Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes 02/02/1971A. G ;E N D .A / PETALUMA °'PLANN:ING COMM1SSION - ,FEBRUARY 2' 1571 / REGULAR MEETING #1 ; 2.', FT;SCAL YEAR COUNCIL, .CHAMBERS 730 Q CLOCK P.M , Z, HALL PET'ALUMA, CALIFORNIA ROLL CALL Comm.. Brunner Y 'Cerini Hood:, ..Waters _Stanley ^ . STAFF :,' Wm,. C .: McGi =vern, 'Director' o,z''. PI n ning o Ri chard : D: A... Aiaderso'n,.:�AS.sistant, planner, APPROVAL - OFD MINUTES Approval- ,of minutes, for-January 19, 1971. . CORRESPONDENCE DEL WILKINSON Public .hearing to.:eonsider ..apph cation fi led. by- Del USE PERMIT Wilkinson, for... :a 'use allow :a= , retail .ser- U8 -7`1 a:ce station_ in: ,.a1_ ro osed: C- i Zone VALLEY GREEN CO. REZONING Z Public .hearing .t ley Gree.n...Compan R- 1 10 1 000 Zone" %n ,Camb ridge Squ McDowell B lvd., CASTER: MOBILHOME Public hearing to CORPORATION ter ,Mobi 1homes, Cc r REZONING side U 101 Z4. -7T sminedi ately.,adjac E states .lMbbilhcme (Lmited;:.'Indu .The site ;is. locat ,.` wester.n ..Pac�'ic consider applicati o • - . n filed by Val - to -rezone A,; "P® 17- 040` =-24 from an > an­R -1- -6; 000 Zoone;, (area included 'e Subdivision located. on South .consider application filed by Case- rporation'.rto..,rezone the easterly Freeway;._. ; of .Corona- Road and ent to the south, ,of the 'Petaluma - ark ':construction' from 'an sif al,) :.:Zone: to an R =M -!500 Zone., ed..between the Freeway and the North_ ai.lroad CR3NELLA 'REZONE Publ °' is ,hearing .;to consider. apply cation. filed- by Marino Z6 -71 Cr.inella . to prezone A.,P. :136 -050 =6 from an "A" '(Agri- cultur-a`l) :Zone .to; an :R -1 -6,000 Zone, to became effec- five u on.4nnexaton to..the city. (located between El Blvd Sou & y Crnella � ° pr.ive :.j.. YOUNG ANNEXATION Publ c hearing to - �determ ermine z: dis'tric�t for' lands 70 - 2•._ZONING' included in Young- Annexat on 7'0 -2,.- .(klocated on ', Z7 -71 McDowell Blvd.) _Aniitiaaed. by' Planri ng Commission;, b .. AMENDMENT TO Public hWaring to :consider.de.letion of Section 5 307 ZONING ORDINANCE- from Zoning Ordinance. :*.,662' NCS. (said- section' permits RES. 51-71 multi - family .dwelling's;; in ,a P -M District),. INITIATED BY P.LANNING':COMMhSS NORMAN . _ROLLINS " TENTATIVE MAP RE S . 6° _pproval requested for .tentative . subdivision map filed by . Norman,. Ro1la.ns '• located on :Magno,lia Avenue,.: -li . Planning .Commission M,_-, Conti -Hued - Februaary . 2 , 19 � {3THER I TEMS, :FOR 'CONS,IDE-RATION c r 1. f .,the , proposed . xil:dening" of P.zG<,E u'tility . +� pprova o 'transmission . right of; way near .,'Old' Redwood ,Highway & 1 l Freeway,. In.terchangeA. .;..(`for-::proposed 2A ".. gas main) 2. Set ublc p., hearing . to determiriex. appropraa'te ,zoning district. for ,lands , included in ''the;.�Peta,luma..70i2 -An- nexation`.:(Larialn Property;: bet seen .-;C Grarade:.Road and Frates Road.)* 1 3'm "Presentation" and_ ado tion.' o� � ' t _ p` 'f ::Rules..& Regrulat -ions for the transact ,on :o.f. business. and..set-.t ng ..forth,.the._,,, duties of' - t,Y a ;PlAnniri Comm ° " g. isson i Februar "Y -:1971 Regal ~ar meeting .of the, 'Planning Commids _on Was,` e d `'on, February 2., 1.971 :at 7':30 o'clock pQ:m. in the Cotzncil Chambers.,, City Hall, Pet- ,alum ,a, Calif-or:nia.. ABSENT PRESEN No e , Br;unner Cerini,, Ho Water's , :Stanley .. r r STAFF: Rich.ard.,D.,•.A. Anderson, Assistant- Planner,.. SUPERV TSOR JOERGER:. Chairman.Stanley veld :P-, P,hi Joerger:. -QRRESPONDENCE. The .following letter,.'s were. - read 'by. -the ,Ass,istaht _ (All, le are , part of the ",permanent file„ ) T Letter from MacKay ,.& Somps - to the P- laftning Director stating final map °,of - Monarch. ,Pacifi;c . - #10� is� in . conformance with the approved tentative 'map- .and„ r.ej,ect, the,- staff's: proposal; to. d i vide' L ,..1'13. The letter further requested the,: f.inal map • , to - be laced - on the..Plann ng Commas °sign Agenda for 'Februar.y > - 2, 1971. (Date of letter Janul ry ° „1971.) ` 2 ® Letter adds_ ess:ed to the �Planhia Commiss dated January' 1.9 ! 1;971, '•from the Director of.'Public .Wo _ 3, Planning Dir'ec'tor. "'s - reply t;o MacKay°&. Somp °s. da:ted.January. "28, 1971 ; A discussion followed relative to, the legality.. of the.-letter .from the Director of Puib.lic; Works' with r.-.e;gatd to Lot 113. , Comm. f Waters read severah. seca:ions f -rom, the Subd ;Yis bn - ,Ordinance . A' mot on ' was made ;by Comm. Waters that ­t'he second paragraph, -of' the:.City Eng. n'eer' s. letterr-- of . ;Ja=n.uary,. 1 - 9 - 1.971 , be r;e.ferred - to the- ..City Atto , ey,'togethet -'Vith copies :of �Qrdinance •. #13'2'; '.the .conditions of approval' for the tentative map , : a_nd . the . letters": for , an opinion' as to the: legality of the Director 'of, Publ -Works letter 'with regard to the •Subd`ivi,s on Ordinance . The- motion ;was seconded -by - Comm. Cerini and pAs sed - un °andmous.iy :, MINUTES FOR App - ,oval. of , the minutes for January 19., JANUARY X19 1971 1971,. was ) held aver "Lintel. the next "meet in -in o g (;referr�n to a ction one' the on; ", g rder to .correc P` ar'agrap h 3 Pa e' 4 to rea ina -. m g d .as. _. map for .Monar'ch Pac �. fc #1 follows: "After - further deliberation, a motion was in - tod - uced by Gomm. Hood..to hold it over- until the. neft _neeti 9 The motion was seconded by Comm Cerini '{ and passed, by unanimously'. '- A motion, � es , as indi, do :'corre.ct ” th e miriut cat,ed-abo {e, was intr6duc'e4.by -Comm; Water;s, seconded. by .Comm,.. ' Cerini, and ..pas;sed by all members present „ - Planning Commissori Mi,nu_tess .- - Page Two.. February 2 , 19'71 j DEL W.ILK•INSON." Chair man S'ta ,ley opened, the public :hear `. USE PERMIT' _ ,:. in:g to consider the application .file;d b,y. RES U8i '�,T: Del Wi,lkihs,on'. for a . use permit .to allow') a retaL1 _se;ry -ice - station in' a proposed C -.H Zone at 259'0' Lakevsl:le Highway. The P Di,rect�or''s report "was- made a, per manent p rt: of the records .. (A rezoning pp t _on i's • end n for =<this .parcel p.- g...° ,. and continued. to -the first_'meeti meeting in August,, .19,.71;= as a res.ul`t-.of "`the 'morator- . • . - . -. ium se.t; , on rezonings : by •the , Counci •:) :, A.. motion to Con a tinue . the public: hearing " to the £first meeting in, 'August, :;1971,, 'was introduced. om ; by . Cm ., u ,Brnner -, "seconded: by . Comm,. Water s, ands passed unanimou'sl:y:. VALLEY GREEN CO.. •. Chairman "'Stanley opened -_public hear -. _ REZOIQhNG' ing to 'consider_ the application filed 'by 7 RES;` Z5; -1. Valley Green Company to. ,rezone .Assessor's Parcel 17= 04© -24, from an R= 1- 1Q.,00.0 Zone, . to an. R i1 =6. Wo - _Zone.. , Ron , Simpkinfs - , en gineer for MacKay '& Somgs representing th:e applicant, was present and'stated the - area; 'an- when wa�sL nexeel `to, the a. tentai.ye map `.f_iled for ',area .was the Square =Su`b visiori) ;, however, the' site . was , never' ,tezon_ed to - R- 1, =6., 0'0 In view of ` the _ ex:tenuatng circumstances . (as:: ,a, "resul;t of;. the , mora:tor> um on re�zon - i '-expira- ng,s and _the September• 18,. 1971, . tion date 'If•or' -.the subj.ect terita.tli e map ); ,: a motion to; "continue this ..'item until the. next - meeting . was intre'd:uced -,by •Comm. „ Waters, seconded by_.Comm.. Hood, - ..and, . paused- by all 'members The. staff was. -. di•rectedl ,, to: contact. -the .City Attorney to determine what - position t'he:.Commi_s S ion should, take on this, •rezoriirg, re quest view •o_f "the Counci -1 ''s moratorium. oft re- .• zon;inga .,, CASTER MOBIZ:EHOME . Chair ma Stanley „opened the public CORPORATION' ,he;ar ing to consider an application f + (:1 by :RE ZONING C:a,>s•ter' Mobilehome Cor- porati.on. to rezone•, - RES .. 'Z4 - 7 "1 " . south r'ona'aRoad andSimme d t l d _ a_e y a - 3 acent: `to . the south of -the Petaluma E fates PAGE- 2 CASTER MOBILEHOME:- Mobleh`ome Park from an M L Zone. to an , '. CORPORATION R 1- 15`O:Of Zone .­ a The ;Planning:-' Direct'or.' s REZONING ,report was,. made ,a permanent part of the RES - `Z4 :71 : Li le.. • Mir 'C lark Palmer _ ,.,attorn repr.,e- ;,(contlnu'ed';" senting te h : app 1ican.ts , .was pre sent and gs�ta:ted 'the `appl cant were aware ' their ap,plicaton was' being ,considered on• this - date, and requested the matter . be -,continued until trle next - regular : meet -._ -in A, motion. to coi ti�nue the `he`aring unt l February , 17.; 1:971, w.as introduced, by•Comm. Hood, s.econded,by Comm. - Cerini; and passed unanimously. CASTER MOBI'LE_HOME A motion to. cont nizey ,use permit ap- CORPORATION cation f°iied by Cla the; ster Mobilehome USE PERMIT Corpora-tion - (:f or • tYie ,same parcel -as the .RES .. '-U7 71 previous agenda ' item) unt=il .the •next mee=ting;; February 1e7, 1971 'wasp. in tro- d:uc;ed- by Comm. Hood.;- 'sec,onded by Comm;. " .Waters ,t and _.pa'ss;ed •unan' mously. 'PREZONE. CRINELLA rma :� �� Chaff opened the public .'hear,- RES. Z6 7:1 '- :. Ong. to consider an d- pplicati.on filed by '. Marino Cr:ine`lla .to prezori(Ei :Asse,ssor' s Parcel ;# 136= 050 -:,6 from: an "A" ' '(`Agrieul- , tural ). . Zbne:. to an R =_l 6 ,,,0 0`0 Zoney : to be- come of f' e ctiv e :upon annexation to the.. City �:The,,area ..i s, .l ocated' between'. Ely - ao.uleva_�rd S'out'h. and Crin'e . "rive : ,) The _ staf;f report was made part of the perma - "S'impkins nen f i,le .. Mr.. ., ; Ron ; • Engineer " for MacKay & Somps �repre;s'en;ting . the pl .c -ant, stated any .- _speed ri pro:eess- ng thi -s` request follow h the - _consul ;tar it Is, proposaI j for -the area would. be appr.ecF aced,.., A MG'tdor 1t,0 continue 'this m�at.tor tUnt l the first :.meeting in .August,, 1,921, was, intro= duced by Comm. Brunner, s.econded:by Comm. �byaal Cerini �:. and .passed members =present, YOUNG ANNEXATION- Chairman }Stanley opened ,the public,'hear- _ , 70 2 -.-REZONING i.ng -..to determine the proper ,z;oning ,dla,s- RE S.. 7 ss.fi:cation 'for the . area . included y in tYe Young.Ann�exati•on: 70 -2: This ''actiori�, was - inia "iat;edi by - 'Planning' Commis °sign:. " PAGE 3. P'lann'ing C ommission M i4u fe s _Page.Fou'r. Febtii4ry 2 1971 Y U' 0 NG: ANNEXAT-ION ..2 REZONING RE S .7 -7 1:• Cconti-n,uE41). Mr:. • Robert- 'La 41l.e, repreqent,ing, D. �D. Young, owner of tho .,property annexed" requested I the., r&zo b,�e'continued, indefinitely; •and if, .'the. consultants make a.- recommendation I I p rior -to the , months mo ratoriurft,de this area. be -at, that :,time.:. M.r..' stated the. f ive -acre parcel anriexea December. 21 1970 is� t an M-L In view -of the - de sirabili of' compatible t-.zoning .and- land use ,pa � andthi����frthe.e- - r - 1 11 -11 � ," '�, fact.th u - , r General 'Plan d6s ignate*�vin_dus trial use for , , .the . area, -, the staff , °recornmends- that - the :P'Ianning, forward 'a recom- me-ndati to- th e City ty, ...Cb on unci,l recommend, " inq the f ive-7acre,L,parcell be zoned M­L (Li-mited;7-I o The.. staff -,furth,et.. pointed-out An - area o - app'r-_,(Dx imate1y 7 1. 4. 3 a cres , mme d, i a t.61y ad j 4cent to the, was , .annexE. d on.�' August , 3. .19,70,'and, is a - '. part . of t he Peta`l�!ma.Egtatels. MobiLeh ..Park.- Thi s area was '-stuaied,during the consideration of P the- I eta 1 uma � Es t a te s Mbbiiehome .Pairk, Use In - view of the fact t I he 1. _ 43 ac re area Is- now a p art, t,- o -th .approved.. mobllehome 'park a, change of zone to 'an. R 1.50'0 Distric is . recommended by the'-'staff: After- a continue t tpr ium on Introduced Comm. Hb_oj iq f dis6qs:sion-, I a motion to! he -re,zoni - ng the lnora_ rezaning_has bebn-lifted, was omm". C i *,'. seconded ..by,.- and 'Pas�s unanimously: .- AMENDMENT TO Chairman Stlanlev opened P0 ' hear ZONING ORDINANCE- Ing to consider ' deletion efsocti ES.-5 On, 3.07 ..R �71 -from Zoning -S This s . # � 0� � C Section per"mits multi - ` J 1_ Awb1dingq a's:.• ami - - y a permitted use - the (Prof e - Medical District .,, A brile,f- grad . report was presented .`by And -ning, prs,on, exV_a:1: tlla�t`_the, .'Prbvi'sIon) a - -as 'ap -tments: ar a permitted - use :'w h no t. o t rp 's.- her' r6 s 0 fi to �'as haf Mo niou s 6evel 6 nt �` m in.,.a,:P-M" Zone c ould c auis e - j init!Orn. with "the hospital and medical us t rs� uses and do c 01 f icas.- No one vpaced 'ppp J .(D�§ - -o -, d e f et ing this section , of •the- - Z oning ,. Ordinance A. PA A Plarmng.Commiss'ion.. Minufttes - 'Page: Five .. .. February 2 , 1971 C AMENDMENT ;TO and .Chai.rman Stanley •-.closed .the public ZONING 0RD?INAN.CE hearin'g:. After .a brief discussion; -.the RES: ,5 7 Commission determined "t :he P =M Zone (cont riueL) s'ho:uld permit• living � quarters as a con di- tisonal . use,. to provide • -far ..doctors and nurses, and .szuggested.,,pffrm.itting ;a , resi -, , dential u'se upon .'the g- ranting �of -.a use permit _.:- A motion 'sto contlhue_ tthi.s matter in: order to prepare `the .necessary - revised . resolution .,was introduced' by Comm..- Cerini, . seconded by Comm. Waters -and passed:unani- mously' NORMAN ROLL -INS The Commission reviewed the T.ENTATIV,.E MAP map • failed by Norman Rol lin - ; for '.a, sub - RES... 6 =71 - division to °b& loea,ted:..on Magnolia .Ave - nue•: • The'staff report' by .Mr. ,.presented Anderson included ten conditions of appr_oval'. Mr. 'Arthuir ,Lafranchi, - attorney representing the `applicant.,,- addr'ess.ed,. the Commission at length..:. • Mr:.,. McGivern's , reply.; dated .January. 4-, 1971, to Mr La- franchi'was also read for the records. Br. efly ;, -the correspo'n'dence to. .re`ferred the legali�ty of° two `maps. ,on file, for e th same area.. l A lengthy the - , condit cant .,voice Nos. '1,, 2, tions.• No's. dktion .No . was ' :reword ing the to vis.i:on wit by � the..Pla duced by C Cer,i.n?i, -an 1 is:cuss'ion f o,l lowed' regarding ions ;af approval.:. The appli- i no o.ppos.i:tion - to Conditions 3 , 4, 6 7, and :10,. Condi- 5 and , „8 ' were, modified; -9 was. '.deleted -. ('Item No. 7 :d. -Resolution 6 -71, approv - . itat:ive,map:.of Subdi I . the .:conditions - las- modified ining Commission•, was; in )mm,'. Waters., . seconded by Comm. . I pa The -Commis s io`n reviewed' the - proposa -1 . submitted by Pacific 'Gas and Electric, Company ..to 'permit the •installation. of a .20 -inch gas pipe. in `the area.. north of the inter section'. of - •0'1-d `Redwood, Highway and the . 101 'Freeway..-. P. . G : &',.... E. ” pro:posos °to,ac.quire a- 30 --foot•eas.ement. and' a 50 foot"terriporary construction str.i:,p.: Mn D. E. :Marquardt', repre-sen:t- ing P.-_G; & E::, .was pt&sentl stat PAGE 5 I . k P:lannin C�ommissio g n: Minuters ,F`ebruary _ 2., 1'971 P: 'G -.& Ei UTILITY' P -G: & E twill contact th e property TRANSMISS,LON,. owners to; negotra -te for rights =o.f =way', RIGHT -OF WAY, involved, P G. E .will_• al-so submit.. '(c plans to the City . Eng 'ne - e'r to ,insure ' that �Ci_t " fac litiefs.. n° tYie .area :would ` riot be damaged during construct'iori.,_ A moa,i on ; approving . the - toute' _for the P G:.' &. E -:was nt.rodu'ced C - instal_kation. by Comm.. erini ._ s.econded .by o - Comm -.. H'od, ' A � passed unanimously. • At . trie time P., _G;. , & E ! c(Dntac City Engineer; ' . -the they shall.al,so sbmit proof that. the ro er't owners involved° l ave•�'been -con7, p . p .:.Y t ac.t:e d PETALUMA 79 .2 r rno;ti,on as introduced by Comm Brun ne:r,- . ANNEXATION• - - seconded. Comm.,`;Waters, a -nd p as sed uri -.' ( PROPERTY) ; .;. .a public',heari.ng ,on Nlarchul6y, j197ho1d 1 , to cbh , :the proposed zoning desigri'ation for the property in- volved the Petaluma 70­ 2 Annexation: A in ,= BY - LAWS & 'DUTIES OF : - = The Comm ls_i.on will c;onside,r adoption _= ELANNING COMMISSION o,f the By = and Duties, of the Phan- &. -BOARD OF . °ZONING n;ing Commils,slon : 'and. _for, .the -Beard aof ADJUSTMENTS _ Zoning Ad�f ustments at' <Jthe°i`r spec-lal meeting sehed'uled ,for February , ' 9 , '1971, l :. MONARCH PACTFI.C; • ,. Mr,: Wal.ter=W °illams;' Vice= ;Pres;d,ent ,of UNIT #10 Atlante: & Pa.c -fic Buldirig Corpor- `:anon;; _ . SP ECIAL .MEE .addressed a dvised . l he ,Comm'iss on ; ,Mr -. , Williams . 'the �t,a!o, made �. C;omm s�sion .of various by. their company w t'h._the P'la rtment lre,lat .ve to the ....final map for 'Monarch; Paci,f is , #10 ;. - along ., . . with their; reque1st.. to .'have the`.m ap; ..pl'aced': on : the,. agerid °a' •for -' th s meeti.]tg . . Commi:SSioft6r :Ce.r] ni stated hereafter. . 'items coming before the Commitssion',in - volwin le ` al . - c.o on should 'be . . accompani ed•.,by.- a Ietter , on , file from - P the City Attgrney'pertainng to the pa'rti.cular I item.- ._ . PAGE ..6­.' ,: Planning Commission' Minites, - Page. Seven . F(ebruaryj.2 , 193:1 'MONARCH PACIFIC A motion �, to -hold ::a, •special : me'eting:.. ; UNLT: #10 -. for 'the purpose =.of .consldetin(4 :the. SPECIAL ,'MEE,T'ING Final' Ma'p of ,Monarch "Pacific #10 :and - .(cont_inued).„ adop'ti.ori'of` the $y - Laws .for - the P-1an- _. ning Commi.ss,ion - and = 'Board of Zonin Adfustmen•ts,.'w-as.Introduced by Comm..;, ' seconded, by Comrri. "IK_ Aters,, an d Passed,- un ' Commission- requested that; the ' City. t Attorney . sub -= . . mit ;.a .legal,; opinion-.- regarding `thd• •mat._ .ter relative to, Lot, 113 `on ;the final. map. s. ADJOURNMENT The-r.e being -.no ,,furth:er business .to come before the., Commission, .•the ,mee't . ing.- was .adjourned . , .At tes =t PAGE, 7 z