HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 03/03/1970PE, T 8 LU M A G I I r P L ANN IN G GOMM,I 5S [ON MARCH 3, 1.970
e
REGULAR 'MEEJING :1 FI&CAL YEA R
: COUNCA'L-CHA*BERS, CITY HALL
7 :30 0 C'
LOC K P°..M. PETALUMA,, CALIFORNIA
ROLL C ALL Comm Br'U h n, er Ka.e n I, t zer Perry Waters Stanley
STAFF: W i 1, 1, i. C,. M'PGiv"e Dfrector of Ptanni,ng.
"An A:nderp
'sn,-,, Ns:sfst n'
ant Pla"ning"D,i,r;ec'tor,
APPROVAL OF M I NUTE'S FO'R F E8 R ARY .17, 1, �'9 7 0 .
GORREr-,S
VONS EN Mil LL CO. '&p p I i c i on,, f I -eA by VonsP;h Mill Ing Company for a
USE PERM iT use . permit to mpdffy and efnl.&rge an exist'ing
FA LE U�5 -10 O t eAl at 205 'Second Street in a C-S
tu'i I .- d I n�g I oca
(S'eiry i ce Commer!c i a I) -,Kon:6. (Confl nuatioh of public
h.6 ar I. n g from F615. .17,, 19701'..
M A.U'R F EN D.IAMBROGI App A icz�t ion t 1 Ie,d M,a,,uree.h D'Armbrogi for a use
USE PER1417
Perm t to 0 low a 'home oc�,(;lu:patlon for teaching
F -L E U6 = ,7 f 1 or arra craft
' s at 108 Maria Drive Fn
an R - -6,00
0 Zone. PUB°L FC H Ekk I NG.
�`. DONALD WIIL 'EY
I S I I c tj o,n f I Ved by Dona:ll d R., WI I sey, f or a use
UtE PERMI'T p_er�rfl,t to al low!, a 'home occupation to conduct a
F I. L E: 07-'70 - commercial'
and te c n I c;a I art :service at 28 La Cres-
'D r 1 v!e 'in an R-i-6,000 zone. PUr
B HEARING.
V NN B,EB'BER A p px requested f or a m nor revision of the
SIJE bl�sfGkl s i te p,I I &n: f a. machine shop at 7l.5 Petaluma Blvd .
R.EV SED So uth 11 n a n M - L
Lim ite,d lndiustrlal) District.
"FI 5. 150 P r6ml o,u �s I y ap.p,�oved -on 2:
FOOTH.i LL.,MAN'OR F I n I . _M I a 0 6 , p P r;OV 6 1 . f or Footh 1 1 1 Manor U n i t 3 SUb
UNIT' 13 d i v 1 s 1 O.n f J l e d by Gan4 I o t t i E n te,r p r i s e s i, I oc,a te d
F NA L m on BbUA,"eVar'd N6,rtth. ➢
, RES 4�7
6F "-was *.
R�E'PQ_,RTS BY P,L,A I NO D I REC _Rf G,A,R D l N G: -
Meeting hp I'n 'Santa Ros by the Division' of High-
ways to dis'cuss I a proposed transportation study for
Sonoma Coumty.
I
Mbdul6 & Rob I I es Co held in San Fr'ranci,sco
March 3 , 19
R;e.gu I;ar meet o,ng .of, . th Pe!ta'1 um 'C.I t y' P I an i h,g C.obm i ss i on was he1.d on
Ra;rch $, ,1`970, of 7.30 -o -' cloc.k i: n the Coun I Cha mbers, `City Ha I l
-Pet,a.I uma, ; Ca I i forn4:a o
PR'E:S . ENT: C'omml's.s,lonen Koen B'run:n -er, .Perry,,, Wate:ns
AB SENT Ch i rm,an Pa,u-I' R Stan I ey .
P r M I asTE The , m1 nudes ;for 't , me.et1 n.g of February 17, 1970,
w e
pp r i bm 6 tt`ed o
C0'RRE S'PON DEN CE
RU BL I__C, UT LI'T 8'E ,COMM,I S,S 011 STATE'10F CALIF °O:NR 1 A
Rr MCG i vern read a :notice recO ved f rom th+e. Pub I 1 c 'Ut i I i t 1 es
..Comm i`ss,i on, State o•f, Ca f f i=onn i,a l nform'g'ng t-h ,Pac_! i't Gas 8
E &c c .Compan and :a I; I 'i,nter°ested' pe.? -t l;e.s., o.f . a .p:u:b I i c
hearing to be .he -I'd o Nosy i I 2nd '& 3rd, . 11.970 i r ,S .Francisco
re.] at i ve to 1 ncr:eas i'ng they r rates. .arid charges for e I ectr i c
se ry I ce o
V0.!NSEN M I L L1 N.G V 1 ce Ch,a l rm;a Koen itzer cont 1 nue�d the pub I i c', hear'i "n g'
C0.. US E PERMIT to. con.s1 A r. t'h'e ap°pI.ioa f Ied :b Vo,nsen M I I ing
ILE U5 7�0 Come pan y .tor a us,e permit t , modi'fy a"nd. enlarge an
; F :�
e�c a;
st'o n`g bu i 1.d I rig I ocat °e:d at 2,05 Second Street, i`n a
Service, G.ommer .la - I Zo Mr - M cG'ive r n- read a letter
re'ce i v;ed. f�rbm 'Pau 0 X. Le.w i s, U i ce. = Pres1 de.n.t of
Vonsen' °Fee:d & Mil 'I i'n Comp:an which stated as
fo1: @ows:
"W e w;&u I d 1 1 k -e too r e c i �n d r e g u es t for
a postponment :for M'arc?,h 3r.8 We are
doing, thls „ requ.e.st of• - 't °he'- commission
5 .th :t'hey may :st "udy th:e> s4t;uafl a,nd
clo�ns,1 de r `° -ezo.n i ng o'
V i 'C' e1 Ch: -atl rma'n Koen i t':zer stated fo-r the" r eetord,s that
the- ComM :i ss .g._b n h not ta'k,e,n, an.y act_;on ' on” t'hl s
matter.' 7N r° = M cG l v e r:n s a tle,d. i't ' .w as h �e s u n d r°'-
stand i n ;g thd.16pp I l carat had c o n ' a.cte�d-•on:e, . or posy i b l y
two, C:o,mm o s's *0p e r.s rega,rd,i mg tta i r app'I. 1 cat 1 on m It
was -the: consensus of o:p,i'n`i,on a study s' &ss 1 on wou l d
be sch °efdu I',e,d to dieterm i ne $'he best I and. ,use or zo:n i n;g
for the ar�e b,etwe 2nd Street, D" „' " the Peta I uma
Flyer° (,and.,'so to the Kres M Coo, ): A mo
to cont th pAI4 h "ea,r -1 hg on the use.. perm
Ap,ri I 7,: 1970,' was lntrod-uced by Comms io,ner ':Waters,
1 seco6 d -by .Comm L,`ss 1 oner Peirry, and passed by ,a I. I
membe4rs' present.
YAUREEN WAMBROGI
US PERM I T
FILE: U6;..70
.V(ce irmzD Ko,evni'tzer - bperfb,d the p U:b I i c hear i ng to
cons Vd e r th e. a if, i c af ii o f it eld by Maure - D I A.m,,b. , �rog I -
'for a h.oae occupation tip a I low the . te;achiing o floral
&rran,geme,nts and craft's 1`6 heir r6s I deh�ce 3t 108 Raria
Q'r� i ve i n an R-,I Z.o"ne. . T Ke staff report, made
part of the - _permia , nen , t record, indicated the home
occu on vi I 'I. M e t t hiO.: r e q . u i rements as,. out lin in the
Z o nJ h. g . Gr d in -a n ce 'f or h�6m o cc.u. p. a- t I o ns a n. d no s i - g i i i f i can t
a 0 1 t i o' I n 6 1 t r a f 4 1 c W :1 tl 1 be g nE,� r'a t e . There was no
o to t itle r e q 4els t The pub I i'c hearin w
ctl,olsed.,.. A mot I, b,n , a.p p, r ov 1 n:g t.h , ie. u .(subject
to the - t - nd i t i bins. ,O:u,t I i1ned In t'he staf ,
I P I I F.. - . rb!p.ort) was
introduced by Comm [ssianer &.runner, secgrid I ed .by
Comm i i one:r Vaters and"passedl unanimous - ly. Mr
D"Ambr gl W-as p and' voiced objections to the
co.n d i t ' on's of a p p'r ov a
DONALD WIS V I ce-Gh a i rmian KoenJtz 4
e ri opened t he pub I i c hearin
US"E PERM I T to 'co.ns 1 cl:e the app I �i cat1o�n frii l&d by Donafd Wisley
'
FI 07-70 to ai'l. I. ow OF tome o cc u a t 1 on. to conduct a commercial
a t e c h n i c a l I art s e r v i ce , 1 n '�a,n R-1-6,000 Zone at
2�& La, Cr_&sta_'Dr The staff rep,o.rt. indicat.ed the
fol. lo,win, g' 3niformat.Aon:� the &p p 1 c a n t wi I I be the sole
p 'oprietoir contact` h iF s c 1 i e n p
by to and
r
w 1 11 p`i ck• up and 'del iver th art wor-k to his` customers;
th,.ere wf
I'D pe no phy.sic,a[ a' r lte to the b.uildinq;
n o (s tock - 1,n! d e w 1! 1 1 :b e in vo Vve:d The staff recom-
menA.ed a of, the use permit sulbject to the
'foli owiin g c,o,h d i t i o*n,s
I. The: subject homeii occupat'ioq .shall comply with
the standards foir home accupati'ons at all times.
2. - CU 1, s : 'tome,r contact sh a b.e made by teleph,one
- or mail]', a' i-nd 'alil work shal I be picked up and
d e l i v e r e d by the a p p ica n t
3. The subject home 0 &ha If be required
to h,,aV,e further - review by. the Planning Commission
Af the manner :of. operation is.,changed in any Way.
Mr. Wal Min.ogUe, speaki ng for hTmseAf •and three
or four otih home o'wners re.sidin in the. area,
Vo to a1 Vow in,g- a.,'commercia . 1 0 n
pl,rc i s e , in�the hei.0b.orho.od'. , H,.p pointed, .out the area
is one of the.• b'etter resfden:t sectiion:s-An the
.City, 'kttlh the p' own,e:rs p. i n,g , -f r,om $500
to &10&G- t ax Os :a ye&r. M1r Minogue also mentioned
the ..diff it,u par-kin.g probiltern in thz
Mr.. the a:pV111 cant, :. addressed the Commis
He eonf irme fl;re: he wo.ufd be the onI,y one
cre;a,t i ng a Ry _tr6ff i c to the. . area a,n•d; that no ph i ca.1
afteiration to his' ho se wo uId b e . miaide j , a s i n d i c a t e d -.
'I n the • s t a f f •. r e,,p or t. V 1 c e - C 1 rm,a Ko:e n I t,ze r c
the pub I ic heari n, i ,,g., The 60mm
s, is i bin , g,ener a I' I y agree
then Co:nd i 't:i o n i mpo_7ed by the staff would ad.eq ua;te I y
- co ntro 1" the. op_er8t ion
Res o lution U7 - 70,, g r ant� i ng...the;.us"e permit with the
co`nd i t G ons. out I' i ne . by. th,e staff, was introduced ;by"
Commissio,n,er Wagers,;. seconded' by Commissioner B r u n n.&r
an d' p,assed b "y th;e f "o`l 1 wing. vote : Ayes : Brunner,
Ko :enitz er, Waters, Noes. Commi Perry.
Absent: Chairman Sta.nle'ye
V BE RBER: The Gomm s s.'sa.'on cons`i,dere.d the rev s s.e:d s i.te �p 1 :ans
SITE DESIGN sub :mItte:d by Geo °rge Van Beb,b.er° fo °r a mach °tne shop
F I L E 5. 15,'0 to `b locate . , .d " a't 7 L';5" P e t a 1 u ma B o.0 V e va, d S o u�th ,. The
sub,J "ect site: des agn. f;i:rst approved on February 3, 1970,.
showed "the mach i'ne ,:s'ho °p b u G G ^djG:ng to be located with a
front y °ard setback i'n e-xcess of 35 feet, with p ark i n,g
in :fro n.t Of th.e bui I:dingo The appI icant now proposes
to 1 oc;ate the bu i d.i rig f_orwxr.d' to the r
y equ i r.ed 15-foot
'a setba I G"ne. T6 i;s w'i' 1 I a B l ow for f "uture addition
to the of the mac:hi.n:e shop an -.d avoid the appear -
an..ce .of,.a par_k.ing lot in "ftro of the bu-ilding.
Th'e. p roposed d;sb o;f the , ad �,a ent p =a.rk i ng. area w i
prowo de; s,,afer -, mo:r.e u"sab 1e .parka ng spaces. The
Comm Pss'ion, v:o ii ce no O�A P 's v `t`i :on. to the revised p I ans .
M B.ergstedt:, repr es,e.nt'ing the .app I i cant, was present
• an:d ,a 1 so ag to t'he ,rey i sed. p.1 a ns as shown on
Exh,.i,bi't` "" as prep&r by the.staffa A motion,
app ro v1, mg tKe rey i s :e pi1.,ans as shown on Exh 1 b i t " AJ ,
was i n t rod :a c e d 'b y C.o.mm'i ss, i ,o n e:.r `P e'r y; sewn -d e -d b. y
Comm iss 'ioners "Waters, a.n•d pas.s,ed by -a11` members
present
F'0 '0TH'I LL MANOR
Thee.' Cd(hml s ±s'i cons ,i dered the f i`.na I map f or Footh i l l
UNIT # 3
Manor, U :n.i't' Su (su.6mGtted by A.
F'I;NAL MAp
Cond i ot't`i) •' to .be o:cat&d on, E;l y Bou 1,evard South .
RES. 4; -
(The f" :hOG `map inc-1ude,s 58 D °ots)o A report_ was read
from the, u 1'i c 'Works Depart ment, wh i ch stated the
map comp I i et w'1 t a I I the requ i re'ments 'o.f tlhe I aw,
ex -t-- -that th;e peel i m i`n_ary map f i 1j ng , repo -rt ,indicates
di f fe'rent owne.rsh G p than that sh ".own _ on- th )e map. The
report f'ur -'her states the PubA o - Work"s Department
w1 ; ,I0 n,otify the City that b :e °f,ore s i gning the
fG na I map =ow "ners;h i p of the T�and rWs't be i n:
a,c;c o r:,d'a n.c e w'i t h t a t. 's h ow..n= o n t h 6, m a p - a.n d the a m e n d'e -d
t[t.l e 'pe;port dated Feb ru;a,r 26 , 1'970 a
Reso ut,i on 4 -70, �a pP. ovi n,g t -he f iyna-0 - map. of Foothill
Manor U.ni t 5, su,b,yect to the - con�'d 1 t i ons stated: i n " the
' I
o "rkIs De t
.;rpp tA,,, wa -s introduc6d by
Comma ssW PerF - -
seconded by C,o,m�m�iss i
'
and assed. b a 1 p'Y _B!run.:ner:
p y ,1 me p res -e.nto >.".,,
r
G'AS:A GRANDE
The C.o:mm i,s. i oner co ns 1 d'.e.Rred, the' f i na I map of Casa
• UNIT TWO
a
Gr ndP 5u,bdiva Unit 92, submitted by A.
.F I'NAL. MAP,
Cond-i ott i,. The subd i v s h on: .s s I orated on South: Mc-
Fl LE : '5 -70
Dowe I I Boulevard and i nc;I ud,es 103 1 ots A report
su:bm i tted iby the :En'g n'e =e ng Department `a ndl,cates
th<e; map t'o be_ co rr ect except the pr°e I im i nary map
i ng; report i n.d i cat,es di fferent ownership than
those on the map They' w,-! I ?. notj fy t'h.e _Ci Clerk
"
t:h'at bef«o�_e sigh 1 v of the ne i map, the owner-
s "h i p o4 the ,,1 rwus't' b e u.n accor dance with those
shown.- on. the map .). Re+s ,. 5-70
a l ng the. f i na 1
map. as„ ° i nd:i ga ted .i'n the Pub I 'I;c: W;o'r'kI s report, was
i:ntr'oduce=d ,b -y Commisslonrer Pe'rry, seconded by
Comm,lss`.ioner Wate=rs, and passed r all members present.
S`TAF'F RE;P0RT�S
D,., v 6 s i vn : o. - H i tj:hways Tra.;nsp:o- rtati'o,n Stud for
S o nom a _Co u n.`I
Mrs.' Mc•G Vn,f.ormeld t'he Gommi :ss,i on of a meeting
he at 1 n Santa R.os. l re i:ati ve to the D vi s'i on of
'roads
Hl ghwa.'y M:aatev P , in of and h i ghways for
Sonoma County ". He stated a c.om'mj ttee was ten.tatl ve I y
's.e;t up, comp r i sed o f ya`r° °s ours re:p.re i ves of
te:.,hn :ca1, s Ioffs o .,a I4 the cwfii;es in Sonoma County, ,
_
togeth.er with rep res:enf`atoye -s from the Regiona
Tra.nsp,o'�ta " - EO:n Comm�ss.�on., and the Division-o'f Highways.
The Commi itee will 0 eyam_i`rie the various facets in t,raff i c
z that w i 'I I be: set ;up: to >st.ud'y= fh e traf f i c
patterns _th ;ti¢o6g ho ut Sonoma C- ou,nt The Di v i s l on of
H i_gh,wa;ys w i @ AI actu.,a tl �I y prepar_e 'thie,* study and the ftna I
report. C.estimaled fi;o take from a. year to eighteen
m oun t h e t,o �c o�mip I e to a. A -� se' ' n d "p h a =s e of t h i s study
w0u I d be the perpetda I .u:o!dat1 ng of the report as
0eve 16vm.ent 'ocPei_rs in va.r i ou.s .na its of the County.
9 n" esse,ns.e tl wAJ 0 be an, u n-dep of the
character a'nd traf f u c. mov,em,e, _V - n" Sonoma County to
find out wh.a�t' types of m, 'Jo '� enter' a tl and secondary
roads. aB°e` ni,eeded
..
Modu0es, '& Mrobile.s Conf he0d' 'In San Francisco
Mr. •McGiverlh, i the Commaasion of ,a mod =ales
and mob c' B e confe, "ren <.c;e he 'a ttonded in S. +F., on
Feb ba:r.y 119, 197 0,. Modfu l.ar h ® u!s i nag . i s be i'ng . con-
s ; i dere.d throughodt 'h' Nations The u °nits are pre-
„
fabri cat,ed 1 n the p Pants a,nA; then s.,h'i peed to the ,s i te;s
and 0re(ete The 'State Depa�.rtm:ent of °.�Hou,s i ng and',
Commun i" Veve -I o0me.nt w i I.,I e nforce the control s :and
regul, reIative to the6' con in the
plants. The I'oc_atl bus'Id'in:g offieiaB�s we I I _,contr'oI
the site Iacation, public amprowet�ents, foundation,
T
erection p roced'b des o$n th;e s i e a'nd u i I i t con-
60 Mr -. McGovern stated a t the p re ent time,
he foresaw no co ncel - te , d o f fo:tt f,. m.o,du I a r h,ousl ng „
fo,r Peta I L) Ma s l nce t 7 - ty pe of h >ous ng. ''i s nos y et
I1
competa t i ve enough W.`i'th ..,c,onv i o.na I ..hour i n,g . .
Mr6 McG._ivern al:s,,o i,ntorm7"—.the.CommissJon of the
d i scuss o.n 'he 'l d on mob. i I e .home P arks , relative to
design concept ., de,ns'p ty, etco 0
PROPOSED Comm i sYstones: Brurine -r� .adv1 sed the Comm that
8- MEMBIER Mayor P`Utn :am -.w i I c;a I a J o.o nt me.eti`ng of the Ci
COMM I S`S'I ON Coun ,.and P B,.ann i ng Commiss i'o:n t cons i'd the
po°sss.b1 "0,ity o f inc.reasw "n,g; the .number of P9- a.nn
COmm o _s�sl o'n' mem;ber,s, 1 ro.m f ive members. to eight
mem .'to a I I'ow the f ormolat v o;'n of a three mem,b�er
B;o'ard, of Zoning A,djusfineht - s.
D1 SCL.O°SURE GF The Comma "ss'y ,on ,,expre.ssed cbnc&rn over the -- upcoming
ASSETS "DVsclosure. of` Asset'" [a:w be.com,ing effective A,pri
C, 1970. .` Mr." M'cGi -rn in formed t °�he Comm "i'"ss`ion,
directi:on 4�e[at'ive to th Faw would be' forthcoming
f ro`m the:. C`,i ty Attorney a
v,,cE: cn" i o�man"
Attest:
5