The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutMinutes 11/23/1982Petaluma Planning Commission Regular Meeting . City Council Chambers November 23, 1982 Petaluma Calif ornia Present: Commissioner Head, Hilligoss, Popp, Shearer and Tencer Absent: Commissioner Bond and Lavin Staff: Gregory C Freitas, Community Development and Planning Director APPROVAL OF MINUTES Minutes of November 9, 1982 were approved as submitted. I. JEFFREY - L. FREIBERG, ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENT - AUTO TOWING SERVICES (Tape 9 -182 Item 11.733 - To consider an environmental impact questionnaire for a Zoning Ordinance amendment. Item `.7.101 - To consider an application by Jeffrey L. Freiberg to amend Article 12 -405 of the Petaluma Zoning Ordinance to conditionally permit auto towing services in the C -C (Central Commercial) Zoning District. The public hearings were opened by Chairman Shearer. Speaker: Dick Lieb, #1 Bodega Avenue, Petaluma, representative of Bob Maser and Tim Hendrickson, owners ' of All Points Towing . The public hearings were closed. Motion introduced by Commissioner Head, seconded. by Commissioner Hilligoss, to recommend to the City Council to direct staff to :prepare and post a negative declaration for the proposed zoning ordinance based on recommended findings. AYES: 5 NOES: 0 ABSENT: 2 (Bond, Lavin) — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — Page 2 of 8 Motion. introduced by Commissioner Head, seconded by Commissioner Popp, to recommend to the City Council that it amend Section 12 -405 of the Petaluma Zoning Ordinance to read: 1r2 -405 - "Garages for auto body /repairs of autos; and towing services g when in conjunction with new automobile dealers, or garages for auto body /repairs of autos, and where visually damaged vehicles are stored i I ndoors. " based{ on standard findings. i AYES: 4 NOES: 1 (Shearer) ABSENT: 2 (Bond, Lavin) II. JEFFREY L. FREIBERG, #1 "C" STREET (ALL POINTS TOWING) USE PERMIT Tape 182 -292). I Item 11.735 - to evaluate an environmental impact questionnaire for a I se permit at #1 "C" Street. Item 1.373 - to consider an application by Jeffrey L. Freiberg for a use permit at #1 "C" Street (AP# 8- 069 -02) for the purpose of conducting a body shop and towing service. i• The public hearings were opened by Chairman Shearer. Speaker: Dick Lieb, #1 Bodega Avenue, Petaluma Tim Hendrickson, 1629 Lauren Drive, Petaluma The public hearings were closed. I, is Motion, introduced by Commissioner Popp, seconded by Commissioner Head, to direct staff to issue and post a negative declaration for the use permit at #1 "C, ", Street. AYES: 4 NOES: 1 (Shearer) ABSENT: 2 (Bond, Lavin) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Motion introduced by _Commission Popp, seconded by Commissioner Head, to approve a use permit for #1 "C" Street for a body shop and towing service, based, on recommended findings and conditions, with Condition #4's first sentence changed to read•, "All visually damaged vehicles, machinery, equipment, parts, tow trucks, etc., "; and Condition #5 added to read, ,' "This use permit shall be reviewed in one year." i AYES 4 NOES:. 1 (Shearer) ABSENT: 2 (Bond, .Lavin) . Commissioner: 'Shearer explained that she voted no. as she is opposed to auto body /town g- 1services in the C -C District. 11'7 Page 3 of 8 11M III, - ALFREDO RAMIREZ, 699.:PETALUMA BLVD. NORTH USE PERMIT � - DELI GROCERY STORE Tape .292 -350 Item 1.361 - to consider a use permit at 699 Petaluma Blvd. North for the purpose of conducting„ a deli /grocery store. The public hearing was opened. Speaker: Alfredo Ramirez, applicant, 500 Ormsby Lane, Petaluma Motion introduced by Commissioner Head, seconded by 'C'ommissioner Hilligoss, to approve a. use permit for a . deli / grocery store at 699 Petaluma Blvd. North based on recommended findings and conditions, with the following sentence add to Condition #8: This use permit will be reviewed in two (2) years. AYES: 5 NOES: 0 ABSENT: 2 (Bond, Lavin) IV. GEORGE C. BRADLEY, 420 HOWARD STREET - USE PE_ RMIT FOR ' ACCESSORY DWELLING Tape 350 -378) Item 1.372 - to consider an application for a use permit at. 420 Howard Street (AP# 006- 202 -06) for the purpose of constructing a 640 square foot one - bedroom accessory dwelling and appropriate off street parking. The public hearing was opened. Speaker: Charley Dawson, 2649 ."1" Street, Petaluma, . building designer The public hearing was closed. Motion introduced by Commissioner Tencer, seconded by Commissioner Head,, to approve a use permit for an accessory dwelling at 420 Howard Street based on recommended findings and conditions. AYES: 5 NOES: 0 ABSENT: 2 (Bond., Lavin) IV. DAON - CORPORATION, "D" STREET EXTENSION - PREZONING Tape 378 -590: Item 3.293 - to consider an-application by Daon, Corp, for prezoning AP #'s. 19 120 -15 and 16 (Dann),, 19 120 - 21 (Scott), and 19 120 - 32 and 33 (Lane) located in the vicinity of the West Petaluma Regional 'Park and "D" Street Extension. Page 4 of 8 119 The public hearing was opened. r. Speakers: Tom Jones of Brelje and Race, engineering representative of applicant Leo Lane, 1318 "D" Street Motion introduced by Commissioner Tencer, seconded by Commissioner Hilligo'ss, to recommend to the City Council that it find the previously prepared environmental documentation (1979) - as adequate for the proposed prezoning . AYES: 5 NOES: 0 ABSENT: 2 (Bond, Lavin) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - LO Motion! introduced by Commissioner Tencer, seconded- by Commissioner Head to recommend to the 'City Council that it approve the proposed prezoning baseds,on recommended findings. co i Q AYES: 5 NOES: 0 ABSENT: 2 (Bond, Lavin) r r' VI. GENERAL PLAN /ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN PLAN - LAND USE MAP AND TEXT AMENDMENT'S Tape 590 -671) Items 8.75/11.711 - Penn Phillips; 8.77/11.725 - Wise; 8.78/11.726 - Conrow; .8.82/11.734 - McCabe; 8.81/11.732 (General) It was the consensus of the Commission to continue this item at a special meeting on November 30, 1982. VII. PLANNING MATTERS (Tape 671 -678) i r The proposed workshop topics were reviewed. ADJOURNMENT . The meeting was adjourned by Chairman Shearer at 9:25 p.m. . Page 5 of 8 1-20 PETALUMA PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES NOVEMBER 23, 1982 JEFFREY L. FREIBERG, ZONING' * ORDINANCE AMENDMENT - AUTO TOWING SERVICES - E.I.Q. ITEM 11.733 FINDINGS 1. Specific impacts created by individual towing services would be considered and mitigated on a case by case basis. 2. Increased truck and mechanical.noise would not be significant on street and would be mitigated`as a use permit requirement on- site. JEFFREY L. FREIBERG, #1 C STREET - USE PERMIT - BODY SHOP AND TOWING SERVICE ITEM 1.373 I P ERMIT FI'NDINGS: - - - 1. The proposed use will conform to the requirements ° of the Petaluma General Plan/ Environmental Design Plan, and. with the Zoning Ordinance. . 2. The use will not constitute a nuisance or be detrimental to the public welfare of the community. a SE PERMIT --CONDITIONS- 1. Use permit approval for towing shall be contingent ' upon an amendment to the Zoning Ordinance becomming effective which would conditionally permit such use in the Central Commercial zoning,,,__- . district. - - 2. All existing on -site signs ..shall be removed and all' future :signs -shall conform with the provisions of .the City Sign, Ordinance. 3. The site shall be subject to site plan and architectural , approval in accordance with Sections 26 -500 and 26 -400 of the Petaluma Zoning Ordinance. Site improvements shall be 'installed to full City standards and shall be completed with all current applicable parking lot, landscaping, fencing and screening standards met prior to occupancy. 4. All visually dariagec vehicle m ch *rery, equipment parts, .e«a+ tc., sh_al1 be s tore 1 indoors . -No repair work -or storage; shall take place.outdoor:s or in the - public right �of -way. 5. This use permit .shall- be reviewed in one year.+ PL INNING COMMISSION MINUTES AL IT • 0 1 EDO RAMIREZ, 699 P 1.361 ITIONS: Page 6 of 8 NOVEMBER 23, 1982 VD. NORTH - USE PERMIT - DELI /GROCERY STORE 1. ! The site, and the proposed parking lot improvements at 701 Petaluma Blvd. North shall be subject to administrative design approval in accordance with Section 26 -400 of the Zoning Ordinance. 2. i All required on -site and parking lot improvements shall be come feted prior to occupancy of the building. I 3. I A minimum of five parking spaces' shall be provided in accordance with Section 20 -201 of the Zoning Ordinance for the duration of the I 1 use. 4. A daily litter collection program shall be undertaken to prevent the i 1 accumulation of outdoor litter created by the deli. 5. Sit -down facilities for the deli shall not be permitted without the provision of additional parking, and an amendment to the use permit. 6. �' f A trash enclosure screen designed to meet City standards shall be constructed. to the rear of the deli. 7. I All outdoor signing shall conform with the provisions of the City Sign i. Ordinance. 8. This use permit will terminate upon loss 'of required parking. This use f permit will be reviewed in two years. e 12 Page 7 of 8 122 PETALUMA PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES NOVEMBER 23, 1 GEORGE C. BRADLEY, 420 HOWARD STREET -,USE PERMIT FOR ACCESSORY DWELLING ITEM 1.372 Recommended Findings 1. The proposed structure will conform to the requirements. of the Petaluma General Plan/ Environmental Design Plan, and with the Zoning Ordinance. 2. The use will not constitute a nuisance or be detrimental to the public welfare of the community. Conditions 1. The project shall be subject to site plan- and architectural approval in accordance with Section 26 -400 of the Zoning Ordinance. 2. Rear and- side .windows 'facing the property line of the adjacent properties shall be view obscuring to fully protect the privacy of abutting neighbors. 1 r,•" J C i1LUM& PLANT . ,tea . i, 1 i" O CRPOR AT,".i� gar, —�_ , 1 NGS: s , I I'lo sig-.ificant aci r: pre- 7onin - as ;:"F -07- be- reviewed further I site. Z lCiclUate envirc>>o._ :_ action in that a p_ Impact .eport anc prepared _u C'ert_f)- I i i he City coaanc 1 l Y ' r j e CORPORAT I I INGS � { That the proppsed. � a rle_. Petaluma . Ge.neral P an( ar ;= I T hat the public l'! /.F visit' }: • - I C's :icly 31 t AT E1ST. .. ,�. . (71-1 - . 'ory C., Frel.ta5 `.•Ci:1iT71 J1'1`�,�`r';� � 211? 1�: ��TisP :i i. and + i I I ii Ii 12.3 Page 8 of .8 124, PETALUMA PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES NOVEMBER 23, 1982 DAON CORPORATION, PREZONING = ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTATION FINDINGS: I. '.do: •.significant adverse environmental effects will result from the ' prezoning, as proposed., which cannot be mitigated or which will be reviewed.' "further prior to any development plan approval for the site. 2. Adequate environmental documentation has been prepared for this action' =in that .a. previously approved site specific Environmental =Impact Report and the City Master Environmental Impact Report were prepared and certified for the density shown. 3. The City Council has considered any comments and mitigation measures received and finds that previously prepared. and certified environmental documentation adequately addresses the proposed prezoning . DAON CORPORATION; PREZONING (INCLUDES SCOTT, LANE) ITEM 3.293 FINDINGS 1, That - >•, -the proposed' amendment is in general conformity with the . Petaluma General Plan and any applicable Environmental Design Plans. 2. That the public necessity, convenience and general welfare require or - clearly permit the adoption of the proposed amendment. ATTEST: Greggo C. Fre s Community _ and Planning Director