HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 07/07/1970JULY '7 1970
PETAUMA �CITY PiLANNIM COMMISSION
RE ' G ' U!L A KE E T 1, N G . #I' F ISCA L , E A R'
ab - 0 C LOCK. P W, , 'CI T'Y H
L
R O GAEL',: Comm. Brupn,er K a i t.,z,e ii
S T A F'F William C. MC'Gfv;ern, Dir,
Andy Ande�r A sistant
RO.VAL :0:
JULY 7,, 1970
CO'UNCII C H AXB E R &
PETALUMA 'CALIF�GRNIA
— P e r ry Wa t e rs, t-an I e y
ec of P'l -
-, a n nlpg:.
Plan,'ning Dfrettor.
NE t6th & 4U N E - 23
CORR
T
m 11 .1
Letter 'from Jim O0,e g oAif tat'on t requir &etforth
on Exhtoit "A" of Si te .0 "si -ovel for, ebsta,ueant located at 501.2
� De sign Abp
- ;-
Pe'tal Boulev Nofth,. (F _ .1 i e. 5 .1 41 ,
So County. Refetrals
S A U70 S J t e, des, ig,n a V! 'alL fqr' & new, car sale, office and dis
SALES COMPLEX p1 ay at
-
cate'4 at .21 P v
etaluma :Bouleard South
'ea � a be 10
SITE, DESIjG'N filed by '-S.ande Moto Co m p._kny o
FIL 5.1,57
ZO"N I NG ORDIN- Proposed to 'Zoning `O to provide f'o,r
=GE, ARENDMENT the h 0 n g of a 111tim i te d n u M b,e 0 � d.am e t it a n i m'a 1 s ' on
n are o
:a '
RES. lb-7' r e s i d e n t-i a I I o ts Ka v I g &m r.
f 20,0 square feet
o,r m . Contiqbaitio!n Of p•blf( hea-ring.
ATLANTIC PA Conti ,60'1-6,tion of P01 fc, hgLartmg on ap i cat'ion f i led by
C VF'I, C B L D G . C 0 R P,. A t I a c � . & P,a c i f I d Bldg.. Corip, 0 to rezone 7007 acres
REZONINGSi from "A" " "'C -H ' "" - 15, 84 acwt&s from "'A" to R-1-6,00 &
Z'6 7 4 , 3
1 0; Z7 & 4 8 aces from "Al", to R-M-1500 zoning disteict. Area
Z. 7 0 in s -t h i n 1, M o n r c'h - P'&c, , I f i c ' Tentative Map
41, Io altle;d wj
filed f6t 0 h t s, 8 - 10 . (Continued for lack of information)
PAUL MASE'LLI, Site d for-propo ware;ho,u,se st1ora19-e
SITE D bufl,din,g to 'b,e locilated t the e,ear of ah stir g, bldg
FILE 5.15.8 at. 64-9. wlls ooh tt,?4e-*t.
DO:N,A R VC HARD- Va'wlfante ap N 3ed by D Ri to, allow an
SON 8 h: ftnc�e a�irpun,d smiffimih
FILE V 3-7 0 1 pooA At 641 klb
W ay
B 'A,U
E T,1F'I.CAT1OV OF -RAILROAR R/'W REPO'RT'
:BAY AREA PL,A - DIR'E'CTORS' ASSO'CI'ATION --
t
R' E�I V a r i a n c e a p I fcz t Va - n to allow a si4eyar.0� setb of
VARIANCE i 1,1 for ramp instp1l:W;oh, foe t�heelc,hair azcess",
E TO U %fA* il 0
a
..
. J I 1970
q
R,e,g u I a r me e t'i n g o f the P et a l um:a •C; i t y P'�1 a n °,n'i njg C.qmm i s i _o n .w; a s h e 'I d on July
c' -7 I'970 ;a,t 7•:3 0 p,. m, i n. the Coun�c - i I Ch,amb;er s, •.CI y Ra I I , Peta I um a.
�RESENT Comm. .Brunne•r`, Koen i-tzer, Pe,'r'ry, S't�an I ey
ABS "ENT;' Co,m'm. Waters
i.. �
- STAF"F Andy ,And.e Assi'st•ant P I an n ; ,i ng D.i,re
23d PRO' tLLj0 NUT,E,S- the, m i n;u`tes. #or the meet i n g of June 1 6tf and Jun °e
. ,, `aoordved as sub,m;i tted.
to'RRESPQN ?
I nd i m Oaberq, r:e C,b :tt- "1 °s' f Restau,r.an't
Mr. And_e:r`s•oh. :re,a:.d a I etter'�.r;e:ce i ve'd #.rom, Jim: Oberg requesting
th4at the requ i remonts s.etforth by the P;I;ann i ng Commi on
-).an uary 6. 1 970: ; fo - r S i t•e Des i gn Re;v i ew. (Exh i' b i t . "'A" 5 . 1 47 )
! the; Cate I'em,en R;estaulrant t oc;at "ed at 50 Petaluma
Bou I evard North- be mod' "Hied, .as fo I' lows
"I . Prov i de:' A; C= pav i n,g; for dr-,i've1w area t'o the site,
i n"cl u.d i ng 40 feet around the .exx.ter;i;or of t;he b u i l d i n g .
Pr ov i de .armor- coat i ng' f park;i'n:g area as outlined o:n
' Exh i b i t P•. Armor coat i n.g to oom;p I y with' Section 37
A
of State sp ec i f i cat i on-s (doub I e srerai coat) . Completion
:o ' f th.e above !stated requ, i, rem - en ts by ,J u 1 y '2 1970
9
Fo I : , I o w i s n g f u r th e,r :d i' s c u s s` i o n w i t h Mr. . Ojb, e r g , a•n , d q u:e.s t i o n i n.g
h i m as to .h,i s' a;b i, I, i t,' to `jmeet the J °u I 28th dead I i ne for
th!e armor icoat i ;P'g as stat in t'he letter, th;e Comm
mod i f'i e t�h-e requi rements of" s.i to des!i gn review, F i I,e 5. 147
as f`';o 1 I, o w;s : -
I , . ; , ! - P r;o -v "i. d'e 'A C ` p a v i `n g., for d r i veew ay 'a r :e,a t o t'h.e s f te, ii nc I, u d i ng
_ 40 `fe,et around t h eex.teri;or. :o th'e b.u,i I di n and cont i n,u i ng
'b e,yolmd w 50 f °e.e t o f a rym o r c o a fi i n -g;, by 'J 'u I y 2 8, 1 9 7.0 .
Provide ,armor t:6.6 t i n,g fo:r r.ema i n,.der opf park i,ng area - .as
ou I fined on rev.`i!sed' ExhAb'i t- ' "A'!' ,w i.t,h,i,n one y'ezr (July
7. ;i 9 7 I
Th!o mot,io.n was i ntroduc.e.,d 'b Gomm Ferry, sec6hd;ed .by Comm.
Brunner and: pas -sed..b t`he fo I;Low'i n :g, vote
A Comm. Brunner, Per'ry., St.an Ie
N Ot's Com m. K o e n i t z.e r i
A,BIS"EN`T Cormm. W ate rs I
ON.OMA B:erdena .J ohnson Rezoning; F I : 48'90
E UN'TY
FERRALS: This cas;.e i nvo I ves Land Located outs,i,de of the Genera I P I a.n
area of i of l uencle, therefore, the Commissioners determined
that no comment was requ.1red.
Bud & S..ose M;a'b'ry - Use Permit App F'i - le: 5306
Request f i 1 e,d b.y ,ap,p 1 1 ca. It`s to, reactivate or i g i na 1 use permit
to allow an existing building to be used for a gas station
and beer bar at 5381 Redw ood Hi'ghwa'y South. The Staff
i nd i cate -d cars enter i ng and I ea;v i ng the s i to cou I d p,resent
a definite hazard to through traffic on the highway and
recommended that the. Plan,ni'ng Commission forward a letter
to the So.n Gounty Board of Z;on'Fng Adjustments .o;ppos i-ng
the re :q.ue use permit.: Commissioner Koen i tzer concurred
with the staff's recommend:ati,on,; however., the, other Com-
m1ss1.o�ners, d;i,d not agree Viand a ;m,oti'on was passed 'to direct
the staff to forward a letter to the County Board of Zoning
Ad j u!stments i nd i cat i ng no, opposition to the use , permit re-
quest. (Mot"i.on was i ntroiduced b,y Comm. Brun.n:er, seconded
by Comm. Perry and passed! by following vote:)
AYES':-. Comm. Brunner, Perry, Stanley
NOES: Comm. Koenitzer
ABSENT: Comm. Waters
ATLANTIC
Conti nuati:on of the pub Ili c. hearing. for re.zon i ngs. requested
& PAC I F-I C
by Atlantic & Pacific Bul'i ld i ng Corporation (for I'a-nd
BUILD.I:NG:
I:ocated within.Monarch Paacific Subd`.ivis,ion Units, 8,9, 10,
ORPORATION
tenta't'i'v'-e .map) was scheduled for this time. Mr. Anderson,
ZO,N.LNG'
act i - n g P I an,p i ng. Director .� in the absence of Mr. McG i vern,
i nformed th;e. Comm i s:s.i on ;th,e Staff h.a,s hot received sufficient
1p 70; Z7 -70
information on the rezo:nling as required by the Zoning
Z8 -70
Ordinance and recommended the matter be held. over unti'I
July 2(st, 1970. He further.s,tated an initial review of
plans submitted o:n Ju.ly llst for the mobile,home portion of the
rezoning, indicates modifications. : ld be required in
order to comp'iy. 1with Zon,i ng Ordinance .re,gu I of ions. Mr. Stuart
Bartleson, representing & Pacific Building Corporation,
was of the op i.n io:n they were not getting. comp bete information
or� from -the City staff._ He further in-formed
.the Commission plans were first submitted cibn May and discussed
at a Subdivision Committee meeting ,on May 16, 1970 and,.the.
delay may cause them to .withd,raw their application. Mr. Hal
Wood, Assistant C i t y Engineer, staraed M,r.. . J i m _Lewis V i ce-
Pr, es i dent o.:f A . & P . B u i l d i n g Corpo,ra.fl on,, w:as present at
the May 16th meeting and!was informed at that time what
w o u l d be required; however, p l a n s incorporating these re-
qu i reme,nts were o n l y r-e;ce i ve >d on J u.l y 1,, 1.970:.
After further deliberation, the Commission continued the
public he.ari.ng for July 2'1, 1970.
ON.OMA B:erdena .J ohnson Rezoning; F I : 48'90
E UN'TY
FERRALS: This cas;.e i nvo I ves Land Located outs,i,de of the Genera I P I a.n
area of i of l uencle, therefore, the Commissioners determined
that no comment was requ.1red.
Bud & S..ose M;a'b'ry - Use Permit App F'i - le: 5306
Request f i 1 e,d b.y ,ap,p 1 1 ca. It`s to, reactivate or i g i na 1 use permit
to allow an existing building to be used for a gas station
and beer bar at 5381 Redw ood Hi'ghwa'y South. The Staff
i nd i cate -d cars enter i ng and I ea;v i ng the s i to cou I d p,resent
a definite hazard to through traffic on the highway and
recommended that the. Plan,ni'ng Commission forward a letter
to the So.n Gounty Board of Z;on'Fng Adjustments .o;ppos i-ng
the re :q.ue use permit.: Commissioner Koen i tzer concurred
with the staff's recommend:ati,on,; however., the, other Com-
m1ss1.o�ners, d;i,d not agree Viand a ;m,oti'on was passed 'to direct
the staff to forward a letter to the County Board of Zoning
Ad j u!stments i nd i cat i ng no, opposition to the use , permit re-
quest. (Mot"i.on was i ntroiduced b,y Comm. Brun.n:er, seconded
by Comm. Perry and passed! by following vote:)
AYES':-. Comm. Brunner, Perry, Stanley
NOES: Comm. Koenitzer
ABSENT: Comm. Waters
SAND:EA.RS;ON Th;e Commission .reviewed he s i to p I ans subm i tt by - Sanderson
AUTO` SALE'S. Mator Company for 'a new ear sa I es office and di sp I ay area
COMPLEX' to be located, at 21 Pet
a�l u.m,a Boulevard South. Mr. Aubrey
S I,TE DES •S °anderson was pr.e.sent and f nd i.cate'd a,gree'm:ent to the .
F fLE: 5. requ i remen.ts set forth by th,e sta °f f o;_n E)ch i b i t "A" A motion,
• grant i n,g approva I .o,f t °heI site design as shown on Exhibit `!"A"
was i ntroduc.e.d b Comm i ss i oner Ko -ep i t'zer, sec onded by
Comm i' ss i o.ner Perry., and passed u'nan.fm,ousl y by a 1 1 members
present-.
PAUL MASE:LL:.I The.'.Co.mm i s' i on reviewe the
site design plans f i led by
S I T E DESIGN Pau I M'ase j I i for a proposed
ware,h,o =use storage b u i l d i n g g to
FILE: 5.158' be I orated to th'e. 'rear of
an ex i s't i n "g bu'i :I ding at -5 1 9
W Ison Street. Mr. And,erjson
state -d t`he .propas.ed warehouse
wi I I cove port .i'ons oaf three
lots ed _ own by the ap;p l i cant
and recommended appr,ova6l�of
he f s h ex des r gn _ a ;hs�,iipw()uon
Exhibit "A ", wh3 c.h i;nc I uded
`f`h ® " `tequ "r' re`irient fi'ht prior to
iss'uarnce of an occupancy'
permit, the final parce..l map to
combine Lots 37, 38, 39,
41 and 4,2, be recorded in the
Sonoma. Coun - ty .Recor'der's
Off ice.. • M.r. Paul Mas "e l I• i and
Mr. Don Petro, Contractor,
,
stated the lots, had already
been comb',ined Into one lot
at the Assessor' "s Office. Mr..
Hal Wood, Assistant City
Engineer, i of °orme,d the app l i cants
and the Comm`i ss i on tf i s 'meth
"o d, does n,ot e -I i m i Hat the I of
lines of a re•cord'e.d s u.b.d `i
v 1 s,i.on map,. Th can on.l y be
aecomp I i shed by ei th,er' a
Rev to Acreage Map or by a
Parcel Map.
Furthermore, tKe: parcel map
L ,
c;an be compiled from recorded
data i f the en,g j ne "e.:r feels
it is accurate otherwise another
survey ,wou I d- be requ i re;d.
After- further d'1 scuss i on, the.
staff was di;re,cted to get
an op - n'ion- from the City Attorney
as to :whether o fiat t'he
Bb i Id [ng Nf`i ci a I •d'an i ssue a
bu i I d'i ng perm i.t without the
requ'Tt,e,ment' of a recorded p.ar'ce "I.
ma . A motion,, .a p v i n g.
s 'i d -es i g n. a s i n d i c a t e d o n
Exhibit "A" e x c l u d i n g tFi,e,
. t'e
re!qu i remen re,l at i ve to the parcel.
map requ i reme.nt a;s stated)
in - the ;staff report, wa intro-
du c, e d by Comm i ssi o °ner Brunner,
seconded by Comm i ss i_oner Perry,
and passed by all members
present.
DONALD The Comm i ss i,on, considered the v'ar i app I i cat i.on f i led
R,I CHAR•DSON b ..Don',a I d R i ch;a rdso.n to a'I I o',w cons i`on o,f a fence 8 -'9
V,ARI AN,OE feet high o:n the side and) rear property I ines at 641 Albert
FILE: V3 -7'0 Way. M "r. Anderson, read a letter from Dr. Stephen Go.spe
indicating Mr. R i chardson� heart con i t i on 'necess
the need for a i sw mm'i n pool. Due to `the high win °ds' in the
Peta I uma :area,, Dr. Gospe sug;ge ;ste,d a high fence b,e burl t
:.around the s!w i mmi ng pool - to avoid body exposure of the-
pat'd'eht. 'N& opp:o;s i t i on was voiced to: the variance request ,
Res I ut;i on V3 -70, ;granting a variance" to permit a 'fenc`e
9_.,f'eet in height on the side and rear.'property lines at
641 Albert Way, was introduced b :Gomm. Koeni.az,er seconded
by Comm.. Perry and pass.ed I unan'i'mou.sl.y by a l I members ,pre=sen. .
FF REP0RTS�;
f l-
re;�.�ula _ The.
ody sesasion 5hou|d b,e hel d (when
re'tu}rhed from vouof|on) prior'fo
ublic h on the matter.
�
-
so.uth side of the resi of 73:2 E.Im Drive.
have -- no - o;bjpjq-t i�on to the c of said ramp,
having anoth"ex study �ses,sio,n befo,re acting. Mr. Carl
- Armstrong,, re,sid,i at 4,22 Gh:e!rry Stre�et,, 'requeste'd action
on this amendment as soon as pos:sible. He info the
i ntrod,,'uce.d, bly Comm .. Brunner, s,ec,ond by Comm Perry... and
FF REP0RTS�;
f l-
re;�.�ula _ The.
ody sesasion 5hou|d b,e hel d (when
re'tu}rhed from vouof|on) prior'fo
ublic h on the matter.
�
-
j is r a
Rezon i'n.q regu.e b.y M aria N,ova.k_.f'or. eX o , of Petaluma
P l aza St.opp 'i n!g, O'ente.r Ia pu;b 1 I c- hear ng to con's i de r th_e
re on i n'g was set for J u'I y 21 , 1 9.70 .
Beaut f'icat on of Ra,i I ro I d Ri h;ts ,of_ W:a y Re ,o,rt - Mr.
Anderson i nforme.d the. `Comm i ss i_�on that Mr M;cG i vern had
attende;d - a mee'ti'ng C' condu,cted under th,e. auspices of the
League of Calif, Ci ti es) com:pri;sed of various staff and
e,I ected oaf# i'c`i a I s of c'i t i�es i n Gal i f:orn i s to, d i s,cus,s and
prepare a res.olutro,n relative to:+ ;Ia,ndscap "ing a,nd b,,eautifica
tT on° of ra:i I road r i'ght - =of -:way; Re, f'u•rtKe: ,r informed th
Commission of the ,Le.ag,ue of Ca1 C letter 't
the C,a I i f.osrn I, 'a S't a t e Pub I i c' U "t i. I i�t i e s: C;omm! i s s on i , n c o r --
porat i n ,a prolgr:am for the ra i 1 ro °ads to ifoI I oar, A
m et i ng of th;e Pub I i c U i' i i t e s, Comm i,: .iss i o;n w i I 1 be he 1A
on July 15, 1;9'70 in .San FIran'c[sc.o., Mr, S.choI.I'enb.erger_,
D i,rectofr of ''Park 8; Re:creati on, w °;i; III be in attendance
B:ay Area PI ann i.ng D i r.e;ctors' Ass °o -ci at Meetll.nq - Th;e
report on this i was hleId over until PIT M :cGivern's
return. f
OTHER ITEMS UNDER COINS I DERA "T "],ON
Comm iss';o,ner Kpp,,n i t z;er i nqu i red about th -:e: st,at'us of, the
Berry Use Perm i t . M.r. A.,nder sta•te�d the staff has received
no ,add 'itiona,I inJo'rmat from +be a.* p,I`i cant . Commissioner
• Koen i.tzer a I so e,Ixpress:ed concern over th Lack of enf&rc i ng
cond.l t'i:o<ns o.f approval for zoning ca's,e's, Re referred to
the Al Stack Use Permit and s i to dogs i,gn granted to Henri s
Supp I C.om
ADJOURNMENT There being 'no further bus i n.es's. to come before the
Comm i ss4on, the meeting was ad.journ,ed.
, a i ma
i °s,t'a h °t P `I a n n i ng D i',rector