HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes 06/06/1956,15
JUNE 6, 195b
(„I egdlar meeting of t;he Plannid.rig C:ornmi s.ian held on. tNedne;sday, J >une 6, 1'956.,
po tponed from.. Tues.day, June. 5, '1956,- Election Day, being" a_ hpI!day( for aj1
gom,e'rnmental of.fic : es) at 7 30 pem. in, t1he Council-Chambers,, City Hal 1,
,Pe.t. &Iuma, CaIifo h a°.
Present: Commi „,ss.ione� Brown „',Elmo :r Heywa:rd, R'obf.oge1, Salle.s and Ta'y'lo:r.:
Ab s: ,qt None..
y Offici.als*: Councilman John King, City Engineer Ru.sse11 Ingram] and
Cit City Attorney Edouard Robert, l
G-ueS, s : None e
APPROVAL OF MINUTE15 The minut e,s of .May 15, 195
6,,. were approved as recorded..
' CHAIRMAN O
'S CI1l1lUIENTS In onde;r t o save -� -� � � e t i'me, Chai rma -n Taylor anno:unped that.:
c with this meeting, agendas wi 11 b.,e v
p roid
at each me =e)ting four the:meinbers:'of the audience to
eliminate x7eadIng each item of .business; .also, the read-in(
of a1,1 'det;airls n ;legisla.t other than the necessary
informati on wi 11 b`e he .,reaf "t.er eliminated.
OLIVE BLAKLEY 'This being, the time and place for the public: hearing on
- - -.
the Use Permit 'appl,ic�at_ion, of 011ve Blakl 3 13, Fifth
St.reet,' 'to ope;rat =e a, beauty shop. in home,, R -3; zone,
Chad rman Taylor, cal upon. the ap.p l i;cant, fo,r an expires-
sl on. Mrs,. Blakley subm ' , g g 1 -4 :
p
g g S i ho were in favor of ran < t in�
tted a etitior containin g
si natu.res of nei hbors w
' the pe.rmrhi . She altso ':s tated that she wi 1.1 operate,
according to un �reguha.tons, which al Lows ::beauty=
Shops t.o 'be open u.nti 1 9' olcaock p.m., on two nights a
Week,; 'that there; is suffI parking spac 'in her d'ri -ve-
way fo custome,rs;' fequested. two hair dryers, which.,
she added, wov l,d not cause rad;i o or `te lev'f s i,o int e;r-
fe,reft e any mo. 'th'an a ho.u I ap,p 1 tan.c'e. T,l os_e Who
spoke an favor of the ap-plication mere Mrs. Harlow
P'ar,k,, 3'0'9: 'Fifth Street, who also: voiced an approval for
�4ro Sam Kerb;ey, 306 Fifth Street,.. Thos..e 'he& in
pro,testt,: Mrs. A1fr:ed Sung, 300 Fifth St -reet, who main-
Aai,fted that: operation of , a' beauty shop might calls °e inter•
ferencae: with radio and tele,tisi.on,, d�fistu`r�b peace and
q, ui,et of residteMial ne, ghbo,rhoodd and that there would'
not be, enough parking �spac`e along, the. st-reet Commun ca=
t i'on was read, `signed, 'by K. Cus 1 i,dge,, -ghat ��Mr - 's. -Bertha
Cus l i d,g °e , 318 F, f t'h St;reet. does .no`t ob j to. the
„beauty sho,po F'ol.l.owing .a bvief di.scus!sion and With th;e
a :p,rova of the app 'the f- ollowi °cofdlti,ons were
a, ec to be ,inc l;ude.d` i`n Aht Use Permit:
Limit to two, hair ,dryers-
2, Oper ate no l ond`er than 6 o d °Iock p, m.
The .hea;rinq wa °s: de.c,lar2d c10 °sea. Resol.ut'i,on . ,17 ,56
granting Use P.ermit,, in :trod�ucRd; by Commissioner Ro,bfogel,
1. seconded by Comm, i,ssi;o,n'e';r Brown, was unani "mou >s.1y passed
f - by' all 'memb-evs' pne.sent,
L ' .
JQHN CAVANAGH,.SR.. This be>ing ,the' time and place f'or the public hearing on
the amended app.1 c at"ion of Tohn Cavanagh,, Sr.., 1�Q0
Do.ugl.as Street, `to rezone. parciels of land hocat.ed on
June 6 , 19.56`
-.
Sprlx str '.� e Extenns�.on and Douglas Street between Fair
„
and ham treet;s from R -2 t_p R -3 and C-- 1: zones
U
tplt 8 ®1:6,,1 -1 and :8-: 161-2 9 .,. 409 °o fr Douglas St e
by 40907'° facing Sprang' St,re.et EXt;ension from R ®2 to
®.l zane.o
Lot 3 54q ' x 150 fiadi.ng Fai 'Street between
Do °ug.1 - as. & Bass:ett Streets from R - "to R -3 zloneo
Lots. 8 142. -10, ll 12, 13 14.9 i5. & 16, 2.90 more or
less: by 45 , 1 .4.E s °outhwesterly corner Douglas and Spr
�° et Ext ens °'.on f r'o.'m R -2 to R -3 zone,,
C 'airma -n T'ay'lor cah.led tipan. Mr, Cavanagh. for an e
si gn•,. In, p,res:ent'ing a plot plan of the p:rop.osed develop=
meet ,Jiro Cavanagh stat'e'd he h ceonferred with Planning
Cons.uiaant ,lames Cam bel'1 a't. the s,a g,g estion of" t_he Plan-
P ,
„
_
na:ng Comm .sfs 1 dn °to, get hi si '1d:eas regarding nevi sing `h"is'
plans.. He a'hso di.s Via. ed= 1ar,ge ,pictures of t'he. pot plan•
P Y
for .the: benefit of the audience and Comm s s.i on o
Thoae beard in favor of the request were:: Mr o Se J o Janes,,
21:1 Douglas, St. and Chas. K,i °nne 9 406 Broadway Street,
T,hos.e heard in protest were: Vic Rossott i, 203 boug 1as
St. , who p.re sehted a 'petdti;on .containing ,5 sig nat ures of
pr-aper'ty owners .,in, the area op;posi,ng said reque:s-t, Ramey
Chaney;, 12 Spring Stne:et and Mrrs.. Ca l ud�e -Ne i.s:;; 20`9
Dou.g Street i Mrs:. Bernice Mart- ine i i 9 , 141. Doug las
req�i,es ,,ed the types of store's proposed. on the
p'1an,, which were name4 .as fol lows a 1 - proposed market,
2W Shops:, 3 ® Shops 9, Bu'si,neiss and profess i ona l
off1ces (to be d'.ete,rmined) 5 B:t.siness and professi
offices 1 6 - PiIu1 °tiple fam_i Iy ,r°es.ident ,q]
units, fort 40 fermi 11es Writ:h sui'tab..le parking. She also
desired t 6 know 'if ther -e Vauld be any guaran-t.ee, that the
plans would gnat, ria.1ize as ,submitted so. that, the land
would not lay idle for some time and be used for some-
thing e Mr. Cavanagh - replied that 'this plan Is 'not "
sorrie4th1,ng `to 'be promoted" in th_e r ture but that the
t;eriant:s are wa'i.t,ing and the project wi'11 go ahead as scan
as rezoning is .complete.d� Foi,l.owing a discuss on the
need f-or a community center at �sa,id' location, the
feaslr? f IIty of ;rezoning, ,'',o TR -3 i'nst,e:ad of C` -1, and further
nevi aw of the plan.,, t: he hear i.ng 'was declared closed.-
- A p:o. of the, Commis�si.o by !a majority vote,, decided'
to take, the matter under adviaemen.t and a, dec to be:
rendelr,,ed as soon as, po. &s1b ^eo
ROY KEISER
Th1s being the `t,ime and p.l -ac,e f:o;r the public hearing on
the ap,p „lication of Ray Keiser to rezone” portion 'of , area
known" as Conway Park Subd #i, loca a,t m' t souther ly
end' of "BP ' from 11Ull to C-1 and R -3; and rezone.
port 1on of Conway Park", 'Suibd'o #1 from R -1 to R -3 (
1 'thru..9) Chairman `Tay1 -or c,a'Iled upon . the appi'icant.
Count I "limn John;Kthg, re;present.ing Mr. Keiser;. o:u'tii,ned
the area proposed to; lie ;re z oned, expl aining that, saint e'
the f III iAg of the ap�J1 cat ion„ an. HM (Hospit.a.,1- .UMed,ical')
zona, has been ,propo :ed whl ch wool °d be s.u%tab 1e for the
are4a. surrounding the ho�s.pkit:a.l inasmuch as t uses would:
be Zest ric't!e,d 't°o a medic c- enter,, further jad;ding that
each ind VIdua1 busfne&s would 'n'ot be. required to secu:r.e'
"
a U's,e P Those heard w ,n favor of th'a appl.icati „on.
June 6, 1
we e a Manor, l Amara l�, 16 Nob Rill, Terrace y who was .read
-he uses in an R -3 and a C-I zone Rai ph fami°ter
'
R`ose l7r tee:, at has °e ae s'� was s hown the ro o se d ex-
ten�s,ion of El Rase Drive - to, Ha La .Mr. Otto Berger
t, �S1x.tll St e,9 %-hc spoke; in the 'ihterests cif the' ;hose; t.al,
and, Evexe� M zea `i El Rase Drive. Letter ,sigrZed by
sol.irrva 'DOlc 9 �tat�.r�,g t, ia:t .;she. will not cgmajdar
rezoning; ors survey ;by peg 2, feet clown on her front proper-
ty, was, x ea;d and f i.Il,�:d` iVone heard in prct,es:t e
3n a cl'i scd .st on that fc�41 -m d,. Ur,.- King stated that the,
appli would be wilting to rezone .the large lot o n the
cernar of El, Rose ; r1.B, Siveet. to ; rn R ®1, Whi he
intends to .use -fo a �!ng le f am ,iy: and that
the area, east of `8' " S In said sub.dfvision could be
changed to an :R-2 zone instea of the' prroposed Rm3 to
serve as a buffer zon for the medi z :on.e e L ot s l thr u
9 9 . he sa;d d.ed , on E.1 'Ro sEe D r i, ve h'e tween "rB I St.' and Mayes
Lane ad 1od' the rear 'of Lots on No Hi Ter;r and
wouId' lie su:itab Le for - pr:ofes °:s•ional off`i;ces, mu1tip1e
dwe l.1 i.nag�s,, etc . and wota ld n Interfere with the . res ®
d'ent,i arl .dd s$ nlc2 t o
The he,a kng was dec'`lared cI,ose,d.
It was ,agree:d. to to °lie th maItter under advi semen't;
and In the meantime proo,e:ed, with the study of the sugg.es
„
t .Hoag1to - Medi lzdna. Comm ss :on;e Brown rec,ommen-
ded that If Cm`l zone w ere, ,changed to HMI, same be made.
�.
on, t .e, 'Qommiss =on "'s ini tiative without expense . to the
,.
applicant,
MARY LEHMAN
Ilse Pe' mist apl� l z c�at,l ora.� of Mi°s a Ma.rjr - Lehman, , �3 Cherry
$t,6 -, to conduct homa i o;r- fester_ c hi ldren -d:ay time car
Rml zcine, ores next ores d'efi'ed., The applicant wa present
and agreed `to th.e. following condition direct. -ed t °o be
included In. the Ll=e Permit - m
Li, to five ,, .fo st children.,
Publ is hearing was not, .deeme,d . necessar whereupon 'Res®
o;Yut.,ion #18-56 g Vantln� Use Permit, intro duced by Com-
m`s1s,foner S les and se'eonded by Commiss,ion E1more,
,
was unan,i-mo.us 1 passed by tL 1. l - cabers present o
JOHN 01BB;f
Ube P ermit a pp cat1ory of J ,4r -i 0 ,'fibs, 6- Vista Way,
to j n,st;a l l: ;rad to a enna, 70 ft. h i.gh,, .Rm l zone, wd"th
'sketch on, subject,: was the next - item of business. Mr.
G.1 was ;pi e&ent and e.x'p.lpa, ned; that. 'he wou.l l Ike to
install a, Q ft. ra,d,lo towe'r f o;r u-se as, an amateur• radio
station t be operated i °n accordance with f,ederal 1ai�s;
'the bas ac t,owe ° to be tr' langu lar 9; " on, a si at base,
mounted" in cement and t 'to a °h eigh;t of' 4 plan..
,t.o extend to maximum height, of 7D e `as vertic'al t,dwe with
only single; pipe extension above 40" or to mount beam
antenna elements (in horl,zonta l plan') between` 40 ¢ and 50 a
in heLghtito Quest ion w.a,.s, raised as to whethe�rl insurance
_
s ou d e c :onsidere'd far ptoaection if tourer collapsed,
an bf t er
' le wou.l.�d be any interference to ... rad+ and tel-e
.,t
i .3
V ,s i on. 1n view of t;his., it was umanimous,ly dec°ide.cl:
to hold a p,ubl'ic hearing!, *h4ch Was set for Tuesday,
June. 19 9 i s ,, at 7 30 o 9 c hock p.m. n the Counc j 1 Cham -
b.er,v e It Was :s:ug:gest to Mr. G:il bs to g e t in
on insurance for tower.
�AZ E L & THOMAS
1 W.- .NDERSON _
WALDO'LAR$ON
ADELINE HOLM
SYB;I L 'SULL IVAN ,
•
JOHN CAVANAGH,; JR
MRS., 60ROTHY GRANT
JuAe 6, 1 "956
.Mr.. Anderson sp to the Commission with regard to the.
grocer for �, k"le in t
:tepds o pear clha >se located at Keokuk
& West - Street I R- IT .zone`, and wanted to know if th
par't-itlors..8 c0111d be rem'ove'd to er?l•arge the Interior of
the s t , o -r and the; IIvi'ng, quart ther.eino
Ch, -1 maxi Taylor t E•fe,r r .., e d t-o Crdapter 7, Sect (o) of
loft ing `Ord o #34,0 NCS, whdclr , he read a,$ fo;l lows "The anon®
canf use of a portion of a, .building may be
extended brotg;hout tl e building provided :that in each
c a ge a • rose permi -t s°ha,l.1, first b;e obtained It was
exps°e,ssed' 'by thfe Commissione;rs that said sert;ion would
permit er�,;l.;ar the i of the store and they
woi ld 'b:e in fav o qr arming a use permit for same
when subtriTTtteda Pjidd rs.o,n stated he would, c•oopena
with. C_it ; En,,g;ineer to. ,prc�ri,d,e proper support of roof
if par-t1 t l,on•s a�re rem y,ed
Comml,�s : Rrown stated he would Grote for rejeditLon .
o f r e , zo��, e r of ap- pl icznt. s if as sured .r , , ezon ng of
the ent.:ir"e . blo: k bqainde,d 'by Qak & Pr'ospect and Ke,l le:r
. ibe:rty Sti"eet,s ; uhic t. Includes pr:oper°ty of applicants,
Res,olut,lor't of the CIty Flann'ing Comrnissiorn recommends
i,ng the r°e jec,t i on, of Prj:csupose,d amendment to 2.on ing Ord:,.
#34 NCS: a: -,r IaS if'yi a. c; pa = 'e:e Y ,s 0/6 -- 21- 3 -1.1, 6 ®c_9 3m L2 and
6- 13 -1`3 log a.t d a't' 3.1,1 Kel.le.r Street, 315 Ke.l ler St
anon sDg Pr cys p ye•pft St,r 1n�;,;- , -Oduced by Commi's.sioner Brown
�i_rn1 by Commissior_e, Heys and wa.s: una'ndmou.sly
pa ,by all merit e1r , px ep;enla
AID Cava.r'nag'h de>s ed . ; lu err if a Mae Perm were rem .,
gUired Ito e ta' ? n s i a cafe. at,. Eay.l.'i.s a nd East. Washington
S`'tnee,t, r?M,ea zone. _ ,a l:lowi °rack a billef disc and a,
p oll qf, the it uas decided that It would be
necel;,. sary for IVi:°'o Cavtvagh to obtain a Use Pe'rm• t
Use Permit . applj -� ation of Mr Dorothy G.ran:t, 499 Mto
V-1 ew Av t operate a rest. home at 23 1 Keller Stre:e:t,
R - 3 zone, vas nex t; Gonsl dei: ec? o .*,Mrs. Gr ant was present
a�n exP 1a..1 d that she d,es i r'es to rent said property• for
the purp;o,se of a: nest 4ome as ioc'ation and house,. Is s,u,l,t-
ab far same,, it, wa 'deci;ded t hat public Nearing wa
fie'c . and was : yet' for June 19th, 1 95 6 , at 7;39 o oc•locl
Pam. i ; a the, Crunoi.1 Chamb enS, it was suggested to the
abljli•can.t that It, - wouLdi be advdsab:l,e to det° Information
for the p4bl.ic t ea:•,r'.ing on wh:et.her the State would .
app .ov.e the propOvl y, ' a, lso 't°y;pe of pat i ent;s, number to
66 heu::sed,, age of patients., person. who, wil o,pe,rate same,
C ue.s't• is on was ra I d by Mr Luke, Demps ;real
e:zt.at.rrr re,p'reseratlny p:pl,Ica�nt, whether owner or
open °at,or s,ho nld. o. ta,iri the Use 'Permit and,, It wad fe lt °by
a ma
.jo:rri,ty of the Commi-s.lo n, that, th,e owner° sh•ou,ld secure.
the p. "�' e A ft -e :r a brief d1 scusys:1on, the action o n
, irig t•.gie 'Public' hea•r°i;ng d=a:tz f or June 19th, •wa:s re-
sc -1 ndce4 and will agal.rn• be, ,%:et :upon notfificoatdon from the
applic°ant, when she has :16 cat e;d a`n ope,r,ator an.6 completed'
all drotall:;o
June 6x 1956..
..
tYit,��. ;��ir���a. e c:, �.;�� dec 1 �.r° ed a ft.e,r which
A * d . - "' ,
t *h:e ,meet' Vng reconvene
PARK LANE ESTATES
70ra;tatIve map of pa'r,k Lane ,Estates Subd Lion #2
SUBDIVISION #2
was, ; 'stibm1tt.ed for , the tommi.ssi.on o s teviews. Marino
Cmin,ella, owngr, wp.s presernt to discuss said map.
Letter from C.lty Er?..g1nee'r Russell Ingrain,, was : read,
stating. 'that sa1d map cor►f orms_ , to provi s i.orrs of•. lav
and Ordinance 4 132 . . NC. S` -and that- he app,roues of
same, wher °ezgpon R,eso Lut ion #59, ap:prov :same,,
introduced by Comm-i. ss i onerr Robfog01� 9 sec�on.ded by
•
:s i r H�.
C omrrzi s �ywa.rd`, was. unarnimousl.y passed by
all mernb,e,rs ;pras.ent e
At "REZONING BLOCK
Resc1u.t-i.on .#60 of 1,nt,erition, of the City P lanni ng
OAK - PROSPECT AND'
Comrn:issioh to propose an ame to .Zoning
KELLER- LIBERTY
Ordi'rr.ance #3' 0 NCS b r ezon3rn enti blo
y g .
bounded by aek- Proz:p St re et s. and K' e . r an d
Lib.evt Str. et,s f rom , an R -2 to an R-� ;done, irl-
�tnodace,d, by Crommissiorne;r Salles and seconded by
Comma ss. 1orne:r° E;l.m'ore was mun..anim passed by' 8,11,
membervs pn e ,,ent o It was noted t hat said b'iock,
ihd ltide:s lm. °ty of Waldo 'Larson,,, Adeline Holm
arnd'. Sy1.�1 1 S';u l :l..1 vary e
RE HOSPiTAALmIUIEDICAL
Lattter�, dated MAY 3,1:, 1956, from Gity',Attarney
?I STRICT
Edo Rob'e'r't wa r ce,ad enclosing cop 1e s of a draft.
_
of a proposed ordlrna;nre t6 amend the Zoning Ord.
fo.r the purpbne of r:�t.abl,lsh1Ag a Hospltal- Medir,a`l
L)ist,ni:ct, or PH -MAY wwh'ich,. Mre 'Robert
stated., as - suggeste,d'i would by of interest to the
med:ic;al.. p,r°q essiLorn and that they might be consul -
ted as t o t par °tic ti,lar needs or r e quests for
c*.,harugose The Conpiss'Ion .f`e1t ,mor"e study was
needed on the proposed ordi nance amd it was agreed,
to hold a 'lunch�eorn- meeting on Tuesday,. June 12t'h,
at 12 noon, at the �a;lms, reservations to .b °e made '
`
by the Engineer° o s office:, to d iscuss ,same a At
the sug, st. of Co mmi s s i oner Brown, Counr.ilman
Kirr;g„ wa requested to di °scuss said pro,pase.d of.-
dina'raee with the Hi�.;lpita.l Di , for r°ec.ommern
dat1on or s:ugges't�ed changes to be sent to the
Commis on ift time for the above mentioned noon
k
meeting,,. Mr. King stated that 'he w.i 12 meet v✓it
the H'o:spita.l Board on Wednesday night, June 7th.
Refe:rri:ng a.ga, n to the r�e.zon nq of t�.h e .Kef�ee.r
property, the Commi f su;i tab .zon .could
be worked out f o l.l•owi.ng the .outc,ome of the ' pr`o
posed H di:s;ltri,ct, Manuel Amaral offered to
c6nt,a.ct, his °neighbor's: on `Nob "H'i l 1, T e.nrac.e whose
;lots Jain. Lots 1 thru 9 on El Rose Dri be`twe:en,
Str and Hayes Lane: arad, send. " 1et to
the. Commi that they favor a zone allowi -ng
p�rof.essi ona l of"f'i,ce;s� 'in that porttton of the ar:e,a e
The Commi ss4on„ r'equ•ested same to be submitted' fo':r
the noon meeting on ,lure 12tht.
June 6, 1956
iOHflT CAVANAGH, SR, In answe:° to Mr,, Cavanagh's que:st„ion,, ,the .Commi.ss on
assured him that a decision on hi,s rezoning application
wi.11.:be made as soon as possible, pointing out, .however,
that the Zoning Ordinance provt.des. 90 days in which to
make 'a decision.
ADJOURNMENT There being no further business to come before the meet-
ing, the meeting was adjourned,.