I
s OIN h 'W jP
U CU I S
4t f
n
L A p-,%ut 6'ummar I y 1 P a �rjl e 2' d' of 1 U I
77
;og, �po'
%
N
It,
271v' -
N
It,
-Ton,
"I
VIII Ip'.
El
At:tachment 2
i
a
0
14!
izo
(27)
Identify sites 1,w/
Build pilot program:
MCI Mf Uilic 01111,5 ea U (f Apensivitf
13
:3
Loi
HU pruc,tfs.�
one% is 6 a ISN"N,1 M
I Ik Lift
T is
iversitl,, a,ttordabi it AUA COMp iantarTe
Vy Y1 6
APE 16 a
JL toi I -L: � at
roje
L09A
rien Y., inTl u P cts t
I:zu an up ate, r nee eld
AL-
tuF OLI
u i
-s a d nv11,1e d ei nt'i ' -W& Lei 0 r1l: n'l t s '-IL en
Y
deve,10
A. A-
Keduce en-Litlemeni, tees and ealml,ine
Relater vrotelctior�
:1
ift
d t y
7)
ED
w
.Ai 0
I.
M J#% Loft Loft 1b, 8 L
F a P ION d
v JP%
L-3 " U t Pi rt u KA*46 i tLY 111 3
lnvp%:Ut 6,ummary- 1 age 3:: 1-1;
7Zw.
�
Ril
14!
izo
(27)
Identify sites 1,w/
Build pilot program:
MCI Mf Uilic 01111,5 ea U (f Apensivitf
13
:3
Loi
HU pruc,tfs.�
one% is 6 a ISN"N,1 M
I Ik Lift
T is
iversitl,, a,ttordabi it AUA COMp iantarTe
Vy Y1 6
APE 16 a
JL toi I -L: � at
roje
L09A
rien Y., inTl u P cts t
I:zu an up ate, r nee eld
AL-
tuF OLI
u i
-s a d nv11,1e d ei nt'i ' -W& Lei 0 r1l: n'l t s '-IL en
Y
deve,10
A. A-
Keduce en-Litlemeni, tees and ealml,ine
Relater vrotelctior�
:1
ift
d t y
7)
ED
w
.Ai 0
I.
M J#% Loft Loft 1b, 8 L
F a P ION d
v JP%
L-3 " U t Pi rt u KA*46 i tLY 111 3
lnvp%:Ut 6,ummary- 1 age 3:: 1-1;
3
gov
u
13
k mx
Ira
�-c�,�cr� �w��oy�� ho�t5
FO
n
'p
c
Ar a A
cl yt; u
13
J
lkk2
jr14
o
1
TOP IDEAS:
Implement anti-smoking vaping (8)
Better river access /path (14)
fTra ms
We I In es' Is ro 6
A f" e Is 0MV
o able ousing
ive un:ity k,D)
Hospl al reflect' of comm
healthy clean air,water,
/active citizens)
00
U
Attachment 2
OBJECTIVES CONT:
Better coordination of goals /priorities
across school districts
Setter l of health
benchmarks and tracking
stats
Support health action effort community
wide
4-
1,
y e�)
neilk bici e
divingBetter park design for active
I
/integrationMore encouragement of Cycling
a J1 0 6
1-oftriori i zing P%roj ec s
ke ed c! mmi,ttel P
P
k
0
Wa. a, e rive,r, ""%a imL#qk emlen!, :o
P
river pan o icompletio.n 9
imement anti-smoking vaping 8
I � Y
Aiv
t'r *11 e n 5 ier better alCitf.-%ess user n,
0
More a! orr a e ousing
Encourage ;we ness programs
Hospital reflecting community
Bike Ipilot (2)
in e ration w ch'ildren schools 1,,
,f%ommunlilt ea th 1
404 Y
Open LRanch (1)
Create /update hazard mitigation plan
Leaf blowers
3
n
IIw
yN
cel
51
lo�ry
AS
imp
6
NP1:1ill
tl
fA
I
. .. ........
�Nl
po
II
................... il V
11 ............................... I I ............................... 1,hi
11 1
11
..... ..... . . . . . . . . . . .
QW
Ali "I
�Y
77!
W
Nil
IRKNil do
'kw
N 4111''
40 , ; - --,r % 1
0 40"
04t, "i
F 11w M
�10M A�
41:
NO1,
....... .......
Aiw� 4
N
A
AL
mmli
M, A,
Appku 1 W-1 n
p u t U M r y 1L A
0
M 0Z
pv
lo�ry
AS
imp
6
NP1:1ill
tl
fA
I
. .. ........
�Nl
po
II
................... il V
11 ............................... I I ............................... 1,hi
11 1
11
..... ..... . . . . . . . . . . .
QW
Ali "I
�Y
77!
W
Nil
IRKNil do
'kw
N 4111''
40 , ; - --,r % 1
0 40"
04t, "i
F 11w M
�10M A�
41:
NO1,
....... .......
Aiw� 4
N
A
AL
mmli
M, A,
Appku 1 W-1 n
p u t U M r y 1L A
0
M
13
0
0
3
111
u
J
Ll
11
11
El
Attachment 2
t rmft
ff I
-1 ]PU Z:) u 1"looll m do-kry Fay e d,4 Of 1 �'j 1
u
Lidj
6%W 12ArtC
I
... .......
Z�77ry77""7` 73
IF
SO-71II ow 1 " . , I P
.0 " 64,v:ef 1, 4c
Ver q
0,6
Fie
W If
bm
8.25 lo
LL Rol t Z� 01J. ie
-N, ;k.4 v A -fro
C.
W't r 1.4
ell
CP
b) (4
RL Up
4A
�t"t,&0OAA Cf
C'X
f(e
4sw sl
OF
..... ......
(b 30
(tillclA
F�
ry "t
'it
<
...........
1w
/* -
lot vvd4
Id
ctv 4ml))(v Vol
I
A
I MIA
07V
4.
IMAIVA U joj�WF fj 4 OtA
sli Thi� i b,
d,4
'10
CA rl
RtV OT
1 14 L?
f
I A
C
kl'
ki
A"f
11 A
sl p A v 010-49�s
I k e4 -
jS7 op 1� 1&q �Ao
I ;Mo co �k
's 0 LV8
Ai IJ'X
i I v
timmID 1 DIM? 4 mw
fr
OVtr Co
m 4 Ilk
op
p"I AV^
aom
I
liage Jb of 1 �jl
bummar
9
m
Ole#
r .,.
�1.
2
oN
ol
I
Ill
11
d
, y r ci y u u
.9
I
0
mp-7
cl
0
I
a, A
AP%L,
f
tut %,Ummofy 1 ea g U t
rr
lip
mp-7
cl
0
I
a, A
AP%L,
f
tut %,Ummofy 1 ea g U t
rr
&7MrIMVj
I-vpri o, zujiN
11% 1
I J
Honorablle Mayor
anei'l
-T-1 'IL Ar
pe, Y
%,,oggy _v iynn., C I
t: ..M,anager
S:'UBJECT. FY Il 9�21 Goal,, Se,tt ng Worksholt,
9
it 1*s d that the Ci"ty Counc
ULO-11 I:k h e uounc, Goal S is Wor: p
l it d, 40
*1 receive and review tb.e . . . . . niormati"on provi ed advank..1z;
wil 4V
+
OP,
ccoelk. provicle X lnsider commumty le db, a i'voi kiIIL hp e
4
priorl.1 ize,'ILL de *fied goals-.
11
Input Summary 1 -Page 38 of 19!1
Attachment 2
In advance of the workshop, Staff has received input from City Councl"Imembers (Attachment 4),
Committees and Commissions (Attachment 5), and from the community via an online survey
(Attachment 6). Community input received through email correspondence to theCity Clerk is
provided i*n Attachment 7. And finally, staff ideas were collected -and are summarized i*n
Attachment 8.
During the workshop, there will be opportunity for both the attendees and the City Council to
weigh in on new goals and discuss the picture of success for each goal. There will also be a
voting exercise at the end of the meeting to help prioritize the identified goals.
The event will be documented on video that will be posted online, by a graphic recorder, and
with detailed staff notes. Staff will take all the input received and combine it into draft goals to
share with the community before presenting a final, proposed goals list for Council review in late
April/early May,,
ATTACHMENTS
1:. Revised Agenda'
2. Council Goals - 2017-2018
3. Council Goals - 2017-2018 —Achievements
4. Councilmember Input
5. Committee and Commission Input
6. Community Input
7. Community Survey
8. Staff Input
1h
Input Summary 1 -gage 39 of 194
U
SONOMA cout4rie,
,SATURDAY APRIL 612011
9AM-4PM
Snacks and coffee will be: provided to attendees &staff
,
2. WELCOME AND OVERVIEW-- MAYOR BARREIT
3. INTRODUCTIONS AND COMMENTS—CITY MANAGER PEGGY FLYNN
4. UPDATES AND REVIEW OF FY 2017 18 GOALS
IN,
9.
REPORTS FROM BREAK
OUT
DISCUSSIO�N
10.
WORKING LUNCH —
REVIEW
OF OUTCOMES DISCUSSION
Is
Lunch will be &#%rovideto attendees & s
P d ff
11. PUBLIC COMMENT
12, PRIORITIZATION DISCUSSION &EXERCISE
11
rl,r
Attachment 2
Tilmes are Approximate
- WMAJ
IuA►r��e�
3
LL LL n 11 - -11-11-11 ., ........ . .. .................................. ... . ...... .
lop
COW. JL 9:1
Input Sum,mary1 Page 40 of
IEJUQ Atta c �mment 2
AWL
I85$
Petaluma City Council Goals and Priorities for 2017 and 2018
I. GOAL: MAINTAIN FISCAL SUSTAINABILITY
1. Priority: Enhance Existin Revenue Sources,
a. Increase Revenue Collections Through Aggressive Utilization of
Revenue and Collections off
icer :osition
bffEva uate for New Opportunities and Increase. Existing U
ser Fees
c. Educate the Public' and Business Community on C ity Finances
22 -Priority: Limit/Reduce Exenditures
a. Investigate, and Implement Consolidation Strategies to Reduce*the
Cost of Services or Enhance Service Delivery, as O :):)ortunities
Arise
bol Continue to Seek Cost -Effective Means to Reduce Future PERS
Liability
3.0
Pr"iority: Establish New Revenue Sources,
a,. Revisit Consideration and Initiation of a Sales Tax Increase
b. Consider other Tax Increase op:)ortunities
4. Priority: Establish Fisca! � SustaV
nable Funding for Storm Water M
Management
INVEST IN HUMAN RESOURCES AND INFORMATION
II. GOAL:
TECHNOLOGY
1. Priority: Establish an,_ In -House
Leadersh� Academy fmil
or
Management and Superviso
rStaff
a. Develop Program Design
bs Conduct Program with New and Existing Staff
2. priority: Develop and Revise Written Human Resources Guidance
a.
U:)date Personnel System Ordinance, and Related Ordinances and
Resolutions
b:w Develop Personnel Policies and Procedures Manual
Input Summary
1 -Page 4.1 of 194
Attac �ment 2
ria s and Provide Staff Training
310 priority:
D evelote
a Resolutions
b ordnances i
Contracts
C19
d Leases owls
Requests for Prop m��Cement
e•C uter Svs1e
Plan. for City -..wide omp
4, priority� stem
the tjseful Life of the Curren t SY
Determinetons
a. e acement �'P Sources� Evaluate R pedea to
Identify and Secure V:unding
c. ,S eb,�teanSocia 1VIthe C�Ycationiority: Continue to,� e�Op a�ments
r More Eff►cient and �nteeactive __---
5• P .Allow for ...11
dents and C►tyD pe�een Rest
Digitize Doc Number of On-lineAP
p
a. Expandlicatiostoragens for a Variety of Permits
� the
e ,
Updte the CiY_C11 harter Ea
Update
nabling
69 priority:ale Consistent Adv1sorq".8 °dies
and M
7. Priority L 1 aflone IS..
x1rPort C ommission tsa• Board of Appeamission
buBuilding usic&Parks Com� Recreaflonivisory cornmittee
do Tran LEGISLAT�ON
REVISE LOCAL 2025GOAL:STABU General Pla_n...-
���• end the Elernents.o_f the
11 Since its AdOPt+on in 2a�$
Priority:Review andAmto Refect chan,9�9�s-r M
apping Update
effect FEMA P011cyP-37)
s )
aU datesto R ssessment(lementation
bConduct UGBSand 9ures to RefleSt to eWjUpdated Plans and
UpdateEXh �b► U date Referent LOS
c' o .
otnd
d ncopthresholds to transition from
Studies an
btffic CA ultletines
e U date accep Witantici �atetlstate Gato VM,►n 9
-
InpSummary 1 gage 42 °f
Ut 19�
Attachment 2
2 Prior-------
ity: Continue to Deve or) and implement-- — Procedural and
Legislative ChangesThat Support the Development ReviewAllil,
Process
a. Revise Local CEQA Guidelines
bN U date IZO CPterha1i5 and Historic Distrct Guidelines, Historic
Preservation Regulations, Guidelines and Resources
c. A IY for CLG certification and the nem available grant cyc e for
matching funds to u:)date
d. Com:)Iete Sign Code U:)date
3. Priority: Update Marijuana Ordinance to Address Recreational Use
4. Priority : Co1,1111 llJiaborate with theCounty of Sonoma to AdoptEx en
d
11
21
.1
Producer Res.ponsibility Ordinance for Des an... Sharps
5. Priority: .Conduct Wor<shnps, Month ly or as \eede.d,Ill,lllllll,lon Topics.
Which May Require Legis a ive ActionZo
Oil
a. Water and Wastewater Rates
bd T
ax and Revenue Initiativesatives
c. Marijuana Regulation
d. General Plan Amendments/U )dates
e. Sea Level Rise
fs -Housing Strategies
g. Transit Consolidation
h. Storm Water Funding
i. Age Friendly Community
IV. GOAL: PROMOTE HEALTHY DEVELOPMENT, SUSTAiNABILiTY,
AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
1. Priority: Plan and Implement Age -Friend y Community Strategies
a,.
wor<-with tie County of Sonoma, and Other Agencies to establish
Manning process to obtain Age Friendly Community status
b. eve -o:) wor< plan across all de)a rtments to fully recognize and
incor,porate requirements and guidelines for Petaluma as an all
ages community
2. Priority: Sustainability PracticeAl
s
a. Design aniverosel Ct-Effective energy and Other Resource
Savings Projects for City Facilities and Infrastructure
n Lit Summary 1 -Page 43 o
f 19�
A
F
0
Attaciment 2
f
3. Priority: Implement the Central Petaluma Specific--- Plan —Maximize
Development Potential Around Transit -Oriented
Development
a. Work with SMART to Site Second Station
b. Work with SMART, Developers, and Stakeholders to Create
Parking Adjacent -to the SMART station and Downtown
4. Priority: Update the 5 -Year Economic- Development Strategy
5. P r Ni o r mi t y Identify and Implement Programs to Increase Affordable
Housing
a., Revise Housing -related Development Impact Fee's
bw Seek to Provide Housing for All Income Levels
c. Focus Attention on Affordable Housing to Attract/Retain Talent
6. Priority: Create and Imp ement Programs to Attract Talent and
AVWWO
Develop the Local Workforce
7.
r
Priority:
a.
b.
c.
Conclude Fairgrounds Lease Negotiations
Complete Joint City/Fair Feasibility Analysis
Revise Lease or Develop Use Agreement
Initiate Public Process as Prerequisite to Property Development
P riority:
9
Establish Sustainability Agency for Petaluma Ground Water
Basin
a. Work with Eligible Agencies in the Basin .to Establish a
Consolidated Agency b y June 30, 2017, Consistent with Prior City
Council Direction: or in -the alternative
b. Establish by June 30, 2017 a Petal u ma-spec'I'f'Ic GSA to regulate
groundwater use'inside Petaluma Corporate Limits
GOAL:
ENHANCE PUBLIC SAFETY
1. Priority: Continuetoim lement "Petaluma Policing
a. Continue to Build
Outreach, Social
Public Trust and Legitimacy through
Med'ia,and Programs
bw Conduct District Level neighborhood Meetings
:1
ct Obtain CALEA Certification
�+ F
Input
Summary 1 - gage 44 of 19
�
Attachment 2
2o, Priority: Reduce Major Crimes bV 511/0 Annually
IP
a. Develop intelligence -Led policing strategies
to target crime and
offenders
bm Increase available time 3y P atrol to more than 30% to al ow s
proactive policing to detect and deter crime before it occurs
c. Ana yze and d'eploy resources to known crime locations and known
offenders to reduce crime
3. Priori#y: _Increase Traffic Safety and Reduce Collisions
afety,educatoniand awarenessa. Emphasize traffic s
b:5 Increase traffic safety enforcement by 50%
c. Reduce fatal traffic collisions 3y 50%
d. Reduce Injury Collisions by 2,a%
4. Priority: Implement Downtown Sprinkler Ord... ..inididiw
ance and Conduct
Outreach.
5. Priority: Prnvide an Additional Paramedic AM D Ua n c
e
6. Priority: Dredge Petaluma River and Marina/Turninq Basin
a. Continue working with Federal and Regional Partners to. Obtain
Necessary Clearances
b. Identify and Pursue Funding Sources to Conduct Dredging
Activities
7:9 Priority:. Continue to Plan and Deliver Flood Protection Projects
aP
Comlete next Phase of Denman Reach Project
VI. GOAL: PLAN AND DELIVER CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS
1. Priority: Coordinate with Ca trans, SCTA and, Others t
DeIiver
Regiona-and Local Highway Transportation Improvements
a. Highway 101 Widening
b. Rainier Undercrossing/In'terchange
ce Southern Crossing
Inpu
t Summary 1 -Paae,45 of 194 3.1
Attachment 2
tdeWa\ks Muit�-
S
� for Streets
ernes
-are Ga ita� e��� S. pals
Pr,or�ty ;
Tee paths and
2• Sources
dent�fiy F
\in tr g tion � Park phase ��
a' ate G ete W ashen to
b• E
Gom , �tNit�es
priorit�l- oxnll P
3,x aseball F z��es and or P�
a 8 du�.� p ark p\ann�n
on
Pr�Or��'aid 3
4� Ranch Fire OXIS
2
a• erty vase and EX aid • ding akxOXIS
0
Rer
� .� �undin9 to bUx
priority
5S to dire�t�� on S ted Fire Station 1
so
co t�nue na lof eto
ae1o�a
a S to seek fu
b' Gont�nue
c.
A Pale 46 �f A 9
�
1�put Summary
ask.::,--L'Ist fro Febru-4
41..'2 017, G o a I S..e.tt i n
n
r
2. Uograde ngage eta1umaimorove timing and
quality of responses to user inquiries.
3. Provide semi-annual updates to City Council regarding 201 rig its
issues.
crosswa s are not *in. use.
-c
t emse ves
1
A
IMP tQ
mail
i
(i
Innu Summar �Pa e47o
Attaciment��
CITY COUNCIL GOALS.AND PRIORITIES
=Y 2017-2018
ACHIEVEMENTS
GOAL 1 - MAINTAIN FISCAL SUSTAINABILITY
ncreased various existing user fees and established new fees
o Completed Utility rate adjustments, implemented partial funding of Stormwater
achment 2
Management through Trash Capture Fees, increased commercial linkage and housing in
lieu fees, adopted Pavement Utilization fees for Street maintenance funding, and Live -
aboard fees for the Marina
• Secured grant funding for a va
� Initiated cost.
o Initiated tiered retirement plans
saving measures
riety of City projects.
to reduce future ret irement liability
o Increased employee share of cost
o Paid down a portion of the PERS unfunded liability
0 Ongoing enforcement of Purchasing Policy resulting in procurement
savings.
Refinanced debt resulting in significant savings- Waste Water Revenue Bonds and Tax Allocation
{
Bonds
GOAL 2 - INVEST IN HUMAN RESOURCES AND
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
•Designed and implemented management leadership class for City staff
• Digitized a portion of Counc
1858-1971;
id r
esoiutions
• Implemented several oni.i
• Initiated procurement of
electronically
• Initiated implementation of an agenda management system to streamline review and save staff
it archives including minutes from 1858-1911; ordinances from
from 1911-1912
6
ne permits for over the counter permit applications
a new, online system for accept ing, processing and managing permits
U
time
• Researched options for city's financial management system in preparation for discontinuation of
current system
• Evaluated needs of Commissions and Committees and revised operating procedures to improve
agenda preparation and plan review tasks. Amendments to enabling legislation were
determined not to be necessary
GOAL 3 - ESTABLISH J REVISE LOCAL LEGISLATION
• Completed several updates to the General Plan including Urban Growth Boundary Assessment,
updated flood mapping, and.other clean up changes
• Marijuana ordinance approved which includes program for cannabis manufacturing, testing and
one delivery dispensary
s
7
Input Summary 1 - Page 48 of 1 1
4
f
11
Attacimen��
CITY COUNCIL GOALS AND PRIORITIES
h
y
ACH I
•
Monthly. workshops covered the foil
2017-2018
EVEM E NTS
owing topics: water'& wastewater rates,, tax- and revenue
IF
inW. . itiatives, marijuana regulations, gene
ral
plan updates & housing strategies
• Study underway to transition traffic analyses for new development i:o evaluate
Traveled" in compliance with recent CEQA guidelines
It
Vehicle Miles
GOAL 4-m PROMOTE HEALTHY DEVELOPMENT, SUSTAINABILITY, AND ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT
• Inclusionary Housing Ordinance complete
• Approval of temporary housing po
•
Ref i
licv in response to
Wanted 5 Affordable Housing developments for r
2017-F'ires
ehabilitation projects; partnered wit
profit to preserve 15t time homebuyer units through a land trust model
• Selected PEP. Housing and completed entitlements to develop a 54 Unit low income
senior/
senior veteran development
which will soon begin construction
• uompletea career and Lifestyle Guide as a local Dusi
meetings with local
management
manufac'turl'
aciment 2
h non-
ness recruiting tool. Held educational
ng group to support talent recruiting and employee
• Pursued a robust sustainability agenda, including:
o Increased water recycling for the expansion of agriculture and urban use
o Increased organic waste composting and refuse recycling,
o Added Electronic Vehicle charging stations
o Purchased hybrid electric buses
o Replaced LED fixtures in over 5000 streetlights
o Used a portion of sewer.b*iosolids to produce an innovative liquid fertilizer
o Discontinued use of glyphosate in parks and adjacent to residential areas
o Restored wetlands and floodplains into passive open space (e.g. Denman and Capri
Projects)
o Pursued grants for shore zone res*lliency'and marsh restoration.
• Update to historic demolition resolution to respond to current context and create three levels of
review
� Approval of public outreach policy to increase noticing radius, require onsite posting, and
require community meetings for major projects adjacent to residential neighborhoods
• Completed consistency analysis with airport land -use plan for Washington ball fields
GOAL 5 -ENHANCE PUBLIC SAFETY
Held fall and spring police academy, j unior police' camp, coffee with a cop, several town hall
meetings and increased social media following from 20,400 to 70,000
Input Summary 1 -Page 49 of 1 4
�r
fv
;f
r�.
{
�f
fr
f
:f
iJ
rf.
}r
}f.
f
rf.
ff.
k r.
r.
f;
ff
Li
%J.
}n
rr.
i�
i
r:
�h
nf:
is
f.
�r.
i�
;f•
fr
f
}r.
�r
f
Y
F
i}•
tiJ•
j+.
l +.
/i
of
tik
ki.
i til
kr.
if.
}l1.
if
}r•
i •f.
}v:
}ry
k
r}
r.
of
}w
7r•
ryf:
rf.
if.
f
k
:f
rk.
.f.
Attac-iment��
CII Y COUNCIL GOALS -AND PRIORI 1.1 ES
Y 2017- 2 0 18
ACHIEVEMENTS
• Reduced many crime categories by at lease 8% and as much as 28%
• Increase patrol time dedicated to crime prevention.from 90-yco to 25%
• Increase traffic enforcement by 42%
• Decreased traffic fatalities by 500/o (from bin 2017 to 3 1*n 2018)
• Completed Denman Reach Phase 3 and began design of phase 4
Spent over $750,000 on ADA improvements, much in the downtown area, to enhance mobility
and pedestrian safety..
•Completed study and analysis to fund the addition of a third ambulance withou
and the addition of staffing to support the third
general fund. An i
ncrease in ambulance fees
ambulance will be proposed
t'*im pact to the
in the'upcoming budget
achment 2
• Following the. upgrade of the Petaluma Boulevard water main, worked with downtown property
owners to install fire sprinklers in accordance with uii:v ordinance
Worked with CALTRA.NS to execute project t
P ineview
o enhance
.1
safety at the i
ntersect*ion of Lakevill
GOAL — 6 PLAN AND DELIVER CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS
• Secured $1.8 million for street improvements through SB -1 and pavement us
• Began design and land acquisition for Rainier undercrossing /'interchange
• Began design for bridge at Caulfield
• Completed Washington Park Phase 1,, restrooms / concessions; baseball field design in progress
• Miracle League of North Bay completed ballf'eld and play area project at Lucchesi Park
• Completed Petaluma Boulevard water main replacement facilitating fire sprinkler installations
i
age fees
e and
0
4
0
Input Summary 1 - Page 50 of 1 4
I
a
E3
f
c
I IF
Inbpo%ut b'ummary 1 PlaytNe bl lof 19'4
E2
Ix ff
,M Ahya OR B; A R R E TI
III
vsvflfvl��Ml�
1:
Address Climate ange with city policies
SB -'s weekly dates
,P
P
No meetings for all city groups on Jewish: holidays
it 0
Speed tablesin neighborhoods.
Loca:l purchase preference
Flag/banner policy
I
N
'a, AMII
VAR, I Ma
permiltte ar. ing and restricte. par, mg for street cleanin"
S
I Irly 0 for the dt
,Sustafinab" " ff icer I Y
Revisimt dispensaries as part of reveniule enhancement efforts
0
Atta lel it 4
Identify a verifiable funding source/ mechanism for Rainier crosstown connector or stop using it as a project
mitigation.
rt signal
ignal upgrades
ADA standards and goals
0 ,
City provided emails an :ones.
P
LI
Ir
9e J.
I ;
nput Summary 1' Pa2 of i I
M
Attac'iment 2
AY PUT
mi R I I M
Attachment 4
IVAYOR BARRET-
• Synchronize traffic lights to ease traffic congestion wherever possible
• Effective street cleaning to stop leaves clogging drains and street flooding
• Require older rentals to have'health and safety inspections to have maintain a permit to rent -- to
prevent disasters by fire or health crisis due to signs of mould. Tenants are afraid to lose'.their rental if
they say any thing themselves.,
• ,Trestle —financial burden on city. Maybe SMART/CalTrans will give it to the city? As it is now it is a
detriment, it is unsafe, an eyesore, and, perhaps, reduces business from tourism
• Friendly competition to tidy up Petaluma streets/trees/Downtown — maybe to culminate with Recognition/prizes at the Butter and Egg Day parade,
YY
Input Summary 1 -Page 53 of 1 1
A" 0"' 1 'k
AF . 4 -*A. Arlh IM'V
"U"Is /" Issues 21) 9
1.) General Plan updates/ Housing /Development
General Plan, Update including examination, of the following:
Move expiration date of the Urban Growth Boundary to a, date beyond, 2,025. Discussion,
and possible action. to place a measure on the 2020 or 2022 ballot.
4
Expand General Plan to require Electric Vehicle charging,stat1*ons in new or substantially
I* -d IN
upgraded housing and commercial structures and Solar panel requirements in all new or
substantially up�%�W,allqadupgraded housing and, commercial structures,
General Plan amendments relating to easing height requn-ements in designated areas of
the City for both housing and commercial development,,
0
t... Goals.
Examination of ways to increase the production, of moderately pmarket based
examination o requirements, orOuSing� (i-Wellthe constriction ofsmaller units, etc,,
Y" nance.
emp4-&, o-Y-ees and teachers.,
U
At 0:
Establis 11, lent of'a Housing commi'silsi, on*
■
11
Ex ansionoi Solar Panels on all City Properties,
to momN
iR 0-11
Discussion an, possible action for installation of solar panels on City owned properties
(rooftop,landetcWork Clean Power' on a program to assist in the
installation. of the panels and potential revenue generation.
Discussion , and paction to move all City vehicles away froiii all- Petroleum or nahual
gas based fiiels and into phtg in hybrids and/or electric vehicles.
Inp:ut,Summary law,
NJ Page b4 Ot I
COUI,NCILMEMBER 1,<IN(I
CI*ty Charter Review and Revimon.
e -1 -
changes and ballot measures,,
n' ra. uc Ure oa s
# Lqtl
H
Attachment 4
lit
Maria ijrive anc't Nortli McDowell d,& into the 2019�:
Keep Sonoma Mountain wa'+i"n tlie 2019 p av
E
Caulfiel!d Cross town. connector Update,
List all road repairs and infiAastructure project/improvement made in the past five years. This has
been started and the st should include ever pan.. identify fusources and dof
completion. Post prominently on the web site..
W
River' Dredging Status and future options 'in light of the federal govermnent neglect of: this
waterway.
111 1 • 1 / 1 1 . • t 1 � � •
9
Exam m*at i*on/Wor1cshop on the following
Parl,c-i'lig, Structure. o�wnto'wn, SMART�r
"I
5.) Revenue/ Financial Issues
Ex-t^ans' of Revenue, 0
P 1011.
if 4:
Measure ex ansion o op ions
6 rN
inico,me tor, the General Fund),,
Pub11*c Safety
Fire Station I Relocation, upgrades to Fff"e, Stati*on 2 and 3.
PoIr ice Sta ion (,upgrade or new faci'li*ty).
a
nplut bummary 1- Flage 55, mo'�
U
TIN
V11:zw I
k, 7:J
[ il IxTki M10-
L- - - - lftl,11-11-
cpl ahmt1ene%it 41
Fireworks B an (phased in over tune to allow non -profits to find alternative fundraisuig
options,). Possible 'ballot measure.
YT
-pl*airArwrounds ume%date.
91 V
Farks and Relcrea-ti*on
0
.T'iL�ii�
Community Sports ,
Status..(Baseball, Field funding; Phase 2 completion and
STA
or Phase 3 (softball fstart).
0, 1
99) City Wide Minimum Wage (Workshop 4/$/19)
10. A Council Liaison to the Public Art Committee
El
[a
I
in
9
a
U
Page 56, of 1 9
,nput Summary 1
t I
^
i
A
Q„
OnI
. I
II
0 ik; ON
o' : k M
' MCDO!
.NC.t
A,.t�tacimen
0
OR I I � ra
Ece an Fire service, inancia
E
,
I
y
climate concerns. Theses
0
t3ut �fi
overarchim'v
9
I
E
II
I
i
1
i
•— c : —.:. :': ' ,. '— ' ` .. .. ..:: �... :.:. • , ... � :.: is
WMA -all
MINm
,
h
t i
is that the city
-t-hat this means �j
F
Y
i
believe that !the klev cha Ile and mvereat
ee,, .
resi ents. KevIernisforined von
t,his
ath
a,ra-
I
lic where they are'' as quest'ions are answered, add them
empower the Committees and Co�mmissionsm increase,their roles as ambassadors
demonstrate foresight; all long term issues n a "white paper" stating an official status -
specifically, items like Raini
r, the Tr
.
t t! r
e House ade uacvl, the Fa'irigriou:n s ancaj inancid
crisis
• be transparent with a plan; if no answer to a challengleis,know, post that's,if an answer's
trusting., Every action taken by st'aff'and council is a step t
don't believe
that the clt'V:currently has the DUblic trust sufficient to succeed w a revenue measure. Many steps and
much trust needs to; be ourimmediate priority.
Paving,a road is a good step but communicating the competency and mi sion are, the trust that will get
us to execution 01 vision.
M
5
t2
U
Atta c i me nt 5Attachment 2
.L
COMMI �I� TEE AND COMMISSION INPUA 1;".
HISTORIC AND CULTURAL PRESERVATION COMMITTEE
• Trestle rehabilitation, including assignment as a city project with city staff liaison assigned and
understanding that the overall project may be longer term than the next two-year goal setting
period,,
• Incorporate ways for Historic and Cultural Preservation Committee to do preliminary
review/concept review to provide early feedback to applicants.
• Consider a 1% fee for historic preservation like public art to increase funding opportunities to
facilitate the city's preservation efforts
• Explore potential historic district designation of Riverfront Warehouse District as originally
referenced in the Central Petaluma- Specific Plan
• Complete Certified Local Government designation process
• Increase enforcement efforts in historic districts, including educational opportunities
• Designate Historic Railroad Tracks through central'Peta'luma a local landmark to ensure
protect'i'on and preservation
PLANNING COMMISSION
• Sustainability in both residential and commercial projects that go above and beyond basic code
4L
requirements
• Amore robust focus on the river front, including redevelopment potential of the Golden Eagle
Shopping Center
• Community resources for teens, nothing for teens do, especially on the east side
• Trestle rehabilitation focus on Petaluma's history and tourism resource in downtown
• Opportunities for. Lynch Creek trail re-do — vision for crosstown connection for bikes and peds,
lighting, way inding, benches, improve safety f
or users
• CO2 Reduction goals —building code not enough, consider REACH codes, mandate not just
encourage
• Focus on public health in planning processes —air quality, walkability, childcare incorporated in
bigger projects, l'im'itations on alcohol and tobacco establishments
• Dredging
• Affordable housing
• Mixed Use downtown development
• Update Implementing Zoning Ordinance (1ZO) for more flexibility in reviewing
• Realization of crosstown connections for -all modes of transportation
• Establish teeth to environmental requirements —update IZO to give discretionary review beyond
building code requirements
• Consider greater massing allowances to facilitate infill development in proximity to the station
Input Summary 1 -Page 58 of 101
Atta c i m e nt 5Attac iment 2
COMMITTEE AND COMMISSION INPUT
• Consider reducing fees within proximity to transit to facilitate housing
•
Walkability'i'n the downtown
• Focus on aging community —senior affordable housing, ground floor bedrooms
• Needed senior center upgrades
• Increase city revenues -
• Increase access to transit
• Solar
PUBLIC ART COMMITTEE
• Climate change shouId be focus on everything that the City does
• Consider public ar-t under lens of climate change (living walls, river focus, etc.)
• Better collaboration and integration with other city advisory boards and committees —join
resources and priorities
•
Morep
lic art events and partnership with other art organizations �0+, iflvertown, Phoenix
Theater)
• Better integration with Ctiy departments to better vet potential public art sites
• Creation of public art inventory to track and celebrate Petaluma's public art
• Education and promotion of public art
• Ongoing and proactive maintenance of Petaluma's public art
N
• More consideration of public art on the Eastside
• Focus on small community oriented public art' projects
• Improve and expand outreach —bring the public into the process and integrate with larger City
approach to outreach
• Temporary art installations and other types of public art celebrations
• Better communication between the city's advisory bodies
Input Summary 1 -Page 59 of 194
0
A
li
0
J
1
Attachment 2
Attac i ment 6
■
i
Input Summary 1 -Page 60 of 104
G
I
i
Patrieia'Tute Brown, PhD, WT Lk k P t Chinese Herbs, Counselling
513 Petaluma ]Blvd,, South, Petaluma, Ca. 94 952 ph 707-762-2240 fax 707-762-9290
********& invoCvedCitizen*********
To: Each City Council Member rend the New City Manager
From., Patricia Tu ffle Brown
Date: 4-1-2019
Occasion: Go al-Seffing 2 019-2 021 Meeting 4- 6-2 019
1) MYSELF AND WHAT I W. -ISH TO SHARE HERE
Attachment 2
1.
i
My name -is Patricia Tuttle Brown, I am 67 years old, and have spent the last 26 years (along with having a family
and a local business) being active un Petaluma city affairs. I have done so both outside the City structure and inside
the City structure, the latter as Cl*tizenaember and chair of aCity-Council ppointed Committee.
This lefter's subject is: the City's Committees/Commissions, the C
ltzens on them and their relationship with Staff,
some dysfunction which has been going on, and what to do about it. All in the light of, from all accounts, a
wonderful new City manager,, working with a newly"reconfigured, exciting Council.'
Yay!
I use the term "Citizen" here, to include all those person
sw
ho work in the City shucture in a non -paid position,
from Council to all those on Committees/Commissions. And alw1ys, standing nght next to Citizen, is "Staff,"
meaning paid employees, with long-standing and hopefully secure jobs, the backbone of how thCiry operates
smoothly on a daily basis. Together Citizen and Staff in harmony make a strong City government.
At this Goals*wSetting session, my wish is to provide perspective specifically about how, for llclty Council-
appointed-Committees/Commissions, the role of Staffhas become too powerful and the role of Citizen, has been
watered..downi"n the last decade, to the detriment of the City. That interplay between Citizen'and'
Staff is a vital,evitable push/Dullin my opinion. A City needs both, empowered. 'Without dialogue as equals, something goes
awry# I illustrate, below. I make recommendations at the end,,
2) WHAT I HA;VE SEEN:9 BAD THL+"N GOOD AND THEN...BAD AGAIN
a) COMMITTEE CRATED, 'THEN 'PHIS BAD THING ,HAPPENED, IN 1993
A Citizen Committee-- the PBACu-malmo'st destroyed aftCron a few months' existence:
• In 1993, the Federal Government stated -9 "Our highway system, our commitment since 1956, is complete, so
now we wish to pnon.tize ding for non motor vehicle transportation options." It was mandated that TF a City
wanted to receive certain IS7'EA transportation funds then they needed to form committees with a majority.
bicyclists.
• So a new -local Committee was publicized which became the Pedestrian Bicycle Advisory Committee AC].
I and others enslasthutically joianed, and as a group we were an idealistic bunch, interested in this Committee
not as a "pathway to Council" and not as "bikes as recreational pleasures" but more as °support of safe
b icycle/safe walking infrastructure as a means to encourage a healthier Petaluma, cleanerairi, a healthier
worldt" Global warming was not in common parlance,then. The mandate was interpreted [by us] to include
Pedes#rians, since "all bicyclists are also pedestrians." In our first 3 months, we began questiomng
infrastructure things like: solid fencing being built between industrial parcels; bl'
ockages being erected by new
development preventing long-term existing bike/ped access; the building of cul-de-sacs wk►ich don't let
pe estrans i es
a' e ough: all things which ultimately result in "everyone just driving cars everyw ere to
avoid meaningless raring car -oriented routes."
But was it an easy birth? No. We had been placed under Park and Rec, its Director attended all our meetings,
and he was uncomfortable with these discussions. He began saying they were not our "purview", although we
didn't have a purview yet. 'We were finding our purview.
Then the bad thing:.a on or three in, we received a letter from the Assistant City Manager, announcing that
this Committee was no longer to meet regularly, that we only would be meeting once a year in order to c ec�C
off the box for the IS01 b 0A favids. 'What??
• Y was appalled, m
y idealistic commitment to our City shocked, and also was 9 months pregnant. But we stood
up and rebelled. That is to say, we crossed Staff: It was not pretty, 'We requested a meeting between ourselves,
the Park and Stec Director, the,Assi'stant City Manager whose letter had d
1111PI���� � f 104
t
i
e
Attachment 2
Council member. Bv the end of thateetm*iz, or soon after, -we had been re -commissioned, removed from
under Park and Rec and placed under the Planning Commission, and were backto meeting every o
The Committee still exists.
b)• THE STUPENDOUS'1`li1i�1G THAT HAPPENED AF111EK9 FROM 19-94 TO 200:3
The PBAC worked creatively�collaboratively for over ten years, in ways that shaped and inspired anv
• Thus came the collaborative work within the PBAC and the City w ch occurred over a 10 year period. Y
tlier week.
inspiring. This work included many things
nd eventually included doing project review.
• That break was not b y, accident. The PBAC me
"In my first job here Y was hired on as a contractor to make a Bike Map
Staff member pulled me aside told me
t in 'the Staff break room near the City Clerk's
was
office. One day a
with bike pedestrian trails all over the undeveloped East side, to bel"Mple ented asi't developed. But--believe
me --as soon as itwaus done it was shelved, and there was nobody, fighting for it. Look, I'm just a bottom feeder
here, still. None of it happened!" He fi
It terrible abou
t it1--was he almost cryng, that tough gu? Not sure.
Anyway his advice: "Your Committee needs to have power. How do you do that? Get on the'Proi ect Referal
List.' Without that, you're nothing." And,he gave me a copy so I could see it and show the Committee.
•So amidst all the planning we did, to figure out how to be a Committee, to write the first Petaluma Bike Plan,
create mandates in the City codes in consultation with Staff, we also put our names on the top of that list, with
Fire, Police, Public Works and the others. Our purview and Bike Plan were approved.
• And thatis how it happened that PBAC became an active, passionate, committed group, within the city
structure, shoulder to shoulder with Staff, for 10 years. An empowered Committee, a willing Council,mingling
with a staff that.... well, 1*n-truth rejected many of our Recommended Conditions of Approval, accepted some
and some got put back in at SPARC -- _another Citizen group!]
0 A ro il ramPm}iPr +1, ; P. .x,av. 10 01 i P Thpatex crniare wac not there_ real old warehouses were still along the River
on 1st St, and most of Cypress Technology was as yet,unbul'lt. There was a lot going on.
• I was Chair for 9 of those years. What did we do, ourselves,-i'n specific?
o we had regular noticed meeting twice a month, and any people who were curious. about us wandered
M, including Jack B,.,Ishaw who cane to many meetings,joking, "I came here to hate you guys but
how can T? Yodre working for the good 1."
o we had far-reaching, raucous discussions,.
o we wrote the Bike Plan ourselves =The Planning Department was being dismantled, and we would pass
the pages by the Interim Planning Director as we went]
o we saw the Bike Plan passed unam*mousl by Council [PattIligoss was mayor]
o we were formally placed on that Project Referral List as mentioned, and were sent full-scale plans for
every project coming through larger than 5 -home subdivisions. '
o we would ride our bikes to wherever that project lay. [what a leanning experience that was !]
o then, at the next meeting, one member would present what had been learned, we would look at the
- plans, and how the project might be enhanced to connect bikes and pedestrians within and without,
then we would write our own Recommended Conditions of Approval.
o those Recoil mended Conditions of Approval were then given to the Staff member in charge of the
project and--noatter what was or wasn'ti'mplemented at Staff level --were always attached to every
project's staff report, a s - written by us, for the record'.
o and eventually (the year 20007) one among us -"I volunteered --was permitted to attend the preliminary
Staff hearings every other week or so. 'That group is now referred to as the DRC (Design Review
Committee) and I surmise Citizen input there does not happen unless it might be a developer. And that
is not good practice for thapuuwssp izen/Staff dance that T am describing as good government,
• Jn sum, it was a collaboration with respect --and sometimes annoyance-- on both sides, and our City contains
infrastructure on the ground todayakm*g things safer and more inviting for Peds and bicyclists, that.likely
would not have been put there without the PBAC.
C) BAD AGAIN FOR PBAC--AND OTHER COMMITTEES
In this last decade, PBAC and other Committees once again demeaned and curtailed:
• rtunately in these last 10 years, the basic problem described in (a) above has been reowenaotedwwwalthough in
a much subtler way-- not only at the PBAC, but other Co mi'ttees As well. [see "Personal Comments by a-
varle
of Committee members" below]
• How did it happen? The last City Manager, at base, saw the Citizen Committees/Commissions as "an annoying
money and time -waster." This was stated iri "private conversations" the City Manager had with a variety of
people who have told e,, But it was no secret, Despite his much good work,eu�.0�.l�mma'r�1�eF�ag� o
.1
I
Attachment 2
difficult financial times, this was one glaring negative. It may have been informed by his concern about
money. But it was not a good thing
• And Staff --for who the City Manager i*s the bossft&"M*
0
exert control. Which they did. Can they unlearn that?
And the process b,% which it haDnened I describe belo,
o _Staffmg�r ramped u
Staffing at all meetin
their turn, were encouraged to abet that viewpoint and
,and it was not just with the PBAC sr
gs was ramped up, from zero Staff much of the time to at
least2atevery meetmg,( leastlenglin r and 1 secretary "to take the notes
watched by the professionals," mecostioreacn meeiingwentup,
o ,A�endas by Staff: It was S taff who begw
mI*ght that be suggested, then di*stributm*
o Who's in charge?" Staff began to playa i
.") WI*th all this "being
n to write the agendas, saying "yea" or It
g the agenda themselves before the next
arge role in runmng'the meetings.
fA o Free Discussion?" With such a set-up, free -wheeling Committee discus
nay" to van'ous'l't
eenng,,(more cost)
ems
sion was no
o Many cancelled: Many meetingswere cancelled by Staff, through no
along the lines of "No issues to discuss."
t so frequent.
tices saying s omething
o Who writes down the decisions? Staff: Those Recommended Conditions of Approval which once the
PBAC had written, became something vetted then written UP'by the Staff (More City cost), and
whatever was deemed not kosher or of value was left out, A's one person stated to me, "Staffjust made
the recommendations they wanted." And, thereby, there was no record of the entirety of t1lei'deas of
the Committee.
3) PERSONAL COMMENTS
a) CONEqENTS BY MLE
"No issues to discuss ??"I
say in astonishment attliel"deathat meetings of the P.IBAC could have been cancelled by
s taff due to "nothing to discuss," I muse on my own experience during these years: "During this last S years I
attended almost every SMART Board meetings. In virtually every one'. there were PBACvwrelevant issues and
decisions being made! SMART was planni*ng'1` ts platforms, its parking lots, - its bike parking on trains, i ts station
bikekiparng whether bike racks or lockers. It was requesting i'nputfrom every City if they wanted extra seating on
the platforms, and was making decisions about tcetprik ices in public meetings. "No issue to discuss ?" that
related to bikes and pedestrians? Absurd! But my observation was: by this time, the PB,4C was dispirited, and my
attempts to get interest and the age n diz, i4ng of various SMART issues, e.g. regularly, was for naught. I didn't blame
them. They were stifled and becomingpassrve. I even went to the City Engineer whom I laiew and likedfrom my
years on the PB,4C, and who was now staffing it and he told me, outright, "I decide the agenda. 1-t, comes down'
from the'top, "End of subject.
b) COMAWN 8 BY A VARIETY OF COMMITTEE MEMBERS
In talking to many people, from various Committees, in this last month, Y have heard're arks which illustrate what
I am saying but in more colorful language:
• "We couldpla'n our asses offa-**.4but nothing happened,"
• Or, "I just gave up on the Committee a while ago, Ifelt so oppressed at how the system was working. "
• Or, "They had neutered it,"
• One ex-Committee member told me: "During that time, the actual charter of our Committee was -changed to
make us have less power!"
• A particularly cynical remark was: "Oh the attitude was `Let them meet and oh, whatever.., whatever the
suggestions, write iet down andfile it and ignore it.' "
• Or, "Wow. We11, there are a lot ofsmartpeople whose opinions or research. are just ignored.,. That's whafthe
City misses out on by acting this way!"
•
And, !'That's what they do, and f they do it this way, you're throwing awrxy intellectual property!" This is what
worries me: referring to Staff as a dismissive "they." That is, an unhealthy situation.
And to me, the saddest, dispirited comments about why people didn't ttaketo take more power -while this
was happening: "Well, that would be fine if you had a gong ho committee. ° I saw that with my own eyes, a few
times, when I sat in; if you are a ColVnittee, gutted of power and initiative squelched for long enough, gong-
ho goes away'.
Input Summary'
1 -Page 63 of 101
0
go
A A U tit
4W
# i # i 1wr# # i
ti
Mb
JAKIL
i'ION
dr def 4W
Ek i (9 tail a fel M�
can be bal ced decisions end 11D stoniiej
",x- 4wY
in the end."p4&�
zen and S
Oh, don't act so polari*zed,
D A 1%^ v 40
S inerenton,onties.. Ulf T/ hi
*A -d ? D"d he asp, how
Di'd the S erson
a.cm.ee wim me 1
i i II a I� a & is It � iso � 1 1 1 • II a�N�
i
sell $6 TQ9111i
do oft i isjot
ILA
lot Vd
r i i lot
i d
jr
lop
id' A
v
M JA 1111111 111! Raw,
�i
A A in indo do Mt
# i i i ilI i
A
06
�' i � i MR
i
3 I•� i i � i � i #
Av
a v
IIIA i i'
AL do
W i
y�
i i i ' do
A # i i i ` A
4W
4.
i � +� � � � i•I � � � i � � � � i � � III
iA i
do Mk
O
M
Attachment 2
d) ONE MORE, BIG IDEA
• Bring back our own Plannmg Department: Yes MP -Group. Are they Staff? Or are they contractors? Is that
healthy? I'm not sure. I wenti"n today to M-Grobp and asked, "If you don't mind, please, could you tell me who
works here as Planners?" and the very patient person working th esk could only give me a paAial answer,
wasn't sure who worked 40 hours a week, and said, "Do you mean at this location? We work in -the whole Bay
Area." There's something strange about that whole setup, and I wonder.. is it time to have our own people
working in our own Staff chain of command?
6) SUMMARY
El It is my hope that this new era, with this wonderful new Council mix and this hi9YPmhlspoken-of new Ci
ty
Manager, is one in which Citizens and Staff work together more closely, as equals. That there are less closed -door
Staff -only meetings. Less top-down dictates from Staff to- Committees/Commissions. And I look forward to the
integration of new energies-- such the Climate Action Campaign --into the City Committee/Commission structure.
b) Without an active bo'lsteri'ng of Committee/Commission role, the vitally interested person can feel shoved to the
outside, alienated. Eventually, after griping a while, such people -just start their own networks, outside.Two new
outside [NGOA111YPe] Petaluma groups grew up, in this last 3 years, both birthed by persons who had experienced
and verbalized frustration within the Committee/Commission process: What if those folks had felt more
empowered on the inside and were now focusing all that creative juju by working collaboratively within the City's
arms, with input welcomed, and available for all of us to vet and view?
Ihankyou- very much for rending this! It
took me 3 full days of endless revision, to try to clearly,
compassionately communicate things I care about, for our C o!! Ilsope it is useful
Sincerely, Patricia Tuttle Brown
40 lop
Input Summary 1 -Page 65 of .104
T
{
Cooper, Claire
...... . ..... . . ..... 1_11 Mill
Subject: Petaluma City Counc'11'Goals Setting, April 6, 2079
FrottleR'chard Brawn
Sent,* M
TTo:City Council<citycouncil@ci.petaluma.ca.us>; -- City Clerk <CityClerl< cvpetaluma.ca,us>
ondav, March 2'5,, 2019 2:51 PM
i
Subject: Petaluma City Council Goals Setting, April 6, 2019
To:
Mayor Teresa Barrett,
Counci- members:
-Mc Donne IKatY Miler.
qP
:)'Lynda Fi'scier, Miciae Healy, Gabe Kearney, Dave King; Kevin
City Manager: Peggy Flynn
Subject: City Council Goal Setting for 2019 (Apr
2018 Goa s cannot
economic co lapse,
n
r.
be used as a mode- to add o
Averting Collapse s could :)e
Teat central issue is insufficient
Insufficiency gas -been allowed t
failure vortex
it 6, 2019).
11
Attachment 2
t
r subtract from,, This City is on the verge falling into
tie community and City CounciPs Number 1 priority.
funding to maintain tie community and
o fester and now is at tie point
Here are some numbers.
its vita infrastructure,,
of having tie community enter a
90
deferred ro.6 9ad maintenance is now over Z�]1.0-$150 mi lion and c eterioraTin-ci at around - -
5% per year. Using tie lower number, tris means tie repair bill will be $5.5 m
cur,rentotioles,pCurrently only $3.5 million is being sp
ent., In 10 years., t -
maintenance
wbe $140 to $200 million: Simply 40% more roadway :)otioles and damage.
illion just to maintain tie
ie unfunded roadway
CALPe's is demanding a $1 mi Iron per year i
And tiat demand may well increase if a recession occurs,
ncrease each year for tie next
In 10 years instead of $40 mi lion fort ie General =und,
mil ion and roads will gave deteriorated an additional 40'%1
Petaluma w
4
10 years.
ill gave on -Y-. $30
Tris is tie ear mark of a City e ntering into a failure vortex. Teat is a government teat cannot
fu Ifi its reason for Being and a community ooking at ever worsening -conditions,
Su es-t*iona, Number. 'I C'1!LRrioritLbe Increase city revenues faster than expenditures..
Does economic GROW I HP roduce more city income t an w�at teat growti wi i be ususing?nq?
Answer: In tie past, nobody cared. Today, we gave tie fruits of teat policy (see above). Tie City
Council gas to ask Itse f if it s�ould survive as a governing body or not. Tie answer will be seen in
whether -or not the City Counci-'takes on the role of focusing on ensu ing a I growti pays for
itself, Future costs are far out stripping future revenues w�ici places tie city a primary state of
col apse,, f Council provides on ly_ Iip service t een mat �ematically, tie city will imp -Ode/colla 3 -se.
Exam
pleA Westridge Knolls leve opment was completed in 1994. Today its roads need urgent
repair. Tie cost will be -ap proxim ate y $1. 5 to $3 million to d 0 tie joy. Because of fund s lortfalls, tie
City, cannot repair t-iese roads. In fact, it cannot even completely ensure internal arteria s are
4i
Input Summary 1 :)age 66 of 101
t
11
u
F
Attachment 2
maintained and n
eig .i)or i
-oo d streets will :e .e .ft to go to ruin. Yet Co.. u
n
ci is still encouraging
activities t gat do not gay for t �emselves.
-
_.
. -
IP
suggest that any prospective deveIoDer :e asked the s1MD1equestion: Siow us (City
C
o
u
nc
il)
pow your project wi l increase. city revenues. No exceDt"ons no negotiations, it has to aDly to
everYtiing. C1early,.t1is Wou d-give.deve1oDers a sol'd.)asis to" Cenci in" whether to go forward with
the eve oPMent.
I suggest that.Council reduce:expenditures and future commitments. Council will gave to
identify those key, functions.it must maintain if Pet 1uma-]s to%survive uggest 10se-areUtiWtY
functions and legal infrastructure in.order.to maintain harmonY4'Tiis means incredible'disappointme
nF
t
for maw. But it is ej ier disappoint or,take tie vortex ride down. I suggest this ent'reGoas Setting
period be used to accomDlis� hese two tasks: identify w�at iasto :e cut in order to do tie east
damage. Second to IdentIfyDoiicies teat wiI ensure9rowth provides more city revenues tian it costs
th e city.
F
Of course, the gird option is �o�e and gayer. But I dou:t God would accept teat Burden.
Sincerely,
Riciard Brawn
41
01
. 2
Input Summary 1 -Pag
e 67 of 19Q
r
L
t
4
0
f
I
+
t
P
F
Attachment 2
11001kinla CI[V Council
Petalmilito CA 911-q5-2
1 I Tnglish Street
April It', 2019 dF
Dear Petaluma C�.,Ity.CO111161,14
Itidl►is161e Potulu�un sup���x�s as 15 minimum wage ordinance- in Ile. Idumpla
r1 c-upori from `nic S i1i v o f Working son 011111 FAA I 1 ti: r1 Fror'llc of Income & R ij*ci 111 1'O- verty .t 1-.:, 0%NY
Wage. 1-11411 11110),1111VIII
(Im�,:fJnoril�b:,vlobs►�itiii►isliic,c)rUS1►u.�+!�>2Qo�'�?f1�11aekine4o305r�nr�n�a���?02(1! K, I`in,71"a2�)12�•pcir�,�c11` y
XPA
Highlighted the following.:
One in four Sonoma Count), residents five in fwnlfles receh'ing annual liwomes of less lhmi 1300 percent of file
fedumal poverty fible- or ahmit $50,'70.U for n ranifly of four;
Qne 111 n -V(I- coul 11), res-ideil(r I I ve i n „�o rk I tig pio r fa nd I I es el -I ni I i ig Liss t lii�ra '?�Il Pin: nl or Ilse ti�dvra7) fm) 41ei-iy�
line iv 11h al IeA 1 oil lie A) repnir11o6 loc(mW rrom imrk;
%81omen Lotions iind other peo.Et of colo�� e�7mi�ience the hl�hesi rnlcs of pmeri�� and di.�r�poriionnlcly
comprlte the working none;
A 11king or svirbsu den ey woge for Son OnM CO un1p is �:.3 nn hour bij1 a hntd I hrec•�unricrs of i hc,ne��3nbS
createdl�et�i�ecn 2014-�mZO'24 mill pay 10M (Im" n 11$MIAC W1191VIO
Neorly onc, in two Sontima COunty renter homvwbO1titi arcs r'oW biwilonvid mid pay more than Vit) percent u1'
11ie1rg'rcxm monthly incimie for rent; mul quitrter ore severehf rent burdened and Pay mare 1111111 SO 1wreen!
f��r reit,
(it��'��e�12011(1 ti�'td 2010 m'(11on rr�1�5 incruuvc�f lay 25 per«nl l�ti the c+�ui�11' ►�'Itil�� medlon roll�r 111��rmr�
)IM11%, 9 Pefte,111)
t�umilies I'll !;gym<,m;a (-7ollity;n'e sh'uj;};ling it) 111:11koe Olds Ined-d PeliP01111.1r.) 1111s 1110 IVirldo Yntl, rlti
clecte'(1 OffidL1111st C40111 move ilii vendul(1111 filster mid ittlop1 this tiew roli� WAV, her�nr�c ti'uUr �onylilllclylti fi�ecl li�ir
�Yi1gCs l�xlt�y; itul I+�tliufrii�v!
111L1'1,%11N-i1)1O I)o-ItI111111a
Co-1-Clin'Irr
Diredor 11inul Gmeffero
i
f
0
0
Ej
Input Summary 1 - Page 68 of 191
❑
x
Attachment 2
Jr
all
Cooper, Claire
LLJ
Ime
Council Agenda SettingSubject* -
susta't'nabie municipal finance
From: Teddy Herzog
Sent: Tuesday, Apri12, 2019 9*18AMI
To:
Council Agenda Settingsubject: sustainable municipal finance
dear City Counci ,
ot a vailab e for tie1\1
wor<solo:) Saturday,, Please allow me to give in gut sere for tieIV
agenda setting Works -10011
Ire
* Sustaina ale rnunici3al finance.
Seems to rne teat 2020 is tie year to get tris done.
Can weeducate tie pub is a:)out the City Budget this year in simplified21.
3resentations?
Thank you for your service to the City.
Teddy Herzog
334 <eokuk Street, Petaluma
(7 0 7) 481-407
Ip
input Summary 1 -Page 69 of .1��
Pkta�hmen�2
'�ate5Sa�QS�1,11
�e
AU101C
ases
�pa neW 219 nc
* diUSted
a\e 9 �o��fO215CP/0
C�o`�efader(i
a9 250%
coIYO
tat Op%450110
eaCorte
but? 9•� o
� Ur0
r\'SP pp%
a��e�
ja'S
'to %
0%0
000
n
e
RoGcP/O
151YI0
t
Sausa��t� �
S°°,
Seba
1e � $'251Y
10
g.2�p0
Pet�'�u�a
r Page 7p of ���
Input Summary �
Petaluma Ci"ty Goals Surv%..y
M
You live anid
work here
M
0
a
T�
COMMUNI , Y SURVEY
fir4.
L 'M
Answered: 5,53 Skipped: 2
M
G
65.28%
ac-%hment'7
M
M
El
361
23
169
1 / 5 Input Summary 1 -Page 7,1 of 194
-17% .0-4 a je-IA
Petaluma City (joals Suiwej
3
Answered: 543
Our Community
Skipped: 12
Our Events!
Our Connection
to Agriculture
Our Concer:
Our Downtown
0
10%
Total Respondents., 54;j
20% 30%
2/5
EZ�Y'�.1
c
F
MUM,
AN
"i M74
R
202
131
315
38
86
168
137*
1 09 1 p Ut, bul 1111 ICIr 1 Payt 72:ue%t I U1,
-rA
-retaluma City Goals Suiwey
I
F
Ej
Answered: 549
a
'A 0=1 111
11
Community
Engagement,
9
M
ANSWER CHOICES
Ifflow
6% =01 ip "I,
20% 30%
m
Slipped:
50%
9
G
7 7,
36,43%
V.
r��
3 / 5
Input Summary 1 Page 73 of 191
'o
,Attachment 2
"
V.arc ta'luma City Goals Suiw�ey
ji� JI I�
lik
TIMM U16 �# M1111 WIS!
Answered: 545
M
Skipped," 15
Family Utopia
CRY
Ir
Cutturally
..............
mnMu"w•nm' ,w
44
., O u w tl a s
ON;
............. .
... . ..... .....
. . . .
Integrated
Ale, 1p r% i Oft 'ONd
ttvrdcr%11b1e% Hokusiiiy
Ayj-'de-Triend'ly U Ity
UU1,1ural'k,m Integrated
y
NOW
if.
Total Kesw"%ondentsm: 540
�p
u
13
a
u
Q
NOW
a it
94
291
135
142
PAN -i':
Input Summary 1 -gage "t'mw 5 of 1 0 4
Attac-iffi oftnt
A CITY THAT WORKS
FISCALLY SUSTAINABLE CITY
A
STAFF
INPUT
=Y 2019-2021
0
City's costs arein balance with income
The community understands where money comes from and where it goes
Regional resources are leveraged
ENGAGED STAFF SUPPORTED WITH TECHNOLOGY TO IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Workload
is balanced
41
prioritized and realistic
New staff is supported by on -boarding programs including a buddy/sponsor system
Staff compensation and support is competitive, so that Petaluma attracts and retains,talent
Internal processes and technology support efficient, collaborative, customer service oriented,
and proactive staff work
Staffing needs consider upcoming
AN ENGAGED COMMUNITY
retirements and support upward mobility
Public information is easily accessible
The community trusts the City because we are authentic, honest'and transparent
A SAFE COMMUNITY SUPPORTED BY STAFF THAT IS PREPARED FOR-, AND CAN RESPOND TO, EMERGENCIES
Prevent fires and accidents by encouraging weed abatement and proper management of
hazardous materials
Be prepared for an emergency
Assure that City's emergency operation center is fully staffed and trained to respond to an
emergency
Engage local non-profit community to help respond to emergencies
Educate community to prepare for an emergency
i
Injuries and crime are prevented through safe buildings and public spaces and community
awareness, education and engagement, and police presence
(Increased community policing)
Police and fire stations, training grounds, facilities, and alerting systems are safe and adequate
(an additional fire station is needed)
. Petaluma's youth know how to react during a fire and how to administer Cardiopulmonary
Resuscitation (CPR) / First Aid
Input Summary 1 -Page 76 of 191
W
Attacim nt 2ftv
-STAFF INPUT
=Y 2019-2021
LIVING WELL, TOGETHER
IN:
A COHESIVE COMMUNITY WITH AMPLE RECREATION PROGRAMS AND OPPORTUNITIES
Safe and Accessible parks, pools,, playgrounds, and balifields
Increase awareness for current program offerings while integrating new.classes and activities
A HEALTHY COMMUNITY
Incorporate park amenities that enhance social connectivity
Incentivize active lifestyles by promoting community events and improving public places of leisure
SUFFICIENT HOUSING FOR ALL INCOME LEVELS
Workforce housing prioritized.
Housing committee established
5-year plan for housing based on projected available-funds completed
OUR HERITAGE IS PRESERVED AND CELEBRATED
Support Petaluma Centric Exhibits at the Historical Museum and library
Offer community events and gatherings that honor Petaluma's past
ALL LOCAL ANIMALS ARE CARED FOR AND SAFE
Animal shelter hours meet community needs
ECONOMIC VITALITY
PETALUMA'S ECONOMY IS STRONG,, SUPPORTS LOCAL JOBS AND GENERATES INCOME TO SUPPORT CIN
SERVICES
Businesses stay and grow in Petaluma
Businesses paying living wages are attracted to Petaluma
Businesses can find trained talent
LOCAL BUSINESS PARTICIPATES IN COMMUNITY EVENTS AND PROGRAMS
INDUSTRY CLUSTERS ARE SUPPORTED BY CONNECTION TO LIKE BUSINESSES,, SHARED TRAINING, AND SUPPORT
EMERGENCY BUSINESS RESPONSE TEAM AND PROTOCOL HELPS BUSINESS PREPARE AND RECOVER FROM
NATURAL DISASTERS AND OTHER EMERGENCIES
VISITORS ARE WELCOME AND SOUGHT AFTER
nput Summary 1 -Page 77 of 19Q
Att a c i mt@nt 2
STAFF INPUT
=Y 20' 9-2 0 2'
GREAT PLACES
DOWNTOWN IS VIBRANT
A VIBRANT AND ACCESSIBLE RIVER AND PUBLIC SPACES
TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT MAXIMIZES DEVELOPMENT NEAR TRANSIT STATIONS
A MASTERPLAN FOR CITY -OWNED FAIRGROUNDS PROPERTY IS COMPLETE.
PETALUMA INFRASTRUCTURE IS MAINTAINED AND PRESERVED
Streettpavemen, paths, and parking lots — (Consider funrciisindg)
Building upgrades such as water proofing, HVAC.improvements, f'i'xtures, flooring
Water, sewer,'Storm systems
Parks -fields, furniture and facilities
ALL NEIGHBORHOODS-HAVE ACCESS TO RECREATION, COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS, WALKABLE PATHS AND
AMENITIES.
TRAFFIC IS RELIEVED WITH ROBUST TRANSIT,, BICYCLE AND PEDESTRIAN INFRASTRUCTURE AND THE
COMPLETION OF RAINIER AND THE CAULFIELD RIVER CROSSING
FIBER OPTIC CABLE INSTALLATION INCREASES COMMUNITY BROADBAND ACCESS
ENVIRONMENTAL LEGACY
WE ARE SMART AND EFFICIENT WITH RESOURCES
Reduce greenhouse gas emission
Facilities that conserve water
Increase recycling standards to "zero waste"
Use wastewater biosolids to fertilize agricultural land
TRAIN STAFF TO IMPLEMENT ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY MAINTENANCE
THE COMMUNITY KNOWS HOW AND IS ENCOURAGED TO DO THEIR PART
Input Summary 1 -Page 78 of 141
a
Axi
Mar�ch,26,,, 2019
dl IN t, a uma
a,lgem :rie, n e
All
Sk
Am,
on�o::Ma uoun,
Wh'Ie there i,
a,
g� nr(D"'one-wsize
able for varying si,:tages
consider stepping up.
11
I & 01
In,pu,t Summary I bot Page 79 o:f'l 91
l
3
�tta�hment 2
lov etaku�r'a S g sta n9
je*0rkted we `N°r t N'\Sofy
vide a AlIXIa senior
1 `es would p�ommunity •`p eta
p nut
00V ....t.� W\ he, ��tN�t�es
Z)
e000iOpa nU`y S
kiiec\a� ilD�a CoU` rat�ona` unities fi°r steers
is\\ng a
a19
e Wh iday Sor �nter9VIene ods and oiler°s reets•� °ee�rNge0o aSp°�S�th`1 f dor Sa orr`ttee afire �de a��eSS ht �etrof�t P aluma eo
p o
G°m markets PTo E� Streee� V\kO
r Me, tetter • )(Iat s 00
e, ak
ur af�'ers t year S nce t M u\d ° e,ment• S 4�d�� ction•
LaE a d�fifiere Butwe �° nd�`! m°v o age 9rOVXpnt, then E
a
` Vea
rly mak�n e
Network lar in the els ca`� then ges int human and a�
and the �\1aJu ExPe twk, aj*0
vSS
e a huge irn'P
„ tom P°p o\d • es y
10�
an BOn ct .Veaab°ut
a, en
h
are
er,
4
I-
v
eaT
^o`d;Sv9he� we efde�`at;s �rso
c,a� eop\e tre
S
pe#�es • en benefiits.o h phys�ca� ax, By 2�35hSto N , thanearSoare not
in
)D es dgethat ne�ess�ty' �n V.S- e extra y u\ts stay
ONN\e t�,being• an out °f e first t�rne � er thos oder ad « roWd
NNehea�ement e,,dyes {Orth are �0 9 o SutSwto �hrien
"10
'tnur�`ber ch hide Pe al �Once� O\At trat tree tyre A
The geowo
ed t° °u Ovoefss � j�\end\y \t f
ps out the
are eXPe�t baby boa\th. Pge" osa�b�e• thr�u910
nofi
°fi�c\e
i19 oo\\e as �on9 as p ood heath ing p0\3U\a��r�ent
in9 ,
and act�v `{S ;S ,�o SupP °r� 9 e have a g�oX mated cab pe fi O\c\er
hea\th`l oder
adu �han9e t �Gr is app 13 �rr�er ta9e ° errs •
Y\eaktfi yend�y . � e\0jAo9raPa uma �S d � 9 tO t�the PUrse� ong the .the ° age Peon36 C'Ofensus ea\J)
y d°areen a�ereV.SGndyu\,Ala comes to urthe �orn�a th unity, a it ubi�e o+comm inden�aea�ternflal
as
O\derer trap u�ey p w �n � be ompared to ,dun\AO\N
h�9 mS easy to adu1't.
Go . � �ont�nue to 9r ° oc�et`1�� it S s, when. �„ aae V. - n the�� an \der
adu\ts w�i oU�h sesse�ahv00
s ger
pan
a y. happen � o age 5
meant 1" your
Jill
to °`'thenommittee*'
0
But#ag�n9 a�ority �fi e . the 9>f?
what wil\ S nor A
m o
.s
the Baas
POssib�e•oU tto he Peta�Uma
hong e �N�\\ `l � pair 0f
and
w 1 lot IS the
Kris 'e
i
1
h
r
i
any 1 r pale gp of
input Summ
�g
1
OW
,,. Striving to create community where people of all ages and abilitl
���;`';�.��`� admin@bikepetaluma.org • facebook.com/ibikepetaluma
A VIP%
:1 a
. Wil 4 2019
t"If I
Y
Pet,alurna Cit Counic'I
11 Street
English
P
,..ta,,Ium,a UA o4��Joz
Dear Mayor, Ci:ty Uolunci'larnembers, and C'I'ty Manager.
boft*
the opportunity t
01
es can sarely eniby bicych"nga
W
II
S can enjoy ucyc1ingO
t,o create ,
a communitN i
,/ w:I ere peop e:o- all ages and a 1 itie
Attacimien't fA,]
Ik.
o owing ne,
II ie e ,
we, ave i enli i ar�terdrn priormes.
So,meone'I's hitt by a driver and injured: (or worse) whit
inf
,jurielis an ....,anties cause
e wal,k"ing or biking on Petaluma, street4Q,
every nine days. A Vis',I'on Zero policy would corm the C
usersing, educei
vu ner,a,, e roa roven engineer;
! 0
Ity's COMM'I't
and enforcement strategmiesS
NEW&
he outdate: Bicycle and Pede,strian maiaLer V anY
6.
V's,B'ICYcd,e and Pedestr'j'an Masteir P'lan I.te: in 2 08) no :.onger incorpora es es
esinn or retlects'bicxcie and ..e estrian
�J JY
in street
loriTies'.
An up� lialtred Ian would'
ncreasing Sratet, and conven
heience of wa,lkin! g and' b'I'king.
Y
JP
n
Attachment 2
3) Plan and implement protected b'ike' lanes on D St. between 1st St. and Lakeville St.
Bike Petaluma has identified this congested stretch of D St. that links transit connections with
downtown as a terrific candidate for protected bike lanes; which would provide physical
separation between pe'ople'bikinq and vehicular tragic. The blocks between Weller and Lakeville
r future, creating a once-winp*a*w1i'fetime opportunity to
Streets are slated for development'in the nea
incorporate this best practice.
4) Make Lynch Creek Trail a welcoming, vibrant, and sustainable pathway that is
of all ages and abilities.
celebrated and used by residents and visitors
Work with stakeholders (including Bike Petaluma, Friends of the Petaluma River, Friends of
Lynch Creek'Tra'11, Petaluma Waterways) to establish a vis ion for Lynch Creek Trail, including
the-i'dent'Ification of near. mid.
impacts on
:9
into a linea
the Rive
r park.
rand surr
and long-term projects that will enhance
Ir -D
its accessibility. minimi ze
ounding habitat, promote active transportation,
and transform it
5) Ensure that bike lanes and shoulders along major roadways are kept clear of debris
and -vegetation.
u
Commit Recology to regularly street -sweep bike lanes and shoulders along major roadways.
Similarly, we request that the City's Public Works Department regularly manages vegetation (or
requires adjacent property owners -to do so) where it encroaches on bike lanes and shoulders.
0
6) Continue to improve the City Engineer, City Manager, and City Council's discourse
with the Pedestrian and Bicycle Advisory Committee.
The Pedestrian and Bicycle Advisory Committee has not been well -utilized over the past several
years. Though the s'ituat'ion has improved dramatically -over the recent months, we hope this
It
trajectory will continue and all bicycle and pedestr'ian-related'planning or discussion will continue
to pass through this group before going to the'City Council.
7) Promote and sponsor events, activities, and programs that celebrate b"icycling, provide
bicycling education, and foster community around bicycling.
Examples may include " open streets" events that celebrate active transportation, educational
events that reach people who bike and/or drive on how to safely share the road, or other
programs aimed at incenti'vizing or encouraging trips made by bike. Ensure that access to
outreach and activities is equitable across the City.
Input Summary 1 -Page 82 of 191
1P
Attachment 2
Attachment: Letter from 2017 Goal Setting Meeting Re: Bike/Ped Master Plan Update
(Resubmitted at 9/11/17 Council Meeting)
September 11, 2017
Dear Mayor and City Counc'['Imembers,
We, the undersigned, urge you to commit to updating -the City's Bicycle and Pedestrian Master
Plan in 2017-18. Of the Bicycle and Pedestrian Master Plans that have been adopted in
California, Petaluma's is now among the oldest.
As the blueprint fori'mprovements that would make Petaluma a safe, active, and healthy
community, it is crucial that this plan is kept up-to-date in order to incorporate 1) new
approaches to bicycle network planning, 2) the latest i1n street design techniques,. 3) recent
changes'in Petaluma I s bicycle and pedestrian network, and 4) projects that would compete for
regional and state funding and/or can be included in new development or street repaving
projects. These needs are outlined in greater detail below.
Adopting a New Approach to Bicycle Network Planning
A 2015 survey of U.S residents found that over half of the population is interested in cycling, but
too concerned about their safety to do so:. Cities that have been most successful at reaching this
group have undertaken a new approach, emphasizing low -stress connections that can be used
by people of all ages and abilities.
This approach has been far more successful at -increasing the number of people who bike than,
the standard bike lanes and shared lanes proposed in Pe'taluma's existing plan. A new plan is
needed to identify steps towards the creation of a bike network that works for all Petalumans,
not just those who are confident and able-bodied.
Incorporating Innovative Street Design Techniques
In order to create a bicycle network that can be used by people of all ages and abilities, it is
important to work with the most up-to-date street design techniques. Caltrans and the Federal
Highway Administration recently approved a new type of bike lane (Class IV) that provides
physical separation from vehicular traffic. Class IV lanes --like many other new street design
elements --did not exist when Petaluma developed.'Its current plan.
Incorporating Recent Changes in Petalu a's Bicycle and Pedestrian Network
Improvements along the Lynch Creek Trail, the new bicycle and pedestrian bridge near Water
Street, and the SMART multi -use pathway form the spines of Petaluma's walking and biking
network. A new plan should prioritize low -stress connections to these'facilities.
nput Summary 1 -' age 83 of 191
Attachment 2
Leveraging Funding, Development, and Street Repaving for Bicycle and Pedestrian
Improvements
As a result of having an outdated plan, 1) Petaluma projects will be less competitive for grant
funds and 2) projects implemented alongside new developments or as -part of street repaving
projects'
will largely ma'intain a status quo that has not successfully increased the number of trips
made by walking and bicycling.
As more cities make strides to become better places to walk and bike, funding opportunities for
bicycle and pedestrian projects continue to grow more competitive. Those who control these
funds use this competitive' process to encourage cit'i'es to implement more innovative projects
that will better support climate change and safety-related goals. By including the latest in bicycle
network planning and emphasizing projects that create connectivity for all ages and abilities,
Petaluma's grant appl'icat'ions will remain competitive.
With a number of large scale development and street repaving projects in the pipeline, it w'111 be.
important for the City to leverage these opportunities to incorporate our needs in an efficient and
cost-effective manner. Again, the existing plan calls for improvements that will not compel
people to walk or bike.
We encourage you to priontize.the development of an updated Bicycle and Pedestrian Master
Plan in- order to meet the mobility needs of children, those who are.unable to drive, and those
who would like the freedom to use active modes of travel to stay healthy and cut greenhouse
.2
gas emissions.
Sincerely,
:The undersigned]
Input Summary 1 :'age 84 of 191
21
Attachment 2
#
Name
Emaif
� Abe Stucky
aestucky@gmail.com71
2 Abigail Smyth abigail_smyth @yahoo.com
3 Abrams, Thomas
Tga3seb@comcast.net
4 Adam W*Iskind
adamwtSKnd@yah002com i
5 Alanna murphy Amurphyh@gmai scom
6 Alden, Dave
davea1den53@coMcastw net
7
AenalHeldecke'-
Alenam'arr@yahoo.com
g Alex
Maslanka
alexmaslanka@comcast.net
g Alexander Kamages Akamagesa otmaill.com
10 Alexi Taylor
alexi@bluesunrise.com
11 Alisha O'Loughlin Alisha@bikesonomanorg
12 A1*ISOn Hutchinsonson
Alison:,hutchvinsonrcogm.ail.com
13 Arnber Szob oszlai ambo@ucdavisffedu
14 Amy Malaise Bibanonl@gmail-comT4�
15 Andrea Anderson and read usterhoff@gmail;,com
16 ANGELA DELTA ANGELA.DELIA@ICLOUD.COM
17 Anna
S1veiraiAnn a6strings@yahoo.com
18 Anna simson
anna-Y
19 Barbara Drake
b arb@uplandfarms.com
20 Barbara Pollack barb arap@son ice net
21 Barry AlbertitzBussewbarryalbert@coMcast.net
22 Barton Smith barton@RealEstateStars.com
23 benjamin sarrazin benjamin@yubabikes.com
24 Bernard(Berne) Album
al
lbernie
5-@
9mcllcom
25 Bernie Album aIlbernie5@gmai scom
26 Beth Meredith beth@CreateTheGood
Life ory
27 Beth Smith bethh bbar
d
a
h
o
tm.a
ll,c
o
m
286ett Pagett bettypagett@gmail.com
29 Beverly Alexander smiIey ev gmai ,com
30 beverlyschor beverlysc orggmai Mc0M
31 Bill Cover wcover@gmai scom
32 Bill wolpert wolpert@sonic,,net
33 Bjorn Griepenburg bjorn.griepenburg@gmail.com
34onnie'deBBerry dkat007@ya N hoo.coM
35 Bree Arthur Mybreebirdgyahoo.com 1
36 Brent Lumsden
brent
37 B
ryan Williams bryw@rocketmail:Mcom.
30 Buck Crowley buckcrowley@hotmail.com
39 Carol Cornforth Caro1.1uber@gma11.com
40 Carole Ambauen carole,ambauen@hotmail.com
41 Caroline Dezendorf cad ezendorf@9ma*11 , com
42 Carrie ashendel Cmash.endgg mail. com
Input Summary 1 -Page 85 of 191
Attachment 2
43 Carrie Tolay road27pics@yahoo.com
44 Catherine V Fok Cvota@Ecotopi'a1nc,com
45 Cathy Kroll kroll@sonoma.edu
46 Charlie Schneider bikecharlie@gmail,.com
47 Christopher Bearden csbearden@gma:I'I.com!
48 Christopher Escam'111a anywave42day@yahoo,com,
49 Christopher Fisher ckatf'lsher@son*ic.net
50 Chrystal Sunshine powmetals@g mail. com
51 Clint Gilbert cl*lntbelove@gma'i'l.com
52 C:)rinne Leland Lei,andvion@gmail.com
53 Craig Bartosch Cbartosch@gmail.com
54 Dale Wannen dale.wannen@gma'll.com
55 Dana and Roland Garcia- dana roland@hotmail.com
56 Dana Te'icheira dte'['chei ra@comcast. net
57 DANIEL BROCKMAN dan@spicetrader,, net
58 Daniel Lyke, danlyke@flutterby.com
59 Daniel Prescott Theprescottblog@gmail.com
Ir 11
60 David Pearson David @pearsonftmfa m i ly.org
61 David perry Fran kly45@hotmail com
62 David Powers powers.davidf@gmail.com
63 David Zimmerman davidazimmerman@gma'll.com
64 Debbie Fox D.edgarfox@g mail com
65 Denise McDowell' Neasydm@gma'll.com
66 Dennis Jongsomjit Djongsomjitl @hotmail.com
67 Dennis Noriel Barndoug@yahoo,com
68. dermis po'cekay dpocekay@comcast.net
69 Diana Corvelle dianacorvell&agmaa
i.com
70 Diane Gentile Dianegent'ile@gma*ll.com
71 D'Lynda Fischer dlyndaf@gmail.com
72 Don Frances dfrances@qmail.com
73 Drew CurbY dcurby@yahoo.com
74 Earl Fisk emfmd@sonic.net
75 Eberle ewing Eberle 1-6@comcast,, net
76 Eckert, Norma N o rm a I'Ita 1 82@ya hoo . com
77 Edward Pay xuxinhauma@gmaii.com
78 Elaine Larson ela*lnelars@GMAIL.com
Elizabeth
79 Pond -McPherson artiques@me.com
80 Ellen B'Icheler ellenb@son'ic.net
81 Emily Cho echomyst@yahoo.com
egardner@emmagardnerdesign.c
82 Emma Gardner om
83 Eric Fiedler ericfied @g mail. com
nput Summary 1 -Page 86 of 191
Att c i ft---ent 2p.
V.
V.
P.
84 Eric Larson Elseawolves@yahoo.com
85 Eric Patterson e ric@cowgirlcreamery.com
86 Eric Storm enc(cO&-POW"createthegoodlife.org
Peripeters@hotma*1'.tcom
87 Erica Blaauw hics.c
echipchase@mercenarygrap
88 E
rik Ch*pchase om
8g Erin ChmieIews I Ebot363agmai
com
90 Erin Devincenzi erindevincenziQwg mail,, com
Thewrightsmanfamilv(COgmail.com
91 Erin wrightsman
g2 Frank Simmons mainstreetfrank@sbcglobal.net
93 Gail Burnett
Glb248(a)att.net
g4 Gail Burnett Glb248rcoattet n
95 gaii'luske 91uskeO@gmail.com
96 Gary Fontenot
Garyfontenot(a).gmail.com
Genevieve Navar
97 Franklin stannavar@gmail.com
g8 Gerald Gass gassulli@sonic.net
gg Gina Benedetti-Petnic ginarnarie,,bp@gmail.com
100 ging charbonneau
gina.charbonnea-u@gmail.com
101 Gina Fabiano Bina@ginafabiano.com
102 Greg Cahill gcahi112002@yahoo:pc.om
103 Gwen Fritts Gwenfrittsl 23@gma*l com
104 Gwynne Johnson Geynnejohnson@gmaiIscom
105 Haines, Nicola
quayle98rcoIsn,t.com
106 Heather bleasdell Heather@heatherbleasdell.com
107 Heather Kurland heatherstarrk@yahoo coM.
108 Heather Luttrell. 1hbomb@gma*11scoM
109 Hugh Helm
hhe1rn,,,,_Sonic. net
1 � 0 Hunter Phi{son
hphilson a�gmall,,com
111 Hutchinson, Tory t,oryan n9com cast. net
112 lain Crabb icrabb@me*com
113 tan Sutherland
i ansuth@fastmail.fm
114 i10ra Koren ibiskoren@gmail.com
115 jaana Nieuwboer nieuw aana@hotmailacom
jyurth(co comcast.net
116 Jacki Yurth
117 James bray ibb94952@gmail.com
118 fames page jiMMYMio@Yahoozcom
119 James Philson philson@comcast.net
120 James Schauer Wildfog@attvnet
121 Jan Kandeman kandeman@yahoo.com
122 Janice Cader-Thollipson Janicecader@gmail.com
123 Jason
jasonoedwards@gmai"Iscom
124 Jason Hoorn jasonhoornggmailtcom
87 of 191
Input Summary 1 -Page
A,
125 Jay Daniel Lapidus jaydan'ie1@m'e:,com
126.'- Jayme Peta ilpeta@gmail.com
127 Jeanette Ben Farhat ibenfarhat@santarosa.edu
128 Jeannie Perez jean n iesdes.ig ns@g mail. com
129 Jed Lane Jed@jedlane..com
130 Jed Lane jed,lane@l*cloud.com
131 Jeff Pierce i magwaza@g mail. com
132 Jeffrey kahn drieffk@comcast.net
133 Jennie Kimmel Jennie. k'immel@gmal*l.com
134 Jennifer Badde'-'Graves earthdancedbg@yahoo.,com
135 Jennifer Boss Jeboss@sbcglobal.net
136 Jennifer okonsky Jokonsky@gmail.com
Jennifer Selby
137 Greenberg jenselb@yahoo:.com
138 Jennifer Stock jen niferstock9@g mail. com
139 Jeremy Shima jeremyshima@yahoo.com
140 Jerry elute Jerry.clute@gmail.com
141 Jerry Fabiano jsfab'iano@comcast. net
142 Jerry Wilkinson jerryrwil ki nson Ag mail. com
143 Jesse Rankin jesseran@gma'il.com
144 Jessica Bryant Jcbacciocco@gma'11:,coM
145 Jessicca Moore J essicca. 1. moore@g mail. com
146 Jessie Neff Jmneff28@grnail.com
147 Jest*ln Brooks jestin7@gmaii.com
148 Joan Rasht'l Pushy43@son:ic.net
149 Joanna -Daly Jodaly@j"od aly., corn
150 Jocelyn Lin jocelynyeh@yahoo.com
151 Joe Durney joedurney@att,net
152 John Comeau jc@unternet.net
153 John Crowley John@aq us. com
154 John Cruz chinacatl 970@grna'11.,com
155 John Hunter johnhuntetaia@gmaii.com
156 John Schmier john@schmier.com
157 Joop Delahaye joop59@att.net
158 Joseph Schommer wintrylion@gma*il.com
159 Julia Anthony J banthony@sbcglobal. net
160. Julie Petersen land ryju1'ie@yahoo:,com
161 Kai Harris kai.harris@gma'll.com
162 Kamala Brown kamalabrown@gmaii.co M"
163 Karen Brigando karenbrig ando@com cast. net
164 Kari kari kittinger@g mail. com
165 Kasia Marelich Kasia7l3@gma*ll.com
166 Kate Hedlund rainmudtrees@yahoo.com
f
Attachment 2
Input Summary 1 - Page 88 of 191
W
r
Attachment 2
167- Katharine Fanning katkatfcrogma M
168 Kat
h
leen Kes
te
lyn
kkestelyn gn
ai
,co
m
169 Kathleen McCormick Kathleenmc1 53uS C
gI
b
at net
170 Keith Jansen biker,z;Mtb@ya oo,coM
171 Ke11i SC o1nick keII*LschoInick@gmai ,coM
172 Ken Cushman kencushman(cogmail,,com
173 Ken Quin to kqu into@sbcglobal,, net
174 Kevin McDonnell
Kevin,mmcd@comcast.net
175 Kit Lofrooslofroos@hotmailwcom
peregrine
176 Lance Roberts ayr88@gmail.com
X77 Larrv,,Goldfield Lxgmusic(coVAhooscom
178 Laura Franklin
laurafranklin222@yahoo.com
17g Laura Johnsen Ljwhitney29@yahoo:vcom
180 Leila Rairn lewanderer@gmatiscom
181 lendri purcell Iendrip@gmail.com
182 Leo Salasalas@netscapesneteoas
183 Leslie. Feldman lesliesfeldman@hotmail.co
I 84 Lindsey Goodwin lynzago'
yahoo.com
� g5 Lisa Eldredge Isacostuimailmer@gcom
186 Lisa Martz Hafalisa@yahoo.com
187 Liskha Arata lishka,arata@gmail..com
188 Liz Chamberlin Lizchambe@gmailecom
� gg Lo
v T
ei
c
h
eira te
Iche
ira
a
a
m
ail.
com
190 Luigi rig wDove Lrpe rig @anail,co
n
191Lyn sey O'Neil LoutoneiI@9natsc0M
1 g2
I nne lynne.benderCcomca
dt. n
e
t
193M deIeine Clare Made einec are msn,com
194 Maggie Dezendorf magdezen Jagmailcom
195Magg*eHohle ma aietext@comcastonet
196 marc nix marcnix� @yahoo.com
oete @mail-com
197Margaret Walter Jg
198 Marian Hughes martanhughes@
o
tmai
scom
199 Marina
Lacy
ma rina lacy(a)yahootcoM
200 Aarja Tarr Marja.tarr@grnaiIWcorn
201 Marjorie Helm
Helmatkin@earthlink.net
202 Marjorie Sands Sandsmarjorie@gmail.com
203 Mark P Jaramillo markpjaramillo@g mail com
204 Marsha Pierson Marshpiel @gmallacom
9-n205 Martin Day
rnday1000 @yahoo.com
206 Martin Roth martinjroth@gmail.com
207 Mary Reis reis,,mma@gma'I'I.com
208 Matt Reischling reisch ling @hotmail 1,tcom
209 Matt Weinberger matt weinberger@comcast:net
nout S
ummary 1 -Page 89 of 191
Attachment 2
210 Matthew Fabiano matthevvfabiano@gmail.com
211 Matthew Ingram mingram@gmail.com
212 Matthew Muldoon Matt@f1*tsqu'1z,coM
213 Maury Cohen Mrcelloboy@hotmail.com
214 Meisse emeisse@yahoo.com
215 michael b*lcheler mb'lcheler@g mail com
216 Michael Rubin ecpetaluma@gmaii.com
217 Michael Wrisley Mwrisley@comcast.net
218 Michael Yares m ichaelyares@myu rbanfarm. net
219 Michael Yoder michaelm'llleryoder@gmail.com
220 Micheal Pucci MPUCC140@gmail,.com
221 Mike Moore mcmooresl @comcast.net
222 Mike Runyeon mrunyeon@comcast,net
223 Mimi Pallas mookat@comcast,,net
224 Muir Heather heathermuir@msn.com
225 Murray Rockow'Itz murray@rockow'ltz.com
226 Nancy Moock nmoock@comc'ast.net
227 Nancy Schwartz nancys8@sbcg lobal. net
228 lqand.a SionomaTrikes@gmail.com
229 Natalia Martinez nat EMEMEMd martinez@icloud.com
230 Ned Orrett ned@ecozo2icassociates.,com
231 Neil Smith neiltbag@yahoo.com
232 N:icki orser Nicki'orser@yahoo.com
233 Nuala Creed nualacreed@gma"Ii.com
234 ona goodrich onanomad@gmail.com
235 Pamela Asselmeier passelmeier@gma'I'I.com
236 Pamela Joyce pamelaj'oyce@comcast. net
237 Panama Bartholomy Panamabartholomy@gmail.com
238 Pat Munsch Apes mu nsch@j u no.com
239 Patricia Tuttle Brown.. drptb@sonc.net
Iff
240 Patricia Webb pwebbosaur@sbcglobal. net
241 Patrick Boyd Pshop@boyd.world
242 Patrick Burns Pillath burn Sinco m cast,. net
243 Patrick Charles Charlespw. n@g mail.. com
244 Patrick Kleeman pkleeman@gmail.com
245 Patty Jepson P a J746.0 IIIE3Dn@me. IlDm
246 Paul Alexander jubileeklezmer@gma:I'I.com
247 Peaches Herman peaches. herman@gma'll.com
248 Pete Gang pete,@commonsensedesign.com
249 Phyllis Sharrow minicooperfun@gmaii.com
250 Raissa Montesclaros raissangel.ica@yahoo.com
251, Ralph Haney Rth777@comcast.,net
252 Raquel V:I'ale Raquelbv*iale@gma'll.com
Input Summary 1 -Page 90 of 191
r
253 Rebecca Emerson becca@theemersons,.org
254 Rebecca Hachmyer Rebecca. hachmYer@,gma'1'1 .-com
255 Renee Hamley rhei1emann@hotma1*1-,com
256 Resneck, Dusty dustyresneck@gmail,,com
257 Rhonda Olsen rock'inronda7@aol.com
258 Ria Brigmann rbrigmann@grna'11.c'oM
259 Richard Burger raburger@sonic.net
260 Richard Moeller drmrick @-pacbell.net
261 Robyn N*lConneY rn icon ney@gmail.com
262 Rose tdrose@son"ic..net
263 Ross Jones Ross:jones@hotma'I'I.com.
264 Ross Nowacki rossn owacki@g mail com
265. Roy Johnston rj o h nston446@g m a *11 .0 com
266 S Ferguson Ferg uson20@sbcg lo'bal. net
267 Sabrina Dove Sabrinadovel @mac.com
268 Sabrina Hearst. Sabr'inaHearst@earthlink. net
269 Sally Bricker Sallytabled@gma'll.com
270 'Sally Denman artsouls9@gmaii.com
271 Sandie, Helena Helenasandie@gmai'l.cim
272 Sandy Molina sandymoj:'ol @gmail.com
273 Sara Greenberg sehilgenberg@gmail.com
274 Sara hennin'g Saradools@gmail.com
275 Sarah hampel sarah.hampe1@1agunitas.co'M
276 Sarah austin Janda saraust*inl-@yahoo:ffcom
277.- Sarah Burkhart Sara hbrkh rt74@yahoo.com
278 Sarah Weintraub opentothemystery@gma'll.com
279 Scott Dusterhoff sdusterhoff@hotmaiLcom
280 Sean Walling walling,sean@gma*I'I.com
281 Sha'ina.Ferraro Shaina,,,ferraro@gmai1.com
282- Sharon Haro sharond66@gma'll.com
283 Sheila Baker she4bl'kes@yahoo.com
284. Shelby Munsch her@smuns.ch
285 Sherry padfield Sspadfl'eld@g mail com
286 Sheryl Chapman
287 Smith, Chelsea
288 Stacey DeGooYer
289 Stacey Earl
290 -Staci Stern
291 Stephani
:5
292 Stephanie Wilkinson
293 Stephen padfield
294 Steve Elias
295 Steve Kirk
M
sherylchapmandesign@gmail.com
Chelseadsmith.@yahoo.com
staceydegooyer@gm ail com
st aceyearisf@gma*ll.com
stac'I'Msmith @g mail Com
robinstephani@gmaiI.com
Stephaniewilkinson6l @gmail.com
Ssp' adfield@gmail.com
a11a*1s3@sbcg1oba'1. net
IL
stevek@sageinteractive.com
Attachment 2
Input Summary 1 - Page 91 of 191
0
Attachment 2
296 Steven Cefalu stevencefal u @mac, com
297 Steven Cozza scozza@cozza homes. com
298 Steven Hancock shancock34@comca.st. net
299 Stroud, Scott Scottrstroud@yahoo , com.
300 Sue Hirsch sueh*irschOl @gmail.com
301 Susan Cohen susan1718 @comcast .net
302 Susan Fabiano susanfabiano@gmaii.com
303 Susan Herman j u d e 124 8@com cast. n et
304 Susan Johnson dextoid@aol.com
305 Susan Starbird starbird@sonic,,net
306 Tammy renstromfam'11y@comcast. net
307 Ted Herman tcsmherman@comcast,, net
308 Teri Shore tshore@g reen belt. org
309 Terry Church tcequine@earthlink. net
310 Thaileah-deRocher Tha*1derocher911 @gmail.com
311 Tina Panza xtpanza@yahoo.com
312 Tracy Rose tdrose@sonic.net
313 Vance DeVost vdevost@gmail.com
314 Vincent- Hoagland vi n. hoag land @sonoma.ed u
315 Warren Dranit warrend@sonic.net
316'
Wayne Gibb wdg'lbb@hotmail.com
317 Wendy Anderson wanderson4l8@gma'll.com
318 William Ortlinghaus wortlinghaus@gma'll.com
319 William sell W*ill iamisell@g mail. com
320-ZahY ra Garcia. ZahY ra9 arcia@g ma'l.com
Input Summary 1 -Page 92 of 191
n
Ll
Attachment 2
Janice Cader Thompson
732 Carlsbad Court
Petaluma, CA 94954
707 7744--w5912
+
April 4th, 2019
City of Petaluma Goal Setting 2019-2021
1. Begin the process for a new General Plan and update and review all
codes
zoning
2. Include the Corona Reach as a Central Park connecting Ellis Creek to Old
Redwood Hwy with bike and pedestrian trails and Kayak up stream.
3. Corona overcrossingm, built i
4.
n 1954 is a regional road. With climate change we
;how can. the city ignore the i
this regional road for safety reason, east west mobility.
can expect more fires and flooding
mportance of
Corona SMART Station: pedestrian, bike and vehicle access to the station is
W
mportant.
5. Rail Crossing must be safe for bikes and pedestrian specifically the Corona
Crossingi"s sub standard.
6. The Corona Roundabout should have been updated with the development of
Brody Ranch. How did this happen? How cani"t be' prevented?
7. Caulfield connection: I would like to see a site plan from Petaluma Blvd to the
Caulfield.
8. If or when a Rainier Undercrossi*ng is bunt a sound wall needs to be -included,
How does the ci'ty-and police department plan to prevent this opening from
becoming a homeless encampment',?
9. Doe's the city have a plan to removi
maintance yard?
the old sewer ponds at the city's
10. ADA: both east and west Petaluma have access issues for people with
disabilities using sidewalks and curb cuts. Federal law prohibits
motorhomes, trucks, cars, etc. from parking on sidewalks. Blocking public
access is an ADA problem and is wide spread in our community.
F
ti
n)ut Summary 1 - Page 93 of 191
Attachment 2
-P
11:, Pedestrian safety need's -to be a priority.
12. Ordiffnance update to prevent citizens from using city streets to store boats,
motorhome's, utility trailers, etc. on streets.
13. $15 minium wage should to be agenized for discussion and action.
14. Ban Styrofoam takeout containers in the city of Petaluma by a date certain.
15. Impact fees should be used in neighborhoods that are impacted with
development.
16. Discuss the value of district elections including rank choice voting.
17. ART: consider a council'liaison to the ART committee.
Thank You,
Janice
Input Summary'
1 -Page .94 of 191
a
Friends of Lynch Creek Tra*11 Goal -Setting workshop lette
a Sheila Baker
Fro
Sent: Thursday, Apr*II 04,
To. h"Wr* City Clerk
a ! oil 4 4
Hello, Cl.aire
Here i's the letter from Fr*iends ol
0
April 3, 20144:�',
Attaciment 2
Lynch Creek Trail for the City Council Goal Setting' workshop on Saturday. Thank you!!
To: Mayor Teresa Barrett and
Peta-uma City Councimembers Kathy Mil er, Gabe Kearney
F'Is-ier Dave K'ing Kevin McDonnell
A& M 4 0
Z�� I I a, - ml
Pe'taluma's Lynch Creek Tra
4
is a beautifu but incomplete
s g : iv ! ing a-,beautifuj sliq It -V W1 d I
a nd creek
3ay. I iona- Y, I
Mike Healy,
11
infrastructure cross""
,?..,nd feel that is incomparlab e to any trai I i
0 ers ent'lall
AOL Aft AL
EI
safe route -to man destinations, but
it 0
1 in ce ain places and at
input Summar :'age 95 o
Attachment 2
consistentgement
th would be 12' widewithaere p0ssible.
of theday•deapa directionswh
ertain times east_west travel -ane
surface an
d aY ellow
strl-3e sep
arating
mall core group O
f i
n iv
idua
S Speaking o
n e
l aof
rlsa S oait isto rehabs hatethe
LngCree poserends etaluma citizensfoernedP Wehave a3dbefore
a larger community o entkiIn pursuit ohat 90 aPOicee pam
anse of Lyne Cre etaUn
entre eyp uC1(eiberSt,e
ken with C1tyStaff, City t ieRecreattion,
ander Sp0 I;OrYCMnitteU
, aswellas
dgIGycteAdvVithFriends oftie Peta uma
the Pedestrian a Waso aligned=Xecutive
a(Sconnisslon. ort from
Music and Pwith and gave received SU0P
Rl\erlNe are in conlersati0ns of the creek NaterSand its
IrectOrteane
3as tao
n in regard to the clea1ess
s and trail
c
OntIguOUs bank.
Uasinle suaccernenroughoue trail1b.
Creeraidumpsters �1aCed at
Ur goalsornch .nage, regularly serviced Well -lighted,
sola11r ghting
rusl.reoja,'S19
eenJIS10 n a cleans
uraitl maintenanCe• sts feesae annate interva S, scns and
a)'3r0P •one over whic Petalum
safe, ASA compIlanrat it,
we come to traverse.
We will look forvvard
to seeing you this aturday•
=of Lynch. Creek rat�
-Wends
2
input Summarypa 6 of 191
Vtar:a Tarr
• kr
Attaciment
I f-
Catdi-een springer
Bernie Album
i�
J
f.
a
ik
�r
ki
if
f.
a h�
•f.
if.
Iti
* a
EMI Y-Jirout
• - f
S ieila Baker
i}
}r,
I
if
h.'
rf.
/i
{v.
i�.
i+
�r
r • Ii.
M1r.
+i.
}4 •
v - •',rrr•
r fl.
}r�
!ti{�
y}•
� ry.
}r-
ti r.
r•f
rf.
}f
ti J:
i tif:
i�
r y
i•�
M
• I
}ti•,
Iv
••f
fr .
}v+
}f
IS
P g
I.
f 91
a e97o 1
Input
'r{
1 it
kk:
it-
if•
Ivy
k:
kh
r};•
r; }•
a rti
a }`r
J{f.
i.^
if
M1ht.
fr
:k.
• r �.t
�4
i
i;.
Sumafoo*[L�Iary
1
Attachment 2
LIVE OAK CHARTER SCI 100L
100 Gnoss Concourse Petaluma, CA 94952 • 707J62.9020
Apri.- 2, 2019
Peggy Flynn
Peta. uma City Manager
1 1 Eng- 1s.1 Street
Petaluma, CA 94952
Dear Ms. Flynn,
Live Oa< Garter Sc.ioo has been in operation on the Sonoma Marin Fairgrouncs since
2005, serving approximately 300 students in grades K-8. Live Oa< current y eases the
m ajority of qui dings on the fairgrounds site for its operations, constituting rough y 1/5 of
the 4t" Agricu tura) districts annua-
income.
Live Oa< has a strong interest in the ong term planning for the Fairgrounds property. Live
Oa< has wor<ed in years past with the Peta uma City Manager to explore options for
continued tenancy on the property, including j oint use arrangements with the city and/or
the fa*irgrounds. As we serve tie oca attendance area for McDowe.. Elementary- schoo,
and many residents in the McKinley service area, our cont0nued'Droximity to these
neigh:)o rhood is important to our families. We would appreciate being involved in goal
setting and envisioning discussions for the property..
We appreciate the renewed efforts by.. the City to engage the community in this
conversation anc! bring about greater clarity for the property's future, and our own future
as aPub is schoo on site..
Sincerely,
Matthew Morgan
Executive Director
nut Summary 1 -Pag
e 98 of 191
4
p a d
N N
eC1 isitor Pb -n ta1u111*1%
P
0
da Aft IIIA 'a Aft
ift
da dft
�I
,,.f Ilw
AA da —
dMb
oci ion
Petalu a Downtown Ass at'
1 Work togethe
Blwu�� t
2. Partnershl",:) �A
lig Ming etc
dw
da da Willi m
*Jolla
da
db Ab dft Awl db Mb
dr
system to restrictive a I nd cum:)ersome witn tc o rTia,
fired.
Ci
. A .1
:)usiness o expan urreni.
dft
7.
Ili
t PDArevenue results
in gatier*ing quarterly economic r
V f
AML
parKing,
:)Ublic
t�venue :)y provid'ing sa e a
KI
j
I
nput Summa it
Y E"*Pa e990
f 191
w.
01
om i o: u n c
2019
and City Manager!
ro, N Pletaluma Cl*imatillilic; Action Daiar
Subje%.L. Climate Akt-ioln Fro:,§.Ios,,a
F
13
SII
III Fir,
,Am
ti..te s ci I e n
i
sts,
more cievastating consequences OTI � 1ODai, warminl are on tne way,, nut we can, ies'sen
"r
rr k
anolth&r cl Y,
or another country. We must approach a crisis of thmagnitude from every angle an --
in every corner of thworld including Petaluma.
'Nii .yipp
its
till
A growing l,n,umbler ot
ncludi'nig Berl<eliey, a1<1an
it
v a o!
r,emont,
if IA c1ruzax ave unanimous te a
• Create a Petaluma Climate Cabinet.
We recommend that this entity include ex officio members and community
members aexpertise.Climatet e ity (0."..ounc1i1'with climate-relatedThe
Cabinet would e charged with assessing the cl'i'mate concerns of all -
those o' experts and people most impacted by the c crisis --and
recommending municipal and community responses.
a
0
Attachment 2
A I TACHMENT A: RESOLUTION DECLARING A CLIMATE EMERGENCY
WHEREAS, all
wa r
to li
the countries that signed the Zo15 Pa
"weI
ming this century
below i°C above pre -i
ris Agreement'vowed to keep
ndustrial levels" and to "pursue efforts
mit the temperature increase even further to 1.5°C"
WHEREAS, the Zo18 International Panel on C imate Change (IPCC) Special Report on
Global Warming of 1.5 °C estimates that humans have already caused about s.o°C of
global warming above pre -industrial Ievels;2
WHEREAS
the Zo18 I
PCC Special Report estimates that to have a 66%chance of
limiting global warming to 1.5° C, we cannot exceed our remaining "carbon budget,"
which is equal to about so years of current -level greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions2
WHEREAS, current global warming has contributed to the
intensity of wildfires, floods, droughts, heat waves, and hu
increasing frequency and
rn ca n es,3
WHEREAS, Northern'Cal'I'fornia wildfires in 2017 and 2o18 destroyed at least-dq8 dq:P
structures, kill
ed 118, displaced thousands, and caused serious reductions in -a*ir quality&'
WHEREAS, the current pace of sea -level rise is already, impacting California's coastline;
—3 feet of sea -level rise, parts of Petaluma would'be under water; and there is the
possibility of 6.5 feet or more -of totalsea-level rise by Zso
at 2
5,6
WHEREAS, climate change and the global economy's overshoot of ecological limits are
driving the sixth mass extinction of species;'
7
WHEREAS, the U.S. has contributed greatly to these climate and ecologic
bears an extraordinary responsibi ity to help solve them;
al crises and
WHEREASrestoring a safe and stable climate requires mobilization at all levels of
government and society on a scalescope, and speed not seen since World War Two;
WHEREASmarginsized communities wor dwide including people of colorimmigrantsindigenous communities, ow -income people, those with disabilitiesand
the unhousedf are already disproportionately affected by climate change and mustbenefit first from a just transition to a sustainable and equitab e economy;
WHEREAS, efforts to control climate change will have many other beneficial effects,
such as cleaner air and water; employment closer to home; cost savings for households
and the City, and the priceless creation of community;
WHEREAS, the City of Petaluma must do everything in its powerto swiftly convert to an
ecologicallysocially, and economically sustainable economy;
Input Summary 1 -Page 101 of 191
E F
NPOW THE,R ORIE BE IT RESO:LVEDI
I I■J
Irmall!'' po_ EAN
A
M, off$ Mr4i
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the City of Petaluma will elevate climate issues to the
highest priority in its goal -setting process; give precedence to, climate mitigation and
adaptation when evaluating policies and purchases, planning projects, and, allocating�
resources; and will seel<financial and regulatory aid to supportthese efforts;:
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the City of Petaluma commits to reducing citywide GHG
emissions to carbon neutrality as quickly as possible and no later than 2045—the goal
i
set by Governor Brlow'n's Executive Order B-55,.,ii.,88—and to accelerating climate
adaptation and resilience strategies,
iiiiiiii Pill I 111N�W
M.
A'S
44LYA
MAILVA Un 0 V 'A "KEL-Ra.0,11,10'r ic�L 1"
t o'w a r e goa o, zero net emissions,
rl rf iD: I I Al &ZZ
I agencies to act imm
partnerw!ith local and reigione e 1,
AWW" 1A
t P
i n
Includling meletini�#
1.04
I
a.
I-iiV
r
'AM
�01 M MOMM MONOWN IN
alct'oions i�n Its 20,45� Genera
. A
Input Summary i Page 10!2 of 1!91
. ....... ...
xr
;7 11"
f V
1Q, jl�p�'m n�'
�qfl
zT, t"O* •p
gt
1 41,
16,
.......... Il'l,
mamm
Friends
of the Climate Plan
Leadership n sL*,t Ut e for Just
and-
Rc
ammuitoes
Ik I AWOL
I 4.
I' A JP% I JIMIL
a a z ct
t,e r
etalurnia Pzy':N:vno--ltf s Ctf i i
T h C i m ,a t PE.k b
AL -2T ff I r 00%
Efw- In t E:wt: r t"O-' ntvrlo 0%, E-:% ILO-%] c
Iii
Lo% top% 10mv0% %0%#% 010% "MM'L JON
-0%2
ism
:f 191
I u t r, y I Ho v; 1 u Ji u 1 19
Attaciment 2
Petaluma Urban Chat/
Know Before You Grow
Petaluma, CA
petalu aurbanchat.,org
April 3,, 2019
Petaluma City Council
Re: Comments for April 6, 2019 Goal -Setting Session
To begin, thank yo u for the goal -setting format this year. It seems far more open and
welcoming than in past years. As a result, many of us will be j oining the session for the
first time.
However, to ensure that our proposals are understood even if we fail to express
ourselves effectively on Saturday, we're writing you about the land -use changes we wish
for Petaluma. Our thoughts are shaped by the mission statement of Petaluma Urban
Chat/Know Before You Grow, which calls for (1) housing to meet community needs, (2)
mobility options to reduce car -dependency, (3) land -use patterns to improve municipal.
finances, and (4) -all possible actions to push back on climate. change..
These four pillars of Petaluma Urban Chat/Know Before You Grow lead us to the
following requests:
• Updating the IZO, SmartCod and Zoning Mai The Implementing Zoning
Ordinance (IZO'.) has been subject to oniyextt changes and limited edits for too
long. It reflects a world that not only no longer exists but also helped lead us
into our current land -use dysfunction- of traffic congestion, housing shortages,
and failing infrastructure. We propose a complete review and update of the IZO
to reflect the land -use patterns we now need, including parking -maximums in
place of minimums, increased attention to transit access, greater FARs, and taller
maximum heights.
If those changes must be accompanied by General Plan revisions, so be it.
The -Smart Code, having been based on a paradigm closer to current needs and
having been carefully reviewed and updated with'i'n the past decade, requires
less attention than the IZO, but a review and likely minor updates are still
proposed.
Furthermore, we suggest that upzoning be considered as a strategy and that all
areas adjoining the current Central Petaluma Specific Plan (CPSP) be considered
Input Summary 1 :)age 104 of 191
Attaciment 2
Petaluma City Council
April 6, 2019 Goal -Setting Session
Page 2
for inclusion within the CPSP so they can be developed or redeveloped under the
SmartCode standards.
Revisiting Impact Fees -While recognizing.that impact fees must fund the
infrastructure improvements identified in the General Plan, we propose that the
impact fee'structure be modified to encourage the housing types needed in
Petaluma. Specific possibilities we propose- are reduced fees -for walkable,
transit -friendly neighborhoods, reduced fees for smaller units, reduced fees for
residences that don't include park ing, and reduced fees for multi -story buildings.
W e a lso propose greater impact fees for homes that occupy large lots thereby
reducing walkability and for homes in car -dependent locations.
,Developing Specific Plans - We propose specific plans, or at least master plans,
for the Fairgrounds, E. Washington Street between the freeway and. downtown,
and E. D Street. We acknowledge that combining all three.toget.her into a single
plan is also a reasonable alternative.
The need for a Fairgrounds plan is evident. With the Fairgrounds lease expiring
in four years we need a plan now for transit- and bike -friendly housing,
neighborhood retail, and park space, hopefully including a reduced -area
Fairgrounds still suitable for the Sonoma -Marin Fair'.
The plan should recognize the disparate boundary conditions, the need for a
strong transit connection to the SMART train station and downtown, and a
connection to the E. Washington Plaza shopping center such that it can be',
reached safely and conveniently from the Fairgrounds site without a private car.
A plan for E. Washington Street is: needed to transform a principal entry into
Petaluma into a multi -modal thoroughfare that supports.housing and less car -
oriented retail while also' providing a more pleasant, attractive trip for drivers.
Lastly , multi -story residential d evelopment at the train station and the
Fairgrounds will put pressure D theE,D St
reet to increase density and lose the
neighborhood culture., While adding housing into that neighborhood is
reasonable and -appropriate, the culture of the neighborhood is worth
M:
preserving. A plan should be developed that will protect the neighborhood by
allowing some development wh'i'le also preserving the neighborhood character.
.Broadening Hous'ingyTpes -While the need for new housing is severe, it needn't
all be met by new multi -story construction:, A portion can also beProvided by
allowing multi -.unit infill, whether duplexes, bungalows, own omes, live -work
In)ut Summary 1 -Page 105 of 191
Attachment 2
Petaluma City Council
April 6, 2019 Goal -Setting Session
Page 3
units or other housing forms. Any revisions to the IZO or SmartCode should
create.clear paths for these currently neglected housing types.
Similarly, the success of recent efforts to encourage ADU'S' should be -measured
and, if needed, additional measures created to further encourage ADUs.
•
Encouraging.Th'I'rd Places - We note that the role of walkable neighborhood cafe's
and pubs such as Ray's, Aqus,'and Mario & John's to create and sustain cohesive
neighborhoods. We encourage the further development of such places through
changes to the IZO or other.measures as needed.,
• Bike and Pedestrian Master Plans -Lastly, we support the calls of others for an
q 1NdWwNNAAik VO
updated Bicycle Master, Plan and note the need for a similarly comprehensive
approach to walkability.
Your attention is greatly appreciated.
Petaluma Urban Chat/
Know Before You Grow
Sharon Kirk Elizabeth Mori Barry Bussewitz
Kris Rebillot Dave Alden Sheila Baker
Dan Lyke
Cop'ies.Peggy Flynn, City Manager
Claire Cooper, City Clerk
Input Summary 1 -Page 106 of 191
Attachment 2
PETALUMA. Make People and Climate Our #1 Priority
Fierce wildfires, toxic air, relentless rainfall.... What we're seeing in our backyard is just a preview,
According to the world's leading climate scientists, even more devastating effects of global warming are
an the wayiBut we can lessen ther impact if we act urgently and boldly to cut and draw down carbon:, i
We cannot delay. We cannot leave this for another day. We must approach a crisis of this magnitude
from every angle and in every corner of the world—including Petaluma. But let's make this more than just
a battle against climate change:, Let's be creative and envision the kind of city we want to create,, For4
p: -
example, let's work for one.w'tih clean air, fess traffic, reduced waste, and good- paying, high-quality jobs,.
To sign the petition and help build a better Petaluma, please fill out the form below. -
We, the undersigned, urge the City of Petaluma to make equitable climate action the City of Petaluma s {
#1 priority and to: �
1. Adopt a resolution declaring a climate emergency,,P,
See full- resolution here: http://bit.1Y /PetCl'i'matellesolution ........
(Berkeley, Oakland, Richmond, Hayward, Fremont, Santa Cruz, and Fairfax have already unanimously
adopted a Climate Emergency Resolution.) j
2:, Create a Petaluma Climate Cabinet toimahelp guide clte-related work. �
3. Establish accountability for meeting Petaluma's cl'i'mate goals.
In add'it'ion, we encourage the City to set a deadline for reaching zero net emissions, fully integrate
climate issues in the next General Plan update,- and engage the community—including those most
marginalized --in cl'i'mateactions,,
Don't stop herel To kPeethe momentum going, please Join us at the Lucchesi Center on April 6 at 8:00
am, This is when the City of Petaluma s goal -setting session will takeP lace. Sign up and show up to help
make -this a reality. Learn more here: (link to Facebooke.pag)
The following organizations have endorsed the a
bove actions as of 31a26-419.. (Partial list. Full list
attached.)
350 Petaluma
Aqus Community Foundation
.Daily Acts
t
Sierra Club
Democratic Club of Southern Sonoma Count
Y '
North Bay Organizing Project
Petaluma People Services Center
U.S. Green Building Counc1'1,m--& Redwood Empire Chapter
WORK Petaluma
�rr
Thank you so much forY our support.K.
�
Petaluma Climate Action Campaign
(Started by 350 Petaluma, Aqus Community Foundation, Daily Acts, Lunchette Petaluma, WORK and
growing daily.)
F
e
Input Summary
1 -Page 106 of 191
e
11
191
i}
i�
r �?
}r
}r
kk
Attachm-- -ent 2
'i dIY�' IYI I Y . Y YY I Y 1,11'..
YIYYY YYY YYY YY I� 11' ' Y "' ' •''
N 1 .11 1 IYY IIYYYI
, YIYY YYY YII YY Y1 �Y1YYY YY Y 11 1 YYYYY I YYY YY YY i
0
I, '1 ,,, , YI 1 11 11111 I IIYYY YYYII IY "�
rf.
r.
>10.
CZ C: C:
i •
0 a)
CZ
0
f.
{r
,f
A
- E
CZ 0cz 0
>1
{
co
0
CZ
cz
cz
0
0 0
cz +Mj
atom-"
0 0
5
r ry
hK
� 4"..
CZ
r'
czv
T QD 0
�
�.rt hti
cz
0
cz
wrrrrrE ter' �
t
''cz
0
CZ
"`•
a)
*�•w
cz cz cz
a) 0
0
•_.._ 11111------- .............
r;
M IuI IIUgIIU ulIII 111111 AMdk =
JL w
0 h{.
cz
00r
od 4Mj
' ' i• r
:V
r-w
x
i
Y - IIII 11 111111
1 = ti iN•
CQ
co
CQ
CQ CQ LO C) C)
• - SII
}:
f
r�.
�r
rte•
- LO
LO
LO C) LO
LO a)-a) 4 r,.4.
rt qqfa) qt -LO LO
a)
of
LO Y � Jh1.
I I IIII II III ��'
is
IIII I i:ti.
^.
t 11111111111111
ri.
• 1 ih.
lk.
k:
r�
r
k
cz4
a)
a)
a) a)
R%
cz
0
U)
0
--*
cz
cz
0
CL
0
E cz
i
!{
cz
won-No
cz
>1 0
:i.
cz
cz- +
0, co
= r II IIIlulum
00
Ln TWA
rp-i
rMl
T-A
..... ......
f.
:f.
F M11
i} {
Y
T Y Y •r
' 111 II II Y •j
mary
v
X1111 U Hil
1Page 108 Of 191 Sum5
;r
rf
• i f.
:i
if
04
«4J
uwm
0
0
to
km
1/10
00I�
,woip**
,,,,,,,..
vWalmoo *
vowma 0
'CIA
rwowa.
M -M3
W-j
CU
N
un
to
K A.A.^ rhmelit 2
,W
t*"I
Input 5u
CN
G
00 cn
Page 109
nary "�
A
r
V
I
I
ir
5
r-4
M
i k
i
r
I
Mill ii . ..........
U)a
I
I
IL I
Attachment
L
SNOW1 E (J)
0 VPMMnmkv
>*
OdillW (1)
-0 C N N
� +Mj O U C C
U) 4*P
41 CZ +-j +'j
U)
C15 0
"PENN*
(D
INFO" (D
0 0
0
Ail C:� boo" aw"i
C �� (D CO
00 0
V-1 F -I
AW#Wphw*.
(D
V+Mi
C:I
c� o
in U
(D W
E (D
o 0
c: �
u- U)0
c�
•
LO.N
O
(D 08MI
00
I
m m
nput Summary 1 -Page 110 of 191
yr`
N
k
.., _,.hmenk 2
A A
s{
%f.
■
{{
t
Y _I III � YIYY Y • � " Y' ' •;
.r
}r
IIII IY�M � II III '
1
}r
ik
i
Attachment 2
A01 fit
APO% W
Y
ILTJ }l
Wool
4__ fr
(D
2WIMM" i �III�IIt
# �Mi1M411E ';'
COr.
Uj
CD�
f!.
La)
CY)
+•.'
J
r.
E a
}r:
dr$Emma
Co
0
- ry
U Cz
:{.
{r.
C)
(D
LO Mamma" ... ............ .
* i•� r
Co (n Dill '
V.
(n
y:
fr;
}s
y ' Y (D
} is
a sown
T
• , �� ,ryr
1 V:.
r.
Vf:
r (D
1 tj'
C) { r.
LO
I MOWN~ —�
ti
I
T t
AM 1 '
M1{
Cq All
• i{
}
f
F
LO
U")
L
LO LO U") Irt
ti
LO
i
1 4lIP1iY. �i uu a uu a 111
if
* "MEN&.
son""
Ot OMMOF
`
IIII
Mill, �.
• `r
00
Ln
tt '
0►� `.. ;{
'�
CF)+MMJ
f
Lr) Lr)
r Lr) Ln
vill -
•
....... . .... ........ .
mihmm
iwuw uulmll .Iu wl Input Sum"lary1 -Page 112of I'l
k
Pttach�'ent 2
� T
cd
Lj N O N
coot
O N Y G N U �?, p VOW N
In 0, � O �d '� `� � �
N 9
7 � � • j< N T td �d G ''� p 7^
woo* goo
� o a�'E.
N .�cd
;PN
� T
�d
.0
U -NNS' VAW
�3�3�E�
� N N oSoo
* 0000
0 W
wood
G G �� '�
o
N� j %000
V
p� N N O :d V
N � %000
$0090
N• `U O� O� T11111111,111,1111111111111111
cd
�d
N
o- 1
N
N �p
illillillillillllowllIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
LO
to
LO
a-)
N � LO%000 oomA�
;Oct
LO Lo
L
�
vow* 0-a U
N c� O
� m �croot
,woo*
iiiiillllllllllllllllililllllllllllI
� �, Page 113 of 19�
ct room Ci
� `� ut Summary �
U �
0
rn
►.n
Attachment
Hill
III VIII . .J.... '�11 .111111 In.df 11 1.1111111 I.1111�1•
f , , �� 1 . I SII. �.I 11 II111111 I I I Ild lllud uu......
All Ok
r.
10 low"
Awl
0
=3
4-J
AM k
r.
0 0
a INNOW 0
r'
.j
V
1
}
v,
U) I,
J
IR
C:
Cli
wo E
CO
+}.
}r;
4
if
i
VFPPPO
0
0
U)
a
}M1•
n:
4 --ft * _
it
0
0
In
0
vr:
1 ?v
�.r
rw
• 4r:
�•r
0
}0.0 0C)r
_.r
• ��
1v.
�w
of
f.
'.
CQ
V)
C�� = ' f.
L - _
- f
i,.
�f
f
hr
LO
C)
LO
LO
LO
CO
0
C E
wwMwffPdv
0
i?
a CIO
0
Cz0
u
Ln
M
t
u Hill aInput Summary I
.rtepage 114 of 191
�.
ryk
+ rl •
k:
Attachment 2
i
a�
. � c
Ire
L)
Wf
N �
0
C)
aCO
AN
U) AN
f �
O
N
O-
>(
W
N '�G
a U
o- c a-
� N*wow*
,loom
N
� 11
U
ANHill
t
� I
Clow
LO
U) CY)
1
cfldd'' �
LO
LO
LO a)
LO
qtzr m I
LO 0)
� LO
� 1
� �- O
J
AN0001Z
cl, a 2: C: 0
orlop"t (D
JT C: (A
%wow 0 00004
U000 swow
0
cc
Wood
400J. Now
td Ln
wo (D =' 00 00
00
Cd
00 � � p age 115 Ot 191
cn
00� - { npU Summar
00kmo
�
r �
1
7;
w
is
Attachment r
k•
�i.n.i..,n�..n� h�. .......... .......n..l......... .
C (0 C) woo
0
0 (D
- vk
* kr•.
yw.
i iiiiii = _ k'
ky
0
_
4—J - r ,i'•
a 0
• ni
0
+-Es NOWr
E�. ■liiiii� �i r{
_ UNION.
Cz 0
a) 0 or *NMa)
pi�JN 0
h;
E Cz
(D
MAIN"" 0
- r•
,.
??
ii,•
CzN (D
(1) 0
.V
rr
(D
W (D r.r.
0
C;) r
(D D E
a) cz
CZ >1 00 goommm 0 �h
II
ammomw
:
CZ
..� ;.:.
v f.
Ir
� V=.
• e � �r
(D
U }
it
0 0
C:
IL
0
}
h:
}
h}
.` v
.Ml+MMNl# 0 0
;{.
0 r -
U)
U h
II f
� ,4
t
FMW - ,X
}k
- ? ti•
� }ti
};;
}r
.'r
Ik:
C\j
CD
C)
rr}.
C\l
(Y)
LO C\j
Y .
•�
LOLO
LO
LO Lo'
L LCo LO y {.
LI kv.
1 I II
0
�qull nom.
. M+M��W I III �, •-r
f:
�w
k-
4 moi.
0 .
IN
0 (M)
0
+
(D (D (D (D(D
11 i
0
0
0
0
Ln
00 Cj)
rf.
y � � � • � ra
z
• II III III 1111111 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII��IIIIIIII IIII IIIIIIII II IIII II
{
.
M r.
k
• "� II
CY) CT)
�0 CY)
00 00 G) Cj)
00
00
Input
ary
Page 116 of 19i
t
:i
:ti
46
. Llo,.Phment 2
X91
t
i'
k'
}:
Attachment
IN
r f:
i
k;
.f
:f•
Y
r t
y �r:
i
f
if
ti }.
L
kr.
v'
r
f J•
'ff
rf
f
i�
_� Yf
4
r r:
fA
f
nti
J �k
ij
rf
r�
�r
Ln
iW
Ix
y
dK
AK
Cri
Cri
. . .... ......
(C)
C\l C\l C\l C\l C\l C\l C\l CO
LO LO CO LO LO
• y �'f
i /•
�r
� of
, Jif
f
M1
f:
}
1r.
r}
i }i•
Y
v
r}
r � Y
J iY
• 1Y
IJ
V
if
it
tiff
• � iti
�f
rf
• � mak.
if
l
iY
k
LO LO LO LOCY) CF) (3) (3) (3)
%
w
LO
LO
CF) CF)
1 � tii
* (3) -G)
W
hPO
(D
(D
(D
Cz E
0 E
0
if
1 1V
� k
• fl.
rf
f�
ti f.
f/
fi.
i}
ik
?k
rr
/.
r k
CO0 JIM 0 0
- ..
(n f
0
0 Igo
Cz 0 :
f
00.r
Ln}.
0 0 0 0
:f.
OWWWWOMM
{
WWM NOW% r �MMMwPrI
Input Summary
:f
• �f
f
P. Lt.,,.hment 2
AqA
w
}r
i�
k
t
� IIIh6. I 111611JIIIU dlll � I!Illp IIII II � III IIII. I ,pq! u U ! 1 ° 1I ' ' � �l
f:
— }ti
rr
i%
i
i = j
Attdo-%chment 2
0
0
P�
cli
(Ti
CTJ AV 9% a)
y
U.
- rr:
0
Sk
>1U):-
U)
w I NORM
If Popp*%0
0 t
w
y i M1.
.. f:
CTJ
■
C.) 0
l �f
{r,
i = j!.
API WA
if
kr.
{f.
f
L
�0�, U:
U)
` rir� IIII II a IIII a III }�;•
0
— f.
nk
00
co
LO LO
f:
}
LO 0)
LO 0) : 1.
0) Act
LO 0)0)
0)
'
...... .
II III Hill
0
0
F
(3)
1hpo
A
V cz
Q) r.
W ,,.
cz 4mj
IIII
I I
-
will
�rrr■�wrrr.t r +
rLn
00 0 rn r
ry)r-ii
rmi
rl r_4
�II III II
1 — NMI II 111111ry 120 of 191
Input :•.
II I II
6umm#
. 1k.
�f
:;ti
I
m
it
a
.
a
mm
O
cn
�c
"Woo
uj
TOO
V 0
ow 0
OHO )1006
S
J O � u� T004
ZJN�Y
ct� � 00 U)
�Dwt=—Z
O
Q oJ- VOOOO,
Q
0
POO
Oz—,_
CrN
on
N
rn
r
�s7
CD
f
c%4
d'
inp t Summ
u
aT 1p A
Page 2� ofi
A (3A
t
i
i=
Attachment:
'r -
All
CID
CIO
MW
_
f-
x r•'•
of
in
1f.
IK
r
r �{
iv
hf
i.:
- Ii•
mak'
7; v
- Citi
}
j:
� II I IIII - IIII r
SSI
a)
0,
l
y
U
4PI 0, IN
- _
4
UL so U)
- '-'
:3
SENN" 0
Cz�..i.r•
y II I I II
1 a
IIII VIII hLI I
II
Y
CQ
Cq LO
LO LO up) LO a)
V) CD 0) A -
CD "t "t CDM
CD 0) (M NMI I III'
IIII
I I I �4M+i+ 1 11111111
� I T
<111 11 11 } Iquu111 u y r
• , i
dL
10
0
T
F r
y
>1 VE
-E
0 Cz CIO
E C:
C:
CO 00(D
M1
11 1111 IIII .III OAWWA1
_
t
U IUIIl1Ul II 11
00 0) 0 Ln Ln Ln Ln
it 4;*. Ln
rMi
.. Will 11 1111111111 1111 111111 1111 111111
Input Summary I Page 122 of 191
t
Attachment 2
AMIN
I �
PU
CIO
cz
I o
0
o�
o�
Qo
� �U I
I U�
L+MM
o
I POW
� .0
U X
l � � O
Q IMMOMM
06
U) cz . I
C)
a)
At AMMO
Hill
IE
I
CQNNOLON m
������Illjllllllllllllllllllll 11111111111
LO
CQ LO
LO
0
110
LO LO Nt
CD CF) CF) mom
CDIIIII III III IIIH owl
UU)
UIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
pi p
a d
cz 0 MI . (1) (1)
cz
cz
LUHill SWIIII IIII
MEMO
W p Z
MON
1 � N m
00 Ln kUD UD rmi rmi
rmi
LnLn Ln� ri Ln r'"i `�
� - � Input Summary 1 -Page 123 of 191
�r
Attach wlql--,-Ient 2
a
MII
(D
Cal.
Owl
If
- v 0
irrrrrrr.t
qt Mal Cz 1.7
f
fir:
} . _ IA
=3
0 ;.
(D
t
r�.
- %mum"
0
Uj
Uj
h:.
r••
'r yv.
r}•
# arm � {r•
U
Cz 0
-
AL
0
,.
E 0
k.
..� w7
{.
U r
Cvj
0
a)
JNLAP%L
01
FM"
fr'
1
- Hill
jy..
i"
_ tiJ
- '
Cz
ti h� •
. ' J Cz F 'hr
0
0
0
i iYilliiii %f•
r.
y r.
Kill
41
CQ
CQ
QD LO
.'r
CQ + UP)+'.
C\j
C\1
CL-0
LO LO L-0
CY)
CY) CF)4qr
(Y) 0) LO
CY) CY) CY)CY)
r:
y
} lw�iumui II
I I I II >•r'
�r
• if
x
a boom
rk.
a) (TJ
0
!E.
� r=
r
CzCz U)
(D
*�
Cz-
Cz-' - r
P
Cz - v
'
a
- -- 1-11 11 ---'IliiPgikfiiiiikllkklililkliM
n
r4l*N
7� itIlYYY1tlY1Y ��
�Yu u u u iWwlmw
00
CY)
�O
Q0
'r
.. _l Hill 1 .•.
iYWYlY1WYYIW ••'.
a�
Ill
M4MMl
Input ummar
of
• cr
Attachment 2
1611 1
N U •i ?�
VIC-
0
1 A
%0 if
t N N
N . N G l •
N � -O O � G �
40900
0 WWI
WIN c:
(n is WOW
loc. 0
4PSA' 0
o 0 1 o�~
'*a
*woo*
N � COOS Oro cis
0
Uo"
o E
.c v
(or Iowa
(D al
Woo"" E W
0 vc. +01 1
4"1 M
CLW
*Poo* UJ o Coe
0 s Poo"- 0
tn 9 *woo
0
room 0
(nul
oa�
-JCD�HillN
LO
N N � rnLO
' ►�s� rn
toEll m
LO
O � �
0
%woo
;Oct
U
O
(n -(D
VIC %woo
p Poo"
(n
slow,"
VC. v
d�
%wow
^� J
LLQ.
00
C%4 00
WIL 00
00�,
00 VO4
maty � -Page X2 5 ot 191
Sum
M
0
0
t
a
a
4
��� ,Ay�quu r •ytillll u
a
i
• •.I as ..I •�
(1)
E
0
2
C:
0
E
L
CO
2
I
AN
Attachment 2
f
rl
n put Summary 1 -
j
t
CF)
rH
Page 126 of 191
i
.106^ lant 2
ON
}r
X:
f?
i'
v'
v,
z'
l�.
1.
FAttachment
CD
}f
YIM4F�I+ihMi Ap .
h,4
aftwe
M"M 0
03
}f
Af
ff
hr
t VNI
h
U)
CO
0 CIO
Cz
Cz
4l
r}�
�r
s
i pow" _
MxMM"
0
Cz�.,..�
_ mom- i
%V 04MA
� �Y�Irl4 v WWI
0
spa
0 CID
(D
(D 0
m cull , I
CO
CO I r
� � � ■� �IiYM11E
0
N
0 +�
CIO 0 (41)
_
1
- II M ul
leu I -
4
+ CQ CQ CQ CQ CQ
CQ CQ CQ CQ
LO
LO
M M LO LO
LO
�,Il ul I lu �..........
LO
�tldiiK umuu l II u I I
LOW
Cz
CO
WAJ P; 0
0
a)
t
i X14
i
z _
art
0 4-1
C13
II � i
{ IIII II .
1�
111111 II II �I I � .
1
00 CY) 0. rpri
Ln 0 0
0 C) N
— uuuuu a uuuuww u u a I I V
Input Summary I Page 128 of 191
a
r
L9
19A
w•
w.
v
r ��i�n� �� � � i � . � III • .•i u.. 111 1 1A••• • •.,
. � III1�11Illli�l I� �� •I I
,, VIII III I • — }r
�r
= w
:f.
r
• if
•h
i%
}f
r}•
r•'.
i vu
1f
y ri.
� • v`�ti
fry
�v.
,
ii
a
ivr
ivr'•
I y.
Attachment 2
0
qF
Cz
CL
Now" a
FMRW*
CO
_ ' � • .. .. .... . III VIIIJillJill
Jill
' 11M
AN
i'
i�
IL rr•
• CO
i�
7}v
Uj
j.
C13
CO
i fv
• � ~ 1.
* v f
I I IIII II III � max•
V
* -
F
A
It
CQ LO
F =
A
icy
tires
kh
• LO
to
LO
LO
LOLO f,
LO ti
LO
LO- II II II II i
Jill
4 =
0
0
UPI
CzNow"
f:
.i
CO
F
Cz
IWO(D
Cz
f.
Cr >1
Cz 0
.
- ,"
. ............
cc
rMi
(n °f
r%J
M {.
Ln M k
r
IIII
. aiYYYW W+tl '�� f
Mill
Jill 9
Input
� I I 130
Summary I Pa.may
rti
191
I
10
I � 'OKI
c
04 C
+_,
-0 4 � A—I 0 N
Mob=
C13 Ri E
ANO -E E
>
0 *11illmom :3 0
U * Cz
0 Foam
Cz
C> Y� C C U
� � ctS fl.. '— � O
Cz 0
0 4-a 0 0 W
0 CZ
a 0 Cz
C:
0
0 JIM town" cz
C:
Q—
c oLE
N N snow 0 w
0
4m4- X
'� Q � td � dj �, � C
(D E
0
(1) Cz 0
U) 0
>1 (D
VOMIJIMMO 4MI
SIUMPMO (1) a)
Cz > >
E cz Cz 4-1
Noma 4-1 0
Cz Cz a) OWN="
Cz 0 4=j W C 0
ia) w
Cz E > 0 Cz
E 0
mown"
> (n
Cz Cz (n
0 4=i Cz
0
Cz Jill
. . ............... . ....... . . . ..
III Hill Jill
0
I C
a)
� U
a�
m � �
CD
Cz
CD a OMM"
r ri a` o � _
1
T N T N
LO CO LO LO
LO LO 0) a) M CD
M LIO 49t
0)
(D
C � Y
(D
.=
2pi
C:
o � o 0 U)
0
W
a>
� o �
� 1O
Cz
C:
C: >
&MEMO
0 0 Name
C)
dam'Ln Ln
Itt I N �' N I r14
N r4
Hill
Hill Jill 1111
I Attachment 2
11 11 Jill
I
0
U)
it
0
4mmJ
Ln
N
0 1 -
If I x
nput Summary 1 :M
40
Cn
Page 1
32 of 191
a,
iV
it
4
. Lt,,,.hmenr 2
AqA
w
L'
r`
w.
4
Attachmulit 2
SII .. ... ....
• I liii3iYilFi u u u u uu a uuu u '
ry:
r
4-j U)
1
Pima
4 - cz
0
0 Zi:
U)
CIO
0 > .00 IL
Af
0
X-C —
4=J 410
{}
fr.
CZ CIO }
_ U)
0 }rr
0
cz
U)
0
C)
h
f:.
hi
cz
Y
0
4=J CIO
0
of
}r.
.µ
# i�Mrll� '`•`
* M c:
yyMINWyM CIO CUL
k'r
cz
hf
.0 (C13 E
0
U)
1 {
� }r:
co
Pima 0 pl-a
U) C
U)
ii
W0
` 1
CLIr,
ENNOW Ll—w CZ PPMj
t
xr
0 tj wt
awl
cz(CO
7
r
3 (D(D (D
CIO W {;
IIII II MMwjlI
{
C) Ob E
CIO
UL
_.CIO
_.l
0 EAW
0 Slow" cz
0
�....
III II u u uIIIII uu a 11 a nillu ul
------------- ...........
• � I II SII
LO
t
LO
LO CIO 1
O 0) ll -
a) ,
0) a
Mgt 0)0) --------r
II II uu II a loom lullum 111111
II u
111 p u
U
0
CIO
C:
PFMJ
0 U)
0 C)
Pima 4—j -
E 0
cz
C:
C: cz cz
Ln
�� � I IIIIIIII III
t
F I I I I II
' itlilrlYY all Hill
1
ENRWPW
irY� M I I u � l I
Input Summary
Attachment 2
a�
MIA
(D.
d Q, N� p� C� �
0 c:� Q- � -a At p 'n
0 (1) (1) C: d dh
moo f% (1)
WA t "Now
Or
t� Iwo
Q %+0000- 0 O � =3� (1)
L
0% 4rwJ o
=3 C:
dowl
-� ' o N Ua UPOW
,w cz
o
AMIJ
o J
O O p � � O- N =3W
U000 V
PoolG � C: � :3 O '- O0 A *6 6 1 w 1
%W 0 4wom 4001111111111,
Awwwwwo .�
�
or O O � � Loa
.N OPWOOO._UNl ,7 �
� °' � (1)3:�o
� � � �
1 3 � � `- D� N
� N :.— � N (fid X� p V N G� row_►,-��
UPSO
* cz
� 0
%+Woo Iwo
= 'N � C � O id
, G N0 t� Ii1 N to i
� � � G �. >+ p
(Zo (1) o C:
- c)
400A 0
0 0, 0 0
umoo
. - (1) ::3 0
0
CQ
I
r
.
CQ �
"it LOLO fid'
LO
LO
0
t�
'd iA
will
T
N
0
0
00
N � N
Ocz
wow""
U
Ln
E - r
Vill
� � -Page 135 of
N _ - input Summ
ary _
AAttachment2
> 0
4-;;J Cid
cd
�
0
O
MOM
0
0 >
cd
cz >
0
(D
0 (1) ro
(cis
0
0
"=MEN*
0
cd
0 4mJ
0
L)
a
cd 'cn
`o <cz � c � v ca c�
o o = c
a
=3
(t 0
cz
+Mom
C Yt cz
�r�
1 �
MaO
O
dL
a�
am oco LO LO LO LO
c�
JOL
N N
LO LO LO 0) a)
0) a) co
LO 0)
I P*Owllllllllllllllllll 1% 11
memo 11 will
0
SO (D E
I
I
� >;v o U m = C/)
cz (D
(D
Uld
,�Hill
Md MOM"
m
pip I corMi
N �
N N N
......... Input Summary 1 -Page 136 of 191
AttachmJill
ent 2
46
N T
"Woo"
CL
co
od
s "pow
0 W%L
%*moo
U00" a mono*
(D
%wow
Awl,
Owl
Ap"llill
wool
cz
. . . ..... . .
Jill
tow
1p
LO J!
4
� T
' � U
N
4- 'd
N CQ' toI to
0)LO it
Jill Jill
� 1
LO LO CD
LO 0)
LO Mt
Jill
co
rn
(Di
1 I
ate. v_ Icz a� �
:3 N WOL
::3 ,Y I
cz
O
Owl N
N N 1
MOWN
137 of 191
PageN A Inpu
t Summary
N N
Attachment 2
a
c
c�
O =3
a�
E �
N o
o
E
O �
'C O
ctt E
0a +—j
>1
Cn
N CQ CQ CQ CO CQ CO
c �
� O
U '
� o
a�
rn rn rn rn rn rn � � w rn
m rn rn �rn m rn rn_ rnrn
L
*WMWA~ ONO
1p
Cz
� L
U)
mom (D
Cz
(np � C � Q z C
CnCz � a. = m C i N o i
Y L -6 Q >' CzCz N
BMW"
> w Cz
U (A 0
d' IIl 00 Ql O c -I N M
p)
N4bN N N N N M M M M
Input Summary 1 -Page 138 of 191
,
Attachment 2
IR
U)
4wa cz
(D
c� a�
-p
co d cz
E E
cz
*Noma 4=IJ
(D C:
Oww"
M am" c cz
cz
Ulm
co
0
(D O I
>1 0
>V, 0 S. 1 0
0 0
� O
c� >1�C
•r C
U �
(D C:
(D
(D cz
> "Wig"
(D
a
J 030
U)
IL
J Q
do
Hill
N
N
CQ CQ to � 0 LOLO qqt 0)
� t
L-0 I LO
CQ LO
V)
LO Hill
a) � -- E
ai
Ulm cz
mom"
E �
m a) (M). —' a)
2
a-WPM"
0
E E00w4Oww
t `^ o 0m 0
rn
Input Summary
7 -Page 1.39191 of
r >i
}r,
l•
F
Attachment 2
��1 Fal�ll
0
U) - � � rr•
(1) 0 0
C 0
=0 (1)
0
A:
�1
k
,f
U) 0
(1) '0 0
.0 C.)
-jllllI
Wf:
U
O f.
W cn
W0 E
f
{ f
0
;f.
MIFI }:
IN
0 0
0
W a� rf
� .,.��.
F=
".4)
..
f
CIO
f.
(D }
0
rr
r w +0
{Y
CIO
{
:3 C:
n�
U W
0
0
nr
F..�
Y>
r'f
WWI + r�rrrr
f
rk
'r
ik
r'n
Iti
r �{
hf
� rti
fti
„f
1 rr
• i 1r
Ik
IJ
j•r
a ,r
_ r�r
fly
M r
rr
C\j C\j C\j C\j
i
i�
• � if
ik
• � til.
� l r
C\j
LO LO LO LO LO C)
LO LO LO
CY) CF)
LOv,
(3) Mill CY) 1 0) No (3)
f
i
r 11.
,1
M1 r
� a M1f
Ol
r A
If
CaY
0
0 Ef
CIO
C"
0
U) 0
=0
CIO
i�
rA
. /.
0
�._ �...�
CD
Idle
CIO 0
r;
00 H
Ln Q0
M ro
Input
Summary
rk
ti:•
Attachment,2
000 0
0 Wawa"
(n E 0
o
c�a Owl *MO(n
#*own*
0
CIO
U) i LOW
o � �
� o
�0
E0 AN
Ise
0
0
mum
cn
iww
0 =3 =3
0 0
0
c
O
N ''J 0 ''J E C I p T
CZcz
0 p cn ,y � O 7+ 1 C
won
'k
Z*2 � � � O RS
CL
1
owl
IP
IL
LMW
cz
� 1
I
N �
E —
CQ
N N ►N �
co
�
N r LO LOLO LOtea. amLO
0) Mill
0)
0
0)
cz 0 cz b(D
N
(D E (D I& IMM""
C:4
U)
0 0 cz
0
slow - Sol
J"Wk Low
Lwow
0
�dw EL
czIn
a�
to UU
S wow*
ct ip *00M CIO
cz
Ln cz
00
rill M N m.III Jill
m m
m
Hill
N
m - � Input Summary
1 -Page 141 of 191
lb
t 2
Attachmen
rW
i
SII
Ar
dill
if
cz
0
�MMM14r! 1 -
�r
f
0 -JCIO
of
- _
i i fr,
E Cz
4-a
CIO
0
0
rf
ar'•
v
rr •
J
n4-1;
� CIO
0 E
rr
WIMMIIIIIIIIIIII0
},
+Mj(n 4=J
= 1 —
CIO 0
0
cz
a)
a)
(D a) cz
> E
1
CIO
• � i �� � �F� iiilifitliiY I l u u I l u u II I �� a 11M*l�M+�M� .
�f
7
a)
i
0
LU
JYYYIOIWIi I u l u l l l I I I ��
CQ TMO
Oro" LO
� u II I ul III III ull I
a
r
CQ L
I L
LO t**ft% I LO CD qqdw 0) * (M
0) '41W 0) LO 41K 0)
—
U") q1w - I—a) 0) 0)
0) (M I I
I III rMiMf1+MU++MM I I u
1 tt
(D
P*Mj
- �IIIE
+M -j
MMMA
a)
CIO sow"
"MMM -1k
_
CIO 0 a)
"OGWMW
10OWNS
UMP" - 1 0
0
CIO
#�
.k
�� luu II
C*1 C)
Ln
M rn+"
rn MM-
cn
r
rrrw
ONO"
va IIII lYii111Y II
Hill Input summary
S
r
i
rf
Attachment 2
� I
U '
0 All
vi
0 0
bo (3)
(1) w I
co
> 2
N
LOSS
*mop"* 4r
LdO
0
too"" E 0.
> WOW
0
E >
a0 0
UNA
mi a
0
0 C �
N � �
ct
co
(Z U
o*mop*
�
1
1
y
G
CD
Eli E Pi
& ON" C:
"OWN*
Sol, o
0 AVOW
Hill
1
CQ �
Lo
Lo,t-4*"(M 0)
i
c
Lo
Lo Lo CD Lo
CQ 10 TOMIS 0) -
CQ Lo
10
Lo 0) 0)
0) Mgt
all
co co
T 'Q O
UdO
wow" *vow
0 E
LIM
co
0 itz :�z "D
"a
SUWON* E
powwow >
opwrm* W M -
7Jill
0 Jill Jill Ln Ln
0 LIIIIII «-' � pp d' M (Y1 m
rn
m � m } m ►nput Summary � -Pag
e 143 of 191 �
f.'
fl.
• r:
{n
• 'f
f
a '.k
:F•
Attdchmunt 2
1f
IIII II
i ' , �'• '. � 11 1 111 Il..il.bl� � • � 1 � r
(D
0
0
lf.
ti•
Ef
x r
• � � i' �YYMM�M1� }r
:f.
f:
€i
kf .
,
!f t0
4
:.
0
0
cz
fir..* w•
=.
# - U) h:
(D
- kr
cz
:f
0
V% 0
0 U)
U)
f
L�
cz Ums V.
0 {r
cz *E
E
T If
I I VIII - %iIrr
rti•
(D
U)
At Afti,
>1
Adw
y
rr
ih
fy
II uu a uuu �I
I 111111
11
SI1111I
r �'r
r
;•r
C\1 i f
C\1 I LO
'C\1 C\1 C\1
LOC\1 UP) 21
C\1l C\jLik
LOLO
LO 0 N
L OF
LO
LO k•
• _ � � 11 II
I I 111111 I I I
y 111111111111 11 •i.
i
,h.
a
U)
E CIO E
0
a)
vi
E a)
t
5
W
r
U)
>0.
.k.
cz a)
cz
mill
11111 111 1111 if
- -------- . . . . . .
co
Ln
LO Ln
Ln Ln AMLA%L (Y)
Ln r1r)
Ln
Lr) rn
v
f
M
r1r)
i +
� 1111111 I IIII I I II 4 "
T �'f
k
l�M I II VIII I IIII I � I I I vhd" II II II I I II I IIII I
M1
` .VIII 11111 moo" a r Input Surfiril y!T Hage
�.
:w
• +ti
r •:t
:k
Attachment 2
k
' y
1
1 �
1
� 1
1
}
_ ' N
Hill
LOOK
J
0
ON
Awl
1"I N
a o
LO a)
to
LO
LO
CQ toLO 0)
�
d' � cid cin
AV
1 %moo W
*mow"
ct
0 U tom`%woo mo W
—
%moo*
W wool
"Op"m
0 W
v9:)
Sol
U of Vow"
scn
p � �O � m �
to =-----' �o motage 145 191
fit
�. � ° m 1 - '' input Summary 1 -
rn QD m
l� M
M �.—
i
:r.
1
•ti
Attachment
Y-
Y Y fi
+ 111 I I YYY YYYYY YYY YYY YY YY r;
�{ Y. IY.Y YY YY YYY Y Y Y YY . YY Y 1 � YY���Y ��YY �� Y �� � Y 1� YY � IIYI �Y I � � Yi YY Y Y III YY Y M1•
Y Y 1 1 � I YY YYY 111 l.lr Y 1 I III YYY 1 M Y 111 1 YI IY YYYY Y YY Y 1111111 1 YYYY I I I IYII IYI YY YYYI I I.IIIIIY IIY IIYIIY ' Y ' !••
T 4•
fr
0
pl, 0
E Ye.
0
IWN"
s OFF"
FROMM
0 0 0
}r:
l
ri
}ti
Ir
. Xr
}r
if
v 'v
i
h:-
lr••
F YI.
if
if
Iv•
f
fix•
::.
Iv
ik
4?
U) C)
1 r�'
# $now
(D
+� r
r}
cc:will
A:
(1)
ti7
■ a w"
k
0 0
0
. ...... )MONRomil
- --------
7
w1II
-- -- - - ---------
- 1
0
- s 1�wrrri _
i•
n�
4-J
- w
i
MINNOW
LO
00
Cq
CQ CQ CQ Cq LO LO LO LO LO
LO LO LO LO
LO a (M
-
M 0) 0) (M (M
- � � II IIII IIII
0
a) W.
Y 1 1 II u l II IIII
C
0 0 0
y - W
U
> ommmono >
pwmd
Y =3 U
U
f
Y = _a)
f
Sir somme
19
UPON*v PWP=qr Cr)
Uoil' JON
II IIII II II I I
C* rwi
Ln
r
C*
r**40.■
r
' I
P01— 4M `
Input Summary
d
t.
r
�w
t
G
N
N
D
m
U
J M
00
m
NOV
0
LO
Ln
00
m
UD
m
woo*
UOM
r"14%
00M
LO
b 11'
WO -00,04 I
I�
00
cn
N
LO
I �
hiRv,chnielilt 2
to
— input su
0
d'
O
i
I
cz
m
M
Page X47 0�
a
191
`f
Attachment
' fr
1.4
CO
� i .4. 'r 4111, � 1 .. 1 II 11 111 w I .I • .
f..
f:
y f?.
- 1
ff
f,l
- }ff
}y.
}r�
r;
' h!
t -
" }
T _ }
}
5
5
� I
F
_
• " * �IIII I II
r _
Cz
Cz
At J01%
Uj
111 III II + "
v hL
111
amok
CQ
CQ CQ
LO
CQ IN AOMJ LO L� t
I ^ LA - a) + `
LO LA IP
0
+
Cz
(D
Cz
' III
,
a)
`JJJ`J,� v
. � I I
_ +
(D 0 Cz
C: *Mi
•
(3)
00 C: Cz Cz
N
some"
Cz
17
)*Jill 1 111 IIII I III 1111111 Jill _ �•w•', _ -
0
II
F
- !
IIIA
n LD a) C)
a) a) a) a) M
Cz
rIM1 J �7�IR dill
Input bummary. Page 148 of 191
{
0
t
i
e
I
• j ' r
' L
• S
• '1
_ • .._ _ ., _ _ .._ � ._ r ..._. , _. ,.• ..__. _ .. _. _. .. _ ._ __.... L-- __ ._... - r—•T � z_ __.... ..._.. -- _ __n • __ .. ._. .._ _.. ._.. L _ r.._ _ a. _ v _.ti__. _ .... u ... _ _ ..—• - .. - , •.�_ _- ._. ... r•... .... y -L_..._ - ' . `
{
Attaciment 2
. ....... . .. .. .... .....
r
_. .. ? } .. • -- — - --•'"-.. —• • - --._ r--•--`-- .. v.- _ .. _ .__.—.L __ - ... _.._. .. _ _.. _ _ ._ ...._. ... _ - .. _ _ .. I .• r ._ - ..v. "_-.. _.. ,. - - .... -• - --•• -- - — ti--- - - -- - __. _.....r ..�.. _.. r ....... . ... ...... _.._- _ ... . _ _. _ _.. _.. .. r.,. r_�---r.._... r ......+ ... n . r.... _. .... .. ..... .... ..• .. l r .. r,_ - _
y
f— --— , ._ ... .....__..ti .L.r.... - _..._ r_ �_ .r_._ -...r— .—r.- - - - ..__..�_.._ _. . �r __ . �•- + a.. _..� - .- _ _ _ _�.. r - • - - - -. _.._.. __..�.. .. - - - -... _._, _..
Aff
q6
+
r.. _ i
5
5
IL
+
... ..... .. . —.......
-�.. .. _.. -• _. -• .-.. _ r• r--- r-rn � .._r- r..-..._-- �_ r v _. .._� .. •_• __ .. _ ._ ._.. .. . i .. ..
a
lF b#
T
.... -- .........
.........._ ,. .. .....•—--•---•'---- •---••"-•-• r:.--..—_.._�• —: rte.. _._ •--...... �_._ .._� '---._.+. .._�,...�..� ---...._._.._ _ ,.... ... �. � - __r•- n .. - -. __ .._ �.-----...--- .v ..,...... .....,.. ... , TM ,r-�... -• -- — � --• •- - •- -•
ikk
I r
1
a � r. --� -� � .-_ , .� - -.- , - r,. --.r• .-._ ..rT �- ••--•�---••--• •----..._ - •---... _ Y.-_... �. r -• - -.._ .. .—•----•-• r _r-. -t- .......--•• ,-•-- . .. •• � v ._. ,..� ..._r ..+� . •• ,- � ._ r ....---.... __... .
I
;i -r
G '
i +
Will i
r
_ . _. _ .. _. _ ......_..,�� ..... , ._ -- ... -•- • •--.._.. --•-•----.._ _....--- .. •.� r .. _� .r . _..----___ ,_ _a—.�.�.. _—.�--- _..--- ---...r._. _.ra_. r �v._._ -.. --- • •-•-• -•-.........r _ _ _... _ _ ..., ....... r ... s .x � . - • • .--r....... ,,. r � ... , - .� . •--- • -- •--- •- -- ��-•- . --- ....__ �_ . r- r -_.,r—. -- -.--• --- - .. , .._ ._._. _. �__ .. � a+r , ti.._.� __ ...._...t . _ , . + . r ,� _.._._.�� __ .... — ,.. _ ..r. _.... ._ , . r ._
R x� 6
k
_. _ _ . ._ - — - --... • - - _.� _ ...... ,......
le.
IP
�
T r - .... r T -- ._.. _ . . r - .. _...- -� r -. -,vv y.. rr .... - �..�r ...r. ......._ -... ... _....._............-_._.._. _.. ...._. ..,
4 +
_ L t
' 1 r
a ,
- �. _..- - --.. .. �r _� .._.i _:..: t� �. •• ter. ••- .: _ . - � .. _ _._... t ._. � _._. ._ ._.z .. _ ._. _. ... _ �. � -- --._. ,
- _ ._ _. —_ — __ __.. .__+_.� _:�_.J.L. r,.r- __.. ••—_ _.__.� .. ,_.. _.+: ti_ .... ..�.r r: r ti... r.. .. ._ t ..._._... _ __... t_� ,• - ._.� __. ._ _.. .. __-__ �`� ',-- ---_,_ "---' .--"'` ..-_L..r— .. .r• _ .� ,�
1
G
r �
, a. �_ • � • _......-'-''--. .- ... L _.-. _. � _�,...... �._- -r r��-_—•- r•• �._ �.�r - ._.... -.� . r...... . _ , _ ... � ...a__....._ .. ,... ... ....� . '.... .. ,. -- rr,.r ...,.r~__.r�..�- . ... r � �r,.r-.. - --� — � . �---- a� � r , v� -�. - �- ._ wr��..._ , _.. ,�-.._ .........- . �. �-,.. r • • ... ..,, .. •• r -• • •- .. r ..- , �. . _ . • ,..__. ....._ . _ ,..r_. .. ...........
t
F �
�k
I
1
6kw
• - , _. L ��„r-• �.�,r -� air--- .. ..... ........s _s. r __._s ._ � u.x t
.....: •• .-._: _ �.._.-, r ---�... � ter— r-• - ' -•--"--r•_.... .-..�... • .. • v- � •rL-.., _.... . r• . •- . �.. _�_..,.._:. �—�- • '•-- - -• --- — •-- - .... - ...... �... r ._... _. -• _r.._ —._.. �. �-.. n..._..r-.�_ -...� .�. ._...-.r ._ ..._.--..- . ��_ r• • w - ..r-.. �. ,. -- - � - v �------t --•-- _- r...__ , •- v... ,+ - n -------- ��. -r.. �. � _....a_...... r _
X
}
+ 1 16lea p
r
_ + �' ...__ ._.....—_ __ _ _ .__�_... __. ... �--._ 1.._R.r-_- _ -r =- _ _-ri 1,.. -.�.� _ __ _,_ -� . .a....r�rrar_.�, ��...�..,��n. _ rrr T � •� r �,. •,...•. -r- � ,r-.. � _.., . -.._ .: .. •- •• -•• .n •.: -- � ._ __ . �..�. �. ..-.._ ._ ,_..... , , ... _.
__ _.. t..••-._--- r�-..__--.,- r_.._ ._. .._•�....._ ,,... _.-.... -..-. ..•..�G�.r Ste: _-...::_.}•�-• ---•�---•• ------..._..__. � --nr- •- �•' --•- ----r..._.. � r _r ,.�. �. .-... ... r �_ �_......_. _ , r � .T •:�.._ � ter -
i
I ,
I � 1
.� •._ — • ._. •• ...___ .. _.�• •-• • �_ L_ � � �.- .. - ��. x� t. _. __._..._.._..__ .. :.. �.� zrr r •• ,.. � ... r _. —�, . a__.._.. .-.. _.._ .. .... ,._. --. .. - ti --• •-. � ... L� . � . w __. _, �. — •__ •_—. —. - _ _ r—. ..—_ ..__,. ,-, ��. ... � ...,�. .. � �. � _— _„ _. _ wti r--. __•, ... .. -• - s -y— _ ._z- �—.. � _. _..._ r _ _.. _�� ••� + - ...... .. _ .
podl
1 F +
4
� I
- _ � _ _ t.. _ .._.. �. * _ ��.�.. � -�.. ._ T „r_- _ _.L_ .— _ _ _. .._.r- •- _v � rti = �. �- . .--._. �— .,,._r-� t.,••r•r . �.._r .- __.-•- k �. � �... t.n. .., J.. � ---•�. � ,�. _ __ �- - ._...
' r
r
._.mar r � ._rte'• L..�_r. a_._.+`� •�.�• .�a _ � � _ �. + _ t —._ _•a _ .+ _ �-� .t —��. +. r-_ta -.a��- �_�a.r. , ti .._�,-r.t.z - _ ._ r — -. .._ ._.� �n w—: ��__-.'�vr—� —r._— ti. a .—.- xr•= _ _•a_—ter—_ _,..__r—_. "—... _.. .__._..—..nJe _.— r. .. ... .._- r.._ •_• _
r
a
.. �__ ..r�.�,� �--- -- +.r-.�- --- �. .......•, ..,... �..t ...:-�- _r-. � -� _.. ,.+: - .. - — • -- .�. - - •-- - • -. _ _.r_.-L� _ �.--� ., �-�, ,a�+s_r .+�-1� � .��, ..r ...� ... „ ,_.. v ., � .,r� - �-_. r-.. �_ , .. — _� �,.--•-�.- -� -- —. .T. r--...- - -- --- ••-• --- •• - • - --- •- • - •• - —• • • -� -• - • r - - • - •—�----••---- --�.. _— .. .
j r dF + ,
/ _ _. ._—`— __ _-.. _i._+. _� u+. .. ._ .._ �a ,et ... w� t,n.�. � � - -- _.�_1 _ .-_ T �A— _r—t ti-_ -_T hr_._ �tiv •� _.. .___ r• � - .� tit• _• .._ ... L..._ _ _.- 4. , __ ,__. � ,_ _._. _. _ -t __.� .a ..._ _ � _ •- ..-. _.-•- .. r -�• _ � r•�•_r - _ _- .— ,} .--. :..__ _ _—_ ..—. _ _._
._. _. ._ ._. .. z_-_ i,+...—... ter._+.�.—_�+,f _••__ ---r 1__�'.-•r.�...��•-z .�•-• � :.�. z.. �.. �_,r—.—��r_ r-r_-•�,...,_—TM-� L-_••_ -� - —• --�` •, ._—_..— ._.-• � ._ .. z :
i •
' � - --- •- "— -••_ - --•- --._.v_.. ._ - .. .. �.�• ... „_ .. .. .... _. _... _. Y... .--- ._ •• .. : •• - z rtm .. r _u .._.�_.... _.-• - .� .- r_. _. �. .__. ... rr• __ , �• .r—_ -- ,_ r __. ___ � -•_-- - -- r'—'-- - _ .. : ..... a a a .. , .i. � �_ _ � � _ _ ..._ ..._. r._ ... ... , .. •• � - a •• •r"-- ..� .r -- �- - —�- l- —J-- — _. _-••--•— a •-•- .-. - z._ ....__ - —� •_ __•• ___
r�
F
a
r '
tia ,r LT r w , - — �trt .I. _ _._. _._ _. .� .. -- r -.._.. _.� .._— ..._ .. .._ _.._. _ ..._.-_.�......--•----------•-- -- - -'"- n -•--- •--•-- •—•-•- -�. - .,. r, _..� ._. --- i---
i
A
as _ ` . � - .... ._ n._ . __._ . . , � � ...._ , , , , - -•-- •- •• -- •--....._ . — _ . _. _._..--- - -- . L -. _ __ _ _. _...._ ._. . _ .... .. _ .. _.
i -
i
.. •_ - __.. _. _.. •. __ __ '• _• •__• _• •—_ 'a... ••..• ..• _ .. _.. .._ _. _.. ....... ._ •-• �.n .. .r , , r. .. •- •. t. ... ... v. r ... _.. �_. ._.. � ._ ._.._ , _ .._. _—_ , ._ .._ , .—, ...- _. ,-•-. t - t— r rz _ _— - — L - + - •_•_ __ _^ � __•__�... _... r. ..v. ... ... _.._._ �r .. •rr r � — - r .. rr.. .. ._.. _. a_. r ..a v � , � ..a• -v • � .. - v-.. - __ __• •__ r- __ .. .._ .... L— ___•• �..—• n —• - --.. ••-v -• -•- �
_ - .. _..... _.—"..._. .ra .rt ..._� .._.. ___•__•_•...,.r y._r... .. -... ._'_ ._ �vti _._._ ._..... ,� ._ ...... T. ..._._ , r n � v _ r—
f
- ; a
5 '
1�
. , , .r_. t.... r_�••- �.. .. •• .0 .. .r .. ... _ r•••t__„ .._ __ }; .._. ... r._a. ..r .. --•_ r_._..._.__.._. _ .__ ..__ _. _ .._ _—_ ____ ._ _ ... ._r_.._ ..• .. .,+.__. _ __�v a.r Jvr r� ... t-••__ _.. ____�__� �_, _.__.___. _._. u.__ _ _. ._ L ._ _ •_ _ _. .�_. ...._.._ _ ..__ t._.___ ._._—_...._. _. r ._ ... t ... �>� .--. __ ,
+
i
'
iti _ ...... .. _.. ._.. ._ _ ... .. rv.::.. .. _ •... _._. ... __ , . _.,_ti- ._ ,__. — . _x.-_-_. _ -..- ... -. , _ _..-- —• ._ .. ..' .__. .-- - ---. ... .. .._ _ _._.� .-a...... ... M u ..0 _ .. .... �-- '--. ._._ •, _.--.-.-_. _. _.. .._r — ti _ ....- -•-...r - __. -_. ..... .. . - .__. .. ..._ , - - - _.... _.r .— , ..._ _ _.. ._ , ._ _ ..._ , ._... , , rs , - •- _... .. ... .... -- , — _. , — _ --•� --- - -
• i � ■
.i
f
i
i
.. ...... .. .... i.... _. •. _.._ ....._ _. _ • -•• _. ••- .. - ,. - --'� - - ... L- •� - r..r ... -__.. - _. .. --. . - __ ' _.. _.._—_ .__ . _ ._.... ... .. __... .__ . _. —_. — -'- - --- .__.. . r v .... + . r. v .. , , ... _. _� - - —_ .. - - ' - - - .. _..... - .. .
a � T
a i
a
" r
/ z
142 16 F Y�
i
� � .. �., .. ..._r..._�._ ,...._._. .. _.__ ._ ...--- - - .. _.. __ -- .---.._._. ..,.._ ..r.- _-•-- r . - •-•- -� ... _.._ , . _ � .__ .. _.. v... r_T ..__ r . _.....r- __...,._ .__. � .. . -..... .. � _ .._, - � . --- --•--••- -- - -- - _. ,.._ --� �_ _ r.._...r-__ ..r -f---- •- - --..._ _.. _ . ___. _.....- - -- ---- . - .--•-••-•-•------•• -- •- .- •• --- .._ _...... - r_ -- -- ... � ., v, , , . _....__... _-----••- •----....
j
$ j +
L
_.._._..- � —_ _... - __— •__ - �---r.._.. _..___• •l�• - •_ __. •_�.... ` ... • _... _. Z _ - .� r .._ r a. __...__—_ „— � _. .... ,_— , —_. a _ _._ ,_ _ v � . _.. ___ •_ • ___ z - __— - - - - _- •• _. � __•_ __ .. _ .. -. .. .� �_. __•__. ... ....+ .. _.. _. � ... , .. ..�4 _..._ , - __ ._ � .. _„ _.._ - ..._ .. - _ - -• : r ,�. ___ .. ._ — _. • __• : N a- ... � .. t , k .. .. , � � •. ,. —__• __ ... __. a
F
,
OA
U M1
, C � � •— _..... F, __. � , — � . _.. �.... _.. _ ._____. _ _� - •- •. . z._ __. t ..�_y_ �+ . - _ •__._ .. v. .._...r • - ... �. J .. _. , •—• - v r x.. r ........._. �v _. t :• . - , .. ._. rt—_ __• - i..... ..— ._ r-•----+ .. ___.. r. ,____. � .._ ..._- _ r .rte -- r - � � ___ T ..___..._ r •.... -,. r•L ._. .... U _. - P
- - _��._r• r—.r—. .—_ ...._ ...
ary
o f 19 1
:
c
. �
�
�
. ! �
�
` ^ �
Attachment 2
. �
. .
�
� ~ �
. .
. .
. ^ °
�
. �
. �
. � ]
' n
" o
loo
� k
� [
"� ' .� �
^ �
i � ^
. �
�
� ~
� U 0
RC
` ^
° ^
/ 1 �
. .
�
�
°
_-' _-'-----' - `-
� ^
. `
. x '
�
�
. U
` l
� o
'
�
'
�
._' - .-''
. .
� .
�
_~---- --- --- -��-'__-'-.'~�_',__'��.'~--'.-.-.-'-_-��_�-�.,--'--~.�--~'�--~.'��---'�.-_-
� .
�
i
/ ~
� U ^
"
� X ^
� n IP
l
� U �
U �
'
^ U �
~ '
� U
'
�
'
,
-
� .
' [
�
�
^ . �
�
. �
. �
�
' .
� � ~
�
� p
�
^
"
'
n �
v � �
'
' ^
' U
` K
U �
�
�
.... ... _____�_________�_ �__........ _._~_______ �� a .~ �~.�_,__.-_,__~--_--__ __`��-_'' �~`'--^.^�_~ --�/��-'`--.�_/-^'�-_`~ �__^ _--�---__---�~-�- -�~_��._.'^ --' -__-`--- --'_-- - ---�' `-_~� -�-- _ --- _'------_--� --__�`'^��--'---�_-- `_--_-_-� -�-----___----_+-�----�--.---_~.-.--�'--- ---,/._� �-�^_-_�~--,_'---~_`---'-.-�,-- ^-..�-.~-..-'�.'�-�'-
'
'
�
~
�
'
� ~
�
* �
� ~ �
: n .
- .
'
'
� ^
' .
'
^ ^
^
�
'
�
�
^ �
| ,
: &
U �
�
. .
. '
� U �
. �
~
�
�
[ ° ^
�
. .
� ~
--�~-'--�----~-`-'----�--..^'-�----�
�
�
~
� .
� . ^
�
, . ^
o
�
�
/ .
� ^
U �
� � ~
�
�
~ '
`
`
` -
�
t
- � � ~'-
_ 2 -of,
� N~ ' -- ^
inpu mary age
-
- .
�
. �
. � ^
� 1 '
' ^
*
Attachment 2
r 1�
Date,: Marcy 18, 2019
To: C ityCouncil and City Mana,er
From:, Petaluma Climate Action Campaign
Subject: Climate Action Proposal ,
Fierce w'ildfi'res, toxic air, torre4 nt'ia I rainfall. What we're seeing today is a preview.
Accord'i'ng to a 2018 consensus report from the world's leading climate scientists, even y
more devastating consequences of global warming are on the way. But we can lessen
their impact if we act urgently and bo(d(yto cut and draw down carbon.
It is immoral to delay to leave this for another day, anotier generation, another city,
or another country. We must approach a crisis of this magnitude from every angle and
in every corner of the world --including Petaluma,.
We can do much more than just reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions'. Let's engage
our community—including those most marginalized—and envision the
kind of city we
wa nt to create: one that improves our lives such as by reducing traffic, managing waste,
improving air quality, and providing good -paying, h.igh**quaI'ityjobs-,
We ask that the City Councilput the following on its 201'9 –2020 gnat -setting agenda,,
Make equitable climate action the City of. Petaluma's number -one priority.
Adopt a resolution declaring a climate emergency (Attachment A).
luding Berkeley, Oakland, RichmondHaywardA growing number ofcities—inc,
Fremont, Santa Cruz, and Fairfax have unanimously adopted a Climate
Emergency Resolution. These reframe climatechange as the existential crisis it
has become and help to prioritize climate action.
•
Create'a Petaluma Climate Cabinet,,
We recommend that this entity include ex officio members and community
members appointed bY the City Council with climate-related expertise. The Climate
Cabinet would be charged with assessing the climate concerns of all—including
those of climate experts and people most impacted I y the climate- crisis—and
recommending municipal and community responses,
• Establish accountability for e a uma s climate goals.
Meet commitments made previously in the Regional Climate Protection
Authority's (RCPA s) C ima e c ion 202o and align wits California's goal of
reaching.car on neutrality as soon as possible, but no later than 2045.
References'.
It IPCC 2oz8 Special Report: Global Warming of I -.5°C
z, Carbon -neutral
n)u ummary 1 - Page 0
f 191
Attachment 2
ATTACHMENT An. RESOLUTION DECLARING A -CLIMATE EMERGENCY
WHEREAS, all the countries that signed the 2o:L5 Paris Agreement'vowed to keep
warming this century "well below 2°C above pre -industrial levels"' and to "pursue efforts
tol'I'mi*tthetemP erature "
increase even further to i.5°C;
WHEREAS, the 2oi8 International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Special Report on
Global Warming of, 1.50C estimates that humans have already caused about i.oOC of
global warming above pre -industrial levels;'
WHEREAS, the 2os8 IPCC Special Report estimates that to have a 66% chance of
limiting global warming to 1.5° C, we cannot exceed our remaining "carbon budget,"
which is equal to about io years of current -level greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions,Z
WHEREAS, current global warming has contributed to the, increasing frequency and
intensity of wildfires, floods, droughts, heat waves, and hurricanesw3
WHEREAS, Northern California wildfires in 2017 and 2oi8 destroyed at least 38,333
structures, killed :L:L8, displaced thousands, and caused serious reductions in air qualityal
WHEREAS, the current'pace of sea -level rise is already impacting California's coastline@-
at
z-3 feet of sea -level rise, parts of Petaluma would,be under water; and there is the
Possibility of 6.5 feet or more oftotal sea -level rase by 2-1006"6
WHEREAS, climate change and the global economy's overshoot of ecological limits are
driving the sixth mass extinction of species;'
WHEREAS, the U.S. has. contributed greatly to these cl'imate and ecological crises and
bears an extraordinary responsibility to help solve them,
WHEREAS, restoring a safe and stable climate requires mobilization at all levels of
government and society on a scale, scope, and speed not seen since World War Two;
WHEREAS, marginalized communities worldwide—'includi'ng people of color,
immigrants, indigenous communities, low-income people, those with disabilities, and
the unhoused are already disproport.ionately affected by climate change and must
benefit first from ajust transition to a sustainable -and equitable economy;
WHEREAS, efforts to control climate change will have many.other beneficial effects,
such as cleaner air and water; emP,yo ment closer to home; cost savings for households'.
and the City, and the priceless creation of community;
WHEREAS, the City of Petaluma must do: everything itn 1"tspowerto swiftly converttoan
ecologically, socially, and economically sustainable economy;
Input Summary 1 -Page 154 of 191
Attachment 2
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED,
The City of Petaluma declares a climate emergency threatens the world;
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the City of Petaluma .will elevate cl*imate'issues to the
highest priority in its goal-setting process; give precedence to climate mitigation and
adaptation when evaluating policies and purchases, planning projects, and allocating C:
resources; and wiI! seek financial and regulatory aid to support these efforts,
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the City of Petaluma commits to reducin9.C.1t.ywide GHG
emissions to carbon neutrality as quickly as possible and no ater than '2045 the goal _
set bY Governor Brown's Executive Order B-5,5-188 and to accelerating climate
adaptation and resilience strategies;YA
BE ITfURTHER RESOLVED, the City of Petaluma will directthe Regional Climate {
Protection Authority (RCPA) to immediately make aromprehe''nsi*ve assessment of:
current citywide GHG emissions including those from consumption of goods and
services—and to track GHG emissions and publicly report annually on'ts progress
toward the9oal of zero net emissions;
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the City of Petaluma will create a Climate Cabinet and
partner with local and regional agenc:ilestoact immediately including meeting
commitments made in the RCPA's C11*mate Action 2020 9 and fully integrating climate
actions in'itS 2045 General Plan;
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the City of Petaluma supports full public participationIN
toward zero net emissions including input from and participation by disen"franchised
communities. and recognizes that Petaluma residents, community organizations,
labor, business, and -schools are integral to' leading this effort;
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the City of Petaluma calls for emergency action at all
levels of government to restore a safer climate, safeguard against the results of climate
change, and support the usttransaitliontoasustalinab e economy with good -paying,
high"quali
t
YJOb S. -
References:
i, The:zo�ParisAq
-Eeement
z. IPCC 20i8 Special Report: Global Warming of i.,°C
3NRDC: Are the Effects of Global Warming Really that Bad?
4. Insurance Information Institute: Facts + Statistics: Wildfires
5. California Ocean Protection.: Rising Seas in California: An Update on Sea -Level Rise Science.
6. Digital Coast: https..i.//coast.noaa,aov/diqitalcoast/tools/sir.html
7. National Geographic: Will Humans Survive the Sixth Great Extinction?
8, Executive Order B --1-8 To Achieve Carbon Neutrality
g.
RCPA; Climate Action zozo a nd Beyond.
nPut Summary
1 -Page 155 of 191
Attachment 2
As of 4-5-Zg, the following organizations or businesses have endorsed this cl'i'mate
action proposal: 1A,C;,o��
wwyArlen,w.laxrok-
.����r.�� Foundaflon
SIERRA ,�r�1�, ��H�M�c�u� --T METTA CENTER CLUB
VC)UNDE I „LA,,,r,��11 for NONVIOLENCE
NO TH BAV
• ORGAI`IIZII`1G PRO)ECT
vwovicio owo:rvuirvo ovLnour7oeumew.
,�v+ far
LEkDLiRSHIP
]REDWOODI*wEMPIRE a�� Transition � N s 7' i z U T F
SUS T � �g���s ���,.,.,,,,,...�,.-.r�.,�,,,,,,,,,,,,,�:•
�� Sonoma
ASSET MANAGEMENT, LLC Valley q►� qt�$
INC.
t4tnox - UNITED STATES
LAMDBOAF6
National Aisoclation of Social Workers
E IT HAPPEN
Car Don Cycle ns i ut PREPAREDNESS SERVICES
P E T A L U M A 7`0 M O R R O W ,. � LITERACYWORKS
qpm CW"x"=M • Rnpeea161eLMelopmnWumAd i`mteahn I `'z � , y�
rL
° FACTSC
HERITAGE SALVAG TwUwroau�►aaI rwiasoiery
THE CLIMATE
MOBILIZATION
THE FARMERS GUILD ��enewable ��
SONOMA COUNTY\\\\ SOYZO�Yia FRIENDS OF THE
f e �PETALUMA RIVER
Continued list:
Democratic Club of Southern Sonoma County -
Friends of the Climate Action P an
Peta urna People Services Center
Urban Chat
A Bay Drilling
The Shuckery
The Oyster Girls
In gut Summary 1 - 'age 156 of 191
C
3ffltax
PR1-.-f,SIDE# NT
707.778.4334
41 C, -"i!W
ldfem.�
KIC E. -PRES EN]
7107.781.1224
MIKE PIERRE
SE CRE TAR Ir
707-78.1-1208,
ur
WALT SPILLER
TREASUREY
707-778.4,456
I ke
11
GARRE T GLANqANO
A,1r4,A,fflER,ATL-A-RGE
707.781.1256
(II, I I a v, i f�hl 0 �'4` vIeUllUniaca,us
ADRIANNE CAUSEY
AllaelBER AT LA RGE
707.781.1278
a c a L j e N I e.1 Ll 111 Z-1JNa., u
NIARI-0 GION11
AlIE, mBEo R; A i" LA RGE
707.776.3722
CL! tuna,ca.LIS
Petah-tina Police Departmen'
Phone (707 778-4372
Fa,v (707) 778-4476
0
C
P[ost Ofice Box 751:0474
Pe a,lunia, 7orinta �,,�;"
April 5, 2019
Honora'bl'e Mayor and City Council Members
Petaluma City Hall
11 English Street
Petaluml
0
(Via em,
Califomia 9495,2
il)
k....ity uounci, emil ers,
ear ayor arrett an
is
#now MOR, 3 1& AMIN WAL P
ice epatImi
e
G! 10aknow, ,,uring the recession the city of Petaluma had to take extreme measures
mm
701 W M -W W -g--10=7 jwm"�= qu,
IN eNd! RL M 9L Yffl
IS
I rw M.T &0 A
Input Summary 1 a. e J ON I Ot 191
Attachment 2
April 4, 2 0 19
I.
with just 49 police officers. These 49 police officers include the Chief, admillistrative staff, and
tions and Tr1
affic Units. Our Patrol
to calls for service) is currently,
operating with only 28 police officers to respond to calls 24 hours a day. The Investigations Unit
our Special Services division which includes our InvestIF iga
Services Division (uniformed poli
1
ce officers who respond
1
s currently operating with only tluee detectives to investi
additional detective assigned to the Northern Cal
gate any major crime and only one
ornia Computer Crimes Task Force. The
Traffic Unit has been reduced and is operating with only two officers In order to provide
minimum staffing to the Patrol Division, the department has recen
ly r
emoved"three officers
from the Traffic Division, two officers from the Homeless Outreach Services Team (HOST), one
Detective from the Drug Enforcement Administration Task Force, and one Detective from the
Sonoma County Auto Theft Task Force and assigned them to patrol.
The loss of specialty assignments has been taken extremely hard within the department. Not
only do these assignments bring additional resources to help with major investigations, but they
also brought in money, in the form of forfeitures and (salary) funding, freeing up money from the
0
general fund for other positions. Officers also look to these specialty assignments as
opportunities for growth and advancement. In order to fill these assignments, officers rece1 ive
specialized training, collaborate with outside agencies, and develop a level of expertise that is not
readily available to most patrol officers. Officers assigned to specialty positions bring their
additional knowledge and experience back to the department, which enriches the entire
department and the community as a whole.The loss of these opportunities makes the Petaluma
Police Department a less attractive place to work and will eventually lowerthe collective
knowledge and experience within the police department, ultimately reducing the level of seryice
we provide to the community.
As Chief Savano outlined in his August 29th, 20181etter to the public, this lack of staffing has
orced the chiefto reduce the services the police department provides to the public. Among
other things, e police department is no longer investigating non-injury collisions, no longer
responding to misdemeanor thefts any theft where the stolen property is valued at $950 ar lesswith no identifiable evidence or suspect leads, nor are vacation checks being conducted.n adition to not responding to certain calls for service the Patrol Division,Traffic Unit, and the
nvestigations Unit no longer have the time, or the staffing, o conduct proactive policing. On
average each patrol officer in Petaluma has only eight minutes per hour when they are not
responding to a call for service, report writinginvestigating a crime, or conducting some other
required duty. The departments goal is for each officer to have 1/3 of their tune flee so they are
able to engagewith the community,provide extra patrolconduct traffic enfarcementor to
conduct other types of proactive policing.
In addition to sworn positions, we cui-rently only have one Community Service Officer. In years
ast the department had five. Community Service Officers provide valuable support to theeparhnent,wich allows police officers to be more proactive.
Our Communications Center is also understaffed and overworked. For years our dispatchers
ave worked a substantial amount of overtime to compensate for the lack of staffing. The
age 2 of 4
Input Summary 1 -Page 158 of 191
4
Attachment 2
Apri14, 2 019
ongoing staffing shortages have negatively impacted employee wellness and morale,
mention the financial cost to the city in regard to overtime costs. A recent (internal)
not to
study/comparison showed that our dispatchers handle more calls for service than other
di"ti*onal
departments of similar size an d recommended hiring at least one more,finot two ad
dispatchers.
Chief Savano has projected that i*n the next 18 to 36 months we will have at least 15 police
officers retiring and he is expecting nine retirements i@n the next. year. Many of these positions
will be the rank of Sergeant or above.
Dayto day we are requiring our officers to extend thel*r'eleven hour shifts two to three hours to
fill gaps I*n the schedule. Officers are routinely required to work mandatory overtime on their
days off, not only to help with patrol staffing, but often to staff special events such as parades,
Our officers are required to respond to and investigate en.9tical
the fair, or high school events.
incic ents wiln gar sewer ouilcers anc resources inan we maac dust i u years ago. i nis is taping a
huge toll on our officer's professional lives, their personal li'ves, and on their. families. This level
of staffing cannot be sustained, -yet this has become the norm within the department.
One of the major factors in officers leaving the department is the additional stress involved in
working with a skeleton crew of patrol officers and not having the resources necessary to
properly and safely investigate critical incidents. Police work today is more complex, dangerous,
publicly scrutinized, 'and filled with liability than it has ever been. Instead of having more
officers to deal with these additional burdens our staff has been reduced. Our officers are now
required to respond to dangerous and potentially deadly situations with far less resources then we
did years ago. This not only places the lives of our officers at more risk, but also puts the public
in danger.
-The City's General Plan,adopted in 2008, guides city planning through 2025. It calls for the city
to maintain the police staffing level at 1.3 officers per 1000 residents, or 78 officers (for a
population of 60,000). Even though the' city has, acknowledged the need for additional officers
the city has done very little to meet its goal.- Petaluma's population has continually increased
over the years. Although the City's General Plan calls for police staffing at 1.3 officers per 1000
residents, no effort has' been made to meet that plan, even with known, expected growth.
Petaluma has approximately 20 developments on line, totaling more than 2000 new -residential
units at varying stages of development. This lack of planning and action has caused the current
staffing crises within the department. If the department was staffed with 78 officers or 84
officers (the state average), we would have the ability to navigate the anticipated retirements and
the normal vacancies without. affecting the high level of servi"ce'to the citizens of Petaluma.'
However, at current staffing levels we will continue to apply more pressure to the remaining staff
at the poliailmentceepin order to provide the most basic level of service.
We know resources are scarce within the city, but i*n order to protect the community, and to
ensure your officers wellness and overall health, the staffing at the police department must be the,
top priority of the city council and the community. We understand that other departments within
the city have legitimate and important needs of theix own, and _other departments within the city
Page 3 of 4
Input Summary 1 -Page 159 of 191
0
Attachment 2
Apri01 4_, 2019
also provide valuable services to the community, but in order to address the current staffing crisis
within the department, and in order to keep the community safe, the Peace Officers Assoc iation
of Petaluma pleads with you to make the staffing crisis at the police department the top goal of
the council,
Page 4 of 4
Input Summary 1 :'age 160 of 191
Cooper," %'..1,aire
Goal Setting Ap
Sent: Saturday, April Ou', 2019 10:135 AM
0
t �C I 1� t'V� 0 f 0', >
i
Council <cit oun: I etaluma.,::org
A
Subj*eC+L,.m Goa'i Setting AP
April 6, 2018
ril 6th,.
[MIN 1714
off
mat
rreint General Plan. I saw Bernmi
focus was not on gorals, buton I
M KFm-,�ALALW.J .0141 R- t W -bas] a, m 09
1-mmi- RTA
11 a
III
I
in
1
Input Summary 1 -Page 161 of 191
0
Attachment 2
Cooper, Claire
Subject: Switch to Sonoma Clean Power EverGreen. Plan
From,* Sandra Messer
Sent: Wednesday, April 03, 2019 10:15 AM
To: -- City Clerk'<Cl*tyClerk@c*ltyofpetaluma.org>
Subject: Switch to Sonoma Clean Power EverGreen Plan
Hello -
As a Petaluma homeowner and city resident, I'm writing to promote Petaluma adopting the Sonoma Clean Power
EverGreen plan.
As a residential property owner, we are already Sonoma Clean Power customers. Why?
believe climate change is an existential crisis worldwide. We must proactively address this crisis with'due haste.
California requires local jurisdictions to have a plan to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. While switching to the Sonoma
Clean Power EverGreen plan will cost a little more, it w'111 also help us meet the targets for greenhouse gas emissions,
make us safer in the long run by reducing carbon emission costs to us all, and promoting more renewable energy
sources. I urge Petaluma to switch to the EverGreen plan now."
Sandra Lee Messer
Petaluma
I'm always in, always, for the necessary fight. Sim
1
Input Summary 1 -Page 162 of 191
Attachment 2
6 April, 2019
To: City of Petaluma City Manager
Claire Cooper, for distribution to Councilmembers
Re: Petaluma City -Goal Setting Workshop April -6, 2019
From: Tarmulara Norman
I was not able to attend this Saturday's workshop, but I would like to offer a few case
studies of my recent experiences with city process.
Perhaps a bit of background may help understand the lens fi4om which I view: I have
livedi"n Petaluma for over 20 years. I have rented here; I now own a home.' I -worked out
of town and had no children; now I wor1c part"wtime (some in town) and have children, one
now in a Petaluma Ci"ty'school. I have tried to be an engaged citizen and have'
been part
of community workshops (Water Street, IZO); have spoken out at council and
commission meetings, on. issues I felt needed a voice; was supportive -and active on
establishing the public arts ordinance and the opening of the Petaluma Arts Center; I
served 8 years on the Tree Advisory Committee. I have always felt Petaluma is a city of
great cultural and physical assets and appreciate the history and multifaceted economies
of this town.
I will be brief as possible with the case studies, but would be available to provide any
further details.
Case Study I - Rezoni of Civic Space on North Water Street
My concern: As a city we continue to undervalue, give-away, underuti'lize and underfand
our civic spaces (both green and urban).
,What I would like to see'..
• City intentions/goals as well as project applicants clearly stated from the
beginning
• Staff recommendations that speak fiom the platform of benefitting the city
and citizens and clearly state any city/citizen negative impacts of proposed
projects
• Engaged discussion with the appropriate Committee early on for input
from typically professional, engaged, dedicated citizens,,
• A review and analysis of "consulting staff' vs "in —house " —Are
consultants really cheaper and most importantly better for Petaluma?
• Funding for maintenance, upkeep and upgrades to be applied to all civic
spaces.
Input Summary 1 -Page 163 of 191
J
40
0
9
q
In November, I received notice of this rezoning and t1-4. en did my research. Only through
much time and effort did I discover that this'was a complicated affair of multiple property
owners and the city trying to get developers to pay for thi'll9 S,$ I found the projec
Attachment 2
description complex in some ways but oversimplified as to the true
Staff recommendations read as a supportive proposal for the nroi*ec
the implications and i
(referencing incorrect
issues on the
t
table.
t versus an analysis of
mpacts. Additionally'l found egregious errors in staff material
parts of the specific plan and later, typos in the proposed
agreement2 : "all" versus "partial" —
a seri
of funding another park seemed flippant and too cursory and distracted from the primary
Ch
ous difference) . Conditions and the initial offer
issue
anging a Civic 8p- acezone to T5.
Case - - -s- -t- ---ud-------------------- -y II -
A�1ying
My concern:
for a Bu-ild0 g_permit-6
for a home addition
I think the city maybe paying more for consultants.. Subbing -out plans
creates a break i*n communication and causes unnecessary paperwork and increases
applicant costs., Staff and subcontractors must know current city codes',,
What I would like to see:
• A review and analysis of "consulting staff' vs in —house" —Are consultants
really cheaper, and most importantly, better for Petaluma?
We hired a local, seasoned, Architect to wank with us on a proposed addadditionto our home.
We applied for a building permit, and waited. Received our plan comments one month
after they were written (perhaps because the contract Planner was 110 longer work'. g) and
had two instances where staff "overreached" current codes. We received:
8 pages of comments from building department sub (some truly nit -picky)
Initial request from Plalui' g for us to do a Historic Resource evaluatoni(even though we
are not in the Historic District)., This would have cost an estimated $2,400- $3,400 and
an extended timeline to get a report done,, Again after much time and effort and research
1k
on my part, and outreach from the Department Head was a compromise resolved,, I
would have preferred a discussion upfront vs a formal dec�laration in writing.
Since the-Fi*re department box was not.checked, our Architect followed up with the,
Department: We were being required to install fire spri -1fl-1clers even though our remodel,
met current code and was not over 50°/o. This required again, both time and a letter on
my part and our Archi'te'ct,
Here is a case study costs of a 560 square foot addition to existing home.,
$16,490 Architect, Structural, Title 24 sub & Cal Green fees
$53481 * * Additional time for revising drawings, follow up & meetings
$5, 550.34 Permit fees
$11955-o76 School impact fee,
Total $29,477
Input Summary 1 - Page 164 of 191
a
Attachment 2
HI
It is this ** additional cost that concerns me,, While some follow ump would be typical, we_
were required to do a consi'de-Trable amount of follow up, some not justified; and this
figure does not include any of my time,,
While I was relieved to find out the permit cost is based on.flat fees and percentages, and
I could understand the cost breakdown, I do wonder who is paying for all this extra time
on the City's end?
Thank you for your attention and consideration.
Tammara Norman
Petaluma, CA
InpUts ummary 1 -Page 165 of 191
Attachment 2
PBAC GOAL SE--ING INPU-
:let n iffic', Gina
Thu 4/4/2019 70019 PM
To:Alverde, Ingrid <IAlverde@cityofpetaluma.org>;
Ingrid ,
The following recommendations were given by this Committee in a round table- discussion at their April 4 meeting (last night!):
• Bike -and pedestrian connectivity for all ages and abilities.
• Encourage Transit. usage.
•
Petaluma,to be known as a bicycle friendly City.
• Encourage Bike/Pedestrian, connections to the River.
• Embrace innovative ideas to street design.
• Plan for new mobility devices.
• "Funky touches" —streets as places; vibrant public spaces (i.e., public art, landscaping).
My day was so hectic -meant to get this to you sooner!! Not sure if this can be used this weekend but sending regardless.
Gina
Sent from my iPhone
Input Summary 1 -Page 166 of 191
Dear Mayor Barrett and Petaluma City Council,
As members of Petaluma's Historic and Cultural Preservation Committee, we urgently r
consideration of "Local Landmark" designation for some of Petaluma's most sign ificant
Attachment 2
ecom end and request your
and character defining historic
resources.. -The historic railroad tracks and the waterfront trestle not only provide residents and tourists wit
connection to earlier ties in our community, they are the backbone i nrrasliructure icna-6
today.,
Of all the landmarks constructed over Feiwuma's 160 -year history, none have cunir-foutea.more to int! economic
4h
success and historic character of Petaluma and Sonoma County than these railroad tracks and trestle. For 96 years there
h a tangible
t created tne town we enjoy
had been a continuous
ne of tracks through the streets of downtown and across the waterfront trestle., It was these
tracks and trestle that canner -ted Sonoma County Farms with the international shipping li
and enabled Petaluma to serve as "
status or designation. This request
nes of the San Francisco t5av
Egg Basket to the World". Yet these valuable resources have no special planning
and recommendation follow a year in which mult'i'ple degradations of the resources
have occurred or been approved, notably:
t
1. The cutting, demolition and removal of the first street line, at "D" Street
2-s Multiple cuts of the tracks'along Water Street
3, Approval of an outwofwtown', for-profit, housing developer's proposal wh*lchl"ncludes demolition and removal of
the tracks along Poultry Street, without sufficient conditions for mitigation or restoration of the line.
Landmark status would not prohibit. odiflications to these resources, but would create a process for review of proposed
alterations,, and the development of appropriate solutions and mitigation measures through a "Landmark Alteration
Permit" process., We acknowledge that past efforts to preserve the tracks and incorporate them into new
developments have not all been perfectly successful. However, we can learn from these, and work with city forces and
private developers to meet their needs, while preserving Petaluma's history. It is also noted that these resources are
owned -by others, this is true'of nearly all of Petaluma's landmarks,.
While these lines haven't carried freight since 1997, they continue to provide residents and tourists with a valuable
d,
connection to the agricultural triumph of Petaluma and Sonoma County. Whether or not these rails will see commerc*ial
service again remains to be determined., but if'you go to the Northwestern Pacific Railroad Historical Society's barn on
Copeland Street, you'll find an operational locomoteive resting on the tracks, ready to roil. Though there are not currently
funds available for'trestle restoration or -track repairs, they are still an extremely valuable asset. It took over 80 years to
re-establish passenger rail service between Petaluma and Santa Cosa. While SMART did have to re -build the tracks, it is a
good thing the right of way was'preserved intact.
Petaluma's City' Council can take action to protect and presence the historic character of our community and the
eleme'nts-that keep it authentic. Please provide the Planning Department with the appropriate direction to explore
"Landmark" status and a Historic Preservation Zoning Overlay for these critical artifacts. In this time of tough decisions,
when resources are scarce and funds are just not available, this is a low-cost measure with lasting value.
Respectfully,
Petaluma's Historic and Cultural Preservation Committee:
nput Summary 1 -Page 167 of 191
I.
U
Attachment 2
6 April, 2019
To: City of Petaluma City Manager
Claire Cooper, for distribution to CounciImembers
Re: Petaluma City Goa
From: Tammara Norman
1 Setting Workshop April'6,
2019
0
I was not able to attend this Saturday's workshop, but I would like to offer a few case
studies of
my'rccent experiences with city process,,
Perhaps a bit of background may help understand the lens from which I view: I have
lived in Petaluma for over 20 years. I have rented here; I now own a home. I worked out
now I work part-time (some
now in a Petaluma City school.
of town and had no children
in town)
and have children-, one
I have tried to be an engaged citizen and have been part
of community workshops (Water Street, IZO); have spoken out at council and
commission meetings on issues I felt needed a voice; was supportive and active on
establishing the public arts ordinance and the opening of the Petaluma Arts Center
;I
served 8 years on the Tree Advisory Committee. I have always felt Petaluma is a city of
great cultural and physical assets and appreciate the history and multifaceted economies
of this town.
I will be brief as possible with the case studies, but would be available to' provide any
further details.
Case Study--I-------Rezonin
My concern
of Civic Space on North Water Street
As a-ci*tly we continue to undervalue, giveaway,
our civic spaces (both green and urban).
What I would like to'see:L
• City I"n t c n ti"
beginning
underutilize and underfand
U
ons/goals as well as project applicants clearly stated from the
• Staff recommendations that speak from the platform of benefitting the city
and citizens and clearly state any city/citizen negative impacts of proposed
projects
• Engaged discussion with the appropriate Committee early on for input
from typically professional, engaged, dedicated citizens.
• A reviewand analysis of "consulting staff' vs "in —house" Are
consultants really cheaper and most importantly better for Petaluma?
• Funding for maintenance, upkeep and upgrades to be applied to all civic
spaces.
4
Input.summary 1 -Page 168 of 191
11
In November, I received notice of this rezoning and then didm'y research.
much time and effort did I discover that this was a complicated affair of mu
Attachment 2
Only tluough
Itiple property
owners and the city hying to get developers to pay for things. I found the projec
description complex in some ways but oversimplified as to the true issues on the
Staff recommendations read a
the implications and impacts.
t
table.
s a supportive proposal for the project versus an analysis of
Additionally I found egregious errors ion staff material.
(referencing incorrect parts of the specific plan and
agreement: "all" versus "partial" —
ding another park seemed flippant and too cursory and e istractee from the primary
o f fun
issue:
later_, typos in the proposed
a serious difference) .
Conditions and the initial offer
Changing a Civic space zone to T5.
Case stuff II — App..lyingfor a Building �ermit for a home- addition
My concern: I think the city maybe paying more for consultants: Subbing -out plans
creates a break in. communication and causes unnecessary paperwork and increases
applicant costs. Staff and subcontractors must know current city codes..
What
We h
I would like to see:.
A review and analysis of "consulting staff ' vs "in house" —Are consultants
really cheaper, and most importantly, better for Petaluma?
iced a
buil
local, seasoned
buil
Architect to work with us on a proposed addition to our home,
We applied -fora
ding permit, and waited,, Received our plan comments one -month
after they were written (perhaps t ecause the contract Planner was no longer working) and
nahadtwo instances where staff "overreachedcu Trent codes.
"
We received:
8 pages of comments. from building department sub (some truly nit -picky)
Initialrequest from Plaluilng for us to do a Historic Resource evaluation (even though we
are not in the Historic District): This would have cost an estimated $2,-400- $3 ,400 and
an extended timeline to get a report done. Again after much time and effort and research
on my pail, and outreach om the Department Head was a compromise resolved. I
would have preferred a discussion upfront vs a formal declaration in writing,.
Since the Fire department box was not checked, our Architect followed up with the
Department: We were being required to install fire sprl*nklers'even though our remodel,
met current code and was not over 50%. This required again, both time and a letter on
my part and our Architect.
Here is a case study costs of a 560 square foot addition to existing home,,
$16,490 Architect, Structural, Title 24 sub & Cal Green fees
$5,481 ** Additional time for revising drawings, follow up & meetings
$5,550.34 Pelmit fees
$1,955.76 _School impact flee..
Total $29,477
1
i
Input Summary 1 -Page 169 of. 191
11
Attachment 2
It is this ** additional cost that concerns -me* While some follow'up would be typical., we
were required to do a considerable amount of follow up, some not justified; and this
figure.does not include any of my time.
While I was relieved to find out the permit cost is based on flat fees and percentages, and
I could understand the cost brealcdown, I do wonder who is paying for all thi"s'extra time
on the City's end?
Thank you for your attention and consideration.
Tammara Noiman
501 Keller Street
Petaluma, CA
707 -v766 -o7258
Input Summary 1 -gage 170 of 191
EM
rl
u
El
c
LA
f
11
m
f
1p m ry 1 '11 - of 1 1
ZON
c
LA
f
11
m
f
1p m ry 1 '11 - of 1 1
Petaluma City Goals Survey
Q4 What would you
CLIV ri M Ni
like to see in Petaluma that is not here now?.
C
Answered: 567
•
EME
RESPONSES
1 Access over Sonoma mountain to Jack London Park.
2 More police More police and More police
Skipped: 92
4
3 More indoor recreational courts for volleyball, basketball and indoor soccer
4 No potholes
DATE
4/29/2019 5:23 PM
4/29/2019 120457 PM
5 More affordable housing. Recognition of Paula Lane Action Network as a nonprofit organization, 4/21/2019 9:49 AM
putting Petaluma on the map in California, in conservation
6
affordable housing
4/13/2019
11:20 PM
7
more support for first responders.
4/13/2019
10:43 PM
8
1. Create a new Police Department building
that is appropriate to the needs of the staff. We have
4/12/2019
............................
10:38 AM
people sharing small offices and people literally working in closets. 2. A Family Justice Center & -
Youth homeless outreach building similar to
Social Advocates for youth in Santa Rosa
9
Note public safety to help combat homeless
problem
4/11/2019
9:25 PM
10
DEFINTELY NOT- BATHTUB ART,. Less pot
.. .... .....
IF in public service
holes, Rainier overpass,
4/11/2019
2;40 PM
employees, preservation of historical landmarks, decrease in homeless related issues, decrease
Adequately staffed city departments with appropriate resources needed to maintain city 4/11/2019 2:04 PM
infrastructure and services.
12 Rainier Overcrossing 4/11/2019 2:04 P:M
... ... .. .... ... .
..... .... . ...
13 Costco 4/10/2019 6:36 PM'
14 More retail to.support the city financially. 4/10/2019 9:38 AM
....
15 Costco 4/10/2019 9:26 AM
..........
16 More police presence 4/10/2019 6:24 AM
. ... . . ... ......
17 Petaluma feels like a great downtown for tourists surrounded by a so-so city for the people who 4/7/2019.8:56 PM
actually live here. Outside of the immediate downtown it is not pedestrian friendly. City services
are lacking. City staff isnot responsive. Traffic and parking enforcement outside of the downtown
is nonexistent. And recent developments like the East Washington St Target development are a
throwback to an era i thought we'd moved past --parking lots and big box stores. I am afraid for the
future of the Fairgrounds if that's what the City thinks is progressive, good planning.
18 Morep olice and affordable housing 4/7/2019 6:47 PM9
19 Many more sports facilities for our youth and families. AND cleaninour downtown and other 4/7/2019 5;57 PM
public spaces. This town is filthy!
20 Bike paths 4/6/2019 7:31 PM
21 Trestle tomb down and replaced with walkway along the riverriver.4/612019 12:10 PM
.. . ... ......
22 Maintenance of established parks & recreation areas. Unequal infill of high-density housing on 4/6/2019 11:40 AM
east side.
23 More homes so others can enjoy the beauty we have. Most people here today came from 4/6/2019 11:18 AM
elsewhere if we had quit building like cadar farms those people wouldn't be here.quit thinking
development is evevil.Your here now because of It., It's actually. part of life growth
24 More affordable housing, more emphasis on diversity and inclusionin Petaluma schools, a living 4/6/2019 9:11 AM
wage, updated zoning and planning laws.
25 More work force housing. Finally get three lanes on Highway 101. 4/5/2019 11:45 PM
1
120
Input Summary 1
- Page 172 of 191
G
PetalumaCity Goals Survey. . . . .. . ..................... ...... ......... .... ....... .......................... ... .. ........................ ....... . ........ .... . . .
26 More walkabiltiy-- more pedestrian friendly sidewalks and thorou9'hfares, including from the 4/5/2019 9:29 PM
Westside to eastside. More parks, more street plantings, more art-- eclectic art, fountains-*-* places
pf repose, benches, parklets. I love our downtown district,. but I do not like that it is all about
commercial viability and development. More adherence to the General Plan, more concern for the
overall environment, the overall general health of the environment. I would also like to see
Petaluma get rid of M.-Group. It is not a long term solution to our financial problems. Tourists will
come to Petaluma-- we are on the map, we do not need to kowtow to the Chamber of Commerce
of the past; we need new thinking in our Chamber. No kowtwing to the past., Preserve the old
architecture, yes, but let's not (ideologically) suspend Petaluma in amber. We can become a
dynamic town that embraces change and innovation. A town that says no to big gas and out of
2�/ 20
nPut Summary 1 -Page 173 of 191
0
I
Petaluma City Goals Survey
twkum'ubo =-4n1n<-"QR&TJ
51
no more growth better traffic flow at washington/lakeville
4/4/2019
3:00 PM
52
I can't think of anything.
4/4/2019
2:09 PM
53
nothing comes to mind
4/4/2019
14-56
PM
54
Perhaps more programs for young adults, jobs, activities etc.
4/4/2019
12:54
PM
55
smooth roads less traffic better safety
4/4/2019
12;k54
PM
56
.......... ...........
The Rainier east -west connector. Streets that are not rated the worst in Sonoma County by the
4/4/2019
10:47
AM
MTC. Traffic signal timing that reflects real-world traffic flow and facilitates safer and more efficient
intersections.
57
My biggest fear, now as a mother of 2, ig how dangerous some parts of town have become.
4/4/2019
10:34
AM
Between transients and people from out of town, I feel like being out past 8 pm is dangerous.. With
that being said, I do know how hard our police department works. I know most people wouldn't
agree with this, but I feel like we need cameras downtown and in'the shopping centers. I .:know
parts of SF are doing it. I also know that it obscenely expensive, but the police department can
only do so much. Maybe with video. surveillance, it'll help deter crime.
58 More supportive services and age -friendly supportive environment for
trails and more trees along streets and in parks
older adults, more walking 4/4/2019 10:11. AM
59
....... ....... ...... . . .... . ....... .. . .. . .. . ...... . .. . . .
Remove the empty space in the center of Petaluma Blvd. and widen the sidewalks.
4/4/2019
8:42 AM
60
. . ... .. .. . .... ... . . ......... . .. . .... . .. ... .. ...... . . . . ...... .
Trees?
........ .... .. .
4/4/2019
12:27 AM.
. . ....... ..... . ......... . ...... . . . . ... .. ......... . .... .. . . .... . ... .. .. ..... .... .. .... . . ... .. .
.........._......._....
62 Well -paved roads 4/3/2019 11:18 PM
63 More affordable restaurants that aren't fast food. 4/3/2019 8:37 PM
... .. ............... .. .... . .....
64 Expand beyond boutique stores and Kohls, Target, Ross and include Macy's or Emporium type 4/3/2019 6:36 PM
store.. Currently you have'to go to Terra Linda, Corte Madera or Santa Rosa to shop for nice
clothing. Attract Biotech or Google, higher tech type jobs. Google looked at Marin, but ended up in
the City. Perhaps we don't want high paying 1"obsin Sonoma County, or can't attract high paying
jobs. We are not that far fromthe City. Find ways to attract younger people both single and married
by making Petaluma affordable.
65 Coordination of traffic, mandatory affordable housing requirements for new construction, better 4/3/2019 5:22 PM
techniques for repairing roads
66 Some type of small business hub for the East side of town. The East side has been given over to 4/3/2019 5:06 PM
large shopping centers, housing and sports fields. There is no attention to creating a shopping'
environment that caters to small shops and businesses on this side of town. Also, it would be nice
to have a (non high end) grocery store located somewhere more central to West Petaluma. A lot of
theseissues would help relieve crosstown traffic congestion.
67 Boats parked along the riverfront again. 4/3/2019 4:04 PM
68 Ongoing community forum for engaging community members with their city govt & each other. 4/3/2019 2:17 PM
69 Lower cost gas 4/3/2019 1:49 PM
70 Stop lights on Washington near Keller 4/3/2019 1:38 PM
71 The effort to step out of what is "normal practice" when it comes to City leadership. There needs to 4/3/2019 1:23 PM
be a change of culture and an effort to focus on improving city management so that the City can
operate more efficiently. I'm excited to see where our new city manager takes us.
72 An event/conference center in the Fairgroundsropperty in place of the racetrack with multi -story 4/3/2019 12:59 PM
hotel/townhomes and a smaller fairground facility.
............ . ....... ... ....... ...... ...
73 more tree lined streets repaired and improved streets 4/3/2019 12:53 PM
74 A third cross-town connector, more money for the PPD, and "Fine Balance" on Water Street! 4/3/2019 11 :20 AM
75.Hover cars 4/3/2019 11:13 AM
76 more affordable housing 4/3/2019 10:52 AM
77, More development around the train stations 4/3/2019 9:43 AM
3/20
Input Summary 1
- Page 174 of 191
4
Petaluma City Goals Survey _Mk
a_r_it: dn W
Y � AT `14-
management, staff and legal staff should be addressed. ButIt won't. The manager before Ms..
Flynn created a terrible closed & disconnected process. The elected officials care about their
"groups" and blocks of voters. That's all. There is no courage. There ibs no real service to the
community. The structure &process are very weak. They will-cover for each other, at all costs and
4/20
n gut Summary 1
- Page 175 of 191
Ll
Petaluma City Goals Survey
106 more affordable housing; more drug and alcohol education in the schools - every year from 5th 3/31/2019 11:47 PM
grade through high school
107 Housing at the train station
108 Truly affordable housing, a plan for creating safe and accessible communities for the homeless,
and ridding our city of toxic pesticides (including regulating what homeowners can spray on their
0
3/31/2019 11 :27 PM
3/31/2019 8:42 PM
109 .Our streets paved. The main streets like Sonoma Mountain parkway towards Washington and 3/31/2019 8:37 PM
Corona reoaved. I'd also like more patrol on the East side during school hours.
111 A city government with a balanced view that represents and values ALL viewpoints...not joust
3!30/2019 9:40 AM
5/20
R.
Input Summary 1 - Page 176 of 191
A
6
Petaluma City Goals Survey
142 Bring in a Macy's or similar higher -end department store. Too many mom and pop businesses 3/28/2019 9:26 PM
investments made there and the costs to' restore just go up. And it's ugly, sad, and gives a poor
impression of the city. A city arborist and enforceable standards of care for our shopping/business
areas would be creat. too. More biking trails would also be welcome - aettina across and around
6/20
4
Input Summary 1 - Page 177 of 191
0
F
Petaluma City Goals Survey
164 Protected bike lanes,, Commitment to carbon neutral economy from government and industry. For 3/27/2019 12:01 PM
the leaders and the citizens to act like climate change is a grave problem. No cops with guns in
our schools.
165 More outside events, Flea markets, farmers markets with better advertising to them and dredge 3/27/2019 11:41 AM
170
171
172
No more building 3/27/2019 6:32 AM
More engagement with low-income families. We are becoming a place for wealthy, hip, millenials. 3/27/2019 5:30 AM
More focus on public transport - get people out of their cars.
173 Traffic relief. Cross town connector. River dredging,, Better parking and access to stores. Pavec
streets. Politicians who actually care about Petaluma instead of national "progressive" ideas.
174 More boy and girls clubs, YMCA programsfor kids and adults. Rooms through the YMCA City o
Petaluma tohave more say when it comes to building or rehabbing housing. A tenantadvisory
Rna rrl
3/27/201 9 1 2:23 AM
f 3/27/2019 12:23 AM
f
7/20 ISummary 1 -Page 178 of 191
Petaluma City Goals Survey
`+ n4a-iv.-1
k F�l
downtown,, That stretch of D street is a great opportunity to show off the town, but it's
underdeveloped and ugly. If I were visiting the town, I would not feel safe walking that stretch
8120
n)ut Summary 1
- Page 179 of 191
4
0
Petaluma City Goals Survey
226 Along-term vision for what will make Petaluma amore livable city. Including better planning of 3/26/2019 10:54 AM-
projects
(housing, commercial space, parking, public art, parks, etc.) to make Petaluma more
cohesive for both our residents, as well as visitors. More focus on In -fill oroiects (ie, oarkinal that
236
Addressing infrastructure. ( have lived here my whole life and nothing about the infrastructure has 3/26/2019 9:42 AM
changed yet the population and building continues to rise.
238 More parking spots required for apartments. At least two -spaces per unit or more depending on 3/26/2019 9:17 AM
11
9/20
Input Summary 1
-_Page 180 of 191
A
W
Petaluma. City Goals Survey
Ot
Ip I F,
my Wd
260 A plan for growth.. 3/26/2019 6:31 AM
262 Affordable housing for the middle class. 3/26/2019 5:16 AM
environment challenges.
fronts/restaurants, sports_ facility for youth with world class amenities, investment in beautifying
public schools, especially the. high schools, the empty lots all around downtown. either landscaped
hni icinn mnrP narkinn fnr train qtatinn to Pnr:ntiranP SMART commutin❑
10/20
Input Summary 1
- Page 181 of 191
r j-
10/20
-
3
Petaluma City Goals Survey
EP
��' � 11hi V4 rXIA
can be spent on it, but the management must come from the city government to ensure
accessibility for aIL
293 more diversity 3/25/2019 84:46 PM.
294 More open park land for hiking such as Sonoma Mountain made into a state park since it would be 3/25/2019 81:35 PM
easily accessible from Petaluma, Mill Valley has Mt. Tam and I would like something similar here,
295 Petaluma needs to be more open to businesses that generate additional revenue. Petaluma 3/25/2019 8:35 PM
outlets are in need of a different owner or Simon Outlet owner needs a good kick in the ass. Buses
no longer bring those traveling to the casino to shop. They*do not maintain the shop interiors,
repairs take months to fix. There are no eateries at the outlets. Not even places for coffee. How
pathetic is that. Eateries alone generate additional revenue and attracts people to take longer to
shop, have a snack or light meal and continue shopping. The Chamber wiukd benefit having a
kiosk there especially on the weekend promoting all the additional things to see and do in
Downtown Petaluma. Also there should beano policy rule to bring in second hand shops just to fill
empty store fronts. This is a rich and diverse area generating weekend tourism. People love to
shop. Petaluma is full of professionals at all levels and everyday working class people that need
good shops that they can buy at and shops who are the outlet mall needs to reflect shops who are
also supported by the community. I am a cottage business working out of my home, licensed by
the city. The majority of us small business owners do very well, many have small store fronts,
many if us provide our wares to other businesses, self promote, and participate in local festivals.
Our network expands throughout the Bay Area and the Internet. The Chamber needs to' be more
proactive in getting to know the cottage crafters, work to promote these businesses that tourist.
love to buy from. That is, tourists love to take away anything "Petaluma". Why not have a
mercantile at the art center with vendors that could sell their wares on the weekends. Or provide a
storefront for this during the holiday season and it could be open Friday through Sundays. Vendors
can pay a fee to support the rent. Many alternatives are available to greatly benefit this community!
..... ... . .
296 Priorityin Infrastructure. 3/25/2019 8:33 PM
297 I don't want to see a gas station across the street from an primary school. 3/25/2019 8-0,32 PM
298 Focus on the waterfront. 3/25/2019 8:31 PM
......... ..
299 Another bridge across Petaluma river connecting west side to east side to alleviate increasing 3/25/2019 8:30 PM
traffic.
300 More things for kids to do. Bet -ter, more engaging parks. Activities for teens that aren't the drug and 3/25/2019 81F28 PM
drama -ridden Phoenix.
301 More bike paths 3/25/2019 8:27 PM
302 better recreation programs 3/25/2019 8:22 PM
303 Better residential street lighting (and safer), better lit intersections, fixed potholes 3/25/2019 8-:21 PM
304 I love the town and community as it is! Keeping the open space, historical structures, connection to 3/25/2019 8+:18 PM
organic and sustainable agriculture, and homes of modest size is a huge priority.
.... ... .. . .. . .. . ..... . ...... ..... . .. . .
305 Dedicated effort to combat climate change. 3/25/2019 $:0$ PM
306 Outdoor spaces! Parks with gardens, views, benches,etc 3/25/2019 8:07 PM
307 A permanent indoor farmers market 3/25/20.19 8:07 PM
308 No more shopping malls 3/25/2019 8:06 PM
309 Stop signs where most 4 ways have them but random 4ways don't. Lights or crosswalks where 3/25/2019 8:03 PM
people often cross...i and 5th needs a crosswalk...use of cameras for red light runners
310 A city council that is concerned with its citizens' needs -better roads, more concern on the look of 3/25/2019 8:03 PM
new buildings, and good pay for police and fire personnel
..... .
. .
....
311 More open space hiking, walking, and biking trails! Not just trails connecting east and west sides of 3/25/2019 7-:52 PM
town, but also open space trails. More regional and city parks to explore. Petaluma is gorgeous,
and yet so many people don't see it from the inside of their cars! Or for those of us that do see it
from inside our cars, we need something to pull us out. Give us trails! Why should I have to drive
down to Marin County to hike around? It's beautiful here',
� �
/20 Input Summary 1 -'age 182 of 191
Petaluma City Goals Survey
gn
to, ANA
N A mci "MUF41
............ . ........
312 Corona Smart Train- Station. More bike trails, 3/25/2019 7:51 PM
313 Riverfront walking path something like in Monterey. 3/25/2019 7:50 PM
.. .. .. .. .... ... .. ....... . ................... ........... .... ..... ... . .............. ....... ... .......... ... .. ... . ..............
321 Our City Council needs to connect with the real world. My impression is that many think we should 3/25/2019 7:31 PM
be a core city where people live downtown and don't need to drive -not at all realistic.
......... .. .............................. ................. ..... .......... .... ............................................................. ........ ........... .. ..... .. ': .......... :...: .......... . ................ .. ...... ...... ......... . .. ........... ......... ................. ........................................ ......... : .......................... . .......... .. : .......................... .............. . ............ ..... . ...... .. ... .. ... ......... .... .. ...... . . ... .... ... ...... . . .... ..... .. . ..... ... ...... ... . . .... .. . I . .. ..... .... .. . ... . . ... ..... ... . I . .. .. ..... . .... . I ........................... . ........ .... .. .......... .
322 Low income housing, truly affordable, for families and individuals who work in nearby agriculture 3/25/2019 7:25 PM
and in businesses in town.
............ ..................... ..... . . . ......... .... . ...... ............ ..... ...................... .................................................................................... ......... .. .................. ... ............................ .. ... ............... .............. . ...... ........................... o
325 More overpasses to get from one side of town to the ther... at least one! 3/25/2019 7:14 PM
............. ................ .......... ...... ... . .. .... ........ . ...... .. I ...................................... . .... ............. .............. .............................................. ................................ ... ....... ... ... . ... .. ... .. ... . .. .............. ... . .. . . ...................................... .... ........ ........ ........ ............. .............................. .................... .... ... ............... . .... ......... ................ ................. .................... .. ........ ........ ..... ...... ... ................................... ............................. ..................... ........... .......................................... ....................................... ...
326 Public celebration of LGBTQIA Pride 3/25/2019 7:14 PM
... ...... ............... ........ . ..... . . ....... . ............... ............ .... . ...... ..... . . . . . ... ... .. .. .. . I ............. .............................. .... ........ .. ........................ ......
327 More p
open s ace.. 3/25/2019 7:13 PM
328
mixed use density 3/25/2019 7006 PM
....... ........ .............. ........... ... ................... .. . .. . . . .. . . . ........ . .... .......... . ..... . .. ... . ........ ......... : .. . . . ....... .............. . .............. .......... .................. . ........................................................................ .............. .......... ......... .. : ... ... : ..... ........ ....................... ....... ... I .................................... ............................ ................ . .... ......... . ... .. .......... ....... ......... ......... .... . ...
330 1 would like to see the building (Arts?) at the SMART stop downtown utilized as a space more like 3/25/2019 7:04 PM
the ferry building in SF. Where you can sit &relax, eat -maybe cafe style, meet up with folks
coming or aoina. use a restroom, etc,.
12 1 20 Input Summary 1 -Page 183 of 191
Petaluma City Goals Survey S IAey.
346 A Pride Proclornation (Santa Rosa has one Stepping up when hate crimes impact our 3/25/2019 6: 17 PM
community. Resources for our Latinx community. More cultural events.
347 Support for a transition to a plant based food economy for reasons of justice, non violence, climate 3/25/2019 6:14 PM
change, environmental racism and public health, to name a few,,
348 Easier access to the west side of town 3/25/2019 6:14 PM
349 Better use of turning basin/river 3/25/2019 6:13 PM
350 Tax revenue to support city. services 3/25/2019 6:12 PM
351 Public indoor swimming pool-, Tree -lined sidewalks (not enough right now, esp in heavy -foot -traffic 3/25/2019 6:11 PM
areas such as E. Washington); More bike lanes everywhere
352 Central community park -like area for evening farmers market or concerts, I feel like the street 3/25/2019 6:11 PM
where the current evening farmers market takes place is not inviting (see Davis for an example).
Or a gorgeous waterfront green for concerts and events like Napa has. Our downtown park doesn't
feel safe/clean.
353 Lynch Creek Trail as a signature project (single surface, well maintained, ADA compliant east to 3/25/2019 6:09 PM
13/20 Input Summary 1 -Page 184 of 191
CJ
W
Petaluma City Goals Survey
379 More affordable housing.
3/25/2019 49#39 PM
380 Walgreen _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 3/25/2019 4:37 PM
.. .. . .. ... . ... . ........ ....... .... ......... ...... .... ........ . ........................ . . .... .......... ....... ....................... I ...... ... I ....... .... ......... . ... .. .... . ..... . . ...... ... .
. .. ..... .. ...... ........... ... ......... .. . ............ ........ .. ...................... .. ... . . . ......... . .. . .. .... .... . I . ....... ..... ..... ............ .... . .. ............. I .....................................................................
........ I ... ............................................. .. ... . ....
381 An affordable grocery store with good, organic produce, Eike Sprouts unfortunately 3/25/2019 4:36 PM
egularly has a lot of expired products..
............. ......... .... ........ ................ ............ ...... .... ..... . .... ................ ....... .............................. ................................. .................. ...... ......
3/25/2019 4:36 PM
14/20
Input Summary 1 -'age 185 of 191
01,
Petaluma City Goals Survey
407 A balanced budget (fill police vacancies and increase pay to market rate to stop exodus) complete 3/25/2019 11:17 AM-
Rainer,
city council steps up and makes tough decisions earlier (tubs, Safeway gas )
.......... ..
408 More transportation alternates -class 1 trails; bike boulevards, EV chargers, busses, trolleys., More 3/25/2019 10:58 AM
renewable energy'.
El
15/20 Input Summary 1 -Page 186 of 191
0
Petaluma City Goals Survey
437 Costco OliverI s market or community market, bike and walking paths as crosstown connectors,, low 3/24/2019 8:45 PM
income housing,. comprehensive public transportation
438 Better plans for"managing the pressure to grow. All the planning I've seen is for.Petaluma to 3/24/2019 8:39 PM
eventually become a continuum with Rohnert Park and Santa Rosa, the same that has- happened
in the south bay. That makes me sad. I've never heard anyone they're headed to Freemont or
Santa Clara for a relaxing weekend.
It
celebration of the cultures that are here. Also, a 'noise retaining wail" at the East Washington SB
exit where homes were removed. Lots of noise..
q.
the character of downtown,.
448 Better sidewalks and water drainage
3/24/2019 2:34 PM
16/20
Input Summary 1
- Page 187 of 191
k
Petaluma City Goals Survey'
f
17/20
nput Summary 1 -Page 188 of 191
Petaluma City Goals Survey
tilt &I' V§
'IL a JJR 12M
18 / 20
Input Summary 1 -Page 189 of 191
IF
Petaluma City Goals Survey S -LAW- *ekq
533 We really need our basic infrastructure fixed before we do another thing. This is neither a 3/22/2019 10:21 PM
progressive nor GOP matter -it's what a city council and management is primarily charged with
doing. Do not get distracted..
.... . .....
534 More places to shop! 3/22/2019 10:07 PM
535 Bike and walking paths 3/22/2019 9:21 PM
536 turning basin and waterfront fixed as well as trestle 3/22/2019 9:10 P M
. ..............
537 Indoor shopping mall 3/22/201 9 9-4,03 PM
.. ............. .. ... .... . . .. ....... .. .. . ... ... . . ........
538 Areal dose of reality 3/22/2019 9,0103 PM
............... ................................
539 More businesses and events geared toward families with young children. A splash pad], More 3/22/2019 9:02 PM
leadership and representation by people of color and LGBTQ people.
............ ... ... .........
543 Pedestrian -minded communityinfrastructure. Cycling paths that are safe. Community engagement 3/22/2019 8:23 PM
hubs
that mix local food, arts and workshops.
Focus on our river access.
The face that the turning
basin
is rung with the backsides of corporate
buildings is a travesty. We
should have places to sit
by the river and make it a central part of our experience., The water st area should be outdoor
19/20
11
Input Summary 1
ON Page 190 of 191
i
seating not parking. We would do a lot to improve access to and connection with our river.
544
....................
New city infrastructure, aevent center, stadium, cross town connectors
3/22/2019
8:00
PM
545
.........
An electronics and computer store like Fry's or Best Buy; Boudin Bakery; Better signs and
3/22/2019
7;58
PM
pavement markings on the bike /walking trailsin town, and feeling safe to'use them; smooth
pavement on our roads.
546
. . .. ...... .
Rainer and Caulfield connectors, an event center, a public safety sales tax measure
.......... . .... ... ....... .
3/22/2019
7:57
PM
547
. . ......... . . ... ... ... . .. .
More green actions
..... .. . ...............
3/22/2019
7:53
PM
548
Smooth streets, specifically Sonoma Mountain Parkway, Maria Drive and McDowell Blvd, More
3/22/2019
7:40
PM
bike lanes. More affordable housing. My kids will never be able to afford to live here.
549
More housing and more off Ramps from the freeway
3/22/2019
7:34
PM
550
Electronics store, Costco, All turf playing fields
3/22/2019
7:04
PM
551
Road/ transportation infrastructure before more growth begins_
3/22/2019
7:02
PM
552
Convention center
3/2'2/2019
7:01
PM
553
Only affordable housing built.. Nothing else.
3/22/2019
6:51
PM
554
The train trestle downtown rebuilt and the river dredged
3/22/2019
6:36
PM
... . .... ........... ..............
555
...... . . . . ....... ........ . ... . . . .. . ......
a ban on glyphosate
3/22/2019
6;35
PM.
556
Clear lines painted on all streets- There are roads that need clear lines.
3/22/2019
6:32
PM
... .. . .. . ..... ........ . ............. . . ... ............
557
... ... ............ .
More diversity
3/22/2019
6:32
PM
........ . ................... .....
558
... . . ....
bridges at Caulfield and Rainier
3/22/2019
6:21
PM
559
Better bike and walking paths between east -and west
3/22/2019
6:19
PM
560
River.11
3/22/2019
6:05
PM
561
I would like to see the skyline downtown without bathtubs. NO BATHTUBS downtown!!!!!!!
3/22/2019
5:52
PM
562
N/A
3/22/2019
5;47
PM
563
.. ...
More effort to reduce noise pollution (vehicles don't ever need to exceed 70 Dbs) More effort by
.. ....
3/22/2019
5-1:46
....... .. .
PM
the city to get funds from county/state/feds for roads A city govt that designs programs/make laws
based on cost/benefit and not because it feels good - then readdress all programs to justify
cost/benefit annually or bi-annually Increase tourism by advertising to all of California (esp
NorCal)., We have too many amazing assets that aren't being exploited.
19/20
11
Input Summary 1
ON Page 190 of 191
i
Petaluma City Goals Survey
564
.... .. ......... ........ ..
dredging Petaluma river
3/22/2019
5:40
PM
565
River access (dredging) and Average streets. Both are infrastructure in decline that will have a
3/22/2019
5:36
PM
very bad long term effect.
566
Abetter local transportation system connected to Smart Train. Parking is atrocious .Also more
affordable housing so service people do not have to move out of their city.
3/22/2019
5:31
PM
567
Rainier Overcrossing
3/22/2019
5:25
PM
i
ti
k
n
F
20/20 nPut Summary' -Page
191 of 191
2
Attac,hment
SIN
M-0 la
A
I N T
S'N
M
0
13
x
N u:
SIN
M-0 la
A
I N T
S'N
M
0
13
F
Z
RE%
0
N;, w4"En
lk iff I N t2
13
j4
4N A
f
Rip%
V.W:i2I.
..dI
UL AMML
I
ff
ff cl
.3ur u IL
I s '11111 7 y
a w Wr In r IL M goft P�
IL I a IL I Ar IL
%01 () r k S ) E Y'w'%F
A cit t h *-N t A f L) I V
y 0001
13
00% to"% a AON%L soft soft Awft r-%
PnI It I
ze
Uu r Eir lvi rut Imic-m;i i a d y
016% soft
IL N OWN
Im a
jr A Iff ccl h lkv-
Ul 1 7 1 ti
el"% KIM OMN lk &
lk I
U IL 9
41 Eu'ulff...v:MlU PFUSPL, riot..
I
0
L w
50 P [old Placc:.s thcoNit
a
m
ri
ra
owft 0%
g 4
I jpft JOEW
Input olullillical, 2 Pd., yt 2 (Ulf 10"5
Kul
ylm
X49
N;, w4"En
lk iff I N t2
13
j4
4N A
f
Rip%
V.W:i2I.
..dI
UL AMML
I
ff
ff cl
.3ur u IL
I s '11111 7 y
a w Wr In r IL M goft P�
IL I a IL I Ar IL
%01 () r k S ) E Y'w'%F
A cit t h *-N t A f L) I V
y 0001
13
00% to"% a AON%L soft soft Awft r-%
PnI It I
ze
Uu r Eir lvi rut Imic-m;i i a d y
016% soft
IL N OWN
Im a
jr A Iff ccl h lkv-
Ul 1 7 1 ti
el"% KIM OMN lk &
lk I
U IL 9
41 Eu'ulff...v:MlU PFUSPL, riot..
I
0
L w
50 P [old Placc:.s thcoNit
a
m
ri
ra
owft 0%
g 4
I jpft JOEW
Input olullillical, 2 Pd., yt 2 (Ulf 10"5
-`77P
Ilk I',
py
aM
nA iiLO
RY
Ik
n
b{ 1
O—T7'
I
lZ
-`77P
Ilk I',
py
aM
nA iiLO
PA
III
II
11
V:zNv,rn
a�ve.
oa
11
1.
C M
]I cl urd t
U- r v R ( z0ft J� e 0 dvft
v
amftk !Ljft Asm% pn& #e" V%O-% I jAft,
d1ld L'Ul I III I It, Itsm
IL 9 JOWN ir" ddhOkIII,
a' --w
ff 'a
u r v
El
cIL a
IL a
W N
11L IN
Input Summary 2 -Page 3 of 185
Ll
RY
Ik
n
b{ 1
I
lZ
PA
III
II
11
V:zNv,rn
a�ve.
oa
11
1.
C M
]I cl urd t
U- r v R ( z0ft J� e 0 dvft
v
amftk !Ljft Asm% pn& #e" V%O-% I jAft,
d1ld L'Ul I III I It, Itsm
IL 9 JOWN ir" ddhOkIII,
a' --w
ff 'a
u r v
El
cIL a
IL a
W N
11L IN
Input Summary 2 -Page 3 of 185
Ll
El
1:
JIM!W
11
al
ri
of
II
d
IIY
tl
xm
Yrti'
II!
11
pm
1111i"IIW
'IY I"%
II
d
IIY
tl
xm
Yrti'
II!
pm
km
aaro
1. DXAI
III
6, 1
IN 011
x", k
P7�: f
Resonates f::a Somewhat Resonates
I
a
ru g"r it -Zk!
U
11
J'
O
:1
M
9
Input QuMi I ldry Z 4 v
u
[a
M
Yrti'
II!
1111i"IIW
'IY I"%
116
hew
Resonates f::a Somewhat Resonates
I
a
ru g"r it -Zk!
U
11
J'
O
:1
M
9
Input QuMi I ldry Z 4 v
u
[a
M
11
""k M—
iq
41
1, �Y
v-1
Cw
113
U emu
K4
.��`M LJ k�: z.d
mil
ri
c
Ali
[ 1put Z:)Ummc,,lry 5 of 181
117,
F
71IIN
mil
ri
c
Ali
[ 1put Z:)Ummc,,lry 5 of 181
In
f
F
Q4,:4/Q45 - Ensure a fiscally and organizat*
onally sustaina:ble City organization thatI's
innovative, efficient, provides valued services promPtly and prote,ssionallY/en a es the
community, and proactively tunds, designs, installs and maintains City infrastructure that is
safe, fu nctional, and sustainable and serves the needs ofour[ residents.
;.iJ';tr A, li,1U-4
Q417,,'Wor:Kp:1an Items:
1. Develop a fiscal sustainability plan with the community that balance
�iam 9 1 a
._ '!"
Mff� to 'AT& "1
effectiveness of the.City.
2. Review and update the City's
DevelaP�ment Impact Flees.
1!
3. Improve the responsiveness and efficacy ot the City to its residents
the City Charter.
V AN
by, examining potential changes and updates to
4. Leverage local, regional, and state programs and resources to maximize city revenues,,
5. Ensure a diverse City government workforce through recruitment, internships,M U Itl
-platform and multilingual j
ob
annuuncernenLs.
loft Ilips
# iG
f
staff and the community, and celebrating staff successes.
8. Host staff trainings incompliance with 'federal / state regulations in
` harassmentwerlIneSjc3,,
satety
-Ara
9. Establish
new
FY 19-120 & 20-21 Draft Goals
Page 11
Input Summary 2 -Page 6 of 185
c
0
3
4
m
Aft
LO (10
Nt NWOWW
0)
1
w
z
0
%aQ
cy)
0
W
Cil
M
C4
LLI
ces
LO
N
U)
CY)
TMI,
m
A'
Attachment
09
rm% up"
I*p-,ut 6,ummary z Fage I of 185
13
0
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
Q45 What do you
ii.< -e about this goal?
Answered.: 73
Or, what'are we. missing?.
Skipped: 202
-6
1
2
3
2
RESPONSES
0
Sounds like HR - an area I don't often dead with.
The need to increase diversity in the City government workforce with outreach.
like the goad of efficient, innovative, responsive, and value; I support proactive infrastructure
considerations and
community engagement.
5 reasonable,,
6 Item 1 -Too bad the City has a history of doing the exact opposite
has the highest -impact fees around.
t
r
�lrl�
6/14/2019
7:09
PM
6/14/2019
6:35
PM
6/14/2019
2:32
PM
6/13/2019
6:16
PM
6/13/2019
3:17
P.M
.Item 2 -Seems that the City 6/11/2019
8:59
PM
can cite numerous businesses that have left town because of
he impact fees were too high for them to expand,, Item 6 - This is a very important goa
f,a.sl
ecently wanted to restore the lower portion of a (previous) URM brick building with marble only to
be told by a recently'graduated planner that what t wanted to do was incorrect - even though
portions of the original marble remained. I have done this on many similar era buildings before in
my 60 year history of building restorations, and -what I was instructed to do was 20 years out of
context. She also wanted to know when the "brick facade" was installed on this solid brick building.
7 Are we looking at other small cities that are more successful than us, at promoting these'goals? 6/7/2019 80,,22 AM
8 Managers need to lead by example! They set the tone. If they are respectful in their interactions, .6/6/2019 6:21 PM
their employees will see thatis the expectation.
. .............
9 They make sense 6/6/2019 6:04 P M
10 Some of these items seem so commonsense-- do we really need an official "item" to make these 6/6/2019 2:14 PM
happen?
11 These are all good, but the city needs to push Sacramento to fix Prop. 13 so that commercial 6/6/2019 1:10 PM
properties pay their fair share of taxes, which they have shirked for 40 years now. Is there a local
version of a commercial property tax that can be implemented? We need it!
12 The goal covers a broad range of city needs, some of which can be facilitated by a helpful county ..6/6/2019 11:51 AM
system
13 goal is okay.. .6/5/2019 8.36 PM
14 Fiscal sustainability should be the #1 Goal right now. 6 /5/2019 3:30 PM
15 Objective 1 should be The Goal. As written, it's numbingly long-winded., 6/4/2019 9:03 PM
.......... . . . . .
16 A well functioning city goverment makes all the difference to its citizens! 6/4/2019 12:53 AM
17 I would like the city to have an in houseanninplg
d staff-, 6/3/2019 7:29 PM
18 serving needs of community 6/3/2019 4:52 PM
19 2 reduce the fees! The rest is either obvious or BS 6/3/20-19 11:53 AM
20 City needs long term funding. A sales tax is a must now,, I dont want to live in a bankrupt city. And I 6/3/2019 6:24 AM
want my streets and parks maintained and police and ambulances to show up within minutes of
calling. The rest of the stuff is city workflow and not relevant.
21 Cut salaries anpensions. 6/1/2019 10:44 AM
22 I like everything listed � 5/31/2019 7:01 PM
. . . . ...... ....
23 Collaborate with the school districts, who' are also underfunded, to6plan for increased revenues. 5/31/2019 12:30 AM
The city and schools overlap on family services; they need to coordinate revenue generation'
accordingly. A children's set-aside fund (like that in SF and Oakland) would serve the town's and
schools' needs,,
24 Nothing, do not raise our taxes for this!!!5/30/2019 5:54 PM
1 /3 Input Summary 2 -Page 8 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
"'moo0 0 -
charge more in fees. Film crews should pay more as they tie up police personnel. There are lots
of fees that should be raised. Just do it. The user should pay more than the taxpayer,,
28 You are missing the cost of pensions and salaries of city employees that are not sustainable., Look 5/28/2019 5:32 PM
at the percentage of general funds that,have gone to employees over the past 25 years and note
the shrinking amount of funds available for services outside of employees. We are beyond being
12
2/3
Input Summary 2 -'age 9 of 185
0
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021.Attachment 3
..... . ... ... .
56 Getting your financial house
in order is great! If you have training issues with employees they 5/17/2019 9:19 AM
should be addressed one way or the other,. We are paying full boat for employee's and we
deserve to receive what we are paying for. That's the managements job,. Maybe the problem is
with the management? The old promoted beyond your abilities situation.
57 This seems overly ambitious to me. When I read minutes of Commission meetings or other 5/17/2019 8** 17 AM
meetings and see the type-o's and low quality of communication in the.written records, I can't
imagine how the City thinks there is staff available to,implement these kinds of goals, with all due
respect.
58 Do something to diversify fire dept . No women !!!! What is going on with the sexual-harassment . 5/16/2019 8:01 PM
lawsuit and subsequent accountability and training
59 Need to elect someone to the city council that has a financial background to help..,,we have no one 5/16/2019 7:42 PM
with that at this time.
60 Ok 5/16/2019 6;49 PM
61 6 and 9 are great 5/16/2019 5:20 PM
62 Again: What are the new extras going to cost the homeowner/taxpayer? 5/16/2019 3:43 PM
63 Pension reform needed 5/16/2019 3:23 PM
64 Sounds great if you actually succeed. 5/16/2019 2:34 PM
65 This is ridiculous: "Develop a fiscal sustainability plan with the community that balances City 5/16/2019 2-:27 PM
services with available revenues and integratespolicies and identifies potential revenue sources
that can ensure long-term financial health and effectiveness of the City." Just say "Develop
realistic annual budgets and stay within the budget Pian". Again, drop the word "sustainable" -
nothing is really sustainable anymore.
..........
66 Is this a plan for social engineering? Can we please hire the best qualified regardless of race, 5/16!2019 1:34 PM
gender, religion, or political view? We are diverse,and are in an area of diversity, at least in my
neighborhood and other neighborhoods around town!
67 yes to-all of the above. I particularly like looking to achieve a diverse city govt. It's not easy, butit 5/16/2019 1;15 PM
should def. be one of our goals.Fiscal responsibility is another laudable and essential goal. 01'm
not exactly sire how we gotinto such dire straits fiscally, but we need to address that moving
forward. The citizens have money, the city should not be as cash poor as it it.
68 We need to consider changing our voting for offices to district elections. I live on the East side and 5/16/2019 1:14 PM
feel like we are not represented!.PAVE McDowell Blvd. If you don't live on the east side you don't
know how crappy this road is to drive every day!!!
69 Sure, "review" fees means increase them... why? Because no one EVER wants any Less of 5/16/2019 11:40 AM
anything. Sustainable? Nope, not unless you make some HARD choices and set some STRONG,
PRACTICAL priorities... NOT THE WISH LIST I SEE HERE.
70 This sounds. good.. 5/16/2019 11:19 AM
71 I don't see General Plan or revisions to'Zoning specifically. 5/16/2019 10:48 AM
72 Focuses on the city and provision of city services,, 5/16/2019 10:37 AM
73 We must be fiscally sustainable! 5/15/2019 3-645 PM
3/3
In)ut Summary 2 -gage 10 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
Q46 What d o you Ikie about this obi ective? Or, what are we missing?
b
b
Answered., 39 Skipped: 236
# RESPONSES DATE
1 May want to consider what the job market will look like in ten years -very different! 6/14/2019 7009'PM
.. .. ..... .. ... . .. . .. .. .. ...... . . . . . ... . .. . .. .. . ...... .... ... ...... .. .. .......... .... . . . ...
2 This is an outstanding ojective. 6/14/2019 2&&32 PM
3 rational 6/13/2019 3:17 PM
......................... ...... .. .... .. . ........ .. . .. .... ..
4 Bring the C.E.R.T. program back. 6/6/2019 6:04 PM
5 I hope we are hiring the best people for the job, regardless of ethnicity. 6/6/2419 2:14 PM
.............. ... .............. ................ ............... ............... ...... ............. ...... ..... .. . ........................ ............... ........... ... ... .
6 Good objective covers a broad range 6/6/2019 11:51 AM do
7 Ojective is ok
kay 6/5/2019 8:36 PM
8 I support it. 6/5/2019 3:30 PM
. ....... ..... .. ...
. ...................................
.....
9 Avoiding bankru tcy is crucial. 6/4/2. .019 12:53 AM
. . ................ ................................................. .................. ............... 1: .... ..... . ... ....
10 maing the city finanicaly fit 6/3/2019 4:52 PM
...... ... ..... .... .. . .. ... . . . . .. .....
11 Cut salaries and pensions. 6/1/2019 10:44 AM
12 I would not change anything listed 5/31/2079 7:01 PM
13 Nothing. 5/30/2079 5:54 PM
..... ... .. ... ........................ ........................................................ . .....
14 I don't know where this goes.:. maybe Item 6. The goals and objectives make NO mention of the 5/30/2019 4:06 PM
Petaluma City Schools. This i's where our citizens begin their lives, and where they first learn
about civic engagement. More workis needed here. I know that Council Members often visit public
1 /2 Input Summary 2 - Page 11 of 185
schools but I think we need to have intention long term collaboration... maybe institutionalize the
"connections between staff and community". How are we going to engage these children if they
do't know what city government and citizen engagement is???
.. . .. ... ... ..... . ................... ...... ....... ..... ............................... ..................................
..
15
Seems like a no-brainer.
5/29/2019
4:43
PM
16
X
5/29/2019
7:27
AM
17
ditto
5/28/2019
1:34
PM
18
I hope the City will look into progressive taxes. A lot of people with money are moving here
5/28/2019
10:02 AM
19
.. .................... ................................. . : .. .. .. . .... .......... ...... .. : ............ .. ............. : .. ............ .. ... . .......................... ... . ....... . . ................ ............. ............. ...... . .. . .. . ....... .. ............... ......... .............. ........ ...................................... .......... .................... .... : ...... ................. .................. : .............. ......... : ....... : ... .............. ..............................................
We should accept nothing less
...... ...... ................ ...................................... ...... ....... ........... .... .............. ........................................ : ........................ .... ............... ........ .... ............ ..... ............................... ........... ......................... ........................... 1-11 ........... I— . ... ........ I . .. ..... I ... .................... ......... ...... .. ..... . ..... .
5/26/2019
2:15
........ ......... .......
PM
20
Recruit locals for local municipal positions in favor of those living out of town.
5/23/2019
3:17
PM
. . . ... .. . . .. ......... ........ ..... . . . ... . . ...
21
.... ... ... .... ..... . . ... . . . ... . . . .. . . .. . ... .. ..... .. . .... ..... ..... .. .. . . .. ... . . . ....... . .. .... . .. ... .... ........ ..........
I like the addition of organizationally sustainable.
5/21/2019
3:14
PM .
22
............... ... ..... . ..
Too broad. Too ambitious
5/19/2019
7:41
PM
. .. .. ... ... .. ..... .. ... . . .
23
Restore public confidence so that we can trust government with more tax money
5/1 8/201 9
3:40
PM'
24
........... ...... :: ........ . ..... ..... ...... ": ......... .... ..
Address transparency. City has a reputation for being fiscally weak.
5/18/2019
............... .....
12:04 PM
25
... .. ....... . .... . .. .......... ......... .. ......... .. . .. . ...... . . . ... . ....... .. .. .... .. ....... .............. . . ..... .. . ... . . .. ........ ...... .... ....... . .. . ..
What does this mean? -Leverage local, regional, and state programs and resources to maximize
5/17/2019
5:48
PM
city revenues. What programs do you mean? A lot of the other points are things you should be
doing already, like preventing sexual harassment etc..
26
... .......
Absolutely necessary.
5/17/2019
.........
5:37
PM
27
Every 6 months, publish all of these full plans, policies, and finances plus summaries thereof
5/17/2019
1:07
PM
online, in news media print, and on the local public access TV and audio channels.
. ..... ... .. ..... .. ... .
28
No further comment
5/17/2019
102-56 AM
29
.... ...... ... .... ... ... ... .... .. ...... . ..... ... . . ............ . ..... ... .. .. ....
Heading in the right direction
..
5/17/2019
.......
10:31 AM
30
..... ....... . . ... . . . ........ .... :1 .............. ...... . ..................... ........ .. ......... ....... :.: . ................ ............ ........ . ............. .. ....... ........ .. .............. ... ......
See previous
..... ..... . . . . . ... ..... . . : .. ........ .............. .. .... ........................ . . . .. ...... . .. . ...... ... .......... ........ .. . . ........ .. ....... ............ . .... .. .......
..... . ..........
5/17/2019
9:28
AM
1 /2 Input Summary 2 - Page 11 of 185
CITY COLTNGIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
31 Sounds good. 5/17/2019 9:25 AM
32 Ok _ 5/16/2019 6:49 PM
33 We also need an open public appraise program. Some sign was well made, some landscape was 5/16/2019 5:20 PM
well done. Let the citizen post what was done right in this city.
34 Tax luxury properties, tax wall street owners, tax out of state immigrants 5/16/2019 3;23 PM
35. HUD Certified agency in Petaluma for fair housing issues. 5/16/2019 2:34 PM
36 _ agree,. _ 5/16/2019 1:75 PM.
37 I don't see anything about making Petaluma pay or benefits attractive to employees. Where does 5/16/2019 10;48 AM
Petaluma stand?
�R If thp-rp. is a nronosal to chance the ON Charter. it needs to be anoroved bv the residents not the 5/16/2019 10:37 AM
f
2/2
11
i
nPut Summary 2 -Page 12 of 185
6
R
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS .2019-2021 Attaciment-3
Q47 What do you like about these work plan items?. Or, what are we
missing?
Answered: 38 Skipped. 237
# RESPONSES DATE.
1 (4) add federal Add: Provide facilities for and training of Fire Department personnel to increase 6/1 6/201 9 4:09 PM
gender diversity,. Support Public Banking to leverage City funds to.circulate within our community
Evaluate the re-establishment of an "in house" Planning Department
............ . . .. .. . . . ... ..... ... .. ...... .. .... ...... ......................... ....... ............. : ... . . . . ...... . ............... .. . . .......
. ...............
...... ..
:-, ......
. .....
2 #5 should be dropped. It is not a part of ...the .........city mission but instead a goal of progressives alone. 6/14/2019 2:32 PM
Dedicate our limited resources elsewhere to ensure sustainability 46 "connections between staff
and community" is excellent.
3 Insure city employees are able to afford homes in Petaluma; support unionization of city 6/13/2019 3:17 PM
employees.
..... ............ .......................... ...... ......... ..... ................. ........................ .. ............... ....... ............ . ......... .. ..... .............. .......... .............. .... .............. ...
4 As a state-run district agricultural association, the fairgrounds will be receiving additional state 6/6/2019 6-M30 PM
funding for capitol improvements. It is starting slow but from a state point of view, and considering
the importance of fairgrounds with disaster services and as evacuation sites, more attention is be
paid to the condition of our facilities and available resources. We have a new norm and natural
disasters are predicted to continue to get more common and more destructive. The state
recognizes fairgrounds roles during these natural disasters and are working to enhance their
viability. These addition funds will be part of the solution in improving -the safety and function of the
1-/2 nSummary 2 -Page 13 of 185
U
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
23 Revise whatever you need to to ensure we can't be bullied by Safeway -and other businesses that 5/19/2019 5:17 PM
24
25
26
27
Item 9 seems like something that should already be in place.. Seems obvious compared to the 5/79/2019 2:42 PM
other more creative work items
Need mechanism to make fiscal situation understandable to the general public. (this might be 5/18/2019 9:26 AM
covered elsewhere)
Many seem like something that should already be in place. What has been going on that these are 5/17/2019 5:48 PM
stated goals that sound brand new?
City government is a weak, especialy city committees and commisions. See Patricia Tuttle
Brown's statement in the community section of the goal setting statements,. We have two newly
5/17/2019 5:37 PM
11
11
w
2/2 Inp
ut Summary 2 -Page 14 of 185
elected city councilmembers. One really needs to come up to speed.
28
Every.6 months, publish all of these full plans, policies, and finances plus summaries thereof
5/17/2019
1:07 PM
online,in news media print, and on the local public access TV and audio channels.
29
Well trained and focused employees should reduce fiscal waste as well and over staffing, good!
5/17/2019
10:56 AM
30
No further comment
5/17/2019
10:56 AM
31
They are wise
5/17/2019.10:31
AM.
............
32
Mentor, internship programs with SRJC
5/17/2019
9-28'AM
33
More details are needed before forming an opinion
5/17/2019
9:25 AM
34
............... .............. ............... . . .. .
Ok
5/16/2019
6:49 PM
35
....... ... .....
We have too many eye -sore spots in Petaluma. We need to hire more, train more people who take
5/16/2019
5:20 PM
pride for their work.
36
agree.
5/16/2019
1:15 PM
37
The model stuff like be a model for the whole world. Come on we inventing stuff -is expensive.
5/16/2019
10:37 AM
Better to use the inventions and best practices of others.
.. . . .. .. . . . . . . . ... . . . .:.. '' .... ''. '' . . . .. . ... ... .. . . . .. ... . ... .. ... .... . . . .. .... .. . . . ... . . .... ....
38
Insure our financial stabilty.,
. . .... . . . ......... . ...
5/15/2019
3:45 PM
11
11
w
2/2 Inp
ut Summary 2 -Page 14 of 185
Attachment 3
make walking"r and bikinmv easl,,
p 5 y, fun and safe.,
I
g
4-% Loft AV-% p e%ta I u M
's planned cross-town connectors.
ION
13
a
structi
I -time trani,c eno"nneo
9 4
AIM%
te the recU---,n
A
P6
ra d e t
42
4 . I
i rn vp,,k rove Lp,-, a
60 1 Mvp"'I'lemen
I
r A111
integ, WALMEAEOPM.ME-FiLw��w- I " .. I I I
400
r-10, I I
0-5
Faye 1 r o f 1
Rage 2
Input Summary 2
I cornorat"
Create a more eff"den-L F ion *yi#a
vellaoff UI-MOCO to.-irammuzeal r%hMIK &I FLO]
wa-ter plarit facilities, and iflte8o-rrate uses inlcludinA-i
IV
go uorn,""llete ine secon(t, 9 IN: IM Ftwioi
1 itate the Trestle
10. Develop
a Plan to rehab
'he ia Iter fac*l'*t
,j a I...0 u %j and Aniff ies.
0 a � 11�1 P III pq PON
ears.
ade'lln the last five IL "
0
0
PY 19-210 &" 20-21 Draft Goals
n
La
ml
21
i
Li
a
m
E
0�0
n
wo
a
c
Q
w
-k
:,Invp%ut "Summary z F ay1 bJ otj
0
E
Eu
f�
U�
�
c
Q
w
-k
:,Invp%ut "Summary z F ay1 bJ otj
0
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
Q49 What doouylike about this objective? Or, what are we missing?
Answered; 90 Skipped: 185
# "RESPONSES
DATE
was slated for it.. But 1*f the City Council follows the Mayor, we can solve the problem by not
allowing cars on the road from 6:00 AM to 9:00 PM!
1/4
W
Input Summary 2 - Page 17 of 185
W
r•
r
f
a
26.
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Streets is a priority but SMP is already started so check it off and add something else. Cross town
connectors is a major priority except for everyone on the Westside. Rainier first and Caulfield
second. Both need a deadline like 8-10 year completion date for both. Dont make Caulfield a lifting
bridge. Stop boat traffic at Sheraton Marina.'Or make boats lower mast and power under bridges
Attaciment 3
6/3/2019 6:30 AM
4
7
0
I
2/4 Input Summary 2 - Page 18 of 185
to help traffic flow but not interrupting at boaters choice time. Sell public works site and move to
airport area where they dont get harrassed by homeless and could expand. Also would help
market the development in area to not be next to a sewer.
27
Increase # parking spaces required for new developments.
6/1/2019 10:46
AM
28
focusing on fixing the roads
5/31/2019
7:02
PM
29
Our infrastructure needs a lot of maintenance.
5/31/2019
12:31 AM
30'
.. ....... .
do not raise our taxes for this!!
5/30/2019
54056
PM
31
#1 Unless you are going to include access to freeways'w/ these connectors I don't see much value
5/29/2019
9:37
PM
at all #10 and #11 resonate The animal shelter needs to stay or be expanded, it's lackluster at
best, but so needed and appreciated.
32
. .. ....... . .
The traffic situation in' this city has got to get under control before any further development occurs.
5/29/2019
11:40 AM
33
........... .............
Finally!
5/29/2019
7:28
AM
34
Reviving the trestle would be wonderful, but given its current state of dilapidation, not economically
5/28/2019
8:54
PM
practical. Focus instead on a less expensive approach of removing the trestle, banking the river --
4
7
0
I
2/4 Input Summary 2 - Page 18 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
52 I strongly disagree with the Rainier crossing. It is environmentally disruptive, and excessively 5/1 9/201 9 2:50 PM
costly. I think examining a second bridge at Caulfield makes sense, and expanding/updating the
Corona overpass (especially once the Corona Smart Station is realized) would be more cost and effective, probably much more useful. A Traffic Engineer would also be able to. help.evaluate
the relative value of different approaches from a traffic flow and congestion perspective. For
example, the Rainier DEIR noted that the crossover would have limited impact on traffic
congestion until Petaluma Blvd. N. was more fully developed:. That's years in the future, if ever.
Meanwhile, a huge amount of cross town traffic at D and Washington (off Lakeville), could be
mitigated by getting it across the river at Caulfield. Determine where the traffic incoming from and
Ir
where it is aoina. and you will see that the southern crossing will be far more effective than
3/4
Input Summary 2 - Page 19 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
80 THIS needs to be Petaluma's Priority #1 and change -the word "promote" to "implement and 5/16/2019 2:28 PM
complete": "Inventory and promote all road paving and reconstruction projects with funding
sources and dates of completion, made in the last five years."
81 Limit building heights as we live in earthquake territoryl 5/16/2019 1:35 PM
82 New development should pay its own way and contribute to past omissions, not be subsidized. 5/16/2019 1 :28 PM
That is the "new" revenue needed to provide for xtown connectors,, The east on and off ramps
from freeway should have been paid for' by the friedmans shopping center developers. Get some
of it from this change in zoning for apartments.
.. .... .............. ........................ ..... .... ............
83 bike share great, cross connector not going to happen. If it doesit needs to be via Hopper etc. not 5/16/2019 1:19 PM
Rainier. Like the idea of addressing public transportation so it better suits residents needs. That
and bikeshare/mobility scooters ability challenged citizens can use too. And obviously fix the
potholes:,-)
84 Yes to road repairs and Corona SMART depot,. We do NOT need a Rainier under pass. Use 5/16/2019 1:16 PM
Corona!
85 Tear down trestle and build a riverwalk 5/16/2019 12,019 PM
86 Cross town connectors and the Tressle are good goals. So would upgrades to Casa Grande and 5/16/2019 12:13 PM
Caulfield be. There are no roads in OK condition running east to west on the east side except E
Washington.
87 I've' lived here 21 years.., how long have you been trying to make "crosstown connector" areality -- 5/16/2019 11:41 AM
give me a break.
88 more bike and walking paths downtown, parking on perimeter of city with electric buses in no car 5/16/2019 11:09 A M
zone
89'Objective is OK but should not be tied to specific proiects. 5/16/2019 10:41 AM
90 Our traffic and streets are getting more over used. 5/15/2019 3%-47 PM
•
r
t
i
f
4 /4
1
r
w
11
a
Input Summary 2 - Page 20 of 185
0
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
Q50 What d -o you like about these work- plan items ? Or, what are we
missing?
Answered. 61 Skipped: 214
N
# RESPONSES DATE
1 Modify (1) to complete or abandon Add: Re-evaluate and expand our public transit options to 6/16/2019 4:09 PM
• increase ridership.
.. .. ..... . .. . . . . . . . . . ... ...... ... .... .............. ... . . ............ ... ... .......................................................... : .... .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. ... ... ..... . . .. ... ..... ............................. .... ... . ... .... . .. . . .. ............ ..... .... ... . .. .. . ...... . ... . . ...... . .... .. ....... . . . .... ... ... .. ........ . .. . .... .... .... ..... .... ...... ....... .... ... .... ..... .................. ........ ..... ................................
.... .
...... ...
2 I like everything about these world plan items and would encourage. you to put them at the top of 6/14/2019 2:35 PM
the list with the highest priority apart from river dredging.
3 Too much. soil in the Petaluma River watershed has already been covered with asphalt and 6/13/2019 3:20 PM
concrete. No.more, please,.'
... . ... ..... . .. .. . ... ... .... ..... ... ... ... I .........
4 Add this item: 1) Identify funding to update the Bike Ped Plan as an addendum to the existing 6/6/2019 9:53 PM
master plan'to reflectVision Zero guidelines and All Ages and Abilities infrastructure.
5 $$$$$$ where is it coming from? 6/6/2019 8:31 PM
....... ............................... ............................... ............ .................... .................................................................... : ............ .. ........ ........ . . ... ... . ... ..... .. .. . ........... .... . .. .... .. ... . . . ... . . ... .. . .... ..... .. .. .. . . . . ....... .. . . ... .. ... .. . .. .. . . ... .. .... . ... . .. . ... ... ... .. ..... . .. .... ....... ...... . ...... . .... ........ ... . . . .. . .. . . . .. .... .. . . ..... . .. . .... . .... . .. . ......... . .. . ... .... .... ... . ....... ... ..... . .. ... .. . . ..... ... . . .. .. ... .. ... .. . . ..... . . . .... ..... .... . . . . . . ... ....... ............ I ............... ..... . I ... ... . I .......... ..................... I ....... .. .. . ...
6 They are all positive i mprovements.. 6/6/2019 6:05 PM
. . ..... ... . . ....... .. .. .. . .... ... .. ............ .......... ........................... .... ........... ..... ........... .... .... ..... . ............ .. .... .......
7 Glad to see workplan item #10 regarding rehabilitation of the trestle, however this item resonates 6/6/2019 5:54 PM
with so many of the other goals and objectives throughout. Seems buried among other CIP's here,
maybe an objective of it's own, or at least mentioned with other goals.
. .. . . .. ..... .. ... . . . .... ...... ... ..... ... . . ... . . ....... .... .. ..... .. . . ... ..... .. .. . ... ... .. . . . . .. .. . .. . . . ........ .. .....
8 Are you planning on getting rid of the animal shelter? NOT for that,. All these things that you are 6/6/2019 2: 17 PM
proposing take money, so be careful about that. As a homeowner, if I want to make improvements,
can't do it until I save the money. City government should be no different.
.......................................... ....................................................... .................................................. ........... .................... ........................................................... ........ . ........................................................ ....................... . . ........................... .. ..... .......... ...... ...... ... ..... .......... .. .......... . . .......... ........... ........ ...... .............. ................. . .. .. . .... ............. .. .......... ....................
9 Yes to second SMART station. Put focus on walking and biking infrastructure, rather than adding 6/6/2019 2:02 PM
cross-town connectors for cars.
.. .... .... .... .......................... ........... . ............ ........ ............... ......... ................................... ...... ...... ..... ........ .. .............. . ..................... ......... .... ......... ........ ... ......................... .. ..... .. ........... ... ...... ....... ... ...... ..... ..... ...... ............ ........ ...... . . ... .. ... ...... .. ........ .... . ...... . . ........ . .... .. .... ...... . .. .. . ...... ... . .. . .. ... ...... .. . . . .
10 see 491L 6/6/2019 11:57 AM
... .. ... ... ..... ........... ........... .. ...... ............................................................................................... : . .. ......... .. ... ...... .. .. ..... . . .... .. . . . . . . .... ..... . . . .. . .. ... ....... . .. .. .. ... .. . ....... ................. ................. ............ ........... .. . .... ... ..... ... ................. .............................. ............. ....... ..................... ..... .. ................................................................................. . .............. .................... ................................ ................ .................................. ..... ... . .. .... ..
11 I like 1, 2,4,5,9 and 10.. I'm.
not sure why the others are priorities. Why are those spec'Ificroads 6/5/2019 8:49 PM
identified in number 3? The roads that get.attention by the city seem to make no sense. Petaluma
Boulevard South is a disaster from D street till the newly paved part by the freeway. The pothole's
make the road undriveable, along with the parking on the side of the road that essentially
eliminates the right lane heading south. The parking situation on the 200 block of Kentucky Street
has also turned the street into one lane. The situation is dangerous. A comprehensive review of all
streets, and the extent to which they are used and/or parked on should be undertaken. In addition,0
the sidewalks are dangerous all-over the west side. We also need better street lighting.
.. ....... ............ ........ . .. .. . .. . . . ......... . .... ........ .... . ............. .. ............. .... ...... ..... ... .... ............. ........... ................................................................................................. ................................................. .................................................................. ................ ..........................................
....................... ..............
...... .
.........
12 Missed:. Public transportation ! Completely missed not just here but seemingly throughout all the 6/5/2019 7:23 PM
plans so far. (l mean local bus routes here, not SMART) Views from Bike Petaluma: Traffic
engineer position needs to ensure qualifications and focus on Bike/Ped design and public transit.
Every single repaving project needs to include dramatic improvements to bike lanes, with special
focus towards dedicated and especially protected bike lanes. Shared bike lanes are not cutting it,
and that seems'to be all the city does when they repave. For that matter the existing "dedicated"
bike lanes are almost all just generous parking spots in the current implementations. Yes, lets
absolutely implement a bike share system, but in the current implementation of our streets, it i's
doomed to fail. Riding cycles in Petaluma is unpleasant and hazardous today, and only getting
worse with more traffic. We need dramatic and aggressive movement towards creating a more
bike friendly city. Petaluma has some of the worst bike infrastructure in the whole of the. North Bay.
Petaluma needs to exert more pressure on SMART not only to complete their 2nd station, but to
deliver on their failed promises of adding bike lanes along the entire system running through our
town. This is the only reason they got their measure to pass, by adding this goal late in the
proposal.. It stinks that they have passed the buck repeatedly' on actually delivering it. We need to
hold SMART accountable.
................................... ........ .... ...... ........ ..... .... I ....... ... ...... . .................. ........ ... . . ......... ...... . ........ .......... ...... ... .. . ...... .... . ..... ... . ... . ... . .... . .. ........... . ................ .................. ....... ...... ..................... ......................... ......................................... ..................... ........ ..... .
13 Fully support all -items. Well written and true. 6/5/2019 3:32 PM
.......... . ... ........ . ... ..... ...... ...... ..... ... ......... .. . ... ................... .................. ................... ........ .. . .. ... .. . .... . . ... .... . .... ............... ... ... ....... ...... .............. .. ............. . ..................... ....... . ... . ... ... ....... I-- ........ "I .......... I ............ . I .......
.. ... . ..... ...... ... ..... . .... . . . .... ... ...... .... .. ........ ....................................................
14 Delete 1 6/4/2019 9:05 PM
u
1/4
Input Summary 2
-Page 21 of 185
0
r
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
15 I especially like #5.
16 Secure the Corona Station, widen
McDowell and Corona.
the rail crossing at Corona and improve the intersection at
18 SMART station at Corona is a must. Downtown is great for everyone excep
Attachment 3
6/3/2019 7:34 PM
6/3/2019
4:52
PM
t for residents. 6/3/2019
6:30
AM
Eastside doesnt go to that station. Tressel would be great if the city was flush with money. But
needs -to be a private project. Regardless remove the falling apart remains,, They cant use it in a
rebuild and it is embarassing,,
19 Yes to #8!! The animal shelter is out -dated. The location does not promote community 6/2/2019 9,0035 AM
connections. The corp yard could use the space...
20 Partner'with organization such as Rotary or Railroad Club loners for trussel funding.. 6/1/2019 10:46 AM
21 focusing on fixing the roads 5/31/2019 7:02 PM
....... ......... .
22 Please build the Corona SMART station! 5/31/2019 12:31 AM
23 do not our taxes raise 5/30/2019 5:56 PM
24 Implement community bike share system and explore other multi -modal transportation offerings. - 5/30/2019 3:43 PM
we don't even have sidewalks in places and this is a priority?
. .. . ....... . .. ... . . ........ .... . .... . .....
25 A lot of these are the important infrastructure elements that the residents want to see happen. 5/29/2019 4:47 PM
These are the goals that I really care about. Organizing the government to run efficiently is an
expectation.
...... . . ......... . .
26 _ Streets _ 5/29/2019 7:28 AM
27 Yes for Corona train station'. 5/28/2019 7:55 PM
..... ..... .......... ..
28 ditto 5/28/2019 1:35 PM
..
29 Like pedestrian friendly spaces in Europe, I would love to see a trolly that takes pedestrians from 5/28/2019 11:08 AM
Webster to Maria...up and down Washington Street. There are so many shops, JC, Library,
Fairgrounds, Swimming pool, downtown that could be more walkable with a reliable bus'going up
and down on this route,,
30 integrating transit and more bicycles 5/28/2019 1044,02 AM
31 Too many items. Given resources available only high priority needs should be called out. It seems 5126/2019 2:19 PM
to put critical, much needed items (roads, connector, etc.) on the same level as nice to haves (bike
share, trestle)
32 Yes on the train station at Corona, and revamping the train trestle. Maybe that will scare the rats 5/23/2019 3:19 PM
away.
33 #4 City Engineer is the Traffic Engineer. Need more sig,nal techs to maintain the system according 5/23/2019 1:24 PM
to State maintenance schedule. Liability currently.
....... . .................................... . .
34 i would add something to the upgrade signals to also make them bicycle and pedestrian friendly. 5/23/2019 8:23 AM
Expand on #5 to include bike lanes and maintenence. add an item to create a goal to get "Bicycle
Friendly" status from the League of American Wheelman as have our neighbors in Santa Rosa
and Sonoma have done.
35 more safe pedestrian and bicycle pathways. Support cross town connector, e.g. Rainier overpass 5/21/2019 9:44 PM
36 1. Proceed with cross -connectors only after measuring them against the new CEQA standard of 5/21/2019 3:27 PM
1 4
VMT, comparing the value gained to alternative uses of City funds, and considering the tong -range
impacts on City maintenance budgets. 4., From conversations with City staff and familiarity with
'traffic signal timing, I believe that the City has consistently paid attention to the traffic signal timing,
that we sometimes have traffic that would overwhelm any signal timing, and that the problem isn't
poor timing, it's street grid that isn't conducive to timing that'll work for traffic flowing both
directions. 6. I love the bike share idea and hope it works, but it should be folded into Transit
because it's the transit/bike share intersection that is crucial. 7. I don't know that "integrate transit
with street design" means, butif it means look for more opportunities to add pull-outs, I'm on-
board. 8. Yes! Freeing upland near the urban core is crucial
37 Mentioned is the 2nd SMART station -- we need a way to safely bike to SMART stations. Now it's 5/21/2019 2:33 PM
way too dangerous
214 Input Summary 2 -Page 22 of 185
0
10
{
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
38
There needs to be more local support for Public Transit. Many cities in the County (Sebastopol,
5/20/2019
10:02 AM
Sonoma, RP, etc) are contributing some local funds to support free transit in their communities.
39
All good
5/19/2019
7:41
PM
40
Build the Ranier connector! Build the second SMART station (with free parking).
5/19/2019
5:17
PM
41
......... .
The Corona Smart station would be a wonderful connection for San Francisco Day trippers to our
5/17/2019
8:27
PM
wonderful "Makers" area
42
Pave the streets before you spend on city hall, more surveillance, and more PPD.
5/17/2019
5:52
PM
.......... ... . .. .. . . ... . . . .
43
... ........ .... ... I..: ... . . ... ........ .... . .. . . .. ... I ......... ..... . .. .. . ... .... ..... . . . .......... . . ... . . ......... . . . .. .... .. .. . ....... . . ...
Streets need to be complete streets with protected bike lanes, protected intersections, and
5/17/2019
5:50
PM
protected crosswalks, Our streets are in shamble
introduced in order to get the developer to fix our
. We wait until development projects are
streets. This is -not proactive. Our whole city
street arterials need to be designed with the expectation that future developers will design their
projects around our complete streets,.
44 More parking at smart train stations would be smart 5/17/2019 4:32 PM
45 Every 6 months, publish all of these full plans, policies, and finances plus summaries thereof 5/17/2019 1:08 PM
online, in news media print, and on the local public access TV and audio channels.
46 Corona extension of SMART, bike sharing and more/ safer paths. 5/17/2019 12;41 PM
47 Noise dampening and protection from 101 from the bridge through East Washington to protect 5/17/2019 10:58 AM
residents and improve their quality of life.
48 No further comments at this time 5/17/2019 10-;:58 AM
.... . . .. .. .. ...
49 Exciting and so useful. 5/17/2019 10:33 AM
................ .... ... ... . . ... . .. . .. . . ............... .. . .... . .. ........
50 Focus on publictransit 5/17/2019 9;32 AM
.... . .. .... .. . . . .... ...... .......
........................ .....
............. ..
...
51 All make sense. We need more camerasin general and not just for traffic. Downtown, high risk 5/17/2019 9:27 AM
areas, common garbage dumping areas, bus station, train station stops, etc and then of course
someone to monitor them.
52 Cross town connectors and alternatives to automobile should be the priority work plan items. 5/17/2019 9:26 AM
....... ........... .................................. ..... .... ............. ................... ......................... .................... .. .... ...... ........... ..... ............................ .... . ... ....... . ....... ....... :1:-1 ..... ............. : ...... ........ ... I ... . ........... ..... ............................ ........ .. ... .. ... ............ .... .. ........ ............................................................. . . . . .......... ..... ........... ... .... ..................... ................... ........ .... . ............... ... ................... .... ... .......
53 The Trestle is also a money -sink. Paula Lane Action Network wrote'a grant app to the Coastal 5/17/2019 8:21 AM
Conservancy for acquisition funds several years ago - and we were advised by the representative
for Sonoma Co. it was a great application and we might be able to look at $400K. As soon as the
then Mayor discovered this - apparently, the City Mgmt had not told the elected officials PLAN
wrote this application FOR the City for the Paula Lane open space property quest and seeking
acquisition funds, then- about $1.5 million total, the Mayor had the ED of the Coastal Conservancy
come to Petaluma to see the "City's" priorities and our $400K was cut to "maybe you'll see $200K"
and that is how the Trestle study funds were obtained - Paula Lane Action Network surely has
been the booster for some of the unethical actions on the part of elected officials to obtain funding .
for the City. Then, there were some fundraisers to rehab the Trestle - but at this point, it is clear
and always was clear to many in the community, rehab'ing the Trestle is a money -sink -hole and
there really should not be another dime going to that effort. It just isn't that important to the City and
its future and it's another one of those efforts that was based on trying to grab funding politically in
an unethical way.
.. . ....... ...... ............... ..
54 11 27 31 4173 91 11 ALL SUPER IMPORTANT and at the top of my list of concerns 5/16/2019 6:51 PM
. .......................................
55 Please don't waste city budget by spending them wise. 5/16/2019 5:23 PM
56 Multi modal transportation? I hope you don't intend to introduce motorized scooters? Because 5/16/2019 3:47 PM
don't. Please. Skateboarders are already a hazard as are cyclists who ride on the sidewalks and
against traffic without wearing a helmet. Think to the end.
......... ..... ........ .. . ..... .................. ......... . ....... ...... ... ....... ... ........ . . .. ... .. . ...... .... . ... .. ........ ... ... . . ... . . . .......... .... . .... ... .. .. ... .. ... .. . .. . .. .... ...... ......... : ..... ... . ....
57 On water activity needed 5/16/2019 3:24 PM
......................... .................... . ...... ................... ..... . . . . . . . .. . . . ...... ........ ..... . . . .......... ... . .. ... ..... .... . . . .... ....... . ... .... . .......... ...... ............................... ... . .... .... . I ....... .. ...... . ....... . ..... . ... .. . .......... ... .. . ......e....................................................... ...............
58 .all good in theory but finding the money is the challenge.. 5/16/2019 1:19 PM
... . . . ........ ..... .... . ..
59 4. Upgrade traffic signal management by re-establishing full-time traffic engineer position:. We do 5/16/2019 10:56 AM
not need this position. Work with current resources. Reduce traffic by not permitting new
constructions. Becoming too busy and hassle. Fix the roads that are pathetic !!
... ...... 1:1..,::,.:::..�:.,.,:.,:.....:.,...,....,..":...:::.: .... ...... .... . .... .......... ........ ......................... ......... ... ............ . . . . . .... . ...
. ....... . . .
n
F
3/4
Input Summary 2 -'age 23 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021. Attachment 3
60 The cross town connector will not work without a revision of the tragic flow in Petaluma. While I 5/1 6/201 9 1 0:41 AM
agree with buying the right of way as an investment, 1 do not support the concept without changing
the traffic flow of the entire city west side. Council needs to work on that.
61 Better tragic light management. 5/15/2019 3;47 PM
f
0
4/4 Input Summary 2 -'age 24 of 185
sustalina le ana
serves needIl .,f our res'l*dents.
...
,
a
rc'
71
.a
�
o�
�x
a it
a, , .
IV
���� 'nef'
^w°q,„u,
n 5
i
746A va
orkpiloan Iteoftams"i
t MKO B z Cal 0-
E
Sell
2. En,,eaee and Cit
sutitioirt all
�>
Clol "r
L-11% f"r Ol f"r eN SoNe% OIN wx Coll
�tCy-%MMr
munli
tionsnroevram
t
.
ff11
IW49111
, r, 19- M- no 11 it V16%
V% I'de
integral: -e
�.:2nd to ..
G
4 Mit I
NOW* 01111 �W,% a Uomm
communication platforms.
x
i c
RON- �=, , ” — I
tions for
Litilty
dedsion-mak.ing.
y Councl nd Plann"n
ss -pollinate wit
t,o, 'j, , , "'. I I R, F
� r
A 0 4
eP Y
iss,ion
,
� ;III', � II
r
I
�I
�"` ",,,', ,,,:wsw' �' ,,., ��r-'14m^, ,': �'.., �, ,'.w. a.'m.' �+'M•,:-� '��'.�" '.,."� ,,'�' ': mm `n.a`u:uad` � .m .w,rx � .. m .� � '� I '.,a,. „, �� n„„,,,” .x„ m,;, „ .�' �� v,. ” I� w,,, ..^ �, ,, ,.�..� � ,.. w, aw �^''�' aw. P
�� „.. a W, .,
r
.�, ', m WY« u.. � � �, , � ' : � , m .. �� i� �imrc�„ .� .�.„, . 'mro. ,w..
�, v m I ., � � � i...., r. ', w„ i � r� k, x i . RYA �
"I I
.,... � i r r �, 'ary .� .�� � .._ , i, .. � '; .'�' .,r � ..�,” " 4 area .�' r
�'� i ��. .J''. �^!' :
MP
i �� �: a
,P ^a ''rM,w"'''�'' ,a~ a+.
,M
0 Aff M
6 A50' to Worln ij1Lems#
low
1. Develop a citywide IT Masterpla1n that identifies and prioritizes City technology needs, funding, and implementation
strategies.
2. Implement an online permitting system.
3. Implement an agenda management software system.
4. Complete the roll-out of an updated City website that creates a more user-friendly, accessible, and interactive
information resource and online experience for the community.
5. Leverage technology to improve efficiency including improved use ot, meeting and conferencing technologies.
6. E
nhance mobile technology to increasee ff clienc
y of fieldstaff.
Encourage the expansion OT'internet f iber bycarriers to provide access tio our community.
F Yr 19'"', - 20'4-& U^ & 2 0% - 20% -41 wU-%%,r a ft 6 o a—
13
Page 3
Input Summary 2 t' --sage 25 ol' 18b'
4
h
Eop-im",
l
rl
In
0�4
0
sit
1 0
u
11
I
.090L fli dll�% vp=%6 looll w jp-%f 1 bf%
kol% Lo"L o'lur"imary Hage ztd)m"' u
If 1p u
A
TMMM
L
i
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 20
19-2021 Attachment 3
Q52 What do you'like about this objective? Or, what are'
we miss ing?
Answered: 65 Skipped: 210
RESPONSES
How about Establish a series of Town Hall meetings, formally inviting our diverse communities to 6/14/2019 7: 12 P M
J
1/3
nut Summary 2 - Page 27 of 185
I.
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 0 Attachment 3
28 Important to stretch to communicate with the townspeople. They are all so busy. 5/28/2019 7:46 PM
29 "Cross pollinate?" Excessive fluff here. 5/28/2019 5:36 PM
30 ditto 5/28/2019 1:35 PM
31 Yes, translate materials and encourage ethnic and social diversity on all committees and 5/28/2019 11:09 AM
commissions.
32 more communication is always better 5/28/2019 1 0:02 AM
33 Language exchange program: Hispanics taught English while they teach_ Spanish to non -speakers.- 5/23/2019 3:22 PM
34 yes! 5/23/2019 8:26 AM
35 It's great. 5/21/2019 3;36 PM
36 Improve Planning Department where city planners are actually listening to the community and 5/20/2019 12:58 PM
council and not what the Developer and private manipulative groups want that are just shills of the
Developer.
37 Good. This next comment maybe doesn't belong here: City of Rohnert Park has- used battery drop- 5/20/2019 8:43 AM
off at City Hall for all residents. Petaluma should have a couple of well-publicized used battery
drop-off locations, as well. East side and west side.
. .... . ......
38 Ali good 5/19/2019 7:42 PM
39 This goes without saying. We need to build community and community confidence. 5/78/2019 3:42 PM
40 #6 is key. Who is not at the table?! ? Again, move City all to the new Fairgrounds and promote our 5/78/2019 1.2:08 PM
cities diversity. Always challenge your own assumptions when making decisions (study Double -
loop Learning for Organizations). Be inclusive. City Hall and City Council feel very Westside,
intimidating, and non -welcoming.
41 I hope it happens. 5/17/2019 6:05 PM
42 Communication with the citizens is key. But if you only communicate out and then ignore what the 5/17/2019 6:01 PM
citizens want, you're just as bad as the next bureaucrat,
. ... .. ........................ .. ..... ............... . ... ...... . .. .... . ..... . .......... . .... ............. ......................... ................... ...... . ..... .. .... . . .
43 Every 6 months, publish all of these full plans, policies, and finances plus summaries thereof 5/17/2019 16909.PM
online, in news media print, and on the local public access TV and audio channels,
44 Sounds like a good plan to bring the cfry management and the community together, We will need 5!17!2019 11:00 AM
to see how to make this happen for the benefit of all
45 Inclusiveness 5/17/2019 10:35 AM
46 Why just the Hispanic community? Why not the Portuguese or the Germans or the blacks or any 5/17/2019 10:13 AM
number of other ethnicities? Why should my hard earned tax dollars go to integrate one ethnic
group.Into the city when all the others are virtually ignored?
.. ....... ...
47 Yes - if course. These should be priority 1 5/17/2019 9:32 AM
48 Sounds good 5/17/2019 9:31 AM
49 This is a nice objective, but I do not see a need to allocate resources toward it. 5/17/2019 9:29 AM
.. ............. .. ......
50 It all sounds good. I have heartburn with the Hispanic community outreach because the city should 5/17/2019 9-F,21 AM
reach out to everyone. The Hispanic communitycan engageif they want to all meeting are public
brown act meetings so hardly exclusive,,
5/1 6/2019 6:51 PM
52 People works for city , their goal is serving public. Government facility and paper should be people 5/16/2019 5;26 PM
friendly.
53 Hahahahahal,10, Transparency? That'll be the day. 5!76!2019 3&1,48 PM
.. ... . .. . .. ..... .. ... ..... ... .... .. . .. .. . . ........... ....... .... . .. . ... .. . .. . ....... ... . ........ . .
b4 Police and fire need transparency too. Publish the pensions 5!76!2019 3:24 PM
.. ........... .... . ..
55 Why single out "the Hispanic community?" 5!96!2019 3:23 PM
...................................... ............
56 Internships in City Government in Petaluma and the County. 5!16!2019 2:37 PM
5 7 This all sounds nice and customer service oriented but should be normal goals for the City unless 5/16!2019 2:29 PM
they feel that the City staff aren't serving the public well enough.
2/3
Input Summary 2 -Page 28 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attaciment 3
58 sounds good. would like a city based equivalent of a Human Right commission - smaller scale 1 5/16/2019 1:22 PM
realize. Though again', perhaps. this is fiscally unrealistic. But outreach to minorities is important
Li
4
k
4
3/,3
f
u
n
F
a
n
1
•
t
nput Summary 2 -Page 29 of 185
Q53 What do.yo-u
r
1
RESPONSES
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
like about these work plan mitemsOr,
missing?
Answered: 50 Skipped: 225
i
Modify (6) Hispanic and other minority Add:, Post Council Agenda's at Lucchesi Center and City
n
what are we
DATE
6/16/2019 4:09 PM
Hall
2 1 think social media is a waste of time and resources. 6/14/2019 2:38 PM
3 Fine. 6/93/2019 3:22 PM
4 Add this item: 1) Provide childcare at City Council meetings 6/6/2019 9:54 PM
5 Sounds good.. 6/6/2019 6:06 PM
6 Just be careful how much is being spent and where the money is expected to come from,, 6/6/2019 20-18 PM
7 collaboration with the county and larger system already developed 6!6/2019 12:00 PM
8 Like comprehensive communication program and Latino outreach. 6!5/2019 10:34 PM
9 Only the last one seems concrete and necessary 6/5/2019 8:51 PM
10 Like promotion of Hispanic Outreach. We have a rich and vibrant Hispanic Community. We need to 6/5!2019 7:24 PM
encourage and integrate them much betterin our town.
11 Item #3 will take man power. Why do we have to provide that? That's what Granicus is for. 6!5!2019 3:35 PM
Everything is televised or available online. Item #6 shouldn't just include Hispanics. The City
should be trying to reach all ethnicities, shouldn't they?
12 I especially like #'s 2, 3 and 6., 6!4/2019 12:58 AM
13 cost to putin action 6!3!2019 4:52 PM
. ...........
14 It's important for the commissions and committees to do meaningful work, making 6/2/2019 9:36 AM
recommendations on actionable City Council business.
15 I like everything listed 5/31/2019 7:03 PM
16 do not raise our taxes 5!30!2019 6:02 -PM
17 Make it easy to identify responsible parties or proper ways to input comments and requests. Clarify 5/29!2019 4:55 PM
what the city is responsible for and what belongs to the county.
18 Plan item #1 is critical 5/29!2019 9:11 AM
19.X 5/29!2019 7:28 AM
. ... ... .... . .. ..... . .. ... ... ... . .
20 Vague.but sounds fine. 5!28!2019 7:55 PM
21 Would like all the city policies and ordinances on an easy to use site that all can access. Would 5/28!2019 7:46 PM
also like how to update policies and interact with the various commissions. Particularly, I would like
to propose updating any flag policy we have to allow the council to give permission to groups to fly
flags -at city hall in response to council proclamations.
22 ditto 5/28/2019 1:35 PM
23 post meeting summaries of city council meetings would be great. A monthly newsletter from city 5!28!2019 10:02 AM
manager would be great too
. . . ........ .. . . . . ........
24 #6 -- offer a affordable course in teaching the basics of English.. 5/25/2019 7:10 AM
25 Place suggestion boxes about town for locals to jot down and submit ideas for city improvements. 5/23/2019 3;22 PM
26 Goodidea but all takes time and personnel. 5/23/2019 1:26 PM
i
1 /3 Input Summary 2 - Page 30 of 185
4
0
q
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
97 the annaaement Dart is important. An easier wav to get info on meetings and agendas is 5/23/2019 8"0,26 AM
important. Many decisions are made currently and no one knows about it until something is a.11
ready approved.
was underwhelming-,.'
. .... . . ....... . .... ..... . . ............ . ...... I ...... ....... : .................................... ...............................
-..: .................. .......... ................................ .. ............... ..... ............................. ........ .... ............... ............... .... ... .... ................................. ..................................... .... : ...... ...................... ......... ... ... .... ... .
30 7. & 3. Establish contacts with individuals or organizations who can help promulgate key 5/21/2019 3:36 PM
information. 2. Cross-pollination is one of the best ideas put forth. It'll also be crucial for the work of
the Climate Cabinet. If we substitute City Hall corridors for sidewalks, Jane Jacobs set forth the
target, "Lowly, unpurposeful, and random as they may appear, sidewalk contacts are the small
change from which a city's wealth of public life, may grow."
.. . . .. .. . ....................................... ................................................................ .......... .......... . ..... ......................................... .............. ........................ ............ ....... ..... ... . . . . . . . . ... .. .. .. . . . . .. ...... .. ...... .. ..... . .. .. ....... ..... . .. .. ... ..... .. . .. . .... .. . ......
31 All Committee meetings should be televised (e.g. BPAC),, Consider providing childcare for City 5/20/2019 10:02 AM
Council meetings to encourage diversity of attendance.
32 All good 5/19/2019 70142 PM
33 Especially like engaging the hispanic community. We need to engage ALL of out citizens. 5/1.9/2019 2:51 PM
.............................................................................. ..... ...... .. ................. .............................................. ... ..... .. ........................ ... .......... ....... I . . .. . ... .. . .. . ..... ...... .... . . . ..... . . ..... . ... .. .. . .. .. . .. . . . . .. .. ... .. ........ .. . . .... .... . . ... .. ..... ................. .
34 Missing a plan to develop an on-line site where residents can go and review all city council, and 5/18/2019 9:21 AM
councillors, votes on all issues without having to review the minutes of each meeting individually:.
... ... . ........... ... . . ..... .. .................. ... ......... ..... ......... ......... ........................................... ..................... .................... .......... ... ...... .. .. ..................... ............. .................
35 I really like #2 and #3. See my previous remarks regarding Patricia Tuttle Brown's statement. She 5/17/2019 6:05 PM
nails it regarding PBAC.. What has suffered from this committee's neglect and the city's arrogant
overreach of the Citizen's advice is 1) a screaming need to update our city's Bikeand Ped Master
plan and 2) very poor streets.with no plan to create complete streets. Public oversight over these
committees and commissions is needed -especially since City staff micro manages the meetings.
The net result is a complete lack of democracy and respect of the public's opinion,,
36 I like the final point to engage the hispanic community. It would also help if PPD were not rac*iracists.It 5/17/2019.6:01 PM
would go a long way to create harmony1f PPD didn't treat law-abiding citizens as criminals and
treat hispanics as illegal immigrants and criminals. I mean for just about any interaction., Just
saying, 1 got pulled over because someone stole the tag off my license plate. When giving my
CURRENT registration, the officer treated me like I was a criminal, insinuated that I deliberately
either didn't put the sticker on or that I took it off, and was basically a PRICK on steroids. There
was no need. It was a fix -it ticket! Yet I was treated as if I had committed some GRAVE
OFFENSE. The grave offense was the officer's attitude:. And so maybe some training on.
communication skills for non-violent interactions would help tone down the racism and misogyny in
the PPD. You'd think female officers would be better, but no.
.......... .. .. . ........................................................... .... .... . .. ... . . ................................ ... ...... ..... ....... ...
........
37 Every 6 months, publish all of these full pians, policies, and finances plus summaries thereof 5/17/2019 1:09 PM
online, in news media print, and on the local public access TV and audio channels.
38 No'further comment at this time 5/17/2079 11:00 AM
2/3
0
n gut Summary 2 -Page'31 of 185
F
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
44 If there is a commitment to better communication (you can only go up from here - it has been so 5/17/2019 8:27 AM
awful for so many years), I think you have to have department heads and management that are
not misogynistic, vindictive and archaic in their ways of "leadership" - there is no way to implement
this goal or the work plan unless you make some major changes in management at. the City
Management level as well as maintain a grounded position and move forward methodically and
.4 &
sincerely to build a record. The situation within management, including absence of communication,
control by staff of Commissions and Committees which is both stifling and inappropriate, is so ,
dysfunctional - and this is also supported by and represented by a legal staff with minimal
credibility and, certainly, a lack of ability to communicate and relate, that I do not seethese items
as being able to be implemented unless there is courage for change and action toward that.
Interfacing is the deep political divide."In Petaluma,'regardle8s of what good behavior the elected
officials are portraying at the moment. 1 have never seen anything like the petty and deep hatred
that exists in Petaluma with the election process and the elected officials. Many have their long-
time friends and supporters and there is no opening for growth in awareness or balance in the
political process. How the City Management and communication process exists in this atmosphere
is a reality to be considered.
45 5/16/2019 6:51 PM
46 City workers need to be paid what they deserve and hard earned. Any body who serve with their 5/16/2019 5:26 PM
true interest for the public should be paid better, and not categorized by their job class.
47 fix the existing city web site with search capability. you send out emails that agendas and minutes 5/1-6/2019 1:32 PM
are available, hit the button and it brings up the web that you must search for the noticed item. The
big kids would provide a direct link to the Item advertised.
48 good in theory, but fiscally possible? 5/16/2019 1: 22 PM
49 Rewrite without all the strokes and petting. 5/16/2019 10:44 AM
.............. .. ............ . . ..... ... .... ......
50 Committee communication and summaries are a great step, 5/15/2019 3:49 PM
L
I
0
0
3/3
i
W
n
L7
F
Input Summary.2 -Page 32 of 185
12
.sJ
H
M,
61
'ON
AWL
0
LO
M
9
a
Attachment 3
11
lnppftkult z�iummary H'Iage j3 of ldl
v
0)
z
0
on
00
(1)
w
LO
00
LO
(Y)
M
9
a
Attachment 3
11
lnppftkult z�iummary H'Iage j3 of ldl
v
f
2
u
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOAI..S'2019-2021 F
Attaciment 3
Q55 W_-ia__t do you like about this objective? Or, what is missing?
Answered: 51 Skipped: 224
# RESPONSES
1 All good; just not glamorous
2 The school districts should be tasked with informing all parents of all the elementary schoo
DATE
6/14/2019 7:13 PM
I 6/14/2019 6:44 PM
options and actively encouraging diversity in all its schools. That specifically includes Grant and
1/2
In)ut Summary 2 - Page 34 of 185
McDowell.
3
I like efficiency, effectiveness and customer service..
6/14/2019
.. ..............
2:40 PM
4
Beware the techno fix.
6/13/2019
3,6,23 PM
5
Onflnepermitting would be great. Also bring the Petaluma GIS up to where it was supposed to be
6/11/2019
9:22 PM
when it was first implemented. Show permit history, etc.
6
.............. ............................... ................. .
Increase response to emails by city staff. I have emailed them about issues and NEVER have
6/6/2019
6:25 PM
received a response. Not even a short response.
.......
7
Is number 7 important? Does it stop Monopolies?
6/6/2019
6-:08 PM
8
This goal and objectives look like the earlier one only with technology added
6/6/2019
12:01 PM
9
Is there a problem now with technology?
6/5/2019
8;54 PM
10
This is more in-house for City workers. Everyone knows the City doesn't have the most robust IT
6/5/2019
3:37 PM
capability.
11
Overall, IT won't solve problems. Though I understand the need to be efficient. Keep it simple.
6/4/2019
9:09 PM
12
.................... ..... ... ..........
Technology is important for a well informed community.
...... . .
6/3/2019
7:37 PM
13
will it help entire community or just a few? ?
6/3/2019
4;52 PM
14
stop ruining 5 gen wireless with unnecessary restictions. Fewer plans and more action
6/3/2019
. ........ . ... .... . .
11:59 AM
15
Kids at our grade schools have better website and technology than our city. Need a new IT team.
6/3/2019
6:33 AM
Half of google lives in town cant we recruit some of them to help.
16
.. . .... ....... ................ .. .... . .. . . ............................... ........ . .....
focusing on getting IT personnel for each government entity
...... .... . .... . .
5/31/2019
7:04 PM
17
do not raise our taxes!
................. . . .
5/30/2019
6:03 PM
.. . . . . . . . ....... ..... .... ...
18
It's a nice to have unless you can show specifically how each thing will improve performance.
5/29/2019
5:03 PM
Simple solutions should be favored. The timeframe also is not clear. A lot of money can be wasted
on technology ifimplemented too rapidly.
19
X
5/29/2019
7-:28 AM
20
Petaluma is already doing an excellent IT job. Be careful that a quick expansion does not lead to
5/28/2019
8:56 PM
software nightmares, or increased exposure to sophisticated hacking. Proceed with caution.
21
Sounds good!.
5/28/2019
5:37 PM
22
ditto
5/28/2019
1,W,35 PM
23
Yes, new website that is user friendly, Support City staff with new tech and recommendations on
5/28/2019
11.41 Q AM
needed improvements from staff,
. . . ... . .......... . .. . . . ....... .. .......
24
The right technology can increase efficiency which is critical for resource constrained cities
5/26/2019
2:21 PM
25
Use local or county ISPs only for hosting municipal online presence.
5/23/2019
3:23 PM
26
looks good
5/23/2019
.... _
8:27 AM
27
Look at Truckee and Spokane, WA
5/22/2019
5:48 PM
... ............ : ..... .... . .
28
For the police department, let's see about innovations/up to date technology to make the job easier
5/22/2019
3:53 PM
and keep officers patrolling as opposed to the station as much as possible.
1/2
In)ut Summary 2 - Page 34 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
29
Very reasonable.,
5/21/2019
3:37 PM
30
Can we afford it?
5/19/2019
........................ ...................................... ................... I ...............................
5/16/2019
7:43 PM
31
Yes, the city needs to streamline and technology helps do that.
5/18/2019
.................................................................
5/1
3:43 PM
32
This seems like an obvious goal for the organization. Stay current'.
5/18/2019
. ............................
5/16/2019
12:09 PM
33
It is needed! Keep the public informed of new ITs completed systems.
5/17/2019
.................. ...... ............. ..... ...........................................................
5/16/2019
6:09 PM
34
.. ... ... .. ...... . .
'It's important to have.a good IT framework
5/17/2019
5/15/2019
6:04 PM
35
Every 6 months, publish all of these full plans, policies, and finances plus summaries thereof
5/17/2019
1:09 PM
online, in news media print, and on the local public access TV and audio channels.
36
A good plan to upgrade the IT, but, what is the environmental impact that may effect our health as
5/17/2019
11:04 AM
it is discussed in -many areas on the Internet, regarding 5g, Celt Towers, and EMFs
37
Connectedness
5/17/2019
10:42 AM
38
I am absolutely appalled that technology hasn't been a higher priority for the City and that these
5/17/2019
10-0,15 AM
NORMS in the regular world have not already been integrated into -city systems,, What an absolute
embarrassment],
39 Sounds good 5!17/2019 94034 AM
46
sounds good'
5/16/2019
1:23
PM
................................. ............... ..... ..... .. ..........
47
.................. ........................................................................................ .............. ........................... ....... .......... ............. ............................. ................................... ..........
Great initiative. Make everything online please.
........................ ...................................... ................... I ...............................
5/16/2019
.................. .....................
12:14
...................... .......................... ........... .. .............. ....... . ...................
PM
.. ... .. . ....
48
....... .....
................... ...
..... . ...... ..... .... .......................................................................................................................
5G and wife deployment downtown
.................................................................
5/1
6/201 9 1
1: 11 AM
49
Excellent but make sure we use only proven stuff.
. ............................
5/16/2019
...........................................................
10:46
........ .....
AM
50
.. .......... . . ...... . ... ... ...... . ........... ...... ... .......
We definitely need to.keep up with technology.,
........... .............. ........... ...................... .. . ....... ................. ................... ..... .. . ........ . ... . . ..................
.................. ...... ............. ..... ...........................................................
5/16/2019
................... ..........................................
10:612
.. ...... ....... .............. .... .... ... . .... ...........
AM
51
........................ ................
Online access is very important.
. ........ ...................... ......................... .................. ......... ............ ... ..................... .............. .. .. .. ............ .............................. ...................... . ... . .... .. ................ ................ ... . .. . ..... .............. ............... .. ... ...... ............... . I . ....... ............. ...................... ..... .. .......... . .................... ... ...................... ..............
5/15/2019
3:51 PM
.. ....
2/2
Input Summary 2 ::'age 35 of 185
4
CITY COUNCIL DR -AFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q56 What do you like about these work plan items? Or, what are ve
missing?
Answered: 42
Skipped. 233
# RESPONSES DATE
1 Add: Create "wi-fi free" zones in our downtown. Insure the safety and privacy of our community by 6/16/2019 4;09 PM
carefully evaluating all 5G and facial recognition technologies.
2 I especially like #'s 2, 4 and 6. 6/14/2019 25-40 PM
3 I hope a serious vetting process will evaluate any proposed technologies for their impacts on the 6/13/2019 3:23 PM
environment, city employees and the community as a whole.
4 I don't know. 6/6/2019 61108 PM
. ...........
5 combine this goal with previous one, it is not uniquely different 6/6/2019 12:01 PM
6 2 and 4 seem appropriate. How do the others help citizens as opposed to employees? 6/5/2019 8:54 PM
.. ...............
7 Love Residential Fiber - we need to bring Sonic to every door. Comcastis the only real option for 6/5/2019 7:27 PM
residential bandwidth in Petaluma right now, and they are a heinous company on many fronts,,
End their monopoly by promoting local competition. Sonic is a great west coast company to start
with:. Many more should be encouraged to promote healthier tech ecosystem. Municipal bandwidth
should be explored as this could not only create a healthy, community focused technology
1 /2
Input Summary 2 -Page 36 of 185
0
i
{
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
27 I'm not opposed to most of this. But I think priorities should focus more on improving infrastructure 5/17/2019 6:04 PM
for the citizens and this sounds super costly. Maybe do less on this and more on potholes, transit,
bike lanes and -infrastructure. Better integration for non -car travel between east and west sides.
... ......... ........ : . ......... ........ ................. ......... . .......................................... ..................
..
28 Every 6 months, publish all of these full plans, policies, and finances plus'summaries thereof 5/17/2019 1:09 PM
online, in news media print, and on the local public access TV and audio channels.
... .. ...................... ..
29 Please do. all your research to makethis a great accomplishment 5/17/2019 11:04 AM-
30
Use technology to keep staffing levels optimal and efficient.. 5/17/2019 11:00 AM
.. . . ................ ... ........ ....... .... : .......... ...... ....... ... ............ ...... ........... .... .. .. ...... .................. ........ . ..... ..... ........... .... .................. . ... . ................... ....... ............................... ........... . ..... ...................................... .................................... ................... ...... .... ...... ......... ....
31 Interesting 5/17/2019 10:42 AM
. . ....... .... ... ........................................... ..................................................... . ..................................... ......................... . ......... .. . ..... .. ....... ... ... . ... ..... ... . ............ .. ... ........ . . ..... .. ... ... ...... ............ .. . .............. ... .................... ... ....................... .... ........... .. . .......... ....... . ... ..... ... . .... ...... ............................................................ ........ ............ ... ............. .. .. . .... ...... ................................. I ... . . . .. .. .. . ..... ....... ............. ..
32 I would add a city wide free WiFL It's incredible and so great to use when I've visited other cities 5/17/2019.9:34 AM
(small and large) that have it. Also, a comprehensive city app would be great. Transportation, city
search, events, maps of key locations and art installations, parks, etc. User friendly and one stop
whan nmmnarPri to "nnnnlinn" natali ima
existing parks and public spaces, remove litter, then move on to other issues.
i
2/2
0
Input Summary 2 - Page 37 of 185
33
No 5g No 5g
5/17/2019
9:33
AM
34
. .. .. .. .. ...
Leverage technology to promote Petaluma for tourism and business.
5/17/2019
9:31
AM
.... . ... ..... .. ......
35
... .. .... .. . . ... ................. ............ ..................... ..... .. ... ..... . ....... ... ... . .. .. .. .... ..... ....... .................
..... .... .. ..... ..... ........ .. ..... .....
5/16/2019
6:52
PM
............ ..... ......... . .... ........................... ............. ...................... ..... ................................. .. ... . ........... ......
None. Just please spend the budget as you spends g family budget
..............:36
5/16/2019
5:27
PM
..................................
37
.... .. .. . ........ . .................... ....................... .... ..... ............................................ ......... .... .. ... ..................... ... .......................................... ......... ................ . . ... ...... .... ... .......... .... . .... ..... .... . . .. .
This survey is much too long. Focus first on making ourroadways safe for all, maintain our
.... .. ..... .. . . ... . . . .............................................
5/16/2019
....................................................
........... ... ...
4:41
. .... ........ .... ..... ..
PM
existing parks and public spaces, remove litter, then move on to other issues.
i
2/2
0
Input Summary 2 - Page 37 of 185
U
Vlip.AL A Q rvM_1
lararo'14,11
'Alk, I IN "U'r
:a
II IM
me
ildeve lop
s. ,.
t
§.: ,.. .. n :: v ,. ::i .., :` i :i. ,. � �. . . ,,. r :" tea: .. .. •,: ;{:
u,
0440 � W!or:kv%la:!n Iternse.
3,0 Consider participati,
practices.
5. Install solar
ng in Sonoma Clean Power
EvierGreen programl
s
f
;
s
program for otenval revenue enerationt
6,,,. Eneva e t; theCry,
1W.&I
Rergrional
'1 1 Iffift 11 0 1 t is & 9
9'reve-opment ot a ci y-wiae Cli-ma -e Action an
onmen:tal
stan and, community the
'�1 in
ycled OTT
M MO.,.1AT.
9. Continue to expand
I
1
upgraded housing and commercial structures.
pipes, and implementing the water/sewermasterplan
12. Increase organic diversion from landfills.
13. Install consistent three stream receptacles at all City facilities.
14,, Adopt a citywide single -use plastic and polystyrene ban.
15,. Extend Urban Growth Boundary expiration date beyond 2025 via ballot measure.
0
Input YPage
C
DI
M
E
m
0�0
U)
w
z
0
CD
W
a
CY)
a
Oo
a
El
13
wi
y
a e uf
U, it. Ipummar
a
11
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT -GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
Q38 What do you like about this goal? Or, what are we missing?
Answered: 95 Skipped: 180
# RESPONSES
DATE.
1 Include "drawdown" in this goal 6/16/2019 4:05 PM
2 All good! Challenging,,, 6/14/2019 7:08 PM
3 It addresses' the need for a citywide single use plastics and polystyrene ban and establishment of 6/14/2019 6:32 PM
acitywide sustainability program.
4 I don't support any part of this goal. None of t
his is the role of city government nor government at
any level. Where in the constitution, the city charter, the state documents are these ideas
6/14/2019 2:26 PM
mandated or encouraged?
5 I would like that, but just how will it happen with all the building?? Hmmmm 6/13/2019 6:15 PM
.. ..... . ..
6 I challenge the oxymoron of sustainable development. 6/13/2019 3:12 PM
7 I think there are good ideas but next to impossible to implement. For Item 1 we need a GOOD' 6/11/2019 8:32 PM
traffic engineer, not someone who received his degree in a Cracker Jack box.. Item 10 can put
undue burdens on some homeowners, so this would have to be studied very carefully, especially
fors'enior citizens who may not drive that much anyway. Item 12 would have to be monitored
closely, as I take great care to make sure "Green".waste does not gointo landfill and vice versa,
only to see the garbage men not care which can goes into which side of the truck. Item 14 Define
"Single use" - I use the plastic straw from 7-11 in my coffee cup and get close to 90 uses before it
starts to crack, and I have to go to 7-11 to buy another soda to get another straw. Item 15 Why be
1/4
nput Summary 2 -Page 40 of 185.
0
concerned about the urban growth boundary when we are not to far away for our 75K max
population? Won't all new residential construction stop then anyway?
8
.... ......................
financing.?
6/6/2019
8:27
PM
9
. .........
there was a site close by, on Stage Gulch road, for green waste recycling. Even though the
6/6/2019
6:18
PM
county decided not to use it, it may b.e something Petaluma could use.,
10
number 4,5,6,7,11 and 15 are good
................. .... . ..
6/6/2019
6:00
PM
11
some good
6/6/2019
5;03
PM
12
The increasing CO2 in our atmosphereis no joke. If we don't handle this in the next decade,
6/6/2019
3:28
PM
nothing else will really matter. I believe it is that serious.
13
I like the goal
6/6/2019
2:09
PM
14
I love these! They should be our constant guide!
6/6/2019
1:07
PM
15
Yes! More bike lanes.. _
6/6/2019
....................
12:029 PM
16
We'have nothing if we don't take care of our climate.
6/6/2019
12:14 PM
17
The efforts towards conservation and preservation of the spaces
6/6/2019
11:39 AM
18
Must keep and adhere to urban growth boundaries.
6/5/2019
10:31
PM
19
I'm not sure reducing greenhouse gases is a viable goal
6/5/2019
8:31
PM
20
Love the Goal.
6/5/2019
7:12
PM
21
I don't care for this goal. I think we have to focus on what needs to be fixed now. This is way too
6/5/2019
3:25
PM
'a
far reaching when there are so many more attainable goals right now. Sorry, too idealistic.
22
There's a misunderstanding inherent in this Goal statement. "Reducing greenhouse gas
6/5/2019
2:00
PM
emissions" just slows down the pace at which we're making things worse. The real problemis not
current greenhouse gas emissions, it's all of the greenhouse gases already in the atmosphere that
will continue to warm the planet for centuries to come. Just reducing greenhouse gas emissions
barely makes a dent in "...preserving and protecting Petaluma's environment for future
generations. °
1/4
nput Summary 2 -Page 40 of 185.
0
5
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
Downtown projects get more importance when it comes to climate change.
vehicles is okay for some but certain vehicles cant be incorporated,. Public works.police and fire
should not be considered in this. Maybe put a solar field on Lafferty to' generate energy for city
infrastructure. Public access wouldnt be an issue and then we would actually use the land for
once".
29 Missing: EIR says no more development on marshes -- we need that land for rain,absorption. With 6/1/2019 10:40 AM
rising sea level, we should not be building on the marshes. I think we are risking lawsuits by
Downtown merchants.
30 I like the use of solar energy and recharging stations 5/31/2019 6:57 PM
.. .......................................... .. ...... .. .......... . ..................... . ....... ................... ....... I- ........... 11 ...... 11 ...... ......
.......................... ....... ...... ........ .... ............. . .. .. ... ......... ............................................................... ................................... ................................................ .. .............................. . ...... ...................... .. ................ .......... .. .. .... ........................................................ . .... ................ ..... ..... ............ .
2/4.
Input Summary 2 - Page 41 of 185
Y
i
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-202 1
F
Attachment 3
50 It's reasonable and appropriate, subject to the comment below under work plan items. 5/21/2019 11:06 AM
transportation for work and errands.
53 Really like idea of electric vehicle fleet, more utilization of solar & better green waste mgmt. I live in 5/20/2019 9:54 AM
a multi residential bldg. downtown. There is no room for the huge green waste bins in my single
car garage. Give us other options,
...........
54 Yes! 5/20/2019 8:39 AM
55 All good 5/19/2019 7:319 PM
56 Yes to all of the above. If we don't protect our environment, we will not be sustainable. 5/18/2019 3:37 PM
57 Yes! All efforts on any of the goals and objectives in this plan should have the environment and 5/18/2019 12:02 PM
sustainability embedded not just a separate goal.
58 This is just a feel -good goal that will cost too much and simply increase cost of living, 5/18/2019 -8:08 AM
59 We need to revisit the urban growth boundry in 2025.. Petaluma has changing needs and we need 5/17/2019 81920 PM
to make sure our growth boundaries are in line with the needs of the population.,
60. This goal is admirable, however more focus should be placed on the nuts -and -bolts infrastructure 5/17/2019 71,056 PM
A.
•
3/4
Input Summary 2 - 'age 42 of 185
of the city, with these type of items -added on as the infrastructure improves.,
61
IP
Missing City ban on all known toxins on lublic land Reduce environmental toxic exposures for all
5/17/2019
7:28 PM
Petaluma citizens
62
Why does this (and other goals) not include any improvements for public transit? I would gladly
5/17/2019
5:43 PM
take public transit from east to west side but it is STUPID to take a bus several blocks (but over 20
min walk) to then have to catch another bus across town. There should be a bus that runs a loop
from downtown Petaluma blvd to redwood to N McDowell to E Washington. It should run every 10
mins or so. If all 1 had to do was catch one bus I would be using them, but for it to take 30-40
minutes to go the few miles from east to downtown is insane. You will not get people out of their
cars unless the public transit is frequent and reasonably priced. When I walk I see only poor
Mexicans and elderly waiting for the bus. Why? Because if you can afford. it you drive, and there is
zero incentive to walk or bike or take transit. if I walk from my, home to the TJ shopping center, itis
an ugly walk down the 4 lane road and there is never anyone walking but me. If Petaluma wants to
be more pedestrian friendly, create more pedestrian friendly walking spaces.
.. ........ ........... . .... ........ . . ... . . .
63
Protecting our environment is a top priority,
5/1
7/201 9
5:20 PM
64
..........
Fix the roads
5/17/2019
2.0-L56 PM
65
Enact mandatory compliance of #1 with specific improvement outcomes for Petaluma s industries
5/17/2019
12:50 PM
that are the most environmentally detrimental; this is probably agriculture and animal husbandry.
66
THE NUMBER ONE PRIORITY..
5/17/20119
12:38 PM.
67
Great
5/17/2019
10:54 AM
68
. .. . . .......
Sounds like a good plan for our city and the environment
5/17/2019
....................
. ............
10-4:50 AM
Pe
69
All good
5/17/2019
10,25 AM
70
Agree with all of this.
5/17/2019
10:17 AM
71
Find a way to do all this without increasing taxes.
5/17/2019
10:04 AM
72
#5-15 - All YES
5/17/2019'9:25
AM
73
It's good
5/17/2019
9:22 AM
74
I like this goal, but do not know if we should be allocating too many resources to it.
5/17/2019
9:21 AM
75
All good! Investigate use of wind power, by City or even individual homeowners, epecially given
5/17/2019
94: 10 AM
our frequest high winds!
76
You have way too many mixed goals in this bucket. Fix the infrastructure we have already paid for
5/17/2019
9:10 AM
and hold off on the "green deal" stuff. You can do that when you have a reserve. Petaluma is not
going effect global warming,
..... ... ........ ..... .
A.
•
3/4
Input Summary 2 - 'age 42 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 201.9-2021 Attachment 3
77 I really agree... 5/ 17/2019 9:05 AM
78 This goal misses defining further "our river and open space" The City doesn't have any plan or 5/17/2019 8:14 AM
approach to "open space." The river is a tidal slough - and a lot of people frankly in the community
of 60,000 have no interest in or even care about "the river"Ahat is talked about so much - it's a nice
place for sitting outside at a cafe - it's an important natural resource as an adjunct to the wetlands but the awareness of that is overridden by a romantic notion that somehow the Petaluma River is
like the Russian River, when it is completely different. - it's good for some recreation -and it exists
adjacent to the wetlands, and that is actually about the extent of it.
.. .... . . ........ . .. ... ..... .....
79 0 5/16/2019 6:48 PM
.......... . ... . ... ............ .... ....... . ..... ..... ...... ........ . .. ......................... ..................................... ........ ...... .. . ......... ................... ..... .......... ........ ............. .... . .... . .. ..... . . ......... ....... ... ...... .... . .... . . . . . .. .. .. ... ..
1P
80 We have enough electric car parking. All electric car parking space should be further away from, 5/16/2019 5:15 PM
low -
entice and entertain the populace that you need to persist in these fossil fueled, noisy, polluting
behaviors? -What is Progressive or protective of our environment about the Speedway or Cruisin'
the Blvd..? Its well past time for the hot rod mentality to die before we expire from their polluting
our air and ruining the enjoyment of our homes and gardens, which we as homeowners/residents.
a
11
q
4/4
C
s
L
In gut Summary 2 -Page 43 of 185
f
ME
1
CI"1'Y COiJNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
I
Attaciment 3
Q39 What do you like about this objective? Or, what are we missing?.
Answered., 58
RESPONSES
Skipped-, 217
would like a Rites of Nature ordinance and more push on businesses to be responsible for their
narkaninn
DATE"'
6/14/2019 6:32 PM
Pius, 15 items is too -many. I don't care enough about this objective to offer input.
13 This objective should be stated in terms of reducing City-wide greenhouse gas emissions to zero 6/5/2019 2:00 PM
by 2030 or other date that is consistent with the IPCC Special Report on Global Warming of 1.5'
deg C and with Jerry Brown's 2018 Executive Order #8-55-18.
14- Missing the need fo.r sustainability, URGENCY, and bold steps. 6/4/2019 8;59 PM
15 The objective is missing the key ingredient of citizen education and buy -in. 6/4/2019 12:35 AM
.. .. .... ..
16 What is missing is our city council treating east Petaluma the same as West Petaluma. They only 6/3/2019 7:23 PM
care about what happens in down town Petaluma,
17 ways to pay for it without charging community 6/3/2019 4:52 PM
18 it is a series of largely pointless or outright damaging attempts at virtue signalling at taxpayer 6/3/2019 11:49 AM
expense.
19 nothing to add at this time 5/31/2019 6:57 PM
.............................................. .... ...
20 nothing 5/30/2019 5:52 PM
21 Dutra asphalt plant -big fat NO - do NOT let that go through 5/29/2019 9:33 PM
.. ...........
22 Objective is good. 5/29/2019 4:36 PM
23 X 5/29/2019 7:26 AM
24 How about just getting the City on EVERGREEN; show us that something is getting done!!! 5/28/2019 1:32 PM
25 Single use plastics ban. Yes! 5/28/2019 10:58 AM
0
0
1l3
Input Summary 2 - Page 44 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DR -AFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
26 We need to install solar panels on the 10 -wastewater treatment ponds at the Ellis Creek Facility. 5/27/2019 1:00 PM
Install a solar water heating system to help heat the digesters instead of burning methane and sell
the excess methane instead. Speed up the process of accepting high strength waste forthe
digesters (dairy and food processing as well as beer brewing spoils) to generate more methane.
Identify more methane customers other than Recology. Use reclaimed water to recharge our
r
aquifers in the winter months when the water is not wanted by ag customers and others fo
ation. Explore using treated wastewater fora "toilet to tap" program as
irrig
I . gets more scarce. Explore partnering with other Nor-inDay cities to start ou
fresh. drinking water
r own facility to turn
sludge from Ellis Creekinto fertilizer instead of sending it to the landfill. Attract business who can
ocally recycle plastic waste into usable products (like plastic used for 3-D printing machines)
nstead of shipping.it off to. China. All new developments should. be, require to have Level 1
charging (120v) located at every parking space, wiring for a Level 2 station' in every garage and.,.
shared bevel 2 charging in multi unit complexes. All city vehicles that can be, should be converted
to EV or hybrid. Work with the owners of shopping centers to install solar panels over as many of
theirparking spaces as possible,,
.... . ... .. .. ... ..... . ... .. ... . . . .. .... . ......................... ...... ....... .......... .................... ..... . ...
27 Yes on using Sonoma Clean Power. CeaseP ublic funds ex penditures on corrupt energy providers 5/23/2019 3:11 PM
w
2/3
1 n gut Summary 2 - 'age 4 5 of 185
0
n
CITY COL7NCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attaciment 3
47 Safeway gas station. Why is it allowed to be built close to school 5/16/2019 5:15 PM
48 Cost -benefit analysis. 5/16/2019 3:21 PM
49 Waste can be converted to energy, along with plastics 5/1 6/201 9 3:19 PM
50 Include all income apartment communities. Where I live, the laundry hours are set from 8X"9. If we 5/16/2019 2:31 PM
are having a spare the air day, or it's very hot, the hours are not conducive to saving energy.
Owned by public non profit developer. And, to get hot water we have to waste a lot of water. This
is AFTER a rehab to be better at efficiently. It's worse because they didn't want to pay the money
for a recirculating Filter of some sort. Just one example of why we need a Housing Oversight
0
L
1P
r
3/3 Input Summary 2 - Page 46 of 185
f
CITY COiJNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
Q40 What do you -Ike about these work plan items'?, Or, what are we
missing?
Answered: 58
(3) Require all new development to participate in EverGreen
Ordinance (13) and on public streets Add
Climate Commission
Skipped: 217
16. Adopt an ordinance creating and empowering a
6/16/2019 4:05 PM
............................ , - :. .'.' - - '. . , . - . .. -, '. - , — . . ... .... . ......... .......... :.,: . .,. .... .. - .. .. .: .. .. - ... . . - .... . - -- .-- - - - - . - -- - - - --- - - - . ... - .. - -- .. .. . - : ............... .
2 This is ridiculous. You are dragging many people along on goals that they do not support and you 6/14/2019 2:26 PM
are wasting precious resources on things that will have noimpact toward your stated goals. These
objectives are driven by group** think, unproven fears and ideals and especially unproven and very
recycling options as well as being required to recycle trash and compost all organics; Recology
needs to be required to provide adequate foodwaste recycling options for all Petaluma restaurants,
delis, cafes, etc..
. .. .. . .. ........ ......................... ......................... I .......................... I ........ ... .. . . .
4 See Above _ 6/11/2019 8:32 PM
.. .. . ... ... ............................................. .. .. ................................... .. ... ... . . ........ . . .............. ........................................................ ...... .. ...... ......... ............. ........ .........
5 Add this item: 1) Identify methods to update city infrastructure to support transition to fossil -fuel free 6/6/201.9 9:51 PM
transportation
.............. . ..... .... ...... .. .....
6 We feel the fairgrounds needs to be man ed with as many efforts towards sustainability and 6/6/2019 6:17 PM
conservation as possible.. With along-term lease in place, greater attention can be paid to
improving buildings and utilizing solar energy and natural light where appropriate. -The soft-scaped
areas are evaluated regularly for water use efficiency and kept conducive to water percolation
limiting runoff and erosion. The property has a tree care plan to help increase available shade,
reduce h8rdscape temperatures and encourage water percolation. Ornamental plants are
continuously changed out for perennial, drought tolerant varieties where. appropriate. This year we
will be implement a new recycling strategy for our concession waste that will drastically reduce the
impact on the landfill. All buildings are painted with recycled paint when regular maintenance is
performed. In addition to all the efforts listed above, the fairgrounds is a valuable forum to educate
the community of the latest conservation options and techniques available so homeowners -can
implement the same practices on their proper -ties. - Sonoma -Marin Fairgrounds' Board of Directors
.................... ........ .. .... ..... .................... ........ .......................... ............... ............... . ..................................................................................... ......... ........... .. ....... ... .. .... . . ...... I..: ............ _...: ..................... . .. ................. r: . .......... ..... ...... .. ...... . . . . . . . . .. ... . . . . ... .. ...... .. .... . ... .. .. . .... . ... . . .
7 Good start.,.. 6/6/2019 6:00 PM
............. . ........ ... . . ............................................................... ................................
. ...
....... .....
.... .....
.......................... ........................
......... ...................
. .................
8 Some of the items could be. simplified if we agreed to go all -electric. 1 know there are some issues 6/6/2019 3:28 PM
with doing that, but in the Big Picture, it would help get us to where we need to be. The rest we
can figure out. Also, for greater impact, the City should divest from any investmentin fossil fuels or
in banks that loan to fossil fuel companies." We need impacts of greater scale than improving
buildings one at'a time,.
9 15 -expand urban boundary - NO NO NO NO NO F1 -x what we have. Make what we have more'
6/6/2019 2:09 PM
evironmentally sustainable,, DO NOT EXPAND
.............. ......... .............. ... . .............. : ......... ..... ....... .... ... .. . . ... ...... .... . . . ... ... ..... . .. .. . .... . . . .. . . . .. .. ... .... . .... .. .. ...... ... ... . . ..... ... : ... .... .... .......... ..... ..... .. . . . .... . ...... . ......... ..... ............ ..
10 Strongly support these workplan items. Make climate mitigation and adaptation the City's #1 6/6/2019 1:56 PM
priority.
11 They seem tangible and accessible 6/6/2019 11:39 AM
.................................... ...... .. . ......... ".,: ........ :: .... . ....... .............................. .. ... ................... .. ....... .. ........ .............. ............. .......... ...... ...... .......... .. .. ....... ..... ..... .. . ..... ........ ... . ... . .... ... .. ........ . ... ... . .. ..... ...... ........... ...... . ....... ..................... ... .. . ..... ........... .......... ...... .... ... . ...... ..
12 Planning for re -approval of urban growth boundary. 6/5/201.9 10:31 PM
................. . . ................ .......... ..... ...................... ......... : .............. .. .. . .......... ............... ........... .............. ... .... ................ ................. ..................... :: ....... ............ .... . ....... ... ..... .. .. .......... -- ------
13 I don't understand all the work items. Some of them seem like wishlist items; not realistic. Too 6/5/2019 8:31 PM
many workitems will spread the city's resources too thin.
..... .... . . . .... .. . ................................ .................................... ...... ............
e ....................
.............. :
: ........
............................
14 Missed: Public transportation'. Completely missed not just here but seemingly throughout all the 6/5/2019 7:12 PM
plans so far.
.................
.......... . ........................ .... . ...... .. ............ ....................... ........... ................ . . ... ... ..................... ........................... .............. ........... ....... .. . ... . ... ... ... ... .
15 15 items is too many which leads me to believe Council is giving way too much leeway to a vocal 6/5/2019 3:25 PM
minority.
........ ... ..... .. ... ... .. . . . .
1/3
Input Summary 2 -Page 47 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
16 Item #4. "Establish and momote a citywide sustainability program leading with exemplary 6/5/2019 2R#00 PM
environmental practices." This either means nothing or everything. All the other work plan items
could conceivably be included in a "citywide sustainability plan."
.... ........ ... ............ .................. . .. . ..... . ... .. ....... ..... ..
17 1. Replace "reduce" and "minimize" with "eliminate." 3. Strike "consider." PARTICIPATE! This is 6/4/2019 8:59 PM
long overdue. 8., "Framework" should move quickly to PLAN. 11. SO IMPORTANT!'
18 The work plan items are all excellent. What's missing is establishing a climate commission or 6/4/2019 12;35 AM
cabinet to keep the focus on tracking and reducing greenhouse gases, educating and involving
citizens to support citywide policies, and staying informed of expert best practices. Developing a
city-wide Climate Action Plan will only be effective if there's a body/commission for tracking the
action plan's progress and updating it longterm, so that it's more than a plan on paper. It needs an
implementing body. In the past, there have been "green teams" within the city that went nowhere
packaging in our markets. With a properly defined scope this could be effective. Perhaps a fee
If
2/3 Input Summary 2 -Page 48 of 185
structure could be implemented as well.
25
..... ....... ..... ... . ......
X
5/29/2019 7:26 AM
26
ditto
5/28/2019 1 :32 PM
27
All great things. But they aren't meaningful unless you also include a commitment to a pesticide**
5/28/2019 12:42'PM
free public space. The river will never be fully alive with herbicide residue draining into it.
28
I support environment upgrades to the water treatment facility
5/28/2019 10:58 AM
29
Do not expand the city limits. Yes on more solar power.
... . ... ....... ..... ... ..... .
5/23/2019 3:11 PM
30
somethings needs to be added to encourage other forms of transportation such and bicycling and
5/23/2019 86915 AM
walking. This can b e -achieved by creating safe conditions for bicycling and walk by improving and
.. . ... ..... .
maintaining facilities that support this.
.............
31
Needs to include giving citizens the option not to drive -- biking, walking, transit, etc.
.5/21/2019 2:32 PM
32-I
don't know what we're missing. And neither does anyone else. The science and realities of
5/21/2019 11:06 AM
climate change are continuing to evolve. Topics that were barely considered twenty years ago are
now considered key to the battle in which we are engaged. The current list of work plan items
seems to imply that we know the steps that must be taken. But we don't. That list will continue to
evolve, likely even more quickly than we can imagine, We need to be taking the steps laid out
here, we also need to be open to education and the addition of further steps. That is the role of the
Climate Cabinet incorporated into the recently adopted Climate Emergency Resolution, a point
that should be more fully elucidated among the work plan items.
33
Wonderful!
5/20/2019 9:58 AM
34
Allgood
5/19/2019 7:39 PM
35
More non -Tesla charging stations! Ban single use plastics!
5/19/2019 5:10 PM
36
Work item 1, while a worthy thought,is not very actionable, especially compared to the others,
5/19/2019 2:40 PM
Suggest these be reviewed to be specific and directly actionable. In addition to city actions, I'd also
encourage rain water harvesting by citizens for irrigation use.. Perhaps hold workshops on water
usage and rain water retention, so that folks are not free lancing these systems; code
requirements are not clear, and a little knowledge could go a long way. Yes on the single use
plastic ban.,
37
. ... .............................. ............ ....... .................. ...... .. ....... ........................... ...... ............ ...................... ........................ . ......... .... . ............
We need to address soil, air, water in order to keep Petaluma livable..
5/18/2019 3:37 PM
38
Redundant
5/17/2019 7:28 PM
39
Missing public transit
5/17/2019 5:43 PM
If
2/3 Input Summary 2 -Page 48 of 185
I
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
years due to drought and disease, without being replaced. Replace them would be a fairly simple,
not too expensive goal, and provide for their watering for first year. Long term, consder becoming
a Tree City again. The other obvious area tha
t needs attention is applying recycling laws to
4
M
0
313
Input Summary 2 -Page 49 -of 185
El
11
I
nk
r.
un
en
DI
Min
�!
mZ
17
"Iff �d
.- :: `�'Is , l
p.::a..,
0
Ill
U
13
0401 armill As,% All 400%
12
0
I��
a F'w
1
�
41;yr
I,"iol
I1,�
s,„. I ^'.
Irb1'!:', ';���' "�,"�,I�I�
\I '',:j',I' yW�IY ��� ! ��
it
nk
r.
un
en
DI
Min
�!
mZ
17
"Iff �d
.- :: `�'Is , l
p.::a..,
0
Ill
U
13
0401 armill As,% All 400%
12
0
Svy
it
nk
r.
un
en
DI
Min
�!
mZ
17
"Iff �d
.- :: `�'Is , l
p.::a..,
0
Ill
U
13
0401 armill As,% All 400%
12
0
a
U
-MI
FFAA Qlr4ro'T�'Irsa
041. 1 042 Uf�jerhive 2 � f'rvmvf,e bt'ilclinq raivacices ariil
act/viec.<anservc�ti
P
etal L-1 In ra r# en � si d s.
1. Educate our community and provide sustainability tools for City st
property
S
Q43, wo Workplan Items.
Downers and all residents.
I'll
2,. Work with Recology to increase the diversion of waste away from the landfill.
I
0r1;
jy�b
aff/ developers, employers,
3. Implement Bust
REACH goals.
4. Continue focus
tices that exceeaiY !t codes i.ncludmg implementation of
on water conservation and urb"an recycled'water expansion.,
F
ilummary z Fage bl� of., 1 b5
n
M,
M
11
u
E-1
R
E
EWA—kl
6ZAM
rlj%�lq
Lipm
mmr-�l
LqL-j
u
Mala
3
a
Ci
IL if
In ut 6ummary z Haye 2 of 100
a
:w
U)
z
0cy
OL
P%,
00
U)
0)co
uj
0
CY)
4
C)
cy)
Mala
3
a
Ci
IL if
In ut 6ummary z Haye 2 of 100
a
CITY COUNCIL DR -AFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q42 What do you l'a ike about this.o bjective? Or, what are we missing?
Answered: 64 Skipped: 211
0
come from policy, not voluntary measures. These have not had a significant impact so far. One
item not mentioned is Sea Level Rise. Do we know what impacts to expect by.the end of this
century and what is needed to prepare for that? The discussion should begin and a fund started to
1 /3
0
Input Summary 2 - Page 53 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
1
ir
Attachment 3
30 I support all of these goals 100°/a 5/27/2019 1:01 PM
31
Excellent objective
5/26/2019
2:13 PM
32
Ban the use and sale of Round -up in the city limits.
5/23/2019
3:13 PM
33
looks ok
5/23/2019
8J4117 AM
34
Let the public know,where the plastic recycling bins are located. It's not enough to say plastic bags
5/21/2019
11:33 AM
should not go in the residential recycle bins. The paper has written on this but was not clear about
the locations city-wide where one could dispose of these type items.. An on -line -search resulted in
states of emergency, medical provider items that must be sterile. (2) Incentivize
businesses/employers that turn recycled materials into in demand products to locate their
2/3- Input Summary 2 - Page 54 of 185
}
two places, but only one was in use.,
35
Same comments as for previous objective.
5/21/2019
11:07 AM
36
Require smart building in housing -not cookie cutter like what Davidon proposes
5/20/2019
12:53 PM
37
All good
5/19/2019
7;40
PM
38
See comments on previous objective and work items.
5/19/2019
2:40
PM
39
Yes..,to all
5/18/2019
3:37
PM
40
Again, should be embedded i.n all goals and objectives. Not a separate line item.,
5/18/2019
12:03 PM
41
............ . ..... ... ... - -
Me h..
5/17/2019
5.44
PM
42
Lofty but doable.
5/17/2019
5:25
..........
PM
43
......... ....................... ............ "I .. ........... ................. ...... .... . .. ..... ... ... ... . . . ....... ....... ......... . . .. . . . . . . ... ... . ............ ........
(1) Ban use of any new.plastic items with exceptions for emergency responders, natural disasters,
.............. ........... ..............................................
5/17/2019
. . ..... .
...... .
1:03
PM
states of emergency, medical provider items that must be sterile. (2) Incentivize
businesses/employers that turn recycled materials into in demand products to locate their
2/3- Input Summary 2 - Page 54 of 185
}
CITY COL7NCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-202'1 Attachment 3
62 Please help Recology to work on recycling. It would also be great if there was a compost initiative- 5/16/2019 11:19 AM
in other coyotes they even have small bins for compost items and it would be nice if that was a
possibility.as well!
63 I am fine with this as it focuses on Petaluma 5/16/2019 10:32 AM
........ .. .. . ... . ........ .. .
64 Excellent. 5/15/2019 3:42 PM
3/3. Input Summary 2 -Page 55 -of 185.
r
h
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 20'19-2021 Attachment 3
Q43 What do you like about these work plan items?. Or, what are we
missing?.
Answered: 47
RESPONSES
Skipped: 228
Add: Explore the
redesign of rainwater management systems to capture and reuse
water,
Limit the
use of lawn area
in new development to a small percentage -of overall landscaping.
Create
a tree
DATE
6/16/2019 4;09 PM
112
Input Summary 2 - 'age 56 of 185
planting and soil building plan for all "green" spaces including parks, open spaces, medians, and
planting areas.
2
Water storage is missing
6/14/2019 6.:34 PM
3
I like the recycled water things.
6/14/2019 2:27 P'M
4
You are ruining Petaluma s heritage and open space.
. . . . . .. . .... . ......... ... ...... .... .. .... . ...........
6/13/2019 6:16 PM
5
Nothing here about urban forests, heat island mitigation, or climate change.
6/13/2019 3:14 PM
6
as recycled water users, we see more expansion as depletion of our use; need more update and
6/6/2019 80629 PM
information on plans
7
Makes a lot of sense.
6/6/2019 6FOI PM
8
. ........ . . .
Make structures as air -tight as feasible. Over insulate. Power with electricity. Provide proper air
6/6/2019 3:38 PM
ventilation. Minimize waste. It is that simple.,
9
...... ....... .
Whatever you do, please make sure there is a balance with all these changes to make us more
6/6/2019 2:11 PM
evironmentally friendly. How are we going to pay for it? Is the cost of living in Petaluma going to go
up? If so then this goal might defeat the earlier goal of having housing that is affordable.
10
Provide dedicated space on the City's website for education around sustainable building practices
6/6/2019 1:58 PM
and conservation.'.
11
the plan ideas are like the previous they can' be interwoven
6/6/2019 11:45 AM
12
Same as last question
6/5/2019 8:32 PM
13
Missing: The city itself needs to provide recycling and compost disposal bins in downtown areas.
6/5/2019 7:14 PM
Take a look at any of the downtown pubic trashcans on any day of the week. FILLED WITH
PLASTICS. These are presumably all going into landfills?
14
Common sense.
6/5/2019 3:26 PM
15
Clarification: "reach codes" should not be confused with REACH helicopter services. They are
6/5/2019 2:06 PM
locally -adopted changes to the state Energy Codes that requires a level of energy performance
that exceeds state Code. Proposed reach codes must be proved cost-effective, approved by the
CA Energy Commission, and then adopted locally.
16
With all the other goals and work plan items the city is aiming for, will there be enough sustained
6/4/2019 12:49 AM
focus on these items in particular without a climate cabinet or commission whose sole focus would
be these items and additional, not yet known items in our rapidly innovating climate crisis.
17
works only if community is behind project
6/3/2019 4:52 PM
18
More marsh parks trails as usage for that land rather than building on it..
6/1/2019 10-042 AM
19
Getting the resources needed to help educate our community
5/31/2019 6:58 PM
20
nothing
_ 5/30/2019 5:53 PM
21
X
5/29/2019 7`.26 AM
......... . .. .. ...... .. I ..........
22
ditto
... ... . ... ......
5/28/2019 1:33 PM
23
Sustainability is wonderful.. If you aren't just using it as a buzzword. It's not just about recycling and
5/28/2019 1:00 PM
reducing energy and water use. Those are good things, but not enough,, You also have to commit
to nontoxic pest control and other products.,
112
Input Summary 2 - 'age 56 of 185
't
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 201900102021
Attachment 3
I %�Mff %No" W,
these folks directly affects mid -town residents' environment including aquatic places.
.......... .... ........... ..... ................ ... ......... ................ .... . .
33 (1) Ban use of any new plastic items with exceptions for emergency responders, natural disasters, 5/17/2019 1:03 PM
states of emergency, medical provider items that must be sterile. (2) incentivize
businesses/employers that turn recycled materials into in demand products to locate their
i
0
0
2/2 Input Sum,mary 2 -Page 57 of 185
co�: 11-77:�,, Zj F
Vm'MQ: i;7
A 0'.
O�ivim
:3
q
G
0
u
u
d
El
u
Attachment 3
El
A I
T z r� t b, U r 1 1 5 0&
y
t ..
� r `
M
V
i
I 11
ff I
f
M 9 --1
it, 4 m- W uo*-%, r
&p% I -a
"
W' ,K
en
r
p
.r.. - � r ... .ter• . ����� ., ��' , as;m� ��w � � . ''. � � .,., .:.,, , :aa"" ...
Aj:V
1. Assess current,staffing levels and adjust publicsatety staffing to ensure rapid response times and the
safety of our firstres onders.
2. Evaluate all city facilities, including our police and fire stations, and develop maintenance and
replacement recommenda
3. Create an Emergency Opei
tions.
tionsCenter (tE10C) that is appropriately equipped and staffed to better
Improve public safety through proact:ve crime and fire prevention activities.
I rove tr-aff eic safety througproactive education, engineering, and enforcmentstrategimpes.
'needss la!nci identify! trat"t"i
i#1 * a 0POSSIDI, Ity Of adding a9%Priorgifii,ze youth sate
!;nd develop organl"zational
support
ity Traff''ic Engineer position.
ucture: needs,
IE'�'
throug'
community
outreach.,
multlingual
%,l
o n s"Id ireworks sales ban.
i era f"
Enhance pavement management
4 1 W ,
in ty ofour:
roads and
; gr
roram to'ilmproveicea �;
to protect drivers, cyclists and pedestrians.
13. Implement City Vision Zero plan witha focus on pedestrian and cyclist safety with improvements to
uncontrolled crosswalks, curb ramps, sidewalk, and bicycle infrastructure.
It 14. Increase functionaliot
ty eo surveillance.
elillit ON so, I=ft - I , 6r
Inp&O-ut tiummary 2 Haye , U of 1 "
ur
Id
Z
w
w�
.w
as r
�
';'....
^" cl
I.a
ft"i
f
M 9 --1
it, 4 m- W uo*-%, r
&p% I -a
"
W' ,K
en
r
p
.r.. - � r ... .ter• . ����� ., ��' , as;m� ��w � � . ''. � � .,., .:.,, , :aa"" ...
Aj:V
1. Assess current,staffing levels and adjust publicsatety staffing to ensure rapid response times and the
safety of our firstres onders.
2. Evaluate all city facilities, including our police and fire stations, and develop maintenance and
replacement recommenda
3. Create an Emergency Opei
tions.
tionsCenter (tE10C) that is appropriately equipped and staffed to better
Improve public safety through proact:ve crime and fire prevention activities.
I rove tr-aff eic safety througproactive education, engineering, and enforcmentstrategimpes.
'needss la!nci identify! trat"t"i
i#1 * a 0POSSIDI, Ity Of adding a9%Priorgifii,ze youth sate
!;nd develop organl"zational
support
ity Traff''ic Engineer position.
ucture: needs,
IE'�'
throug'
community
outreach.,
multlingual
%,l
o n s"Id ireworks sales ban.
i era f"
Enhance pavement management
4 1 W ,
in ty ofour:
roads and
; gr
roram to'ilmproveicea �;
to protect drivers, cyclists and pedestrians.
13. Implement City Vision Zero plan witha focus on pedestrian and cyclist safety with improvements to
uncontrolled crosswalks, curb ramps, sidewalk, and bicycle infrastructure.
It 14. Increase functionaliot
ty eo surveillance.
elillit ON so, I=ft - I , 6r
Inp&O-ut tiummary 2 Haye , U of 1 "
1 -77-7777-7777'2
I
mi
A w
21
r.
n
ON
O
WON
0
z
0
LO
m
(D
I
1
9
o,
0
LLi
W"
LO
(Y)
Oo
p7* -
I
AMP
R
z
JON AF% JoRk
IL jovi
X"M"
Y
C '
3A
I It
AIN
Ivv
each ServicesTeam.
4,. Work with service providers and countywide agencies to coordinate response and solutions to the
tion including transitioning homelless Petalumans into shelter and housing.
b 4Facilitate construction of Accessory Dwelling Units.
6. Consider establishing a Housing Commission.
a kw, inclusive
10reCreate a 5 -year strategic housin plan to provide housing solutions that are attordable, ADA
7A g
compliant, age friendly, and ensure the continuity of City services to a growing residential
population.
11
f
a
Input Summary 2 -Page 61 of 185
w
UA Mbe. �56
�VF I I
do
MA
13 M,
'I� IMS I�� � � �, : E E � ..
4 Y , plil". 4 0
Ix. F'11 -hp 111--jiltif a 1!
90
P,:j
Aalli�
aW
i?
J
4,-1 ei-
01/'
if I. )i
ACO,
%AIU " Workplan Items:
1 Collaborate with the Health care District and other service providers to identify and promote
Mae
46:
q4i
sing ordinance
Create and promote multi -cultural and multi -generational recreation and wellness programs that
11
A
Attachment 3
M ALW
Develop tee structure for Alcohol -Related Nuisance Ordinance for sustained management and
"'cense
a
cens,,e a, establishments.
5. Consider adopting, a
i
construction.
r1i
W
A
o 1111611, �"
visitabilIty" ordinance to provide accessibility in new single-family home
a,
6. Improve access to healthy, sustainable food throughout the community,
7., Evaluate becoming an Age Friendly City.l
8. Increase efforts to support seniors that help them to remain engaged, active, and independent.
13
1,nput i6ummiary 2 0- Paye b2 of 185
r��
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q2 What do you like about this goal? Or, what are we missing?
RESPONSES'
Answered: 198
Skipped: 77
DATE
..... ... .. .. . .. .. ..... . .. .......... ........ .. ............................................................. ...... ........... ........... ... .................... ... ............ ............. ... ....... ...................................... I ........ I .......... . I ... ... . ..... 11- ... .... .... ................. I ........................ ...................... . ... . . . . ............................................................ ..... . . .............. ............. ......... .... ... ................. . ... ................... ....... .................... ........................... ................ ..... ....... .................................. .................... ........... ..... ...... .... ............ .. .. ..
15 Ideas are great to promote. What do you plan to DO? 6/612019 7:48 PM
1 / 9 Input Summary 2 -Page 63 of. 185
11
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
28 PIs add: Evaluate city animal shelter for needed upgrades, and include pets in disaster dannina, 6/5/2019 10:20 PM
Banning fireworks is essential! Thank you, v v
29 Fireworks ban, More Police, Traffic congestion, Missing address homeless issue, too many 6/5/2019 8:58 PM
30 I think emergency preparedness should be higher up 6/5/2019 8:20 PM
31 Our police force is severely understaffed and that definitely needs to be addressed. Our first 6/5/2019 6:14 PM
responders are a crucial component to the wellbeing of our community and we need to ensure
they are paid well, properly trained, and kept safe.
32 I like it. 6/5/2019 3:10 PM
33 Like the public safety aspect and emergency preparedness, however too many things lumped into 6/5/2019 2:17 PM
this one goal. Items 6, 71 11-1 4 should be placed elsewhere. Needs to be focused.
34 Whatis missing is an acknowledgement of the fact.that preparation for climate crisis can be seen 6/5/2b19 1:37 PM
entirely as a public safety issue. Or a disaster preparedness issue. Missing is an
acknowledgement of the predicted consequences'
of a rapidly warming climate (as noted in our
Climate Action 2020 Plan, Section 6.3.1)'I'ncluding "more extremely hot days, more frequent -and
intense droughts, more frequent and intense wildfires, greater risk of extreme floods, higher sea
levels and storm surge." And w absolutely need to prepare for PGE's preemptive power outages,
which can last for up to a week,, One of the best ways to prepare for disasters is through building
community.
35 Bike Petaluma depends heavily on safe facilities throughout the city. 6/5/2019 10;25 AM
36 I like the focus on safety as I have been saddened by the increase is crime and traffic incidents 6/5/2019 8: 14 AM
over the 14 years I have lived here .
37 I don't think any members of the general public would say public safety was the biggest issue 6/5/2019 8:09 AM
facing the city. This seems like it comes from the police department, not the public. The traffic and
roads objectives are important,, as the public has repeatedly expressed.
..........
38 Why is "support facilities" the first item? Maintenance of facilities is good, expansion and renewal 6/4/201.9 8:12 PM
takes lower priority.
39 na 6/4/2019 1:2.0 PM
. ..... . . . ...... ... ... .
40 I like the establishment of an Emergency Operations Center, considering the fires that have 6/3/2019 10:44 PM
ravaged CA the last few years, and that P.G. & E may be turning off the power during the
upcoming fire season for 2-5 days at a time. Promoting emergency preparedness needs to be a
priority, though free city workshops at varied times to inform residents of what exactly will be the
resources available when the power is shut off for up to 5 days! A fireworks ban seems a no-
brainerwith all the danger of fires, and of course, maintaining our police and fire personnel and
facitlities is a bottom line.
41 I like how the goal carries into all aspects of the City and how each department has a role within 6/3/2019 8:14 PM
the goal.,
42 I don't trust our police department to work for the community. The police department is political 6/3/2019 6:46 PM
and I am tired of their bully politics
43 Important that our 1st responders'
are safe in their workplace as well, Legal fireworks are nota 6/3/2019 4:51 PM
problem and should not be banned
44 We can't afford all the extra staff needed especially the pensions 6/3/2019 10:38 AM
.......... . ......
45 That it emphasized the need to increase public safety and infrastructure as housing is added. 6/3/2019 60&00 AM
While housing is a significant priority when can just added it without adding sufficient police, fire,
and.infrastructure to handle the challenges associated with increased housing/populations
46 Improving traffic 6/2/2019 5:599 PM
.. . ... . .... ....
47 I like the proactive approach. 6/2/2019 9:14 AM
48 This is fluff, feel -good stuff. People are angry about the traffic and parking and departure from our 6/l/2019104&907 AM
town heritage. This comes off as transparent attempt to pad payroll/pension fund. We do not need
" emergency preparedness" - we NEED TRAFFIC RELIEF NOWH! Don't take away the fireworks.
They have not been aproblem -dela with reality rather than perception and fluff.
49 Fix the traffic issues and increase fire department staffing. 5/31/2019 7:51 PM
0
2/9
Input Summary 2 -Page 64 of 185
.0
}
sp 1P 1P W
anaY nrinrity
57 These items are all well thought out, but theinevitable sea level rise catastrophes 5/30/2019 3:23 PM
(inondations))aren't addressed. I suggest including language about developing strategies (maybe
working with Point Blue's "Our Climate Our Future" team) to mitigate sea level rise.
58 There is very little too like about these goals.. Our police department and code enforcement are. 5/30/2019 10:34 AM
corrupt.
................ .................................. . ........ ...... . ............................................... ........................ .................. ...... ......... ......................................... . ....... .......... ............ ...... . .............. ............. ...... . .. ..... .. . ... .... . ...... . . .. .. .
59 ! think there are some very -touchy issues (fireworks ban) to the community but it really needs a 5/30/2019 9:27 AM'
review. I also like more video surveillance ideas. We have a lot of increasing crime and traffic
issues..
should identify and maintain their own lists of expense'and capital projects. These should be
presented annually to the city and funded based on performance and budget.,
.................. . ...... ............ .......... .......... .. .............. .. . .......... ........ . ....... .......... ............. ... ................................. ...... . ....... ............ ......... ... .... ................. .... ....... . .. .. ..
61 Regarding Fireworks ban - `State -Approved fireworks sold by Petaluma nonprofit organizations 5/29/2019 8:42 AM
are not the problem in Petaluma... Jllegal fireworks are the problem. * Restricting the use of state-
approved fireworks will not lead to lessillegal fireworks. * I want you to adopt a strong fireworks
social host ordinance, increase the administrative fine and participate. in the Nail'em free illegal
fireworks app,,
.. .. . . ....... .......................................... ............. . ... ... .. .. . .. . ..... . ... . ..... .. .... ......... ....................................................................... ............... ........... ........ . . . .... ...... .. . .
62 It covers necessary items 5/29/2019 7:17 AM
.. ... ..... ... ................ .................. ..... ... ................................................................... .......... . ......................... ...... ........ ..... .......... .... ....... ............... .......... ....... ....................................................... ......... ....... .... ... . ........ .................... .... ....... .... ..... ............... .. ............... ..................... . ....... ............. ...... ... ........................... ..... . . .............. ............................... ................. ........ ................ . i ................. ........................... . : ................................................. ............................................. ....... .......... .. .
63 The focus should be lesson public safety and more on preserving open space, increasing 5/28/2019 11:26 PM
recreation opportunities, preserving Petaluma's historic past, providing affordable housing,
eradicating homelessness, curbing climate change
. . ..... .. .. ..... .. . ... I ............... ........................ .. .... .......................... ................................ ......... I ........................ ... ....... .. ....... . .......................................... __.- ........... . .................. : ...................................... ...... ....................................... ............. ....... ......... . ..... ... ... .... .. ..... .... .... ... . . . . .. ... . .......... ... ..... . .... ... ............. ..... ... ........................ ... .. ...... . ..................... .................... ...... .......... .. ........... ............. ............................................ . ................
64 Focused on community wellness through prevention., Be it crime or fire preventative measures. 5/28/2019 9:25 PM
Seems odd but I like that but don't like the fireworks ban. The problem isn't the legal versions, It's
the illegal ones
.. .. . ... .... . . .. ... ..... ........... .. ...... ... . .................. ........ ....... .. ......... .... ... ........ .. . . . .... .. ........ . . ... . ... . . .. ... . .. .. ..... ...... . ........ . .. .. . ..... ..........
65 I like the focus on taking care of our citizens. 5/28/2019 5:07 PM
. . ........ ...... .. I.- ....... ........... . I ................ 11 ....... .. ................ .. ... ............................ .......................... ... .. .... ... .... . . . ............ .......
. .....
..
66 Too many goals beyond capability of handling or paying for. Need to prioritize, Too many "feel 5/28/2019 4:57 PM
good" aspects. Should concentrate on important requirements like fixing the streets and traditional
governmental functions and basics rather than "youth safety and community resource officers."
Focus on -greater needs.
. ........ ...... .. .. ... .. ... . . . . .... ... . . .. . ........ . . . . ..... I . . ...... .. ........ ... .... . .. . ............ .. ....................... ........... ........ .......................... ..................... . ............. ........................ ......... .................. ....................................................... .......... ................................... .................... .............. ............ ..... .......... ...................... ........... ...................................................... ...
67 Everything makes sense 5/28/2019 1':,,26 PM
........................... ............... . ..... . . ............. ...
68 Most important goals, to me, are HOUSING & ENVIRONMENT!!! 5/28/2019 1-4-17 PM
............................ ...............
..... ........
......... ..
.... ...
.... ..
.......... ...............
.. ...........
............................................. .........................................
69 Specifically workplan item #11: � State -Approved fireworks sold by PetaEuma nonprofit. 5/28/2019 12,41,51 PM
organizations are not the problem in Petaluma... illegal fireworks are the problem. ~Restricting the
use of state -approved fireworks will not lead to less illegal fireworks. -I want you to adopt a strong'
fireworks social host ordinance, increase the administrative fine and participate in the Nail'em free
illegal fireworks reporting app,,
. ...... .. ... .. ............................. ........ ..... ....... . : ........ .......... ........................................ .... .... ......................... ......... . . . .... . ..... .. .......... .... ........ .. .... ........ .. . . ... .. .... . ... . ... ..... ..... ..
70 #11 needs to be revised. Legal fireworks sales raise lots of money for various non -profits, like the 5/28/2019 12:37 PM
Petaluma Panthers and the DARE programs,, It's not legal fireworks that are the problem, It's illegal
fireworks. Restricting or eliminating legal fireworks will only lead to people purchasing them
elsewhere and leaving,our local non -profits high and dry. Go ahead and nail the violators using
illegal fireworks. Make the penalty stricter,'and use any of the,fines to help the non -profits! Thank
you! Denise Kramer 521 S. McDowell, Petaluma
71 Go after the people that set off illegal fireworks spend your money there 5/28/2019 12:34 PM
3/9
Input Summary 2 - gage 65 of 185
A
ti
9
72
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
It's focused on us, the community and is really what a city is supposed to focus on for its
nnni dation
t
Attachment 3
5/28/2019 12:32 PM
73 Bike way improvements 5/28/2019 124117 PM
74 Plan Zero -pedestrian safety and bicycle lanes. I support a firework ban. 5/28/2019 10-6623 AM
75 Safety is great. But especially as to keeping youth safe, resource officers may not be -the best way 5/28/2019 9:19 AM
Petal uma....illegal fireworks are the problem. Restricting the use of state -approved fireworks will
84 oState-Approved fireworks sold by Petaluma nonprofit organizations are not the problem in 5/23/2019 1:28 PM
Petaluma....illegal fireworks are the problem. o Restricting the use of state -approved fireworks will
not lead to less illegal fireworks. o I want you to adopt a strong fireworks social host ordinance,
increase the administrative fine and participate in the Nail'em free illegal fireworks reporting app.
85 I am excited that Police Staffing and resources have become a priority to the city manager and 5/23/2019 8:49 AM
council.
86 this is good -test 5/23/2019 8:43 AM
........ . . . . ... ......... 11 ....... : . .. .. ....
87 This should be every city's top priority.. 5/23/2019 8:09 AM
88 You cover (tall here... might be better fora 5 year goal. 5/22/2019 6;50 PM
.. . .... ...
89 Our city is growing in size and certainly popularity. We need to ensure we staff our public safety 5/22/2019 5:37 PM
agencies accordingly. Thought we need the residents to be engaged, there is a small uprising of
vocal folks who don't necessarily represent the majority: (i.e. Indivisible Petaluma)
90 maintain ex'I'sting'bicycle facilities and replace with more modern and safe ones when there is new 5/21/2019 11:58 AM
development and when streets are resurfaced. Currently many bike facilities are poorly designed
and unmaintained.,
91 I would like to see provision for our schools to have more counseling and good citizenship 5/21/2019 10:34 AM
programs.
...................... ........
92 Lots covered. I really appreciate getting rid of fireworks. It is too dry here to sell fireworks. 5/20/2019 4:04 PM
.......... ... . .. .. .. ... ... ..... .. .. ..
93 Seems good. 5/20/2019 3:56 PM
.... . . . ........
94 If we assume that the proposed Climate Cabinet will focus on reducing the impacts of climate 5/20/2019 3:18 PM
change, we still have a hole on how to address the impacts that will nonetheless occur. And these
will be very different than the type of disasters to which we're accustomed. E.g., Planning for a
downtown with water in the streets at every high tide is different than planning for a downtown that
floods once every 10 years. (Also, I'll always argue in favor of the Oxford comma.)
...........
95 Banning Fireworks?.Seems overblown risk. 5/20/2019 1:08 PM
96 number 12 5/20/2019 12:44 PM
97 I'm glad bike/pOd infrastructure is included, and the fireworks ban, Public Transit availability also 5/20/2019 9:48 AM
contributes to a safe and healthy community, and might be added..
.... ...... .. . . ... . ... ... .. .. . . ....... .. ... . . ................. ............ ...................... ... ...................... . ............. ........................................................................ .......................... .......... ................ ............. .................... .......................... ......... ............. . ............ ...... ........................... ......................... .... .. ....... ..... . ... . ...... .. .. ........ . . ..... .. .. .. .... . ........ .. .. ........ ... . . . .. . . .. .. .. ... . . . . . . .. ............ ... ......... .. ...... .... ............... .... .. ..................... . ............... ....... . . .... . ..... .......
98 Safety for walking & bicycles & keeping up with maintenance of facilities for safety providers.. 5/20/2019 9-:27 AM
rl
4/9
Input Summary 2 - Page 66 of 185
not lead to- less illegal fireworks. I want you to adopt a strong fireworks social host ordinance,
increase the administrative fine and participate in the Nail'em free illegal fireworks reporting app..
79
Adresses current needs.
5/25/2019
9:57
AM
80
( find the goals to be all encompassing
5/24/2019
6:18
AM
81
It will improve the safety of citizens of Petaluma.
.5/24/2019
5:57
AM
82
Good overall needs fire work sales for nonprofits
5/23/2019
8:58
PM
83
Scratch the bathtubs slated for erection on Water Street. Address the rampant coke dealing
5/23/2019
2:49
PM
84 oState-Approved fireworks sold by Petaluma nonprofit organizations are not the problem in 5/23/2019 1:28 PM
Petaluma....illegal fireworks are the problem. o Restricting the use of state -approved fireworks will
not lead to less illegal fireworks. o I want you to adopt a strong fireworks social host ordinance,
increase the administrative fine and participate in the Nail'em free illegal fireworks reporting app.
85 I am excited that Police Staffing and resources have become a priority to the city manager and 5/23/2019 8:49 AM
council.
86 this is good -test 5/23/2019 8:43 AM
........ . . . . ... ......... 11 ....... : . .. .. ....
87 This should be every city's top priority.. 5/23/2019 8:09 AM
88 You cover (tall here... might be better fora 5 year goal. 5/22/2019 6;50 PM
.. . .... ...
89 Our city is growing in size and certainly popularity. We need to ensure we staff our public safety 5/22/2019 5:37 PM
agencies accordingly. Thought we need the residents to be engaged, there is a small uprising of
vocal folks who don't necessarily represent the majority: (i.e. Indivisible Petaluma)
90 maintain ex'I'sting'bicycle facilities and replace with more modern and safe ones when there is new 5/21/2019 11:58 AM
development and when streets are resurfaced. Currently many bike facilities are poorly designed
and unmaintained.,
91 I would like to see provision for our schools to have more counseling and good citizenship 5/21/2019 10:34 AM
programs.
...................... ........
92 Lots covered. I really appreciate getting rid of fireworks. It is too dry here to sell fireworks. 5/20/2019 4:04 PM
.......... ... . .. .. .. ... ... ..... .. .. ..
93 Seems good. 5/20/2019 3:56 PM
.... . . . ........
94 If we assume that the proposed Climate Cabinet will focus on reducing the impacts of climate 5/20/2019 3:18 PM
change, we still have a hole on how to address the impacts that will nonetheless occur. And these
will be very different than the type of disasters to which we're accustomed. E.g., Planning for a
downtown with water in the streets at every high tide is different than planning for a downtown that
floods once every 10 years. (Also, I'll always argue in favor of the Oxford comma.)
...........
95 Banning Fireworks?.Seems overblown risk. 5/20/2019 1:08 PM
96 number 12 5/20/2019 12:44 PM
97 I'm glad bike/pOd infrastructure is included, and the fireworks ban, Public Transit availability also 5/20/2019 9:48 AM
contributes to a safe and healthy community, and might be added..
.... ...... .. . . ... . ... ... .. .. . . ....... .. ... . . ................. ............ ...................... ... ...................... . ............. ........................................................................ .......................... .......... ................ ............. .................... .......................... ......... ............. . ............ ...... ........................... ......................... .... .. ....... ..... . ... . ...... .. .. ........ . . ..... .. .. .. .... . ........ .. .. ........ ... . . . .. . . .. .. .. ... . . . . . . .. ............ ... ......... .. ...... .... ............... .... .. ..................... . ............... ....... . . .... . ..... .......
98 Safety for walking & bicycles & keeping up with maintenance of facilities for safety providers.. 5/20/2019 9-:27 AM
rl
4/9
Input Summary 2 - Page 66 of 185
W
Y
CITY COUNCIL DR -AFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
99 Improvements in practicality and safety all along Lynch Creek Trail in order to allow for more public 5/20/2019 8:29 AM
use/less crowded roadways. This is a stretch of land and waterway where children should be able
to play and explore, not a site for trashy homeless encampments'.
. .... .... . . . ...... ... .. ......... : . . ....... :-.1: ....... . ........ ... .. ... ... . ... ...
100 like it but it sounds too broad., Can you make it more SMART? 5/20/2019 6:322 AM
........ ....
101 Crime and safety. You are missing the fact that we need to Not be a sanctuary city. What kinds of 5/20/201 9 1 2:10 AM
disasters are you preparing for ?
overall safety.
. .. .......... . I .......
106 More police and fire department funding. Medical calls are at an all time high and with increased 5/19/2019 5:36 PM
population it'.11 only rise.
107 Cleaner safer parks, 5/19/2019 5:34 PM
............... : .......................
.......................................................... ...... ... . ................ .................................................................... ........ ................. ... .................... .... . ............ .... .... ................ ....... . . . . .... . ............ . -.-1.-.-1:-..1 .. .......... .............................. .......................... . ........ : ... .... ........... : ........... . ........................................................... ............ I .. ......
108 I don't like the fireworks ban - it is not legal fireworks that cause fires, it is the illegal ones. Non- 5/19/2019 5:19 PM
profits count an funding from firework sales to fund their efforts. And I need more information
about what video surveillance means
5/9
i
In gut Summary 2 - :'age 67 of 185
109
Admirable statement, but not a goal but a sentiment. Professionally a goal should be stated as a
5/1 9/201 9 2:26 PM
measurable result , be realistic, and have a finite timeline for accomplishment. Your work on this
satisfies only the timeline criterion, and if that is two years, I suspect the realistic may not be there.
Howl"n. the world do you think that you. will be able to, in 2022, assess the degree of success or
.
failure in specific terms? Our city, as most, sadly, needs good strategic planning but this is -not yet
it. PLEASE use this compendium of good and worthy feelings to develop a short list of prioritized
goals that can be accomplished in the next two years, and the a further list that might cover an
additional three years. Then we MIGHT make some progress. This is not meant as bare critique,
but as a plea for substantive strategic planning. I --think the concepts are worthy but must be
pursued in a disciplined way, acknowledging what is and is not possible with limited resources and
the time frame defined. This comment is in relation to the full plan presented..
110
..... .... . .. ... ..... . . .......... .. ......... ....... ...... .............. .... . ...... ........... .. I . ......... ............................. .............. .. .............................................. ..... ... ..... .................................... ................................................ ....... . .. . ...... . .. ..... .. ................................................ ..... .......... . ................... .. ............................................... ............................. ......... ................... ....................................... . .. .................. ......................................
We need the roads to be repaired or re -paved, So many potholes are becoming harder and harder
.................................................... ................................................ .............................. ............... ...... ........
5/19/2019 2:03 PM
to avoid. We also need some focus on limiting building unless'congestion is also addressed.
111.
. ...................................................... ................................................................................... ...... ...... ........ .... .. .......... . .. . ..... ..... ......... I . ............ .. .
PROHIBIT VAPE SHOPS OPERATING CLOSE TO OUR SCHOOLS, ENFORCE LAWS AND
........ ... .... .......... ...... .......................... ..... ..
5/119/20119 11:33 AM
FINE SHOP OWNERS WHO SELL TO MINORS. Example: VOLCANO VAPE SHOP ON
BODEGA SELLS TO PETALUMA HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS UNDER 18
112
.. . . ............ ... . ........ . . --1 ......... .. ..........
-Good to have on-going cyclical (annual, bi annual,) assessment of facilities and personnel..
...... .... ....................... ...... ........................................ .............. .............. .... .. . ....... ... ...... ... .. .. . .. ... . . .. ........ .......... ...........
5/19/2019 9.:22 AM
113
................... ..... .. ....... .. .. .... ... .. ... ..... .. ........ I .............. .. ........................ ... . ....................................................................
We have residential codes that are not enforced. We have street and -parking rules and regulations
.. I.., ....................... : .............. I .... . ........ . ... .
5/18/201.9 7:12 PM
that are not enforced. Cars park on the sidewalk. They park on the curves at the corners., Street
cleaning can not be done because of the many cars, boats, campers and RV's on the street. The
value of homes in the neighborhood drops.
114
. ..................................
. ... .......................................
. ...
. ...
................................... ............... .... ......... . .. ... .... ............. . ................ ................................................................................................ .................................................................................... ... .. ...... ..... . ................................................
There will be more extreme weather and disasters due to climate change. ...We need to be
.......................
5/18/2019 6:32 PM
prepared.
115
Sustainable development plan. Petalumais building a huge amount of new housing while traffic
5/18/2019 6:19 PM
congestion seems to get worse every day. Lets keep a smart development and zoning plan in
place. If you cant build a school next to a gas station, why did you approve The building of a gas
station next to a school in a area where there -are already 2 gas stations within a block,.
116
..... .. ..... . ........ ... .. ... . . .. . ........... ................ .
Not specific enough. And redundant,
5/18/2019 5:16 PM
117
..................... .............. .......... ........ .................. ........... ............. ... ... . ....... I . ...... . ... ... .... . . .. ..... . ..... ... . .... . ........... .. ... . .. ... .......... ... . . .. .. .. . . ....... .... .... .. . .. . ... .. . .. . ... ... ..... .. .. ... ... .... . .... .. .
Emergency preparedness is very clear, but safety is all over the map.' Public safety should be
5/18/2019 2:55 PM
subdivided into categories that relate to infrastructure, social, health, crime etc.
118
. . .... . ...................... ............... ................................... .............................. ........................................... .... ..................... ............ ..... .................................................... ........ ......................... ....... ..... .................. ........ ................... ................. .... ..........
4, 51 6110, 12, 13
.... ..... ...... ...... ..... ... .. .... . ...... ... ..... ........... ... .. ...... . .. ... ..... ....... .. .. ...
5/18/2019 11:35 AM
11.9
.. . .. ... .. ......... ..... . ... . . ... . . .. ..... .. ...... ............ . ... . ........ . .. ... . . .. ..... ........ ........................................ ................... ................. ...................................... ................. ................................... ............ ....... ............................. .. .......... ................. ...................... ....... ...
Police staffing is a must. An updated/centralized police station would be well worth it.
.. ....... ....................................... ........................... .............. .......... ...... ............... . ............. ................. . .... .... .......... .... .... .... .. . ..
5/18/2019 9:56 AM
... . .......
120
...... ...... ... .... ...... ....... ........... ............ ...... ...... . . ........ ....... .... .. ............. I.", ............ ..............
The'goal mentions community members are "housed" yet, there's nothing about housing
...... .. ..........
5/18/2019 6:30 AM
mentioned in the bullet points.
5/9
i
In gut Summary 2 - :'age 67 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
121 I like this part of the goal, "...create a healthy, resilient, and engaged community that is prepared
safe and housed." The first part of the goal should be revised to s'top'wasting taxpayers` money
focusing on People -of -Petaluma and not the "facilities, or design new programs" when we have
programs in place that could be improved or revised. Lastly, what does "housed" mean in this
0
Attachment 3
5/17/2019 8:43 PM
goal? Is this referring to the homeless? Housing costs are controlled by the market, not Petaluma
City Council
. ...... . . ....
122 Environmental impact concerns/policies 5/17/2019 8:20 PM
..... ........
123 We have a serious homelessness problem in town that impacts community safety. Especially 5/17/2019 8-9,08 PM
encampments in creeks and other wooded areas in and around subdivisions. Also, the traffic
assessment is huge. We need to reconsider Rainer as an option to- alleviate traffic congestion. The
traffic over W. Washington is insane..
124 Make sure pedestrian and bike safety infrastructure improvements are coordinated with each other 5/17/2019 7:39 PM
to create workable continuous paths of travel that don't leave peds, cyclists or wheelchair users
stranded.,
125 21729111 5/17/2019 7;00 PM
126 The Goal seems broad enough to allow for flexibility of what programs to create first. 5/17/2019 6:02 PM
...... . . ... .
127 Stop spending $ on surveillance. Instead, fix the streets, which are pot -holed and dangerous for 5/17/2019 4:59 PM
cyclists and motorists. Also fire the cops who are racist/misogynist. PPD needs to clean house and
begin "protecting and serving" vs harassing and hating on its citizens.
128 Like the fireworks ban. Housing everyone. Definitely would like to see'pavement management' set 5/17/2019 4;13 PM
as a high priority! Roads here are a horrible mess!
. .. .. . . ........... .. ..... ... . . .. .. ... ..... .......... . ... . .. ........ . . .. . . .. .................. .... ....... .......... .................. ...... ..... . ... ..... ....... ........ . ................. . ... .. ... . ..........
129 Maintain current programs. 5/17/2019 4: 10 PM
130 Start building more houses or get the out of council you old people _suck at your jobs 5/17/2019 2:49 PM
131 The city should focus on housing before any of the other issues., Does anyone actually feel 5/17/2019 1:31 PM
unsafe? Maybe the same people that fear illegal immigrants...
132 Missing- Eliminate the bathtubs project. Fix potholes, 5/17/2019 1:02 PM
133 It is noble and lofty. 5/17/2019 12:17 PM
... .. ..... .. . . ...... ...... . ... .. .
134 Enact Rent Control 5/17/2019 12:09 PM
135 Traffic and in particular pedestrian safety are a huge issue in this town and 1 see it as the biggest 5/17/2019 11 :33 AM
safety challenge. Also, the city has been "considering" a fireworks ban for far too long --itis time to
take action.,
136 Facilities does not entirely cover any roadwork or other projects that may be needed for traffic 5/17/2019 10:28 AM
management
137 Headed in the right direction. 5/17/2019 10:22 AM
................ ...
138 This goal sounds great. I hope we will have. the funds to dd this. 5/17/2019 10:19 AM
139 Improving traffic and safety. 5/17/2019 10:02 AM
. ... ... ... ..... . ..... ..
140 Seems to cover many of my concerns. It is a big list and seems it could be very expensive to 5/17/2019 9:48 AM
accomplish. While also ,being very important. So I hope as residents we are all will to pay more
taxes to get the job done sooner than later.
141 #8J91 11, 12, 13 5/17/2019 9:43 AM
142 I like the emphasis on police work, and would really encourage Council and City management to 5/1 7/201 9 9:36 AM
consider adding to the police force and/or increasing their wages so they can attract quality
applicants'.
143 The condition of our streets needs to be a much higher priority than #'12. Banning fireworks is 5/17/2019 9:32 AM
ludicrous. You can't even prevent illegal fireworks across the city, so why would you ban what is
legal??
144 How about a clean streets program. Whenever I travel I am always impressed by how litter free 5/17/2019 9:02 AM
the town's ,streets and highways are in other states. Why can't Petaluma set an example for the
rest of the state. I'm sure volunteers could be utilized with proper leadership.
.............
6/9
Input Summary 2 -Page 68 of 185
`
4
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
121 I like this part of the goal, "...create a healthy, resilient, and engaged community that is prepared
safe and housed." The first part of the goal should be revised to s'top'wasting taxpayers` money
focusing on People -of -Petaluma and not the "facilities, or design new programs" when we have
programs in place that could be improved or revised. Lastly, what does "housed" mean in this
0
Attachment 3
5/17/2019 8:43 PM
goal? Is this referring to the homeless? Housing costs are controlled by the market, not Petaluma
City Council
. ...... . . ....
122 Environmental impact concerns/policies 5/17/2019 8:20 PM
..... ........
123 We have a serious homelessness problem in town that impacts community safety. Especially 5/17/2019 8-9,08 PM
encampments in creeks and other wooded areas in and around subdivisions. Also, the traffic
assessment is huge. We need to reconsider Rainer as an option to- alleviate traffic congestion. The
traffic over W. Washington is insane..
124 Make sure pedestrian and bike safety infrastructure improvements are coordinated with each other 5/17/2019 7:39 PM
to create workable continuous paths of travel that don't leave peds, cyclists or wheelchair users
stranded.,
125 21729111 5/17/2019 7;00 PM
126 The Goal seems broad enough to allow for flexibility of what programs to create first. 5/17/2019 6:02 PM
...... . . ... .
127 Stop spending $ on surveillance. Instead, fix the streets, which are pot -holed and dangerous for 5/17/2019 4:59 PM
cyclists and motorists. Also fire the cops who are racist/misogynist. PPD needs to clean house and
begin "protecting and serving" vs harassing and hating on its citizens.
128 Like the fireworks ban. Housing everyone. Definitely would like to see'pavement management' set 5/17/2019 4;13 PM
as a high priority! Roads here are a horrible mess!
. .. .. . . ........... .. ..... ... . . .. .. ... ..... .......... . ... . .. ........ . . .. . . .. .................. .... ....... .......... .................. ...... ..... . ... ..... ....... ........ . ................. . ... .. ... . ..........
129 Maintain current programs. 5/17/2019 4: 10 PM
130 Start building more houses or get the out of council you old people _suck at your jobs 5/17/2019 2:49 PM
131 The city should focus on housing before any of the other issues., Does anyone actually feel 5/17/2019 1:31 PM
unsafe? Maybe the same people that fear illegal immigrants...
132 Missing- Eliminate the bathtubs project. Fix potholes, 5/17/2019 1:02 PM
133 It is noble and lofty. 5/17/2019 12:17 PM
... .. ..... .. . . ...... ...... . ... .. .
134 Enact Rent Control 5/17/2019 12:09 PM
135 Traffic and in particular pedestrian safety are a huge issue in this town and 1 see it as the biggest 5/17/2019 11 :33 AM
safety challenge. Also, the city has been "considering" a fireworks ban for far too long --itis time to
take action.,
136 Facilities does not entirely cover any roadwork or other projects that may be needed for traffic 5/17/2019 10:28 AM
management
137 Headed in the right direction. 5/17/2019 10:22 AM
................ ...
138 This goal sounds great. I hope we will have. the funds to dd this. 5/17/2019 10:19 AM
139 Improving traffic and safety. 5/17/2019 10:02 AM
. ... ... ... ..... . ..... ..
140 Seems to cover many of my concerns. It is a big list and seems it could be very expensive to 5/17/2019 9:48 AM
accomplish. While also ,being very important. So I hope as residents we are all will to pay more
taxes to get the job done sooner than later.
141 #8J91 11, 12, 13 5/17/2019 9:43 AM
142 I like the emphasis on police work, and would really encourage Council and City management to 5/1 7/201 9 9:36 AM
consider adding to the police force and/or increasing their wages so they can attract quality
applicants'.
143 The condition of our streets needs to be a much higher priority than #'12. Banning fireworks is 5/17/2019 9:32 AM
ludicrous. You can't even prevent illegal fireworks across the city, so why would you ban what is
legal??
144 How about a clean streets program. Whenever I travel I am always impressed by how litter free 5/17/2019 9:02 AM
the town's ,streets and highways are in other states. Why can't Petaluma set an example for the
rest of the state. I'm sure volunteers could be utilized with proper leadership.
.............
6/9
Input Summary 2 -Page 68 of 185
P
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
145 I like it all but eSDeciallv reaardina EOC community education and oreoaration for disasters and 5/17/2019 81:45 AM
the ban on fireworks. We are asking for a major fire with allowing them even if its only supposed to
be within city limits. I like out in the county area of petaluma and people use them all the time.
.... ... . .. . .. . ... ........ . . ... .. . ........... I ....... : ................. ........ ... ...... ..... . .......... ......................... .. . .. ...
146 I like inclusivity and focus on resiliency. What's missing is mention of development of 5/17/2019 8:43 AM
neighborhood plans for elders in case of a disaster.
..... . . .... .... .... ......... : ......... ... ............ . .......... :...: ........ .............. . .... ..... ....... ... ... ... .. ......... ............ ............................. ... .. . ....................................................................... ................................................... ................................ ...... ........... ....... .... ...................... .. ......... ..... ... .... .. ........ ......
...........................
147 You have too manyissues, some conflicting, in one bucket you are calling "Safe Community" I 5/17/2019 8:43 AM
generally agree with about 1/2 of them but a good second scrubbing of these would MUCH better
define what they really are. It is a good §tart but not data to act from.,
foremost. This already is out of balance and way over funded. We need to lift up our community
and give personal power and opportunity to our citizens. That will eliminate crime onit's own. 1
cant drive down any street at any time of day without encountering a police car. We are over
7/9
Input Summary 2 - 'age 69 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
167 Emphasis on community safety issues is great - except IMPLEMENT fireworks ban, not consider.. 5/16/2019 2:09 PM
This needs to be a priority with all the fire related disasters in the past two years..
168 All income Housing issues. When you say "community", include all income housing communities., 5/16/2019 1:30 PM
Petaluma should have a Housing Oversite Board. We need a Oversite Board where there is no
"conflict of interests"; no bias, or political ties. Petaluma needs a "HUD Certified" Fair Housing
organization. Petaluma tenants are not protected, according to Marin Advocates Fair Housing,,
.... . .. .. . . .. .... ... . . ......... ... ...
769 Traffic needs 5/16/2019 1:07 PM
170 Seems to cover a lot.. 5/16/2019 1-002 PM
171 Am very concerned with "overbuilding" and lack of infrastructure /parking. Analogyp too many rats 5/16/2019 12:57 PM
in a cage end up devouring each other!We are not SF. Do not think health and safety are factored
in.
172 Its an ideals goal 5/16/2019 12:49 PM
173 getting citizens more active in there own protection. Grow the neighborhood watch programs. 5/16/2019 12:32 PM
Emphasize citizen first aid and CPR training.,
174 traffic help ,safety, re evaluate city planning.? 5/76/2019 12:24 PM
175 One Petauma asset that has not been mentioned is it's Airport. As the City reviews Emergency 5/76/2019 129&'14 PM
and Disaster Preparedness, how is the City reviewing and engaging the resources at the Airport.
During the wildfires over 40 firefighting aircraft used the airport. Routinely emergency medical
aircraft use the Petaluma Airport to move patients to hospitals with greater care capabilities. There
is an emergency communication facility located within the airport terminal. How is city utilizing the
airport to make its citizens safer.
176 Operations should be added to "facilities and design programs". 5/16/2019 11:56 AM
177 A clear plan needs to be addressed in regards parking in residential neighborhoods. Because of 5/16/2019 11:50 AM
the increase in vehicles within the home it is causing overflow into other neighborhoods. This has
become a danger on Sunrise Parkway and McDowell Blvd. Cars drive very fast on this street and
with the additional vehiclesit has become very dangerous. Many people who do not live in this
neighborhood have commented that they avoid Sunrise Parkway because of this. My suggestion
would be to implement permit parking after certain hours to discourage of dumping vehicles and
speed bumps along sunrise to get the flow of traffic to reduce in speed. Being a home owner and
resident on this street for 15 years now I've seen the change to the neighborhood. I can honestly
say it is only a mater of time before a child or adult is hit by a car. Because Sunrise is also
considered a dog park-it really is very unsafe for animals at the speeds cars drive.
"I'l-l"...",.,.,"-,.",.,..-''I ... I. 1. 11.1 "1",", .1111'..,...........................-..-...:-.:..:.....-.-.- - - .. - .. ... - - . .. .. . . .. . . ... ... . . . .. .... ,:.-,-:-,,-.'- , - - , , .. , , - '. : ................
178 We need to be sure that we do not do anything that raises our tax base!,.,,, 5/16/2019 11:35 AM
. ...... ... ... . . .........
179 This, and the other priorities won't be feasible unless the basics are addressed ... roadways, /16/2019 11:22 AM
traffic, permitting. Why? because those are the basic functions that enable the tax base. Without
the basics, the city's "priorities" as presented are only dreams, and frankly, not meaningful, as how
do you MEASURE these goals?
...............
180 How about safe and healthy environments for the animals of Petaluma? 5/16/2019 11:13 AM
.......
181 Wrapping too much into this first question. Item by item. 5/16/2019 11:01 AM
182 Regarding item 4: The proposed resource manual should include operations standards with 5/16/2019 10:54 AM
medical requirements. Operators of emergency shelters during the fires had no plans or guidelines
to assist with preparation and handling of our displaced citizens. The Health Care District should
be involved in creating those guidelines, And finally, we should have a list of properties available
as emergency shelters updated annu-ally,,
................... ........................... ..... .. ..... ........ .. .. . . ..... ..... .. .. .... .............. ................ ..... .... . ... .... . ..... ..... . . . .
183 I would like to see more emphasis on improving pedestrian and bicycle travel in town. I would 5/16/2019 10:53 AM
appreciate more emphasis on projects that improve sustainability and address environmental
concerns.
184 Needs more focus, too general/fuzzy language,, Stop putting narrow curb ramps into streets--5/16/2019 10:51 AM
dangerous--go back to broad ramp than prevents tripping on sharp new curbs.
185 Road repairs 5/16/2019 10:44 AM
186 Hello, i went to the public forum and 1 felt that the "budget' or "tack of assets" needed to be 5/16/2019 10:42 AM
addressed first so that the community could contribute in a more beneficial and informed manner.
feel that we still need that information in order to reply to this surrey, More transparency please.
8/9 Input Summary 2 - Page 70 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
important but it is also the responsibility of those individuals. I constantly see poor behavior by
both groups but cyclists are by far the worst and almost always fail to follow traffic laws. I wonder
can NOT handle that volume. v v v
.. . .... ...... ... . . .. ... .... ..... . ..... ... . . ..................... ....... : ............. : .................... : '.'- .- ..: ......................... .......... .......... ... ................. ... : ": . . ........ . . . . ......... . "., '. "" ., , , - "" - , "., '.- - : .. . .... . .. .... . :-:1 - ..... ..... . . ..... .... .......... ......... . .... ...
194 Community trust between PD and people of color. Especially, with SROs in schools.. Not every 5/16/2019 9:59 AM
student feels safe with them. Just something to think about.
. . . . . .. . .. ... . .. ..... . ... .. ................................................ ......... ............................................................. ..... : ...... .... ...................... : ........... .... ........... ...................... ...... ....................... ... ...... ....... ....
.......... ... . . . .. . .......... .. . .
195 I'm not sure people need more help to walk around town nor have I heard we are not prepared for 5/16/2019 9:54 AM
a emergency? Is the council thinking of fires? Earthquakes,. It it not,clear to me what the thinking is
here?
. ..... .. . .. ... . ... ................... ............................ ....... . .. . . .. ... ... ........... . ...
..... .. .. . ...... . ............ . ........ . .... . . . ... ... ..................... ... ................... . .... ... ......
196 Finally we are prioritizing Police and Fire. It blows my mind that they have been an afterthought for 5/16/2019 8:08 AM
all of these years.
. .................... ....... ---- ... ..... .. .. ... ... ....................... .......... ................. .. ................... ..... ... ..... . .......... .. . ............ ...................... .. . .. ..... . . .. .. ............... .. ... ...... ............
197 Emphasis on Public safety and awareness; community involvement. 5/15/2019 2d:54 PM
. ... ... . .... ... .. . . .. ...... ...... ... . ...... .............................. ....... .... ............ .......................... ...... ...... .......... ... ...... ... ........................ . ... . . ...... ....... ......... ................. ... ... ... ... .. . ...... ...... . .. ... . . . .. ......
198 Police, Fire and Roads should always be #1 priority 5/15/2019 9:47 AM
......... ........
9/9 Input Summary
2 - Page 71 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q3 What do you like about this objective? Or, what are we missing?
Answered: 151 Skipped: 124
# RESPONSES DATE
1
stated above
6/17/2019
7:21
AM
2
Glad to see more focus on emergency services - perhaps a nudge toward creating resilient
6/14/20119
6/9/2019
6:49
PM
... . . .... . ... . . ........ . .... ... . ........ .... ........ . . ..
Good
neighborhoods could come in here,,
4:30 AM
12
The use of "traffic safety" implies a narrow focus on cars; work plan items 12 & 13 include
6/6/2019
3
It makes so much sense during our year-round fire season,,
6/14/2019
6:12
PM
4
Increase prosecutions and consequences for crimes that occur.
6/14/2019
1:31
PM-
5
.
too much emphasis on Po'Lice,,
6/13/2019
6/6/2019
8:54
PM
6
Increased support for first responders
6/13/2019
6:03
PM
7
Assessing traffic needs should focus on strategies to reduce automobile use in town and
6/13/2019
6/6/2019
2:39
PM
Connector. To help get around town in emergencies.
improving traffic flow to address growing congestion issues
16
I'd like to see some talk about how growth of the town is going to go. What is the plan? I feel that
6/6/2019
8
...............
That it speaks to emergencies and disasters as well as the day to day services of our police and
6/11/2019
9-9k53
PM
fires dp_nqrtmA_nt_q I ,
1 /6
nput Summary 2 - Page 72 of 185
I&
9
Explained above
6/11/2019 7:43 PM
10
Promoting business
6/9/2019
8:18 AM
11
... . . .... . ... . . ........ . .... ... . ........ .... ........ . . ..
Good
6/7/2019
4:30 AM
12
The use of "traffic safety" implies a narrow focus on cars; work plan items 12 & 13 include
6/6/2019
94W,43 PM
pedestrians & cyclists. A broader term that encompasses cars, bikes, pedestrians, transit
riders...would be more appropriate. You improve it by specifying "tragic safety for pedestrians,
bicycles, and cars"
13
........... . . ... . . ......... .... ..... .... . ..... .. . ... .
action plan missing
6/6/2019
. .. . . . ....... ......
7:48 PM
14
Take into consideration all agencies that would be involvedin an emergency into this goal.
6/6/2019
. .. . . .. ... ... .............. . .... .
5: 18 PM
Training and education foran emergency response strike team, ,
15
All the emergencey and critical safety recourses being number one, and create the Rainer
6/6/2019
4:27 PM
Connector. To help get around town in emergencies.
16
I'd like to see some talk about how growth of the town is going to go. What is the plan? I feel that
6/6/2019
1:33 PM
there is a lot of growth plan with little to no consideration to traffic, quality of life in Petaluma for
those of us who already reside there. I absolutely hate the thought of losing the Fairgrounds., I fear
we are losing our agricultural/country roots.
17
Climate mitigation is also a #1 safety issue.
6/6/2019
1:27 PM
18
Missing Caulfield Cross connector
6/6/2019
12;17 PM
19
no additional comment
6/6/2019
11: 19 AM
20
. .. .. .... . . .......... .. ....
I like to see there may be a plan in place for natural disasters and I also like that we should be
6/6/2019
10:55 AM
putting more funds into our children's safety
21
The safety focus for young people and families
6/6/2019
10,933 AM
22
PIs add: Evaluate city animal shelter for needed upgrades, and include pets in disaster planning,
6/5/2019
10:20 PM
Banning fireworks is essential! Thank you,
23
Homeless
6/5/2019
8:58 PM
24
Seismic safety. The D Street Fire Station and the Historical Museum are two facilities that have to
6/5/2019
3-1-10 PM
be seismically upgraded. Any other buildings that support habitation or are significant to our
historic and/or cultural identity need to be strengthened.
25
Keep it public safety specific; given that (ie, other 6 points referenced above removed), it reads
6/5/2019
2:97 PM
well.
1 /6
nput Summary 2 - Page 72 of 185
I&
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
26 The emergencies and disasters for which we must prepare go far beyond "crime, fire prevention, 6/5/2019 1-6037 PM
and traffic safety." Refer to Climate Action 2020, Section 6.3.1
27 Include safe roads for alternative transportation users. 6/5/2019 10:25 AM
28 1 like crime &fire prevention and traffic safety. I see lots of development that does not seem to take 6/5/2019 8:14 AM
traffic safety into account. I would like to see realistic assessment of traffic, Not iust assessment
2 / 6 Input Summary 2 -Page 73 of 185
.0
with the intention of accepting developer plans.
29
. ..... . .. ... .... .. ... .... ......... ....... . :': .. ... .......... ....
See above
6/5/2019
8:09
. .. ..... ... .
AM
30
.... ....... ... : .................. . ..... . .. .. .... . . .. ..... ..... .. .. ... ... .......... ... . ......
Community engagement
6/4/2019
... .. ... ......
1:43
............................ ....... . . ..... .......... . .. . .. . . ....... . ...... ..........
PM
31
na
6/4/2019
1:20
PM
32
See goal comments above -the same here,.
6/3/2019
10:44 PM
.. .... .... . ... . . ...... ... . . .
33
. .... . . ...... ... .......... .. ..... .............. . ..... .. . ... . . ........... .. ...... .......... ................. ......
Very little.
... .......................................... : ......... ........... ..
6/3/2019
.........
.. ....
6-146
PM
............. .. ... I ... ......
34
. . . . . ... . . .. . ...... . .. ... . ............ . ..... .............. ..... .. . : ....................
How to fund. Missing the fact that fireworks sales fund many of our non -profits in the city, Without
.. .. : .... . .......... ......... .............. ......... . : ..
6/3/2019
.. ..
4:51
PM
fireworks sales many of them would be unable to continue doing the work, and giving back, they.
2 / 6 Input Summary 2 -Page 73 of 185
.0
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
56
Everything....
. ... .... . ...... . .. . ..... .. ................
5/28/2019
1:26
PM
57
ditto..._
5/28/2019
1.17
PM
58
It's to the point and clear..
5/28/2019
12;32
PM
59
Same
5/28/2019
12:17
PM
60
. .. . .. . .... . ... ....... . ... .... . . . .. ... . .....
With traffic issues, I hope there is a focus on alternate transportation like pedestrian friendly paths.
5/28/2019
10:23
AM
hope a priority focuses on the environment and eliminating environmental toxins and pollutants.
61
see above
5/28/2019
9: 19
AM
62
Focuses on public safety needs that have been eroded during past years
5/26/2019
1 :54
PM
63
Hiring more police officers for traffic control in neighborhoods where people fly through stop signs.
5/25/2019
9:57
AM
64
Emphasis on prevention is always important
5/24/2019
6:18
AM
65
We all learned from the fires that we need to be better prepared for emergencies on a large scale.
5/24/2019
5:57
AM
66
More funding for youth programs
5/23/2019
8:58
PM
67
Please address the homelessness problem.
5/23/2019
2:49
PM
68
I like that city staff has recognized that pubic safety has to be a:high priority for they city
5/23/2019
8:49
AM
69
.. .... ........ ...............
this is bad - test
. .................................... ....... .... ..
5/23/2019
.. ..........
8:43
AM
..... .... ...
70
Likewise, this is
5/23/2019
8:09
AM
71
All good
5/22/2019
6-10,50
PM
72
. . .. . . .. . ..... . ... . . . .. ... ... ... ......... . . ..... . ......... ... .. .. . . ....
Yes yes yes! However, we have to invest in infrastructure. Our roads are past deplorable and
5/22/2019
5:37
PM
unsafe. They've moved to embarrassing.
73
For #11 I would suggest replacing "Consider" with "Implement". We need action not talk. At the city
5/21/2019
5:34
PM
council candidate election forums I believe that most everyone was in favor of this.
. .. . . .......
74
better pedestrian safety downtown and at busy intersection. an example would be to give
5/21/2019
11:58 AM
pedestrians a head start at crossings
75
I'd like to see some reference to support of infrastructure and budgeting to cover this in the future.
5/20/2019
3:56
PM
76
The costs of some items will likely be beyond City capabilities, even with revenue enhancement.
5/20/2019
3:18
PM
And, while a traffic engineer is a good idea, I suspect the upside is less than people think. (I've
never lived in a place where the city did more to optimize traffic signals, but the population
assumed that nothing was being done.) Lastly, much of Vision Zeroisn't aped/bike issue, but
street design issue by which we give too much priority to cars. Slowing cars by 10 mph will get us
80% of the way to Vision Zero.
. . . ........
77
safety
5/20/2019
12:44 PM
78
At first glance it appears to be through
5/20/2019
12:24 PM
79
I like banning fireworks sales for sure.
5/20/2019
10:36
AM
80
I wish to see more discussion on Lynch Creek Trail improvements and safety.
5/20/2019
8:29
AM
81
Very clear
5/20/2019
6:22
AM
82
Where is your focus on volunteer networks ? Nor a dam thing about how churches can help,,
5/20/2019
12;10 AM
83
Fix your street and sidewalks
.... . ..........
5/19/2019
8:46
PM
84
the objectives are good, but if we could just support our first responders and improve
5/19/2019
7:18
PM
infrastructure, we will be in good shape
85
Public safety is good..
5/19/2019
7:12
PM
8 6
See above, looks good overall.
5/19/2019
5:36
PM
87
I like focus on public safety and community policing. Not so sure about more video surveillance.,
5/19/2019
2:03
PM
88
increase staffing of Fire and Police
5/18/2019
7:12
PM
89
.............. .. .. . . . ........ ...... . .. .. .. . .
The goal states housing is needed butit is missing from the objective.
.. . ..... . .. . . . . . .... .. . . ............
5/18/2019
. .. .. .. ....
........ .....
6:32
PM
. .... ....
3/6 Input Summary 2 - 'age 74 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
90 Fixing
the streets,
hiring a city engineer. Working
to help the police
department.,
5/18/2019
99
540-:16 PM
91 Safety
is a critical
'issue, but means many things
depending on the
application. It should be part of
5/18/2019
2:55 PM
every objective
............ ........................ .. .. : ............ ........... . ....... ......... ......................... -: ....... I ... ...... ...... .................. . .......... .. ... ... .... ..... . ....................
94 n/a 5/18/2019 6:30 AM
... .. ...... .......... ..... ........ . ... . . .... . ... ............. ..... ....... ... ........... ... ..... ..... .... ........ ......... ............................. ............................................. .... .. .... .. ....................... ..... ..... .................... ........ ..... . . . .........
95 1 like the objective It makes sense. I believe adding "populationgrowth" should be considered 5/17/2019 8:43 PM
since Petaluma has seen a boom in immigration, drifters, and folks traveling/commuting
throughout Sonoma County to work. i.e. Highway 101
96 Liked the cared for and housed aspect. 5/17/2019 8:20 PM
98
It's essential for the 21st Century
5/17/2019
7:00
PM
99
...... ........................... .. ........... ............... ........ .. ...... .................... ................... 1-1 .......... .......... .. . . ........... :..: . . . ..................................... ... ..
Keeping Residents safe during emergencies/disasters is definitely a priority. Being able to rely on
5/17/2019
6:02
PM
our first responders and making sure they have the equipment and resources to be effective is key.
............. ... ..................
108
..... ........ ... ...... . . .... . ....... ........................................ ... ....... ...... . .. ...... . .. . ... . . . . . . . ........ . . . .. ..... ..... .. .... . . ... .. . . . . . . .. ... . . ... .... . .. ... ..... ... ....... ... . ....... ......... .... .. . .. ....... ... ... ........................
The objective makes a lot of sense given the previous years of aiding Sonoma residents during
......... ..... : ........ ............... ... . ............ ... .. . ......... .... .... .......... .... ... . .... ......... ............... ................... . . ..... ... ......
5/17/2019 10:28 AM
Enhancing public safety with education, improvements to infrastructure and community outreach is
are not mentioned,
109
terrific.
5/17/2019 10:22 AM
.........
110
. ...... .. ... .... . . ................ ....... . ...... ..... .
How does the community provide input and request repairs to broken sidewalks, roads, and trees
5/17/2019 10:19 AM
100
.... .. ...... . ..... ...... .. .. . . .. . .. ... ... ... ..... ..... .... ... ........................................
1 would like it more if the surveillance item was off the list.. It's a total waste of $and is also an
. ..................................
5/17/2019
ill
4:59
PM
112
invasion of privacy. I would also prefer actual road repair vs checking out the facilities for the PPD.
5/17/2019 9:43 AM
alternatives including safe bike routes
101
. ... ...... .. .. ..... . ... .. . .
Be realistic about maintaining ining funding needs of safety personnel,
5/17/2019
4,910
PM
102
Nothing
5/17/2019
. ........ ..
2:49
PM
103
..... .......
The objective does not address the goal of providing housing or an engaged community in any
..............
5/17/2019
.............
19,31
PM
. . . ...... ............ I - . ........ I . . ... ........ .. ...... I ... ..... ........ : . . ............ ............................. ... ...... I ...... . .......... I. -I ................ ................. : ...... ....................... I - ... . . . . . . .. . .... .... . . . - .. .. . . - . . .. ".. .1. ..,. . . .-.. . . - ..... .... : ... . .......................... : ............ ..... : . ...... . .. . . . .......... ..... .. ..... . . ........ - . . . .. . . . -.. . - - - ... - .... -:- .... ... .... . .. . .... .... . -... . .. . .... . . .... .... .. -1:. ... - . - .. . ... .. . . - .. . . . . .. ". .... . . . . :.. - - . . . . . . .. - . . .. ... . .. . ... . .. . .. . . . . .. . . .. .. . . . . . .. ... . .. . .... . - . ....... : .. ....... : .. .: ... ..... .... , - - - . ... ... - .. I . . . . .. .. - .. - .. - . .. . - . . . . - - ..
105 Prevention is key here. What exactly do we need to do to prevent a disaster like the fires in Santa 5/17/2019 12:17 PM
Rosa. How quickly can we do it? WHAT ARE WE WAITING FOR.
. . . ... ........ . .. . ..... I .. . ...... .. .... ..... ...... ... ... ... ...... . . I . .. .... I ... . . .. .. ... .. .. . ... . . ......... I ............. .. ...... ..... . . . .......... .. ............. .... .... :1 .... ... . . ....... . . . . .. .... . .. ....... .. . ............... ... .................................. ................... .............. .......... ... ... ................................ ...... . ................. : ......
106 Enact Rent Control 5/17/2019 12:09 PM
.... ........... : ...... ...................
107
.............. ............... ..................... .. ....... ....................... ............ I... ... ... . . ........ :..- .... ... .... .... .... - ... I .... ........ ..... ... ............. ..... . .. ........... . ................ . ... ........ .... ............. .... .... .... .... ...................................... ........ ........ .......... .. ---.: ....... ...... ............... : ........ .................... -:.-I .... - .. ... . ..........
Emergency preparedness is important but I see it as a different type of threat., Cars are a much
.... ... ... . ................................... ......... .............. . ....... .......................... ..
5/17/2019 11:33 AM
bigger day-to-day danger and quality of life issue. Overall, I feel that people who create dangerous
situations in this town do so because they have no fear of getting caught --whether it's not stopping
I-
at stop signs, using illegal fireworks, speeding, there doesn't appear to be any enforcement so
they do it.
............. ... ..................
108
..... ........ ... ...... . . .... . ....... ........................................ ... ....... ...... . .. ...... . .. . ... . . . . . . . ........ . . . .. ..... ..... .. .... . . ... .. . . . . . . .. ... . . ... .... . .. ... ..... ... ....... ... . ....... ......... .... .. . .. ....... ... ... ........................
The objective makes a lot of sense given the previous years of aiding Sonoma residents during
......... ..... : ........ ............... ... . ............ ... .. . ......... .... .... .......... .... ... . .... ......... ............... ................... . . ..... ... ......
5/17/2019 10:28 AM
fire evacuations. Considerations for 'air quality during those periods may also be of interest and
are not mentioned,
109
. . ..... .... ... .... .
Headed in the right direction:.
5/17/2019 10:22 AM
.........
110
. ...... .. ... .... . . ................ ....... . ...... ..... .
How does the community provide input and request repairs to broken sidewalks, roads, and trees
5/17/2019 10:19 AM
breaking electrical lines.?
ill
Good job
5/17/2019 9-4:48 AM
112
1 like the focus on better roadways surface and moving towards better and more bicycle
5/17/2019 9:43 AM
alternatives including safe bike routes
. .... ...
113
....... . . . . . . . . .... . . . . . . . .. .. ............ ..... ..... .......... . ....... .. .. ........ ... .. .. ... ... . ....... ... ... ........... ... ... .. ..... .... . .... . ..... ........ .. ... . . . .. ............ ........ ......... .. .. ....... . ................. . I ... ... . ..... . I . . ...... ... .. ... . .. ... .. . .. ... .. . .. ... ... .... . .... ............. .. . ....................... I . .... .. I . ....... .... ...... . ........... ..... .... ......... . ... ....... ....... ...........
The facilities inventory/condition is important, and the effects of deferred maintenance can be
... ... .. .. .... ...............
5/17/2019 9:36 AM
devastating,
......................... ........ I ................................ .... .......... .... . .. . .. ......... ........ ......... ..... . . ... "'"' ...... . .. ... .. . ........... . ... .............. ......... . .............. ................ ..... ............ . ................. ........... ..... ................ ... ..... ...... ..... ..... .. . .... . ...
114
.... : . .....
Hiring more cops &firefighters is paramount to our town's safety, especially with increased
. ........ .....................
5/17/2019 9:32 AM
. ........ ..
homelessness and drug usage in areas like Lynch Creek and downtown.
....... ..... ..... . .. .... . ... ........... ... . . ..... ... ......
115
See last answer. I'd like to see the homeless 'issue addressed. Maybe a strict ban on pan
5/17/2019 8:45 AM
handling? And the loitering that happens at the gas station on western. Every day school girls are
cat called when walking home from school,
.. .. ... . .. . .... . .. . .... . ... ..... .. ... .... ... .. .
116
....... ...... .............. .....
It's comprehensive..
......... ....... ................ . .
5/17/2019 8:43 AM
4 / 6 Input Summary 2 -Page 75 of 185
117
118
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
I like that there are lots of ideas, The problem is the methodologv used to define the broad 5/17/2019 8:43 AM
category is flawed thinking
. It is wonderful to think in terms of "public safety
" but in reality the city
departments are the ones that will actually get funding and execute the work. So what really needs
to be thought out is to align these "goals" with the responsible departments. If you do so you will
quickly see what departments are failing to meet the needs and perhaps some real funding
decisions will come from that. Attempting to solve broad problems in broad buckets is short
sighted and will accomplish nothing in the long run.
Change gears - focus on the community taking care of themselves. People want to work with 5/17/2019 8:32 AM
neighbors, help each other. We dont need more funding going toward more police and firefighters.
..............
119 I think. traffic needs to be moved to the highest priority regarding this objective. 5/17/2019 8:16 AM
120 What is missing: school safety, what are we doing to train for and prevent school shootings. Our 5/17/2019 7;59 AM
students and teachers are afraid, this i s unacceptable. Narcan, what are we doing to prevent
overdose and connect residents to treatment resources.
121 10, 12, 13 should be implemented 5/16/2019 1 1.h931 PM
122 I don't have the answer for the need to increase housing while maintaining a decent traffic flow 5/16/2019 7:52 PM
with all the additional cars
123 increase police numbers 5/16/2019 7:35 PM
124 See above 5/16/2019 7:03 PM
125 See #2 5/16/2019 6:35 PM
126 Who decide our budget? Where are all the tax money go for our city? 5/16/2019 4:50 PM
127 Defining terms would be helpful, ie. traffic safety? What is the current level of crime and fire 5/16/2019 44120 PM
prevention? What base line are you building from? Many of us don't know.
1 28 That you are being proactive. 5/16/2019 3:49 PM
129 Don't like the fireworks ban. 5/16/2019 3:12 PM
130 Upgrade buildings to be more resilient- that is a must. 5/1 6/201 9 2:49 PM
131 These objective's cost money. Lots of money, which we don't have.. And we refuse to be taxed. 5/1 6/201 9 2:49 PM
Petaluma is not San Francisco. Is Petaluma a San Francisco wanna be? If we had wanted to five
in San Francisco, we would have bought a home there. We also could have bought a home in
Healdsburg. But we didn't want to live in an over -populated tourist town,,
132 Thoughtful., 5/16/2019 1:30 PM
.. .. .. .. ...
133 We are building so many more homes and east Washington is a nightmare please build the 5/16/2019 1:07 PM
raineer over pass., Also the homeless and obvious drug use and sales on the lynch creeK path
134 ROAD REPAIRS!? 5/16/2019 1:02 PM
135 Makes sense. However, good luck with responding to any emergency in a reasonable amount of 5/16/2019 12:57 PM
time with all the traffic congestion on Lakeville/101, especially during commute hours. Did anyone
think how just one accident on Lakeville will impact traffic in nearby neighborhoods????
. ...... ... .
136 I like that there's a lot of things we're striving for 5/16/2019 12;49 PM
.............. .......
137 Help homelessness in the city. It's an epidemic for a small town. 5/16/2019 12:24 PM
...._...._..... _....
138 Airport engagement 5/16/2019 12:14 PM
139 People need to feel safe. 5/16/2019 11:56 AM
.... . .. .. .. ..
140 I really like the -additional personal being mentioned to be added. If another parking enforcer could 5/16/2019 11:50 AM
be added that would be great. With the abandoned car and trailer issue happening in town having
only one person service the entire town is a lot to ask.
141 It's NOT that I "dislike" this objective, who doesn't want these things? But you've got to have a 5/16/2019 11:22 AM
foundation and fiscal health to make progress.
142 Traffic control. i.e.: Provide incentives for employees in Petaluma to stagger work times, thereby 5/16/2019 11:13 AM
decreasing traffic during the usual busy hours and spreading it out more evenly to reduce
congestion.
143 See previous 5/16/2019 11:01 AM
5/6 Input Summary 2 -Page 76 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
144
Put breathalyzers in local bars/restaurants. Stop prosecuting citizens
at below .08 blood levels to
5/16/2019
110:51
AM
match with the published DUI information. Prevention over prosecution. Stop incentives to give
tickets to raise funds for police --they have become too eager to get $
from small infractions.
.. .. .. .... . . .......
.
145
Emergency safety plan
5/16/2019
10:44
..........
AM
146
I think more information about what video survalence will look like, so
that we are not sacrificing
5/16/2019
101:35
AM
too much privacy.
147
Too many crosswalks a not illuminated, impossible to see individuals
after dark. Vehicles are often
5/16/2019
...........
10:32
.......... .......
AM
parked too close to crosswalks blocking drivers view, pedestrians fail to check whether
approaching vehicle can see them early enough to stop.
148 Same as #2 5/16/2019 10:02 AM
.....................
149 It's a great start, just need to be mindful with communities of color and their ex'periences with law 5/16/2019 9:59 AM
enforcement.
.. . ....... ....... .... . .. . .. ..... .. . . .. ..... ........ .... . . .......... ............... ...
150 I don't believe it needs to be addressed I would like to see pensions addressed or the city and 5/16/2019 9:54 AM
county will be so in debtit will be difficult to afford what is being considered This description is very
vague
....... .. .. .. ... . ............. .. ... .... .. . ... ... .. . . . . ... .. .... ... .... .... . ..: .. .... . . . . . ...... .. ... .... . . .. ......... ........... ............. .... .. ........ . ... . . ... . . .... . .... . . ...... ...... .. . .. . . ...... ........ ......................................... ....... . .. ..... .... ..... ...... .. ....... . .. .............. .... . . . . . ..
151 this is a very well thought out objective, 5/15/2019 2:54 PM
. ..... .. .. .. ........ ...... ....... . ........ ................... .................. ... : ..... ..... ........... . I ........................ .. ............. ..... .... . .... . ...... ...... . . . . . . ... . .. .... ......... ....... ........ ... ..... .. . ...... . . . ... ........... ...... .... . .... . .. . .... . ..... ..... . .. . . ... ..... .... .... .... ........ .... .............................................. .. . . ..... .......... ............ ................. ...... ....... ... ............... ... ..... . ... .......................... .. ..... .........
616 Input Summary 2 - Page 77 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attaciment 3
Q4 What do you like about these work plan items?. Or what are we
missing?
Answered: 138 Skipped: 137
M
11
# RESPONSES DATE
1 looks good to me 6/17/2019 7:21 AM
2 Missing are: Support police officers on bicycles in our downtown and dense neighborhoods. 6/16/2019 3:15 PM
Promote neighborhood sustainability efforts.
3 Seems we need bottom up and top down working in unison. This is top down. I know democracy is 6/14/2019 6#11-49 PM
unweidy but we need more of it right now!
4 Where is the "prepared, safe and housed" aspect located in this goal? I see emphasis on policing, 6/13/2019 8:54 PM
yet nothing on housing'. Nor on fire safety, btw.
5 Reducing automobile use in town is imperative. .6/13/2019 2:39 PM
6 I really appreciate #9 and #10 to increase our preparedness and resiliency and to coordinate fire 6/11/2019 9%,-53 PM
and policing at the neighborhood level. The more involvement from the community, the better'.
7 see above 6/11/2019 7:43 PM
...... .. ..
.. ... .. .. ... . .. ...
8 Traffic and road condition seem to be a hot topic. I'd like to see less cars more pedestrian /bike 6/7/2019 9:59 AM
10 Item 12,,r Add "maintenance" so it reads "Enhance pavement management and maintenance
program".. Although management likely encompasses maintenance, it's valuable to be explicit
because of the need to improve maintenance to enhance safety for bikes, e.g., the need to street
sweep bike lanes more frequently. Otherwise the issue ofinadequate maintenance will not be
6/7/2019 4:30 AM
6/6/2019 9,4,43 PM
emphasized and this is a key issue for Bike Petaluma.
11 no concrete actionpIan 6/6/2019 7:48 PM
12 See above about saving the fair grounds, 6/6/2019 6:05 PM
13 Take into consideration that the city may need to provide mass care for humans and animals. 6/6/2019 5:18 PM
What other organizations should be included in a mass care plan.
...... ........
14 More ways to get around/across town. Safety on Streets. Keep the Historical Area Historical. 6/6/2019 4:27 PM
15 Planning for natural disasters and providing a safe place for the community to shelter is essential 6/6/2019 3:53 PM
to survival during such events. If access or communications are cut-off/limited, the population
needs a centralized place to seek shelter, medical care, food, power & information. Especially if
access to the east side of town is compromised. We feel a fully functioning fairgrounds that not
only provides these services but also helps facilitate outreach and education to empower the
population to better weather an emergency or natural disaster. Especially those with animals. We
also feel, should the council decide to discontinue fireworks sales, the fairgrounds already
provides a free fireworks show (attended by over 8,000 in 2018) that has plenty of space to expand
AND we could accommodate the non -profits who raised vital monies from fireworks sales by
staffing a concession stand at the show to offset the loss in their fundraising. Probably an even
more preferred option as it would require only one day of volunteers, produce less fireworks waste
and significantly reduce fire risk for the community. -Sonoma-Marin Fairgrounds' Board of
Directors
. . .. . . ....... .. . . ....... ...... . .
16 Some of the workplace items could be more specific, for example, #5, 6, 9, and 10. 6/6/2019 114027 PM
17 They are fine 6/6/2019 12:17 PM
. . .. ..... ....
18 Enhance/widen "bicycle lanes" where possible for safety. Eliminate bicycle lanes that assessed as 6/6/2019 11:19 AM
"unsafe". Too many lanes are unsafe for cyclists & motor vehicle traffic.
. ... ... ... ..... ...
19 _ N/A 6/6/2 019 10:5 5 AM
1 /6
Input Summary 2 -Page 78 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attaciment 3
20 You are missing the direct promise to sustain the fair and the fairgrounds from being developed. 6/6/2019 10-:33 AM
Taking away a community space for the area is not the way to preserve a town's character.
Because of the goal about housing, I hope your goal cannot become turned into a development for
builders pockets and people to live in crowded conditions with no fairgrounds. Taking away the
agriculture atmosphere and space to have events should not be on the table. Why would people
want to stay living in a town that sells out. The developers cannot build over every historic site,
and support in Petaluma is quite frankly some of the very worst I have seen in the North Bay.
Including both Marin and Sonoma Counties. We cannot justifiably continue to ignore this problem
whilst claiming to try to e a climate conscious community, nor claim we are doing more to reduce
traffic problems in our town. Cycling and waikability are crucial components in solving Petaluma's
traffic problem, NOT part of the problem, which seems to be one of the prevailing views amongst
some detractors of this idea.
.. ... ...... . ...... .. ............. .. .. .. ..... ............. .... .. ...........
25 It seems to imply increased staffing for police and fire departments to some level that is pre- 6/5/2019 3:10 PM
determined. I question that. I do not see indications that we are under -staffed. I would support
more video surveillance especially for speeding and stop light violations. I do like the idea of
"beats" with officers on foot or on bicycles, engaging the community. Hopefully, it would reduce
the "us vs. them" dynamic that seems to prevail. Similarly with our Fire Department, we are trying
to create neighborhoods that are more conducive to pedestrian and cyclists, yet the Fire
Department would like bigger streets, more paved surfaces around buildings, infrastructure that
accommodates bigger fire engines. Just the opposite of pedestrian priorities.
............. ............................................ ........ .. . ... ... ..... ...... .................... ....... ... : ........... .......................... ......... . ................................... .......... ..... .......... ......................... ... . . ..... : ... .. . .. ..,: .... . ........... : ............................... ..... ................................................ _._ ....................................... ........................................................... ......... ....... .... ... . . I .... . ... .. .. ...
26 There are too many of there. Impossible to focus on all. 6/5/2019 2:17 PM
. ...... .......... ................. ...... ..... ............................. ............. ... .................................. . ....... ............. ...... ." ............... .............. . ....... ...... ........ 1� ...... __ . ................... ... ..................... ..... .. .... ..... ................. .. .. ......... . ......................... .. ................................. .................. .. ... ...... ....... .. ........ ..... ............................... ....... ................
27 Include protected bike lanes throughout the city with no road sections left incomplete. 6/5/2019 10:25 AM
.......................... .... ............... . .......... ........ .............. ............................... ..... .......... ...... ............. ............ .. .... ..... .... ....................................... . ................... ....... ............
28 I like the majority of items. I do not agree with the fireworks ban. Petalumans have been enjoying 6/5/2019 8:14 AM
safe fireworks for years. Instead let's focus on enforcement for those using illegal fireworks both
on the 4th and throughout the year. They are breaking the existing law and are most likely to cause
fires.
29 There are too many work plan items. It I s not feasible. Focus on roads, sidewalks and traffic. 6/5/2019 8:09 AM
. ... ........ .. ... . ..
30 Prioritize these efforts based on global warming and its effects on our environment. 6/4/2019 8:12 PM
.. ..... . .... . . .. .... . ... ... .. . .. .. ... ..
3 1 Video surveillance where - red light cameras only or somewhere else? Slowing traffic on 6/3/2019 10:44 PM
thoroughfares, and coordinating lights will help with safety for everyone. "Safe" bicycle paths seem
to be rare or missing with the condition of the roads, the speed of traffic and unprotected bicycle
paths that are shared with traffic.
.................................. :� ...... ................. ............... : ............ ..... .. ...... . ... .... .... :: ..... ... .. :: .... ........ ......... . ..... ..... .... ........ ............... ..... ................... ............... .......... . ........ .... . ... ... ................ .. . . . .. . . ..... . ....
32 The items sound good. What is missing trust and money. 6/3/2019 6:46 PM
................... .......... . . .... .............. .. . .. ...... ... ...... . . ..................... ............................... . ......................... ... ... .. .. . I-- ... ... ... I ....... .... . ...... .................. . ........ ........ .. ... ..... .... 11 ......... ....... ............... .................... ... ........... ..... .......... ..
33 Input from those served, ways to stop use of illegal fireworks. 6/3/2019 4:51 PM
.... .. ........ . ..... ............ I ........ I ................... ... .... ................. I .......... . .. .... ..................... ..... ... . ...... . . . .. ........ .......... . . ............ .. ... ... ............. . ....... . ..... ............. ............. ....
........ ........... ... .............................................
34 The City is barely able to do what it currently attempts- what makes you think you can manage all 6/3/2019 10:38 AM
this extra?
.. .... .................. ... ........ ... .. . ..................
....... ..
.................. -",:
...................... .
........ ..... ............ . . ....... .. .... .. . ....... .. .. .......
35 Cross Town connectors at Rainer and Caulfield have to be incorporate in this. 6/3/2019 6:00 AM
........... ................. ............... ... ........... . ..... .. . .. ... ..... . .............. .... . . .. ..... .... .. . ... .. . .. ........ .... ......... .
..... .. .... ....... ................ ....................
........ .. ........ ............ . ......... .... . ......... ... . ... ..... .. .. .... ..
36 I like the idea of fixing the roads but we need to get more people biking/walking or using our bus 6/2/2019 5::59 PM
system.
. ................ . . .... .... ............... ...................... .......... .............. . ....... ..... .. . . .. . . ........ . ... ............... ......... . ...... .. .......... ..................................... ............ ............................................... ............. ....
37 As the work plans move forward, please include animal advocatesin preparing a strong case for 6/2/2019 9-0014 AM
banning firework sales and fireworks.
.............. ........... ... ................ ............... . ...... ........ ......................... ........... ......... nr: ......................... ......................... ............. ....... .. . .. . ... ... ... ..... . .. .. ... ...... .. ..... . . ... .............. .... .....
38 Looks like afeel-good excercise. WHy are you asking now if you didn't even incorporate the input 6/1/2019 10:07 AM
offered in the first survey?? ? "People are concerned about future problems with (survey): Traffic
58.13% Growth 42.48% • Streets 37.42% • Crime 37.27%"
. . . . ... . ... . . . .. .. .. .. .. .. . ..... .. ............ .. ... .. ......... . . ............... ................... I ..... ...... I ....... ..... ....... . ... .......................................... ............. ............. .............
39 We need an Evacuation plan in case of a catastrophe 5/31/2019 7:14 PM
. .......... . . .... .. .. ... . . . .. . . ........ ... . . .. ... . . . . .... .. ... . .. . .... ...... ..... ...... .
... ..... ..... . . .. . . . . .. ... .... ... ...... .
40 I like the plans as stated 5/31/2019 6:41 PM
.. . . ................ ...... ... .... .............. : ................. ............... . .............. ............ ... ....... ... . .... . ... . . ......... . ....... ....... .. ...... . ........... ......... ............ ...... ........ .. . .............. . ....... ...........
2/6- Input Summary 2 - Page 79 of 185
41
42
43
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
I like that you are looking at the pot hole problem
Funding needs to be addressed better.,
Items 8 and 13 are particularly important for youth. I also appreciate items 3 and 9 focusing on
Attac i men
5/31/2019 3:11 PM
5/31/2019 10:22 AM
5/30/2019 11:59 PM
t 3
community.
49 X 5/29/2019 7:17 AM
50 Safety is important, but the work plan items ignore underlying causes for crime such as 5/28/2019 11:26 PM
homelessness. We should care about people being housed and fed as much as we care about car
break-ins. The work items disregard community needs as a whole, including preserving open
space and beautifying our community.
........ ... . .. ... ....
51 Much redundancy with this 5/28/2019 9:25 PM
.. ..... . . ... .... .. .. ........ . . ..... ... ........ . .... .... . .
52 Would like more on helping our underrepresented populations feeling safe in town. 5/28/2019 5:07 PM
53 Same 5/28/2019 4:57 PM
54 Everything 5/28/2019 1:26 PM
55 ditto 5/28/2019 1:17 PM
56 They're to the point and clear however I do not agree with banning fireworks due to the revenue 5/28/2019 12.32 PM
loss it will create for non-profit organizations associated to each firework stand.
57 Same 5/28/2019 12:17 PM
.... .... .... .
58 So vague that they could refer to any number of things. Overall, sure, increased safety and health 5/28/2019 12:16 PM
and a thriving community are all wonderful things. Without details,it's hart! to say how much I
support the specifics.
59 Very much in favor of banning sales of fireworks. Would also like to see ban on lighting fireworks 5/28/2019 9:19 AM
coming from fairgrounds. That was scary last year.
60 Not sure we need afull-time City Traffic Engineer 5/26/2019 10-54 PM
61 Good enough 5/25/2019 9:57 AM
........... . . .. . . . . .
62 Neighborhood policing will definitely bring people together 5/24/2019 6;18 AM
63 I like them all. 5/24/2019 5-1957 AM
64 Great 5/23/2019 8:58 PM
65 Initiate rent control measures. 5/23/20'f9 2:49 PM
66 For the most part very good especially fireworks ban. Missing the need for staffing in all 5/23/2019 12:34 PM
departments to better service the proposed work plan and to keep up with the city expansion. City
Engineer has Traffic Engineer responsibility, less engineers and more boots on the ground
workers to keep up with State regulations.
. . .......... ... . .
67 I think the public needs to understand that police staffing is approximately 20 officers less than the 5/23/2019 8:49 AM
state average for a city our size. This is producing negative moral, officer burnout, and crimes not
being investigated:. The crime rate goes down with less officers due to less reports being taken,
yet several crime categories continue to go up even with the skeleton crew of officers we have.
68 I'm not sure -test 5/23/2019 8:43 AM
...... . ....
69 Again might be too many. 5/22/2019 6:50 PM
70 ROADSH! 5/22/2019 5:37 PM
71 Policing efforts that work with the community 5/21/2019 7;57 PM
3/6 Input Summary 2 - :'age 80 of 185
M
emergency preparedness.
44
. .. ... ....
needs to be revised, do not ban firework. The look on the kids faces watching them is priceless!
5/30/2019
5:30
PM
45
See above.. attention to seal level riseis missing
5/30/2019
3:23
PM
46
Very little, our police and code enforcement is corrupt,,
5/30/2019
10:34 AM
47
I think there are too many details in this section to be considered at the full city level. These items
5/29/2019
3:59
PM
should be properly assigned to departments and specific positions in the city.
48
1 am happy to see our youth included in the plan and the effort to address non-english speaking
5/29/2019
8:42
AM
community.
49 X 5/29/2019 7:17 AM
50 Safety is important, but the work plan items ignore underlying causes for crime such as 5/28/2019 11:26 PM
homelessness. We should care about people being housed and fed as much as we care about car
break-ins. The work items disregard community needs as a whole, including preserving open
space and beautifying our community.
........ ... . .. ... ....
51 Much redundancy with this 5/28/2019 9:25 PM
.. ..... . . ... .... .. .. ........ . . ..... ... ........ . .... .... . .
52 Would like more on helping our underrepresented populations feeling safe in town. 5/28/2019 5:07 PM
53 Same 5/28/2019 4:57 PM
54 Everything 5/28/2019 1:26 PM
55 ditto 5/28/2019 1:17 PM
56 They're to the point and clear however I do not agree with banning fireworks due to the revenue 5/28/2019 12.32 PM
loss it will create for non-profit organizations associated to each firework stand.
57 Same 5/28/2019 12:17 PM
.... .... .... .
58 So vague that they could refer to any number of things. Overall, sure, increased safety and health 5/28/2019 12:16 PM
and a thriving community are all wonderful things. Without details,it's hart! to say how much I
support the specifics.
59 Very much in favor of banning sales of fireworks. Would also like to see ban on lighting fireworks 5/28/2019 9:19 AM
coming from fairgrounds. That was scary last year.
60 Not sure we need afull-time City Traffic Engineer 5/26/2019 10-54 PM
61 Good enough 5/25/2019 9:57 AM
........... . . .. . . . . .
62 Neighborhood policing will definitely bring people together 5/24/2019 6;18 AM
63 I like them all. 5/24/2019 5-1957 AM
64 Great 5/23/2019 8:58 PM
65 Initiate rent control measures. 5/23/20'f9 2:49 PM
66 For the most part very good especially fireworks ban. Missing the need for staffing in all 5/23/2019 12:34 PM
departments to better service the proposed work plan and to keep up with the city expansion. City
Engineer has Traffic Engineer responsibility, less engineers and more boots on the ground
workers to keep up with State regulations.
. . .......... ... . .
67 I think the public needs to understand that police staffing is approximately 20 officers less than the 5/23/2019 8:49 AM
state average for a city our size. This is producing negative moral, officer burnout, and crimes not
being investigated:. The crime rate goes down with less officers due to less reports being taken,
yet several crime categories continue to go up even with the skeleton crew of officers we have.
68 I'm not sure -test 5/23/2019 8:43 AM
...... . ....
69 Again might be too many. 5/22/2019 6:50 PM
70 ROADSH! 5/22/2019 5:37 PM
71 Policing efforts that work with the community 5/21/2019 7;57 PM
3/6 Input Summary 2 - :'age 80 of 185
M
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
and
barely
stopping
(or not) at
stop signs taking kids to schoolln the
AM
(Elm and Schuman, Elm
and
West),
and kids
racing up
western after school. Enforce the laws
for
these folk, and you
4/6 Input Summary 2 - Page 81 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
100 Our roads are in need of repair in many places all over the city. This needs to be a priority. I am 5/17/2019 12:17 PM
constantly swerving to avid giant pot holes and dips, hoping to avoid blowing out a tire and I can
afford to keep my car safe, new and maintained. Imagine others who are less fortunate? I also like
the idea of focusing on walkability and bicycle safety. As important as our roads are we need to
make our city accessible in more ways so that driving isn't as important. Our cityisn't THAT big.
People can easily bike from North East to South West with the proper routes and safe paths
identified. In terms of preventing disasters, we need to invest in modernizing our city so that we
are on the forefront of climate change related upgrades. More solar, underground connectivity,
incentives to green businesses, schools, programs THINK BIG, BE BOLD. BE LEADERS.
101 Enact Rent Control 5/17/2019 12:09 PM
. .. .. ... ...
102 Traffic planning and health. With the upcoming expansion of 101, there are certainly 5/17/2019 10:28 AM
considerations around dampening the noise and air quality of increased traffic. Fireworks ban,
good.
103 Headed in the right direction. 5/17/2019 10:22 AM
104 No comment at this moment. 5/17/2019 10:19 AM
. ... ...... .
105 Refer to question #2 5/17/2019 9:48 AM
106 Impose stricter penalties for cyclists who don't follow the rules of the road (i.&., not stopping at stop 5/17/2019 9:32 AM
signs/lights, impeding the flow of traffic, etc.)
. ... .. .. ... .
107 I like all of it. 5/17/2019 8-L45 AM
108 Bring back Community Emergency Response Training to educate and engage civilians. 5/17/2019 8:43 AM
. ......... ........ ...
109 Like I've shared the items are the items, what is importantiswh1chdep artment "owns" the issue 5/17/2019 8:43 AM
and WHY have they not addressed it? Itis not that these items are new or that somehow were
never thought of before, because they are not and they have been addressed many times,. The
REAL issue is the politics of funding and the politics of pet projects and social engineering which
has dominated the council for the past 15 years. All while the unfunded pension liabilities sky
rocket, the airport, marina, roads, street lights and traffic signals are nearly destroyed due to
"deferred" maintenance.
110 Community first - neighbors helping neighbors. Neighborhood watch programs, first responder 5/17/2019 8:32 AM
training for civilians. Support our growth not more city departments and bureaucracy.
111 Sadly I do believe it's time for a fireworks ban :(Sonoma County has seen to much destruction 5/17/20198pl6AM
from fires.112 Much of the first points ae all things any city should be doing without a survey. Duh. As far as 5/16/2019 11:31 PM
public safety and kids go, resource officers are not helpful, unless the ultimate aim is to punish and
harm kids when other socioeconomic factors need to be assessed first.
113 They are good 5/16/2019 7:52 PM
....... .. .
.1.14 good start 5/16/2019 7:35 PM
115 Looking at ways to reprioritize spending, not addition spending 5/16/2019 7:03 PM
116 See #2 5/16/2019 6:35 PM
117 For all the Sonoma county cities, I saw the worst road condition is in Petaluma. How do you 5/16/2019 4:50 PM
encourage our city worker to take pride for their work? All the land scape in Petaluma is a mess,
who should be taking responsibility to improve it?
118 Assess and identify traffic needs and develop organizational structure to support needs, including 5/16/2019 4:46 PM
the possibility of adding afull-time City Traffic Engineer position.
119 what work plan items have existing programs in place? How do you know where you want to go if 5/16/2019-4:20 PM
you don't know where you are? For each item I would want to know where we currently are and
percentage of budget currently allocated.
120 Same as above. 5/16/2019 3:49 PM
... ......... ................. ....... I ...
121 Don't like the fireworks ban. Prohibition doesn't work. 5/16/2019 3:12 PM
....... .. .. ............ ...... . . ... .. . ... ........
122 Better city transportation should be factored into this work plan 5/16/2019 2:49 PM
... ...... . ..... .
123 What's next? Safe injection sites? You are also turning Petaluma into a homeless destination. Be 5/16/2019 2;49 PM
careful what you wish for.
... ....... ... ............ .
5/6
nput Summary.2 -Page 82 :)f 185
0
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
.1
Attachment 3
unsafe.
............... .................................. .............. . .............................. ........ ................... .. .. ....... ... ... ..... .... .... . ... ... ......... .... ... ..... . ... .
129 I'd like to see a greater focusin promoting safety downtown, including bike and ped access, and 5/16/2019 11:56 AM
thp- narkinn naranac
trying to get across town --many who've diverted from 101 to D Street for example-- are stuck in
long queues'? Of course, some bad actors will do bad things, regardless of what'education' or
traffic enforcement measures.
... . ... ................ ............. ..... . . .... .. ..... ... .. ...... ............................. ... ... ........
131 Considerations for cyclists and pedestrians 5/16/2019 11 : 13 AM
.............. .... ...... ...... . . ...... . . . ....... .. I ......................................... ............... .... : . .... . ...
132 113ke that there is an emphasis about emergency preparedness, especially in light of the Paradise 5/16/2019 10:35 AM
and SANTA Rosa/Napa Fires.
133 There was a time when there were PUBLIC SERVICE MESSAGES.. We need something like that 5/16/2019 10:32 AM
again to educate people about how to be safe.
..... ....... I ...... I., .... .. ............. .. .. ...... .... .... ................. ...................... ............... .................. ...... ................ .. ...... ...... . .. ... . . .... . . .... ... ..... ... ...... ........ .. ... ... ........ .. . . ... . . .. . . . ... .. ... ... .. ..................... : .... .... 1:1 ..... .. . .. . ... ....... I .. ..... .... .. . I .... .... .............. . . ': ...... .. .. ........... ......... .......... ................ .... ........
134 7. Assess and identify traffic needs and develop organizational structure to support needs, 5/16/2019 10':26 AM
including the possibility of adding a full-time City Traffic Engineer position. Instead of adding a
resource, ensure the development is not aggressive. Have been noticing many houses being built
in a veru small real estate area without much consideration to traffic. Sustainable growth is what is
6/6 n Summary 2 - Page 83 of 185
I
21,
LO 00 (Y)
llllli� CIO
VMO
m
c
Min
Input Summary 2' Page 84, of 181
i�
K�
0
r
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
Q6 W-iat do you like about this o.-:)Jective?. Or, what are we missing?
Answered: 167 Skipped: 108
E3
RESPONSES
1 focus on affordable housing
DATE
6/17/2019 7:22 AM
2 Considering alternative housing - good to check in w. Habitat for Humanities program in Oakland 6/14/2019 6:52 PM
building inexpensive homeless housing without usual permits.
. . . ....................... ........... . . .. ......... . . .......................... . . .. . . .. ... .. ....... . . . .......... . .. . ..
3 affordable housing plan 6/14/2019 6-614 PM
. . .. ...... . . .. .. ... .. ... .. .. ..... . ...
4 It is not the role of government to create housing opportunities. I especially disagree with municipal 6/14/2019 1:36 PM
bureaucrats tinkering with property rights and wasting resources over "diverse" housing
opportunities.
5 Nothing. Home prices are set by the market. We do not need more people in this city and we 6/13/2019 6:04 PM
definitely don't need any more slummy section 8 housing
6
..........
good, but need
to
emphasize safe,
healthy,
affordable and
attractive, as
well
as "diverse."
6/13/2019
10
......................... . ...... ... . -.: .................................... ......... .......... ................ .... ............ . . ... . . .... ............ ........ ....... . . . ..
average citizen housing affordability?
....... .. ........... ..... ....... ...... . ............ .... 11 ..... ...... .. . .......... ............ . ...... I ........ . . . ... . .... ........................................ ................................... ......... ..................... . ... .. ..... ..... ...... ....... .......... ...................................... ............... ........................... . .......... .. . ... ....... ........................ ... .... .. .......... . ................................... ...... ......... ....... ..... ....... .... ......... ......
2;42 PM
7
........ .. : ........................
The city needs
.... ... I . ........
to
. ...... .. . ... . . I .. ... .... . ...................... ............ ............................ .............
address housing
... ..................... ............................
needs in
......... . .
a multitude of
.................. ................
ways so I like
: ...................................
that
..................... .......... .. .... ...................................................... ....... ......................................... .........
the objective includes
........... ...............
6/11/2019
............................ ...................................
.... . ..... ...... . ....
6/6/2019
.................
10:04 PM
"diverse housing opportunities".
8
Items 1, 2, 4, & 5 I agree with and are good. Not sure if Items 3, 6, & 7 are needed..
....... .... ........ . ...... ..... .......... .... ......... .. . .
6/11/2019
. ... ............... 1-1 ... ...... . ... .... . ........... .............. ......... .......
.. . . .......... ... .... ... .. .. .. . .
7:43 PM
......... I .... ...... I ............. I .... - ..... ... '.., ........ ..
9
. I .. ........... .... . .
Affordable housing
6/8/2019
8:34
PM
10
......................... . ...... ... . -.: .................................... ......... .......... ................ .... ............ . . ... . . .... ............ ........ ....... . . . ..
average citizen housing affordability?
....... .. ........... ..... ....... ...... . ............ .... 11 ..... ...... .. . .......... ............ . ...... I ........ . . . ... . .... ........................................ ................................... ......... ..................... . ... .. ..... ..... ...... ....... .......... ...................................... ............... ........................... . .......... .. . ... ....... ........................ ... .... .. .......... . ................................... ...... ......... ....... ..... ....... .... ......... ......
6/6/2019
..... ... ............... ....... .. ..... ...... .... . ..................... ..................................
7:57
.. ........
PM
................................ ....... .................... .
11
The homeless outreach team should be a very high priority
6/6/2019
6:06
PM
12
..... ............. .. ........................ ..... .......................... ..... ............ ........................... .... ..... I .... .. ................. .. I . ... .. .. I .... ........ .. . .. .. .. .... ... ........... ... I ... . ......... . .... ......... ...... ... - . .. . . . . . . ................ .....
Affordable housing
.... . ..... ...... . ....
6/6/2019
5:19
PM
crime.
17 I don't want to have Petaluma create an environment that draws more transient homeless people 6/6/2019 12:10 PM
to our community increasing their presence. 1 see several intersections in Novato with homeless
people on a " schedule " to replace each other throughout the day to make sure the location is.
staffed to get money from dr ivers passing by or tents and trashy mess on our streets or shopping
centers.
1/7
Input Summary 2-'ag
e 85 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
.... . .... . ..
22 This coal/objective set is really critical. The moblems of homelessness and housina affordability in 6/5/2019 6:22 PM
Petaluma are becoming worse and worse and I am glad to see the city seeming to step up in this
.0
area. We must approach these problems with a compassionate heart and a desire to help uplift
those in need. I feel this goal/objective/work items strongly represent that ideal. Specific call out:
am strongly in favor of restoring the Homelessness Outreach Services Team ASAP. Also, the
process of approval for Accessory Dwelling Units in Petaluma is one of the worst I have
encountered, largely due to the lack of consistency between planning department documentation
and actual enforcement at the permit/planning approval process. The major divide seems to be
between the main planning department and fire department. I recently experienced this firsthand
when attempting to get through the permit process which initially seemed straightforward and then
spiraled into a grueling 6 month process between my architect, the planning dept. and fire dept:
23 I like inclusive and diverse housing stocks. 6/5/2019 34914 PM
......... . . .. . . . . . .... . ......... . .....
24 Addresses the housing issue in Petaluma and the fact we have a homeless problem. 6/5/2019 24:24 PM
25 We need to integrate housing types and household types. A bit of chaos enlivens a community. 6/5/2019 140-40 PM
26 It is ok.. 6/5/2019 11:02 AM
.............
27 It's unclear whether any of the homelessness proposals are likely to succeed. I think the city needs 6/5/2019 8:15 AM
new ideas - eg a study of best practices - to work on homelessness and to determine if housing for
teachers, etc. is really a priority. There are lots of affordability issues in the city; I'm not sure
housing for these particular groups is the best use of funds. Police and firefighters make way more
money than people working in retail, for instance. I like the idea of loosening restrictions on
accessory dwellings.
28 Re instate homeless outreach. This city needs it the city has become over run. 6/4/2019 8:40 PM
.. . . . . . . ..... ......
29 Disconnect permanently from the M Group and start listening to the citizens of Petaluma re 6/4/2019 1:45 PM
development, traffic, water shortages, etc.
. . ........ . .. . .. . . ...... . ..
30 I like the focus on housing - the lack of it and especially the lack of affordable housing What's 6/3/2019 10,0,50 PM
missing is more innovative ideas like "tiny" houses for the homeless and veterans that some other
communities have successfully built on city owned property, for example it could be part of the
pian for the fairgrounds.
.... ......... ......... .
31 I don't want to hear how government workers need a handout to buy a home. police and fire have 6/3/2019 6:48 PM
good salaries and benefits. I am sure they are a two income house hold.
32 How are you going to do this 6/3/2019 4.-,,51 PM
.. . .... ..... . ... ...... . . .. . . .. . ... .... ...... .
33 All your attempts toirnprove housing have made it more expensive for most buyers. 6/3/2019 10:44 AM
3a,
Much of this is somewhat already being done. Bringing back the homeless cops is a priority and 6/3/2019 60011 AM
there should be more of them added. Stipends should be added to employee benefits to
encourage and assist them in affording to live in town. City should include subsidized housing
units and make them available to city employees like they do for low income. Currently, cops,
firefighters, teachers etc cant afford to live in town. I know I would love any of these to be my
neighbors!
35 Restoring homeless outreach team 6/2/2019 6:00 PM
....... .. .. ..
36 We need housing for people who already live and work here. 6/2/2019 1:27 PM
37 You are missing the fact that we are a sprawled town not a city. To fix housing problem, partner 6/1/2019 10:12 AM
with Vallejo or Marin to get them to build their fair share. Why ruin Petaluma?
38 To bring back the HOST team 5/31/2019 6:42 PM
39 I like that it notes the need to handle the housing issue with collaborative means. 5/31/2019 10,028 AM
. .. .. ..... ..... . .. ....... .
40 Housing costs are the biggest barrier to thriving lives in the Bay Area, and they promote 5/31/2019 12;03 AM
gentrification of the region. We need to create conditions that promote diversity and support
working class families.
..... ....................................... .
41 low house community will HURT Petaluma, why!!! 5/30/2019 5:34 PM
..... . . ...... .. ....... ....... I . . ........ ...... . ... .. .. ... .. . .........
42 Such a high priority. If we can provide housing for the entire community we will thrive. 5/30/2019 5:19 PM
. .. . .. ...... ........ ..... I-- .. ......... .... ................... .. .... .... .. ........... ...... . ......... .......................... . ............
43 Secure affordable housing is a critical need. We must support policies that create living 5/30/2019 3:26 PM
opportunities for the workers we rely on.. and for our children..many of whom can't afford to live
here.
2/7
nput Summary 2 - 'age 86 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
44 Addressing low income housing. If the city council was serious about housing thev would have a 5/30/2019 10:43 AM
plan in place. What gets approved in west Petaluma is vey different than east Petaluma.
45 We develop housing that has very little affordable housing and our next generations are being 5/30/2019 9:28 AM
priced out as well. I understand supply and demand but something has to give
. ... .... ... ... .... ..... . .... ... .... ... . . ... .. ... ....
46 Petaluma needs to stop growing - we've allowed way too much building and we are losing our 5/29/2019 9:22 PM
charm, our country vibe and our infrastructure cannot handle the additional traffic/ cars. -Crime is
higher as we have more people/ apartments/ condo's etc. and less police officers. I am against
any further building'.
47
The objectivels clear and laudable.
5/29/2019
4:03
PM
48
Would love to see no panhandling
5/29/2019
7:18
AM
49
. ... ....... . . ... ... .. ..... . . .... .. ....... .. .
Shelter is critical. Be careful where it is located. Santa Barbara contributed to the decay of its once
5/28/2019
8:19
P M
thriving State Street retail area by locating homeless services next to a retail center.
50 Separate the homeless who need help with housing from the bums. Some people are just not 5/28/2019 7:28 PM
3/7
n)ut Summary 2 -Page 87 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
74 [like the plan, I would like to see more programs for kids who are homeless, perhaps building up 5/21/2019 102-38 AM
and expanding programs such as Mentor Me and Boys and Girls Clubs, a couple of open gyms
after school.
75 Allowing tiny houses,maybe for the homeless. Maybe a family mobile home park as affordable 5/20/2019 4;06 PM
housing.
76 I didn't see a reference to middle-class types with service jobs outside of government; people other 5/20/2019 3:59 PM
than teachers, police, fire, municipal employees.
77 The objective as stated is reasonable, but see comments below on workplan items 5/20/2019 3:21 PM
.... .. ...... .... ...
78 Housing for teachers and public service employees 5/20/2019 12:46 PM
79 Work with Davidon to transfer their ownership of ALL the land into Sonoma County Parks and in 5/20/2019 12:42 PM
exchange do a Land Swap. They can build their Expensive Homes but with a percentage
dedicated to First Time Home Owners-lesser price point, at the Adobe Creek Housing/Golf course
Area that already has infrastructure .
80 Agree with all points 5/20/2019 10:37 AM
81 I am glad that bike/ped infrastructure and a fireworks ban are included. Public Transit also 5/20/2019 9:49 AM
contributes to a healthy lifestyle and should be added.
82 It's essential to infill empty lots, allow for mixed housing (single home &multiple units) in a 5/20/2019 9d:30 AM
neighborhood &good access to mass transportation &shopping close to neighborhoods.
83 Everything.5/20/2019 8:30 AM
84 Wondering what diverse means? 5/20/2019 6:27 AM.
..... ...... ....
................... . . . . ....... .. ... . .... .... .
85 I like the affordable housing and ada housing 5/19/2019 8:46 PM
. ......... . ..... . . . . .
86 This is an ambitious, action oriented plan. I especially like the idea of expediting accessory 5/19/2019 7:20 PM
dwellings for needed housing.
87 #1, b ut that's' it. The rest is a waste of money. 5/19/2019 7:14 PM
88 Need a whole lot more information to formulate an opinion here... 5/19/2019 5:21 PM
89 Parking needs to be taken into account. 5/19/2019 4:56 PM
90 I think all of these objectives are vital to our community. I would very much like to build an ADU, 5/19/2019 2:05 PM
but simply can't afford it. Perhaps some financial support for those who would like to provide
housing in this way?
91 Housing is critical issue. I'd like to see something done, perhaps through grants or something , to 5/19/2019 1:49 PM
facilitate more affordable housing, and also perhaps to support first time home buyers and city
employees.
92 Needs to be community wide re "affordable" housing—notj"'ust a select few. Also re "affordable° 5/19/2019 9:27 AM
have you considered alternative building materials/construction designs? For example "Earthship"
homes that use recycled materials, and leave virtually ZERO carbon footprint?
93 Affordable housing, such as PEP 5/18/2019 7:14 PM
94 Recognition of the housing crisis. 5/18/2019 6:35 PM
95 Affordable housing and homeless services are important but a works program to help the 5/18/2019 6:21 PM
homeless lift themselves up could also help
96 It's fune 5/18/2019 5:17 PM
97 I like that there is a recognized notion that we need a 5-year plan. this was missing in the previous 5/18/2019 2:58 PM
objective. We need a plan so that we can maximize efforts and results.
98 More attention to mental health/addiction services and training for police in de-escalation 5/18/2019 11:37 AM
techniques.
99 Restore Homeless outreach team. 5/18/2019 9:57 AM
. ... .... . .. .. ..... .
100 We have enough housing already. Build infrastructure before you invite more people. 5/18/2019 7:56 AM
.. . ... ..... ........ ...... ....
101 Good. 5/18/2019 6:32 AM
102 Considering existing options for housing 5/17/2019 8:24 PM
4/7J Input Summary 2 -'age 8 8 f 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
103 Love that the homelessness is being addressed with these. Affordable housing for teachers is 5/17/2019 8:10 P M
crucial,.
104 we need to be more concerned about the workers that need housing and health care. We need to 5/17/2019 7:56 PM
take care of the people who work in our communities.
105 My top priority is #3 Agree with all Would add de-escalation training for teachers and first 5/17/2019 7:03 PM
responders.
. . .. ........ .... . ..................... ..... . ... ........ ........
106 The word "diverse" is.
important, We must recognize that we need to support affordable housing 5/17/2419 6:07 PM
options, so that we do not loose our teachers, first responders etc. due to their struggle to live and
work in our community.
. . . . . . . . . . . . .... ....... . .. . ......... . ...... ... ... ........
107 Well we certainly need to do something about affordable housingin Petaluma. It's.not surprising 5/17/2019 5:03 PM
that oeoole are !!vino in their vehicles or comr)letely unsheltered.
green and clean? How can we feed our low income and homeless population with community
narrlanc atr.
housing. Affordable housing is too often poorly des igned. Good design doesn't mean expensive. A
5/7
In Dut Summary 2 - Page 89 of 185
housing commission should include designers and architets with a proven record of affordable,
....... ....
sustainable, and well designed projects
................. .. ........ .. ..... 1: ..... I ....... I ...... I .... .... I ... :-----.--.'.-.-: ........ ........... ...... ...... ................ I., .... .. _._: .. ........ . ............ _:. ........ . . .................... .. .................. ......... :,: . ....... : ...... ...... ................... . ... ........... : ... . ........ . . .. . . .. .. ... . ..... .... .. ...... . .. ....... ..................................... ......... ............. : ........ ... : .... ....... . .... ...
.. .... . ..... .... .
114
..
Addresses community need
.
5/17/2019 10:30 AM
..... .. .. ... ..... . .............. .... ...... . .... ..........
115
...... ...... I ...... .............. ...... I . . . . ... .. ... .. .. .. ... .... .... . ... . ...... ... . .. ... . .. .. .. .......... . I ....................... .. .. ....... ..... ... . ....... ... ............. .. ..... ... . . . .... ............ ....................... .... ............ I .................... .......... ........ .............. .. ..... .. .. .. .... ... .. ... . ... .... . . .... .... ........ ........... .... ............. ......... ....... ..................... ..... .... ....... .. ............... ................. ......... ........... ......... ..... .......... ......... ....................................... ... ... ........... ... .. ... .......
Again, I believe this is a tong needed goal for renters and people suffering from homelessness.
... . .... .
5/17/2019 10:25 AM
When will the city decide to adopt "Rent Control Laws" similar to Berkeley, Oakland, Richmond, or
San Francisco. Will all new housing developments include affordable units
116
. .... ......... . ... I ..... ... . I .. . ...... . .... . ............ ... . . "I', . . ........ I ....................... ................................................ ....................... ... ......... .......... ..................... ...... ........... ..... ....... ........ ........ .... ........... ......... ......................... ................................ ......................... ...... .. .... I", ................... .. ...................... ..... ............... .................. ..................... . .......... I ........................................... ........................... ......................
Headed in the right direction
... .... ....... ......... .. ........ .. .. ..... ... ..... ... .. ... . .... ... .. . ....... . . ..... ... . ....... ... .. ...... . .. . .. . . . ... .. .. .. .. . .... . . ........ . .
5/17/2019 10:22 AM
.. . ... ....
117
I agree with supporting services for the homeless, but we can't continue to building housing. We
..... ..... .. 1: .............. ...... I ...... .......... .... ... .. .. ..... . ......... . .. . .. . .. ...
5/17/2019 10:07 AM
are already too populated,,
.... ..... ...................................... . .
118
We need more lowincome housing.,
. .... .. . ... ... ... ..... ... : .... ...... ... .. . .. .. . .
5!17/2019 9:52 AM
............. I ......
119
Everything!!
........... ..... ....................................
5/17!2019 9:51 AM
120
..... ..... . .. .... .......... ................ ....... ..... ... ..... . . ............... ...
I like that housing in general is getting attention., My children cannot afford to live here, that is not
. . .. .. . . . . . .. . . .... .. . . . .... ..... . ... ..... .. ... .. .. . . ........ ...... .... ........ .... . .. ...... ............... . .... . . . . . .. .. . .. ....... . ..... . .. .. ... .. .
5/17/2019 9:47 AM
good, Homeless folks need a way to get out of that cycle, this is a step in that direction.
. ..... . . ... ...................................... .... ... ... ...
121
........................ ....... . .... .................. . . ....................... ...... .... ......................................................................... .... ..... ........................ ............... .... ...... .. ........... ....... ............................. : .................... : ...... ......... ... ............................................. .. . .. .. ....... ............... ................... ................... ........ .................... ....... ........................................ ................. : ................... . ................ : ......................... .... .. ........ ': .......... .. ..
Developing housing programs for teachers, municipal and safety workers is a great idea. They are
.. .... ........................... ..... ..........
5/17/2019 9:41 AM
a tragically underserved population who aren't paid enough to meet the high cost of living here but
who make too much for public assistance. Teachers should be at the top of the list for help'.
122
....... . .. ......... ................................ ...................... . . .... . . ...... ........ ..... .... . ... .. .. . . ... . . . ... ......... ... ..... .. . . ... .... . . .. . . ........ . .... . ... .... ...
1 like that it seems inclusive..
5/17/2019 9:39 AM
.... ..... ............................ .. ........... ....... .....
123
... ........... :: ........ ......... ........ ........... ......... : ............ ..... ......... ... .............. : ......... ..... ............. . ....... ........... ......... : ............ . ...........
I love that you are addressing Accessory Dwelling Units. Please make it easier for people to add
....... ... ...................... .......
5/17/2019 90:18 AM
ADUs to their property for family and others who need affordable housing.
124
. ... ...... . ........... . .. .. .
Nothing. Cities are not in the business of housing affordability or availability. They can control and
5/1 7/201 9 8:47 AM
effect neither. Lots of puffy talk but no real solutions other than to drop the price of permits for'
.. ...... . .. .. . ..... .... .............. .. ..... ..... ..................
developers who profit from that drop.. Silly.
.... .. . . .. . . ....... ........ . . ........ ............ . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . ..
............. .................. : .......................... ....
125
All of it:. Sounds comprehensive:.
5/17!2019 8:46 AM
... ..... .. .. .... . ......... . ..... .... ..... ..... . ....... . . ...
126
.. .. .. .
Support & Design? There are no existing organizations to support this objective. The designers of
5/17/2019 8:45 AM
such programs are large development companies that build for profit not for communities. This
objective is all words with nothing to back it
127
......... ..... .... . ................... ... ............ ...... .
Housing insecurity and food insecurity are big issues. both affect employers.
5/17/2019 8:04 AM
. . ....... ....................
128
... . .. ... . ..... . . ... .... ................... .. ........ ....... ....... .... I ... .. ...... ... .... . .. . .. .. .
This should be a top priority. And require future developers to adequately pay for roads and public
... . .... ..... .. . . . .. . . .. . ....... ... . .... .... . ........ .... ......... ... . .........
5/17/2019 7:46 AM
facilities that will help Petaluma accommodate the growth that will come with additional housing.
.... ....... ................. . .. . . ...... . . ..... ........................ ....... I ..................... ................. ... ..................... ....... I .. ..... - ... : ........... .... I.: .... . . ................................ ...................
. ..... ....................... . ..............
5/7
In Dut Summary 2 - Page 89 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
129 This should be near the top of any goal list so I'm glad it is. 5/17/2019 7:14 AM
130 Stop housing homeless and making this a place where they are welcome! Many stop signs/ off 5/1 7/201 9 6:18 AM
ramps/ and nearly every department store parking lot has homeless and beggars. Petaluma is
becoming less and less safe and desirable.
131 This needs to be objective #1 5/16/2019 11;32 PM
132 Whv would we spend all this money to house all those homeless that are showing up here that 5/16/2019 7:54 PM
See #2
The'lligh management staff need to cut down their salary, and restructure with less high
managers. The base staff like teachers, school staff members need to get pay better, also hire
5/16/2019
7:36
PM
5/1
6/201 9
6:36
PM
5/1
6/201 9
4:54
PM
136
housing!
5/16/2019
4:32
PM
137'
........... ..
Like "all' petalu mans
5/16/2019
4:23
PM
138
N/a
5/16/2019
3:51
PM
139
Affordable housing. Rents are too damn high.
5/16/2019
3;14
PM
140
Need more creativity- micro hotels, safe places to park.... etc Wheres CASA compact? Elephantin
5/16/2019
2R,-59
PM
the room,
141
Not in favor of accessory dwelling units. Almost everyone has at least one car, guests, and
5/16/2019
2:59
PM
laborers, etc. Where will they park their vehicles? The streets are so narrow in some areas, that
cars can barely pass safely on streets with parking on both sides of the street. How will fire trucks
and other emergency vehicles be able to respond when the streets are clogged with vehicles?
And in Petaluma, most of these vehicles are trucks or SUVs. THINK]. Not everyone has to live in
Petaluma. When is enough ENOUGH? Again: Please don't turn Petaluma into San Francisco
south.
.... .. ... .. . .. . .
142 Needs to include WHO and HOW this is going to be paid for. Parcel taxes? Sales Tax increase? 5/16/2019 2:10 PM
It's all nice to write this down but there aren't details how to pay for it.
.. ...... .. . .... .... . ...
143 That houslngi's included. Although we need a Housing Oversight Board all incomes. 5/16/2019 1;34 PM
. . ....... . .
144 Rent is very expensive here and all no -developments are only required to make a fraction of the 5/16/2019 1:09 PM
homes for low income.
145 We need affordable housing 5/16/2019 1;02 PM
146 Whereis Marin County's part in this scenario? Seems like Sonoma is getting dumped on. How do 5/16/2019 1:01 PM
you house homeless if they do not want to be housed? I think homeless families need priority.
147 That it includes inclusivity. Like the idea of a Housing commission 5/16/2019 12:51 PM
............
148 Recognizing that the current infrastructure does not support the current population, New housing 5/16/2019 12:34 PM
must be preceded with improved roads.
149 I believe we all see the need for housing. How do we get past the barricades of development? The 5/16/2019 12:15 PM
small group resistance to development in a specific location.
150 This is the most urgent issue facing our city in my opinion. 5/16/2019 12:14 PM
151 I feel we are trying to get more housing for the people who work in our town, that ya great! But I 5/16/2019 11:52 AM
also feel we need to make homeowners feel more welcome.
. . .... ... ..
152 Businesses, our diverse community, those less fortunate... all of us have a shared interestin 5/16/2019 11:28 AM
affordable, safe, housing. But, with what I've witnessed with both California (abuse of CEQA by
disingenous parties using environment objections to serve their non --environment real purpose) --
who's going to put up with 6 or 7 or more years to take a developer's risk? Has the City ever
conducted a "peer -review" of the effectiveness vs. costs of our existing subsidized housing?
153 Safety is very important, more police officers are needed. Pedestrians and cyclists safety is vital 5/16/2019 11:24 AM
but will never be satisfactory unless better is improved, Cyclists almost never follow traffic laws,
often behaving like pedestrians on wheels at crosswalks/intersections. Need I go on.
154 Would be nice to include the housing of homeless animals. 5/16/2019 11:15 AM
6/7 Input Summary 2 -Page 90 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Also, we have to doing a housing first appropriach to u sheltered individuals and where would that
Wr 14W,
that can only be done centrally: infrastructure, utilities, etc. Once again doing the political niceties
that one.
............. .. .... ..... ..... . . . ............................ .. . .... . ..... .
165 Finding programs that are affordable and to have a specific team for our homeless community is 5/16/2019 10:01 AM
1
7/7 Input Summary 2 - Page 91 of 185
T
t
1
2
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q7 What do you like about these work plan items ? Or, what are we
It missing?
Answered
RESPONSES
:122
Skipped'. 'E53
making our town more affordable will be a more inclusive approach and enriches the community
In addition to affordable housing for public safety, municipal employees and teachers, please add
those working in the nonprofit sector. Add: (1) Provide housing for our current houseless
population. (2) Eliminate single family zoning and allow for up to four units per lot.
DATE
6/17/2019
7-9,22
AM
6/16/2019
3:19
PM
. . ..... ........ . . . . .
Basic good nature - devil in'the details. What will support these ideas? What will block them? 6/14/2019 6:52 PM
They are aimed at our most vulnerable residents and may encourage more diversity. 6/14/2019 6:14 PM
5 You are missing fairness to all that are not unionized employees. Why should they deserve special 6/14/2019 1:36 PM
housing treatment?? You also neglect to consider enforcing vagrancy laws and removing bums
from sleeping on our streets and in our parks and menacing public health and property rights.
6 nothing _ 6/13/2019 6:04 PM
. .. . . ...... ............... .... ....... .. . . . ... . ... .... .... .. .
7 Need to provide housing while achieving no net loss of open space/unbuilt land 6/13/2019 2:42 PM
. .. ... .... .
8 I love that #1 addresses housing needs for our city, school and safety workers. That should be a 6/11/2019 101:04 PM
priority. I also like #7 that seeks to develop an inclusive housing plan.. The tract homes of the past
are not going to fit many of the needs today. We have to start thinking outside of that very limited
model.
9 They address the needs of the community. As John Records told the leadership class of '97 the 6/11/2019 7-0,43 PM
average Petaluman is only 3 paychecks away from being homeless.
10 without affordable housing for employees, businesses will be leavingarea; employees already 6/6/2019 7:57 PM
commute from other counties, which increases traffic problems
11 Discount rates for seniors keep them going. 6/6/2019 4:30 PM
1 2 Missing is the plan to not expand the town, how we are going to manage what we have existing 6/6/2019 1 :37 PM
before we get bigger. It is just vague enough to say that we are giving carte blanche approval to
get bigger.
13 Like focus on ADUs. Absent are workplan items to address affordable rent. 6/6/2019 1:30 PM
14 Nothing 6/6/2019 12:18 PM
15 On the other hand, housing brings traffic 6/6/2019 12:03 PM
16 Please read my 6. comment 6/6/2019 10:36 AM
. . . . .. . .... ......... .. ... .. . .
17 getting homeless off the streets 6/5/2019. 9:00 PM
18 Speaking from Bike Petaluma: Referencing "healthy community" without calling out actions to 6/5/2019 6:22 PMi
promote and improve cycling and walkablity in the community seems wrong.
19 Glad to see health services included, including mental health, I hope. I don't know why the City 6/5/2019 3:14 PM
does not do more to support COTS who already has a successful, proven program.
20 I like that a committee on homeless will be created. It is a chronic problem and is creating 6/5/2019 2:24 PM
dangerous streets, However, too many, perhaps, utopian plans that can't realistically be
completed with City resources right now.
21 Bike Petaluma would like affordable housing accessible to safe complete streets. 6/5/2019 11:02 AM
22 See above 6/5/2019 8:15 AM
23 Love them! Let's emphasize simple dwellings, smaller footprints, filling in open lots, smart housing 6/4/2019 8:15 PM
That's sustainable. Eliminate McMansions and other behemoth dwellings.
24 See number 6 above for what I like and what's missing. 6/3/2019 10:50 PM
1 /5
1n)..utSummlarY2 -Page92 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
%WO I I I
housing first for those who already live and work here. Keep the lists-* do not do a lottery.
31 Work plan 44: include-* work with City's Animal Services provider to coordinate wellness, food, 6/2/2019 9:17 AM
supplies for pets of homeless &seniors in need.,
2 / 5 Input Summary 2 -Page 93 of 185
for example) that there should be no more building for many years. We're losing our open space
feel.,
35
...................... .... . . . .................. .. ......... ........ .. ...... ................................... .... ..................
Item 1 is important to ensure that our public servants can actually live in the town they serve, to be
........ ...................
5/31/2019
12:03
AM
apart of the community they serve.
36
... . ... ... .. ... . .. . .. . .. ....... . . .... . ..... . ......... I ... ... .. .. ......... .. . . . ...... . ....
Nothing this Will HURT Petaluma and cause too much traffic. Also the Illegal immigrants are not
...... ................. ....... ........ ..............................
5/30/2019
...............
5:34
PM
always nice people, and they do not follow rules!! This is about money?
37
. .. ... . . ... .......
It hits all the key points I can think of.
5/30/2019'
5:19
PM
38
. . . ....... . ....... . . .
Very little except support for homeless and substance abuse need to be a priority, I do not support
. ......... ..................... .......... .... I ..... .
5/30/2019
10:43
AM
subsidizing police, city employees or teachers. I don't support subsidizing two income families.
. .. . ... .... . ...... .
39
..... ................ ........ . .. .. ............. ........ ................. ... .... ....... ... . .. .... ... . .. ... ....
affordable housing
. ....... . ....
5/30/2019
.
9:28
AM
.............................. .......
40
.. ....................... ... ... ........... ...... .... ......... ........... ............................................... .......................... ....................... .... .......................................................... . .. .... ... ...... ... .. ....... ..... .................... .................................................. ....... .......................... ....... ..... .. .................... 11 .......................................................................... ............ ... . ...... ...... . .... .... . . ............................................................................................ ................................... ......................... .......... . . . . . ......... ........ ...... .. ... ... .. .... . ...............
We already have affordable housing on Petaluma Blvd North and Payran/ Magnolia/ Petaluma
..... .......... ............... . ........
5/29/2019
.............
9:22
PM
Blvd North,.
41
.... .. ............. .. . . ...................... .... ... ....... .... ......... .... ..... ...... ....... .... ............ ......... ............... . ......................................... . ... ........ . ... . . . . ...... . ....... ... . ...... .. ... ........... .......... .................................. .. ... .... ...... . ................. .... ............... ..... ...... .. .. ........................ ............. .... . ........ ... . . .. ..... .......... . . ... .. ..
It's not clear how you intend to assign roles and responsibilities. What will the Team do versus the
. . ........................... ... .. .................. .... ..........................
5/29/2019
........................
40403
.. ............................ ............. .. . .... ................. .... ...
PM
Commission?
42
. .. ... .. ... ... ..... ... .. .. . . ... .. ........................ .. ...... ........ ... .. . . ........ . . ........
X
5/29/2019
7:18
AM
43
. . .. .. ... ..... ... . .. ... .... ..... ..... ...... .
none
.. ................. ....... ..........
5/28/2019
5:07
PM
44
... : ........................ ... ............ ...... ....... ...... ... ......... ....................... ........................ .......... .......... . ....... .. ... ............. : ............. ............................................. . ...... ....... :.:.: ..... ................ ...... ....................... ..... .... ............... ....................... ........... .....
see above
.............................................. .........
5/28/2019
.........
..........................
5:01
............. ................................................ ......... .
PM
45
........ . .............. ..... .. . ..................... .............. ................ ... . . . ..... . .. .. ......................................... .. .. ............. .. . ... ....... ................ .... ... . ................ ...... .......................... ................................ . . ... .......... ... . . . ....... . .......... .. . .... ... ............ . . .................................
Same as 6
........ ..........
5/28/2019
1:27
PM
46
. . . . . . . ... ... .... ............... ..... ................. . .................................................. ................... ... ...... . .... ......... . . . . . .. .... .................. .. ........ ................. .................. .......... ...
ditto
...........
5/28/2019
1:19
PM
47
.... .. .... . I .... .. ... .. . . .. .. . . . . .. . .. .... . ............ . . . . . . ......
Adding affordable housing to an overpopulated area is not the answer. People can either afford to
.... . .. ... ... ........... ..... ................... . ............ . . ... ..
5/28/2019
... .......
. . .....
1214,37 PM
leave here or not and if not there are plenty of affordable places to live outside of Petaluma or even
California. Why do we continually add more and more people when we face 'issues of drought,
traffic, pollution, etc? I am not for affordable housing in Petaluma.
48
. .............. .. .......
Housing provided should be high density to support other City goals
...... ..... .... ............ .. ...................... . ..
...... .... .......................... I ...
5/2812019
.... .
... .. .
12:23 PM
49
It sounds great. On paper. So far we have police whose main in interaction with people who are
5/28/2019
12:18 PM
homeless seems to be to move them away from the shelters they've created for themselves. While
it's not ideal to have people living along the river/trails, until you create real alternatives for people,
it's inhumane to just break down the camps.
50
............ . ..... . . . .... . . ........ .. .. .. .. ... ....... . ... . .. .. ... . . .. . I . .. . . ....... ... .. .... . . ......... . ...... . .... .. .. ..... .. .. ... . .... . ....... .............. .... 11 ...... .... .. : ............ . ......... ....... .. ....... .. .. ... . ........ .....
Worthy goals
5128/2019
9:20
. ...... ... : . ...... . ..... .... ... . . .... . . ... . . ..........
AM
.............. . .....
51
. ..... . ................ ...... . I ... ... I ..... .. .... ..... ........... . ... ... .. ...... . .... ..... ..... .. . . . .... .. . . ..... .. .. ........ .... . . . ................ . ... ............ ....... .. . I ......... .......... ................. ... ... ............................ .............. . .
1 like numbers 6 and 7, create a housing communion and work on a 5 year plan.
5/2712019
....... ..... ........... ........................ . ....................
12:34 PM.
52
...... .............. .. .............. ............ ..... ......... - . ...... .................. ......... . ..................... ......... ...... .......................... .......................... . ................. . ... ...... .. . ............................
Generally manageable items for the local community but many of the problems need state and
5/26/2019
1:57
.......... ............ . .....................
PM
federal solutions and resources and cannot be solved by local communities
53
.... ........ ....
Increased crime problems as a result of homelessness.
.. . . . ............... . . .. . .. . ... . .... .. .. . . . .... . ..... . .... .... ......... ..... ... ........... : ...... ............. . ................ ..................... ............ .................. . . . . ....
5/25/2019
9;57
........ ........... ....
AM
2 / 5 Input Summary 2 -Page 93 of 185
J
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
55 Mandated substance abuse treatment connected to benefits offered the homeless. Differentiate 5/24/2019 2:20 PM
panhandlers from homeless from urban campers from mentally ill .Don't lump together. Video
Lynch creek drug deals goin down.
56 Is one of the possible solutions to increase affordable housing is to encourage home owners with 5/24/2019 6:24 AM
extra space to open their homes up to share with those who need to live in Petaluma
... : .... ...... .............. . . I ... .................................. .............. ... ................................ .. .............. ........ ...... . .
57 Improve the municipal water supply. Currently what runs from our taps is UNDRINKABLE., 5/23/2019 2:51 PM
58 Missing; The 5 year plan needs to include the water system. System needs to be evaluated for 5/23/2019 12:40 PM
59
60
capacity and fire needs.
1 understand the urban growth boundary is sacred ground for a significant portion of the populace,
but you can not create affordable housing without some growthTherernn andneedstn hin-
a
It t
balance between growth and environmentalism. Smart and we
community and environment healthier.
You are missing it with the accessory loving units!!! You kill neighborhoods and increase traffic. If
hought out growth makes the
you make in law units easier to build i t you MUST consider the neighborhood and street traffic and
............. ... .. ....
5/23/2019 8:49 AM
5/22/2019 6:53 PM
3/5
Input Summary 2 - Page 94 of 185
infrastructure.
61
Identify areas where housing should be developed,,
5/21/2019
7:59
PM
62
a thriving and safe community requires opportunity's to interact. A good way to do this is to make
5/21/2019
12;02 PM
Petaluma a bicycle and pedestrian friendly community. Another way is to have more parks.
63
Need to encourage, promote density near city core, as part of walking/biking plan. Also much more
5/21/2019
8:43
AM
should be done to encourage ADUs in current single family zoning
64
See above
5/20/2019
4:06
PM
65
Otherwise seem .good.
5/20/2019
3:59
PM
66
.
lfwefocuson publicem ployees in need in need of workforce housing, wemissthemany
... . ... ....... . ................................. ........ ..... ..........
5/20/2019
3:21
PM
members of the labor force who work for similar wages for local employers.'Perhaps we can find a
way to make the employers partners in this conversation. And for all beneficiaries of workforce
housing, how do we address the question of them taking jobs in other communities?
67
.............. .... ... . . ........ . ........ .. ... . . I ...... .... ... ..... .
Careful of too much in -fill that is literally choking existing neighborhoods and flow of traffic.
5/20/2019
12:42 PM
68
All good. And more patrols along LCT in the meantime, please.
5/20/2019
8:30
AM
69
Supportive services including mental health and SUD Tx?
5/20/2019
6;27
AM
70
Good
5/19/2019
7:20
PM
71
Nothing
5/19/2019
7:14
PM
72
.. . ... .... .
A specific plan to deal with drug abuse among the at risk and homeless.
......
5/19/2019
5d11,21
PM
.... .......
73
Housing must include parking. Please do not assume everyone will'use transit or have electric
5/19/2019
4-8456
PM
cars - that is a privilege not everyone can afford. Many of us have long commutes and transit
infrastructure is not where it needs to be to address this. New housing needs lots of parking.
74
see above
5/19/2019
2:05
PM
75
I really like the idea of affordable housing for city employees and teachers. I'd suggest using part'of
5/19/2019
1:49
PM
the fairgrounds property for that (as a quid pro quo from a developer for other parts of the fair
grounds
76
The City needs to look at howit can help incentivize new construction through improving the time
5/18/2019
6:35
PM
and costs of entitlements like Santa Rosa.
77
It's fine
5/18/2019
5:17
PM
78
Petaluma has too long allowed developers to tell us what they want,, We need to tell developers
5/18/2019
2:58
PM
what we need if they want to do business here.
79
The long term plan.
5/18/2019
11 :37 AM
80
. ........... .. . . . . . .. ...............
Not considering the impact on infrastructure,,
5/18/2019
7:56
AM
81
Good.
5/18/2019
6;32
AM
3/5
Input Summary 2 - Page 94 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
82 Like al of them, missing maybe reevaluation of habitable buildng codes to consider all the existing
empty buildings as temporary or live/work housing
Attachment 3
5/17/2019 8:24 PM
83
more affordable housing units would be built if it was more affordable to build in Petaluma.
5/17/2019
4:15 PM
7:56
PM
84
Everything
5/17/2019
. . .. . . . ... .. ....... ........ .................... ... .. ... .. ................... . .. .......................... . .. ............ . .... ....................
See above
71-103
PM
85
1 especially like 41 and 47
5/17/2019
.... .. ........ ... ... . . ................. .......................
12:10 PM
6:07
PM
..............
86
. ... ........... ................... ................ .. ... .............................. . . .. ....... . ..... ....... . . .......
Have PPD stop harassing the homeless for one. Instead. thev could TRY to help them find
5/17/2019
... . .. ..... .................... ..... ...... ............
AM
5:03
PM
services/housing. Maybe get training for officers so they aren't such douchebags and
condescending creeps,,
87
. . . . ..... ... . ... .. .. . . .... . .... ..... .... . .. . . ... . .. .... .
Item Create housing for the homeless.
5/17/2019
4:15 PM
88
. . . .... . ..... ........... . .
Get out of city council
5/17/2019
2:50 PM
89
. . .. . . . ... .. ....... ........ .................... ... .. ... .. ................... . .. .......................... . .. ............ . .... ....................
See above
.... ..................
5/17/2019
12:20 PM
.... ....... ................
90
... .. .. ..... .................... .... .. ........
Enact Rent Control
...... . . . . . . .... ... . ........
5/17/2019
.... .. ........ ... ... . . ................. .......................
12:10 PM
................ ............................ .................. ....................
92
......... . . . ......
Headed in the right direction
................. ................
5/17/2019
...... ...... ... .. . ..... .. .. .....
.............................. ............................................................ .................
10:22 AM
.. ......................................... .... 11 ......
93
1: ................. . . .... ... .......... . ....... I ....... I . . .................. .... .... . .. . . .
Seems comprehensive from what I know at this point in the conversation.
....................................................................... .... ... ................... . ......... ..............
.... . .................... ...............
5/17/2019
............. . . ..... ... .. .. . . . . ... . .....
......... ... .. . ..... .........
9:51
........... ......................... .............. .. ....... . . ............ .. .... . ....
AM
..
94
.................. . . .............. ........ ....... . .. ... .. .. ..... ... .. ... .. ... I .. ...............................
Why we don't already have a
................. ........ ........................ ......... ....................................... ......................................... .................................... .. ........... .......... .
Housing Commission is mind-boggling!
... ..................
........ ............ ...................
5/17/2019
.. ................. .... .... .. ... ...
......... ........ . ..................................
9:41
... . .. ..... .................... ..... ...... ............
AM
95
. . .. . . ..... .. ........... .. ... .. . . .... . . . . .... . .. .. ...................... . .... ... ... ...... .. ......... ... . .. ... . ... ..... . ........................ .. ........ ........... .......... ................... .. ... ........ ..... ........ .... . . .......... ... .. . .............. ...... ... .
What is missing is the realization that homeless is perhaps never going to
go away until there are
....... .... ........... ..........................
5/17/2019
.... ....... ......... .......
..................................
9:39
........................ ........ .. ... . . . ........ .. .
AM
programs in place to address
the root causes. Some people are not going
to accept housing, just
because. I'm not sure it's our
responsibility to make sure everyone is housed,
96
.... .. ..... . :
A little reality needs to be put
.. ...... .. .. . .... .......... . . .. ... :-1 ..... .. ............. ................... ................................................... ................................. .... ........ ......................................
in place here. Yes every elected city council
...................... .............. I ..... . . . ... -, .... .. .... ..
person wants to say the
..... ................... ..............
5/17/2019
...................................................................
8:47
.... .. ... .................
AM
"right'
right" thIng but the truth as I've said here is you cant do a thing about this.
is
It a free market and
the market will dictate. Focus
on something you can actually do.
97
. ..... . ... .....
All of the above.,
.......................... .. . I ................. .............. .. ..... ... .................................................................. .............. .... .......... ............ .. .............. ........... ... ... .... ...... ... ...
. ... . . .. .. ...... . . . .. . . .. ..
. ... ... ...... . .... . . .. . . .. .. ..
5/17/2019
. .. ....... . . ..... ..... ... . . .. . . ... . .. ... .. . ....
.. ...... . . .... . . ..... ..........
8-:46
.. .... . .. ... .. .. ..... . .... .. I .... ... ... .. ...... ... .. ........ . ... . . .....
AM
....................... .... ........................... .......................... .... ........... ...... ......................... .... ... . .. .. ......... ......... .......... : ..... ... . ... ... ....... .. . .. I ............. .. . ..... ..... ... . . ... . I ...... 11 .... I ...... . .. I... - .. . .... .... .... . . . . .. ... . ... . .. . . . .. ... . . .... . .. . ... . .... .. .. . I . . . .. . .. ...... ... ..... . . ... ... . . .. . .. ...... .. ......... .............
103 Have you appoint along-terrn members for this plan to oversee how it is built? 5/16/2019 4:54 PM
. .... .. ............ ...... ........................ ............... ...... .. .. ..
5/16/2019 4:32 PM
... .. .. . . .. ... . . ........... . ... .. .. .. . .. ..... . . .
5/1 6/201 9 41:23 PM
. ... ... .... .... - - .. .. . .. .... . .. . . . .. .. . . . . . ... ... . . . . . . .. ... . .. ... . ... . .. . . . ...... .. .. . . ... .. - .1 . .. . .. ... . .. . ... . ... .... - - .. .. . ... .. .. .. . . .. .. .. . .. . . . . .. .. .. . ... . .. . . . - . . . . .. ... .... .. .. ....... . . .... .. . . . .. . . . ... .. . . . . .. .. . .. . . . . ... . . .. . .. . . .. .. . . . .. .. . . .. .. . .. . ... . .. . . . . .. ... . .......... . . ...... .. ... .
106 N/a 5/16/2019 3:51 PM
..................... ........ ............ .................... . . . ........................ . ........ ...... .. .... ... . ... . ..... . . . ...... . .. ... . . ... ....
107 Affordable housing, 5/16/2019 3:14 PM
..... ............ ..................... . ............. .... . ....... ....................................................... ................
..................... .... ............. ----------- ............ . ........... ..... .... ... .. . ..... . .. ........... ...... ................. ....
108 Safe places to park (at the fairgrounds). Create-taxes/fees to discourage out of state residents 5/16/2019 2:59 PM
moving here and taking our housing... Luxury property sale tax and increased assessment, Tax
owners of multiple homes (ie 5+) so wall street doesn't own our single family homes
. ..... ... .... . . .. . ....... . ....... I ........... ............... ...... ....... .................... ... ..... ..................
109 Again: Who pays for additional Commissions? Do you really want to attract more homeless to 5/16/2019 2:59 PM
Petaluma? The last time I visited the animal shelter, I was put off by all of the homeless along
Hopper Street. And they are in that area because of COTS. And I understand that COTS now
allows drug users and alcoholics to stay at the shelter? I used to donate to COTS but no more. I'm
disgusted. And it's bringing more crime to Petaluma, too. Are you going to continue to turn a blind
eye to this, too?
...... ............ .. ... ........... .. ... .. ... . .. ...... . . . .. . . . .... ..... . ............. ...... .. ..................... . ........... .... ... ........ ... ........ . ......... I ....... . . . .. ........ .... .............. ... .... . . . ... ....... . :...: . ..... . ..... .... ... . .... I . ... .. . . ... ... .... ..
4/5
Input Summary 2 -Page 95 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
.. . . . ..... ..... ..... . . ..
110 Certainly idealistic! Are we being realistic? Seems like a small percentage is working very hard to 5/16/2019 1:01 PM
subsidize a large part of the population.
1 11 It's missing Funding 5/16/2019 12:51 PM
112 I am highly supportive of reestablishing the HOST team and making it easier to construct ADUsdr I 5/16/2019 12:14 PM
think we need to encourage all types of housing, even market rate.
......... . . .
113 Think about a small home village- less than 1000 sq,. ft,, 5/16/2019 11:59 AM
. .. .. ......
114 Again, we all want housing for all of our community. So, show me how the City plans to set 5/16/2019 11:28 AM
MEASURABLE objectives or milestones for this? How do we cost -justify to make sure we are
"best -practice"?
115 Too many crosswalks are poorly lit, some not at all. Very dangerous after dark. Take a look at the 5/16/2019 11:24 AM
crosswalk out the public library. It is missing access ramps and amazingly is only as far as the
median on the divided street. Never seen anything like it, surprised the ADA or some other entity
hasn't sued.
116 Consideration for the aging population and affordable housing 5/16/2019 11:15 AM
. .. ... . ..... . . . ......
117 I would like to see more open space like Helen Putnam RP and schollenberger 5/16/2019 10:55 AM
1 18 I think there also needs to be a plan for infrastructure, because our roads suck and if there is more 5/16/2019 10:38 AM
housing or more people, how we are going to budget and pay for ongoing road repair.
119 3., Restore the Homeless Outreach Services Team. Not sure about what it means by "Restore". If it 5/16/2019 10:35 AM
creates any financial impact to the city, itis not something that I would recommend doing. 5.
Facilitate construction of Accessory Dwelling Units. This is Great 1,.1 However, the whole approval
process, stringent requirement (most stringent among the counties according to everyone single
person 1 have interacted with), incredible atrocious fees collected for securing the permit needs to
be IMPROVED or ELIMINATED in certain cases. Reasonable permit fee would be much beneficial
to both cities and people who would like to construct. Please help.
120 Delete in its entirety. The City cannot work as a charity. It has to look after ALLits residents. 5/16/2019 10:05 AM
121 Solid. 5/16/2019 10;01 AM
122 Community oriented and caring. 5/15/2019 2:58 PM
5/5 Input Summary 2 -Page 96 of 185
k
I
% 0,
al
•
a
Input Summary 2 :.. Page 97 of 185
cl-M
L�
i
all
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q9 What do you li {e about t iis objective? Or, w'iat are we missing?
RESPONSES
Answered; 134
1 Seems a good direction; no additions at this time.
.. . .. . .... ... .. ...... . .
Addresses the need for more access to healthy food.
Skipped: 141
DATE
6/14/2019
6:54
PM
6/14/2019
6:16
PM
This entire objective falls outside the purview of government. It is not what American government 6/14/2019 1:41 PM
was created for and itis not sustainable. I do not agree to pay taxes to support any of these
objectives.
6 The automobile is missing as a source of negative health impacts 6/1 3/201 9 2:44 PM
7 I'm all for promoting well being. 6/11/2019 10:18 PM
8 Items 1, 31 4, 61 71 & 8 are good Item 2 is a waste of time. What do you really think it will achieve? 6/11/2019 7.44 PM
Item 5 - What is meant by "visitability"? Don't we have enough encumbrances on new constriction
as it is?
15 Providing more for seniors 6/6/2019 12:04 PM
16 Where is your commitment towards preserving the fairgrounds? 6/6/2019 10-439 AM
17 To promote well-being of families, must include well-being of pets. 6/5/2019 10:23 PM
18 1 don't understand the objective. Is this about supporting our aging population.? 6/5/2019 10:10 PM
19#4 6/5/2019 9:01 PM
20 Sounds OK, but seems overly general and non-specific. 6/5/2019 3:18 PM
21 You can't go wrong with promoting good health and making public services and facilities available 6/5/2019 2:29 PM
to do so.
22 It's too vague. We need a clearer vision of what is meant by "healthy community," and "active 6/5/2019 1 :42 PM
living."
23 It is ok, 6/5/2019 10:38 AM
24 The city has lots of opportunities for people of all ages. Keep doing what you're doing. I'm not sure 6/5/2019 8:19 AM
what the visitability ordinance is but that seems like a low cost option., Fixing roads, sidewalks,
lighting and public toilets would be helpful to promote walkability and community involvement for
people of all ages.
25 Government should not bein business of encouraging active living and increasing recreational 6/4/2019 8:22 PM
opportunities:. Leave it to families, friends, and our cultural norms.
26 All the health promotion measures are valuable, 6/3/2019 11 :02 PM
..........
27 Lots of territory. 6/3/2019 6:50 PM
28 How funding 6/3/2019 4:51 PM
1/5
Input Summary 2 - Page 98 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
29 More useless busybody bureaucracy and fees passed on to customers. Do less better, not more 6/3/2019 10:48 AM
worse.
. ....... . . ..
30 The city should ban marijuana dispensaries, vape products.. Incorporate small circuit training 6/3/2019 6:11 AM
equipment along walking jogging trails and at parks like Spring Lake trail. Make the Community -
Center and Lucchesi Park a priority and clean it up. Cleanliness is an issue there,, The pond,
geese, and homeless all contribute to make this park disgustingly dirty littered with feces and
prevents me from frequenting the park with my family.
.. .............. ....... . .. ................ ......................... .......... . . . ......... .............. .... ..... ...... . ..... ....... ....... . ........... ........ .................................. ..... ............... . .... .. ....... .. ..... ................................ ... .......... ............. .. ...... . ..... ... I ............. .................. ...
31 Are you kidding? This is not quantifiable.? It is spending without hard results. No "wellness" -that is 6/1/2019 10:18 AM
not a top need. Deal with the homeless, the garbage and human feces along the river, the
druggies that hang out along river trail, the beggars that obstruct traffic at many intersections.
.. ... . ...... ...... . . . .. . ...... ... . . ... .. ... .
32 the focus on wellness 5/31/2019 6,0144 PM
. .. ... .. . ... .. .. ... ...
33 Lovely objectives, We don't have the financial resources to support this. We don't need to spend 5/31/2019 10:43 AM
$$ to evaluate "becoming an age friendly city." Creating programs for item 3 above is something
that we already have,.
...... . ..... .. . ...... . . ..... ........................... ... ................. .... .........
34 We need more recreational opportunities and spaces for our youth. Not baseball and soccer fields, 5/31/2019 12:06 AM
but spaces to gather and events that promote community.
.... .. .. .. ..... ...................................... ............. .......................... : ..................................................................... .......... .. . ....... . ..
35 Nothing 5/30/2019 5:35 PM
. ... .. ... . .... . ................................... .......................................... .............. . ..... ...... . . ........ . . ... .. ....... . . . ... . . . . . .. . .. . ... ... ... . . ..
36 We're humans and we need to be healthy. 5/30/2019 5:21 PM
. .. ...... ........ .. ... . ... ..... ... . . ... . ..... ... .. . ...
37 Engaging seniors is beneficial to the community as a whole. Collaboration with the health care 5/30/2019 4:33 PM
district is an ideal method of utilizing existing quality infrastructure.
.. .... . .. ...................... ..... .. ........ .... I . .... .. .... I ...... .. . . I ... ...... ............ . . 11 ... ........ .. .... : ...... ... I ... ... : ............... ................. ..................................... ....................................... ........ I ........ ... ......................... . . .... .. ...... ..... .. ..
38 Attention to quality of life. This then encourage community, and individuals engaging with each 5/30/2019 3:28 PM
other, which is the basis of a vibrant City.
.... . .. ................... .............. ... .... ... .......................... .. ......... .. ...... ......... ............................. ... ... . ...... ....
39 Anything we can do to increase healthy options is a good objective but focus less on the aging. 5/30/2019 9:30 AM
. ........... .......... . ........... .. .. .. .... ......... ...... .... .. . .. .. . .. . .. . .... ..... . . .. . . . ... .... . . .................. ... ........... . . .. .. . . .... . ..... ... .. ....
40 1 like very little about the plan:. 1/2 the towns concerns:, 5/30/2019 9:27 AM
. . .. ..... ... ...... ........ .. .. .......... ........ .. .................. ... ..................... I ....... ............. .................. ... .............. .... . ..... ............................ ............ ................. ... ... . . . .... . ..... ... ..... . ....... .. .... ........ ... .. .......... .... ................ . . ... . . ...... ...... .
41 #8 resonates with me 5/29/2019 9-60-23 PM
44
This is too much for the City
. . ...... ........ ....................... .... .. .. . .. .. . . . .. .... . .. .. ... . . . ... ..... .............. .... . .. . . . ... ...... ............... .. .... ............. ..... ... .. . ...
to take on, particularly a city facing serious financial challenges
.......... ......... ..... ........
5/28/2019
51
8:21
PM
45
What about vaping? I hate it
.... . ....... . . . ....
and teens should not have access.
5/28/2019
7:30
PM
46
Low cost recreational or free
..... ..... .... ... .... ........ ..... ..... .......... . ... .. . ... .... .. ....... .. ..... ..
activities/facilities needed
5/28/2019
.... ......................
5:09
.. ......... ............ ......
PM
...... .... ............. . ..... ................................. ..... .. ... ... ... . ............... ........... .............................. ............................. ...... . . . . . ..... . . . ... . . . .. ....... . ..... ... .......... ... . ... .... ... ..... .. .. ..... . . . I ....... ..................... .... . .......................... ......... I .. ... . ..... ...... . I ... ...... . 1: .. ...... .... . ... . . .... ... .. .............................................. ......... .. . .................................... : .........
49 See item ONE answer! 5/28/2019 1:20 PM
.... .................................... .......... ...... ...
50
...... .. ..... . . . . .. . .... . . .. . .. . ..... I .... . . .. ... I .... . ...... .. . I . ...... ...... ... .. ... . ..... ...... . . ..... ... . . . . . . . ..... .. ..... ............... ... . . ........ ...
Multicultural wellness programs
... ..... .. . .. . . .. ...... ....... I-- ....... .... ........... ........ ...................... . . . . ...... . ...................... ....................... ........ . .......... ................ ......................... ........ ......... .................................... ......... ..
5/28/2019
.. ...... .. ........ ........ ...
. ............... . .. ... ... .. .... .. .. .. ... ........ ..
12:29 PM
... ....... I
51
Not sure what "Visitability" means for single home dwelling. I would like to see an imphasis on
.. .........................
5/28/2019
.........
. ....... . .. ........... .......
10:28 AM
support to grocery stores that focus on zero waist. I dislike stores that skirt the plastic bag ban that
mask plastic bags by calling them "reusable.." This example may not be what the city can focus on,
but my hope is that the City could adopt measures that truly prioritize "zero waist" and the use of
one time use packaging/materials,.
............... ........................
52
... . ........................ .................. .................... . ......... ..... .. ... ... . ...... . . . . .. ....... . . . ... . .. ... ....... . . .. .. . . ..... ....... ............ . .. ... . . ........................... .... : . ..... :.: .............. ..... : ....... . . . .... ........ . . .. . . ... .. ... .
Worthy goals
5/28/2019
..........
9:22
AM
.....................................................
53
... ..... .. ............ ............. ..... ........... .. .. .......... ....
.............................................. ... ........ . : .............. : .................. ..... ... .. .............. : .......... . ..... ....... I ... . ............... .. ......
All ages addressed,
... ...................................... ... .. ... .. . ..... . .
5/25/2019
9:57
AM
54
Let's be clear there is only so much we can do. In regards to seniors homeless etc. unless they
5/25/2019
6:51
AM
want to change and/or participate all these new idea and programs may not appeal to some who
do not want to change. we should organize our priorities accordingly.
55
... .. .. .. ..... ....... ..... ... .. . .. .... ...... ..... .... . ....... .......... ::: ...... ...... .. .. ......... .............................................................. ..................... . ........
Offer free behavioral health services,
. .... . .....
5/23/2019
2:53
PM
2/5
Input Summary 2 -Page 99 of 185
56
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Marijuana use has become an epidemic. Vaping is now rampant among our youth and vaping is
often how marijuana is used. They city needs to pass strict marijuana use laws, eliminate
dispensaries, and create an anti-drug education program.. We are telling our youth that drugs are
not only ok, but encouraged with the current stance of the city and the public. The city can and
should pass Taws that our more restrictive than the state. Don't let the vocal minority allow drug
Attachment 3
5/23/2019 8:49 AM
58 The Healthcare District is very important, but it's important to engage with St. Joseph's at the 5/22/2019 5:40 PM
hospital as well.
59 looks good
60 I like working toward our town offering a healthy environment no matter your age or income.
....... ..... .. ....
61 I think seniors have a lot of things available. Petaluma is doing a good job there..
5/2112019
12:04
4:08
PM
5/21/2019
10:40
4:01
AM
62 There should be mention of practical, affordable, aligned means of transportation other than
private autos.
63 The objective is fine, but see the following notes on the work plan items.
64 Need to stay focused on promoting and supporting healthy lifestyles. Once you shift to restricting
5/20/2019
4:08
PM
5/20/2019
4:01
PM
5/20/2019 3:27 PM
5/20/2019 1;1 1' PM
alcohol and tobacco sales, you start to infringe into "Nanny State" policies.
65 Caring for the aging population 5/20/2019 12:48 PM
66 Would like to see fewer tobacco and smoke shop retailers. Curious about how the wellness 5/20/2019 10:40 AM
programs would be setup.
67 Evaluate becoming a Age friendly city 5/20/2019 9:N34 AM
.. .. ..... . ..... .. .......... .. ... ..... .
68 Being a senior myself, I like the City's vision and goals. 5/20/2019 8:32 AM
.. .... . . .. .....
69 This is an Asian community and it is difficult for elderly people on the sidewalks and use the roads. 5/19/2019 8:47 PM
Fix your roads and sidewalks
70 We could eliminate #3, 5 and, 8'. 5/19/2019 7:23 PM
.. ..... ... ..
71 Eliminate #3-7 5/19/2019 7:15 PM
72 Supporting our elderly 5/19/2019 6:58 PM
. ..... . ...
73 Accessible housing is important to me. More housing should be wheelchair accessible, including 5/1 9/201 9 4:58 PM
ramps, wider doorways, accessible bathrooms, etc,,
74 All of these objectives resonate with me. As a nearly 70 yo single woman who owns a home in 5/19/2019 2:14 PM
Petaluma for the past 17 yrs, I am having to consider selling my home for more affordable housing
if I ever want to retire. I don't want to become a renter again. So I'm having to consider moving
away from Petaluma and that's very sad. I would so love to stay, I know I'm not the only one facing
these challenges. Two of my neighbors are facing the same dilemmas. If there are 3 of us in one
block, I imagine there are many throughout the city.
75 Health and wellness is important. It is encouraging to see the City trying to improve its quality of 5/18/2019 6:40 PM
life.
.. .......... ... .. ........... ... ... .. . .... . .
76 Aside from an alcohol ordinance, this list seems to be too " pie in' the sky". 5/18/2019 5:20 PM
77 I like the inclusiveness of this objective and all the levels of community 5/18/2019 3:03 PM
78 Missing the connection between schools and the community. Concerned about lack of connection 5/18/2019 11:42 AM
to development (Safeway gas station and other things) and health of children. Include focus on
development of downtown waikability (river access, rail trellis, Petaluma Park at McNear, etc.)
79 Far more important things to focus on in the next two years than this. 5/18/2019 7:57 AM
80 n/a 5/18/2019 6-9,35 AM
..... ...... . .
81 I like limiting tobacco sales and investing in wellness activities but feel the resources would be 5/17/2019 8:12 PM
better used bolstering some of the other initiatives.
.. ... ........ ..... ... . ... ..
82 We need to prioritize our seniors who worked their entire lives and now financially struggle over' 5/17/2019 7:59 PM
the homeless who are to lazy and chemically dependent. Everything is about the homeless when
we should be worried about the senior population. ir
3/5
11
Input Summary 2 - Page 100 of 185
0
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
83 Everything but missing Increased Awareness of Environmental toxins'and hazards.. Ban Roundup 5/17/2019 7:08 PM
etc Stop using poisons on public property landscapes etc where people get exposed
84 Not sure how you accomplish this for all age groups in the community 5/17/2019 6:10 PM
85 Sounds veru lovely except for this niece: Develop fee structure for Alcohol -Related Nuisance 5/17/2019 5:08 PM
Ordinance for sustained management and enforcement of license alcohol establishments'. - Just
skip this one. Just another way for PPD to continue to harass citizens. Is this another cash cow
that will mainly hurt the poor? I think so!
.... ... . .. . . .... ... ... ....
86
.................. . .. . . . .. . .. . .. . .... .. ...... . .. . . ... . ... . .. ....... ... .. .. . . .......... ..... . .. ... ... . ... . ... ......... ............. ................. ......... ........................................ I ...... .. . .. . . ... . . .. . . . . . ..... . . .. ... .. ...... ... .. . . . .. . .... .... .. . . . . .....
Promotes well being of Petalumans
. . .. . .... . . .......... . ...... .. .
5/17/2019
.... . . . .. ........... . ...... .
4:19 PM
....... . .. . ...
87
... .....................
Stop spending all the money on the old people
5/17/2019
. . ....... .. . . .... . ..... ..
2:51 PM
88
......... .... .. . .. . . ...... ..... . .. . ................... . ............ ....... . . . .. . ..... ....... . .
I think active living will help us combat climate change-. Itis important to build it into our daily lives
5/17/2019
... ........... ... .......... ............ ........ ................................................
Perfect !!!
12:25
PM
and not have it be an exta. i.e. Now can we be active getting to work and back.?
.. ......................... ... . ....... .. .. ...... ... . ... ....... I . ... .. ......... I ........ . ...... I .. ..... ...... ........... ..... . ...... . .. ........... I ..... ....... . ... ......... I .............. ... . I .............................................. .................. ......................... ..................... ... .. . .......... . . ....... . .................................... ............. . ..... .............. .................... ............... .... .................................
Limiting tobacco sales will only result in people going to other cities for their tobacco,, Our city will
.... ...... . ...... ................. ............. : ........... .......... . .......................... ........ ........
5/17/2019 9:45 AM
lose a lot of tax revenue with this initiative. You cannot violate people's freedom to choose what to
89
............... . : .. . .................. ...... ......... .. : ....... ........ :: ................... ... .. .. . .... .......... ........... ............ I ......... .............
Enact a soda tax.
5/17/2019
12-4:12
PM
90
. . . .. . . .. ...... .. . .. ....... ...
Nothing
5/17/2019
senior health programs or baseball fields.
11:46
99
AM
91
1 don't understand what item 5 means, so I cann't give the plan my full support
.. ........ ... .
5/17/2019
10:40
Sounds good.....
AM
92
This seems to be a catch-all collection of diverseissues that may each have very specific needs.
5/17/2019
1
0:33
AM
Not sureit is actionable.
95
encouraging healthy habits will benefit the community overall. We still have agricultural
5/17/2019 9:56 AM
connections so promoting healthy foods, farmers markets. Limiting tobacco and alcohol outlets
seems healthy as well. Being on the edge of so-called wine country creates a need for delicate
balance as our recent increase of hotels seems to at least partially target that market.
... ..... ....... . . . ...... .. . . .... . .. ..
96
... ........... ... .......... ............ ........ ................................................
Perfect !!!
............ ...... ........................ ............ . ....................... ........ ........ . .. . ..... .........
5/17/2019 9:53 AM
. ..... 4-:V: ............ ... .....
97'
.. ......................... ... . ....... .. .. ...... ... . ... ....... I . ... .. ......... I ........ . ...... I .. ..... ...... ........... ..... . ...... . .. ........... I ..... ....... . ... ......... I .............. ... . I .............................................. .................. ......................... ..................... ... .. . .......... . . ....... . .................................... ............. . ..... .............. .................... ............... .... .................................
Limiting tobacco sales will only result in people going to other cities for their tobacco,, Our city will
.... ...... . ...... ................. ............. : ........... .......... . .......................... ........ ........
5/17/2019 9:45 AM
lose a lot of tax revenue with this initiative. You cannot violate people's freedom to choose what to
ingest or how to treat their own bodies (I'm anon-smoker, but believe others have the' right to
smoke if they so choose),.
98
That you actually mention the need for more support for recreational opportunities not just more
5/17/2019 9:23 AM
senior health programs or baseball fields.
99
Prepared Safe & Housed - How are do any of the proposed objectives meet this goal? We dont
5/17/2019 8:51 AM
need the city to provide wellness activities - if we were all housed we would be well. Keep it simple
100.
Sounds good.....
5/17/2019 8d:51 AM
101
............. ................. . . .... . .. ......... ... . .. ................. .... ............. ........... : .. . . .... ....... .. . ...... ..... .
Age -Friendly City initiative and support for seniors at all income levels living independently
.... .... .... ....
5/17/2019 810,49 AM
(especially middle-income seniors who will often lack resources to age in community as Baby
Boomers start reaching 75).
. .. .. .. . . . ..... ... .. ...
102
. .. . . . .. .... .. ..... .. ............ ................. . ..........
I like having the bars pay for the police response and supporting seniors, the rest are eye wash.
............ ...................... . . . .. . .. . ... ........... .. .. ..
5/17/2019 8:49 AM
. . ............................ . ..... ................ ........... . ... ...
103
I don't think you can do this until the basic infrastructure and economy of Petaluma is repaired.
5/17/2019 7:47 AM
104
. ...... ... ...... ... . . . . . .. .. ... .. ... .. ..... ......... . ... . ..... .......... .... . .... . . . .. ..... .. .. ... ..... . ...... . ............. I ....... .............. I ........ ..... ......................... ......... ....... ... . .. ...... ..... ......................... . ... .... .....
I'm not sure who designed this survey, butit is much too open ended and much too time
. ..... ................ ........ ........... .. ........ ..........
5/17/2019 7:43 AM
consuming - that should be a clue in terms of organizing communication and management.
Already, 1 want to sign off - we have busy lives, many of us work full-time - this is designed for
someone who has an hour or so to read and now give even more feedback - it is a terrible survey
.. . ... ............ ............... .. . ..... ........
design, frankly.
..... ...
.. .
.. ....
............ .
... .. . ..
.... . ....
. ..
................. ........... . ....... ....... .. ...... .. ................. ....... ....................... .. .................. ....... . .. ...... ......... .. . .... ..
105
Also a good goal, but something that's more a "feel good" goal instead of something harder.
5/17/2019 7: 15 AM
. ...... ..... .... ... .. . .... .. ....... .... .. ... . .. .. . . .. .. .. ... ... .. .. .. ... . ... .... . .. . ... ....... .... . .
106
Tepid. How about shooting for a Transition Town status?
5/16/2019 11 :33 PM
. .......... ... .....
107
. ..... . . ..... ... .. . .... ... .... ...... ....... I.V......"......: .. . ..... .. . ............. ..... .... .. ......
Great!
..................... ............................................................................................ ............ . .... .... ........ ............... . . .. .. .. ....... . . . .
5/16/2019 7,1%,54 PM
415 Input Summary 2 -Page 101 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
110 Do we have a senior community center? How do you get the information to public? Will you buy 5/76/2019 4:57 PM
local commercial time to broadcast for educate and inform public?
111 WE ALREADY HAVE A REC., DEPARTMENT 5/16/2019 4:52 PM
.1.12 na 5/16/2019 4:33 PM
.. .... . .. ..
113 'Encourage active living", promote well being..What does that mean? 5/16/2019 4:27 PM
............. ....... ... ..... . .... . .
114 Look good 5/16/2019 3:15 PM
115 What the H is °visitability"? Perhaps you might explain this to those of us who aren't part of your 5/16/2019 3:01 PM
clique.
116 Where is cannabis!! Allow dispensaries and listen to the voters 5/16/2019 2:59 PM
117 Again, all nice and fun to say provide healthy sustainable food for the whole community but who 5/16/2019 2:12 PM
pays for this? What one person might think is healthy and sustainable might not be what the other
person thinks. I would love to see the word "sustainable" struck from every single goal that cities
and counties are trying to attain. It is overused and has lost meaning.
118 Seems all the building on the city plansis counterintuitive to the goal of "healthy, safe living." What 5/16/2019 1:06 PM
on earth is a "visitability" ordinance?,
. ... . ......... .. . .. .. . . ... . ....... .
119 Like the Age Friendly City & support of seniors.. 5/16/2019 1:03 PM
. .. . .... ....... ...
120 I like theidea of it being an age friendly city. Wheelchair ramps are far from perfect as is for 5/16/2019 12:53 PM
example. mesh schedules with golden Gate transit and Sonoma county 5/16/2019 12:38 PM
........
ot
121 Missing that the city buses do n
routes. Lock the schedulers from all the agencies in a room and do not let them out with out
schedules that mesh!..Even as crude a goverment as Mexico can do it why continue to waste the
funds on unused seats that do not go the correct places at a time required??
122 I support this objective. 5/16/2019 12:21 PM
.. ........ .
123 Again, hard to disagree who doesn't want these things. What do they cost? How do we measure 5/16/2019 11: 31 AM
progress? Besides raising taxes, what's the City's role and efficacy to "make" something "age
friendly" (Can you give me an example ?)
................ . . ..... ... ............. .... .. .. .. . . . ...... . . . . . . . .................. .. . . . . ..
124 We cannot do everything, lets be sure to do well what can be done. 5/16/2019 11:26 AM
125 Fee structure for alcohol/drug nuisances -could deter heavy users from being in public or on the 5/16/2019 11:18 AM
road.
126 Age friendly city? What does this mean? 5/16/2019 10:54 AM
127 Help for seniors 5/16/2019 10:46 AM
128 we need more transparency 5/16/2019 10:43 AM
129 There is no discussion on how young parents, post -partum Mother's can be supported in the 5/16/2019 10:41 AM
community, when there have been at least 3 suicides in or around Petaluma for post-partumum
mom's if children who were under 1 years old. There needs to be more resources and discussion
about support post -partum Mother's and free indoor play spaces for moms to meet and support
one another.
130 Good ideas, look to Richmond and Oakland for ideas of what works and does not around alcohol 5/16/2019 10:39 AM
issues.
.................. ... ... . . ...
131 Again what is Housing doing in a safety issue? 5/16/2019 10:06 AM
132 How to pay for it in a rapidly increasing costs environment. 5/16/2019 10:03 AM
133 Looks great., 5/16/2019 10:02 AM
134 The emphasis on diversity and senior citizens healty involvement. 5/15/2019 3:05 PM
.. .........
5/5
Input Summary 2 - Page 102 of 185
n
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q1 0 What do you like a :)out these work plan items?. Or, what are we
It
missing?.
Answered: 101 Skipped: 174
# RESPONSES DATE
1 Incorporate the elements of the City adopted Food Action Plan. Ban all use and sale of glysophate 6/16/2019 3:21 PM
within city limits.,
............ .......... ... ................ . ................ .......... .... ".., ........... .. ...... ... .. .......... . . .... . . ... .. .. .. . ..... ... . .. ....... ..... ... .................. .. ... ... ................... ........ ....... .. ........ . ... ..... .........
2 Could identify people or groups that could help support this work. 6/1 4/201 9 6:54 PM
3 Tobacco should not be illegal, especially in light of recent cannabis legalization. Please 6/14/2019 1:41 PM
concentrate on infrastructure and public safety and leave the rest to private individuals and groups.
Quit wasting my tax money on "multi -cultural" and age- related schemes that not everyone in our
community supports. Those should be handled by the people who believe in them,, And forget
catering to the elderly now just because hippy baby- boomers have reached that demographic.,
Vni i ara thp- waalthiact Hp_mnnrqnhir. in Amp-rinq
1/5 Input Summary 2 - 'age 103 of 185
campaign that promotes police -community partnerships and neighborhood camaraderie to make
our neighborhoods safer, more caring places to live. Currently, Petaluma holds this event in the
Target parking lot'. That is not conducive to neighbor meeting neighbor. I moved here 2 years ago
from a city (Fremont) that has a very active'program. Neighborhoods get a city permit for a block
party; the neighborhood has a wonderful get together on Natl Night Out and the city police dept,.,
fire dept., and city council members pay a visit to those block parties. There are parties all over the
city that strengthen neighborhood bonds, relationships with the police and fire services, and city
staff. This kind of connectivity helps with disaster preparedness, crime prevention and keeps
eiders in their homes with the help of caring neighbors.
7
... ....... ...................... I ... ... . ....... .. . I . ...... :..., .... .. .. . ............ . ............................... ..... ........................................................................ ......................................... . ......... ............ ............... ........................ ............ ..... .... ........... .... .. ....................................................... ... . . ......... :.: .... ..... .... .....
1 am 73 and I think the cityis already "Age Friendly".
... ... .. . ........... .......... ........ ....... .. .. .. .................... ........................................................................ . . .........
6/11/2019 7:44 PM
8
.. . . ......... I ......... .............. .......... ................................................. ........... I .......... . .... ................... ... .... ....... .... ..... . . ... I . .. ..... . . . . .... . . . . . ......... .... . . .... ........ ... ...... .... . .. ........ . ..... ....... -, ......... .. .. .... .... .. . .. . ........... ..
Add 1 item relevant to Bike Petaluma: 1) Identify and promote how alternatives to driving individual
........ I..............,.,.:..."....:,.:......,..:,....I ......... ...... . ... .. ..
6/6/2019 9:46 PM
cars (biking, walking, transit) exemplify this objective.
9
.... ..
.. ..........
Downtown is scary at night, especially on the weekends. We need to acknowledge that and
..... ........ .......... ... ....
6/6/2019 6:07 PM
. ..........
change it!
.......... .........
...................................... ..............
.... .
... . ...... . .............. .....................
�,: ............
........ . ..... . .. ...............................
.............
10
We feel the fairgrounds can be a highly effective conduit for educating the public. The fairgrounds
6/6/2019 4:41 PM
main event draws over 60,000 annually along with interim events of over 300,000 annual
attendance. Where else in the city is there an opportunity to reach that many people, across all
demographics & backgrounds on one property? There irs always room for more education and
outreach. The fairgrounds represents an ideal venue to offer wellness education, healthy &
sustainable food education and promote the benefits of an active lifestyle. The fairgrounds would
also be a great location to move the west -side farmers market to. The property is close to all forms
of public transportation, accessible from both the east & west sides of town and -could have a
dedicated bathroom for hours of operation. This would alleviate parking strain around Walnut Park,
lessen theimpact on those adjacent businesses and allow for much needed market expansion.
The fairgrounds has over 200 volunteers, most of them are seniors. Their participation not only
supports our fairgrounds activities but many are there seeking socialization, exercise and (in the
case of exhibits) one of the few local formats to showcase their talents in arts & crafts,
photography, gardening, baking, woodworking, etc. The fairgrounds also functions as a location for
seniors groups to meet. Events held at the fairgrounds represent all segments of our community,
especially from a variety of ethnicities, All year long there are celebrations for quinceaneras,
baptisms, weddings, memorials, religious services and many other multi -cultural holiday events
that brings communities together and offers opportunities to celebrate their traditions and culture. -
Sonoma -Marin Fairgrounds' Board of Directors
. ...
11
.............. ........ . .. ........ ............ ......... ............................ .............. ................................................. ............................... ................... .... ... ... .. .. ... ..... .. . . . ... ... .. . .... .. . .. I .. ..... .... . ... ....................... .... ................... ... . ... .... .... .............................................. ...... ...
Assistance when/where needed for seniors and families with family members with disabilities.
. ....... . . . ..... .. . .. ... . ...... ....... ... . ....... ...... ..... .......................
... ..... .. ............ ................... . . ...... .......... . . ............................ ............................
6/6/2019 4:32 PM
. .. . . ... .........
1/5 Input Summary 2 - 'age 103 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
12 I am concerned about what is mentioned about alcohol and tobacco ordinances. That is a slippery 6/6/2019 1:40 PM
slope of having too much government control "big brother is watching" type of thing. Also, #5 item
-what does that even mean?
13 Take steps to enhance food recovery 6/6!2019 1:32 PM
14 Nothing 6/6!2019 12020 PM
5 I want there to be cross cultural community activities and for this goal to have more visibility in our 6/6/2019 12:09 PM
town.
16 You are missing the concept of community based fair ground preservation. where are you 6/6/2019 10:39 AM
developing these houses in section 5 listed out? This is an agricultural community not a track
housing plan.
.... . . .... ...
17 Don't understand how tobacco ordinance and creating an Age Friendly City are both work plan 6/5/2019 10:10 P M
items for the same objective.
18 What does "vistability" mean? 6/5/2019 6:23 PM
19 I like the concept if kept to numbers 1, 3, 7 & 8. It gets too 'big brother watching over me' when #'s 6/5/2019 2:29 PM
21 4-6 are added.
20 They are too timid'. 6/5/2019 1:642 PM
21 Bike Petaluma recognizes community bike safety is for all ages S to 80. 6/5/2019 10:38 AM
...........
22 See above....... 6/5/2019 8:19 AM
23 Only one that seems important and that impacts all economic strata is ensuring ACCESS to 6/4/2019 8:22 PM
healthy food.
24 What's missing is more resident education about air quality, so residents and visitors alike through 6/3/2019 11:02 PM
signage reminders don't idle their vehicles, especially at school pick-ups and drop-offs. We still
have too many "Spare the Air" Days, and 2.5 particle emission days of "yellow" air quality (not
green good air quality), but no one "sees" the pollution, since it's better than it used to be. Yet it is
still affecting our health. A no idling ordinance would be very
... .......
25 I would love to see something specific about working with our teenage population as well as with 6/3/2019 8:14 PM
the school districts in partnership.
26 Money 6/3/2019 6:L50 PM
27 need to get input from community 6/3/2019 4:51 PM
28 Visitability- more costs for first time buyers? Do you have the expertise to draft INEXPENSIVE 6/3/2019 10:48 AM
rules?
..... .. ... .
29 Focus on creating a healthy city and investing in our people. Might be expensive now but will help 6/3/2019 6:11 AM
in the long run!
30 Evaluate what it means to be a 'pet friendly city'. Work with animal services provider on public 6/2/2019 9:23 AMi
education to reach that goal. 8. connect seniors with volunteer opportunites or with organizations
that aggregate volunteer opportunities
. . ............ ......
31 Senior goals -- how about more senior housing, which is a tangeable thing. 6/1/2019 10:18 AM
32 creating a wellness program 5/31/2019 640144 PM
33 Visitability ordinance?? I have no clue what that means unless it's for additional parking and I 5/31/2019 10:43 AM
certainly support that.
...... ..... .. . .
34 Item 3 resonates the most. 5/31/2019 12:06 AM
35 nothing 5/30/2019 5:35 PM
36 missing: a city that provides a physical environment for citizens to be active and well. 5/30/2019 5:21 PM
. . ... .... ... .... . . ....
37 I think it would be ideal to look at gaps in areas for walking paths, sidewalks. For example, 5/30/2019 9:30 AM
Lakeville between Frates and 101 has many new shops but hardly any way to get to them without
weaving in and out of businesses. Make areas with retail accessible throughout the city.
...... .... ........... .. ............ . ... ......... ...... ....... .. . .. .... .. ......... ....... . ................ ... .. ... .. . .. . .. .... ... .. .. ... ... . ... . ........ .. .......... ..... . ... . ... . ....... ............ ..
38 This plan is about west Petaluma. The plan is an elitist plan like our council. 5/30/2019 9;27 AM
2/5 Input Summary 2 - 'age 104 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
39 1 find the
work plan items to be
inappropriate (1
and 5) or vague (6,7,
8). 1 think 2
and 4 sound like 5/29/2019 4:10 PM
you have
revenue in mind, and
they don't seem
appropriate. I would
recommend
dropping this
For example, as someone severely disabled by exposure to cig smoke, I support initiatives to
reduce secondhand smoke in public places. But I can't tell. if what you're proposing does that or
not.
. .. ..., .., .. : . ..,. . . - : . ..... - - - :,.:: .... :..,. ... I... .. . . . .. . . .. . .. . . . . . ... . . .. .. . . . . . . ... . . . . .. .. . . .. ... . .. . . . . .... .. ... . ... ..., ............ .. ............. .................... .... ..... . ................. -, ..... .... . : ....... :.... ...: ..... ......... : . ..:: ............ ::.:.:: .... : ... .. .. ... I ............ .. ... . .... ... . . .. . ........ .. . ... . . . . . ... ..... ..... ............ .. . ....... .. .... .. .... . . . ........... ... ...... .. ... . . . .. ... ... .. . ...... ......... .......... ............... . ............ .................. - . . ...... .... .. .... .. ....... . .... ... ....................................... .... 11 ...... .. . . . . .: ..... . .. ... . .. :... . .. . . . . . . .. ... . . .. . ... . .. . - . . . . . . . ... . . . .. ... . . .. ... .. ... . . . ............. .. .
53 If walking and/or biking was part of Petaluma infrastructure/culture, this would go a long way to 5/21/2019 8:45 AM
promote health,.
............. ... ............... ..... ......... ................................... ...... .... .... ..... . ....................... .... ............. ..... . . . ......................... ................... .......................... .. . ............. ....................... ...... ............. ..................... ................ .. ............. ........................ ........................................ ....................................... ..... ................... .... .. . ... ......... . ... ... . . . .. .. ... ... . ...... . . .. . ....... . . ...... . .. .. ..... . ... .. ... :..." .. . ..... .... .. ..... . ...... ..... .......... ............... . ................................. .............. ................ ........
54 Seems good. 5/20/2019 4:01 PM
.. .... . .... .. . ..... I ........ ........ .... :1 ............ ... . .. . . ............... ..... ...................... ....................... ........... .. . .. ... ... ... .. ... . . ....... ...... ...... . . . . . .. .. .. .. ... . ... ... . . .. ... .. .... . . .. .... .. .... ... .. ....... .. . ........ .... ..... ............. ........ . . ...... . ................... .............. ........ ....... ......................... ..................... ........ ........ : .... .... ......... . . ............. . . . .......... . . . . ... .. . .. . .....
55 1 generally support the "visitability" idea, but caution about the unintended consequences,, On one 5/20/2019 3:27 PM
hand, providing an elevator will increase the cost of living in two -or three-story buildings. On the
other hand, once the elevator cost has been incurred, developers will likely be more willing to go to
four or five stories, perhaps mitigating the cost increases. Engagement with the construction
community to understand the impacts of this proposal should be undertaken. And while I support
engaging seniors, I note that we need more civic engagement from many demographics. I prefer
an 8 to 80 strategy over asenior-focused strategy.,
....... .................. ... : .......... ........ ...... ...... ..... ... ........ . . .... . ........................ ... .... . ..... .... .. .. .. ............ .. ...... .:: ...... ... ....... .. .. -.1 .... .. ... . . .. ... ...... . .......
56 The best way to encourage healthy aging in place is to offer good public transit options, 5/20/2019 9:49 AM
.......... .... ........ ........... ........... ..... . . . .... ............... .............................................. -- ...... . ... .............. ... ........ . ........ . .............................. .......... ... .......... ................ : ........ ...... . ........ .... ......
57 If the community is safe for walking &bicycling it will go a long way toward a healthy community. 5/20/2019 9:34 AM
. . . . . . . . . . .. . .... . . . .... ..... ......... ....... ..... .. ............................................ .................. . .. I ...........
...... . . .. ... ........ .... ..... ................................... ....... .... ... ............... ....... ........ ................. .. .. .................... .............. .. ............................ .......... . ... .... . ...................... .... ...... ......... . ....... ............ ................... ............. ...................................... ............ .. ........ .....
58 Housing! Affordable housing for all ages, actually. 5/20/2019 8:32 AM
59 OK 5/19/2019....7:23 PM
.. ... . .......... .........
. . ... . ...... ...................... ...... ....................
60 love the focus on affordability and livability. The population is aging and more support needs to be 5/19/2019 2:14 PM
put in place.
.. ... ..... ... .. .. . .......... . . . ... .. ......
...........
61 Too heavy on seniors and accessibility. The visitability idea is in conflict with things like promoting 5/19/2019 1:53 PM
ADUs, since (if I understand it correctly) this idea will add cost and complexity to new dwellings
and it is cost and complexity for unknown potential users of the dwelling. Seems like a big ask for
someone who does not have any disabled visitors. Not clear what real value this brings to the
overall community. This is usually an issue that is addressed as if arises by those involved. Not
something we need a city rule for.
.... . ..... ..... . ....... ............. .......... ......... .... ... ... .... . ............ ... ... : ........ e .. .... ...... �.: .... ... .. .. ..... .. . ... . . .. .. ... .. . .. . . ....... .. ... ........ . ......... .......... . . .......... . .. ........... ................... ...... ..... .... . . .... .........................
62 One is the biggest determinants of health is education. We need more collaboration between the 5/18/2019 6:40 P
M
city and the schools,
63 Alcohol ordinance 5/18/2019 5:20 PM
. .... . ......
64 For too long, Petaluma has focused exclusively on kids...ball fields, recreation programs. But 5/18/2019 3:03 PM
community is more than sports and wellness is more than physically fit.
. . ................ ... . . ........... .. I ............ .................. : ............... .. ................ ...... ..... :.:: .................. .. . ........ ..... ............................... I ..... . .............
3 / 5 nut Summary 2 -Page 105 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
65 Have you studied the Petaluma General/Specific Plan (?) from years ago? 5/18/2019 11:42 AM
66 Working with Petaluma Health Center (in addition to Healthcare District) is essential. They offer 5/18/2019 9*418 AM
classes that are open to the public,,
67 Missing: maintain current multi -use pathways (ie: Lynch creek trail) and develop more 5/18/2019 6:35 AM
pedestrian/biking friendly access to and from one side of town to the other.
. .... . . ... . ........
68 Redundant 5/17/2019 7:08 PM
69 We don't need more "enforcement' - how about focus on better public transit (buses that run more 5/17/2019 5:08 PM
frequently! what a concept!), fixing the roads that are dangerously full of potholes, and building the
Petaluma North SMART station
70 We need a smoke free Petaluma..
71 Nothing at all
5/1 7/201 9 4:19 PM
5/17/2019 2:51 PM
72 Healthy sustainable food! Incentives for businesses that use local vendors/farms so that pricing 5/17/2019 12:25 PM
can come down and more people can access this food.,
73 Enact a soda tax.. 5/17/2019 12:12 PM
74 #3 not city responsibility 5/17/2019 11:46 AM
75 1 like promoting multi -cultural and multi -generational recreation and wellness, but think the city 5/17/2019 10:33 AM
may not be the best to handle it. The city should consider funding an organization like the YMCA
or JCYC in San Francisco to consider facilities and programs.
76 No Comment Needed 5/17/2019 10:27 AM
77 some way to teach children the benefits of local and healthy food is needed, to get them involved. 5/17/2019 9:56 AM
78 _ It is inclusive 5/17/2019 9:53 AM
79 Allow cannabis dispensaries., Think of the millions of dollars the city can receive from those taxes! 5/17/2019 9:45 AM
80 Missing is an explanation of what an Age Friendly city is - I'm guessing that means friendly to all 5/17/2019 9:43 AM
ages? I like that idea.
81 I'd like to see some emphasis on team sports for adults. With PVAC closing, the tennis community 5/17/2019 9:23 AM
was decimated and everyone has gone to other towns to play. I'd like to see the Council make a
proactive effort to help us rebuilt that community. Buy or rent PVAC and those 7 courts and ask
PTA to be responsible for running it? Cheaper than putting in new tennis courts somewhere else!
Build tennis courts at Lucchessi (at least 4) plus pickleball courts plus raquetball and wallyball
facilities! We lost all that with PVAC's closure.
82 They are so off base and unrelated itis almost not worth commenting. Who drafted these plans? It 5/17/2019 8:51 AM
sounds more and more Orwellian as I read on. Back off the over reaching control. If we were all
housed we would be more safe. If we all had fair paying jobs we would be more safe. It's not
rocket science.
83 Not sure what " visibility ordinance" entails but if it's an unannounced drop in on home construction 5/17/2019 8:51 AM
by a city/county official then I'm not for it. We have scheduled inspections for a reason., Love the
tobacco idea. Squeeze them out. I'd love to see officers citing juveniles with those jute sticks too..Do the middle and high schools still get campus drug dog walk throughs? I think with this opioid
crisis that it's valuable,.
............ ....
84 Who will be responsibile for Age -Friendly City implementation? Perhaps a collaboration of seniors 5/17/2019 8:49 AM
orgs: Senior Center, PEP Housing, Rebuilding Together, the Village Network of Petaluma, and
Petaluma People Services Center?
85 see above 5/16/2019 11:33 PM
. ... . .......
86 #7 and #8 imporyant 5/16/2019 6:38 PM
87 _ n/a 5/16/2019 4:33 PM
..........
SS Please be as specific as possible 5/1 6/201 9 4:27 PM
89 Good.. _ 5/16/2019 3:15 PM
90 What about the governor's plans? More early childhood programs please 5/16/2019 2:59 PM
4/5 Input Summary 2 - Page 106 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
91 An " age friendly" city that expects everyone to take public transit, walk, or ride a bike in very hot 5/16/2019 1:06 PM
weather and in rainy weather??? Would take the train ' more often, but too expensive and little
parking.
source for other wellness projects.
...... .
............ ...
. .
98 5.1:Considerm adopting a "visitability" ordinance to provide accessibility in new single-family home 5!16!2019 10: 37 AM
construction. No ordinance required for visit. Not sure what it means.
r
V
LJ
5/5 Input Summary 2 - Page 107 of 185
ZIP
c
a
io% roll%
No 5
Input bul 11111 ry U 1 UO %.OIF
li
19
2,0
3:16
Ilk
Pit I
A
0� J .,`i.
T: H T P
Ilk
iff IL
P Ell
&MI.
IM X
HIM 1 ra M
lC '41, 4
7N, 771 410f Wide
-we
Work,v%la,n Iterns'
F I
ien:d y olw%eraL
ic-e an 'Promote business-fril" ciby ih
U rle aL
P
riiiiii'% # 61* tainable, * i ----lop,mentl
rriorruze an incentivize sus, inifffl-deve
permit consultations,
City
Establish minimum wage ordinance.
Provide
00 licensing and permitting guidelines in Spanish.
It' 0 is
and
Work with regional workforceagenciesattractto talent for local businesses.
Economic Development Strategy.
-5business
re-zoning as a catalyst to new opportunities,.
it""mi 3 3 P- W o r: Plan Items -
1i
15!
A
lki �,�61
Support tourist -oriented events with police and publilc work,
Facilitate the developmentof an additional downtown e
an a
Identitv Dotentia Da r r MR alternatives for downtio:wn,.
Support and leverage promotional efforts of the Petaluma Tou
Maximize use of current parks and recreation infrastructure fo
events that attract visitors to Petaluma,,
rism Improvement Dlistrict,.
recreational
r it h e h o stii n g o
'Fit
l`=1 74
;. I i , i i r I
PO
v HA
J
4 a
t J
"I ilk
.30 Am Workplan Items.
1. Identify short and long-term funding solutions for dredging of the Turning Basin and federal channel.,
dredge the City Marina.
2. Support Federal dredging efforts of the river channel by maintaining a viable dredge disposal
site at Shollenberger.
3. Establish bicycle and walling paths and other river access amenities along the Petaluma River.
Ink -*w. Summary z' 'Ha"e iu�j of lbb
P: Y
Aesonate with
me
Somewhat
a
resonate witoo.
Needs to be
revioed
z Mort N 0 N I rrw^z W''O
Total Respondents. 158
9
u
I
S111<i I pped: 117
1/1
*7' � III W
BMW
PMof
ImpeNut 6ummary 2. F)ayt 11 i 1 bib
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q 28 W�at do you like about this goal? Or, what are we missing?
Answered: 96 Skipped: 179
RESPONSES
DATE
1 I like attracting talent,.,. minimum wage and Spanish translaton for public meetings.
..... ............... . .. .............. ....................... ............. . . .............. .. ......... ....... .
6/14/2019
7:-03
PM
2 It addresses the need for a minimum wage ordinance and written materials in Spanish
6/14/2019
6:23
PM
... ....... ...... ................... ...... ..... ...... ............. ..... ... ......
3 Business is good and I like that you propose supporting et. The less you get in the way the better.
6/14/2019
2:07
...... .
PM
. . . ......... .. . .... .. .. ..... .. ..... . . .... . .
4 There is enough industry in Petaluma. We need less people. The city already had plenty of money
6/13/2019
6: 13
... . .... ...... .. .....
P M
coming in. We don't need more business, especially corporate stores.
"Business Friendly".
.. .. . . .. ............ . . ...... . .... .... . .. .. . . .. .... . ... . . . ... .... .. . . . .... .. . ......... .. . . .. . ........... ... .. ... . ..... ........ .. 11.1 ............ ... ................ . ...... .... ....... .... ............. ...... . ................ . . .... ... . .
7 It is not local governments job to establish a minimum wage - the state has set that., 6/9/2019 8:26 AM
........... ...........
....................
8 support for agriculture and business outside of city limits missing; what is produced in the 6/6/2019 8:21 PM
surrounding area supports the small business within the city!
.. .............
9
.... .... . . . ......... .. .. ............. ............ I ..... . ........... ................ . .... ...... ....... .. .... ... .. ... . .. ..
How does a minimum wage ordinance attract business?
.........................
6/6/2019 6:12
.............................
PM
10
Seems like something is being missed...Like the Petaluma River accessability.
6/6/2019 4:55
PM
11
.... . ..... ... ... . ........ . ... ...... 1: ......... . .... .. . ..........
The goal is great in theory. If it is going to be used as a way to expand Petaluma or attract more
6/6/2019 1:59
....................................... ..................
PM
people living here, then I am not for it.
12
Encouradna businesses here should be done with a filter towards always supoortinp
6/6/2019 1:05
PM
environmental sustainability. No more auto parts stores, please! v
. . ........................ . .... . ............... . .......... . ............... ...... .......... ... ................ ...................... I . .... ...... ... ....... ... ...... ............. ....... .... .............. ......... . ...... .... I ...... ............. I ........ ............... I ........ I .......... . ..... .............................................................................. .. ....... ........... ........ ........ ...................... . . ..... ........... .... ....... ...... ... .. ............... . ..... . ... ....... ........... .. ........... ................... . ................... ........... . ........... ........... ................ ... . ....... .. ............. ................... .................... . ... .. .. ......... .............................. ............... ........ . . ....... ............ . .... .. ...... .......
13 Great 6/6/2019 129,26 PM
16 Great goals. If we want a healthy business environment, we need to really work hard to promote 6/5/2019 7:11 PM
locally owned businesses over large corporations that just see our community as a small piece of
the picture for their national and multinational business ventures. Let the huge corps fend for
themselves. They'll do just fine. It's the little guys that need the support., Olivers, not Safeway.'
Petaluma Market, not Whole Foods. Acre Coffee, not Starbucks. What a Chicken, not KFC.
Original Buffalo Wings, not BW3. You get the idea...
....... ........ .. .... ...... ... .. ..
17 It's what we need. 6/5/2019 5:07 PM
18 Petaluma needs to identify itself as a hip, welcoming, thriving, recreation -oriented, forward- 6/5/2019 1:49 PM
thinking, climate- resilient city. This identity will attract the kind of businesses, development, and
tourism that we want to attract. We currently lack that identity.
... ................... . .................... ................. . ....... ................. .. ............... . . ............. ..... ... . ............. . .......... .. ................ . ... ....... ... ........................ ... . .. . . .. . . . ...... ..... .. ...... ..... . . .... ............... ................... ............. .......... .... .. .. . .. ... .
19 I think what's missing is requiring "union" work agreements on all new construction. Unions pay 6/4/2019 12:00 AM
living wages. I heard recently Sonoma County is training union apprentices, but they're going
elsewhere for jobs because of the lack of employer union work agreements.
............................................ ............................... ... ...... ....................... ...... ...................... ........................ ........ .. .............. . .. ........ ........... .................. ....................... ..................................................... .. .......... ........................... .......................... ........................................................................................ .......... ......... . .... ........................ ......... ....... ... ...................... . ........ .......................... . ...... ............... . . .............................. . ........
20 The city needs to take control of development. Developers are in control. The theatre district 6/3/2019 7:10 PM
should have been five stories,, Petaluma continues to look at today instead of 20 years out. Four
story building around a rail station is not sustainable.
.. .. . . ... . . . .. . ... . . ... .. . .... ........ ........ . .... ..... ... ......... .............. . .................................. ............. .. .... .............. ... .... .... ... ..........................
21 getting new businesses 6/3/2019 4:51 PM
.......... ......................................... ......... .. ....... . ........................... .. . . ......................... I ............................. ........ .... . . ........................ ....................................................... ................ ....................................................... . . .... .................................................................. ............................. ........
22 Minimum wage rise is foolish and counterproductive. NONE OF YOUR GODDAM BUSINESS., 6/3/2099 11:38 AM
THIS IS ALREADY AN ANTI -BUSINESS TOWN- YOU BANKRUPTED THE FIRST SILK MILL
DEVELOPERS AND THE SAFEWAY NIMBY FARCE AND MANY OTHERS ARE RIDICULOUS.
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
23 living wage is a joke for petaluma..sufficient.,Even a minimum wage of 15-20 dollars an hour isn't 6/3/2019 6:17 AM
There is an economic development person already at the city this should already have been done.
24 We've lived here a long time, and always have to commute for work. We need to find a way to 6/2/2019 1;38 PM
attract more business that pays good wages.
.... ... . ...
25 What do you mean by airport rezoning? Get businesses in the already vacant places in malls. 6/1/2019 10:36 AM
.. . . .... ...... .....
26 nothing to add at this time 5/31/2019 61:53 PM
. .. ........ .. ......
27 We definitely need to focus on infill over new development., Lots of vacant spaces. Also need a 5/31/2019 12:22 AM
focus on lobs for teens. to help them become more independent. Provide incentives to businesses
28
29
that hire local teens, particularly for summer jobs,.
good idea
5/30/2019 5:48 PM
Business are critical to the city and establishing a minimum wage does not lend to the appeal. 5/30/2019 4:44 PM
There are plenty of places new business can land, don't make one more reason for them to
choose another city..
30 You're scaring me with some of these proposals -would need to know more, 1 am not for fast 5/29/2019 9:30 PM
tracking permits and what do mean about the airport rezoning, not sure that's even needed.
31 The goal is good...... 5/29/2019 4:27 PM
32 Fill empty storefronts downtown, provideincentives to landlords to keep business there., 5/29/2019 11:36 AM
33 Items 3 6 and 7 are important 5/29/2019 9;06 AM
34 Focus on retaining 5/29/2019 7:24 AM
35 I like focusing on small business needs 5/28/2019 7:38 PM
36 Good goal, but ambitious 5/28/2019 7q-33 PM
37 Mostis good. Not sure about needing Spanish language as this is a disservice to people who need 5/28/2019 5:20 PM
to learn English to better -their economic positionsin this country.
. . .........
38 Min wage ordinance was "ordered" by council 7 weeks ago, yet we are stili waiting for draft?! ?f 5/28/2019 1:25 PM
Please, let's not say YES to stuff, and then hope it dies in staff work setting!,
..... .... . . .
39 Increasinbusiness and sales tax better than increased property tax. 5/28/2019 1:01 PM
40 We need to prioritize locally owned businesses,, Local business revenues put back more money 5/28/2019 12:36 PM
into the community.than non -local businesses. It's not just about sales tax and the like.. Local
businesses hire local people (not just on-site staff). Local businesses spend their profits locally.,
. ..........
41 What attracts business is city infrastructure that keeps workers out of cars. This plan should 5/28/2019 10:49 AM
encourage smart commuting, bicycle paths, and amenities for workers "cafes, health center, etc"
42 I like everything about this goal! 5/28/2019 9:33 AM
43 We need to keep focusing on infill developments and not sprawl. We need to go higher and more 5/27/2019 12:45 PM
dense with our development. We need a $15 minimum wage and work with our neighboring
communities to do the same.
44 This is essential for our community 5/26/2019 2:09 PM
45 Business opportunities for prospective first time business owners., Rents that are affordable. 5/25/2019 1 0:00 AM
46 Increase the minimum wage to a living wage. 5/23/2019 3:05 PMi
47 The city should not create a City Minimum Wage ordinance. Ths will drive businesses out and 5/23/2019 9-914 AM
raise the prices of everything in the city. Allow the free market to work. Minimum wage jobs are
meant to be jobs people start off on and not meant to be a long term job. Instead create job
training and education programs people can use to enhance their professional lives that lead to
higher paying jobs. Other incentives can also be created so businesses are encouraged to pay
higher wages, but forcing them to pay it will cause small businesses to fail. It is already almost
impossible to start a small business in Petaluma. This would make it impossible for new
businesses to start and only large corporations will be able to afford the start up cost and support
the 1st 3 years of running cost's before most businesses make a profit.
48 sounds good 5/23/2019 7:59 AM
49 Costco? 5/22/2019 3:49 PM
2/4 Input Summary 2 - Page 112 of 185
f
CITY COUNCIL DR -AFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
50 Fees for new residential buildings or remodeling are too high. 5/21/2019 11:28 AM
57 All good 5/19/2Q19 7:34 PM
59 Dredge the river so that rich out of town tourists can spend their money here! 5/18/2019 5:26 PM
wage.
62 Need to grant access/permits to marijuana dispensary. 5/18/2019 10:02 AM
............... I ......... ....... .... ................ ......... ...... . ........ . ......... .. .. ...... ..
63 simplifying the permit process will allow businesses to thrive in a time when increased healthcare 5/17/2019 8-1,12 PM
costs, a possible minimum wage increase, wage creep, increased sunk costs are already
challenging profits.
64
A strong business Community can be a very effective economic driver for the city.
5/17/2019 7:50 PM
................ 11 ............. ............ ........................
65
.. .... .. ........ ..... ..... ... ........ ....... ......... ..................... ....
Looks right
5/17/2019 7:23 PM
66
...... . .... I ..... . .. .. . ... . . .. . .. .... .. ......... . ......... . ... .. .... . .. .. .. .. .......... . .. ............... ..... .. .
goal is ok
5/17/2019 5:31 PM
67
. ..... ............ ..... ........................... ....... .... ..... ......... . ................. ...... . ...................... ........... ......... . . ..... . .. ............. ............... ..................... ....... ........
We need our work and workforce in our town,,
.............................. ....... ................ ...... ............................ ........... .....
5/17/2019 4:58 PM
68
.. ... ................................. .......... . .... .. I ................. .. .. .. ............. ..... ........... I ........................ ........................... ................. ..... ............... . . . .......
Yes, attract sustainable businesses that will provide good jobs and. contribute to the community.
........ .. .. .. . .... .... . . . ... .. ... . .. .. ........ .. ... . . . ............................ ......
5/17/2019 4:30 PM
Businesses that produce useful products or services. Small niche businesses create a diverse and
interesting mix and larger companies provide the scale and volume of jobs that are necessary to
move the needle and provide the tax base for the future.
69
Identify the one most ubiquitous reason businesses close and turn over, which is probably
......... ...... . . ....
5/17/2019 12:33 PM
commercial rent hikes., Enact commercial rent control and lower commercial property taxes:,
70
.. ... .. .... . .. . ..... ..... ............... . ...... .. .
Sounds very positive. Who or how will this be done
. . . . . .. . .. ... . ..... .... .... . .... ..... ..... .... ......... ...... . ....... ...
5/17/2019 10:43 AM
71
Yay.1-1.
... ... ... . . ... ...... . .. . . .... ..... .... . ..... . .... . .. . .. . ... .. ... .. ... .. .... . ...... . . ... ... . ... .. .. ..
5/17/2019 10:05 AM
72
........... .. . ... ........... . .. ... . ..... . .... ... ........ ..... . ..
Why just Spanish? Why not add German, French, Russian, Cantonese, Japanese, etc.??. Oh,
5/17/2019 10:01 AM
right, because they usually learn English when they move to this country and don't expect special
accommodations. How. silly of me to forget!
73
..... .... . ... .... . ............ ... I .... ....... ........... .. .... ..... . .. .. ...... . ........ .................................... .... . . . .......... ................ ... ....... ..
#4. Yes #5. Yes #6. Not regional - developed city wide work force agency - SBA! #7. Yes #8 Yes -
5/17/2019 9:13 AM
Autocross with professional auto associations. Porsche club of America Redwood Region is
looking for new autocross cite. They are a reliable source of funding.
..... .... ... . .. ..
74
. . . . . ..... .... .. . .. ...... ... ..... .
....... ..
Economics is top priority for the sake of being able to afford all other goals.
5/17/2019 9:11 AM
....... .... .. . .................
75
.............. ................... ............... ............... .................. . . . . ...... ... ......... . . .................................. ............... ........ : ........... . ..... .......... ....... . .............. .......
NOPE! the free market controls this not the city. Do the rest ofyour business and it will come.
... .. ..... .
5/17/20199:04 AM
Don't waste time and resources. Providing services in any other language than English is
.................................... . .............
ridiculous and pandering.
. . .................... .... . ... ...................................... .... ....
76
In terms of economic development, the mapping of districts and neighborhoods should follow the
5/17/2019 7:59 AM
General Plan. The West Hills of Paula Lane and Kelly Creek west of Windsor Lane should be
visible in economic development promotional mapping - and not arbitrarily changed. This area
represents an important wildlife corridor and also natural area where people also live - and will
attract new residents. It is not the Oakfield -Brewster District..
3/4
Input Summary 2 - Page 113 of 185
0
CI1'Y COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-'2021 Attachment 3
77 This is good! 5/1-1/2U19 7:24 AM
78 Establish City minimum wage ordinance. ---this should not be a priority. This will damage our 5/16/2019 7:41 PM
small businesses community and take opportunities away from low skilled workers. This is a social
HOUSING ON EVERY EMPTY LOT INSIDE CITY LIMITS.
83 No minimum wage
84 Sounds like a lot to do. Is this plan feasible, giving the budget of Petaluma? 5/16/2019 2:23 PM
......... ...... .. . . ..... .
85 Stop with this: "Prioritize and incentivize sustainable infill development." This will lead to rezoning 5/16/2019 2:22 PM
S
n residential neighborhoods to add high density housing. Again, ditch that word "sustainable" as it
86
doesn't mean anything anymore and is so overused in all planning documents and public
meetings.
Too much infill development. Starting to look like San Jose. Do we really want to look like Europe
after WWII with all the massive high-density concrete apartment buildings and no parks, parking,
etc,.?
5/16/2019 1:27 PM
perform any outreach to aviation businesses. Yet the airport adds approximately $30M to the
community.
89 Measurable goals, milestones and timeframes. 5/16/2019 11:37 AM
90 Yes, we need to have these items in Spanish also, and also need to support minority businesses 5/76/2019 11:16 AM
for women and people of color to start their own businesses.
91 Everything. Critical to have local employers so we don't become more of a commuter town,, 5/16/2019 10:43 AM
. . . ...... .... ..... ...... ....... ... .
. . ...... ... .
92 Create and promote business -friendly city operations such as zoning, permitting, and licensing. 5/16/2019 10:21 AM
Revise in its entirety. Rewrite to'-., The City will encourage entrepreneurship, and interfere with its
development only to the extent it must provide more city funds than the cost of services it
consumes.
. ..... .. .. ..... . ......... ...
93 Same thing. Nice words but. , , 5/16/2019 10:9,09 AM
94 Hoping the city takes into consideration that the state wide moratorium is ending May 31st and rent 5/16/2019 10:08 AM
cap of 10% will end. Therefore, we need to move quickly on raising the wage. Or just have
Petaluma extend the moratorium just like Santa Rosa. 4 1
. ..........
95 The fire prevention bureau needs to work better with the community. Private businesses are doing 5/16/2019 8:15 AM
g their best to make it. They need to work more with these private businesses
96 Yes community prosperityls important. 5/15/201,9.3:33 PM
4/4
Input Summary 2 - Page 114 of 185
11
M
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
objective? Or, Q29 What do you like this are we
RESPONSES
Answered,.- 54
Skipped: 221
DATE
1 It considers the welfare of the diverse workers in our city 6/14/2019 6q423 PM
.... .... . . ....
2 1 like everything apart from the "living wage" part. That is a fallacy.. Minimum wages have been 6/14/2019 2:07 PM
proven to not work and cause more harm than help.
... ..... . .... . ......... . .... .... . .... ..... .. . ..... I ......................... . .... . .. . .......... ... ...... ... . . . . .... . . .... . . .......... . ... .... . . : .. .... . ... .. . ...... ........ ... . .
:I
3 Get out of here with "living wage". People need to find other work or better ways of spending their 6/13/2019 6:13 PM
money.
........ ... .... .. . . . ... .. . . . . . . . . . .. . . .
4
. . ... .. ... . ... . . .. ... .. . . ..,: ....... : ...................... ...... ....................... ... .. .. .... ..... .......................... : ..:.- -: .... :.. ..: . .... .. . .. . . . . . ... . . . . . . , ". :-" .-: , . ... -'. :" - . .... .. . .......... :... ..:.. .. .. . . . .., . - . - . .. . . ... . . . .. . '... . . . . ... . . . . ...: ...... ...................... : .... . .. ........... : ............ ..... ...... . . . . .. . ................ ................... ..........
seems to assume "businesses" are good; are all businesses good?
... .... . , . . ... . . . . .. - . .,. ... - . - , ..,. ... . .. . . . . . . . ..
6/13/2019
. .. . . .. . .. ... . .... . ... . . ... . .... . . . . . .. .. ..- . .:... . . .... . . ... . - ... ..,
3:02 PM
5
............. . ... .. ...... ........... :...: .... ....... .. .. .. ... . . . ... ..... . . . ..... ... . . ..... . ....
See Above
. . .... ... . .... .... ... ... ................................. ....... ........................... .............. ...... ........... ......... ......... ... .. ........ .. ..... ... .................. ..... : ... ..... .. . ........ ............ ......
6/11/2019
. . . .......... . .. . . . ..... :-: ............................. ........ ................. . :-: . ... .
16
...............................
7:59 PM
. ... . ... .....
6
Every employer has a different structure. Some
... . .. . ... .. . ......... . .... . . .. .... .. .
pay all of the health benefits -others pay none,
6/9/2019
........................... .. ............. .......... ...................
6/3/2019 4:51 PM
81,26
AM
....... ... . ...... ... ............... ..... .... .. . ...... .. . ..
When you demand a minimum nimum wage with short
.............. ........... ..................... .. ............. ................. . ............... .......... . ... ..... ....................... ... ......... ............. .. . ........ ....................... ........................ ............. ................. ........................... .............. ............... ............... - .......... ...
notice it is difficult for businesses to adhere
................... .............. ...... .................. . .. ........... ...... . . . ........................... .... ................... ............. ......... ........................... .... ...... ................. ...... .
come here,
.... ..... ..... ... . .. . .. ....... ... ....... . . .... ... ... . ... ... ................. ......... ...
19
7
..................... ......... ... .... ............... ...........
raising wages only raises the cost of goods and
............. .. ................. I .. ..... . . ... ..... . ... ... . . ..... .......................... ................................. ............ ...... .......... .... ............ ..... .................................... .......... I ......... .. ...................... ........................ ................ ............... .. ..... ......... ......... ....... ... . . ..
doing business
.......................................... . .... ......... .. . .. ...... ... . . .. ...... . .... . . ... .... ........ . ..... .. ................. . ...................... .... I .. ........... ................................ ........ .... .. ...... . . ...... ..
6/6/2019
. ..... . .....
Collaborate with
8:21
....... ......... ...................................
PM
........ ............... ..... .... ................ . ..... ...... .
8
Dredging'.
even seasonally,
6/6/2019
................. ...... ............... ... ... .........................
41:55
PM
9
............. .. ... ..... ............................ ................ . ..... .. . ......... ......... ....... ....... . . . . .... ............... .... ... . . .. .... . . .... ..... ..................... ........................ ..... .... ........ ....................................................... .........
1 would be careful about the businesses that we
...... .. .. . . ........... .. .... ........... ....... ......... .......................... ........... ........................................ ............................................wase........................ .........
attract here that oav a living Unless we
6/6/2019
5/29/2019 4:27 PM
1:59
PM
want our town to turn into another San Jose. And honestly, I don't see how a living wage can be
made with retail/s'ervice related businesses. The cost of living is outrageous as well as housing.
1 Clearly everyone can benefit from being bilingual. One way to reduce the cost of this for the city is 6/6/2019 11:26 AM
to have more language classes held at discounted and complimentary days at SRJC Petaluma
.... ..... ........ ..................................................... ....................... .. .... . ........................... : ............................ : ........ . .......................... : ............... ...................... ............................................. ........................................ ............ . . .............. .......... : ........... ........ ...... ....... ... ... .. .... .. .
12 See above. 6/5/2019 8:21 PM
..... ...... ...... ... ..... . ............................................ ............................. . ......................... .................. .... ....... ... ..... ................... .... ... .. . ....... ... . .... . ....... .... ....... ........ ................... . . .................... ........... ........................ .................... . ................... ........................... .... I ............
13 It all has to go together with affordable housing. Attracting companies that pay higher wages must 6/5/2019 5-E,07 PM
not exacerbate the affordability divide.
..... .. .. ..
15
.......
All good.
... . .. ....... ...... ....... ... .
6/4/2019 8:46 PM
. . . .......... . .. . . . ..... :-: ............................. ........ ................. . :-: . ... .
16
....
Leadership
............ ......... . . ...
6/3/2019 7:10 PM
.. .. . . ...... ..... .. . .. . .. ... . --c ....... ..... .... . ...... ............ ....... . ....
17
........ .. ....................................... . ............... ......... .. .. ............ . . . . ..
creating a living wage for all
........................... .. ............. .......... ...................
6/3/2019 4:51 PM
. .............. ..... ............. ................................ .... .. .... .. ............
18
. I . .. . . . . . . .. .. .. .... . . .. . . . .. . .... .. . . ...... ... ..... ..... ...... . . . . .... ... . .......... .
attract business.
. .......
too much tax base slippage is lost. Stop fighting businesses. encourage them to
6/3/2019 6:17 AM
come here,
.... ..... ..... ... . .. . .. ....... ... ....... . . .... ... ... . ... ... ................. ......... ...
19
.. ... . ... . . . . .. ... . . . .. . .. . . ......... . .... ... . ... ... . .......... ... ... . . .. .. . ..... .. ............ . .. ....... ....................
nothing to add at
.. ....... ...... ..... .... ........... ....................... ... .......... .................. . .................... ........ ........................ . ............ . .... ....... .................. ........... .. ............... ................ ........ ................. .... . ......... .................. . .. .... . ... .. ..... ... ..... ... ...... . .. . .. . .... . ... ..... .. . .. .. . .... ... ... ... ....... ..... .. .... ... .. ...... ...... .. .. .. I . ... ..... ... .. ..... . . ......... .......... . .. ... .. ..
this time
..... .................. ............................... ................. . .. . .. ..............
5/31/2019 6:53 PM
.... ....... ...... .... ........ ...... ............. .....
20
. ..... . .....
Collaborate with
.... .. .
Petaluma high schools' career and technical education programs to get more
5/31/2019 12:22 AM
teens employed,
even seasonally,
................. ...... ............... ... ... .........................
..
...... .. ...... .. . ............... .............. ......... .. .... ................ . ............. ...... ...... .. ...... .......... ......... . ... ............... ..... ............... ........... ............ ....... . ...... . ...... .. .. .. ... ... . .. ... .... ..... ..... .. .. . . .. ..... ... .......... .. . .. ........ ..... ...... ...... .. ........ ...
..... .....................................
21
1 like inclusion of
revenues and jobs.
5/29/2019 4:27 PM
....... ..................... .
22
. .. .. ... . ... ... .. ... ..... . . . ............ ..... .............................. . ... ...... .... ... .. ............
X
..... ....................... .... ..... ..... . . ....... ..... . ........ . .. ....... .. . ... . ........ ... ........ ... ..... .. ... . .. .. .... .... . . ........ ... . ............... ......... ... .... .. .. .
5/29/2019 7:24 AM
23
.. . . ............... I .... . ........ : ... .. . ..................
see above
. ... .. .. . . . ... ............... ...... ........ ... . ....... ...... .... ..................... . . ....... ..... . 1: ... ...... . ....... . . ......... ...................... .......... . .. . .. .. ..... . . .. ... ... ................... .. ............. .. ........................... .. .......................... ... .... . ..
.... ... .. . . ... ... .... : .. ........ .. I ........................ ....................................... .. .................. .......... : .................... .... . .. ......
5/28/2019 5:20 PM
. . .. . . .......................... .
24
.. . .... ....
ditto
.............. ....... .......... 1:1
....... ... .... ... ..
5/28/2019 1:25 PM
1 / 3 Input Summary 2 -'age 115 of 785
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-202
30 sounds good
31 By much contemporary thinking, the objective is reversed. San Francisco didn't trigger its current 5/21/2019 9:55 AM
boom by attracting Twitter and other businesses. The boom began with San Francisco being an
attractive place where young, talented, creative people wanted to live.. Twitter came to San
Francisco to tap into that desirable Tabor pool. Similarly, Petaluma needs to be a place that attracts
potential employees who businesses want to hire by relocating the Petaluma.
.. ... . . .. . ........
32 All good 5/19/2019 7:34 PM
33- Updating our Economic Development strategy should be the first step 5/18/2019 3:30 PM
34 Work with regional workforce agencies. We should be able to promote Petaluma as an alternative 5/18/2019 1 1:57 AM
to San Francisco for start ups.. Still cheaper to live here and a great place for families.
. ..... ... . .... .. .. ... . .. ... ..... . ....
35 Redundant 5/17/2019 7:23 PM
36 Minimum wage ordinance is essential. Wages are so low that most people commute long 5/17/2019 5:31 PM
distances to be able to afford to Iive in Petaluma..
. . .. ... .... . ......... . . .
37 Living wage jobs will hopefully pay viable wages. 70o many employers have underpaid workers 5/17/2019 4:58 PM
while claiming their living wages are adequate.
. .. ..... .. . ....... ..
38 Changing or creating variances in zoning, licenses, et al for business is a double edged sword.. In 5/17/2019 4:30 PM
the past it seems this has been done with little or short term benefit to the community.
. . ...... ..
39 Identify the one most ubiquitous reason businesses close and turn over, which is probably 5/17/2019 12:33 PM
4
commercial rent hikes. Enact commercial rent control and lower commercial property taxes.
4 0 I am concerned about attracting anymore big box malls. It has been proven that smaller local run 5/17/2019 11:01 AM
businesses actually add more to the city revenues. I believe that the big malls take away from
downtown, which is already competing with amazon.
41 No further comments at this time,. So many plans in this amazing proposal for all of Petaluma 5/17/2019 10:43 AM
42 For the people love it !! 5/17/2019 10:05 AM
43 See prev ious comments 5/17/2019 9 -op 13 AM
........... .... .. .. . . ..... ..... . . . ..
44 Definitely not a'fan of city minimum wage. It's counter productive to economic development. I don't 5/17/2019 9:11 AM
know what it is about Ca wanting to set these minimums. It actually limits the ability to conduct and
keep viable businesses sustainable and without constant turnover., It raises prices for those that
cannot afford the increases. Let the market sort it out,. It's like putting handcuffs on any business
that wants to operate here and that will leave more store fronts empty. Economics'l 01.
...... .. . ..
45 Again, this format is terrible for asurvey - please take note of that. It is too time consuming and I 5/17/2019 7-4,59 AM
am taking time to provide feedback - but I also know -my feedback will beignored and not
acknowledged at all, so why bother, frankly. That is the record of the City of Petaluma in
management and archaic communication thatis basically nonexistent. The slaughterhouses and
the very prominent presence of 2 of those on either side of the City is a reality that is not ever
discussed or addressed. I would like to see both businesses depart from the City and be replaced
by something that is more sustainable in terms of agriculture and production.
46 Petaluma is already well ahead of the cities to the South of us, but we need to keep it that way. 5/17/2019 7:24 AM
Fees and delays should be kept to an absolute minimum.
. ... ..... . ... ...
47 Ok 5/16/2019 6:45 PM
. . . . ...... ...
48 No bilingual documentation. Learn English or get out. 5/16/2019 3:19 PM
. ..... . .... . . . . .. . ............ . ..
49 Not enough green space being considered. Too much high density housing. Spread it to the 5/16/2019 1:27 PM
Westside of Petaluma too,.
...... .... . ........
50 zoning for marijuana related business perhaps also comes under this heading., Issues as I noted in 5/16/2019 1 :03 PM
an earlier question
. . .. . .... ..... . .....................
51 This is a much higher priority - it enables all the other things the City wants to "be" and to "do". 5/16/2019 11 :37 AM
businesses to expand 5/23/2019 9;14 AM
2/3 Input Summary 2 - Page 116 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
................................................. .... .
52 The city needs to focus clearly an its -sources of revenue. It has to maximise highest and best use 5/16/2019 10:21 AM
of land, coning that allows fest supporting infrastructure, separation of neighborhoods into
commercial and residential, promote activities based on the math of cost to the city vs. revenues to
0
3/3
U
1.
nput Summary 2 - Page 117 of 185
rim Ad
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q30 What do you like about these work plan items.? Or, what are we
M
RESPONSES
missing?
Answered: 58 Skipped: 217
1 (4) Establish City minimum wage ordinance for now and the future.
2 I think rent leases should be available in Spanish..
DATE
6/16/2019
4-4,04
PM
6/14/2019
6:23
PM
3 Ido not support language segregation by developing guidelines in Spanish,. I am utterly opposed to 6/14/2019 2:07 PM
a city minimum wage. You do not have the expertise to mandate things of this nature.
6 Not only does the fairgrounds infuse hundreds of thousands of dollars a year into local businesses,
the grounds offer an opportunity for budding new businesses to rent a kitchen or meeting space at
a significant discount. The main fair event provides small local businesses the opportunity to
showcase their products and services to a large population in a short period of time. - Sonoma -
Marin Fairgrounds' Board of Directors
6/6/2019 5:29 PM
.... . ..... .. ..... .. . . .......
7 With out the use on the Petaluma River the Coast Guard has been petitioned to keep the SMART 6/6/2019 4:55 PM
Train Bridge closed more. Without dredging there isn't a reason to open the bridge to take your
vessel to the Turning Basin.
8 I'd like to see a workplan item that doesn't turn our town into another San Jose type town. 6/6/2019 1:59 PM
9 Prioritize #2 and #4 Add: incentivize space to rent/share equipment or recycle/repair old equipment 6/6/2 019 1: 50 P M
10 Great 6/6/2019 12d:26 PM
11 see 28 and 29. 6/6/2019 11:26 AM
12 See above,, 6/5/2019 84921 PM
.............................. . .. . ...
13 Bring back contract planning staff as City staff. Pay planning staff to address the list of mistakes 6/5/2019 5:07 PM
and contradictions in the IZO already known to them. Small project often don't get the attention
bigger projects do and take longer to approve than they should. Some simple permits should be
over-the-counter. Only expedite projects that go beyond code minimums in reduced energy and
carbon generation.
14 #8 scares me. Let's not bring anything more to the airport other than personal craft and the 6/5/2019 3-9,03 PM
occasional USPS or FedEx plane. It's situated in a residential zone; air pollution and ground
pollution (traffic) will only come if bigger, more commercial craft are allowed.. & the roads will get
even more torn up.
15 F i n a I I y S p a nis h! 6/4/2019 8:46 PM
16 A city minimum wage ordinance is really needed. 6/4/2019 12:00 AM
17 some items are ok, however some could be dropped( ie #5) 6/3/2019 4:51 PM
18 nothing to add at this time 5/31/2019 6:53 PM
19 I don't know where this belongs: we need to think about the bridge between highschool/jr college 5/30/2019 3:56 PM
and entering the work force. If we want to attract businesses we need to offer a robust well of
potential employees. We need to work with the community educators to develop course
work/programs that prepare our young citizens for employment where they live. Maybe a mini
version of what Silicon Valley does with the local educational institutions in the South Bay
. ....... . .. . ....
20 The current state needs to be well understood first. What are the ramifications of current licensing, 5/29/2019 4:27 PM
zoning, and policies? Then develop the strategy to achieve the objective.
21 X 5/29/2019 7:24 AM
22 I like the minimum wage ordinance 5/28/2019 7:38 PM
. .. ...... .
1/3 Input Summary 2 - Page 118 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-202.1
Attachment 3
23 same
5/28/2019
5:20
PM
........ ...........
24 ditto
5/28/2019
1:25
PM
..... . . .. . ...... ... . ... . .. ......... . . ....... .. . . . .. . .. . . . .. .. . . . . .. . .. . ..... ..... . .... ... . . ..... . . ...... . ..... . . ........ . ............. :.: . .... ...
25 "Business -friendly" is usually code for "bend over backwards for corporate chains." It doesn't help 5/28/2019 12:36 PM
the community. Infill development? Noway! It's not sustainable no matter what words you tack on.
Yes to a living wage for all workers. Yes to Spanish language forms,
.. .. . ....... . ......... . ..................... ............ . ........ ... .. . ............................. ................... ............... ......................... .... .................... ...... . ... . . . ..... . . .. ... . . ..... ... .... . . ... .... . ...... . .. .
26 1 support infill development as long as biking and walking paths are incorporated. 5/28/2019 10:49 AM
.... . .. ...... . .
. ......... ...... . .
27 1 love everything about these work plan items! 5/28/2019 9:33 AM
"...: ..... ........ .... .... .... . .. .. ....... ... ... . .... ... ..... . ... ..... .... ... .. ... ....
28 understand cause and effect on minimum wage. higher minimum wage higher goods will be thus 5/25/2019 7:03 AM
creating the issue we are in. have events for businesses that utilize pay for performance. ie
something the employee would work towards in order to climb up the pay scale. hard work
rewards, not something that is just another handout,
. ... . . . ..... ..... ..... ........... .... .. ........
29 Recruit local talent for local businesses, not out-of-town candidates. Housing is scarce enough as 5/23/2019 3:05 PM
it is.
30
Over all
good. Missing: Addition of personnel to cover in-person consultations.
..
5/23/2019
. .. . .. . ..... . .. ...............
1:05
.. ...... .......... ............... .... ...... .. .. ....
PM
31
i like the
.................. ........... ....... ..... .. ......................................
........ ...................... ........ ......... ..... .. .............. I ....... . ....... ..... . .... I . ....... .. ....... .. . .............. 11 ......... ..... ... .... . . ... ........ ... ... .. .. ... .............
start up business part
....... .................. ................................... .. ..................................................... ............................................................. .................. ............. .......................................................... ............. ...............possible....................
5/23/2019
.
7:59
AM
32
Friendly
zoning reads a lot like having permitted uses in as many zones as which in turn
...... ................
5/21/2019
9:55
AM
F
can evoke an echo of the Safeway gas station., The permitting and licensing process should
proceed as
expeditiously as
possible, but it's zoning
where
we protect the
integrity of the
community.
Also, "Infill" can
be a confounding word.
In the
hands of some,
it can mean 40
.... .... ......... .... ............ ...................... ......... ..... .................... ...................................... .....
in
40 1 don't know what the airport rezoning entails or whether those living n the area will think that's ok. 5/17/2019 5:31 PM
but I would welcome more businesses on the east side that stayed open later than Spm (seriously
ALL. the restaurants close at 9pm). Why are there no bars that stay open late on east side? Do all
the bars have to be in downtown? Also, allow marijuana dispensaries! Why so weird on that
score? But I think it's really weird to have to drive downtown to buy a cocktail. Seriously. Why is
the east side just grocery, pharmacy, and a few random restaurants?
.. ... ...... . . ...... ............... . ....... . . ........ . ..... . . ...... ...... ..... . ................ .. : ..................... : ..... .. I.: ................... ......... .. ....... .... .. .... ..... ......... ........... ...........
41 The city should do this. We will keep our workers here in Petaluma. Currently our city bus 5/17/2019 4:58 PM
drivers are underpaid. A minimum wage ordinance should correct that and stabilize the driver
workforce.,
.. .. ...... ......... ... ... ..... ..... .................... ... ......... ... .... . . ... .......... ........................ ......... . . ... .... .. ..... .............. ......... .. .. ... ..... ............................. .... ............. ... ....... ...... .. ........... ......................... .... ....... . ..... . . .....
11
42 Parking. You're missing parking. As usual 5/17/2019 4:26 PM
.. .. . .... .. . .. . .. ...... ... . . .. . . . .... ........... .. ............. . .. .... ... ................. ..... ... . ................. ....... .... .............. ....... .................... .. .. ....... .......... . .... ................................ . ............................ - ................ ... ...... ............. . . ................... ..... .............. ....... ..... ..... . .. .. . .... . . . . .. ................... .............. ................................... .......... ....... ...................... ............... ................. ........ ..... ....
43 Incentives for local and green businesses 5/17/2019 12:35 PM
...... ...... ............ .............. .... ................................... ................................... ............................ : ............... ... . .............. .... .................... ... .... ........... ........................ .. . .............................. ........................................................ ............. ......................................... .... .............. . ..... ...... .. . ..... ....... .... ...................................... ........................... ...... .. .... ...
44 Identify the one most ubiquitous reason businesses close and turn over, which is probably 5/17/2019 12:33 PM
commercial rent hikes. Enact commercial rent control and lower commercial property taxes,
.. .......... ........ ............. ......... ... . . ... ..... ........ . . . ..... ...... . . . .. ..... .. ... .. ... ............ .. . . ... ... ....... .. ... . ... . . . .. ..... . .... ..... .... . . . ......... ...... . . .. ... . .. .... . . . .... . . .. .. . .. . ..... ... . ...... . . . ...... . .. ... ... . . .. ... . .... .. .. . . .. ... .. ... ..... ... . ... . .. . . .. ... .. ..... ... . ... ........ .. ..... ... .... ... . . ... .. ... ....... . .. . ........ . ... .. ... .. ... . .. .. . ..minimum........ .... ..... . . . . . ..... . . . ... .. . . . .. .ordinance,........................ ......................... ............... ... . ....... . ... . . ............. . ..... . ... .... . .... . .. ... . .. .. .. .. . .. . . ... . . ...... .. .. ........................ . .. .................... ...... ............................................. ... ........... .......... ................................................. ........ ..... ................... ...... ..................................... .................... . ........ . ... ...... . .. .. ..
45 1 don't think Petaluma should establish a City wage it's cumbersome and will 5/17/2019 10:50 AM
restrict business interest. I'm also not sure that the Airport re -zoning will be a catalyst to new
business opportunities and would like to see this assessed. It seems more likely a drain of city
funds. Finally, there is no mention of tech, which plays a heavy role in the bay area economy and
yet still feels unwelcome in North Bay. To drive better wages and growth, we need to attract tech
businesses driven towards local economies and health and wellness:,
- - " ". " - " - - - " " - - - - - " - : . .............. ............. :: ...... : __ : ... . ...... :. . :. . ........... ........... : . . -.": ........... ......... ... ....... - :: . :.. .,.. . . . : . : - :: . . .,.,: . : . : . ,: ........... : ....... . . ......... ... .................. : .............. .. ............. -,.: ................ ....... ................... .. ..... . . . 1: .......... ......... . . ... . .. .... ........ . .. : ... ...... ... . . . ..... : .. : . : .:.... ... :%.I:-.-.-::.......... - ... - .... . .. . .. .. ....
46 No Further Comment at this time 5/17/2019 10:43 AM
..................................... ................ .......................... . ....... .......... . .. .................. .... ............................................... ...... .... ...... ........ ..................................... . . . ..... .. . .... ................ .............. ... .................... ......................................... ................... ............................ ......... ... ............ ................................................ ...........
2 / 3 Input Summary 2 -gage 149 of 185
unit/acre development with minimal parking adjoining a major transit stop and also a 6,000 square-
foothome at the end of a quarter -mile driveway Just inside the Urban Growth Boundary. "Walkable,
bikeable, transit -friendly infill" gets closer to what we should desire.
.......... .................. ......... .. .. .. ........... ..............
33
... ....... ............. .... ........... .............................. ... ... .. ...... ................... ......... ..... .. ....... . ......
good stuff but without increased housing, businesses cannot find local talent which encourages
........... .
5/21/2019
8:57
AM
long commutes which is not sustainable
............... ......................... ...............
34
........ ................ .................... ............... .................... .. .................. . ...................... ........ ................... ...... :.: . ...... ...... .... . . ........... .. .......... ...... . ...... .... ... ................... .... . .............................................................. . .. ..... ..
All good
..............
5/19/2019
7:4134
PM
. . .. .................................. ....
35
...... . ...... ........... : ..... .. .... . .
These seem to be well thought out! Go implement them!1
5/19/2019
2:27
..... . . ..... ........ . . . .. . . ... . .
PM
36
.. ... ..... . ..... ........... ................................................ .... ................................ .......... ......... . ..... ................ ...... .. ..... . ... ... . .. ... .. . ...... . . .. . . . .... ....... I ...... . . . ... ... .. ..... .. . ..... ................ ..... .............. .......... ................ ..... .. ....... . . ..................... ...... .. ......... ................. ................ . ...... .. . .... ...................... .. .
The City needs a clearer vision of itself.
........ ................. ................. ................................ ....................................
5/18/2019
3:30
.......... ...................................................... ... .............
PM
.... .... ......... .... ............ ...................... ......... ..... .................... ...................................... .....
in
40 1 don't know what the airport rezoning entails or whether those living n the area will think that's ok. 5/17/2019 5:31 PM
but I would welcome more businesses on the east side that stayed open later than Spm (seriously
ALL. the restaurants close at 9pm). Why are there no bars that stay open late on east side? Do all
the bars have to be in downtown? Also, allow marijuana dispensaries! Why so weird on that
score? But I think it's really weird to have to drive downtown to buy a cocktail. Seriously. Why is
the east side just grocery, pharmacy, and a few random restaurants?
.. ... ...... . . ...... ............... . ....... . . ........ . ..... . . ...... ...... ..... . ................ .. : ..................... : ..... .. I.: ................... ......... .. ....... .... .. .... ..... ......... ........... ...........
41 The city should do this. We will keep our workers here in Petaluma. Currently our city bus 5/17/2019 4:58 PM
drivers are underpaid. A minimum wage ordinance should correct that and stabilize the driver
workforce.,
.. .. ...... ......... ... ... ..... ..... .................... ... ......... ... .... . . ... .......... ........................ ......... . . ... .... .. ..... .............. ......... .. .. ... ..... ............................. .... ............. ... ....... ...... .. ........... ......................... .... ....... . ..... . . .....
11
42 Parking. You're missing parking. As usual 5/17/2019 4:26 PM
.. .. . .... .. . .. . .. ...... ... . . .. . . . .... ........... .. ............. . .. .... ... ................. ..... ... . ................. ....... .... .............. ....... .................... .. .. ....... .......... . .... ................................ . ............................ - ................ ... ...... ............. . . ................... ..... .............. ....... ..... ..... . .. .. . .... . . . . .. ................... .............. ................................... .......... ....... ...................... ............... ................. ........ ..... ....
43 Incentives for local and green businesses 5/17/2019 12:35 PM
...... ...... ............ .............. .... ................................... ................................... ............................ : ............... ... . .............. .... .................... ... .... ........... ........................ .. . .............................. ........................................................ ............. ......................................... .... .............. . ..... ...... .. . ..... ....... .... ...................................... ........................... ...... .. .... ...
44 Identify the one most ubiquitous reason businesses close and turn over, which is probably 5/17/2019 12:33 PM
commercial rent hikes. Enact commercial rent control and lower commercial property taxes,
.. .......... ........ ............. ......... ... . . ... ..... ........ . . . ..... ...... . . . .. ..... .. ... .. ... ............ .. . . ... ... ....... .. ... . ... . . . .. ..... . .... ..... .... . . . ......... ...... . . .. ... . .. .... . . . .... . . .. .. . .. . ..... ... . ...... . . . ...... . .. ... ... . . .. ... . .... .. .. . . .. ... .. ... ..... ... . ... . .. . . .. ... .. ..... ... . ... ........ .. ..... ... .... ... . . ... .. ... ....... . .. . ........ . ... .. ... .. ... . .. .. . ..minimum........ .... ..... . . . . . ..... . . . ... .. . . . .. .ordinance,........................ ......................... ............... ... . ....... . ... . . ............. . ..... . ... .... . .... . .. ... . .. .. .. .. . .. . . ... . . ...... .. .. ........................ . .. .................... ...... ............................................. ... ........... .......... ................................................. ........ ..... ................... ...... ..................................... .................... . ........ . ... ...... . .. .. ..
45 1 don't think Petaluma should establish a City wage it's cumbersome and will 5/17/2019 10:50 AM
restrict business interest. I'm also not sure that the Airport re -zoning will be a catalyst to new
business opportunities and would like to see this assessed. It seems more likely a drain of city
funds. Finally, there is no mention of tech, which plays a heavy role in the bay area economy and
yet still feels unwelcome in North Bay. To drive better wages and growth, we need to attract tech
businesses driven towards local economies and health and wellness:,
- - " ". " - " - - - " " - - - - - " - : . .............. ............. :: ...... : __ : ... . ...... :. . :. . ........... ........... : . . -.": ........... ......... ... ....... - :: . :.. .,.. . . . : . : - :: . . .,.,: . : . : . ,: ........... : ....... . . ......... ... .................. : .............. .. ............. -,.: ................ ....... ................... .. ..... . . . 1: .......... ......... . . ... . .. .... ........ . .. : ... ...... ... . . . ..... : .. : . : .:.... ... :%.I:-.-.-::.......... - ... - .... . .. . .. .. ....
46 No Further Comment at this time 5/17/2019 10:43 AM
..................................... ................ .......................... . ....... .......... . .. .................. .... ............................................... ...... .... ...... ........ ..................................... . . . ..... .. . .... ................ .............. ... .................... ......................................... ................... ............................ ......... ... ............ ................................................ ...........
2 / 3 Input Summary 2 -gage 149 of 185
5/16/2019 6:45 PM
5/16/2019 5:08 PM
5/16/2019 3:19 PM
54 While I agree with having Spanish language guidelines I believe that language often separates us 5/16/2019 12:00 PM
often AND holds people back. I always encourage others to learn other languages, the Dutch and
Scandinavians do this to near perfection, but it is still crucial to learn the language of the country
0
3/3
Input Summary 2 - Page 120 of 185
we live in.
55
Minimum wages ... they KILL 1 st job and part-time "get someone back into the workforce"
5/16/2019
11:37 AM
opportunities --just how much more do you want to incentivize employers to automate?
56
Streamline permitting., Down time makes it more expensive for everyone.
5/16/2019
10:43 AM
57
This is how the city generates revenues. The work pians do not orient on this objective.
5/16/2019
... .... ....
1 0:21 AM
58
Good and recommended.
... ... . . . ..... . .. ... .. ... ... . . . ... . . ...... .
5/15/2019
3-0,33 PM
0
3/3
Input Summary 2 - Page 120 of 185
Ale
I
m
I
,,a
mor -7-1
47A
m
A
V-A
I
A
Alk
r I "l of 1 lnb,b,, ) m
u 6umar"" 2 Iwo Fa e 2
y
Lmmi
6�
gra
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q32 -What do you like about tris objective? Or, what are we missing?
RESPONSES
Answered: 95
Skipped: 180
9711110 =
1 QUite general - would want to consider specifics. 6/14/2019 7:04 PM
2 I think the parking options downtown are much better than other similar cities like San Rafael. 6/14/2019 6:25 PM
3 You are missing mention of river dredging. This is the low-* hanging fruit for increasing tourism- 6/14/2019 2:10 PM
oriented business. In fact, we already had much of that business which we have lost as a result of
nA
government neglect by not getting our river dredged.
Where the hell have you been Petaluma is already a destination., The same hipsters who swore
to never come to "cow town" are flocking here like we are handing out free flannel and craft beer.
6/13/2019 6:14 PM
Get these people out of my town. The tourists are irritating.,
5 Tourism may be a cash cow, but it destroys the hearts of communities. 6/13/201.9 3:05 PM
6 Why do we need another hotel downtown that will require more parking that we don't have. And 6/11/2019 7:59 PM
It
how can you "Identify potential parking alternatives for downtown" today, when the city hasn't
been able to do that for the last 40 years that 1 lived here?
7 is everything geared toward tourism? how about support the locals? 6/6/2019 8:24 PM
8 There needs to be another parking garage, and please don't ok development that uses leasing 6/6/2019 6: 13 P M
existing garage spaces to meet their requirements. That just takes'space away from the already
small number of spaces.
9 Overlooks an important asset and great opportunity: Historic character and outstanding collection 6/6/2019 5:46 PM
of historic buildings and resources.
10 This is a River Town. This is what made Petaluma the 3rd largest port back in the 1800's! Use this 6/6/2019 4:57 PM
resource we already have for bringing tourists to Petaluma,
11 I like the idea of promoting SOME tourism. After all, Sonoma, Napa, Marin counties all have a lot to 6/6/2019 2:02 PM
offer someone who is vacationing. Adding another hotel? Nope. all that does is increase traffic, and
I'd like to see how existing traffic is going to be handled before we add more growth. It already
takes 45 minutes to an hour to drive across Washington from the west side to east side at certain
times of the day.
1 2 Yes! Tourism. Fix the parks. Fix McNear Park. 6/6/2019 12:27 PM
13 A plan that economically makes sense to do this kind of development.. How to keep a tourist 6/6/2019 11:4:28 AM
focused place still reasonable for locals
14 Seems appropriate. 6/5/2019 8:23 PM
...........
15 Not interested in being a tourist attraction. Petaluma needs to be a great place to five first and 6/5/2019 7:11 PM
people will want to come here naturally. "Promoting Tourism" is so artificial. Examples include..
Build better cycling and walkability infrastructure, make Petaluma more bike/ped friendly, add city
bikes for the people of our town to use. Tourists will naturally be attracted to our town because you
can stay here and get around easily and pleasantly by bike and by foot.
. . .... .... ............... ..
16 Nervous about what successful tourism program looks like. Does it look like Healdsburg with tour 6/5/2019 5:17 PM
buses and traffic?
17 As a resident, I'm sort of meh on the prospect of sharing the road with any more people. Do I like 6/5/2019 3:06 PM
sharing the sales tax burden and using funds from visitors, yes. However, the City hasn't done very
well when it comes to taking care of those who live here. Let's focus on the local taxpayers first
and then consider paying attention to the outsiders.
18 Wouldn'tit make sense if we had some models, or references, for the kind of destination we're 6/5/2019 1:51 PM
talking about? Carmel, Aspen? Rio Vista? Savannah? Santa Cruz? It's the vision thing again.,
19 Good.. 6/4/2019 8:48 PM
1/4 nut Summary 2 - Page 122 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
20 Petaluma needs to charge for downtown parking and create more parking away from downtown 6/3/2019 7:13 PM
with shuttles to downtown.
.. . .... .. ..
. ..... . . ...... ..
21 Have lots of that already 6/3/2019 4:51 PM
22 THE LAST TIME YOU SCREWED AROUND WITH "PARKING ALTERNATIVES WAS A 6/3/2019 11:40 AM
DISASTER- ALL YOB WANT IS REVENUE -HANDS OFF PARKING!
downtown..
matter art events.
.. . ....... ........ .
33 I am not interested in bringing more people to town/promotion of tourism. We have enough. 5/28/2019 7-0,40 PM
2/4 Input Summary 2 - Page 123 of 185
51
CITY COiJNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Definitely parking. Another hotel would be great, but it
Attaciment 3
must fit in with the surroundings. Petaluma 5/18/2019 5:29 PM
has a "look" and the hotel planned for B Street and Petaluma Blvd. does not blend in.
52
We should create a Petaluma
that works
for the Community first and tourism will follow,,
5/18/2019
5:34
PM
3:32 PM
53
This is broad and needs more
detail. Let's try again for a baseball team!
5/18/2019
5:06
PM
11 :58 AM
54
Fix waterfront
5/18/2019
61
10:02 AM
55
Yeah, sounds good, but unfortunately
we
lack theinfrastructure to handle the current population.
5/18/2019
wording seems to imply increasing those departments, I am leery of increasing the police
8:07 AM
56
Parking is an issue downtown.
We find ourselves driving further to other towns to eat out rather
5/17/2019
department for periodic events. There is at least one downtown hotel that has been in the works for
8: 14 P M
than struggle to find parking in
Petaluma.
quite some time. Refer to the previous question about expediting permits, etc. Also this goal fits
57
A healthy tourism industry can
contribute
to the vibrancy of the community, however the needs of
5/17/2019
7:51 PM
the tourism industry should not outweigh
the needs of the residents and businesses in Petaluma.
There is room for city hall, the PD, a convention/hall, hotel, housing and more. Creating transit to
59
Petaluma is already a destination.
5/17/2019
5:34
PM
60
Yespd o romote Petaluma as a destination butimprove walkability, b ikeability, and safe transit
5/17/2019
5:06
PM
access,,
61
The wording of #1 is a bit concerning. While police and public employees would be needed this
5/17/2019
4:41
PM
wording seems to imply increasing those departments, I am leery of increasing the police
department for periodic events. There is at least one downtown hotel that has been in the works for
quite some time. Refer to the previous question about expediting permits, etc. Also this goal fits
right in with the larger transformation needed with the geographically central fairgrounds site.
There is room for city hall, the PD, a convention/hall, hotel, housing and more. Creating transit to
and from this site would further the goals stated'.
62
Forgetift, Petalumals busy enough
5/17/2019
4:28
PM
63
People don't come to PETALUMIA for the parks
5/1
7/201
9
2:56
PM
64
Identify the one most ubiuitous reason businesses close and turn over, which is probably
q
5/17/20119
12:33 PM
commercial rent hikes. Enact commercial rent control and lower commercial property taxes.
65
Tourism is a great boon for our restaurants and famers.
5/17/2019
10:53 AM
66
.... ............ .... .... ............... . ........ ..................... ........
Great idea to help Petaluma and our businesses.
5/17/2019
... .. ... . ........... .
10:45 AM
67
. ..... . ...
I am not in support of the potential large downtown boutique hotel. It is too large.
5/17/2019
10:15 AM
68
Good
5/17/2019
10:06 AM
69
Tourism is a great economic driver and helps support a vibrant downtown
5/17/2019
9:19
AMi
70
The only thing needed to attract more tourstsis outreach and marketing campaigns,
5/17/2019
9: 18
AM
71
It's good
5/17/2019
9;15
AM
72
This needs some more Fleshing out but is headed in the right direction.
5/17/2019
9:07
AM
73
City-wide bike sharing for tourists as well as resident, so tourists don't need to bring cars.
5/17/2019
9:05
AM
74
see below
5/17/2019
8:03
AM
75
#2 and #3 important!
5/16/2019
6-::46
PM
76
We do not have enough parking space in Petaluma?
5/16/2019
5: 10
PM
77
PARKING?????PARKING?????5/16/2019
5:01
PM
78
Hotel downtown? ike that 5 story monstrosity on the blvd next door to Rex's Hardware? With no
5/16/2019
3:31
PM
parking on site and teenagers zooming around moving cars to stolen parking places?
79
No hotel. Traffic is bad enouas it us.
gh
5/16/2019
3:20
PM
80
Stop the Petaluma hotel from freeloading on parking
5/16/2019
3:15
PM
81
Agree..tourism is good, people love coming to Petaluma but DO NOT ever get rid of the free 2 -hr
5/16/2019
2023
PM
parking downtown. One' of the reasons believe San Rafael's downtown is dying is because it is
impossible to park and costs a fortune.
82
. ... .. ..... .. ............ .. .... ..... . . . . . ...... ...... ... ... .
Definitely need more recreational areas for soccer, basketball, tennis, etc.
5/16/2019
1:27
PM
3/4 Input Summary 2 - Page 124 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
84
I agree.
We needs
.. . .. ..... ..
tourism dollars
at this point.
5/16/2019
1:06
PM
85
Foster a
new hotel
??? The roads
into Petaluma a overstressed now. Whv promote more traffic?
5/16/2019
1:04
PM
Seems the cartis backwards with the horse. Fix existing problems before building and causing
more!!
........... .. .
86 There are many modes of travel and some individuals choose the fly to Petaluma. This is a source 5/16/2019 12:22 PM
of greater tourism dollars the could flow into the local economy. It will require greater involvement
in the airport and its operations to leverage.
90 Not missing because later you discuss Turning Basin and boater access. No access, less boat 5/16/2019 10:44 AM
tourism. Takes no time to lose, lots of time to inspire confidence and get boats to return.
........... . ... ....... ......... ........... . .............. ::-:: ...... ......... .. ..... .... .. ... .. ..... .
91 Right now Petaluma must focus on curing its problems. This does not. The problems are road 5/16/2019 10:23 AM
repair, traffic congestion, crosswalks that impede traffic flow, development without concern for
parking or traffic. It is a mess.
. ... ... .. . . . ....... .. ... .. . ... ... ..... .. ... .. .
95 Tourism is excellent for Petaluma. 5/15/2019 3:35 PM
d
11
14/4 Input Summary 2 - Page 125 of 185
F
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q33 What do you li <e about these wor< plan items.? Or, what are we
missing?
Answered: 71 Skipped: 204
i
# RESPONSES 4 DATE
1 (3) Explore the elimination of free parking in the downtown. Add: Explore -creating pedestrian only 6/16/2019 4:04 PM
"streets" in our downtown.
IL
2 You are missing streamlining event permitting and making it easier for people to host private & 6/14/2019 2:10 PM
business events. There is too much regulation in this city getting in the way. Your work plan goals
are great but you are missing the forest for the trees, and many of the trees as well
3 We need less San Francesco in Petaluma. Keep people OUT. 6/13/2019 6:14 PM
4 The community needs to organize around serving its citizens and protecting its environment, not 6/13/2019 3:05 PM
5
catering to visitors, while remaining visitor friendly.
. .
....... ..
......
See Above 6/11/2019 7:59 PM
6 Add thisitem: 1) Consider "maximum" numbers of parking spaces for downtown or new 6/6/2019 9:51 PM
development rather than "minimum" numbers to emphasize a move away from fossil -fuel
dependency
7 we already avoid going downtown as much as possible; work on alternative traffic routes 6/6/2019 8:24 PM
8 Add workplan item: Celebrate and promote Petaluma's historic character and promote Heritage 6/6/2019 5:46 PM
Tourism. Look for new outreach/advertising opportunities in magazines, etc. Continue to build the
Petaluma Star website and work with the PDA and Visitor's program to leverage new opportunities
to attract tourons
9 The fairgrounds facilitates destination events all year round. Music festivals, multi -cultural festivals 6/6/2019 5:45 PM
& celebrations, agricultural showcases, wine & beer competitions, athletic competitions,
fundraising events and of course our main fair event which -also features The Worlds Ugliest Dog
Competition that promotes animal adoption which is showcased nationally. That all said. We'd love
to do more and partner with the city on topics and ideas to expand our events and promote the city
as a destination. - Sonoma -Marin Fairgrounds` Board of Directors
10 Itis missing the River! 6/6/2019 4:57 PM
11 I like the idea of some tourism. What I don't want to see is traffic get worse than it already is:, 6/6/2019 2:02 PM
12 Add shuttles to tourist destinations to cut GHG emissions. 6/6/2019 1:52 PM
13 Fix McNear Park 6/6/2019 12:27 PM
14 see 32 6/6/2019 11:28 AM
15 Don't just host'sports events, Promote activities on the river, and hiking Lafferty Park and Putnam 6/5/2019 10;29 PM
Park and Tolay Park to bring people to the area for wholesome, healthful activities.
16 See above 6/5/2019 86923 PM
'17 (not so subtle) View from Bike Petaluma: Parking alternatives? Cycinq!'nufflsaid. we already have .6/5/2019 7:11 PM
3 public parking lots downtown free of charge. That's ridiculous. Frankly, we should begin charging
for parking and use that money to build better bike infrastructure. Missed: Public transportation!
Completely missed not just here but seemingly throughout all the plans so far.
........... .............
18 We need more hotels downtown. Parking does need re -thinking. Kentucky should become a 6/5/2019 5*917 PM
pedestrian street with a weekly Farmers Market, not 2nd Street. We need to be smart about what
exactly we want to attract. Simply more people (tourists) would not be something I would support.
Anything to support the Latino community would be good..
. . ... ...... ..
19 Always about the West side. Sigh. What about promoting the East side? I like #5 the best of all the 6/5/2019 3:06 PM
items.
1/4
Input Summary 2 -' age 126 of 185
0
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
...... . .....
20 No new hotel. We have the hotel at the Marina, the new Hampton. Enough. More affordable and 6/4/2019 8:48 PM
HUD housing!
21 Regular shuttles from hotels and the SMART
frequent shoppers' shuttle.
train would be very helpful, especially a free and 6/4/2019 12:03 AM
22 Many of these ideas are old ideas that have never been implemented. 6/3/2019 7: 13 PM
... ..... ..... .... ........ ............ ............... .. . ..... ......... ........... ............
. .. ... ............ ...... ..... .. ... . ..... ... . . .. .. .. . . ... . ... . .. . . .. . . . . . ... . .... .. .. . ... ... .
23 City has lots at attention getting activities already 613/2019.4:51 PM
. . ... ...... ..
. .. . ........... . .
24 As mentioned above 5/31/2019 6-:54 PM
29 ditto 5/28/2019 1:27 PM
.......... : ....... ........ :.1 .. ...... .... .... ..... ........ ....... I . .. . . .... ..... ... . .... .... . . ..... .. .. .......... ... . . .. . . ...
30 Tourism is an important part of Petaluma's economy and I agree with supporting it. That " second 5/28/2019 12:40 PM
downtown hotel" is going to be a disaster. The building itself looks fine but it has no parking..
"Parking alternatives" is gov speak for "we don't care if locals can park downtown." Sure, boost
public transport, increase walking and biking pathways, all of that., But don't even consider a large
hotel that does not have its own parking to support guests and employees. Renting space in other
lots does not work (doesn't work for the Hotel Petaluma either).
........ .. . . ........ . ................... ........ ................... . ... .... .. ............... .... ...... ...... .....
. ....
31 Pedestrian friendly paths. The worse thing i see is the hords of visitors walking along the horrid 5/28/2019 10:52 AM
Washington Street to get to downtown, Improve this stretch or provide a safer alternative!
Improvements include Shade TREES, safe road crossings, a visual sign that tells people a better
walking route...
................. .... ............................................ ............. .... .. ...
32 Not sure if this is place to ask but would love if the City revises its flag flying policy to allow flying 5/28/2019- 1 0:02 AM
the Pride Flag in 2020 and beyond
. ...... ................ ................ . .... ....... .... . ...... ..... .... . ..... . .. .... ......... .................. .... ...................... ..................... .. ......... ........... I ...... .. ... ...... . .... ........... .... I ........ I .... ............ ............................... ..... . ... . ......... . ..................... ... . . ............................ .. . .... ... ... . ...... ... ... . .. . .
33 #5 is great as for parking.. we should look into permits for parking and the majority of these funds 5/25/2019 7:05 AM
should go back to public safety. .. . . . ... . . ................. .. ..... . ........ ..
................ . ....................... ......... .......... ......................................... ............. ... . ....... ................... ............ . ............
34 More parking: yes! 5/23/2019 3:06 PM
.. ....... ................... ........ ........... ....................... .. .................. ...... .......................... .................. ... ................ ................... ........ ....... .................... ........................... .............. ..... ....... .... ............. .......................... ... ................... ..... .... . .. . .................................. .............. ... ..... ... .................. ... . .... ......... . . ...... .. ................... . . .... . .... .... .... ...... .. ................... .... .. .......
35 Over all good. Missing the addition of personnel to cover events,. 5/23/2019 1:06 PM
. ......... .... ................... . .................. .. .........., .. ..... I ........... .... ....... ....... .... ...... . ................ .......... ......... ....... ................ . .... ..... ...... . ........... . . .... . .. ....... . .......... ......... ....... .................... ... ............. .... ......... .... . ...... . .. .. .. ............. . . ................ .................................. ......... ................................... ....................................... ... ....... ......... ................... . ............ .
36 I would add something about improving and maintaing the bicycling trail and lane networks and 5/23/2019 8:10 AM
leveraging the excellent recreational bicycling opportunity's in the surrounding area. This would
expland the -focus beyond downtown. excellent bike facilities and wayfinding would spread tourists
out and share the benefits of tourism to more parts of the city..
...... ....... ....................... . ...... .. ..... I . ...... I ... ..... ...... .......... . ... ... .............. ......... ........ ............. ... .......... .......... .......... .............. .. ... ..... . .. ..... ............ .... ............... ..... ...... .. I .. ... .... .. .............. I ............................ ............ ........ .......... .............. .... ... . ... .. ............. . ............................... ... ........... ....... .... ................. ................. . ................
37 Support and promote local wineries' and breweries 5/21/2019 9:40 PM
........ .......... ....... ......... ...... .................... ... ... . ...... .... . . .. . ..... .. . ...... I . ...... . .... . . ... . : ..... ...................... : ... ..... ...... .. . ...... .. .... ... . ... . . .. . ... ... . ....... . .. .. ..... ... . . . .... ....... ... 1: ... . .. ... ........... .... . .. ........ .. . . ....... ......... . ..... ........
38 The default assumption of downtown parking is troubling. Can we consider bike share from the 5/21/2019 10:54 AM
train station, shuttles from outlying areas of street parking, or stronger walkability so visitors are
comfortable parking several blocks from downtown? As is often said, "If we plan for cars, we fail
for everything, including cars. But if we plan for people, we suceed for everything, including
people."
2/4 Input Summary 2 - Page 127 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
44 We need to spend money on caring for the people we have before making Petaluma a 5/1 9/201 9 2:27 PM
"destination". No more hotels.
Let's make Petaluma great for Petalumans. The world will discover us if we accomplish this.. 5/18/2019 3:32 PM
The Petaluma River dredging!! People from all over the Bay Area used to come to Petaluma via 5/18/2019 6:44 AM
boat and visit the local downtown businesses,, We are overlooking one of our major assets to
promoting Petaluma.
47 I'm not sure we need another hotel. 5/17!2019 8:14 PM
48 Redundant 5/17!2019 7:24 PM
. . .. ...... ............ ............ .... ..... . .
49 No extra downtown hotel especially without parking. Tourists will all arrive in cars (duh!). If you 5/17/2019 5;34 PM
really think tourists will be arriving by SMART train, dream on! The artist rendering of the proposed
extra downtown hotel is gross. Please have some architectural standards so the downtown doesn't
begin to look cheesy. And allowing a 4 story hotel with zero parking is SO irresponsible. Did the
3/4 Input Summary 2 -Page 128 of 185
developers bribe you for that one?
50
Work on D Street issues around, the SMART station. People get off the train to walk or bus
5/17/2019 5:06 PM
downtown or east toward the fairgrounds on an absolute street nightmare! Fix this!
51
Instead of looking for more parking, lets look for alternative trasnportaion in the form of walkability,
5/17/2019 4:41 PM
public use bicycles, bike paths that encourage everyone to hop on a bike. We need to move away
from fossil fuels as quickly as possible and providing alternative forms is perhaps one of the best
methods to do this. Make Petaluma "green" would be a great goal as weU.
52
.. ... .. . ..... . . . . . ..... ..... .. . ..... ...... ............
Identify the one most ubiquitous reason businesses close and turn over, which is probably
.................
5/17/2019 121:33 PM
commercial rent hikes. Enact commercial rent control and lower commercial property taxes.
53
another downtown petaluma hotel that is 5 stories tall is not in keeping with the existing buildings.,
5/17/2019 11:06 AM
If another hotel is to be encouraged it needs to the best contemporary sustainable architecture that
is up to the same standards that our historical buildings are. The key to a thriving business, tourist
attractive downtown is a combination of historic architecture with excellent comtemporary Gold
standard sustainable design.
54
Missing a connection to local transit (Ferry to SMART) as a more sustainable option than spending
5/17/2019 10:53 AM
money on parking and increasing traffic. No mention of promoting events.
55
... . . .... ... . . .... . ... . .....
No further comment
5/17/2019 10:45 AM
56
Good
........ ... .. .. . . . ...
5/17/2019 10:06 AM
57
I like that the police and public works staff are included, but please make sure their departments
5/17/2019 10:00 AM
are compensated for the time that they put into these efforts. Asking a department to eat the cost irs
unfair.
58
Leverage the SMART station as an amenity to attract regional visitors without adding vehicle traffic
5/17/2019 9; 19 AM
and car parking..
59
. . . ..... . . ..... . ... . .. ....
#1. Police? Really? No #2. No more hotels, boost air bnb - city gets tax revenue from this plus it
5!17/2019 9:18 AM
promotes more of a small town vibe: Farmstead air bn-b -people from the city crave a farm life
experience not another hotel. #3 No parking structures public; transit.
60
Identifying additional parking is not helpful. MAKING actual additional parking is a MUST!
5/17/2019 9:15 AM
Especially if the city allows another downtown hotel. And in my opinion, we already have a lot of
tourism here. Petaluma has been " on the map" for years. It's already growing naturally onits own
with city transplants and visitors, boutique beer and wine locations, superior restaurants,
community events... ! think city energy for this could be used elsewhere.
3/4 Input Summary 2 -Page 128 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DR -AFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
61 On #5 - I intended to comment in an earlier item - the community sports fields is a money sink and 5/17/2019 8:03 AM
the project should not have been constructed in that location. This is a perfect example of a project
that was too expensive, a City with no ethics that ran over the Paula Lane open space application
to try and grab whatever money was available, rather than apply in the next cycle as should have
occurred, for a high millions of dollars project that still to this day cannot be completed and is
piecemeal as well as with many many problems occurring at the site. The City is very short-
siahted and the politics were immense in this particular oroiect pursuit. P 11 of the elected officials
were competing to see who could take credit for and claim this sports fields project was going to
be created and constructed. In the process, they ran over sincerity, authenticity and many years of
hard work toward obtaining open space grant funds. It was a disgusting experience and very
disheartening - and exemplifies the underbelly of politics in this community. I don't think any
additional funds should be directed to the community sports fields or hosting events, other than
having the sports teams and clubs themselves raise funds for completing construction as they had
q
W
4/41
Input Summary 2-'ae 129 of 185
agreed to do and never did. On the other hand, I believe hosting limited sports and athletic events
that promote health and well being are a good idea.
62
42 and #3 super important
.... ... . .. ... . ..
......... .... ...........
5/16/2019 6:46 PM
63
Number 2. Are we benefiting any specific business company?
5/16/2 019 5:10 P M
........ ......... ..
64
................. .. .............................. . .........
NOT IN FAVOR OF THAT HOTEL. WAY TOO TALL AND BULKY., A BLOT! SOMEONE CALLED
5/16/2019 3:31 PM
IT AN ANCHOR,. I CALL IT AN ALBATROSS. BUH BYE CHARMING PETALUMA., HELLO
SANTA ROSA. GAH! I do not care to live in a "destination" town. VVTH?
......................
65
... . ...... ... . ..... . ..... .. .... . . . . ... ....................... . .. . .. ... ........... .. .................. . ...... .. .. ........... ...... .. . .... ... ........ ...... ...... ...... . ....... ... ............ .....
Traffic solution
5/16/2019 3:20 PM
66
.. . . . .. ..... ....... . ...... . ... ......... ..... ... .. . . .. . . . ...... .. ...... . . .. ... .. ....
Establish more paid and permit parking.. Just like Marin. Every resident gets 1 permit, every thing
5/16/2019 3:15 PM
else paid
.......... ..... ....... . .. . .... ..... ................. .... ................ . . . .. . . . ... .. ..... .. ..... ... ..... . .... .. . . .....
67
.
I'd like us to work towards encouraging LGBTQ tourists in somewhat as a stop off on the way to
5/16/2019 1:106 PM
the River so to speak. Sorry Im not sure how, but it seems that its an opportunity we are missing.
But I'm all for catering to tourists as long as its not at the expense of residents. For example, it was
great that the city finally gotit together around AirBnBd Thank you for that.
. . ... .......... .. .. ................... ............ 1-1 . . . . I ... .... ... .... ....... . .... .... ...... ............................. . ..... . .... .... ...................................... .............. .... . .... .. ........................... ..................... ......... . ....... ........ ................ . ......... . . . ........... . . . .....
68
. . .... ............. ..... .... .... .... . .. .. .. ... .. ....... . ........ . . ... ..........
Parking alternatives are vital if this plan is to work. This needs to be done before and not after plan
5/16/2019 12:04 PM
is implemented. Development without adequate parking is wrong, if parking spaces are ever
redundant is is easy to convert that space to other uses. The opposite leads to trouble and is
difficult to remedy.
..... .... ...... . ................... .............. ...
69
......................... .............................................................. ............. ......... .............. ....................................... .... ... .. . . . .... . ...... .. ....... . . . ... .. .. ....
2. Facilitate the development of an additional downtown hotel. We do not need any hotel in
5/16/2019 10:43 AM
downtown. It is beautiful now and do not take away that by looking for revenue out of hotel please.
.. .. . ... ......... ............ . .. .... . .. ... ... . . . .
70
.......... ............................................ .......... . ......... ................................. . ... ... ...... . .. . ...... ... ... . . .. . .... .... ... ... .. . ... . . . . . .. ..... ..... . . .. I ... .................. . ............. ................. ..... ..... . ........ ....................................... . ..............
Again, stop playing with words. Fix the problems.
... .... . . . ................. .. ..... ...... . ........... ..... .. ..... ........... ........... ......... ...... ... . ... .. .... .. ..... .. ... .. .. . .... I ... . ............ ........................ ............. ..... .... ..... ..... ............. . ... ..............
..... . I ........ .. ............................ ............................................................................ ........... .................
5/1 6/2019 10-1:23 AM
.. ........................... .........
71
We should definitely promote Petaluma.
. .. .. . ...... .. ...... .. .. .. .. . . .. ... . .. ... ..... ... . ... . . ...................
5/15/2019 3:35 PM
.............. .
q
W
4/41
Input Summary 2-'ae 129 of 185
c
I
'10
I
-1
-211'
90"WMI
OR
I
MR,
I
IR
I
MIN
Ri
E3
lnput Summary I e 130 of 18
L�
2
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
Q35 What do you like about tris objective? Or, what are we missing?
Answered: 99 Skipped: 176
RESPONSES
Petaluma would shine with a clear river and Shollenberger in. the process.
DATE
6/14/2019 7:07 PM
.. .... .. ........ . . ... .. ........... . ... .. ........ . . . .. ... .. . ... .. . .. ........ .. . ... .... . ........ .................. .... I ... .. . ... ....... . .. . .. . ... .... .. ..... ...... .. . ... ... .... . . . . . .. . . ... . . ..... ........ ..... ...... . ... .. .. ... . . .
It addresses the need to increase river access. 6/14/2019 6:26 PM
. ..... . . ...... . ... ... . ..... . . .. ... .. ... . .. .. ..... .. . .... . ... ... ..... .......... .. .. .......... ... . ...
3 I like everything about this objective. 6/14/2019 2:12 PM
.. . .... . .. ....... . ....... ................. .. ............... . .. ......... ........ : ..... .... . .. .. ........ ... ...............
4 HAH! 1 would love it, but it will never happen, Been talked about for years but city council's pockets 6/13/2019 6:15 PM
come first. It would be nice to use, but not at the expense of untrustworthy city council building
monstrosities on it
...... .... ........... . . ...... I-: .......... . ............ .......... ...... ...........
5 Need to plan for how to do this while enhancing natural values of the river and its surrounds. 6/13/2019 3:08 PM
... ...... ...... . . . ......... . . . . . . .. ............ .... . ................................... .. ... ................................. .. . . .............. ...................... ......................... .......... ...... .. . ...... ..... .. .. ..... . . . .. ... .. .. ..... ... . . ........ . .. . ... .... . . .. .. . .. .. . . . . . . . .. . ... ... ..... ...... .... . . . . .... . ..... ..... .... .... .. . ... ... . .. ........ ...... . . . . . ...... . ...
6 It has been an objective for the City for over 40 years. So what's new? Abetter question would be 6/11/2019 8:04 PM
"How do we get back the commercial tonnage that we used to have on the river?" That's what
prompted the Army to do the dredging in the past. Now they have no motive.
7 Keep bike trails safe, and not over run by homeless. I won't ride Lynch creek trail by myself, and 6/6/2019 6:14 PM
won't allow our teen ager to do so, either.
...........................
8 Harvest the Dredge Spoils...Thisis why that area was bought way back when. 6/6/2019 4:58- PM
........ ........ ... .. . ........... I ....... ... .. . ........
9 Now you're talking! Let's fix what we already have before adding new!!! 6/6/2019 2:06 PM
.............. . ................. ..... .. . ............ . ... . ..... . . ... .. ... . ....... .......
10 Yes'. Fix this and have a Petaluma Queen boat or water taxi. 6/6/2019 12:28 PM
1/4 Input Summary 2 - 'age 131 of 185
a
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
........
27 I don't think the river should or could be restored for commercial/industrial transportation. But it 5/31/2019 12:25 AM
should be developed for recreational and aesthetic purposes.
29 I commented earlier about paths along the River. The R iver is more than a
5/30/2019 4:01 PM
2/4
Input Summary 2 -- Page 132 of 185
commercial/recreational traffic waterway. It will be out buffer with sea level rise IF we take care of
it This is more than dredging.. we must pay attention to restoration issues also, to ensure that the
marshlands can accommodate rising water levels..
30
i would love to see this happen.
5/30/2019
1:47
PM
31
Love all of the above -you've really hit the nail on the head here
5/29/2019
9:32
PM
32
. .. . .. ..... ...... . ... ... . .... . ... .. . .. . . ........
The river and bicycle infrastructure are very important to the future of the city.
5/29/2019
4:31
... ...
PM
33
The river i's the heart of the cify. It needs care and attention, this should be a top priority,,
5/29/2019.11:37
AM
34
Fix the turning basin, it will aid in tourism
5/29/2019
7:25
AM
35
Dredging is essential. The City cannot afford dredging. Doing everything it can to support creative
5/28/2019
8:47
PM
alternatives should be a planning priority
.... .. ........... .. . . . .
. . .....
36
I support dredging and maintaining the river/waterfront. It's a huge part of downtown's charm
5/28/2019
7:40
PM
37
... .. . .......
We need to fund the dredging, period!
5/28/2019
7:34
PM
38
"We" can't afford to dredge the river. And we will be lucky if the Corp of Engineers can find money
5/28/2019
5:24
PM
to return to that function. This may be a lost cause.
39
ditto
5/28/2019
1:27
PM
40
Yes! Dredge and support PATHS along the River. Build the boat house and more small craft
5/28/2019
10:55 AM
launch sites for access to the River. Promote river activities like kayaking, rowing.
41
.... ......
I don't know enough to comment on feasibility of dredging
5/28/2019
. . .. ... ....... .
10:02 AM
42
tourism brings with it financial stability
5/27/2019
2;56
PM
43
.... ..... ....... ..... .................... . ...
It would be nice to have the river dredged but it is not one of my priorities.
5/27/2019
12;46 PM
44
Creation of a riverwalk with entertainment shell.
5/25/2019
...........
10:01 AM
45
Air show: to fund river dredging.
.. . . . ..... .. . . . .... .. .... . .... ... . .... . ................ ... ............
5/23/2019
3:07
PM
46
_ _ __
looks good
5/23/2019
8:11
AM
47
.......................
please dredge the basin and put docks in the turning basin. Also, fix the walkway.
5/22/2019
3:50
PM
48
Dredging the turning basin is many years overdue and should be one of the top priorities for the
5/21/2019
9:41
PM
City
...... .....
49
River dredging is a HUGEIssue for the city and our elected representatives should be held
5/21/2019
11:30 AM
accountable for this problem.
50
The objective is fine, although a supplemental note about enhancing the role of the river channel
5/21/2019
1 0;58 AM
in promoting water quality and absorbing some portion of the rising river from sea -level changes,
that would seem appropriate.
51
............ ................ ... . . . ............................... .......... .. .. . . .
Commercial river trafficis a thing of the past. Focus on recreational use.
5/20/2019
1;18
PM
52
Most importantis the river getting dredged
5/20/2019
12:58 PM
.. ..... ... .
53
Absolutely!
5/20/2019
10:48 AM
54
Yes! The river feature is under utilized.
5/20/2019
9:50
AM
55
You've got it!
5/20/2019
8:39
AM
56
. . . . ... . . ........
Good for locals and visitors alike
5/19/2019
7:39
PM
57
100% support his goal
5/19/2019
2:34
PM
58
Like everything about this plan and think it should be a priority.
5/19/2019
21:28
PM
59
Yes, Yes, Yes! The river is our heritage, the river makes us unique, the river is our core.
5/18/2019
3d:35
PM
2/4
Input Summary 2 -- Page 132 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
60 This should be the first priority. The River is what makes this town special. Many of the other 5/i8/2019 11:59 AM
goals and objectives stated here will be resolved/improved just by prioritizing the River.
61 All of it. Get it done 5/18/2019 10:03 AM
. ....... ... ..
62 We are known as a rive ont town. I believe the dredging is important to keep the river viable,, 5/17/2019 8:15 PM
63. the dredging of the turning basin and restoration efforts of the Petaluma River should be one of the 5/17/2019 7:53 PM
top priorities for the city. This is a central feature of the city that is unique and could be a driver for
tourism, business, and quality of life for residents. It should be a point of pride, not a sad and
disappointing embarrassment.
64 Yes yes yes 5/17/2019 7:25 PM
. . . ................ . .. .. . . . . . ... ............. ..... . ........... . .. . ...... .. .. . .... . . .... I ...... ... .. : ..... ...
65 This is long overdue. 5/17/2019 5:36 PM
. .... . ..... . ... .. . ...... ..................... ....................... ..... . . ...... .. .. :--,----:-�1 . ....... ............... ... . ..... ... .... .. I .. ...................... ....... ...... .... ....
66 Very good. 5/17/2019 5:11 PM
67 The river (though really it is a slough, don't tell anyone) is a key feature of Petaluma, i think it is 5/1 7/201 9 4:54 PM
also a mini gold mine in terms of untapped recreational and tourist use. The river (OK call it a rive
but don't tell the Feds) needs to be dredged on a regular basis and it doesn't look like the Army
engineers are going to be doing this but perhaps one more time. Congressman Huffman has been
pursuing this for some time and the current Fed administration is not likely to give'anything to CA
in terms of , well anything really. A recent presentation -about public funding dredging via a tax had
some promise and many questions. Bottom line a solution must be found and as it stands it does
seem some sort of tax will be needed. On the bright side once it is done, the opportunity for various
water related activities is huge and one not mentioned is a floating restaurant. However the river is
used promoting it as a tourist attraction ideally might resultin creating a revenue stream hearty
enough to fund future dredging needs. Schollenberger offers some leverage to strike abetter
bargain with whoever might do the actual dredging.
68 Create a 4 01 c3 foundation for the waterway. Ask the U S Army Corps of Engineers to make public 5/17/2019 12:44 PM
their plan and specs for fixing the waterway. Ask private environmental engineering and
construction companies to complete the project (tax deductible) with the USAGE lending any
necessary equipments if these companies don't already have them..
........... .......... ...... ............ .........
.......
69 G reat 5/17/2019 10:53 AM
73
Eliminate the commercial component to this goal. Keep the river a environmental protected zone.
5/17/2019
9:21
ANI
Walking paths ok,M no motorized vehicles.
74
.......... ....................................................... ........... ...... �-: ......... .. ....... ...... . . ...... .. . ... ...............
I support this objective
5/17/2019
9:20
.......
AM
75
............................................ .... . ..... . ....... . .. . . ... . . . ... ........... . ..... ........................ . ... . ..... . .... . . . .... . ... .... ... ... .... . ... .... ......... ............................... ... . .. ............................. . .. .. .... . ......... .... ................................. .... I ..........
Sounds good
..................
5/17/2019
..... .................. .................
.........
: ................... : ......
9: 19 AM
76
....... ...... .. . ......... ......................... ................. . .. .... ...... .......... ......... ......... ........... .........
This all seems vitally importsnt! The river is a vital treasure, in combination with our preserved
......... ..............
5/17/2019
............. : ...... ... . ....
.......... : ........
9:Q9
........ . . . .......... ......... .... ..................... ...... .. .. ...
AM
downtown and thriving restaurants, etc. - if we can increase'access and make it a welcoming
destination., include educational signage on the life in and around tidal sloughs/rivers.
77
.. ... ........... .. ..... .... . ........ ....... ........ .................... .. .
The Army corp of Engineers owns this 100%. so lets not spends - too much time on it. No more bike
5/17/2019
9:08
AM
paths till you fix the roads we all paid for already.
78
............ .. ... ..... ....
This is a key one! What is a River Town with no river?
5/17/2019
9:04
AM
79
. . .. .. ...... . ..... .
The dredging of the river is unlikely to occur in the near future. The river is actually a tidal slough.
5/17/2019
8:07
AM
That is how it should be viewed. It is adjunct to the wetlands, which are actually the most important
resource now and likely in the future.
........................................... ................ ..............
80
...... ................. .......... . . . . . ....... ....... . ... ........... : .... ..... ......... ........... .... ..... ... ..... ..... ... ...... ... .. . . . ... .... ........ .. ....... ........ . ...... . ... ..... . . . ... .
Jeff Mayne has a solution for dredging.
5/16/2019
7:41
PM
......... ........................................... .......... .... ...........
81
.... ..... ..... .. .. .... ... . ... . ........ ......... .................. ..... ... .. . .. .. ... ...
Good'.
5/16/2019
6:47
PM
.. .. ...................... .... ......... .... ......... ...............
82
........... ......
...
Wondering how you create spaces that we do not have.
........... ........... .. . .... ........ �.: ..................................... ................... ... .... .................. ........................ ......................... I . .. .... : ...... ... . I ......
5/16/2
.. .. . . .. ... ................
019
. ....
5: 11
P M
�.:
83
YOU WILL NEVER GET THE MONEY FOR THE RIVER
5/16/2019
5:02
PM
M
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
85 Have a shovel ready set of projects for the federal infrastructure plan
86 Perfect - yes!
87 How are we supposed to navigate D St, with the bridge aoina up/down more often, bus stop, fire
88
89
90
91
station, proposed high density housing, etc,? It is already dangerous and like an obstacle course!
Attachment 3
5/16/2019 3:17 PM
5/16/2019 2:23 PM
5/1 6/201 9 1:29 PM
Yep
5/16/2019
1.09
PM
Yes to all of the above.
5/16/2019
1:07
PM
In Marin county they are dredging the river to use the material to raise the leveys. They will use a
5/16/2019
1:07
PM
crane and drag chain to pull material from the channel and place it on the levies. Why can't that
Oh come on. Dredge the Petaluma River using money from taxpayers who will not benefit. Again
5/16/2019
10:26 AM
process be used for most of our river?
. . . . .......
$- this is making the General Fund in to a cookie jar.
Encourage a thriving business environment. Lets move forward on attracting businesses to the
5/16/2019
12:24
PM
airport and actively market the airport to businesses that seek alternatives to San Francisco and
Santa Rosa. Businesses travel in business aircraft.
92 Love it. Anvthina to do with r)romotina safe places for animals and cleaning up the environment is 5/16/2 019 1 1: 2 6 AM
much onus on a developer to figure out the solution, potentially harming good projects from
11
4/4 Input Summary 2 -Page 134 of 185
happening.
96
I like that you have this. Dislike that it has been talked about so long that the city is nearly
5/16/2019
10::46 AM
inaccessible by boat..
97
Oh come on. Dredge the Petaluma River using money from taxpayers who will not benefit. Again
5/16/2019
10:26 AM
$- this is making the General Fund in to a cookie jar.
98
So important to this city. Dredge the river and fix the docks downtown. They are a blight right now
5/16/2019
80017 AM
99
Our turning Basin must be dredged.
5/15/2019
3-4:37 PM
11
4/4 Input Summary 2 -Page 134 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q36 What do you like about these work plan items? Or, what are we
miingiss?
Answered: 61 Skipped: 214
RESPONSES
1 (2) Explore more sustainable and viable options for dredging spoils.
. ........... . ... ... ..
2 A river walkway/bike path would be great!
DATE
6/16/2019 4:04 PM
6/14/2019 6:26 PM
3 I like that these work plan
items
are appropriate
and would be effective if
implemented. They 6/14/2019 2:12 PM
improve the quality of life
for all
Petalumans and
visitors. They should be
the highest priority for the
5
Avoid development of the.river
shoreline, including paved pathways; plan for 6'of sea -level rise
6/13/2019 3:08 PM
16
along the river channel and maintain appropriate buffers.
6/5/2019
5:23
6
See above.
encouraged development to compromise river access and the trails that should be following the
6/11/2019
. . ........... .. .... ..
8:04 PM
7
Keep the river dredged to help
with flooding, too.
....... .... .............. ..................... . . ... ......... .... . . .......
6/6/2019
......... . ............. ................. ...... . ........................ .
4:58 PM
8
. .. .. .. . ... ............ . .... ...... I ..... ...................... ................................ ...
Love that we're fixing what we
. .....................
already have!
. ............................
6/6/2019
2:06 PM
. . . . ......... .. .
9
.......... ................ ..............
Rehabilitate the trestle.
.... .......... . ........... ....... ........................................ . ..... ... ... ...... ...... ........ .... ..... .. . .. ...... .. .. ..... . . ... ... ........
6/6/2019
1:53 PM
................ ................................... .......
10
..... .. . . ... . ..................................................... : ......... ............. ..... : ..................................................
Nothing
. ..... .... ....................................... .................................................... ......... .. ... .... . . .... .................. ............ .. .............. .................. ... . .... ........... . ...... ..... ..... ... ........................ ............. ............................... ...... ................... ... .
..... .. .. ... ......... ..
6/6/2019
12:28 PM
.. .......... ......... .. -, ... .... . . ..... ... ..
....... ...... ............................ .. . ..............................................................11 see 35
.............. ..... ............. ......................... ............ .......................... .................. .......... ......... .. ....... ....... . ... .......... . ........... . .. ......
# 3 is the important link for a healthy community. I don't support motor boats north of the D street
6/6/2019
....... .. .
11:35 AM
.. ..... ...... . .......... ... ....... .
12
. . .... ... ... ....... ..... . . ..... .... . ... .. .. . . .. . .... .......... ...................... ...... ... .....................
Let's get people on the river in
........ . ....... . .......... .. . . . . ... ... . .......... .. . ..... ........ .......... .... ............... . . ..
people -powered boats.
.. ... ... .. .................................. .................................... .........
6/5/2019
...... .......................................... ................ ....
10-0,30 PM
... .. . . . . ... ..... . . .... ..... .. ... ... ..
13
....................... ........ . ............... ....... ................................................................. ..... .. ............ ... ............... ........ ................ ............................. .................... ........ ....... . ................................................ ........ . ... .... .. ..... . . .. .. . . . .... ... . . . ... ... ...... . .... . ... ...... . .. ... I . ......... ... .. ...................... ............ ....... ............. ............ ......... .. ........................... ....................................... .... ......... . ... .. .. ......... .... ...................................
I love theldea of developing more biking and pedestrian paths along the river,,
............................ ......... I ................................ . ... ... .... .
6/5/2019
... . ...... I ............... .. ....... .. ..
10:22 PM
... ........... ..... .... .... . I ... .... .. .... ...... ....
14
. .. . . . . ... ... .... ..... ... ... ... . . .. .. . ..... . .... ... ... .. ...... ...
Like them
. . ... . . . . .. ..... . .... .. ..... .. ... .... .. . .. . . ... ...... ... .. .. .. .. .
............... . ........... .......
6/5/2019
I ...... . . I ...... . I.: ...... .... ... I ...... .......... ... . . .. ...... ... . ....... ...... .. .... ....... .. ..
8:25 PM
. . . . .... ......... ... . ...... .. ....
15
..... ........... . ......... .. ..
We ABSOLUTELY need bike/r)ed..... . trails along o..... ..ur beautiful river. Lynch Creek is barely scratching
6/5/2019
. ... ... .. .. ................ _: ......
7:11 PM
the surface of our beautiful waterways. Missed: Public transportation! Completely missed not just
here but seemingly throughout all the plans so far. Dredging the riverinto schollenberger is a
terrible idea. You will utterly destroy one of Petaluma's last remaining natural habitats that can be
enjoyed by the public. PLEASE DO NOT EVEN CONSIDER THIS
..... . . ......... .. :..: ... .......... ........ : ..... .......... . . ..... -1 ...... .. ....... .... .... ...... .... .... . . ....... ....... ..... . ............... ....... .....
. .. . . .......
16
1 agree with all of them. Some City Council members have not upheld the visions and have
6/5/2019
5:23
PM
encouraged development to compromise river access and the trails that should be following the
banks. River front development should actually provide river access to their residents. Mentioned
previously, but the Trestle is integral to the river in so many ways.
17
. .. ......................... ...... : .. ..... .... . ..... . . ........ ........ ...: ................. ............ . .......... .................. I .. ......... ....................... ........ ... ......... .... .... . ................ ....... .. .................... ... ..... ...... . ....... ....... . ..................... . .. ............ ....................
Agree on all.
....... .
6/5/2019
3:06
PM
18
..... .......... : ......... .. . .. I .......................... ..................... ... ...... ..... ....... ........... .. ... ..... ....... .. ..... . .... .. . . .. ...... ..... .. .. ... .... .. . . . . ... .. ... ... .. . . . . ..... I . ...... ................... ... ... : .......
1 'and 2 are important for coming climate disasters.
.... ...
6/4/2019
.......
8:50
PM
19
.............. ..... ............. ......................... ............ .......................... .................. .......... ......... .. ....... ....... . ... .......... . ........... . .. ......
# 3 is the important link for a healthy community. I don't support motor boats north of the D street
6/3/2019
. ..
7: 18
...
PM
Bridge. Raising the D street bridge is bad for traffic and climate change.
20
. . ...... ........ .. ........... . . ...... .....................................
all of them
6/3/2019
......
4:52
".., .. .....
PM
21
...... .. . ...... .... .... . " ............... ....... . ...... I ........... .. ...... .......... ..
nothing to add at this time
... . .... . I ...................................
5/31/2019
I ...... . . ...
6:55 PM
..... . . .. ... . . ... .......... I .... . .. . ........... ... . ....... . . ..... ... ... .......
23 Love all of it 5/29/2019 9:32 PM
. ...................................................... .. ... ........................... ...... ........................ . ... ..... .... ............. ... .. .. ... ...... ....................... I ........ ........................... ...................... ... ........... ... ............. . .. .. .. ..... . ......... ............... . ..... .............................. : .. .. ..... .......... .. ....... . ... ... ............ . ...... ...... ............. ........
24 Connect the bike paths to a full network of bike infrastructure. 5/29/2019 4:31 PM
. ..... ........................................ ................ ... .. .. .... . .. ....... ..... . ... . . ... .... . . . . .......... ............................ .... .. ................................. . .............. ......... . .... .. ..... . ....... ......... . .... .. .................... ..... ............................ .......................... ............. . ... .. ....... ......... ..... ........ ....... ... ... ...... .... ... .. _ .................... ............................ ........ ................ ..... . ........... . .. .. . . . ....... ...... ... .... . .. ... . .... .......... .......................... ............................... ............................... ....................
25 X 4 5/29/2019 7:25 AM
.. .... ........ .. . ... ......... . .................... ..... ............ ....... .. .. .. .... ......... ...... .......... .......... ...... ............... . .. .... .. .... . ... ..... . ... .. .
26 ditto 5/28/2019 1:27 PM
1
/3 nput Summary 2 - Page 135 of 185
fr.
. ..... ........ . . .. . ... . . . .. ..
27
28
29 Missing: Need to add Marina and Turning Basin docks to be rebuilt for safety and ADA
requirements'.
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
know nothing about a dredaina disr)osal site. Mv hone is that whatever is considered is done so
with environmental protection or used the materials as a way to decrease erosion to land along the
waterway,,
5/28/2019 10:55 AM
5/23/2019 3;07 PM
. ......................... ...... .
5/23/2019 1:10 PM
35
36
banks,
. ...........
Dredging for commercial use is a waste of tax payer money. The turning basin is only needed to 5/20/2019 1: 18 PM
be dredges so wealthy yacht owners can sail into town.... not a priority for residents.
YES on bike trails. Not in favor of using City funds to dredge the marina. 5/20/2019 9:57 AM
It's interesting that the city included this, but only reluctantly approved the Adobe Winery space on 5/20/2019 9:50 AM
the river. The city needs to have a big vision & not get caught up in small details that won't have
much impactin the.long run, e.g. trail to no where.
.. .... .... .... . ..
37 all good 5/19/2019 7:39 PM
.. . . .......
38 I would add support in whateverway is possible to the Floathouse and rental boats so that folks 5/19/2019 2:34 PM
can use the river more easily. Dredging the river is a good first step, but people also need a way to
do more than just look at the river. Also need to improve the operational aspects f the city docks.
Once the turning basic is navigable, we should establish fixed bridge opening times (coordinated
with the- SMART trestle does south) and limited reserved opening times (to simplify bridge
operations, make openings more reliably available to boaters, and to minimize the impact on
traffic. Recommend consulting with PICYA or other local yachting organizations to define
schedules, since these are fairly predictable (for example few boaters ever arrive in the AM,
because getting here takes several hours from anywhere else, but boats often leave here between
10 and noon, especially on Sundays)
39 We need to accomplish all of these work plan items and we need to do them together. 5/18/2019 3:35 PM
........... ......... . ... .. .... .. . ....... . I ... . . .. ... . . . .. ........... .
40 Move this to the top. 5/18/2019 11:59 AM
. .........
..
41 Petaluma River makes our town what it is! 5/18/2019 6:45 AM
. ..... . . .. . . . . .. ......... ....
. .... .....
42% Redundant 5/17/2019 7:25 PM
.... ... .. ... . .. ..... ...
43 If we don't dredge, we won't have a river. Isn'tit obvious? I support any bike paths and bicycle 5/17/2019 5:36 PM
infrastructure. Currently we are not very bike -friendly, and we are very car unfriendly with all the
pot holes.
44 Horrible idea to dump the river dredged residue at Schollenberger! Please don't do that! 5/17/2019 5:11 PM
45 Create a 401 c3 foundation for the waterway. Ask the US Army Corps of Engineers to make public 5/17/2019 12:44 PM
their plan and specs for fixing the waterway. Ask private environmental engineering and
construction companies to complete the project (tax deductible) with the USACE lending any
necessary equipments if these companies don't already have them,
46 possible transportation/ ferry out of Petaluma to reduce traffic? Love the idea of bike paths and 5/17/2019 12:36 PM
recreation along the river
47 Awesome 5/17/2019 10:53 AM
..................... . .... . . .. . .. ....
48 No further comments. 5/77/2019 10:47 AM
49 Love it a lot 5/77/2019 10:07 AM'
. ................ .......
50 Dredge yes -protect our river from commercial businesses and motorized equipment of all kinds 5/77/2019 9:21 AM
.. ..... ........ . .. ... .. . . .... . . ..... ... . .. ....... . .. ................... ..................... .. ... .. ....
51 I think the trestle should be highlighted as potential amenity. 5/77/2019 9:20 AM
2/3 Input Summary 2 - Page 136 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
52 The harbor needs to be dredged and the railway/deck restored. These would be a huge boon to 5/17/2019 9: 19 AM
Petaluma. Restaurants could have river seating, small entertainment could be located there (3
piece band), sidewalk cart vendors during downtown events, etc. The area could be utilized to a
much greater extent. No, no, no on dumping the dredge at shollenberger. Has that been approved
with an environmentally? Native and location appropriate trees should be planted at shollenberger.
....... ... . .. ..... . ... ...... ...: ....... 1: ... .. ............. . . .. . . . . . . . . .. .... ......... ........ ............ ........ ............................... ..... .
53 There is way too much impact to McNear Peninsula. The Friends of the Petaluma River has been 5/17/2019 8:07 AM
allowed to hold a "revival" and negatively impact the peninsula and the natural resources that used
to exist there are now gone. There should never have been plans for a dock there - the float house
planned by the boating community is what is appropriate and that is where any boating activity
should be%focused, I think perhaps the City should offer to give back all open space funds that
were provided for acquiring and conserving the McNear Peninsula and "Steamer Landing" Park -
because the birds, wildlife and habitat areas are miniscule and just surface presentations - what
was once a quiet grassland habitat area with thriving birds and wildlife, which was actually the best
natural
attraction that could
have
existed, been
protected
and enhanced,
is completely gone - the
human
impact and the way
this is
approached
in the City
is with very low
consciousness and little
n
3/3
i
Input Summary,2 - :'age 137 of 185
iIPbwit srrx�On
0
rl
o
%
iIPbwit srrx�On
0
rl
� M I "Mj
e;77p') "�7,9
wu
ND
It
11
u
(00%1 '4' V
do*
M 4oMWkr A~ dP"16 04 el 0 1". -C 01 () ru
%
� M I "Mj
e;77p') "�7,9
wu
ND
It
11
u
(00%1 '4' V
do*
M 4oMWkr A~ dP"16 04 el 0 1". -C 01 () ru
Q11 / Q12 Create inviting natural andU11
t places and:. spaces for contemplation,
p ay, arts, and connection whine celebrating our,history and encouraging
community pride,,
:( ,1) 11 -- f)��jec�:ive .� -� Fnvisrc�n �nct criect�� ca scrl`e �-l��vnto �nir� f�h;rf is a�%rr�ctive, clet7vi, c-tr)d ca:nbeleiijOye:! Icy a//
0
Q14
Wlorkplan
o
I
o
i � ;• .. .: .. a ..� '.. .., ,. ..' ��. .: .� ..
3. Fund and support a Downtown Streets Team,.
review a cce
11
dentif i led needs.
a ON
ss']'blity to public restroom
:ev op ana impierne.
Pet�aluma Downtown
IS in It
he; d or wIntown area and dleoL-1 a an to
It a Downtown maintenance and,beau
41'ssociation,11
tification an i,n partners
p
G
Input Summary z" e 139 of 185
7
E
1:1
Em
I
I
I
M
46,
A
:mln
2 F 4 0 bpoNut 6u mary age "i
L�
L�
I
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q1 2 What do you like about tris goa ? Or, what are we missing ?
Answered: 129
# RESPONSES
Skipped: 146
DATE
1 Wouldn't want this to prevent other things, planting trees, for instance, to get stopped because of 6/14/2019 6:55 PM
" new" program.
............. ....
2 public restroom need is addressed 6/14/2Q19 6:16 PM
3 This seems like a frivolous goal. We have higher priorities for our limited taxpayer- provided 6/14/2Q19 1:45 PM
budget..
4 What exactlyis a "Downtown Streets Team? The PDA already is supposed to have beautification 6/13/2019 8:58 PM
addressed. What do they do with their monies?
........
5 We don't need more build ing/infrastructure. This goal will never happen if you continue to throw 6/13/2019 6:06 PM
away funds by "helping" the homeless. Everything currently done makes it easy for them to
continue to abuse drugs and alcohol and live on the streets and make downtown look bad
.. . . . .... ....... . .. . .. ..... .... . .... .. . .... ..... . .... ..
6 Avoid projects that lead to gentrification of downtown 6/13/2019 2:48 PM
.. . . .. ... .... ....
7 Overall they are good objectives, but I'm not sure what a "Downtown Streets Team" is or if it's 6/11/2019 7:44 PM
needed. Just keep the Contemporary Public Art out of our Historic Downtown lest it no longer
becomes a Destination.
8 We definitely need more public bathrooms and garbages thoughout the city. More Doggie garbage 6/7/2019 119,56 PM
stations..
9
make more assessable to local residents
6/6/2019 8:11 PM
10
...... ...... ..... ...... . .. .... ....... .. .. ...... ...... . . ........... . ... . . ... I . .... ................................ ............................ ...... .. . ... .. .... .... . ........ . ......... .... . .......................................
Shut down problematic bars
..... ......................
6/6/2019 6:08 PM
........... . ..........
11
.................... ... .... ........... -, ...... I ... .. . I .......... .. . ....... .......................... ........ ...... ...... ...... . . ....... ........................
This is an excellent goal, but missing a critical objective. Add Objective #6-. Preserve and protect
... ........... ... ... .. . .......... . .. .... . . ..
6/6/2019 5:21 PM
Petaluma's significant historic resources and character defining features. Include the following.
workplan items: 1. Landmark designation for the historic tracks and trestle (immediate action
needed to halt further unchecked destruction of these important resources) 2. Rehabilitate the
JP historic Trestle (this is buried elsewhere, more appropriate here) 3. Streamline the planning
process to encourage people to actually apply for permits and do the right thing 4. Conduct a
citywide inventory of historic resources.. 5. Acquire "Certified Local Government 11 status (this has
been in process for years) 6. Consider designating the "Rivertront Warehouse local historic district'
7. Take advantage of opportunities that encourage preservation and adaptive re -use of historic
structures (Mills act, Tax Credits, State Historic Building Code, Downtown Facade Improvement
program) 8. Establish funding mechanism for maintaining historic features in public spaces
... ........................... ... ...................................................
12
.......... .................. ..... ... ... . .
More Public restrooms and parking! When volunteers help with Public events and have to park 5
.................... ....................
6/6/2019 4:35 PM
blocks away and most are older and may not be able to physically walk that far.
.... .... ..... .................... . ..... .... ........... ........ ..
13
I like the overall idea of the goal. It's a good thing to do for our downtown.
6/6/2019 1:45 PM
.. ........... ......... ...... .....
14
Keeping the streets and sidewalks clean is important to me.
.. ..... .. ..... ..... ............................................................... ..... .. ...... .. . ... .......... ...
6/6/2019 1:00 PM
... . .........
15
. ....... ... ........ .........
........ ... . .. ...... . .. ... . .. . .. . . ... . .. . . ... . . ... . .. . .. . . . ... .... .. . .. . ...... ...... . ... .... .. . . .......... .... .......... ... ..... .. . ... .... .. .... . ................. ...... ... . ...... .. .... .. . . .. . .. . .. . ........ .... .............. . . .
Yes interactive art! Fix the gross promenade. Add a carousel.
...... ...... ........................... .......... .. .... . ... . .. . ... .. .... ..... . . .. .. .... ..
.. ... .....
6/6/2019 12-0,22 PM
... ....... ... .. ....... . .......
:,: ..............
16
................ 1`-'1',--,--,:
Dredging of the turning basin has been put off for years, now causing the downtown area to lose
:
6/6/2019 12:17 PM
hundreds of thousands of dollars annually since the boating public can no longer bring their boats
into the turning basin
17
.............. .. I ........... ..... ....... . .................... ...... .... ............ .......... .. .......... I .. . ... . ...... . .. ..... ..... ... .. ..... . .... . .. . . . ... .. .... .. . ....... .. .... .. .
No bathtubs....that is not beautification, a waste of funds
6/6/2019 12:06 PM
18
... .......... . . .. . ... ... . ... ........ . . ..... ... . .. ..... ... .. . . ........ ................ . .................................................. ....................... ........ .......... ............................................................................ .- ......... .................... ............................ ............... ..... ............................ ... ......... .......... .. . . . ..
You are missing the commitment to save the fairgrounds. What good is a street team in an over
. . .... .. ... .. . . .. . ........ ... ... . . ... ....... ... ... .... ......... . ...
6/6/2019 10:42 AM
crowded track housing complex when the kids can currently enjoy the library and walk to the
fairgrounds for special events
............ ............................. ...... .. .. .... ............ .. ........... ....... ......... .. ........ ........ ...... .. ... .. ... .... .. . . . .. .. . . ..... . ......... ..... : .... ...... :.-- .................. ........
............. : .. ............................ ............. ....... .. .....
1 /6
Input Summary 2 - Page 141 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT DUALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
19 Frankly 1 think Petaluma makes way too much of its supposed "Historic Downtown". While thereis 6/5/2019 6:37 PM
a strong character in some o
preserved, and
understand
f the historic areas of the downtown, and this absolutely needs to be
this to be the motivation behind this "goal", a lot of the attention and
action in this area has been completely wrongheaded in the past and we are frankly wasting
important resources. Case in point; in the not so distant past, repaving certain downtown streets
with cobblestones to capture some false sense of character? All the cobblestones do is make
cycling and walking downtown more hazardous and unpleasant. If you want to help Petaluma
enjoy and embrace its downtown more, make it
could easily sell me on this item a lot more
easier to do so without cars. Plain and simple. You
if you make it sound less like it'
21 Very positive; work plan items seem doable.
22 I like these objectives. They are among the highest priorities for
s about turning my town
6/5/2019 3:35 PM
6/5/2019 2:31 PM
me and they seem doable. Not
sure what a streets team is though..
23 "Create" means money.,, I suggest modifying and modulating what already exists, through traffic
patterns, walking patterns, events, etc. History and community pride - it'll happen organically, so
don't expend additional resources on these.
24 Paying attention to the built environment, whether parks, buildings, trees for shade, -parklets with
resting places, wide walkable sidewalks, etc., makes all the difference between and ugly or
6/5/2019 8:23 AM
6/4/2019 8:31 PM
6/3/2019 11:10 PM
beautiful city.
. ........ .. . . ......... .. .. . .... . ....... .. . .
25 I love the idea of giving support directly to the downtown! 6/3/2019 8;14 PM
.... ........... . ....... ......................... . ...... . ..
. ... . .. . .. . ...... ......
26 our community is divided. Maybe it it time for district elections. 6/3/2019 6:53 PM
27'how to fund... _ 6/3/2019 4:51 PM
28 At least it mentions input from businesses 6/3/2019 101:50 AM
29 Fund a street team to pressure wash the urine debris etc away from downtown. Visited other cities 6/3/2019 6,911 AM
and you can find gum on the ground and it was so inviting and created a lasting impression. Fund
a fulltime alcohol enforcement position to address -alcohol issues with establishments downtown
they create or play a part in most downtown related issues with exception of homelessness which-
goes
back to homeless cop requests. Consider a pedestrian bridge over PBN to assist with traffic
improve safety in downtown area. Examples are Scottsdale at ASU. Could be options around
Leghorn Park as well or Lagunitas to keep pedestrians/drunks from crossing SMP or McDowell
and playing frogger.
30 Do NOT allow the Tubs (fine balance) and Stilts to be installed into our small riverside promenade 6/2/2019 1,1:29 PM
(Water Street) downtown in the midst of our Nationally Registered historic district.
31 Really! ! ? Downtown has THE LEAST NEED for help in Petaluma. Do not allocate more $ for this. 6/1/2019 10:22 AM
Stop justifying spending more $ for pensions. Stick to the assignment: "People are concerned
about future problems with (survey): Traffic 58.13% Growth 42.48% • Streets 37..,42% Crime
37.27%••
32 focusing on what our downtown is known for. On weekends it is known for the bars and drinking. 5/31/2019 6:47 PM
.. .. . . . ......
33 Love it. We pull in visitors and dollars because of our lovely, historical downtown. And not having 5/31/2019 10:47 AM
buildings 3 or more stories tall means there's light and openness.
................. ......... . . ....... ... ... ..... .. ..... .. .. . .. .
34 The downtown is a regional draw for tourism (and tax revenue). We need to enhance and preserve 5/31/2019 12:08 AM
its character and function.
. . .. .. ... .. ... ..
35 whereis the money coming from? Do not raise our taxes for this'. 5/30/2019 5:37 PM
36 desperately needed. the heart of the city needs investment from the entire population. 5/30/2019 5:23 PM
37 I'd like to see more about encouraging citizen/visitor use of downtown parks. If we are inviting 5/30/2019 3:35 PM
"contemplation...community pride" we must remind people of the spaces that support that.,
Workplace Item 1 talks about "upgrade/improve downtown .,spaces" but people need to know the
spaces are there... maybe better maps, more public meetings/events in the parks,, Since we will
soon have many more apartments right downtown these public spaces will be an essential part of
the residents sense of community
38 very little. The city council are elitists 5/30/2019 9;27 AM
.. . ...... .
2/6 Input Summary 2 - Page 142 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
.. ........ .. .......
39 Petaluma has a wonderful downtown,, except the new Petaluma BLVD four lanes to two lanes and 5/29/2019 9:26 PM
the fact that parking spaces were removed. You've made parking harder and that's not.,great,
however you do have two parking structures w/ free parking and that's awesome. I'd loe to see a
walking path. Petaluma lacks hiking/ walking. We have awonderful/ beautiful river, it would be
nice to have a proper meandering walking path/ bike path.
40 Public Art Downtown on Water street! 5/29/2019 11-9,31 AM
41 Focus on maintenance of downtown infrastructure and public restrooms 5/29/2019 8-0,58 AM
. . . . ... .... .... . .. . .. . ...... . .................................... . ................. ... .... ..... ........................... ............................ .................. .............. ..... . ...................... ......................... ............... ..................................
..
42 Great goal, work on rat abatement 5/29/2Q19 7:20 AM
... ....... . . . . .. . . . . . .......... ...... ...... ....... .. .........
.. .... . . .. . . ........... . .. I .... ... .. .. . . ....... .... . ............
43 Like the focus on arts 5/28/2019 7:3Q PM
44
.. ........... ............ ......... ...... : ....... ......... ..... ..
Missing how we are going to pay for this. Suggest look Co community volunteer financial support.
............ .. . .....
5/28/2Q19 5:06
PM
45
..... ...... . . I ........... ...... . . . ...
In Europe they have pay toilets; also as far as homeless go, how about clean campgrounds
5/28/2019 1:4,131
PM
... . ... .. ..... . .. .. .. ... ..
46
See last item!
5/28/2019 1:21
PM
47
...............
Low priority,, Needs lots of funds.
5/28/2019 12:56
PM
.. . ...... .. .. .... ..............................
48
..... ........ .......... ..... ................... .................. ............................................................ ................. ............................. .............. .............. . .. ...... ... .... ...................... . ...........
Please incorporate a plan that encourages businesses to create public spaces in alleys, roofs, or
5/28/2019 10:31
AM
River facing. Much like Napa downtown, the city has created dining and parks areas that
. .... .... .. ................. ........... ... . . ........ ......... ......... ........................... ...... ............. .. ............ .. .... . .... ................. ..... ......... ..................... .... ..... ..... .. ............. . .......... ............. ...... .... .............. .. . .. ................. ....
50 This goal only focuses on downtown and completely leaves out the east side of town. 5/27/2019 12:36 PM
............ ...... .. . . . . ... ........ ... .... . .... . .. . . . . . ... . ... ......... ... ... . . . ..
. .................. ........ . . .. .... . . .. . .... . ..... .......... ...... ....... ..... ......... . . ...... .... ................... ........ ................. ............. ... .................. ............................ .................................. ................... .. . .... ..
51 Focuses on one of the strengths of our city 5/26/20'19 2:00 PM
......... ..... ............... ............... ... ..... I .. . . ........ .. ..... . . . ... . . ..... . .. .... .. . . .. .. . .. .. ... .. . . ...... ... .. ... .... ...... ..... . . . . . . ... . ..... . . . . ..... . . . . .... . .. .. ...... . ....... .. .. .. . . ....... ...... . . .......
52 More artinstallations that truly reflect Petaluma. Dowtown bathroom are definitely needed. More 5/25/2019 9:59 AM
parking'.
...... ................... .... ..... ........................
... ............ ... ..... .................... .. . ... ... ....... . ... ..... . .
53 downtown needs security cameras. specially on Kentucky street,, safety is of the utmost 5/25/2019 6:052 AM
importance and CCTV should be looked into.
..... ................. ...... .... ... .... I--, .................... ......... ...... — . ........... .. .. . .. I ............... .. ........ ..... .................................................... ................ ................... .. . ..... ..... ..... ............................ ........... .... ..................... ....................... ......... . ... ... ..
54 Again, nix the bathtubs on water street. Get rid of the cobblestones too,. They hinder pedestrians 5/23/2019 2:55 PM
and are a public safety issue. No one likes driving over them either.
.......... ..... ... ................... I .......... .. ....... ... ..... ... .............. I ... ........................... .... ......... ...................... ................... ....... ..... . ... . ......................................................... ............ . ... ..... .................... . .................................................................. ................ ........... .. . .. . . ....... ................. ......
55 Downtown and the city as a whole looks rundown'.. I understand the need to conserve water, but 5/23/2019 8:49 AM.
now we have dead grass and plants everywhere. If we are not going to water city landscapes then
replace it with things that don't require a lot of watering.
........... ...... . . ... : ............ .................. ... : ... . ....... ........ : ......... . : ...................... ...................... : ....... : .................. ..... . ... .................... ....... ................ ....
56 Item 3?? Not sure what this is all about? 5/22/2019 6:55 PM
..... ........ . . ... . . .. ... ......... .. . .. ........ 1:—.1 ......... ......... ... ...... ..
57 Petaluma Downtown Association is defunct and ineffective. We paid them for years and have zero 5/22/2019 5:42 PM
idea what they do. We don't need to "fund" a Downtown Street Team unless that is law
enforcement, in which case, yes please! Government "finding balance" in the businesses is a
slippery slope., However, a limit on the smoke shops and their locations is important to review.
............. .. ........ ............ : .............. ..................................... . .... ............................... ... : .............................. .... .................................. ........................ .... ..... .................... ... ..........
58 I think there needs to be a review, especially regarding public perception, of art displays. A . a la, the 5/22/2019 3:46 PM
bathtub project....
..... . .. . .... .... . ..... . ...... ... e.e .. . . ..... e .. ...... ..
... .
... ....
. .....
. .
.................... .
.... ......... .........
......
59 I like that the inclusion of 'celebrating our historV is kept in mind. 5/21/2019 6:50 PM
... ... :1 .......... ... .................................... .. . ................ ......... .................. .. .... . .. .. .. . .. ... ..... ..... .. ... ..... . . ......... ..... .. ....... . ..... ... ..... . . ... .. ... .. ........... .......... ..................................................... .............. ....................... ........................................ . ....................... . ... .... ....
60 It's important for the city to look good in general:. We do need to balance that with budgetary needs 5/21/2019 5:39 PM
also though.
..... .......... .. ...... .. ::.� .... ..... �.: ........ ....... ... .... ................... ........... ................. ......... ............ ...... ................................... e ...... ............... .... e ............. .. ......
61 looks ok 5/21/2019 12:06 PM
3/6 Input Summary 2 - 'age 143 of 185
e
CITY COL7NCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
66 Allow a living vibrant
downtown
that
is safe, walkable and encourage merchants to
stay open later..
It is disappointing to
try and "go
out"
for a nice meal and restaurants are closing so
early. They
want increased revenue -try staying open later for many of us that are still working in our 60's plus;.
67 More parks, open outdoor areas.
Attaciment 3
5/20/2019 12:44 PM
68 The downtown could use more street trees and bike racks. There is never anywhere to lock your 5/20/2019 9:51 AM
hikes
4/6
Input Summary 2 - Page 144 of 185
69
I think the downtown already has done an excellent job of being vibrant. There is a lot of turnover
5/20/2019
9:37
AM
in businesses. Need to understand that and help them be successful for the long term.
70
Repair his Storico sites and houses. Stop gentrification
5/19/2019
8:48
PM
71
...... .. . . .... . . ... . .. ..........
this goal recognizes the need for keeping the welcoming spirit of Petaluma alive as we grow.
5/19/2019
7:24
PM
72
Missing the bathtub debacle. They are unsafe, unattractive and don't represent our town.
.........
5/19/2019
....
7:16
PM
73
This is completely focused on the west side and leaves out beautification programs for the rest of
5/19/2019
5:00
PM
Petaluma. What about the east side and central Petaluma?
74
A vibrant downtown is essential to the community.
5/19/2019
2-4,101
PM
75
Downtown needs to be the heart of Petaluma. We need a-atherina places of different kinds so
5/18/2019
6:46
PM
4/6
Input Summary 2 - Page 144 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attaciment 3
97 Downtown is a visual disaster and I'm surprised business would stay. There are signs, boards, 5/17/2019 8:58 AM
painted utility boxes, overgrown trees, dog crap, the odor of pet urine, homeless pan handlers and
window clutter everywhere. It looks ridiculous, it is FAR from charming, and frankly a deterrent to
rest often.
....... .. ... :.: . ..... ... . ...... .......
101 The entire natural resources existence, conservation and protection are missing - natural places 5/17/2019 7:47 AM
aren't created - they are identified and then managed for protecting natural resource' s, diversity of
resources, and conservation. This is completely absent from the awareness of the City
government, elected officials and most of the community. The fact there are 2 active
slaughterhouses in the City, a reality no one wants to even acknowledge, in concert with a
discussion about creating all of the beauty and natural places, is a conflicting reality. Anyone with
5 /6 n)ut Summary 2 - Page 145 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
118 There are other areas within the City that need attention, yet the focus is always downtown
119 Public restrooms should be a high priority, should not be left up to businesses to provide, This is a
problem across the US, we should learn from other countries.
120
5/16/2019
121
11:33
122
5/16/2019
123
11:36
Attachment 3
5/16/2019
5/16/2019
12:17
11:33
PM
5/16/2019
The beautification plan - so many options here: gardening, painting/art, clean-up, etc.
11:36
bars
AM
See my previous comments regarding " wishes" goals, and who wouldn't want these things.
5/16/2019
getting
11:33
There needs to be
AM
The beautification plan - so many options here: gardening, painting/art, clean-up, etc.
5/16/2019
bars
11:20
. .........
AM
I appreciate the idea of cleaning up downtown.
. ... ............ .... ............ ....... . .... . .
5/16/2019
percentage of development fees
10:57
AM
........ .......
middle land on Petaluma Blvd not functional. new rough stones are a bike hazard. more clearly
5/16/2019
The arts are important only to the extent they do not take from the essential.
10:56
AM
defined bike lanes
124 It seems like some
of the highest crime times are when bars are
getting
out.
There needs to be
more preventative
measures so that there is more accountability
for the
bars
and how they are
5/16/2019 10:43 AM
-3
6/6
nPut Summary 2 - Page 146 of 185
serving customers and increased police presence tointervene early on physical altercations.
125
Have you considered an art requirement, maybe you already have one? Could be based on a
5/16/2019
10:41 AM
percentage of development fees
126
The arts are important only to the extent they do not take from the essential.
5/16/2019
10:08 AM
127
Hoping that these teams would also be a learning experience for our community.
5/16/2019
10:03 AM
128
... ..... ..
............
Not sure what a downtown streets team is. Need more parking
5/16/2019
...... . .
8:11 AM-
129
The downtown is the heart of Petaluma and tourism, we should definitely take care of it.
5/15/2019
31:11 PM
-3
6/6
nPut Summary 2 - Page 146 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
bob'ective?missing?Q13 What do you like a out this ., Or, what are we
Answered: 81
# RESPONSES
0.
Skipped: 194
DATE
1
I think this is a reasonable objective.
6/14/2019
1:45
PM
2
Do it without building
6/13/2019
6:06
PM
3
. . ...... ...
attractive"- is a highly subjective term, maintain historical integrity, avoid gentrification.
.... .. ..... . ...................... .. .........
6/13/2019
21V48
PM
........... .. . ... ....
4
... ................. .. .. . .. ..
See Above
......
6/11/2019
7:44
PM
. ...... . . . . .. .......... . .. ... . ....... .. .. ... ....................... ........... ........ ..... ................................. ......... ..... ..... ......... ......... ..... . ...... ........ ... ...... . ... . : .......... ... .. . ". ... . .... ... . - .... .. - ... 11. - .. - . .. 1. . . . . . .. ... . . . . . . . .. . . ".. . ... . . . . . ... :,.,. .'- . ... . .... . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . .. .. .. . . .. ... .. . ... ... .. ... .. . . . .. ... .. .... . . .. . . . . . .. .
6 1 like the objective. I think it will be important to address how it is implemented, so as to avoid 6/6/2019 1:45 PM
another "bathtub on stilts" debacle with the community so obviously divided.
....................... ....... .......... .. ................ ..................... .......................... ...... ............................ ...... . .. . .. ...... .. ... . ....... . .............. . .. ..... ..... ... ........ . ... . ................. . .... ....... ... . .
PM
7 Fix the promenade and have more interactive art. 6/6/2019 12:22
...... ............... ....... .................. ........... .. ... ........ . ............ . .... . ...
8 Dredge the river. I believe Jeff Mayne's idea is a good possibility for funding and needs everyone's 6/6/2019 12:17- PM
support
....... ........ ................................... .... ...... . .. ....
9 1 like the community focus and promise of events and safety. You need to make a guarantee to not 6/6/2019 10'N'42 AM
develop the event space that this community has..
. ......................
10 All good, 6/5/2019 3:35 PM
..... ............................................. .. ..... . .... .... . ....... I-. - ......... ............ : ... .................... .. . ..... .. . .... ..... .....
I Can bring only positive outcome to the Downtown area. however, Petaluma has an East Side too,, 6/5/2019 2:31 PM
Why not promote ALL of Petaluma to the tourists and consumers,
.......... .1 ... ... ", ... ... ........ .... . I ....... ... I . .... ... ....... ...... . ...... . .............. : .. ...... . . .. .. . .....
12 See above
6/5/2019 8:423 AM
.... . . ....... ......... ..... ... ...... ..................... : .. ........... .... ... ........................................... ........ .. ........... . ... ............................................ : ....................................... ... ........ . ......... . : ... ... ...... ......... ............... ...... ............... ............. ..... . .... ......... . .. . ..........
13 Everything! Nothing! 6/4/2019 8:131 PM
.... . ..... . . . . . ... ..... . . .. ... . ... . . ... . ... . ...... .. . . .. . . .. . .. .. . . ..... ... ... .. .. ... .. .. ...... . . . . ... . ......... .... .. ..................... ........... . ....... . .. .......................... ..... . ........ ......................... .... .................... . ...... .................. ........................ . ........ ..... .. I ............. . ..... . ...... ...... .. ... ... . . ..... ... .. .. . .... . . ... . .. .. ... .. .. . . ... . ... ..... . . .. . .. ...... ...... ..... .. ........
14 The downtown association needs to hand out brooms to the merchants. This organizations 6/3/2019 6:53 PM
complains all the time.
.. .. ....... . . . . ...... . ... . .... .
... . ... .... .......... . .. . . ......... .. . .... ........ ............................. ....... .................. I .................. .. ... ...... .... .. ... . I ...................... .. .......... ....... : ...... .. . ... . ...... . . : .. ........ .... . .. .... .
...... .. ...
. .. ... . ..
..... ..... . .
. ... ... . . .. ... . .. - .1 . . .... .. . . .... ...
PM
19
It seems to be okay but I feel too many hands will cause too may problems.
5/30/2019
1:21
5:37
PM
20
. . ... ......... I . ..... .. .... . ..... ................. ..... ..... . ... ............................. I.." . . .. ....... .............. .......... ............. .. ....... .... . ............. . . ... ... . . . .. ........ .. ... .. ... .. ... .. ..... ... .. . . ... .. . . .. . . . ...... ....
see above. Sorry I couldn't be more specific..,
............. ............... ...
5/30/2019
3:35
... ....... ...............
PM
21
.. ..... .. .. .. . ........... ........ ... . . . ......... . . . .... . ....................... .. .................. . ..... ....... .... ..... ........... .. ...... ....... ....... . ............. ....... ............................... . ..... .............. ...... .... ............ ....
Nothing.
. .......... . . .
5/30/2019
... .
9:27
AM
22
. ......... .. ..... . ...................... ..... ............................... . ..................... . . .... . ............ . .... .............................. .. .... . . ... I .. .... .. . . ..... . ..... .... .. .
Bike/ walk path that extends all through Petaluma and by the river.
5/29/2019
9:26
PM
. . ......
23
.. .. . .. ......... . .. ... 11.1 ... .. ..... . .. ....... :: .. ........................ ......................... ....... ....................................... ................................. ........................ : ...... ... ......... -..: ........ ................... ....... : . .......... ....... r .. .. .... .......... : .. .. ............... ........ .... .. ...
Only pertains to downtown, but is good for that scope.
............. ....
5/29/2019
..... .....
4:13
PM
24
.......... ....... ..... ..... .. ... ..... ......... . ...................................................................... .................... I ......... ......... ....... . . . . ..... ...... .... . .. . . .. . . .... ... ... .. . .... I ........ .......... . ...............
Make fixing the trestle a top priority as well, it as an eyesore. Have plans to turn more of the
5/29/2019
11:31 AM
downtovin to face the river.,
... . ...... . . ..... .. ......... .. ..... . . .. .. .
27
. ... ... .. . . .... .. .. .. .. . . .... .. . . .. . .... .. .. . .. .. . .... .. .... .. . .. .. .. . . ... .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . I . .. - .. . - - . - - . . . .. .. - .. . - . . - - . . . ... .. . . . .. .. ... . . . . .. ... . . .. . . . .. .. .. . . . . . . .. . . . .. . . . . .. .. . . . .. . . . . .. .. .. . . . . . .. .. . . .. . . . - . . . .. . .. . . .. . - .. ..
Same answer
... . .. .. .. .. . . . . .. .. . .... .. . . .. . . .. . .. .. . . ... . .. . .. . . .. . ... .. . .. .. .. ... .. . .. .. . . . . . . . .... . . .. . . . . .. . .. . ........ ... .. . .... .... .......... ..... - . . ..
5/28/2019
... .. . . .. .
1:31
. .. . .... - . . - -...
. ... ... . . .. ... . .. - .1 . . .... .. . . .... ...
PM
28
ditto
............. ...
5/28/2019
1:21
PM
1 / 4 Input Summary 2 -Page 147 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021 Attachment 3
31 More public restrooms: great idea! 5/23/2019 2:55 PM
......... . . . . .. .... . . .. .... . ......
32 Don't allow anymore bars in the downtown area. Instead encourage family friendly business where 5/23/2019 8:49 AM
parents cant bring their children.
35 Think about how walkable our city is and easy for tourists and citizens to get about. I would love to 5/21/2019 10:48 AM
see the core of downtown closed to traffic and more sidewalk eating. Build another big parking
facility and open the streets.
36 Downtown needs more public space (park/square) for people to meet and socialize.
37 It ignores the fact that we won't be a river town if we don't dredge the
river. The river is what sets
us apart from other towns on the 101. Better: "Create inviting natural and built places and spaces
for contemplation, play, arts, and connection while celebrating our history as a river town and
5/21/2019 8:49 AM
5/20/2019 4-11,05 PM
encouraging'community pride.,"
38 The objective is fine, subject to -the work plan comments below,, 5/20/2019 3:32 PM
... . ... ... ........ .. ..
39 Please consider creating a Parking Benefit District downtown and use the revenue to funnel back 5/20/2019 9:51 AM
into downtown amenities (sidewalk improvements, landscaping, parking garage cleaning, etc)
40 Local art needs more consensus than the bathtub project, which is ugly. 5/20/2019 9:37 AM
.. .......... .........
41 OK 5/19/2019 7:24 PM
... .... . ...... . ........
42 Missing the majority of Petalumans who don't live near downtown. 5/19/2019 5:00 PM
43 In terms of zoning, we need to address some of the overzealous fire department rulings that have 5/19/2019 2:01 PM
resulted in several popular venues being closed. It goes without saying that safety is critical, but it
is also possible to have a safe environment without asking for unreasonable changes, or having
rigid zoning that eliminates creative solutions to the space availability downtown,
... ... . ...... .
44 I like the maintenance objective - it is hazardous to walk downtown -- sidewalks are a mess. 5/18/2019 6:46 PM
. . ........ ..........
45 Public toilets. What is a Downtown Streets Team". You guys have to be more specific! 5/18/2019 5:22 PM
......
46 This objective recognizes the gross neglect of our downtown. 5/18/2019 3:08 PM
47 See my previous response. 5/18/2019 1129,43 AM
48 It is vital to the life and livability of the city. 5/17/2019 7;44 PM
49 #3 is an absolute top priority or all else will fail 5/17/2019 7:10 P M
50 It's not important to spend $ on the downtown. How about stop letting developers create housing 5/17/2019 5:12 PM
that most people here can't afford? How about stop with the additional hotels if you can't figure out
traffic and can't repair the streets. This doesn't give me much confidence in Petaluma city
government.,
51 Safe from vehicular danger. Limit vehicular use downtown. 5/1 7/201 9 4:26 PM
52 The drunks after bar closing. It would be nice if the retailers on Kentucky street didn't have to clean 5/17/2019 4:21 PM
up vomit from their doorways before opening
53 Nothing at all let PETALUMA change all the old people will be out of council soon and the senior 5/97/2019 211:53 PM
programs will be gone
54 sustainable, renewable, green and clean. 5/17/2019 12:28 PM
.... ..... . .. . ....... .
55 Residents select art installations by direct vote. Vote online only to save election costs but offer 5/17/2019 12:17 PM
voting, at libraries, at city buildings, etc.
2/4 Input Summary 2 - Page 148 of 185
0
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
56 Petaluma's downtown is obviously a aem and I know that this anal is downtown-f0rHs P. d but 5/1 7/9 (t 19 11 -43 AM
please let's not forget there's more to the city than downtown. I fear we have focused on how
special the downtown is to the detriment of the parts of the city that house most of its people. Also
connections to that downtown for the rest of us are important --being able to walk there safely and
securely instead of driving, and having points of interest along the way would go a long way
toward furthering a lot of city goals (inclusivity, reducing car travel, healthy and safe community)..
. ....... .. . .
.. ..... .............................
57 No Comment 5/17/2019 10:33 AM.
............. .......
58 small transit, SF used to have jitneys that ran up and down Mission St. public bikes- I understand 5/17/2019 10:01 AM
that is being looked into already. More focus on bike and pedestrian use.
........ . . ... ... . . . ....... . ...
59 Covers great needs. 5/17/2019 9:5 6 AM
60 The MOST deterring item is theinsane traffic downtown. the VAST majority of the traffic is caused 5/17/2019 8:58 AM
by the crosswalk near Starbucks. What genus though tthat having a unsignaled crosswalk in the
middle of downtown with traffic lights one block either direction was going to work? People just
walk on out into the crosswalk most doddering around with their phone some -just standing there
making every car stop while they saunter across the road. Thisis poor planning and literally
someone with zero traffic management experience making decisions based on what would be
3/4 Input Summary 2 - Page 149 of 185'
I
ti
0
4/4
0
t
Input Summary 2 -Page 150 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attachment 3
Q14 What do you like about these work plan -items?. Or, what are we
missing?
Answered: 81 Skipped: 194
# RESPONSES DATE
1 Add: Expand SMART Code to include properties along Petaluma Boulevard. Create a plan to 6/16/2019 410-04 PM
4 Integrate residential into downtown by rehabbing upper floor spaces; avoid 6/13/2019 2:48 PM
gentrificationP'modernization" of downtown; Stop permitting malls that gut downtown's economic
area v v
..... ......................... ............... : ... ............... ....... ............. ............ : ............... ... .................. I . .. . ........ . .............. ..... ......... ......
9 1 like the ideas. Again, my concern would be how they are implemented to honor who we are. I feel 6/6/2019 1:45 PM
as though long time multi generational residents are not being heard in favor of progress progress.
Take the bathtub on stilts project. Very divisive for our community. Those kinds of debates will be
nothing but counterproductive and a waste of time and money:,
10
.... .. .....................
foundation,
6/6/2019
... .. ...... ....... ...... ............................... ...
110,36 PM
................................ ............. .. ...............
................. ..........................................
5
.... .. .... ....... I., ............... .... ......... .... .. ...... . .. ... :,.--...... . . .... ........
See Above
6/11/2019
. ... .......... ....... ...
7:44 PM
6
. ... .. ...... .................... . . . ... ... .. .. .. .. .. . . . .. .
Bike Petaluma suggests to add this item: 1) Improve access to downtown areas 'Via alternative
6/6/2019
. . ..... ... ... ...
9:47 PM
.. .. .... . . . ......... : .... . .
13
modes of transportation to address congestion and parking saturation
. . . .......... :..-.
6/5/2019
.. . .... ...
10:13 PM
7
........... .......... ......... .... . . .... ...... . .... .... .. ... .. . ......... . . ..... .. . .. . . ... . . .... . . . .. . .......... ............. .. ....... .... ...... ................ .................... ..... ...... ........ . ...... . ......
Public input,
6/6/2019
. . . ..... .. ... ...: ........... .. . ... ..........
44:35 PM
8
. ... .. ..................... ..... . ... . ..... ..... .currently......
Don't for4et to include and sunnort the aaricultural businesses that exist in the downtown
6/6/2019
3:50 PM
area v v
..... ......................... ............... : ... ............... ....... ............. ............ : ............... ... .................. I . .. . ........ . .............. ..... ......... ......
9 1 like the ideas. Again, my concern would be how they are implemented to honor who we are. I feel 6/6/2019 1:45 PM
as though long time multi generational residents are not being heard in favor of progress progress.
Take the bathtub on stilts project. Very divisive for our community. Those kinds of debates will be
nothing but counterproductive and a waste of time and money:,
10
.... .. .....................
Create space for outdoor summer concerts.
. ................ . ............. ................................. . ..... ................. . ......................................... .......... ..... .............................................. . . ... ........ I .................................. ......................... ....... ..... ..... ................ .. .. .... .... . . . .... ....... .. . .. . . ..... ...... ..... ....... .................................... .......... .... ................. ............ . ......
6/6/2019
... .. ...... ....... ...... ............................... ...
110,36 PM
................................ ............. .. ...............
11
Fix promenade now.
I . ....
6/6/2019
......... ............... I .......... ..... .. .. .........
12:22 PM
. .. ..................................
12
... ............ .... . ............. . ....................................................................................... ................. ............... ........... .... . ......................... . .......................... ...................... .................................... . .... . . ............... ...... ... ...................................... . ....................................... ........ .................... ... .. .......... ..... ......... ................... .................................
see 13.
... ................ . ................ ....... ..................
6/6/2019
........ ................. ...... .........
10:42 AM
.. .. .... . . . ......... : .... . .
13
.. . .. .:... .. .:., __ - . "' '.-.'---:1,.,.-.,.,::, .. . .. ..,. . ..- ... . - :.,: ...... . . ..... ............ .......... . .. ...... . .... ....... .... .......... ...... ... ............ ...... .
Support buy local campaigns. Limit the construction of additional box stores.
. . . .......... :..-.
6/5/2019
.. . .... ...
10:13 PM
14
.. .. ... ...... . . .... ............................ . ...... . ........... . . e .......... ....... . . .. ........... .... ....... ............................. ............. ........ ....... ...... .. . .......... .. ... ...... . e .......... .. ...... .... ..... .. .... .. . . .
Item 3.. Funding a Downtown Streets Team. What does this entail? It sounds like a waste of money
6/5/201.9
...........
61:37 PM
to me, but if elaborated, it might make more sense. View from Bike Petaluma: Also, I think there
needs to be an 'Item somewhere here to promote more bike parking downtown. The current state
is pretty sad. We have no less than 3 free public car parking lots in the downtown area. Let's do
more to get more people on bikes already,,
15
.... . .... .. ............. ............. . ......... .... ............ .... ..... . .................... I . .. ... ... ......... . . .. .. . .... .... .... I ................. ........ ............................... ... ..... ............ ............................. ...... ..... ..... ........................ .... .............. I ........... I .. .................................................................. ...... . ..... . .. . . .... ........ . .. ............. ...... ...................................... .... . .. ........ ......... ... .............................. .. ......
Have a greater police presence to curb drunks especially on weekends nights. Have the
. . ...... . ... .. . ....
6/5/2019
3:35 PM
Downtown Assn do something to better support local businesses. Have shops keep the sidewalks
in front of their stores clean....with a broom. Use local restaurants to provide food during Butter and
Eggs instead of bringing in outside vendors. Have a retail store shop window competition during
..... .................. ............
the holidays. Get strong graphic way -finding signage and get rid of the sidewalk sandwich boards,
........ .............. .. .......... .... ... .................. ..... ................ ................. .......... ...... ........... ..... ... .. . . . . ... .. .............. ... ...... ........... ........... . ......... ........ . ... ..... . ... . .... ......... . . ........ ......... ... I ..... .. I ... .. ...... .. .... .
16
................. .........
This list is manageable.
.............
6/5/2019
. . ......... ........... ............ ..... ..... .....
2:31 PM
.... .. ...... .............. I ..........
17
..... ..... ... ... . .... ... . ...... .. .. . . .. .
We need some beautification efforts in other parts of the city too, including the north, south and
...........
6/5/2019
8:23 AM
east entrances to the city.
. ... ..
18
..... ... . ...... ... . .. ... . .... . .. .... . . . ...... . .... .... ...................................... ......... . . ............
An improved and safe downtown is great. Beautification sounds like more money than we have or
. .. .... .............. ... . .......................... ..... ..............
6/4/2019
.............. .. ....... . ..... .............. .............. .. ... .. .. .
8:31 PM
should be allocated
.. . . ... ...... . .... .......... . . ...
19
. .. ... . .. . . . . . . ................. .................. . .. .... . ..................... . ...... .......................... .. .............. ..........
A Downtown Streets Team is a great ideal. Accessibility of free restrooms for residents and visitors
. .................. ......... .................... .. .... ............................ .. ...................... . ..... . ................. ..................
6/3/2019 11:10 PM
alike is a necessity and not just inside businesses. Palo Alto's Town and Country Shopping Center
is a good model for having multiple, well maintained restrooms outside of the businesses.
20
..... . . . . ... . ... . ... .. ...... . . .... .. . .. ... .. ... ... .. . .. ... .
If we are talking about celebrating our history, we should see more collaboration with the Museum
... ... ..... .... . ........................ ......................... .
6/3/2019
.... ... . . ... . .. .. ... ..
8:14 PM
in this.
. ...... .... ... . . .. ... ..... .. ..... .... . .. .. ............ ..... . I ........ .. ........ ................................ ... . . .. ............
... ... .. . . ... ..... .. .
21
East West connection
.......... ...... ........ ................ ..... ................. ..-: ........ .................................... .... . ................ ....... -::-,� ........ : .......... ................... ...................... ............ ...... ........ ............ ....... .... ...... ...
6/3/2019
.......... : ... I ... 11 ....... I ..........
64--53 PM
........
1-/ 4 Input Summary 2 -Page 151 of 185
4
0
M
CITY COiJNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
22 Support the community cat colony that is thriving downtown. Connect with animal services
provider to help downtown businesses and patrons promote pet safety - rules about pets in cars,
pets in businesses, etc.
23
24
25
26
This is so clearly aself-focused vanity project for the City, Petaluma is much more than
Downtown; fix the traffic.
nothing to add at this time
Love it
Attachment 3
6/2/2019 96-23 AM
6/1/2019 10:22 AM
We need a small conference center or retreat center in or near downtown, to attract San Francisco 5/31/2019 12:08 AM
companies for their staff retreats.
open spaces/park areas in mind
34 same _ 5/28/2019 5:06 PM
.............
35 _ Same answer. 5/28/2019 1:31 PM
36 ditto 5/28/2019 1:21 PM
.. . . .... . . ....... .
37 Again, very vague. What is a "downtown streets team"? What kind of zoning changes are you 5/28/2019 12:24 PM
proposing? You already chased out adecades-old Petaluma business because you wouldn't allow
it to rent space that met the spirit of the zoning laws if not the exact wording (with ridiculous
distinctions). How many other local businesses are you willing to lose? Is all the zoning going to
favor chains and other large businesses who have dozens of options in this high -rent town?
....... . ...
38 Dredge the river. 5/23/2019 2:55 PM
39 Do not like #3. All streets need attention and have been hampered by differed maintenance and 5/23/2019 12:49 PM
low personnel numbers..
40 More park benches 5/21/2019 8:02 PM
..... ..... ... .
4 1 If these work plan items can be implemented our city would be much better, A Destination City. 5/21/2019 6:50 PM
.. .........
42 more natural parks away from busy streets 5/21/2019 12:06 PM
.... .... . .
43 Doesn't address the traffic problems. Especially the situation on D Street/East D Street. With new 5/21/2019 11:24 AM
housing planned for that area and a tasting room going it, the traffic problem will be magnified
beyond the current inacceptable level. The lights on D Street are not timed well and it's a problem
for pedestrians as well as cars.
... .. .....
44 The city needs more 'meeting' space (park/square) downtown. The old tracks by the river currently 5/21/2019 8:49 AM
fenced off are an abomination. That area. could easily fill that void. They should be removed or
renovated.
. ..........
45 I generally like the concept, but am uncomfortable with the focus on our one " downtown". For 5/20/2019 3:32 PM
Petaluma to thrive, we need multiple areas that function as separate downtowns and thereby
promote walkability and other alternative modes of transportation. What improvements we envision
for the current downtown should be equally applied to all similarly functioning districts. Also, I don't
know what is meant by a Downtown Street Team.
46 See above. 5/20/2019 9:51 AM
47 Not excited about funding a Street team 5/2012019 6:29 AM
48 OK 5/99/2019 7:24 PM
.. .. ...... ... ... ......... . . . . ............ . . .
41
2/4
Input Summary 2 - Page 152 of 185
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
Attaciment 3
49 Missing elements like dealing with sanitation along water street *(the rat problem is partly caused 5/19/2019 2:01 PM
by the trestle structure creating a habitat, and partly by the restaurants not having effective means
for dealing with food waste. Placing public art that is FUNCTIONAL (e.g. benches, play structures,
bike racks, etc), as opposed to intrusive and non -engaging (e.g. the tubs on stilts) is also important
to creating in inviting and engaging downtown., Also need to review the historic district so that it
includes all of the historic waterfront (which seems to have been illegally deleted from the district
hni inriary
.. ....
chamber groups..
.. ... .. .. . . ..... .. ..... ... ......... . ...........
59
I'm not sure about the increase of public bathrooms. There are several in downtown. Public
52
Missing: Parking and traffic flow
5!18/2019
bathrooms can become drug hangout problems. I assume that increased bathroom facilities are to
6:36
AM
53
Redundant
5!17!2019
7:10
PM
54
.... ... ... . . .... ........ . .. . ...... . .. . ... ........... . ... . . . .... . .
Fix the streets first, then decide if you should have more "fun" downtown.
5/17/2019
.........
5:12
PM
55
.. .................................... ... .. ... ... : .. .... ......... ................. .......... ................... . ....... . ............................. .... ....... ..... ...........
#34. A Downtown Streets Team would go far in keeping Petaluma safe and attractive.
5/17!2019
... ....
4:26
PM
56
. . .. .. .. . .. .... ..... .. .. .. ............. ............................................... ... . ... . ........................ ......... ........... .. .............................. .............. .......... ...... .. . . .. . ... ... ...... . . .. .......
Parking! Parking is very difficult downtown. We don't all live close enough to walk! If you want us to
5/17/2019
... .... ....... ................. ... ...... ................ ... ........... ............. ................ I ...... .... :.: ....... . : ..................... ...... ........... ........ . ..... . ... . . ....... .. ..................... :—.1— .... ............................. ..... . ......... .. . .... .. . . ..... . .... . .... ..... ..... ... . .. ...... .. ... . . . ... .. .. .. ... . . . .. . . .. ..... . . .. .. .. ..... ...... ..... ............... ...
Would make Petaluma even more fun!!
4-0621
PM
....... ...... ............. . .... .. ..............................
63
'shop local'give us decent parking and don't sell the existing spaces
. ..... ..... :: .
5/17/2019
...... ........................... ...... ................................................
8:55 AM
64
.... .... . ......... ....... ............... . . . . ... ........ . .. ... .. ..... . .. . .. ... .. .. . . ... . .. . .. .. ............... ..... .. .
Nothing
57
.. . . ... ... .. . .... .. ... ..... ................. ..... .......... ......... .. . ...................... ............. ... ... .... .. ....
Beautification with climate change in mind. Sustainable, low water plants, community gardens and
5/17/2419
see above
...................... . . .......
12:28 PM
3/4 Input Summary 2 -Page 153 of 185
dP
voting, at libraries, at city buildings, etc.
59
I'm not sure about the increase of public bathrooms. There are several in downtown. Public
5/17/2019
10:46 AM
bathrooms can become drug hangout problems. I assume that increased bathroom facilities are to
accommodate the homeless. Unfortunately, i don't have an alternative to offer
....... ..... .................
60
....... ........ .............. ................................... .................................. ........ ...... . : .... . . . .... .... ..... ...... . . .. .
Highlight zoning and building a corridor of housing and retail between the transportation hub
5/17/2019
10:37 AM
(SMART) and downtown. Building out these corridors will lead to jobs and opportunities for both
low and middle income housing.
... .. .. . ... .. .... . .. ........ . . . ..... ..... .
61
. .... .... .. . ..... . ... .................. ...................................................... ............................. ................. .. ........................ ......... ............................ ...... ..... ....... ... . ..... ..... . . ... . . ..... ..........
No Comment
5/17/2019
. . .. ........ ........ ..... ..... .. . .
10:33 AM
.... ........... : ...
62
... .... ....... ................. ... ...... ................ ... ........... ............. ................ I ...... .... :.: ....... . : ..................... ...... ........... ........ . ..... . ... . . ....... .. ..................... :—.1— .... ............................. ..... . ......... .. . .... .. . . ..... . .... . .... ..... ..... ... . .. ...... .. ... . . . ... .. .. .. ... . . . .. . . .. ..... . . .. .. .. ..... ...... ..... ............... ...
Would make Petaluma even more fun!!
...... . . .... ... ......... . . ....... ..
5/17/2019
. . . I ...... .. .. ...... . .... .. . .. ... . ... . .. . . . . .. . . .. . .. ... .. ... ..... ............. . ........ . .. . ... ... . ..... .... .. . .... ... ...
9:56 AM
....... ...... ............. . .... .. ..............................
63
............. ........................................... .......... . ...... ............ ...... . ........ ... . .... ....... ...... ... .... .. ... ....... ......... .........................
Read previous comments
. ..... ..... :: .
5/17/2019
...... ........................... ...... ................................................
8:55 AM
64
.... .... . ......... ....... ............... . . . . ... ........ . .. ... .. ..... . .. . .. ... .. .. . . ... . .. . .. .. ............... ..... .. .
Nothing
5/17/2019
.............. ....... I ........... . . . .
8:54 AM
65
see above
5/17/2019
7:47 AM
66
Same
5/16/2019
6R-40 PM
........ ..... ..... ... ...... ... ..
67
.... ... .. ...................... ......... .. .. . ....... ......
Like the clarity
5/16/2019
.. . ........ .. .
4:30 PM
......... . .... ........ .... ..... . . .. . . . . . . .. ... . .. .
68
.. . .. . ... ..... . .. ... .... .. .. . . . ...... ... ......... .............. .................................... ....... ....................................... ...... ..... .. ..... . ... ...................... .................. .. .......... . ... ...... ................................. ................. . .... ............... ...........................
Good
5/16/2019
...................................... ...... . .................... .................. ......... ......... .
3: 15 PM
.. .. . .....
69
. .. . .................. .. ........... .......
Allow more street vendors and close the streets more often
5/16/2019
3:01 PM
.. . ...
70
. . . ...... . .... ... .. .. .. . .... ... .. . .. . ... ... ... .. .............................. . ....... . . ..... ....... . .. . . . ........ ...... .......
Need more green spaces/parks/shade!
5/16/2019
1:10 PM
71
This is a good work plan.
..
5/16/2019
123-58 PM
72
. ..............
Again, not mention of budgeting issues:.
........ ..................................
5/16/201,9
12:57 PM
73
........................... . .................... ............................................................................ ....... ............... ...... ............
Restrooms, prepare for the future need for parking. Basic'mid range retail for residents is needed,
5/16/2019
11,936 AM
not just tourist brit or brat and so called antiques.
74
. . ...... .... ........... I ..... .. . ........
same as above
5/16/2019
....... ..
11:33 AM
75
.. .. ................ . ....... ....... ...................... . .......................... .......
Overall it is needed.
5/16/2019
10'u,43 AM
....................... .. ...
76
.... ....... ...... ....... ... .... .. .. ................... ..... ................ ....................... ........... ......... I ..................... I .................. ................. ... . .. ........................... .................. ....... .... ..... . ............... . ...... ........................ ........... ....... ........ ...... .... . . . . .. . ..... ..... .... ...... . I ............ ........
3. Fund and support a Downtown Streets Team., Support Downtown streets team with available
5/16/2019
. .........
1 0:39 AM
funding or by prioritizing funding from other buckets,,
. . ...... .. . ... . .......
77
. ...... .... :e . ...... .. .. .... . 1-..e::�.--.%-.%1 ......... .... .. .. ..... . .... . e .......... e ....... .. ..... . ......................... .. .... .... e .. . ......................... e ..... .. ......... ................... ......... . ................. ...... .. ... .. .. I—: . ... ... ................ ..............
Like the review of downtown zoning and hope it allows for variety of interesting maker type uses
.. ................. ...........
5/16/2019
..... ................................. .... .... .....
10:26 AM
... . .. .
(light welding, CNC machining, 3D printing etc),
. .... . ... ... ... . ... ... ... ... ...................... .... ................. ... ... . ...
3/4 Input Summary 2 -Page 153 of 185
78
79
80
81
CITY COUNCIL DRAFT GOALS 2019-2021
It might be helpful to delineate the boundaries of the historic district better with signage, i.e. an
overhead street banner,
.............................
OK
Solid plan.
Good idea to maintain and improve dowtown fac
A.
Attachment 3
5/16/2019 10:21 AM
414
{
Input Summary 2 -Page 154 of 185
�Z
41
9
1.
1V
a 11
iN
01
ql
Ia
9
1.
iN
01
ql
9
I1.0ma saffs. :4 1 1 ("N 1
F
iN
01
wl
I1.0ma saffs. :4 1 1 ("N 1
F
wr
uklPOIYY
I1.0ma saffs. :4 1 1 ("N 1
F
0
(7-C
0
a I'.e ai e 1 w,c e 0
like to see inclusion for, adults as well.,
r would (il<e to see pickle ball courts brought
uommissioner FlIsche
W,,hen d,iscussing tennis cou
rt renovations across the City. (objecti
into
the conversation
two) ve
,ke to see verbiage about access'lb'I'lity to
0
1. Commissioner Snore reminded the commission that the
needs to be considered within City objectives.
t
a ii s i S 0
it
-,%aand I a r 'esrkt lver is he City s 9
F IL
sa-s,
• Expandeld transit service on primary corridors (A city that works for everyone obi". Z)
• Study and begin preliminary planning for electrification
of thePetaluma Transit bus fleet
and facilities (Our Environmental legacy-obj. 1., or 2.)
• Expand integration of transit and with Petaluma community human service. agencies and
nonnon-profits (A safe community that thrives obj. 3)
• Provide additional real-time schedule information an.... infrastructure for Petaluma Transit
.A city that works for everyone obj. 2
C)
S
PS: We should establish response times that are related to CEQA, then! projects would be
responsible for paying for needed staff.
• HB: We need to increase staffing in Police and F
• DG: Don't0 think aboutbothS'1es of and
EOCs.
• RM: :What does an EOC look like? What services does it provide?
HB: We need to evaluate our air quality filtration systems in our Emergency Operations
;l Commissioners were very
Centers, especially given health concerns from smoke. (Al
supportive of this).
M
ri:pu 6ummary 2 age b. 0 b
r
Attachment 3
• Consider reducing fees on projects with access to transit and :improve transit density
bonuses.
• BW: Disincent'lvize the demolition of smaller homes in exchange for bigger homes.
• BW: There needs to be better coordination between Building and Planning with regard to
ADUO
• SA: What would a Housing Commission look like and how would it operate? Need some
more detail with this idea.
• SA: Be proactive with fees i
• DG: Objective 3 workplan it
n a manner that incentives affordable housing.
em #1 should add "Petaluma" to read as follows: "Collaborate
with the Petaluma Health Care District...
• SA: Objective 3 workplan item 2 should strike "consider" and replace with "adopt" to
r
read as follows: Adopt a Tobacco Retail Licensing ordinance. Also needs stronae
' to deter youth access.
language as a means
• SA:
• SA:
We should update the IZO to have greater oversight of ABC uses either by staff or PC.
Consider a bar tax or more oversight on alcohol processes and the proliferation of
ABC license downtown.
• HB; What is a "visitabliity" ordinance??
• RM: What is a Care and Shelter operati
• RM: What is an Age Friendly City?
SPACES AND PLACES THAT INSPIRE
They were confused by this.
ons manual?
• CG: Don't forget the east side; Deer Creek, K -Mart, Target can all be better spaces and
are opportunity sites., (PS: Agree, this should be a workplan item under Obj. 4).
•
PS*., The 'Downtown Streets Team' needs to be better defined. Asked for a CBD, which we
indicated we had one, but were unsure of sidewalk maintenance.
• BW: Downtown association should get businesses to maintain their own sidewalks,
• RM: Would like a recap from the city on where we're at with the Fairgrounds.
• SA: We should -recognize existing non-ag businesses that are at the Fairgrounds.
•
?,?.: More bathtubs and less bureaucratic process for public art (general agreement)
• BW: Not supportive of a council appointment to the Public Art Committee.
• DG: Call out Lucchesi Park in Objective 4 by name.,
• SA: Objective 5 should acknowledge Measure M funds.
• DG: Wanted to know how much money/time is left for East Washington Fields.
• BW: Add McNear Park as Objective 6. He loves the ball park and grandstands, misses the
lights.
AN ECONOMY THAT PROSPERS
• BW: Concern that the minimum wage will spur gentrification. (Not a consensus point
with other Commissioners)
• All: Unclear about what the Airport re -zoning is.,
Input Summary 2 - Page 157. of 185
f
Attachment 3
• BW: We need to decide if we're a community that wants to attract tourism, or if we want
to be a tour ist destination. There's a f ine line... he used the number of tour buses in
Healdsburg as an example.
• DG: Concerned about Objective 2, Workplan Item 2,
bias towards the Petaluman. It should be stated as "
hotel rooms,.. "
because it reads as though there's a
Consider the number ol downtown
• All: Confused about Obj. 3, Workplan Item 1, regarding dredging. They have all
' re at
several ideas/timeframes for dredgina.
noted two upcoming KBYG talks about the river on 6/24 and 6/26.
Wanted more clarity about where we
• All : Add Restore the Trestle and Workplan Item 41.
0 OUR ENVIRONMENTAL LEGACY
• BW;
• RM:
•
D G: I
• RM.
• BW:
consider building decarbonization through elec
Encourage Evergreen program participation.
nstall more public water fountains.
trifoicat*ion.
heard
Very supportive of the Biofuel project at Ellis Creek. Would love to know more.
Ri�
Would like to know more about the city fleet shift from fossil -fuel based to hybrid
and/or elect
ric vehicles.
• DG: There should be a
It least two waste streams in city parks (trash/recvcDG: There should be a city-wide recycling plan for retail uses and city fac
ling).
ilities.
• ??: Clarify the intent of the single -use plastic and polystyrene ban-,
-P
• HB: Add Obj 1, Workplan Item 16: Promote recharge bosinsfior groundwater recharge
• HB: Add Obj 1, Workplan Item 17: can pesticides in developments ondpublicploces.
• All: Collective "Amen" to Promote sustainable building practices and active conservation
efforts to Petaluma Residents.
• All: Supportive of continued education for community, staff, developers, employers,
property owners, and all residents.
A CITY THAT WORKS FOR EVERYONE
• RM: Add more staff !
� PS: Everything about Obj 2 is a priority for the Planning Commission,.
.0
• SA: Very supportive about the idea of a community bike share system,,
• All: Excited about the website, it should be in Obj 3 because it's p''111111 ublic facinL,Ry.0uld like
periodic updates on website roll-out/timing.
• SA: Would like to see an advance calendar and pages dedicated to specific projects.
GENERAL COMMENTS
• HB: Likes the formatting but add numbers.
• Survey was too long
Input Summary 2 -Page 158 of 185
dry
2
'14
77')
....nm I
. .. .. ... ..
,,ky, ,11—.",ft I , F —.1
.. ...
. ...... .
0.
til I
.4 ML L n 4 0 Loft -d -i &�-� Aiiiiiiiiiiiii� :&.& * p
mood* joi
Z
I
lo�
nq
77')
....nm I
. .. .. ... ..
,,ky, ,11—.",ft I , F —.1
.. ...
. ...... .
0.
til I
.4 ML L n 4 0 Loft -d -i &�-� Aiiiiiiiiiiiii� :&.& * p
mood* joi
ulty of"'Peta,luma
'Ime
May,or -barr,ULL a,n,d Crty uouncl mberl
c,lmemberso
,,-"-eajr M.ayor Barrett and Cotm 1, 0
o
u A"lok
JUN I
CITY MAN,AG- ER
AW
all 10-
le usiness "as e Iflat is key to the Cl"ty's
e 0
Inpull 6ummary a, y u 0 -
-
mole an - � I M
"Ut'll WWI
In bT -OM 0 1:0-HELIM110,411"IM �-Mllllll' UM Modal
eltoils to attract and maintain b:u.s mess,es m Petal"uma.
City regaxding threse issuesw
Input Summary 2 Page !l 61 of 185
rl
t
II
I rovnig erne i astiveftue e.,,:,. ii er t
the lome prenuses are
Y:O"Uxs
a EO
Onita Pellegrnu, C
Petal,wna Area Chainber ofCommerlee
is I, -me Vol
Pef-r -1 yn,,n,,, Ci*t ana "er
A Verde, Economic e v elo" ment Direc, or
Attachment 3
!of
t;ummary age 62 85
11
4 11
3* Creat U-,* aii: Eij,i'*eroei-ii,"4'v0
01)erafloiis Celdei4
enietweiicies and ittool (lisasters'.
9
10. Pi•otirote ireiglrboi•Irood policing girdftiv safetyr�ssignruents•,beat coijinr[rlrit�> errgrrge»reitt, and
o[rtreaclr.
Ill. CO11S7(ICT afirejvoteks sales GCl/l.
12. Eirltairce paverneit! snariagenteirt progi•attr to ifnprove the safetjt antd sei• viceability of ouu# ro«
IL
4Irivers, cyclists rurdpedes iafrs.
lit civase fiiiicit0ii ality oj viaeo s,tirveillalice*
(Is acrd to protect
OvC'il1C'1115 to 1l11C0111i'
a
n!/eel
Planningprovidingf&r natural disasters, anda safe place for the community to shelter is essential to survival during such
events,. If access or communications are cut-off/limited, the population needs a centralized place to seek, shelter,
medical care, food, power &information. Especia y if access to the east side of town is compromised.
We feel a fully functioning fairgrounds that ese services a so helps facilitate outreach and
education to empower the population to better �wealther an emergency or natural disaster. Especiallythose with
animals.
'0% Minot
nput 0.
u mary a. e uo o
II l�I
1W
a
Attachment 3
eady provides a free fireworks
show (attended byover in thathas of space to expand. ADDITIONALLY, we could athe
fits who raise vital monies from fireworks sales by staffing a concession stand at the show to offset the
I
ire
lonly one day of volunteers,
F.0O3 'WrAb
r.
V
-"Ctolrs
InSon t-airgrol,un : oma-AMari ds" Board of'Dire
is
design 'pi'*ogtvams, that ci•eate a healthy, resilient, acid e��gaged community that
Goal I un Suppo►•t faci'1i"ties an(
prepared, safe and housed.
A
WOI'Ilipv-% 'an lte�nis:
u
'u
Fitcuthite consh, 4 I'lCtixi
oll q/ ccessoij, ivelling Ift's.
6.01 010 6 1 0 a 0 10
nsiaer e tablIS11111" 0 Hollstlig 0111111ISS101110
W E , Itenises
p
2 c 0 0 0 No
0 Onsulett a(lopting a Tobaeco Retail Lt*ceiisuilor ordinaitce
f% row
0
n1pu bummary 2 age
0
r
II
Nz
JI
HUI 1 ,A iM.
IMUZ 1 mw r In EM I'M M"I
A .1
0
4Sfi'[/CiUi'C'
f0/' . Developfee rfoi'#.Alcohoill,=Rel(ited Nl[ISClI1C2 Ot'!IlilC[IlCL'si11C1/1(lbeillC'/7l (111 CI BIlfO/'Cei112111 Of
(icense alcohol establi,s/i»ients.:
9
w
E l(de becoill,11*111, 19 (IH A ae Ft e
,i
6 b Ci
each: that many:people,
tM ,0:00 annual attendance. Where else in �the C,Ialtv, is there an
acrossall demograp ics & bad, grounds on lone To ertv?
M
a i rgro: n d s re rese ints, a n ao.
LOU" 5 41AW01ME111,011
1-1")Mqrqilmioj,mt*,Iojlo-matw-[*I 1111 2, , "I I
forms of pu� 11c, transportation, acclessi,ble �frlom bot
for hours of oplera,tion. Thlis Would alle i e, p ,ri<ing
V
M, MlRellM�012,MM M ne M�1111[4 0 t 0,111111�,
ain around Walnut Park, lessen the impact
businesses and allow for much needed market expansion.
" 1 :
on those adjacernt
The fairgrounds has over 200 volunteers, most of them are, seniors. Their participation not only supports our
A 6
case of exh'ibits) one; o,f t�he ifilewl local
1 t ion, eXercise a Ifa rgrounds activl Iles but miany are thereseekng socializat* nd n the
formats, to showcase their talents in arts &crafts, photography, gardening, baking, woodworking, etc. fairgrounds
also functions as, a location for seniors groups to meet.
i rsegments All year
Events, held at the fa grounds, represientall of our especially from a variety of '
long there are celebrations for quinceaneras, bap
tisms, weddings, memorials, religious services and many other multi-
cultural
holiday events that brings communitiestogetherandoffers opportunities to
celebrate thew -traditions, and
culture.
�)olnoma-ldmarin Fairgroun S' Board of Uirector
ON".1.1TY COUN;CIL D GO 20 021
16
rYorlrplrrir Iteirrs:
3o Fuiid a d sul-)porl a Downtown StreeiSr Teant.
r-
,ff
nput Summa Y Z dj%.x 100 G U0
�1
M Mtff
Tll
oil
Awl
CUM, i
A
Work�)I,au Ifeins.0
hll
public. We feel the fa
represents the ri
irg-rounds is
ch heritage of Petaluma iout should serve as the communities' gathering place long
Irs flexibilifty and ablilty to serve
greiatler community itserves and
so many different functions IS vital to the health and secu
represents.
into the future.
rity of Petalumans and the,
T G S 2019-20.21
CITY CO 1
1L D 0
I"w I
Sonoma-Mar*in, Faiirgrloun:: S' Board of Directors
U
0
Workplan lte,insi.
0;
b
Piwiiiote cy,lsf it P 11,lic. (ttot.
Input Summary 2 Page, 166 of 185
13
210 Err,,gage the Citjl's Art Coturjthe coi�tjlrrurity,ns,stion. (ind to f•e►lieiv the Ci "S I'ttblic Ail lllusierplarr to ejtsrrre foals
(Hrrl objectives erre cru•reirt uirrl reflective of the c'Oi1117111/lI/y.
The fairground
s property 'is, dated and buildings are! bland. Through rejuvena
its buildings can serve as fantastic out -lets for the arts.
showcase Petaluma, agriculture, multiculturali
i
reflection of t city and region.
The facilities also: represent venues for art education, art shows, rotating displays and even iannual art festivals. The
.
fairgrounds has plans to add gardens, including teaching and demonstration gardens, which can, serve as an additional
from elementary grades: to college.
healthy connection for� seniors an famiies, as wellas a "lab" for local students
tion and i
0 .4
mprovements, the, property and
murals that represe:in't an
i ne 'Doara wouia iove pai,nungs, or
Kim W N ki
RM&-WqW1 `7
k.
*d
"M
gina COMM1Un*t3'7r P, 00:1 OU14,ft'1StO1*.Ya'nd encoin
Ej
Sonoma-Marin Fai,rgrounds' Board of Director
a
+p' n
Items,
1. CC[]llilll I71l11111871!!)1CP !/Illl l!f)bra(les to Citj11 facilities to pf•onide places anal spacesfog' C011liil!/11It1l fllCllOa 1[C', p1lbl/C
1t1eL'llitgS, and L'llSlO/IIL'I' SL'PvICe.,
6 Ift10
2* Develoi) a reh(ibilit(ltl*oiilrecoi?lt',at114(lf"I*OiI pli-titfor City Hall itllil'cli 1*11clu(les a lobky area, expa)lsion COl[ill)'-
ivi7t.c,
andtivrr�fndi�rgSlbll(lae.
mill
6
Worliplan Itenis.
npiu Summary:Zr Page 167 of 185
4i �ilit►� !!11(�itse,TIICIl!lllllb40 Iniprove exisfing trails andpai#A-, pathjvttvs to i*ncrease accevsib 1 L}ii1CI1 Creek Trail !!71d
Prince Prrrk.
, & it
590 Prioritize couipletioit of allpha.,ves of the Petalinna Coiliii i U// 'y Sports Field prgject.
(did, not cornment:but the , "resonated with me/us".)
1 1 1' • • I ' 1
1111 111111 1� ,: 1, F 711 q
lllw=w= "I'lliq
M"MM
xe
VA 11L, _2 I
0
Workplan Items.
0 a I w 01 to Is
Hize aiia iii,ceilitivae sits 11 folwnenIq
Prior tai'tiable * ifi'll (leve'
a # If If* 0
5. FIr"'twilkle liceitsl*llg andpet"1111"Jil, lig giies iii Spaitish.
�opulafionin a short per*lo:d of ti'me.
MAN
Sono,ma-mmarin Fairgroun S' Boar re ct o rs
a
lnP!U, Summary 2 Pa e 16:8 of 185
Attachment 3
business ltverse, resilient econonii.i an environnaiii aGoal3 smEncouraue a t1ir1*v1*nuent that ttestilts (ILuft) tn
t
Supports COM,11,1"''I'llutly P1,00spel
Objective 2,, — Protuote ,,;.x. it as a destniatioul
0
W plan Itenis,
IS 1 0
34 I(ley/11 1potent1*(,t1p(ti 4, iiia alleriiatives,,,f0to I-101 to w/10
& to 1,
S.Ij'IO\%17177e
use Clil'1'L'111p!!1'%lS lllt(% i'L'Ci'G'(/1(O/1 !ltfl'l/Sil'1lClllYB f0/' theIIOSPlit, Of 3'2C7'e(1PlOT1lt1 SJJ07,
attract visirors ro Peralunrrr.
The fairgrounds facilitates
devents all year round. Music femulti-cultural festivals & celebrati
showcases, wine & leer competitions, athletic competitions, fundraising events and of course
eveins l%1(11
eve ntaw i c:: a i s, o
n ionaii�j,
Y en� a, tur, e s :T e Wlo-% ...... . .. .. .. .. .. . ...... .
g
liest Doe Competition that animal adoption wis showcased
That all said. We'd love to do more and partner with the city on topics, and ideas to expand our, event's and promote the
city as adestination.
Awl i0i Al - " Board of" D:irectorll.,11
�)onomla-Marin Fairgroun s
1 1 1' 1• 1 ` 1
Obj lective 3
recreati'ona
Res-estab
'I fivaf, 17i,c.
:o - jc,t,l*.ve 3 W
� � �,. #, ,fes.
8.
tiplaiiItems,#
L
nput Summary z Page 169 of 185
'A I
oal 4 moss.Pio eslerve aiid, p
sustain,a.b,i i y by p s' 2e
"N 'S
Sustai*naDie development.
I
Workplan, Ite,MS.
ii,Ppsio,l(n 4
xau
I
I gc:lII
910 Continue to eiprutd rec>>cled wnt
reso races.
er sef•►lices to support local t-tgj•icrrltrrre ani! gro
1[7t(Ilt'CIfL'I' llll(I surface,jtlateto
0 0 W W
iierg,v in neit, oil, SlIbstaidiclUjiiiFFIii�t�
0
12. Iticrease otla(111,
b
awetstoiifronit i(ril
0
1 4o A (lo t (I C1*tvjt4'd'e, st*ii 4-*,1t),P--4ttse p1(1IS1jC'(jjjdPo1 I -�SO�reiie
9 AIL
We feel the fairgrounds needs to be managed with as many efforts towards sustainability and conservation as possible.
With along -term lease in place, greaattention can be paid to improving buildings and utilizing solar eand
natural light where appropriate.
The soft-scaped areas are evaluated regularly for water use efficiency and kconducive towaterpercolation limiting
runoff and erosion.,
,
'The fairgrounds 'has, a tree care plan tohelp increase available shade,'reduCe hardsca e andencourage
water percolation.
Ornamental plare cout fperennial, tolerant where appropriate.
Input Summary 2 -Page 170 of 185
This yeaIr
onthe lani
e will be 1
fill.
mplernent a new recycling strategy for our
r....oncession w4
ste that w*111 d
i 1
S
L
a
i"lly �r
*ty of the lat�est
, 0
their properties,
Sonoma-M,ar*in: Falirgrounds' Board of Directors,
sustai".itabit �development. I
0
Worliplan Iteins:
(e�x anded: on 'ini, -r*ior ries! onse.)
111"'W"i'M
RIEW"tI
M UR1,1111, 11,41JL tin Hi,
t IH R I
U
Worliplan Ite�inis
ortY
�act Fees'.
I Developinent Inip
0 0 4. Levore eralocal, regional, and state progiAanis aiid resources to inaxinuzcite tvveirrres.
Input Summary 2 -Page 171 of 185
0
I, , ,
1tv
w
i
a
in
I
h
h
M; N•.
a
�I
t € I I 9
E`
I ;
t
r
It I
i
I +
I
II� A
li SII s
Ia
Y.
( _ l
of coect[Connection_
u II'
Y I
I
s9
M
s,aretv
1,
asse,.Kv
(uld'wor.'
�lrrce security (IS well as otheim imelevantustaff li'!llll[)t�y ivIIICII it�lll be i(lentl�e(I throita,ll (vtie
ed,
ruerrt.
9,0 r t .,.
stablis i, a nen, entorientation
, P: vee
P,'%, s st a t e - r
a
5.
i
'` `� ' � 1 • .. . � u ' f 1. ? ,. ':
I
k
:+
un district agricultural association, the fairgr
ou,nds will be receiving additional state funding: or capitol
isaste'r
services
, evacuation
'ore attention
,itels:, rn
M if
is
7
acl l
k
z
Y
�• ��, :, �il�u , ter.
c � C
I
I• ,
w01 111111i,
M , Y
L
,
€
:
u
r
n
Y
a
^
x€
r -
I JM
L
5
£
I
I
40
D'ire
�Sonorna-MaHin Fairground,s' Board�
A;C11TYT
WO
SFOREVERYONE
MWa
v
Y
r w,
i r
tt` x
w,
n a
, .... _ ,..,, , .. :: „ . .i:. ', a •.:, t ,
4
t
i
III
�C
k
l
n
Worlaplam
jj
wr
m
I
,
arm"
€
N
,
I [
I
1.
F
E
u f'
I
II x
x I��
1
1
N l
r „
M
I t
4r, 4
w»�
x ar
a
W
. a, ,sem: ,.:.• .,,.. t �< ,:.. .... ..: ,- ,. .. . .., 5.. ., I IZZ
f »
s
, RHIN
7o i*ntegi*ate
1111"th.
Befter
street (le'st'glits.,'.
9*
10.0
Conil)le-le the secloii d SAIL41? T sla,11*011, (it corlottalo
Develqjpbk
b
_� tilan to relutilit(de l,e Tresile.
Mallitai'lls I
O"ALIT 41k,11M, vttlAWS,
Objective 3 Maxirnize a
Ill Ill I I � I I �
ext
Wor,kplan Items,
34, Pro vi"de pos
0 0
C0,11111,111111c(l 1011
a
and sllstaionab�le and seiires the nee(Is of our resi'd,eutsO,
40 CnorlIl/1ldL' l[71lI elllillilCeG•oss-(leprrrlineirtal social iiredia collaboration.
CITY COUNCIIL D,, G 0 �S 0,19 2 02 1
F
Woi,,, kplan Items.
01% ^je 1'73 of 185
npufL \Q..ummary 2 Pay
lelln
2* linpleinent an online pettin ti'lig SJ78, 1
Iniplentent an agend'a na.aentent sqftivaise, sj,7stein,
a
y
Input Surrnmar Page 11 7,4, of 185
6/24/2019
w�
Re :
ie draft city goa s are readyl
BIRENT RUSSELL <russe11202@comcast.net>
Thu 5/16/Z019 10;27 AM
To-.Alverde, Ingrid <IAlverde@cityofpetaluma.org>;
---Warning: Use'Caution before clicking any attachments. THIS EMAIL IS F
Hello Ingrid,
Mail - IA]verde@cityofpetaluma.org
0
ROM OUTSIDE OUR EMAIL SYSTEM. ---
Thank you for your outreach to the community regarding City Goals.
have a list of items that I would like to see happen.
Attachment 3
1. Since Caltrans is working on the freeway widening, it would be great to get the Rainer overcrossing work started.
2. Putting solar panels on City Hall to reduce the City's carbon footprint would be great.
i
3.. It would be nice to get the rest of Sonoma Mountain Parkway, McDowell Blvd, and Petaluma Blvd South repaved.
4. It would be good to put some funds towards maintenance and visual improvements at Luchessi Park and
Community Center.
5-P Aside walk along English Street at Petaluma High School.
I I
On a personal note/request, I live on Webster Street which gets a lot of traffic from three- (and soon a fourth) school..
Although I know it will be expensive, the street needs to be re -built to reduce the crown in the road and to deal with the
have lived on the street since 1989 and it has never been paved or sealed. The only
places where there is new paving
multitude of pot hole patches
In�ut Summary 2 - Pa
Sincerely,
Brent Russell
is where home owners like myself have r
On May 16, 2019 at 9:45 AM City of Petaluma <ialverde@ci.pefaluma.ca.us? wrote:
eplaced their sewer lines'.
https:/loutlook.office365.comlowa/?path=/mail/AAMkADIi0
DZNWJmLTAzMWYtN DdINy04NTZiLWVhODh1Ym
ge 1
YO TRmMAAuAAAAAABW igsl
175 of 185
uLUTp... 1/2
G
31
--d
Mail - lAIverde@cityo'fpetaluma-orY
OX
Petaluma Economic Development PAOIN �!!B� 1
C, i iit
vi� M. dw
All% 3
ib
peta I U M;d: c A
�Jn�ubscrib� russe10_�cp_M cast, net
Update Prafile Abaut%our
service__,provi der
Sent by ialverde@ci.petaluma.ca,,us *in collaborat"ion with
�"' Trusted Emil from Constant
Contact -Try it FREE today,,
Try emall Marketing for free told:ay'.
In�ut.SummaryAhttps://outlook.office365.com/owa(?path=/mail/AAMkADIiODZNWJmZjNWJniLTAzMVVYtNDdlNyO4NTZI*LWVhODhIYmYOTRmMAAIUAA
e
0
a
"7n
to of 18b
Lj I I
L,,Tps
Fil
K a i*ri, e J :iri e
Wed 6/5/2019 9:13 PM
I
io:Alverde, Ingrid <lAlverde@c I lty0lfpetaluma.,org>; Flynn, Peggy <PFIynn@c'ltyofpetaluma.org>; Barrett,Teresa
<tl�anett@cityofpetaluma.org>; Fischer, D'Lynda <dfi6slicher"@cityolfpetal'umaorg>., Healy, Mike < mhe:a ly@c*ltyof,peta lu ma.or:g > ,' Kearney,
all
INS meAft Z��llolrffilm* m Ell, Mm m� rane I I
---Warning: 1—Warning: Use caution before clic-king any attachments. THIS, EMAIL IS FROM OUTSIDE OUR EMAIL SYSTEM.---
Good
Evening.
_ � _ _ � SII
C�
n _
m I
f � �E
m I LIM' M
I found the Survey Monkey a bit overwhelming and hope you're ok with ine
providing the
following c
ro arram
articipaLc; in 4 1 S, Alc
When updating the City's
Economic Development Strategy, please include heritage tourism as a
lcey component.
Need ideas?? Look to Main Street L1S,A, for ideas.
10
Complete the Certified LLocal G�ovemme;nt, applications process!
P"� joe- Aor— aO� A polo' ^
9462
k,r,,, rine-harto'a"comcast., net
Atl'a.chment J^
WA
FA
IPFAA W
W_FA4
hi, Uk, VATAfflal W I W-10 I I III
.FJF T T 11 , IVA!�
I I Mel Or, _u I =1 a I M -P I RIVOWN-A M WRA4
6/24/2019 Mail - ]Alverde@cityofpetaluma.org
FW: 1put oi draft Goals & Priorities
Pascoe, Samantia
Tue 5/21/2019 8:37 AM
To.-Alverde, Ingrid <IAlverde@cityofpetaluma.org>; Sands, Nancy <NSands@cityofpetaluma.org>;
Samantha Pascoe. CMC
Deputy City Clerk
Main 707.778.4360 Direct
www.citvofr)eta1u amet
Hou
707.778.4575
rs,.,Mo — Thurs Sam to Spm
Closed Fridays
I
From: msaragina< saragina@gma*11.com>
Sent.,, Tuesday, May 21,, 2019 8:3 5 AM
Ir
Too. Fischer, D ' Lynda <dfischer@C1tyofpeta1u a.org>
Healy, Mike <mhealy@cityofpet aluma.org>
<gkearney@cltVof etaluma.or >' <dkin&Sc&
tVofpeta1u o r9>
McDonnell, Kevin
<kmcdonnell@ci yof etaluma.or >1 Miller, Kathy <kmiller@ 1ty0f e aluma.or >; Barrett,T resa
.0
<tDarren evc1tyoTpetaiuma.or9> City Clerk <U1tyU1erKCa)citYoTpeta1u a.,org>
Cc: -- City Clerk <C'I'tyClerk@cityofpetaluma.org>
Subject: Res. Input on draft Goals & Priorities
Attachment 3
1 9 Iearney, Gabe
---Warning: Use caution before clicking any attachments. THIS EMAIL IS FROM OUTSIDE OUR EMAIL SYSTEIVIVMW--
4. Dear
Mayor Barrett & City Council Members,
Unfortunately, I was not able to attend the planning session. However, I have reviewed the draft of the Council's Goals & Priorities and
input for your consideration.
A Safe Community That Thrives
Objective 1, Workplan.1tem #5, sets a plan to improve safety through proactive,crime and fire prevention activities.
As you probably know, substance abuse among our teenagers and young adults is a problem and Petaluma is not immune to this problem..
Developing programs and/or finding funding to develop programs to address this issue is essential to improving safety and homelessness
4P
in our community.
In addition, we have many at -risk students in our schools. The Mentor Me program does an excellent job, but I believe the City could be
more proactive in helping this program or similar programs.
Spaces and Places That Inspire
Objective 3 refers to public art installations
am assuming the reference to the City Art's Commission is an inadvertent error and the reference is to the Petaluma Public Art
"Committee" and not commission'.
ri
Ingut Summary 2 - Pae 179 of 185
https://outlook.office365.comlowa/?path=/mail/AAMkADIiODZjNWJmLTAzMWYtNDdINy04NTZiLWVhODhIYmYO TRmMAAuAAAAAABW igsluLUTp... 1/2
6/24/2019
applaud you for Workplan
of dollars from public funds
liaison onthe PublicArt Committee. The isMail - IAlverde@cityofpetaluma.org
liaison on the Public Art Committee. The is
item #3 - exploring a Councilreceiving hundredsto�ifi'ousan�s
It is important that they a Council member attends the PAC meetings to provide them insight into the larger
Petaluma plans and issues as the PAC makes decisions'.
Issues Relating Substance Abuse
Lastly, it should be noted that there are numerous areas in Petaluma that
before installing artin those areas, the Public Art Committee works with t
have been identified as
"historical locations,." Itis important that
he Cultural and Historical Committee to ensure the artwork is
appropriate for a historical location to ensure the City continues to value and protect our history. Also, adequate and timely opportunities
for public input should be included,, Again, the PAC is using public funds, so the public should be noticed well in advance before the funds
are approved for an art installation.
Thank you for your consideration of these issues,
Respectfully,
Margaret Saragina & Daniel Plumley
Residents of Petaluma since 1961
i
I
t
https://outlook.office365.comIowa/?pafh=/mail/AAMkADIiODZNWJmLTAzMWYtNDdiNy04NTZiL
U
7
Ing.ut Summary 2 - Pae 180 of 185
WVhODh1YmY0 212
N�oi
��✓ioon , <,ti a r'i,i<�r�r�er
TO.Flynn
e H<PFynri@cit f eta1L1ma.orq.>
1:
cc.-Alverde, Ingrid <lAlve,rde@c'i"tyof!!L-%,et-a,luma.ore4>-
D... I a
r' I-lynn,
a
communityL,
P L t P11 rese,rve
it au a ance Na: ure
Oalw-
is a s'De....1IE
01 r lace
:3
El
I'm writ*ig
n
N.
een e:twPLA: a the Ci:ty. , ions. p ni
Input Summary2 Pa 181 of' 185 -Page 1/2
1� A
Mail - lAlveride@c*tyof,petaluma.org
4
Preserveand am filled w,
exirsts to ProvIl
ide a forever-refUge for the nati"ve w
Soincerely,
Nan Moan
ormle: Oar...
e:M :er
a
httpsm.Houtlook.o,ff*lce365.com/�owa/,,?path-/``ma�,ii:mi/'.search
.A, t�achment 3'
e
Input Summary 2 -Page 182 of 185
2/2,
Attachment 3
Date:
To:
From:
Re.
June 5
2019
City Manager Flynn
Pete Gang
Comments on Council Goals and Priorities -- --- ------ - - -- -- - --- ---- - --
Comments on Council Goals and Priorities FY1 9m=20 & 200"21
want to acknowledge the heroic effort that has gone into soliciting and incorporating the input of the
community.,
This is democracy in action!
Although climate issues were affirmed by a large number of part icipants at the Goal -Setting Workshop, I
d o not see that they are elevated " ... to the highest priority in :the City's] goal-setting process
for in the Climate Emergency Resolution passed bv City Council on May 6, 2019.
that the community of nati
further to 1.50C."
]" as called
The Resolution notes
onsnasvoweato " ...pursue efforts to limit the temperature increase even
This is not a new goal. The City of Petaluma already affirmed its commitment to th'i's goal through its
explicit endorsement of the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement. In doing so, we pledged to "...adopt, honor,
and uphold the commitments to the goals enshrined
temperature increase to 1.5 0C , we must completely eliminate all fossil fuel emissions within 20 years
while concurrently drawing down the excess atmospheric CO2 that'is our real adversary. This is
the challenge that confronts us., And this is the challenge that provides us with both theiancentive and the
opportunity to build a vibrant , safe, prosperous , inclusive, and susta'ina'ble
N
n the Paris Agreement [and to] intensify
efforts to meet each of our cities' current climate goals, push for new action to meet the 1,5
degrees C target, and work together to create a 21st century clean energy economy.... i ne world
cannot wait — and neither w6111 we."
order to have a 2 -in -3 chance of limiting the
The.
community.
The Special Report on Global Warming of 1.5°C, the m'Dst recent report from the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change (IPCC):, tells us that i*n
vision of a future Petaluma that emerged from the Goal -Setting Session is entirely congruent with the
vision of a future Petaluma that results from strict attention to greenhouse gas reduction and drawdown of
excess greenhouse gases.
AND we need to better articulate that vision of where we're headed as a community.
Will our fossil -free future feature more segregationist zoning and more cars to get us from place to place?
Or will it feature more compact, dense, pedestrian -centered infill?
Will we have more crosstown connectors, smoother roads, and more cars or w`111 we have a complete
network of bicycle lanes, paths, and trails that makes it easy for people of.
all ages and abilities to get
around without needing to drive a car?
Will Petaluma be known for its big box shopping centers and franchise eateries or for its welcoming funk
and diversity, its embrace of a lively old -town future?
The changes ahead arei'mmense and time is not on our side..
As a community, we can do this!
Respectfully,
Pete Gang, Architect
Input Summary 2 -Page 183 of 185
t.h�z:
t'ut
t�% #PON S
i
Flynn Ppn::n\/
=I
1 '0
Hi Mr. Brawn -A
z
� N
s
;I
IN
uIla*
u,
r
�W4j"'j, r
Y111
'RI IF te
gralS
addition
to
�we
Imo! survey
16 i work,shoL^-i
P/
E
r, oa get
w Iso be driculating the nex, rafc oI
and priormes into Council for consideration.
coming lbacq
Thank,
,,d and
4. e.;.i .. �7 ablolut aur Gity.1
All m%, es
Peggy
Warning: Use caution before clicking any attachments., THIS EMAIL IS FROM OUTSIDE OUR EMAIL SYSTEM.---
Its
Dear Madam Mavor Members of C'Ity- Uouncil and City anagier.
� 1111 1
t,
is ¢.R,
Wr
. '
ION,
What a surprise! I found myself agreeing with 'yna Fischer concerning what needs: to be done. If there i s a FUNDING
sources and. _uses, meeting, I would like to be notified so I might attend. I would hate to miss it because I did not look at City
Council's agenda.
Input Summary 2 -Page 18,4 of 185
https:/loutlook.office365.com/owa/?path=/attachmentlightbox 1,,2