HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes 11/20/1956ass
RO'ILLM3EP 0 , : � 9.5 6
Regular meeting of the Planning rorrLnisszoh held on November ZO,, 19`56 at 7
o' cloek, pomo in the ,Council Chambers,, Cj'ty Ha 'l. Petaluma, Calif°orniao
Present Commissioners. Carlson, E lmore, Heyward,, Robf -ogel and 'Taylor.
Absent.° o Oommissioner's Brown and Sallosa
City.' Officials,,: City Engineer RCvsse_1 ?No ,TrI am
APPROVAL OV YENtTTES 1VIin:, te of No vember 1956' were :approved as
r ec'orded;a
KENNETH :KYLE' Public hpa.r,.ing on application #8342 of Kenneth
Kyle, 25 KentuckAT Street to r-ezzone Lots •g�061� -3
and 8061-4 located: at 417 and 421 t'B,rt. Street
from R -3 zone to C`- ;
,zone was het „d November 6;,
05 a . iV1r T.s B? Vorthing v,on was present repre-
senting "Mx Kyle, Chalr°an Taylor asked .wire
WdrtI that if the property in question
was rezaened to a C` zone would Mr. Kyle be
willing to czrtaln °c' haltions placed upon, the
rezoning such as . maintaining the 10!
lease with, option to renew for another 10 years
on the adjoin n� lot fore parking facilities as
originally stated; constructionA'o reasonably
c.onforrr to the fploVplan as file with the
Planning Go r rrlss on;9 and the placing of a, time
limit on the starting aril completion of the
bu .l.ding. Chairman. Taylor further stated that
Chris prb -edure of placing conditi upon; a•
rezoning was s `new and that it Mould be
a :policy of' the Planning, Commission in the
future. Mr. Worthington stated ghat it was the
sn,ent10h of sire yl;e to ;continue the, lease he
had at present on the aa�aining .Iot and that
T+ 1 , 6 Kylels archiu L, w si making - some changes in
trie interior of `the, building, but the .exterior
would be t'he, same a °s that on the plan filed
with the „Planning C;ommiss1on.o As.tohe time
limitation Mr. Worthington explai ` t ned that con
struction ��r;ould be commenced as rapidly as
possible,, bu:t that he could not give; a definite
date. After general discussion it was agreed.
to set a time limit of 0 months after final
action of the City Council in which ta commence:
construction and c.ompl to be within one
year of ter final act1on of the Council o Mr.
Worthington agreed that this, would be bmple time
foie the construction of the building and he felt
that all. of the conditions were fc but he did
not have* power of attorney to make a final
decsion At” the suggestion of Commissioner
Robfogel it was decided to hold' up voting on
the resolution until later' on in the meeting
and see if° Nlr ?ildorth- ng�'on ct�uld get. in touch
With Ivtr. a FoT e by phone 9 in order that the appli
ca'ti on aoij.1d be acted upon without Durtl er delay,.
Is-'
OVENIB ZO., 1956 ®page 2
POULTRY' PRODUCERS' OF
LTse.` Per°rnit appl i catlen #8424-,of Poultry Pr c)-
CENTRAL:_ CALIFORNIA
. ,.
uuc .rs o r° --' ;f Nh- Cal= far°llia, 323 East Washing-
t0 toi cons r uct: an, experimental station
ad jacent to their laborat'ory at 323 East.
Wash'inQ.t on ill an � gene was next considered.
IV . Be Tviaxwe Ll was present as the representa-
tive of the Poultry Producers. Mr. Ylaxweld.
Ijooug th a pi t- plan and explained to the
Go_rrt issione�a the type -,.of construction contem-
plated and the location. Af ter a general
discussion It was ex aimed to Mr Maxwell. that
there was no e.) ec U to the construction of
1
t 7 s Pxper 1- mental st'ati'on but the requ cements
of t� be Depar °ttiesn- o f, Public Health would have
t.o be ( bIie d with. A letter written by
'Dr. R, S u 'Nestpha.l.. of the. Department of Publ
Nea4lth dated November• 3, 1�55 was read statz.ng
c;onditi.0y -is to be riiet by the `Poultry Producer - °s'
if a , hicken experimental stat Was `built o
Mr. Maxwell stated that, they Would comply with
these At the suggestion of City
Engineer° InFram t; e; conditions as stated- in
the letter from 'the Department of Public Health
Were i'.ncludel in. the resolution, as follows a
1 . Chicken droppings ar& to be removed
twice a; week to prt fly breed ngo
2 -6 �adequjat,e :se'reening around, station to
prevent fl: -'es from entering,.
3, tTse re;� du:s_ spr°ys during .fly breeding
months as pro tective measure e
4. The use of chl,,ot ne compounds if -neces --
vary as an s d to odor contr when
washing cement .slabs a
VVher°eupon, Resolution. No, 35 -56 gY °anting the
use permit was introduced by Commissi,on.er
Heyward seconded by Conmiissioner Elmore and
unanimously passe'd� by' all members present,.
` DAVIS POULTRY_ C
tTse Permit .application #8551 of Davis. Poultry
CI inlc, 176 Main StPe'et, to..expand the r present
business 'to include day -time dog and. cat cl'ini
C ®2 zone. was next considered, Dr. Dungan was'
present on. behalf of this Application and
explained that at the presenV their clinic.
only performed vetei'inary .services on all types
c if
poul,tr`y, including; the handling of drugs and
vaccines, but that; they woul dd Like to expand
in order to 'take care of dogs, and cats In the
daytime only. after a brief discussion and with
l
NOAEN1BEEi. 20 195.6 - page "3
r
DAVIS POULTRY CLINIC. (Cone _d)`
the permission of th'' applican the following
condition Was included in the use permit!
Dogs and teats -not to be left over night
Without an. attendanto rr
Resolution No, -7 56. granting the use permit
was then introduced, by C Carlson
'
sedonde by Commi st oner Robfogel ari'd unan -
mously passed `by all nember`s present.
SHE LL .QIL C0MP. TY�
Use: Permit' Appliea:t �on x£3555. of Shell Oil Com-
parry, 3050 Montgomery Dr,, Santa Rosa to
construct -and operate a service station at the
northeast corner of East Washington. and Payran
Streets { Feterse property), C -1 zone, was the
next, item on the akendae .Chairman .Taylor
stated gnat. inasinuch as :the C,t,y Council did
not, act within the required '6`0 day period as
-
set forth in, Section. 11.18 of the Zoning Ordin-
ance� the Planning Commission did not feel that
this particular property had been legally
rezoned to. a. - zone s and they Would not con
isider this application fora use permit. A.
'
motion was made- by Commissioner Robfogel,
se.cohded - by Commi:ssi�oner Elmore and unan mousy Y
passed by all members present that the Planning'
'
Coinraissioii -riot. consider this application for
the reason *that the property had not been
-
�o :action' 'was on the n
n eseted9
The Clerk' was instructed, to return the appli=-
cation fee to the, applicant', Nir. Petersen was
present and remind@ - d the Commission. that the
City l ttorney had rendered an opinion with
,respect to the .rezoning of this property
Chairman 'Taylor stated - that they were aware . of
this opinion but died not agree with it, and
that it would have too be: tested Chairman.
Ta -ior informed�:�2r Petersen and the Shell Oil
Company representative present that they 'could
take the 'matter to court` to be 'te;sted, Nlr�
Petersen said he would do sop
ERIK '-klk UESEN
Use Perim ,t* application #8565 :o,f Erik- I18M esen
of 2560 - Red,00d'H ghway North to conduct home
o,c:cupat on of telephone answering- :service at
53.0 Wil Street., R. --3 aone was next considered =.
The applicant wa.s. present and pointed out that
an error. had been made._ in the application and
that �theP correct address should be 130 and 13OA
Wilson Street. The. +appl cation and resolution-
din Iya �Iro
�r;e �.e corrected cco Mathie;sen
further stated that since ther..e `was no teZ ephone
• /.5-'
DIMMER 209 19.5.6 -, page 4
RI K- KkTI-ITESEN .:Cont Td.,)
answering i n and because of
the: ;need of it i1a I.As ID us he Was applying
for a 'use pe•rTb,-it t() operate a telephone
an' veering, ser Via . ' ,He explain tha the
(� ilJipll F%7t used ift this type of bLl'SineS`S would-
cbrisist O a serf- tihb�oard with approximately 80
U 1( lJL.nes and that, anyone could have. their
tee- Iepho e�, an , Wered can a'24, 1.1o1a-r° basis by sub
S , - r- Bing .i,e this senrice. Busi subscr -
bing to this t, pe of aerviee generally would
be Vhv yI - ians ,, ' Jeterl:'n '' c a. 8 and other bLl`S1nas-
ses of this nature. After .a brief discussion
it was de termined that there would be no loud
ringing of belha or buzzers connected with this
occupaf,ion T,n1aic - I). vvc. - be a - nuisance to the
s rraunding neighborhood. therefore a public
heari'rig wolxld Hoo=t re necessary. Thereupon,
Res'c1u��z.dn X39 - t;ng the u'se permit was
in,V. °oClaeed by C`o;�ni ssioner El :more - _ seconded by
Comi Heyward and unanimously passed by
a.11. , yembeY`•S present:.
MS. TIARGPOET SHEARER'
Use Permit a=pplication #9575 of i \jlrs. IYargar
Shearer ref` 529 x,2urra Drive, to conduct home
I
for foster czll&oe --n daytime care, R -1 zone,
Was next_ conslder°ed. The applicant iA s present
and after a br ief discussion, requested a limit
o.f six children., b ^rhicZi vas Included as a con.
d Lion in th Ji,se Permit. Resolution, #40a -5:6
.p
granting the use permit,, introduced by Coma is-
sioner R' obtogel and seconded. by Cominssonera
Ca'r 1so.n was unanimoixsly pas=sed by all members
present
KE�i�I�ETH KYLE
I�ir'. Worth Lpgton stated that he had reached
Mrs Kyle by phone and that he. Was in. agreement
with all of the conditions' except 'the time
limitations At the present - he 'anticpated'
start within 6 mont-h� arid' -completion t o .
-within one yeas,, but souleth.ing unforeseen could
happen whi h. could prevent him from starting or
completing con.stnzction within the time speci
fled. Chairman Taylor explained that if cir-
cumstances arose Which Would prevent him from
.starting or completing on. schedule, an extentaon
:could be granted upon request. This being,
afire :eabl.e, - the foll.owi ng, c,ondition.s were ordered
incorpQrat -ed in 't'he resolu.c ona
l.o Applicant to maintain lease on adjoining
lot for parking fat illties for 1:0, years
with option to rerne v for another° 10 years..
/S'?
NOVEMBER 20,;,, 1:956 page 5
r ,
NETH KYL (c ont ? d.e
2 Pl:ar s as subffIttIed to "the Planning
�ComgiJ lion by ' the applicant to be
closely (. on_6,rme d t6.
3,; Ap "O,° p Ift to commence of
building w t,hi`n, �6 ' months after - final
a -ti of 't C'� ty Council and building,
�o be cotnplet.4 d within one year after
f rral action of the City Council,
1rherettpon, Resol ition NTb,, 68 recommending the
adoption o ... proposed amendment to Zoning Qrdin
M*iae No "F4u N.O.S a , reclassifying Lots 8=- 0.61, 3
anti `8061-4 '3 0c , te , at 417 and 421 ' Street..,.
Petal ma,, r.r °rr1 an. II R• 3" zone or district to a
2 4 7 one or district was introduced by.,
Comrlssio Robfogel,, seconded by Commissioner
Car °l,son., acid Tiinanimously pa -ssed, ''by all members,
Pr`esens: �a
PRESS ,DEMOCRAT REPOR,TJM,
Chairman. Taylor introduced Ruben Salazar,
reps �,er.° r. eplaclr g Howard Kessler, for the
Pr e.s s Democr
T' BOB WE
Alell..a a0d eased the Commission: and asked
Vi-I y coed t"on a had, been placed upon the rezoning
of lei °a F ylF s prc�pFx'ry and not on :other com-
?ne�.c; al °rez;c�- r��Ilg. a iri the past. He also wanted
- to knL} �� if these conditions vvEre not complied
With, would the rez be null and. void.
Cha.irT :n Taylor explained that due to the fact
that in the past, property had been rezoned
comme cially,, bat nothing, further had developed,
and since there had been a. lot of ,criticism
_
because of this,, the Planning Commission felt
that if certain conditions had. to be met In
order for p p; J be d 9 ' that
voul.�nottapplyfor until -
applIcants d .
they were able to c;a;r°ry ou_;t their plans as
presented 'to the Commission at the time. of the
rezoni:ng� ' 'He further expitiained t °hat if the e
cond.itlon8S were notr met, the property might'
possi:bly back to the original zone.. He
stated again that this was 'a new procedure and.
that it. would be the .policy of the Planning
C'omTftisSlon to, r.equ re certain conditions of a
reasonable natgr6 On a ll rezoning applications
'in the: future.
T AND
Chai a s a result of
GH�iAYS
;meeting held on
N•ovemb:er 6, 1956., the- following - members were
"
appoint.ed'to serge as a committee to. work with
jTEIVBER 20' 195E page ,6
ASTER STREET AND thip- Clt Errg ��-r and su�rmIt 'to the Planning.
HI,C�HWAY PLAN. �Cont 9 do ): Camn�iss bn as a °;C. �T reLo r�ie -7dat oils for
b�in`gin th Mlas ei, Street and Highway Plan
CCum , 8 or�er He;yMard,, Chairman
Corr�nl, one S'aZles;
ComiIIssioner Carlson
ADJO, URN INMIT shere' bQ g; no f_,uMher t7xsiness to come before
t'he mee:�ing,, the meeting was, adtjourneda