Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes 08/26/1980- REGULAR - II. ET.ING % :30 :P :i:1;: CITY COUNCIT CII11P1)'I P.S, CITY HALL PET;iLUIL!V, CA_ The rlh.inning Co miss.ioa.i •cncoura`Tes .app'licaafs. or- their representative to be available- at the meetings to answer qu'esti`ons,- that no':, agenda items need be deferred. to .a, .lat.er date .du< . ' to. a lack of per:ti:nent: information. PLHDGE'I LEGIANCE; TO TH_E FLAG POLL CALL Comm,. Cavanagiz Head Lavin bpp Sheare:r Tencer 1,,'arit -e STAFF Gregory Ereitas;, Cciminui 1 . De elopnient -. &. Planning Director APPP.OUAL OT MINUTES : -. Minutes of,,,August 12` 1980, CORRESPONDENCE DIRECTOR REPORT': COMMISSIONERS REPORTS: :.a PUBLIC, HEARINGS I DIAMOND HEAD, INC. L. Public, Hearing to evaluate. .the Environmental u - S PEyTALUA4A BLVD :S =- Impact _ Quest_ionna re. for.. the following General/ E.: I;Q.,:; EVALUATION /`GENE)tAL, -_.. Env,ironmen.tal:Des, gh:° Plan -Amendments and P.U. D:. FLAN" (EDP) APIENDTIENT /: • rezoning. P:U.D! P.EZ UN; ING. `2. Public. Hearing to con the request to amend (11.561/8•,52, /3.249) the General and :Environmental Design Plan designations f'r.om Central: Urban. and Service. Commercial 'to, Urban= Dens_it Presidential (2 - .dwell'ing units / -dcre) with a bonus density of 'up to •l0,•addlt biiA' units /acre. "3. Public_ Hearing - b. c;ons,ider the. rezoning of AP No 0 °- 2'81 -52 and 5`5 from° C =N. (', e ohbor - ood' Com- mecca > 1) and a s, ' all of 12 -1 -6,500 to j P.U.D. (Rlanned Unit Development- for a 53 unit " elderly persons •housing pr.o,jett `to be located on the L.8. acre.sit'e. : TIADISOIv VI °LLAGE; Public Hearing to review tine Tentati, �e Subdivision (.4 APPLES DEVELOPPIENT)- Map for a 31 unit condominium development at the EDITH, A1`'D TIADIS01\1 ST>S- ` n_orth!east corne of Edith and' Madison! Streets. 'TENT�IT,IVL..11A1'; (Put�.hic hearii g ; opened /c1bsed' on ,S /.12/'8O)' (6 42: ar � PETALU' A PLA'1 M&e COi` ITIS`SION C GE *\ '1 TDA, EAU UST °2�6 X198 '., ' ^•.• DkAFT `I.LaSTER Ei��'LRONI El TEL.. fix, Yr ,' x? rx, ' Put�lic <hei1 ins to "consider„ the adequacy of:•';ttre '. LP`II'i�CT REPORT �� �., Di -att Taster } n�i�ronren`tal' impact' Rep.`o;rt prepared,. ' lb�'C'O tARC De'siSn •Syst'ems qi the' :iaplementta,t'ion ale. City's General _ P.lan,, •.- ..,. ... Tt1 CR) ti4 VINEILh, '.[INEPY- Yubli,c Herrin to,', consider a us;e - Permit for a 1314 - D ROS'S', wine. nal -ling operation to' be,.aoc_ated at: 13147D USE PLftPi -T Atp-OE R'o'ss Street•._ La. Cr.ema Vine'ra Vinery r-ece'ived a. (,1 2`80): Use Permit f "qr their p.res _na' lgcat one, at 1250 Ho •lin P:o'ad RICHARD` COLON190 Public Hearing -: to:. corisader..a variance request for' 343. 'lLt`Ek' STP.EET a :zero° • f ron-t_ and° `s.t e&t sid -' s'e't back f of : a, _VARIAf \`CE PEQUEST garage ,a•t . 343 Keller 'S,tree•t .5 PLANNING, 1`IATTERS ° ADJOURN11ENT • NOT' OFFICIAL UNTIL APPROVED BY, THE PETALUMA •PL'ANNING 'COMMISS ±ION .MIN „ TES PETALUMA PLANNING COMMIS_S';ION :AUGUST 2h, 1980 REGULAR 'MEET.I.NG 7:30 'P,. M'.. CITYV CHAMBERS PETALUMA, :CA PRESENT Comm. 'La `Popp, :Shea "Tencer, wane ABSENT:. Comm: : H'ea'd :r :.:STAFF ` Gregory r ` F,.eitas, Community DeVelopment.& Planning Director I Cynthia 'Bee ken,. Associate Planner: APPROVAL OF MINUTES Minutes -of August 12 were- approved as corrected,`. Page, 3, Madison Village'Tenta . ve Map,,; de lete ,las;t se tenceinsert - The <pub'lic hearing wa's postponed' to the meeting of , August `12,, 19,50. Io •DIREC:TQR'' S REPORT;- ` General P;1 °an Ain"endmen;ts The Commission is .following tle: policy.""se't by the . City-Council on General Plan changes in "wh'ich the staff would roces;s project's .that `need” a General ''Plan, change; as part of 'the 7 or 8 condominium type- prgjects received by "the riay'2 cu - off - .date. The present Commission: polic .ls that. G`en'eral `Plan changes will be: beard "on February 2nd'. In eases where applications are received, the; staff would bring 'these 'to, the Commission f6' `c6ns d'era,t- ion'in "the. eyen-t , the Commission might want to .set a - hearing at' an earlier--date. A request. `was- submitted. by Forrest Lindsay7, 215 a residential cafe b "r amend the General Plan Land Use Map from Industrial to North McDowell Blvd to ; - �� g y The •property is note in An, area where there isR any current . pro'j,ec,ts,. It would requife' annexation procedures- and other change§•. It Zip's mined ateeiy, �to 'fhe - nor -th o,f the Friedman .property on N' McDowell Blvd!-. .. _ It was the consensus of the Commission the "request; of Mr. `Lindsay to amend, the Gen�e'ral Plan be reviewed with!. `the others General Plan changes in February.'.. ' DIAMOND HEAD. - 718'• PETALUriA BLVD S; E I':.;. Q _EVALUATIQN (Tap` e 035 -63,7) Item 11 56,1 The :Planning Commisstion d "erected thee, .Community,Development Direet•or to, issue :eNe gat' ve:-- Declaration° for- the General. Environmental Design Plan Amendments P.0 '.D!. ; rezoning,. The .pub'lic• hearing wa !; pened'�and. closed Motion introduced by Comm Po seconded b Comm. Cavana h to d,rec't st to 4prepare a Negative Decla'r.at. on .for th'e prod ect based , on th e r'ecommend'ed- findings; AYES c 6' ABSENT: Gomm. Head' - MAD' - PETALUMA BLVD.,. S; GENERAL PLAN (EDP),,: DIAMOND .,.HE 718 ' M Ite�` m 8 5,•2 t:o. amend the Gen a and Enyironmental"Des'ig d n Plan esignations froip Central U_rbam and '` C'ommercia'l to= `Urban Hgh i Density 'Residential (20' well'ing units /acre):.with a bonus.,density of up to, 10 ad`diti =onal units /. • acr;e;. The,pub'li�e hearing was' opened and closed., Motion in, troduced by Comm,. Popp; seconded by _Cgmm. "Lav n •to lrecommend,:to tfie, "City "Council that it - rgve an- 'amendment -..to the General P`Ian (EDP,) d'esi'gnation„ .,20 :dwell_ing unitsVacre; with a bonus dens -t-y of •up :to 10 units/acre and that additional modif:icat ; ons to. PETALU11A PLANNING GOMMISS!ION" MINUTES. .' AUGUST T 26',. 19180 ' DIAMOND °`HEAD GENERAL PLAN (EDP:Y.AMENDMENT CONT''D '. the General, Plan be requested by the applicant. ;at.a later, da te,.. ^ AYES: 6 ABSENT':. Comm: Head Speakers : ' ;Dick Lieb, representing Diamond,' ,Head Donha,Ander,s6n, 24;85 .Petal Blvd' N Sfuari: ;Mullins; .728 Petaluma Blvd; S ° . DIAMOND 'HEAD := 718 PETALUMA,BLVD, S -• P.U.D. REZONING to_ con'si :. Item 3 24'9 er the `rezoning1'o AP ' No., 08 -281 :52; and from'C` -N` ,55: (Neighborhood Commercial) and a small portion. of R -1- 6,.500 to P U,.D. (Planned Unit.D:evelopment) for a 53:unIt elderly persons housing project. The public h ";ng was opened and closed, Motion introduced by Comm. ; Popp;. seconded by Comm. Shearer -to ; recommend to -the City Council, ;approval of 'the . rezoniri based -on, the recommended conditions w �th. the fo lowing g' 1- ,. modifications °,: ` ' Condition . 3 - d'eleted which read - `Minimum 125 square. foot :garden. .pl'ot, /per, ,Swelling unit. shall ;be provided on-site for at :least 75: percent of the living "unts. irk Condition '8 delete last sentence which read - In addi,t ori, ,all` pr,' Vate units; shall .be. specified for occupancy by the owner only,. - it ion 10- 'add -: Said ;modief;ications shal 'b:e subj,ect. to review by the . Site ;Plan. and Architectural Committee: Condition '11- add, - l -f the ' applicant I ' s proposal to dedicate wo units for:. g vety income elderly for 'the project: in lieu of the 161 Loderate units ° is approved ;by ;the City_ Council this. condition shawl become null -and,' d.. ' Condition! 13 add - A modified '.reduced :publ'ic'- stre,e't shall be; required `to,., extend from Fifth Street to serve the. vacant lands to the so,u heas;t''ds' indicated_ by the Community nevelopment and Plan nin'g.Director, with the :des =ign ' of ' of -the. street - to , the' ; approval: the City Engineer:: Condition 14 add - :.,Rig- ht...turn only : signs; shall tie• insatalled•at.each.,drive -:. way exit onto Petaluma' Blvd S`o-1, -h. AYES: _. $ ABSENT: Comm. Head MADISON ` VI_LLAGE_ (`4 APPLES,,. DEVELOPMENT) EDITH '& MAD:.ISON' = TENTATIVE MAP (Tape 6 ° 3.9 - 77`2') Item 6,. toconsder the 'Tentative Subdivision' M P for a 31`unit condo= f minium development, at Edith . :and, `Madison Street. T.he public 'hearing was opened `and, ,cloSed, ' .Motion introduced' by Comm. S;hearer°; sec•ohded by ..Comm:;. 'Lav, n, to to the C ity Council. approva_1 of the _Tentative Sub:d'ivision. :Map based on the`iecommended .conditions' and,f;ollow.ing modifications:, Condition 8 reworded:'to r ead -- 'Both.' Oak trees.- located at the end of Edith Street cul- de =s'ac bul -b shall be permanen,t.ly.pr.'ese,rv'ed an a'. healthy' growing condition „2 T-ETALtMA; `PIANNIN G II CbMMIS • MINUTES AUGUST 'I 00 .6 8 A'9 MADISON - TENTATIVE` M AP` �CQNTb MAVIS'W�, VILLAGE EDITH Conditiod �tOlWftded to read In order to avoid a b ions to, the My o -struc-t 'Flooh d_+ tak d `- d' . Y, h b c onstruction shah pl ace 1Pq e or over its boundaries. s The - ay' �g of ih'�a at ,portion of he f9ite lyd g: we !(toward the ;Petaluma ° River) -, of th'e, 11 connec't'ing �the f o ll owing 11, line _Qv;Lng wp points: the rpm p oint of the n4rthe ost, ex T.. isting Proper-, y l ine measured f eet f rom' the..I�enter­ of the r d' '(2), the point ' of , the. Madison St re et right of 'way),, an ropos.e Lf d back .'Of sidfeW a! , k on Idith-Stte,bt lying 527' f eet from the center of the 'Ma, righ*-6f�wa3i-.' No ing "fill or earth � :Madison .,t.rep.h ' re �_ moval shall. take e�­F!A-.00''d - and soil ace ,�,i�n . I f way dt8er..,that'mi . .. - _. -, - _. nimal grading t req=uired o . prepara ion - f or land's A statemeni-8­�in the maps and texts, s ubmitted , for subj which indicate c�ale the gradin g o f th e 'Floodway sha11 be deleted.. AYES 6 ABSENT i , :Comm; Head Emil Mog'��J, fj ogel Engineering allejb Street Lett6r from Emil d �&/Z6/80-� ;L err," 't - City Engi neer's referring to: dated t t- h e: F anning! r - /80 received le 8 � St aff Ropoht, -da�te� '8 'and filed It was the` consensus 'ol' .the , Co - a� mmis t D k- f-'t,:-'Master Envirohmental impact Report 'be ; placed l last-, on the Agenda - ;, LA CREMA' �S STREET-- USE 'P-E_RM--IT'T, V!'NERA.'WINE�RY', ROSS (Tape'_777 8'09') Item, 1. 280 0 "c ons der a Us& -applftafto'n, for- 6 , Wine making operation e - f c '6ned and closed. I to"bO' : located _k 13`14'�� Street. . T-4 )b earing,was 6, • p h Motion intrioduted, -'by q7 o mm 'e; seconded by Comm,. Lavin to 'gran a Use Permit f or 4jmine�"qakiii stibJec rec .,g� optet It t o' the. ' condi ions. AY ES: 6 Comm. Speaker:.` Rick La Crrma* Vi'ne'r'a Winery Par ther- CHA ST EET VARI �P " 43 M'COL OM90 -3 A�-`K(hLLER I E k t �u front 2 8 7 o cons u=,Vari-ance req.ue'&t,f Z J t', and s itk 6et side- f or a •zer yard se f back, f a g ar a e The a at 34.3 'Keller S publi : hearing was opened n M o , td Com ! h earer: to and clo on. Introduiced 'Comm C6 1. W Ite seconded- by,,, (Q.dm S grldrit' variance .. request based o t , re q n commended •cbnd "ons;•. ES:' ,AY.ES:" 6 ABSENT; . Comm He 1 of Protest 1 64.4s. recelved. 'and f iled, tj 3 DIAMOND;,, HEAD tTALUMA BLVD S NR t STREET E r ..I.Q.. EVALUATION .. ITEM 11. - Fi 5.61 - nding's _ 1. 1' Some tr_dsh enclosure's will be 1relopa ted to reduce the potential visual,, odor and,h61se disturbance ,to neighbors as. a. condition of rezoning approval. r, g. 2. T "raffle, eneratgd',by the proj'ec -,t will tly ; not ;s gnifican; impact on _. Petaluma Boulevard South -. ` r3 - pr'op,osed. 1' s`e wi.11,hehp to meet. the .much.'neeaed,'demand for elderly the City The architectural -design 'w'111 be regdr ed .-to be, more consistent with that of "the surizq ng - neighborhood as a, condition of rezoning :approval . Item 8'.,52 - Gene:r al :P Lan' (EDP` Amendment s)- Finding 1. The request. 'is consistent with the; general ;health, safety' and welfare of the - community,. ; and - , with -the in en't 'of `the :General' Plan. 'Item 3,2 -- P:.U.D Condit 'ons.. J. A minimum of,, one (1)- 'parking space per living unit shall be :provided on- site, All garages. 'shall- "be provided with ,remote c.ontro' ' garage door op;ener&, On=site!sidewalkks'and patio areas' shall be .constructed w th•concrete shall have `a texiured'non= =slip surface. '2. .Outdoor trash enclos.ur,es; sha 'l be ; relocated- away..fr.om existing .residential -, Property lines as: much ;as; is feasible; to reduce potential ,complaints. :3. Driveway curbs shall be' separ -ated, from exis'ti=ng, side and year proper-t'y lines: with a minimum of three (3); of landscaping Parking spaces curbing shall' 'be sep,ara;ted from existing side and "rear ,prop'er'ty lines with a, minimum of: five (5) ' 'of landscaping as required' by the City landscape policies:• - 4,: Perimeter fencing' shall comply with Section 23 202 • of. the Zon'i'ng Ordinan:ce,- and create a' f - in- fished. appearance on both _sides. 5. Tl'e project 'shall be. subj.ect to sate plan; and architectural approval in.' accordanee with Section 26 -400 of . the Zoning Ordinance` `prior to Tentative `Map ,rev-iew• F 6. R'esiden iai construction ;shall,'be designed to meet all State sound insulation 'stand?ards f(j"r, multi- :f'amily``housing to "the approval of the Community Development and ; Planning b1tect'or. - he pr:o'ject' conditions, covenants and restrictions (CCandR's) .shall be - 7. T _ ,- subject to.'„ review and ;appibval by the: 'City, Attorney prior to Final Map approval. Said 'document -shal "1: restrict the mitiimum age :of tenants to. i 62, years old,, and the maximum on -site automobile storage, to one per living tinier. a DIAMOND' HEAD - 'PETA'LUMA ,BLVD .S .NR `I STREET -. PUD CONDITIONS CONT`''rD -' 8. A. common mail receiving V area shall. 'be provided ''.in the xecre'at on ' building.• _ 9.. Exterior ' buiad'ing siding shall consist- l 'of' 'wood lap siding and minimum 5/8 inch plywood. (Sec,: 26 - :40b ,Al`) ., .The 'end builfding elevations facing Petaluma Bl -yd. ;South shall b'e. redesigned to. be mo. - -e compatible , I J w th,the: surrounding neighborhood in terms :of 'proportion, and 'three'- dimenslonal appearance (Sec: "26= 406 -A2, ,and 5) More' :decorative' detail-, 4 shall be designed into the window,, doo:r, and. stair detailing the buildings (Sec: , 26 406 - A1) The opening of the interior court- area at Petaluma B_. vd shall 'b6 enclosed with A, solid wall at least 12 -feet high for acoustical protect- ion'of the court a�r,ea. .'Said' modifications' shall be - subj ec6 to . r'eview by - the" Site Plan and, .Afthit,eatural.Committee., If the sixteen: (,16) moderate cost housing unit option, is .chosen, t'o sat sf.y the bonus density requireinent, the sale an'd res'ale� p,ri'ce, of: i established such'.dwellings shall he by the City Council. The proposed off�=site street ,connection to 'thee subj'ec;t `site , (as shown on the - Proposed Private /Public;..Stree Pattern" plan,.. dated 8/'7,/'80), shall :be required _ as .a `condition of R.0 „:D. zonin a., (oval. If the applicant's - g P,P ro,posal . p to dedicate two, uni'.ts for very low. in'c`ome elderly- for th'e project in ` lieu of' the 16 .mod'er i units a roved PP by - -the City Council, this condition shall become null and Void. ” 11: A minimum of six (:6) on -site ;cloth 'es washers, and dryers shall. be . provd`ed ' for common use.. " 12. A modified- reduced public , street- shall be' required; to extend. from is 1 Fifth Street to "serve undeveloped properties to, th'e south east of 'the i site :and as presented 'by the Plan-in& staff, the desi rn of the g public street shall be approved by the City Engineer and -,its .I -ion by the Community Deve- lopment and Planning Direc or with the understanding that any street design chosen which °would offset tte pr_nciple. design: < ...elements. of the- project would require redesign Wand.resubm ttal of the development.. plan to the Commission. Right, turn onl. si g ns ;shall be installed' at eacr _dr,iv onl - eway. exit Onto Petaluma Blvd: South:. . t al MADhSOM VILLAGE 4 ( - AP,P.LES DEVELOPMENT) T' ENTATIV }F , BDIUIS'ION HI P 3 • _:S _ _ Item' 6.'4.2;6 OpTi'dit- on - 1 " The appl,ie Yt' shall. comp'ay � m th ajl l° requ' rPme;nt's of tho ,Ciay Engineer . speeafied in the zttach`ed;. letter and s11AlI supp,`ly all 'necessary' -oR -site utility eus cements {a5requ'- irr,e`d =by P..G' •, & E ., 1 P'aciEe Telephone, and local " P Ie T,. V ,., t °o ;the f infa`' ap o f ,the C1 ty .Eng nee r 2 4 :. Grad' ng and storm; ;elr`iina'ge design shal -1, conform with' the requireme'n,ts of '. the..'Sonoma County• Waxer .Agency FLo`od Controla`D�sn Criteria. 3 - Durin he' course of develo ment `if a g - ' " p , . rctiaeohogical ma °teria'1s are :found', all wor:�c in -the vzc nit,, 'of, the find(sF' N _ 1: y )' shat be .'stopped and a qualif ied arclia eolog•i,s,.t contacted to ev,alAuat_e the mater als': acid' make 'the' ecommemda= tions for- mitigation as 'd'eemed neee'ssary. • 4,. Community F I_s .and` 'De r velEopment fees will be collected at th'e time building,; permits are" issued 5, The location ,number; 'and 'size' °oE 'on- site; fire hydrants shall, be .:determined. b yt 't4ie Fire • 6 ". l : . Any- necessary: pe rini s sia;al.l be ob tained from, the. U . S . 'Army: Cotr..p s . of ' Engineers ;prio >r to: the issuance ,o,E .any . - rad'ing .or building Permits; 7. P'riva3te street construction shall be sub.',e'rt to d'esi�n approval b:y the Cit,y')r'ngi "Weer;. .8 .Both, Oak 'trees ocat;ed at the ;end' of dith 5`Greet' cul -d' bulb shall E - be permanent y preserved. ;in- a heal`t'hy ?growing condi';tion:. 9. In ord °er'to 4 any o;bs;truc't ons to the Floodway, .no construction shall :take:plac,e inside or' ove, <r its', boundaries':. Ta;e Flq.odway. constis.ts of that . _ . _ site lying; nest (toward: the Ppp- alupia River) ;o,f the line" Portion ,o t'he ,,. .. connectin the _followin two oints: (1),' te the• northermost .g �. P ' h point of exist -ing p,rop,e;rty line ineasu:red 64:0 feet ,from the center of' . Madison h MADISON 'V — APPLES - DEVELOPMENT) IEN.TAPIVE MAP` "-It'em 6.' - Conditions' Conn'd Street right -of `,way, anal (.2,)' the �pointt o,f' the proposed. back of s', d'e= ` walk; lime on .Edditt Street - -ying 5127 feet from - thee ceriter_o the "Madison" S'tr:eet. right -of' =way. No grading,: fill or „earth r- emovaI - shall take, place ' °in 'the, ••Floo:dway, other than ;m_inin aI grading and soil preparation' required, for. land's.caping,: All .statemen.t's ,in h'e -maps and ;texts sArnitte`d for s ibjject: development 'cahich.,. ndicate the grading of: t•he. Floodway shal be. deleted. A1T driveways':,. parking 'spaces , :common open - space` and; yard 'areas not enclosed by :f`encing'shall 'be. owned and maintained' by the 'homeowner'',§ asa,ociat = ion, :. "the to lines ad'us.ted,'a`ccordng =ly,, ..: 11.. : _, The Location Maps shall be modified to meet all tegp rements• of Sect-Ion 20.16.05`0. The inter' "or - private loop street shall be given a - st`ree -t name in accordance with 'the.' provisions 'of' the S`ubdivs =ion; ,Or' fi'nance: ;The, Gommurity' Dewelopment_ signature block °shall be provided : on the :Tentatpe Map. . 12'; :The app'l'icant shall comply' with all •other applicable °C Ity regulations., b.l... RICHARD COLOMBO - -34.3 KELLER. STREET = _VARIANCE ,REQUES,T ilk htem 2.287 S. Peculiar-- and unusu'a'l .con& 'ions erea,ted` by tli,e slope ofc• the site exist° which• are 'su_ff'iclent to cause a hardship. Such cond'it'ions are 'nolt ..: common 'to all o;r most ,o of the, properties in the, immediate ,area. 2:. A hardship peculiar" .to ; the property and not, created 'by, any' act o'f the owner- exists. 3. A va is : necessary for the .preservation and enjoyment. of �propert.- r;igh.ts poss;esse.d.;by oilier • propprties in 'th'e' vic ni[y, and °if granted, would,, not cons.titut a special - privilege of the, recipient not, .en , ''d' .b`y oy his neghbors' 4. i. A variance would no be :of _su'bst`antial- detr mein to, z4dj °ace,rnt ,propert'y', and would not materially impair' the pu'rpo. "ses 'of the Zoning Ordinance .or the public interest,. Conditions 1.. The' proposal shall , 4e subject to site plan and arehltec .approval in' accordance, with Section 2' -400 of ;the Zbnin& Ordinance:, g g p rs and '.rol,l up dooxs shall 'be require °d as shown g.. di