HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 01/06/1970„
„
January 6,
1970
R'egula`r m:eetF6g of th.e Petaluma City Plan
r Commission was held on
January 6`, 197.0 at 7:30
o. c6�ock, p.m. in
the Counci'I Cham,b;e.rs, City Hall,
11
RetaIumaa, Cal' if ornia.
'Wate:;rs.
P'RESENT': Comm. Brunner,.
Koen i Perry;.,
Chairman Pau'I, R. Stan 1 ey
ABSENT o
APPROVAL OF M',I
The minutes for
the me ef t in of December 16, 1969,
`D`ECE +MBE °R - -_1 6, ;I' -969
were a:pp' roved as
s u,bm s tied .
CO!R R E'S PO N.D'E N C E,
1 ��REDG €„
IERNAR,D E. ELD
Th -e ,P;1 pn,n„i n.g, Di
rector read ° a I e`tte,r received from
.
PAR'EN'TS x TE&C-HER -S
M'r, „George Th�ut„
Pres i 4e�nt -of Bernard E. E I d.re�dge
'TO GETRE R :;�
Pa;re..nts &�Te�ach��er,'s
Toge ^thee, express i ng concern
A l
over p o.s,sj b 1-e p�ro,posia
I s' I regard i n,g• h i gh dens i ty
hour °i ng i'n t�h,�e
east -er•I y s i ons of "the City of
�
a
rn stems from the fact that
t h d, Nd'ob,e
o , , D i's tri c 'cannot provide
°
the- n,e(cOsisary'sch
ooIs. to, ja;c;commodate the additional
chi Idare.n"� 1'ivi,ng
i,n th,es,0 'hi,gh. dens housing units.
Mr. Lorngak;er. Princ;ip
-at Bernard Eldredge School,
`
w;.as pres,en't.. M
McG i ver” n.:. staged the letter was
dl'r.ecteA as a J_
u.); of, a propio'saI by Young America
Bu I' I d_ hg Corpo`r�at
i o °n sub,m i,tted to the Planning,
C;o�mm i :s y s i o t
has n ot" y et b�e ,considered due to
4
t.h7& d,e�s i res of
l a ants to present an a.l ternate
the; app c
"
or re'vosed pro °posa'L,.
9 ce- Cha'irman Koenitzer
stated the You�n�g
Ame H omes. proposal fo proposed
tn
g !ensI y u
d
its would be considered by the
°
�� lanni�n, Comm arson
P ° g
o� Feb r'uary 3, ,1970,
�
1
' SiON COUNTY'
The Comm i sa i on
rev i wed a,n app I i eat i on f i 8 ed with
REFERRALS
the Sonoma County Planning „'C:ommission by WiIlow
Creek Or i es, Inc. for' a division of land (into 3
W 110w . Cre
p'arce:I°s) .16' ca:t6d at 5.22,5 0I d R dw:o'od Highway, A.P.
Propert i es, I ht
#''47 2,i 1 0'. M,,r.
KcG I vein stated the 'P I ann�i ng Comm 1 s-
F'i` I e # 1 74°4
swi, on. had re i e4ed Cou�n ap,p I f'cat i ons for a us pe rm'i t
and r�ezon i n,g for the sam;e: :area `at their I a:st meeting
a.nd had f. certa'i n recommen,dat i,on.s to the
Co -unty -A; d.i scount st':ose i s pro. - posed t:o ;b,:e located
on th;e siie. the P9a - ni,n'g Director, state,'d a study
"Denman
of e, artea surround I n Xthe I nterchan g e
the ent'e r.
Ls n.o;w y to determ i'ne thb,e t land u se. He
I:
,,underwa
f'uPrt.her stated
certa -'n bou,ndarL es wi I I have to be _
estab,V Vs so
al :1 property owners w! I I know the
p'oten,tia,I of the
Ar property and h,ow they may, us,e it.
*_
i , n "c o r' po-ra to d a.r e a, i t
A I thou`gN the area - i s .i n the° uni
f
r,s wa th i n the sphere of I n ,,f l uen'ce of t'he Petaluma
Area Genera I P - ,1
an µserved w.ii'th City .ut i 'I i t i es, anal
,
ma b;e ann.exedJto
fhe aty C in the n:e.ar future..
i
P.Ianning Commission
January 6, (00
Martin A.
s 'Permit
F 1&.: 5165
Gay.ri Koff
'Bio- .Controls';
F i, ,I e# 5 .I 5 3
Inc
Minutes
Mr. VonRa es'feld and Mr.'Horace Henris, representing
Wi f.Iow.Cree &k Pro'pe.rtias, Inc., were present and
asked several lquesti'ons. In answer to a question
from Mr. He:nrIS, Mr. IMcGivern explained the
proposed Ivt spI it pos =e.d. s;.everaI technical problems,
such as access t.r� the proposed parcels, shape of the
parcels, etc. FoI'lo ng further discussion, the
Comm4 ss i on upf, e I d th -e sta'f ; ' recommendation to
request the :County P Commission to delay
action on the ,app Iication until January 22, 1970 in
ordier to give,the Ci Staff time to determine the
best',lan.d use the area in question.
The Commission reviewed the use permit application
f,iled with the Sonoma Cniant Planning. Commi b
Martin A.. .Ga to permit storage facilities
for boats, t,ra;i lers, car >,, etc. at 306 McDowell
Road, North
Mr. McGivern ilnform.ed the Commission there is a
d:eJinite need for this type of use but was concerned
about allowing the proposed commercial use without
proper cont'roll. If the use permit was granted,
periodic review of the' operation by the County should
.be 'm,ade to ass'u.re c o m p a t i b i l i t y with the de °ve I opment
trend around the subject site,. Mr. McG i vern stated
the Petaluma Alrea General Plan. designates Limited
Industrial zon n,g for the area. In the event the
s i t e i s_ anne,xeld to the City, the, use could become
non - confo Mr. Gavriloff was present and said
the odd - shaped parcel, ad.,jacent to a railroad, would .
not lend itself to any other type of use. A#te,r due
cons i de r_at i on, a mot -ion, re I commending approval of the
use permit to the S >noma County P l a n n i n g Commission,
with the con'diti ihat .1 c- and fencing be
provided to improve the aesthetic value of the area,
was introduced by Comm. Perry, seconded by Comm.
Waters and passed by the following vote: Brunner,
Per - ry, Wate.rs j Abstaining: Vice_ - Chairman Koen i tzer
(due to financial involvement); Absent: Chairman
Paul R. Stanley.
Mr. McG i vern stated the subject r e f e r r a l for a m o b i l e
office trailer to be Iocat;ed at 14:64 Middle Two Rock
Road, wa,s not received in: time to ''be i nc.l uded in
the las Pla.nnling Commission meeting of De ce mber,
1969: ( -This refe�r.ra*l was acted upon by the County
on December 29 1969 ) Mr. M'cG vein read a favorable,
staff report f'o'rwarded to th,e County on this applica-
t1on..
-2-1 .
i
I
GOLTE'RMAN.N
SITE` DESIGN The Comm'i :ssio :nire.v'aewe'd the site pl.an.°.for a duplex
FILE .# 5: 149! t b'e` construrcted by Ken G'ol to :,rmann at the corner of
Howard an,d Pros'p Streets (25I &" 253 Howard)
- 3-
P'f an:n i ng CommSi ss i on
M i nutea
�. J'a n u a'r y '6, 1970
1
H, y. �B"arb;o °n i ..
i
The sub jest use p.e:rm i t refe-,rra I'- for a -.mob i I,e home
Fi I e # 5 14 $
at 1 1.9 Safi Antonio: Ro °a_ time
ast Comm'issn
to be i nc I:ude,d i n the I` g on
meet l n.g., of December i 96:9.: I n . or'der to be co'n-
s i:sItent. rexga.,rd i ng r:emfer-,r'a'I'_s Ln v o l vi ng - mob i l e homes
on s i n-9 e I ots'
the staf f forwarded a Fetter recom-
,
men - d i ng" the us,e
Permit not be granted.
n
OBERG RESTAURANT,
s
fsOOn i&V i : ewed ' the s, i'te design plans
DES GN
SITE I
submC mm, he. r. ehab'i h i tat on and .remode l l i n g
F1 LE # 5,. 1 47
° g . g
o�f a °n bnf i n,i shold e,x.rst'I n b;u i L,d l.n - I oc "ated at' 50 12
Pet a 6uma B I vd... INorth :for the p,ro,posed_ use as a night
c I ub resta,ur' nt A' st'aff rep:o:rt, .ncorporat i ng the .
requii; oft the Fire Chief and City Engineer was
'
presented by M•r�.
Ande.r's,on� Mr. Ly'I e Hood, Arch i tect,
and .Mr Jim 'Obe
develop r°, were present and
1. g.em6r6 l I y `ag.reed to th.e reiq;u i �rem0nts •out`I i ned i,n the
-
s'taf f a °n „d Ekh i b i t” " A" except for the require-
'The
„rep.ort
me.nt for A. C.e pjavIng f,o'r• th:e ent i re parking area.
Comm i st's i on mod Vf i e;.dp th:e. req,u i r.e`ment to i nc,l ude A.C.
paying' f or the d.ri'veway a rea to the s to and around
the bui' Y`d i ng, and ar "mor` °coa i.ng 'for a portion of
the park i ng area. A moti on a p,pro.v i ng the s i to
'design ;as mo,dlfjied on.Exhrbit ".A ", vas introduced
•
by .C'om:m, Perry,l seco,nde „b' C "' Brunner and pass "d
b a6 "I mein,b,e;.rs ,prese'nt. . ".
CO -OP CREAMERY
The 'Comm i;ss i on Irevi ewed th.e site ,plans submitted
S :ITE ..DES 'I GN
C.I,op G.: jeamery fbor the.. construct i on., of a
F I L E # 5 . 1 4 8
40 OQO a n g I"o sto'r'e -up, tank ap!p - o,x i ma te I y 55 feet h i gh
b e "s i d e t h;e- e x -i "s t i n'g c re a m e'r:y b , u i 1 d i ng located a t " t h e
so.lithwe,st corner oaf W.e!stern, Av -ensue and Upham .Str "eet.
T,h e s +a f f 1� e pro I t j T ,d0c:ated t h.e s i t e is l o,c a t:,e d� in an
M -S (S,pec i,a l I ndustr1 ajl) Z,o)ne` whi ch does not ha a
m.axim'um h,e,i'ght
I I im fo.r a :c ;cess.o ;r°,y structures. After
due cons i d < <srat i ;o�n .and i n vlfiew of the fact the zon i ng
nce erm tits the proposed nsta,l l at i on, .a Mot i o"n..
ord i na` ;p
appProv iing thfe s i to -.d`es i�g ;n -° as s.ho.wn on Exh 1 bit "'A ",
with tihe co,n,d'i that th tank 'be painted a co'Ior
compa'rab Ise to the adJac -e nt tanks, was i ntroduced. by
Comm,;. Perry, .sec :o by Co'mm... Brunner' and pas -sed by
'a: l ;J 'm em,b e.r. s; p r e s e t,.o
I
GOLTE'RMAN.N
SITE` DESIGN The Comm'i :ssio :nire.v'aewe'd the site pl.an.°.for a duplex
FILE .# 5: 149! t b'e` construrcted by Ken G'ol to :,rmann at the corner of
Howard an,d Pros'p Streets (25I &" 253 Howard)
- 3-
BAN E NGS I ON A gent 6 e ma n i dJ pq :R .i o V 1 sta Way add r6s
thse Comm i &s Von ask f n g 0. irez"t- i on; about s top p i n g the
ergs i o:n, o I -a a I o the Peta 1 R i vb r i n 't-he
L inda D e l Mar ' S u b d i v i s i o n . Th Commission was
symp c but i h f - ov'rfi e�d -t-.h,,e - gein t I e m e n the h a d n o
j u r i's d 1 c t 1 on r e,g ar d i n g th p ro b I e m Mr. M;cGivern
rdf;eLrr,e,d h i m, to, -th Sonoma County F Control and
Wate Cons�e,rva D s-t r i ct
,A1DJ-O;U:RN T'hvere b,eAng :no futthe r 'b us i n,e s s to come ;before the
C&mmissi�on, th e me-e1 was adj
Vice- Chairman, PI
Commission
AI
A °t t=est: ��(
Wj C- McG i ve'r-n*
P I'a nn i n,g C o m m i s s i o n
M i n u t e s '
�O 72
I '970
,J an ula ry 0
Mt.
,
McGiver'n st the pf.ob al, me,e-ts all the
pos
requirements
of',th-e Zoning Ordinance. A motion
ap
1 v v i : n g s i t o des:i-gn as, s.zhown. on Exh i b i t "A" w,as
i
by Gomm. Walters,, seconded by Comm. Perry,
and
passed by PI I mem'b�e P=res,ent.
.PQ.PU,LATION ESTIMATE
Mr.
M c'G'i ve r n gage a, brief s of the results
of
thee, survey c,ond,uc,te b th,e. State) Department
of
Fin i n A,bgus,t. of 1969 oJ our recent poou I.a.-
t ion 0, A wri ttpR r w i I I be f orth i ng
BAN E NGS I ON A gent 6 e ma n i dJ pq :R .i o V 1 sta Way add r6s
thse Comm i &s Von ask f n g 0. irez"t- i on; about s top p i n g the
ergs i o:n, o I -a a I o the Peta 1 R i vb r i n 't-he
L inda D e l Mar ' S u b d i v i s i o n . Th Commission was
symp c but i h f - ov'rfi e�d -t-.h,,e - gein t I e m e n the h a d n o
j u r i's d 1 c t 1 on r e,g ar d i n g th p ro b I e m Mr. M;cGivern
rdf;eLrr,e,d h i m, to, -th Sonoma County F Control and
Wate Cons�e,rva D s-t r i ct
,A1DJ-O;U:RN T'hvere b,eAng :no futthe r 'b us i n,e s s to come ;before the
C&mmissi�on, th e me-e1 was adj
Vice- Chairman, PI
Commission
AI
A °t t=est: ��(
Wj C- McG i ve'r-n*