The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutAgenda Bill 4.C Part 6 07/14/2003r ; II ✓ Enine ern 2941 Sunrise -Boulevard, Suite 106 Timothy'W. M.cPartland. SE3826 1 Rancho Cordova,CA,9742' Amy Dale McPartlan d. CE46742. Phone: 916-859-7300 Fax: 916-859-.7304 E-mail; atmriatnieneineerine.com ST-RUCTURAL EV Au "ATI"N Prepared' f&—. ';Basin .S;treet Properties , 1318 df Way; Suite 140 Petaluma,'CA 94954 :, ;. DATE: May 1.2', 20:03 ATM Engineering JOB 903122 NN'WATM Engineering � eerng 29.41 Sunrise Boulevard, Suite 1:0'5; Timofh� W.., Ivlcl?artland: SE3826 Rancho Cordova CA 9)742', - Phone: 9.16=859-7300 Amy D'ale.McPartland, CE46742 Fax: 9.16-8�0-7304 E-mail'. ;atm@atmengi'neei-irig:com STRUCTURAL -E Of McKin-ne Levi Iry Stble Pe zaurnal,, Californaa Prepared._�for Basin, S."treet Properfes 1318 Redwood Way, Suite 140 Petaluma„C'A 94954, DATE: May 12 2003 ATM Engineering JOB #031'22 . C i v. i I a n d' S t. r u c: t :u `r a,I E n 2;i n e e r i, n o g-., ne-ering, REPORT McKinney Livery Stable, 1:62'l) Street, Petaluma, CA BACKGROUND On April 9, 2003,AT M-, Engineer . nglVas'hi I red by Basin Street Prope . rtie . 9 Soevald I ate the structural condition of fiVe-bui-ldin��.lo-c�iti�d'in"'d'owntbwn,:P.e,failurna.for:the Purpose of.de-�terminingth,e buildings' structural into and suitability for rehabilitation. In order to accomplish this evaluation .we,h . ave visited the site,. madevisUa);bbservations, and taken digital ,p hotograohs.. No construction drawings for the buildings are available lfor revieW. .,We have not done any destructive testis nor have we,attempt0b to expose any areas-thatarLi concealed, by finishes. Since par f each o, buildings' structurei,is exposedJor viL:iWihg,'the results, of our investigation zhould�, be Cons r idered to be typical of concealed` ardas,, however deficient conditions may existed which were not idePtifie'd because hey are CC)n,cealed-.,. In additi,99,,,we have not perfbated an exte6siVe stru 't6r'al analysis of-tb��,buildings but have rather C based our ,cdh I -b and experience with, oth'eir''si '"I s. The extent of and conclusions on, durb observations ' a ion accuracy of 'this I . , repo.ft is accordfrig'lly1irnited. _M!, ar"building ,it is our understancling�lthat these, evaluat'ib'ns'will be required as,a part of, 'an,'aopkation fora .Certificate of Appropriateness as reqtiired by Section.7'of the Central Petaluma Sp6cific, Plan. The ,buildings to be evaluated'areas follows:. 1 The McKinney Livery. Stable'V 1�02 D, Street , , 1 '2 Ware ' house 'Building *1 1�, lit" : 'Street 1 "I'st -Street Warehouse Building #3,;lSt .- Street, 5Warehouse Building #4, 15, Street The following is a.summary of our,findings for,McKihri6y Livery StaWd,.702 D3,Sireet BUILDING DESCRIPTION This building jis c.pIrnposed, of a,main stable'building4hich.was built between 19da and 1,906 and a lean-to addition which. was added ,about ,1921 " The ' main, story siabl . e building,:is�one�storywi . ftrloftS on both sides and one end. The addition is one -stoand is built'--a'djacefit tothe -original structure,. See'atta.che6 photos. The roof structure of -both the original ,,bu ildi ng and the additicn:consists of heavy1imber beams . and columns which supp,orti 2, inch thick roof joists; The roof is sheathed with 1 inchr wood 0 od straight sheathing, and roofed with corrugated Metal roofing. The e1xteri0r'\A(aII construction varies between the original cons exterior construction and the addition., The Or walls of the addition are constructed of 4�' x,6" vertical posts with double 2'inch top plate, '2 'inch'sill, plate, and 4 inch h6rizo'ntlal-.gi'r-t's�at�oiid-�'heig�t.The,w Ils,ofthe,,o- onstrUcted'primahly of 2 inch studs 'spa . ced at -a Oginal-buildi I ng arec about -2'-O" olnce'nter-ahti,sheathed with vertical :1-x 1,2 wdodL'sheathing. The lofts of tho,original building are again Constructed of heavy timber beams and, 2 inchm'ood :floor joists and sheathed With 1 inch straight wood sheathing. The building has.no structural ifloor system. It!is.diffC ult-to,determine what kind of'fourid'ations may exist but if i - any concrete footings or piers exist'they would appear'to be minimal. S t r u c' t u r a I E n_ g i n e e r i n < "*ATM, .EIl�--lil��°1 i REP n� ORT McKinney Livery Stables 1Q2'D Str..eet,.Petaluma,, C FINDINGSAND: CONCUSIONS This building should be consitlefed in, oor to ve P ry P% condition from a structural standpoint., The building';rnay have been well below current seismic and wind loading standards,when it was originally'constructed, but; is in considerably,worsestructural condition now. In the building's present cond►tion; Partial or complete coilap`se should 6e considered likely in a significant'wind or seismic ,event. The amount of?w,ork needed to; rehabilitate the structure would depend'on'the ,design criteria used. S_ hould,the current.Uniform Building Code be,used as a deslgn,criteria, extensive upgrade: work, lfnot corrfplete reconstruction would likely be required. Some_ notable;areas .of deficiency are as.fol lows 1. The condition of fh'e weathered wood, and ry of the e' ist nfg connection ma! b onents'such' as r ails.and bolts creates a condition where the ca ci y e significantly reduced;, 2: Although some diagona_'l; blocking exists in part of the building there is Virtually no,reliable lateral force resisting system present in the building; 3. The, roof beams and roof framing memberswould likely, nottai lb to current code ,prescribed roof loading. 41currently udg t! frUgility of the building, `in addition to the overall. buildingszeand ark ofstucralsoundnesswould eqre . the building to be completely dismantled to facilitate the in'stallatibn of anew. foundation. New,structurally �soun'd framing tie=dawns;, sheathng,and other rnsulation; rated wall con ld be necessary, in addition to req uired.fire safety improvement.such; as seismic connections wou struction, etc. Based on the above: listed building deficiencies `and the steps necessary to bang this building' up to a standard that would.,allow the, safe use and occupancy: of'the building for economically Viable uses; it is my opinion that;this building is not;.suitable for rehabilitation and to do sowould be the equivalen ,of`:complete:'building replacement., I hope that this, information proves, helpful. If you 'have any q uestions.or comments; please ;call'. Sincerely; Tim McPartlarid, SE 2. C i v i f a n d `S .t ,r u c ,t u r a I E n i' n' e e r i 'n I REPORT, McKinnev Livery Sfabfe: 102 n Street_ Petaluma Ce . View From D Street View From, ?St Street • 3 C i v i. I a n d S t r u, c t u r a I. E. n o i. n e e r i n e V J O N Cu N O r //cc�s-yIt �' !� r/ arm'm'm m C C 0, G). CO, U O Q O O' Awl Alk A Eoginee�°lll, REPORT Warehouse'B'uildirig #I First:�Street, Petaluma, GA • BACKGROUND On APril 9 2003 ATM, Engineering was hired by Basin Street Properties to evaluate the :structural condition of su tabve ildl for rlehabiltl-ation..•Wntown Petaluma' ,,.for the' purpose,of determining the buildings' structural-''-itegrityand. ty 9 In oorder,to accomplish this.evaivation we have V1 ' : te, made, visual obsery g p � g .the si , ations .and taken digital is�ted' _ p P ✓ y y ;have not�done any, p to ra hs. No construction drawin s for the buildings are evailab_le for review. We destructive testing nor havewe'attem ted', to .ex ose an areas that,are concealed b finishes Since part of each buildingsstructure is exposed .for viewing, the results of our investigation should .be considered to be typical of concealedareas,. however deficient conditions may existed whichhwece not identified because they, are. concealed.. In:addition;;we'have not performed an extensive, structural analysis of,the buildmgs,huf�ha:ve rather based, our conclusions on our observations and 'experience with other°similar buildings: The=extent of and accuracy ,of, this report- is 4ccording'ly limited. Itis our understanding thatthese,evaluations will 'be required as',a part of an,application for a Ce, ificate•of Appropriateness as required by Section'7'of the Central; Petaluma, Specific Plan. The buildings to be evaluated are, as follows: 1: The'McKinney Livery, Stable, 102`D Street: 2. UVarehouse,Building #1;,,; 1st Street 3. Warehouse':Building,#2„ 1s' Street 4. W6'rehouse ,B'uilding #3, 1's` Street 5. Warehouse Building,#4,•1s' Street The following, is a summaryof our findingsfor Warehouse:-Buildings'#1., ;lsr street: BUILDING 'bESCRIPTION This building'is a one-story• warehouse with large�dooropenings on the frontand,'was const7rucfed in. f two; main bays with parallel ridges., See attached photos. approximately 1!910, The structure•consists o The ,roof structure consists, of corrugated metal ,roofing dver2x6 ,wood.rjoists spaced,, ah;abbut 4-0" on center which span between timber' trusses„ The`frusses-are. su''-ported on 6xwood beams which are then. supported 'by 6x timber posts;, The timber posts rest.on concrete. piers. Itis,unknown atthi,s-time Iiow;deep the piers extend. The: building walls °are constructed' of 2x6 wood °studswhich are blocked' at;about,4'=0 on centerand are sheathed with, corrugated, metal siding which appears to 'be the same: material as,ih'6 roofing. At some wall locations there is' diagonal blocking but no, Sension, bracing was observed! ' The building has some. concrete slabs in various locations which do'not'a;ppear to ;6e part of the original construction `The exterior walls_rest,on a continuous concrete curb however the'fouridation below the curb is unknown at this time': FINDINGS AND CONGLUSIO,NS This building should tie considered in oor co d'E' f 9 on .rom C1,0 tructural standpornt, The building may have been p mm,44i i well,below currentseismic and wind loading; stand'ards'when.it was or iginallyconst'ructed,"but is in considerably REPORT r Warehouse Bwi'dm'g`#1 First. Street, Petaluma, CA worse structural,i'condition now in the bufdin 's'present condiEion, pa g " rtial or complete collapse should be considered likely'in,a significant Wind`or'seismic event. The armount'of,work.needed to rehabilitate the structure would, depend on the design criteria used. Should the current Uniform Building Code. be used `as a design criteria, extensive upgrade. work, if not complete reconstruction,wou,ld likely 'be,required.Some notable':areas of deficiency are as follows- 1:. The,condition of the weathered woodrarid deterioration of the connection components such as nails and bolts creates a condition whece,the t'apacity of the existing connections may be significantly reduced. 2. The 1lateral system for the bulldin,g apapears to rely primarily on the:corrugated metal siding to act as a ' sidin - rovides a re pp ' p - y g e roof, Itis unlikely that"the metal �p 9 . p g 'form of-lateralysu ortJ articular) iven tlieacondition of siding and the vertical dia hra rn�on the walls and a�� onzontal diaphragm, mon th �9 P e�� iding connection betwe ' and the�wood.. , liab e tithes roof trusses a„ d roof frarnin members would ilikel not calculate to 3. Ther n g members y ° current; code prescribed roof loadingtL It r , 9 ty4 , 4. There Is cur, Th g � ry; dditlon to - the overall ' gently Little to no building foundation � efra III of the buildin in4a - bullding„slze,and lack of�structural soundness;` would require ahe'bulldmg tobe completely dismantled to, facilitate the installation as n'e,w foundation New,structo "il sound framing, tie -,downs; she"tithing and other seismic connections would'be'necessary''in,addition to,required fire safety improvement such as insulation, "rated wall construction, etc. •Based on the:above listed building deficiencies and the steps necessary rto.bring this building up to a standard -thatwould allow the safe use and occupancy of the building for economically viable: uses, it is my opinion that this �building;is-not,suitable for rehabilitation,and:to do so. would be the equivalent of .complete building replacement. I. hbo6,that tl is,,-ihformation:proves-helpful. If you have any questions.or comments,'please call.. .Sincerely„ IT McPartland,'SE . � i. ;• �i. - r i„ r � ,. i I, - it i^ , • 2 C i v i I a n d S t r u c `C a r a I: E n g i n e e r i n View. From 11$`Street View°of lnteriorWall Framing 3. i View, of Interior Column;and.Bearris a n d S' [ r u ;c', 't u r a I E n g i n, z ;z' r i n ,2. 'View of'l'nterior Trusses. • IM .r CD, N N N N C � cn �n ?. ba 'co rn CL) c a) (D d) iu ' a) a) a) .;ar N ;cam ,c*' Ln J i ''T'<<*A,!I En ire r` e -in a 2941 Sunrise Bqulevard Suiie,]0---v Timothy W.,McPariland. SD 6� Rancho Cordova CA 9 742 Amv Date;McPartland, CE46742, Phone: 91,6.=859-73'00 = Fax..91_6.-'U94304; E-mail: atmrccL.atmengineering:com STRUCTURALE ALIJA . T� OF - . gar h "u , u ld" n' = Petaluma., .alvfornia Prepared 'fo,r; ,Basin Street Properties 1'318 RedWdod Way, $u'i:te 140 Petaluma, CA 9.4954 DATE Maly '12; 2003 ATM Engineering ,JOR #.03122,: C i v _i; .Ia; ri d S t r u c, t u• r a, 1' E n: 's i n. a :e :r i n �AT.m - gm ern REPORT Warehouse Building #3 First Street, Petaluma, CA BACKGROUND On April 9, 2003 ATM Engineering was hired by Basin Street Properties to evaluate the structural condition of fiive buildings located in downtown Petaluma. forth`e purpose of determining;,the buildings' structural integrity and suitability'for rehabilitatibh- In order to accomplish thisevaluation we have,visited the site, made visual observations, and taken digital photographs. No construction'drawings for the buildings are available for review. We have not any destructive testing nor have we attempted to expose any areas that are'con.cealed by finishes. Since part of each buildings' structure isexposed for°viewing; the results of,our investigation should be considered to be typical of concealed areas, however deficient conditions may existed which were not "identified because they are concealed. In addition, we have not performed an extensive structural analysis of the.bu_ ildings but have rather based our conclusions, on our observations and.6perience with other similar buildings. The extent of and accuracy of this report is accordingly limited. It is our understanding that these ;.evaluations will be required 'as a partzif,an application fora Certificate of Appropriateness as required by Section Tof the Central Petaluma Specific.Plan. The buildings to be evaluated are ,as follows: 1. The McKinney Livery Stable, 102 D Street 2. Warehouse Building #1.,:151 Street 3. Warehouse Building #2, -1 s' Street 4. Warehouse Building,#3 151 Street 5.. Warehouse Building #4 15' ^"Street The following is a summary of our findings' for Warehouse Buildings#2, 1sr Street BUILDING DESCRIPTION This building is composed of two parts; a one-story low bay warehouse and a on'e-story high bay warehouse with a mezzariine. As Warehouse Building#1, the building was constructed in approximately 1910 and consists of two main bays with parallel ridges. 'See attached photos. - The roof structure consists of corrugated metal roofing over2x6 wood joists spaced at about 4'-0" on center which span between timber trusses. The trusses are supported on 6x wood beams which, are then supported by 6x timber posts. The -timber posts rest on concrete piers. It is unknown'at this time how deep the piers extend. The sheathing ovee2z the high bay side is constructed entirely of wood. The floor structure consists. of straight wood wood floor joists supported' 'by heavy timber beams and .columns. 'There is a seriously deteriorated set of wood stairs leading to the mezzanine level. The building walls'are constructed of 2x6 wood, studs which are.blocked at about 4'=0" on center and are sheathed with -corrugated metal siding which appears to be the same material as the roofing. At some wall locations there is diagonal blocking but no tension bracing was observed. The building has. some concrete slabs in various locations which do not appear to be,part of the original construction. Much of the floor consists of soil with a thin layer of concrete:,that has large shallow depressions in various: areas. Th'el exterior walls rest on a continuous concrete curb however the foundation below the curb is unknown at this time. C i v i I a n d S t r u c t u r a l E n s i n e e r i n g <<*ATM i� Engneer�in.g REPORT Warehouse Building #2 First Street,, Petaluma, CA FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS This building should be considered in poor condition from a structural. standpoint.. The: building may have been well below current seismic and wind, loading standardswhen it was originally constructed, but is in considerably worse structural condition now. In the building'spresent condition, partial or complete.collapse should be considered likely in a significant wind or seismic event.. The amount, of work needed to 'retfabilitate the'sffucture would depend on the design criteria used. Should the current Uniform Building Code be used as a design criteria, extensive upgrade work, if not complete reconstruction would likely -be required,, Some notable areas of deficiency are as follows: 1'. The condition of the weathered wood :and deterioration of the connection components such as nails' and bolts creates a condition where the, capacity of`the,existing connections may be significantly reduced. 2. The lateral system for the building appears to rely primarily on the corrugated metal siding; to act as a vertical diaphragm' onthe walls and a horizontal, diaphragm on the roof. It is unlikely that the metal siding provides a reliable form of lateral support" particularly given the condition of siding and the connection between the siding and the wood., 3. The roof trusses and roof framing members would likely not calculate to current code prescribed roof loading. 4. There is currently littleto no building foundation. ' The fragility of the building, in addition to the overall building size,and lack of structural soundness, would require the building to be completely, dismantled to facilitate the installation of a .new foundation. New structurally sound framing, tie=downs,,. sheathing and other seismic connections would be..necessary in addition to required firesafety improvement such as insulation', rated wall construction, etc, 5. The mezzanine structure lacks significant lateral resistance to seismic forces. 6. Significant damage has occurred in some locations including the exterior walls.. Based on the above, listed building; deficiencies and the; steps necessary, to bring this .'building up to a -standard that would allow the safe use and occupancy of the building for economically .Viable uses, it is my opinion that this building is not: suitable for rehabilitation and to do so would be the equivalent of complete building replacement: I hope that this information proves helpful. If you have any questions or comments, please call. Sincerely, Tim McPartland, SE ,C i v i I a n, d S t r u c' t u r a I E n 9 i n t e r in g • • • ATm.Engin eerin�' REPORT Warehouse Building 92, First Street, Petaluma, CA PHOTOS View From 15' Street View of"Interior Wall Framing View of Interior Column. Beams. and. Mezzanine View of Interior Trusses and Mezzanine 3 C i v i I a n d S t r u c t u r a I E n -2 i n• e e r i n a 301 Ist street Warehouse #3 — 7 ist street 219 1st Street= Warehouse.#4 lotWarehouse treet It 2 Warehouse pl View From 15' Street View of"Interior Wall Framing View of Interior Column. Beams. and. Mezzanine View of Interior Trusses and Mezzanine 3 C i v i I a n d S t r u c t u r a I E n -2 i n• e e r i n a G7 w Q CD Q ,L1 Cl) V) U) N N N y cc vJ yN� lw z iT ;AD •C C' C C cu .0 Cn fn' Ln c U O .O O O L L L L L CO -M cc cO' . :: c�i c•i Ni Lri <' +ATm'En gineering 2941 Sunrise Boulevard. Suite. 105 Timothy W. McPartland. SE3826 Rancho Cordova, CA 95742 Amy. Dale McPartland. CE46742 Phone: 916-859-7300 Fax: 916-859-7304 E-mail: atfh0batmengineering.com 0 A •T ' #3 VVaa-ehouse �uilc9ing Petaluma, California - Pre'pared foet Basin Street Properties ties 4318 Red'w66d'Way, 'Su'ite'140 Petaluma, CA 94954 DATE:, May 12, 2003 ATM Engineering JOB #03122 C i v iI a n d S t r u 'c t u. r; a I E n 2 i n e e r i n Q '(*<*,A TM Engineering REPORT Warehouse Building #3 First Street, Petaluma, CA BACKGROUND On April 9, 2003 ATM Engineering was hired: by Basin Street Properties to evaluate the structural condition of sIu vetabulity for rehabifildings tatioin drowntown Petaluma for -the purpose :of determining the buildings' structural infegrity`and In orderto accomplish- this evaluation we. have, visited the site, made visual observations; and taken,digital photographs. No construction drawings for the buildings are available for review. We have not done any destructive testing nor have, we, attempted to expose any areas that are concealed„ by finishes. Since part of each buildings structure is exposed 'for viewing, the results of our investigation should be considered to be typical of concealed, areas, however deficient conditions may existed which were not identified because they are concealed. In. addition, we have.not;performed an extensive: structural -analysis-of the buildings buthave rather based our conclusions. on our observations and experience with other similarbuildings. The extent of and accuracy of this report is accordingly limited. It is our understanding :that these evaluations will be `required as a part of an application for a Certificate of . Appropriateness as required by Section 7 of the Central Petaluma .Specific Plan. The buildings to be evaluated are as follows: 1. The 'McKinney Livery Stable; '1'02 D Street 2. Warehouse Building.#1, 1St Street. 3. Warehouse Building #2, 1 st Street 4. Warehouse Building #3; 1 sl Street 5. Warehouse Building #4, 1St Street The following is a summary of our findings for Warehouse Buildings #3, 1" Street. BUILDING DESCRIPTION. This.buildi.ng, is aone-story warehouse with large door openings on the front and was constructed in approximately 1910. The structure consists of two main' bays with parallel ridges. See attached photos. The roof structure consists of corrugated. metal roofing over 2x.6 wood joists spaced at about 4'-0" on center which span between timber trusses. T.he trusses are supported on 6x wood beams which are then supported by 6x timber posts. The timber posts rest on concrete piers. It is unknown at this time how deep .the piers extend. The building walls are constructed of 2x6 wood studs which are blocked at about 4'-0" on center and are sheathed with corrugated metal siding which appears to be the same material as the roofing. At some,wall locations` there is diagonal blocking but no tension bracing Vas, observed.. The building has, some concrete slabs in various locations which do not appearto be part of the original construction. 'Much, of the floor consists of soil with b1h'ih layer of concrete that has large shallow depressions in various areas. The exterior walls rest on a. continuous concrete curb howeverthe foundation below the curb is unknown at this time. FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS This building should be considered in poor condition from a structural standpoint. The building may have been well below current seismic and wind loading standards when it was. originally constructed; .but is in considerably C i v i I a n d S t r u, c t u r a I E :n - i n e" e r i n a. •Warehouse Bu worse structura Id -O ilding #3' First Street, .Petaluma, CA l condition now. In the bui g's res p ent condition, partial or complete collapse should;. be considered likely in asignificant wind. or seismic event. The amount"of work needed to rehabilitate the structure would depend,on;the,design criteria used. Should the current Uniform Building Code.be used .6s,a design criteria, extensive upgrade work, if not 'complete reconstruction would likely be required. Some notable areas of deficiency' are as follows` 1. The condition of the weathered wood.and deterioration of the connection. components such as nails. and w p y c y g reduced. `•' of the existing connect. y bolts creates a condition where the capacity ions may be significantly 2. The lateral system, forthe building appears to rely primarily: on the corrugated metal siding to act as a r l phragrh' on the.walis ^and a honzpoptal F app uariy given the coed tion okely that the metal verticaldia pg sidii rovides a reliable form of lateral su ort f siding and the connection. between the siding and ,the,wood: 3; The roof trusses.and'roof framing members would likely not calculate to current code, prescribed 'roof loading" 4. There is currentiy'little to no building foundation. The fragility of the building,'in addition to the overall building size and; lack of structural soundness; would =,th,e building #o be completely, dismantled to facilitate the, installation. of a, new foundation; New,rally'sound framing; tie -downs, sheathing and otherseismic, connectionsiwould be necessary in addition to, required fire safety improvement such as insulation., rated wait construction; etc. Based on ou dt'allow th safe,use and occupancy of the,building for' econo 9 9. P o a standard above listed building deficiencies and the steps necessary:to'bring this building u t the e p y g rnlcally wiatil6 °uses, ;It is my opinion that this building is not suitable forrehabilitation and to do,so would be the equivalent of complete building replacement. I hope that thisinformation proves helpful: If you have any questions or comments, please call. Sincerely; " 'Tim McPartland, SE 2 C i v i I a n d S t r u ,c t u r a l E n g, i n e . e 'r i n g s u i � a a u i s uo n 1 S p u e. 1. i n sass04l Joualul Jo M@IA suwnloo pue sweag sassnil jouajul;o Main cu w a)i. a)' C - (n CnL ClIT cri 16 m m cn' C:QD CD cu cu. cu cu C - i cli -.q: ui Enbineering 2941 ,Sunrise vau95rd. Suite 105Rancho Cordova CCA QdTimoth} U'. ;McPar ldnd. SE3'826' 742 Amy DaleNcPartland: CE46742 Phone:; 9.1,6=859-7300 .Fax! 9),678,559-7304 E-mail: atm(a).atmengineering com " T"UCTURALEVA LUATION OF Warehouse �:ulding 44 Petaluma, California Prepared :for: Basin Street Properties 1`3`18 Redwood'Way, Suite 140: "Petalum'a, C;q 94954 DATE: May 12; 2003 ATM Engineering JOB #Q.3122 C 'i v i I a ;n `d S t c 'u ` c G u r a, I E.n e: e r in • BACKGROUND herr l REPORT, Warehouse 13#4'First Stireet,.Petaluima, CA On April 9; 2003 ATM Engineering was,hired by Basin Street Properties to,evaluate'the structural, condition, of five buildings. located In downtown Petaluma for the purpose, of determining the buildings' structural integrity and suitability for rehabilitation. In order to accomplish this evaluation we have visited the site, made visual observations, and taken digital photographs'. No construction drawings for the buildings are available for°review. We have not done any destructive testing nor have we attempted,tc expose anyareas thatare concealed by finishes. Since part of each buildings' structure is exposed for viewing, the results of our investigation should be considered to be typical of concealed areas, however deficiegt conditions may existed wh°ich'were not: identified because --they are concealed. In addition, we have not performed an extensive structural analysis of the buildings but have rather based our conclusions on. our observations and experience with other similar buildings. The extent of and accuracy of this report is accordingly limited. It is our understanding thaf these evaluations will be requiredas a part of an application "for a Certificate of Appropriateness as req uired.by Section 7.ofthe Central Petaluma Specific Plan. The buildings to be evaluated are as follows - 1. =The N1cKinn. ey.Livery'Stable, 1''02 D Street 2. Warehouse Building,#1; 1st Street 3. Warehouse Building 1st' Street. 4. Warehouse Building #3 1's1 Street 5. Warehouse Building #4, 1,s''Street The following is a summary of our findings for Warehouse Buildings #4, 1st Street. BUILDING' DESCRIPTION This building issa one-story warehouse with large door openings on the front and was constructed in approximately 1930; The structure consists of one main bay. See attached photos. The roof structure consists of corrugated metal roofing over 2x6 wood joists, spaced at about 4`-0" on center which spanbetween timbertrusses. The trusses are supported on 6x wood beams which are then supported by 6x timber posts-, The timber posts rest'on concrete piers. It is unknown at this time how deep the piers extend. sheabhedi g h co r8re 'studs which are *bloc about 4'-0" on ted metal sidin which a center and are ' �� constructed of 2x6. wood g g- ppears to, be the same material as the roofing. At some wall locations there; is diagonal blocking' but no fensibn,bracing was observed. The building has, some concrete slabs in various locations which do not I appear to :be partrof th;e original construction. Much of the -floor consists of soil with a thin layer of concrete that has large shallow depressions in vanous.areas. The exterior walls rest, on a continuous,concrete curb however the foundation below -the curb is unknown at,th"is time. FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS •This building should be considered in poor condition from a structural standpoint. The building may have been well below current seismic and�wind loading standards when it was originally constructed, but is in considerably ] C i v i l a n d S t r u c t u r a l E n s i n, e e r i n a 2 <<'+'-_ATm Engineering REPORT Warehouse Building #4 First. Street, Petaluma, CA worse structural condition now. In the; building's present condition, partial or complete collapse should be considered likely in a significant wind or seismic event. g p. design i used rehabilitate the, structure would de end onthe.desi n cntena 1. The amount of. work needed to reh Should thecu ' . Building eria, extensive upgrade work, if not complete reconstruction would I kely beerequi ed In, the build ng` p be considered likely in a significant.wind or seismic evenpresent condition, partial or coin fete collapse should The amount of work needed to rehabilitate ther stucture would depend on the design'criteria used. Should the current UniformBuilding Code be used as a design criteria; extensive upgrade work, if not,complete reconstruction would, likely be required. Some notable areas of deficiency areas follows:' 1. The condition ofthe weathered wood and deterioration of the connection components such:as nails and bolts creates a condition where the capacity of the existing connections may be significantly reduced. 2. The lateral system for the building appears to. rely primarily on the corrugated_metal;siding to act as a vertical diaphragm on the walls and a horizontal diaphragm on the roof. Itis unlikely that the metal siding provides a reliable form:of lateral support particularly given the condition of -,siding and the connection ,between the:siding,.and the wood. 3 loading f trusses and roof framing members would likely not calculate .to current, prescribed roof 4- There is currently little to no building foundation. The fragility of the building, in addition to the overall building size and lack of structural soundness; would require the` building to 'be completely dismantled. to facilitate the installation of a new foundation. New structurally sound framing, tie -downs, sheathing and other seismic connections would be necessary in addition to required fire safety improvement such as insulation, rated -wall construction, etc. Based on the above listed building deficiencies and the steps necessary to bring this building 'up to; a standard that would allow the safe use and, of, the building for;economically viable uses, it is myopinion that this building is not suitable for rehabilitation and to do so would be the equivalent of complete building replacement. I hope that this information proves helpful, If you have any;questions or comments,, please call. Sincerely., Tim McPartland, SE C i v i l a n d . S t r' u c t u r, . a 1 E n g' i n e e r i, in g 0 • 3 -Im Engineenna- REPORT )Yar,ehoase-Build'ing #4 First'Street, Petaluma, CA 'PHOTOS, SEiee t View From 15" Street VieWbf Exterior from 1 s' Street CD a� cn o _ cu r n> 0 m ,Cn ,m C" as C Cn;,. in ',Cn. N O L 'CC (O'.. CC cO CN C• • i CA.REY• &'CO. INC: ARCHITECTURE'. BASIN'STREET PROPERTIES -Petaluma; Califorrnia HIS;TORIC'.RESOURCE -CFE ST May 2003 INTRODUCTION' At the request of Bastn,Street Properties, y resource Care & Co. has undertaken historic evaluations of the properties located at, 102 D Street, 209, 219; 301 and 317 First'Street, 101, -"` Bouleva,rd�,S,outh, and 205`and.209 C Street in Petaluma. These taluma properties to ten buil •contain e dings.'ncluding a livery.atable, four'warehouses, a gas,sta[ion, an auto an showroom, and t relate ' '4. '" ' coma hree auto- ds strut ures;, Previous, evaluation and:survey work by Dan Peterson, Dan Napol►, Kaeherine`'Johnson Rinehart, Page and* Turnbull, and Clark Historic Resources Consultants, Inc., was'.reviewed and incorporated into the e;valuaeions. None of the selected properties ,have hot;b6ei Centered in the California Historic Resources Inventory System (CHRI'S). This reportTMis irate background info i ration to aid the owner and .the Cite of Petal City uma in their.eyalaatton of the historic sig rifica'property. tY P ncerof this' ro . _. ,_. METHODOLOGY " Carey &;Co. re� ared these, evaluatioris�',:b visinii Y. P properties, g photo lP p y g the sites to v'isuall inspect the oerties, takeg research The` • ' � 1.6� 200-3 nd,ApnhZ9, 2003 Dunngarchival � site v�stts w re ca eX1dton t n April' n the' Co.- evaluate - �� site visitCa'rey &.�. d the; g 'conditions,.historic,;features_, and architectural -significance of each property. Research' o'-n-'-,'t'he properties was„undet1.taken,at the •City offetaluma Community Development Department Buildin Division, Petaluma. , • Historical Ivluse.um and Library; and the Petaluma "Regional 'Branch Ing, Library and History'Room, This historic`i•esourite evaluationliclidi.not include invasive/destructive.tes ti ngj paint sampling and finishes ainalysi's,'archeologieiiI investigation;' and other similar techniques.. historic status of the selected `ro X i ,,p g the p eries' provide, Care &.Co. s rofesslonal o, inion regardin These hstoric;resource evaluatiop•4A property is considered;historlc if itGqualtfies as ns eligible for listin ;on the National,Re g g gister of Historic Places (NRHP), the'California Register - eligibility, Carey & Co. has followed /rocesses' created b the U In rnakin this determination of of Historical Resources CRHR and or'an relevant local Tists. g p y United States Department of the lnterior. (NRNP), the California State Historic.Pre_servat on"Officer (,CRH, R.); and any relevant local agencies. The authors of this •report meet the United, States °Department of the Interior' Professional Qualfi'ications.Standards for Architectural, Historians and,Historicai Architects.. As- . -• pp rofess o , 1 orad enOffic al.decl�a'rations of eli•r b lit ized as: vand:undercur_rerit P P P g gy historic ate ervat ons p to the NRH,P, CRHR ,and' local. lists, however, can only be madeby the appropriate government agency.. SUMMARY Our -evaluation was, b.ased,'on the Cfitefia-,f4 Evaluaiion:for the NRH'P which requires.that thei resource; be at'least ;fifty years old' "(except underspecial circumstances')., that it, retain its historic integrity, and 1 that it>:b'esignificant under at least one of four criteria: Thesefour criteria include: association with historic events,, association with important .persons,,d'istinct_iue; design or° physical characteristics,, and the potential to provide important information about history or prehistory. In determining National Register eligib'i'lity; we weighed, known, historical associations,. architectural merit, and the current. level of integrity. 'We have assi ned11 1. the ro er at 102 �D Street P g p p ty eet a NRH -P, Code of NR . in our o inion, that the: property appears eligible for separate listing; in the w ich indicates, HP for the building's aaaoctation with historrc events and for its physical; c'haraeteristics:. Therefore; the :propertyalso, wars eligible for. listing: on the,'.CRHR and` Petaluma'.s list of city. landmarks: We have pass ned' the-" ro ertiesat 209-;2,1,9 - g_ p p , 301, and 317 First S.treet,a NR4HP S`tatus'Code of 5,'which.indicates, in "our. opinion, that the,propertie -are ineligible'forlisting tn.the_NRH'P but are still of Vocaliinterest as:part of a locally designated. h:i toric district related ao °the. buildings'' association with historicevents. r is also our opinion that,the individual_ properties,are, not. eligible for listing.on the CRHR or Petaluma's list of city landmarks. P uth, and at.;Z09 C' Street ro erties at 101, and 11.5 Petaluma Boulevard So We have assigned the p . p ' a NRHP Status Code of 6Z, which indicates, in our o_ inion that. the properties do not possess (official)' evaluat on process. Because the _7 Pliroperties, g g complete hist ric, P _ properties, are over,50`years,old and,are .no significanceg for ksItin in the.NRHP throu h a property type ,at, are enerall iautomaticall' dis ualified''from lisun ori. the; NRHt one of 'the ro y tyP g y y q g R these, properties'has beenevaluated'under the standard'�Natioi al'Register,Cri"terra for.Evaluaition. B' ecause no historic significance has been established, these proper'tie's',integri't'ies have.not'been evaluated. Finally, we.hav,esae assned the ro ettrt,123PetalumaBoulevard South and 205 C Street a 'NRNP Status Code, of 6Z, which'indicates, in'_our opinion,, that the properties do not possess: (offtctal .evaluation rocess. Because the g .tmg in the NRNP through a complete' i _ P istoric) t nificance. arid' are therefore :ineprobert es late: not over,50 yearsold, and are.not of exceptional importance they.are automatically°disqua .'ified from listing on the NM -P. BASIN STREET ?ROPERTI ES HISTORIC RESOURCES EVALUATIONS List of Properties: John Grimes L"iveiy,;102' D'Street ■ Bar Ale Feed Co:, Warehouse 1, 209 First Street • Bar Ale Feed Co., Warehouse 2, 219 First Street ■ Bar Ale Feed Co., .Warehouse 3, 301. First Street ■ Bar Ale Feed Co., Warehouse:°4, 317 First Street ■ Flying A Gas Station, 101,Petaluma Boulevard. South :4 ■ Auto World, 115 Petaluma Boulevard South Auto World Sales Kiosk, 123 Petaluma Boulevard South ® Automotive Appearance. Specs; 209 C Street ■ Barker's "C"'Street Auto Body, 205 C Street State of California— The Resources.Agency Primary # DEPARTMENT'OF PARKS•AND RECREATION HRI # PRIMARY RECORD Trinomial NRHP Status Code 3S Other Listings F •. Review Code Reviewer Date Page 1. of 12 `Resource Name or #7 Inhn C7rimnc r "I.– P1. Other Identifier: McKinney Livery Stable 'P2. 'Location:. ❑ Not for Publication 1 Unrestricted `a. County: Sonoma, and (P2b and P2c.or P2d. Attach a. Location Map as necessary.) 'b. USGS-7.5' Quad: Petaluma Date: 1980 T R '/.'of '/. of Sec ; M.'D. B.M. C. Address: 102 D Street City: Petaluma Zip: 94952 d. UTM: Zone: 10 mEL m(G. R. S.) e. Other Locational Data: (e.g., parcel #, directions to resource, elevation; etc., as appropriate)' Elevation: Assessor's Parcel Number 008-068-003 'P3a. Description:; (Describe resource and its major elements. Include, design„materials,;condition, alterations, size,,setting . setting. and boundaries) The one -and -one-half story wood frame rectangular barn at the southwest corner'of D and. First Streets covers a footprint of approximately 50.feet.by 60 feet. Corrugated,metal •clads the gable roof obscured by the stepped wood parapet of the false front on.D Street. Painted V -rustic wood covers the D Street (east) elevation, while unfinished. board, and batten protects,the north and south -facades.. The west fagade-features').a combination of,board and batten siding on the gable end wall above vertical redwood siding at the lower, level. Along the•entire south side of the building a 201feet by 60 feet -board and batten clad single -story lean-to completes the barn. The walls typically rest on wood mudsills. The east, fagade, facing D Street, contains seven window openings: Corrugated fiberglass panels on the, exterior cover all but one: opening. Sliding oversized doors made;of vertical wood'boards,hang:from a"metal track at` the street level centered beneath the tallest reach _of the•parapet. Five window openings penetrate the elevation south:of the central ,doors, at the ground.floor. North•of the central door; one double -hung alurninum.frame window punctuates the faca ew at the ground level with a second, covered window opening above at the second level. (See Continuation,Sheet} •P3b. Resource Attributes: (Lists attributes and codes) HI?4-Ancillary,B'uiiding (Barn) " •P4. Resources Present: ElBuilding ❑Structure ❑Object ❑Site ❑District OElement'of District ❑Other (Isolates, etc.) P50. Description of Photo: (View. date, -,accession #) View of the�Scutheastcorner April '2003 °P6. Date-Constructed/,Age and Sources: OHistoric I ❑Prehistoric OBoth c. 1900'Sanborn Insurance maps `P7. Owner and Address: Robt;& Rose Baker, Tr Stanley & Evelyn Ramatici, TR 5 Highland Rd., Petaluma, 94952 °P11. ReportCitatiorj:s (Cite survey report and other sources, or enter "none.") None "Attachments: ON019E ❑Location Map ❑Sketch Map ❑Archaeological Record ❑District Record ❑Linear ❑Artifact Record, OPhotograph Record O Other (List): DPR' 523A (1195)' `.P8 Recorded). by: (Name, affiliation, and address) Kimberly Butt and Connor Turnbull Carey & Co, Inc:,. 460 Bush St., San Francisco; CA 94108 `P9. Date Recorded: April 2003 `P10: Survey Type: (Describe) Project Related, inclusive_ of . six properties IRContinuationSheet 2112luildi6g, Structure;' and Object Record Feature Record OMilling Station Record ❑Rock Art Record 'Required information State 'ofCal_iforma:= The;Resoy'r'ces Agency Primary;# •DEPARTMENT OF',PARKS AND'.RECREATION HRI# IC®WIN ATI.O:�V SB-IE'ET' Trinomial x Page,,1 'of 1_2 „ - '+'Resource:Name or 4 (Assigned by,record'er) janies Grirries L;very *Recorded by: Kimberly Butt and Coivior T.unbull Date A r�12 D Continuation0 Update ow modem wood ' p S The window and, door opening all feature flat -, A'narr, •� door coin letes'thenorth end -of the, ade wood trim surrounds „ The .west, rear facade,presents four corrugated fiberglass coveredwindow o en' fi central,,two vertical.board slyding;doors ;A'six life partially concealed fixed wood game wrndo'w' ' n tra es he wall n' lower of the eve above;°the central doors. Some w -m c ood'tnm'surrounds 'South, central doors a narrow vertical board door,stands,flusKwithhwall ure f4feature..flat w ace, as do the;two doors penetratuig the westwall of.the lean=to. Five window opening'penetrate the doo'v-kss'`north, river facing faq'ade A sixlite`wood-frame fixed window punctuates the easternmost end of ,the wall"with atwo=lite wood-frame'win _to:hewest.•Corrugated fiberglass lean=to elevation features y our covered window openings. covers, the ;remainuig openings The south -,only f it'ion. The'east.elevation exhibitsreelui" The:exterior is m poor overall Gond p` g;paint; cupped acid split cladding, and water damage. Other. typical exterior conditions.includ'e'biological>growth and, rising damp , Two east west.rows of,structural heav `firnber ost§ divideithe ma'inbarn°into three bays on the: interior. A,wood- Y- p. framed u shaped platforms rests on the -timber posts forming a loft, a_ lbeit without any provided access and surroundrng;a double heighi central'open volume. Plywood panel's and vertical boards clad the=;northern structural row fo ming rooms'to`tNe north. The southeasttcorrier of the,mam'structure i`s.enclosed with vertical tongue -and- gr6ove,dada' g'framing a-;toilet:room A board'and batten clad wall;acYoss the+south side separates'the lean-to from the main barn: The: flooririg;� ane"stithrougt out with areaslof;poured concrete, dilapidated;wood -boards, and square ;asbestos ti esin the -main barnYGravel on_,earth`floors the•lean-to No'historic "fixtures light the: interior Instead modem fluorescent celling,rnounted fixtures?'and', bare Bulb fixtures as well as _na Pial light illu ate the barn tyTpe extant windows througl'out are'm poor condition and many appear to be modem re acements. Typical wuidow s, include wood frame slid'rn g'and mulfi-lite fixed and hopper. Alterations Several alterations have transformed the live 'sJfa : earance since its:.inifial,constn�ciion:.The southern lea - rY Pp to addition was completed b ear, we n p y 1.923 A one story wood frame structure at the r ' � st, side once°stood adjacent to the present barn :This structure, was iemoved, in the early 1950s.,At some point'after the de"molihon of the rear lean-to, the was construc,e elevation,was moved west approxIirnately ten,feet away:from the,street and, the v=rustic clad false front I - east, D Street,.do Other visible alterahons include;.areas of wood utfilhabove;;the'narrow entrance door on the east elevation and. above the�central large slidingrdoors on'both the east and'west elevations. Also Sanborn•,Insurance maps. i•indicate,that'.wood:shingles�once,clad the roof wliichjs now covered by rusted:corrugatedhmetal. DPR 523L (1195) 'Requiredinformation' f" r �JG rff � r4 State of'Californa — The 'Resources Agency Primary # DEPARTMENT,OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI CONTINUATIONSHEET:. Trinomial'` -" Page 4 of:12 'Resource Name or. # (Assigned, by ;recorder) lohn Grimes Livery "Recorded by: Kimberly. l 6tt'and Connor'Tiimbull *Date: ,April 2003 El Continuation O Update I 26 .rcw'�rrErs'nwv,Nnn - ' ............ 66 ' {� 66' n *r Q FIRST_ A C Y p SECOND' 1894 Sanborn Map shows the vacanf site of 1906 Sanborn Map showsithe original two structures of the Livery Stable at 1" and D Streets' the Livery, Stable yxx � .1 x1 i sT 1923 Sanborn Map.shows buil'ding,adc ' the south and east of the L' NIble, DPR;523L (:1/95) 2 ►�exir. ier '--Cos Fri � i.-.. Insawnlx/-Jni (� jnIjII ff T 157 0 I �7. �''�2 1949 Sanborn -.Map shows the removal of the center section of the east'end and the addition "of the adjacent Fire Station *Required information � wwwxjjj� 6Q• Y p SECOND' 1894 Sanborn Map shows the vacanf site of 1906 Sanborn Map showsithe original two structures of the Livery Stable at 1" and D Streets' the Livery, Stable yxx � .1 x1 i sT 1923 Sanborn Map.shows buil'ding,adc ' the south and east of the L' NIble, DPR;523L (:1/95) 2 ►�exir. ier '--Cos Fri � i.-.. Insawnlx/-Jni (� jnIjII ff T 157 0 I �7. �''�2 1949 Sanborn -.Map shows the removal of the center section of the east'end and the addition "of the adjacent Fire Station *Required information State of California —The Resources Agency Primaryr# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND%RECREATICN! HRW BUILDING STRUCTURE9AND OBJEC GTRECORD Page of i,? *f*kOP'Statu Code 3S *Resource Name -or # (Assigned'6r)"lohnr6 M record Iver BI., Historic Name; - McKinney ' Livery" table, B2. Common Kq!tie% none; ,B3. Original' Use 11yetilStAble B4. Present Use: Farm mathineryshop/sforage *BS.' Arch itedt,Uta 1"Styli., VernacularTarm Structure BJ6. Construction History: (Construction date,, afterati6ps, and date;ofialterations)' COnstructedX.1906.5hed additions by 1923. Rear portion removed c.1958. Additional window op*q�' ings,(dat-vuriknown). *BT Moved? ONo. OYes O.Unknown Date: .0riginaltocation: *98. iRilated Features- N/A. ,None ;B9a. Atdhitect:, Unknown, b. Builder: UnknoWh, *t% Significance: Therne:,.Tranit!ortAtian Area*: be -talurfia' W&r 4 Period of Significance: 19064-94 Frbpertk'Type:- -Livery. Stable ;AppIjcbble;,Cdteria: NRNP (Discuss,'importahcell'n,terms lbf'hi'storicalor architectural cont'exuas defined by thbme, Oeridd: and,ge_ograpN6 scope. Also address integrity.) 511.. Add itional'.'Resource*tributes: (List attributes and codes) .'*B12. References: Sanborn MppCprqpany, "PetailiimaCity,"'jUly--11'983 Novem6b& 1886;w&r gust ,_1,898 becerneber,1894,'Novem ber'1906, ;Novernber:19,10, Decembw, 19231 September 1,949,(See.,e6nti)i,iiation.,sheet) B13. Remarks: *B14. Evaluator,* "Kimberly berly ttafid Connor Turnbull. Care & Co Inc:; rchite'c',ture '44�i_0, Bush St.. an Frghcisco. 0410' J,'Da'te'!,ofEvalu'atJon,: Aprf 1200 (This PIP -4c.6 reserved for official comments.) ... DPR 523M(1/95) 7 f, Tj%W14 L SUMCT i PROPERTY vpjtD SDUTH -PFTALUkA1301 !*Requi i red lhformat . ion State of California —,'!The Resources Agency, Primary,# DEPARTMENT OF,PA'RK'S-AND RE;CREATIO,N HRI#' CONTINVATJONSHEET. rTrinomial; - - Page :ab of 12 'ResourceName' or # (Assigned by recorder) 'James Grimes Livery 'Y *Recorded,'by KimberlyButt and Coh idt Turnbull *Date:.A nP '12003 El Continuation 0 Update Background. The Petaluma River attracted, early :Gahfomia.settlers to the -area. Hunter's.cainps and'trading posts were est ablished-,,alongitsbanks in1W, The Petaluma area became a popular source of agricultural production including grain_, feed,,,and vegetables.. It later became renowned for its poultry businesses which thrived until the mid:�1950s.'.Along with •river boats,, railroads and livery, stables provided other forms of ransportaton in the burgeoning City of Petaluma at. the tune of�the century, . At the juncture. of D Street ' formerly the,McKuutey.�.Livery'Stable Livery stables were a popular come �together,�stands 102 D Street, - And- First Street, where the aver<, railroad tracks and cit streeopula_r and important business in Petaluma :during its early'growth,as a city,: A;centeniiial edition of the Petaluma Argus C: '(1 argues that the popularity, of"livery, stables in:ea`rly Petaluma was due to the: high demand, for horse drawn vehicles for traveling around Sonoma County for distances in excess.of,35 miles,or•mor.e " The livery stable at 102 D Street.'is largely intact. Other Petaluma;livery stables, like the American; L;iveryStables on Kentucky Street, have been adaptively re -used by more recent owners. A Sanborn 'Fire Insurance,rnap.dated. 1894 indicates a residence and'twa,small buildings at the 102 D Street site., However, on a 1906'5anborn n ap, these small buildings are replaced by a one=story livery stable with a central dividing partition wall. The building is labeled "McKinney Livery,Stable on the map and shows a small off'i'ce and a harness room: By c. 1908;, McKinney was partnered with a breeder named John Grimes; as his name- appears on Arii historic, photograph of that time'.'" In that photograph, the building's horizontal wood-clad,'false front faiade appears very similar to its present composition'and` the names McKinney and Grimes appear as. signage. `In' a 1910 Sanborn map the liverystable is unchanged,. In 1920 George P. McNear purchased the'livery stable and leased it'to a veterinarian John E. Tierney°in 1922." A 1923-Sanbom-map shows'a shed•addition,at the south elevation, and'.' a small one story shed atthe°corner of the D Street facadeAn the:1939 Petaluma. City Directory,', Tierney's Petaluma Veterinary Hospital is listed at this location.'Later City Drectories:,indicate that, althougli:`vacait in 1947, the. McNear Company used 'the building,as,a barrel dep4rtrrerifirr.1950." An historic aerial'photograph indicates that a rear portion of the building was, removed by -1960.""' The:`building is currently used as a farm machinery repair shop. Evaluation Criteria National Re i"ster B g " ullefin Number' 15; How to: Apply, the National Register Griterid for Evdl ivation, describes 'the Criteria,for Evaluation as being.composed of two factors. First, the property must be "associated with an important, historic context." , The National Register identifies four possible, context. types, of which at least one:must be applicable at 'the hationali state; .or local level. As listed under Section'8,'"Statement of Significance;"' of. th6 National.Register of Histor'ic.Places Registration Form, these are - "A. Property, i's associated with event s:that-have made asignificant contribution to the broad -pafterns of. our history.' , "B:. Property -;is associated.with the,lives.of persons significant in our past. • ' `'C. Property` embodies the distinctive characteristics atype period, or method of construction or represents, the work of, a master;; orpossesses high artistic values; or iepresents'a'significant'and distinguishable entity whose components lack individual distinction. DPR 523L (1195) 'Required information Statel of California— The'Resources Agency Primary # DEPART ,IMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Page 7 of 12 'Resouce Name or #,(Ass i 9 ned by ,;;recorder) Iarries Grimes Liver Y' _ F 2003; O Continuation - p Update Recorded b Kimberly -Butt Arid Connor Turnbull• Date:, A nl` "" pX y y y to yield,. information important to prehistory'. o>• . D..Pro ert has ielded, oris likel history, Sh st nc inte rit -of those featur` sine essa y to., for-. ap p ty q y nal Register s Criteria for Evaluation, rt must also retain' g Y p y g gnificance ""' While a.'Property"'sssignificance o- context, itsr ry o .conve rts si relates. to jis role within a s .ecifit historic irate rity refers to ';afproperty' - physical features 'and how, they relate to its significance .."x"'To determine if, a property retains the physical characteristics. corresponding,to its, historic :context, ,the: National Register has iderif°ified seven; aspects'of integrity. These. are: "Location• is the,place `wheie the historic property was, constructed or the place where the historic event occixrred:.. "Design is ,the combiriation,of elements t-h'atcreate the form, plan, space,, structure;nand:style of aproperty,;:: „ 'Setting is thephysical environment' of a historic property:.. "Materials is -the physical elements .that were combined or deposited during a:particilar0 period of trine and.in a particular pa#tern or, configuration to form * historic. property:.. "Workmanship is the physical;, evidence of the crafts .of a particular culture or peopfe,,durilg, any, given period" in,history o ,vrehistory : „ "Feeling •.is ar property's expression of the; aesthetic or historic. sense of a particular period of time... "Association .is the direct link between an, imp,ortant..h'istoric:everitor person and a historic property:" 'iii Since integrity:is based,on a property's significance within a specific historic context, an evaluafion of a property's integrity can: only occur,after.historicf significance• has beer► established,"'"" California Office of Historic'Preservation's°Technical Assistance Series 06, Calihrniq Register ctnil.Nat oval Register: A Comparison, -outlines the differences between the federal ,and, state pi ocesses'The context°types to.be used when establishinga the significance of a property fora'isting on the Calforitia'Reg'ister are: very similar, with emphasisonlocal„and state,"s'ignifican'ce: Theyare: 1. Itis associated with events that have patterns of local or regional.:.history..;_ or t rnade,a.signzficant contribution,tothe broad he, cultural heritage of Califoinaa or .tlie United States; or "2. It is.associatedwith the lives. of persons.rnportant to local; Galifomia, or national " history; or DPR•523L(1'/95) - 'Required"information ' a State ,ofCakornia' 'TherResourc Resources geh�y, Prim ry # DEPARTMENT'OF PARKS ANDMECROT)dW HR( QONTIPUATONSHEET 3rinornial' Page 8 of 32 *Resource ,'Name or #. ('Assigned, igned, by recon6r)j6rhesGrimes . Liver "Recorded. by: Kirhbetl BUti-and Connor Turnbull'Date: Aprif:2603, r-21'Continuation 0 Update '1- It embodiesAhe distiActiv characteristic's of'a' type,-.��eri"od,�'or,method,of construction or represents the w"ork,o��,a',ma"s"ter, or possesses . sesses hiLih , art , isilc'values;l ,tor 4. It has yiel&d','- or i's�llikely� to�yield, information- importa�ntto prehistory or history of the local area, Cdlif.MIA, or the nation. Like the NRNP, evaluation for eligibility to the California Register ',requires. an,establishment of historic significance before integrity, is`c'ons'ider&d!'0 CalifofnWs-infegifty, thr"eshold"is slightly lower than the federal level. As, a result, sorte!�'�res.oiitces,-th4t,'alre historically sigh"ificarif-but do not NRHP integrity V1 standards may be eligible for- listing on the California 9&gister.' California's list. of special considerations is, shoiter and more lenient , than'the NRNP. It includes some I allowances for moved buildin 'str S�w ll,as low-er,fe-quire�ments for proving the buildings,.s. uctures�,'orobjects, a, e, i significance of resources -that are less than 50 years old and a more elaborate discussion of the eligibility of reconstructed buildings.'" In- addition to separate evalluatiphs; for eligibility to the,Califorthia RegisterAhestate will automatically list ig resources if they are listed or determined eligible for the, NRHF, )4h Toug .,-a vompl6te evaluation process list of 'ity landmarks. The city e local register relevant tafhis`� h"is"tibIc resource, evaluAfT '48'Feta uJi-na's ci government, has formally ad'6pie'd,the,',CR.,HR..criteria wlth�,-effiphasis oft'local significance for use in determining local landmark staius. Findings 10 o JS WehaVe'assigned the property, at', � �"D,`Str'e6t,.a"N!RHP Statug',C' a�-�',6f-,,,3S,,:Which.i,ndicat'es, in our opinion, that the property 'is. eligible e' National Register.""`The livery„stable'po'ssesses historic significance under the theme of transportatibn in the area, of the P , etAluma River and is.therefore eligible fot'individual listing in the NRNP at the local' le f f vPl,o significance. Because the property is over .50 years old and is not one of the property types "that are :generally ,automatically disqualified ftdrfi listing on the NRHP,,this property ha's been, evaluated under the standard National Register Criteria iorEvaluation. in that the Itis opih'. icaficeand ,istherefore eligible for individual listing on the California Register'of 'Historic Resources. i. Theproperty'Wo6ld be automat,'ieall,y,lisfL-d,on,.th6,CRHR'becaus4e�it�is.a-possib,le*c-and'idaie:forih&N,R,,H I P and has been ,deter-rnined individ Vally eligible through a compl6tei&a1lua1i'6n pro.ces I s, As a 'result, this Property has been evaluated under the stand'ard,,state criteria. R);1- pro S h events that have made a Criterion, A -(NREP), -J."KM The , Y:au,102 'U� freet,!§ ry OCIatedTWItportignificant,co Intfibu"ttbAh&broad pattern ,Sof -Pefalurna'9 histoThe liver ion� c yy,stable is significant as an q .I A” ft, JIL rlyTeka'lufria-.� Theparticular, stable at 102 D Street, stands ad I jacent imp6rtariVttAn "po a ion provi er in ea D"St,-L kik • to the active �ree-t�b-r�i'd,"g6,,tra�ris'-o-' ationcofrid6f-aaw Tasthe once active w are"hous6s along First p r.t ''I', T1 Stfeet.,,,Unlik& 6th6r liv. tables in Petaluma thait"Wet�!,Adaptively°re-us6d'-*for other programs, 102 D S . fteet is relatively t ively un4ltL �red. COR 523L (1/95) *ReqUired informati6n, State of California- ' 'The Resources Agency, Primary it DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND. RECREATION HRI# CONTINUATION 8` EET Trinomial Page :9 of''12 'Resoiirce;Name or.# (Assigned,by recorder) IainesGriin-sliver y; `Recorded; by Kimberlv..Butf=and Connor Turnbull 'Date: A141 ='. ' O Continuation` .0 Update Criterion B (NRHR) / 2 (CRHR): The property` at 102.:D Street is "not associated with the livesof'personsI significant in our past: Criterion C (NRI IP) / 3 (.CRI-iR): The: property at' 102. D!'Street doesfiot embody°the distinctive characteristics of a'type, period, or method of construction. The property does,not,rep esent theiw,ork of a master; possess high artistic values, or'represent a. significant and distinguishable entity whose compon. ents,lack individualdistinction. Criterion D (NRHP) / 4 (CRHR) The property at 102 D-aStreet has not yielded, nor is it;hkely to yield, inforrnation:important~to prehistory°or history While, this criterion is generally applied to archeological resources; itapplies to any building, structure, or object whose physical.: fabric itself can be. considered an artifact The i02 D Street property, ,contains no visually -observable,: above=ground elements .,whose physical. :fabrie'includes lunique materials, provides information on special building techniques, or.has fhe,potential. to -provide: information, about our past. retain its integrity., ignif cant association with early Petaluma transportation, the table at,1'02 D Street must p g p Petaluma Museum'and the-.Petalurria.Library and Sanborn Fire: Insurance ma sindicate• that: Historic , hoto ra .hs located at; the P „. `Location; 102.,D Street is in its originallocation: Design., Althou 'h.not.outstandin u1 its desi` theform style, and Pr. , ular;buildin g g ` gn, , lan of this vemac g to gn gn P Y. p y f the, rear portion of contribute, to its sr j icanee. The desi has been artrall grn aired b. the removal.o the building.„ Setting., The livery stable; stands in a similar setting, to;its original. The building hashistoricallri;free; g -. J Y g g g building's,access to a city.sfi -is . standin The ma•ont of the ne hborun buildin s. are extant and. the retained. Materials. The, livery stable's material:.are mostly' extant; except where the ;rear portion was, removed. The remaining wood frameis;i' tact. Workmanship. The: livery stable isa vernacular-,structu- and retains its false front, and wood cladding' over a,;wood frame: Feelin1.g. ,This.. building continues to express the nature of its use as a;forrner l verystable:`The vernacular wood construction,;fdlse' front and open plan contrib'ut e'to this feeling:, Association.°The warehouse'"s' association with transportation eontiriues In -4 its present use -as a _farm machinery -repair shop. p g Y le ' ronve its. significance The propery ontinues topossess. sufficient to nt , such that, rt is ;ab y, • W_ efind• that,the buildup e at 1'02• D, Street has been.assi ed a NRHP Status Code of 35;; as it is eligible for. individual „listing on the National Register at -the local level of significance: DPR 523L,(1/9.5)"'*Required information • • State',of California —.The Resources Agency Primary DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND" -RECREATION HRI# CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial VI IL -miesource, Name or ago. ku `. 9 Y ''D'ate": A n imesLiverr Recorded b Kim erl' -'Butt_and. and -Connor Tumbu ssl ne recor of ,.1 ameS ' r y:- b y C 11 P 12003' 9, Continuation 0 Update Endnotes 'Adair Heig, History -of Petaluma: A:California River Town (Petaluma, CA: Scottwall Associates, 1982): 123 John Anderson, Earl Pet orse Drawn Street Cars, Many Livery Stables," Petaluma Argus-- y luma� Had:H Courier (August 18, 1955) Ll Petaluma Historical Society Ral, mpllet (untitled, 1997),Petaluma,Muse' m Archives. Lee Torliatt Voices of America: Gol . � den Memories Redwood Empire (Chicago, IL: Arcadia Publishers, 2001) Kath erihe Johnson, A Walkin Tou ' : g r,of Petaluma's South Central RiverfrontNeighborhood" (October 2001 Petaluma Cit Director 1939 City y ( )Petaluma History Room;.'PetaPurna Main Library. Petaluma City Directory (1947, T950);Tetaluma History Room; Petaluma, IVlain Library. `'n' Photograph binders, Petaluma Museum Archives. ix. How to Apply.the National.Register Criteria'for Evaluation, National :Register:Bulletin, no. 15 :(Washington, D.C.: United5tates Department of the Interior, 1997): 3. x. How to Complete the National. Register Registration Form, National Register Bulletin, no. 16A (Washington, D.C.: United States Department of iheInterior, 1997): 75. xi. How to Apply the National Register Criteria for Evaluation, 3. xii. Ibid, 44: . x I hirAbid 4.4""-45. xiv. Ibid, 45. f g Sere°s, no. 6 (Sacramento, CA'rCalifomia be California artOrnfent of Pai one Preservation Register and National-Register:,A, Com a Technical Assistance 'p ks and Recreation,; 2001), xv. a t or 1. xvi.:Ibid, xvii. Ibid, ;2: 1Heiorical Landmarks l from number'770.onward are also automaticall fisted on the Cal forn'ia Reg' (California Register of Historical Resources. TheiIistmg Process, California Office of DPR 523L;(1'/95) *Required, information StaWof California,— The Resources Agency Primary # DEPARTMt-NT OF PARKS' AND RECREATION HRI# CONTINUATION !SHEET" Trinomial Page 1_1 of -12 'Resource Name or'#"(Assigned by recorder) IarnmG'rimes Lived ., *Recorded, by: Kimberly Biittand Connor Turnbull *Date: AprJI'200O Continuation O 'Update Historic Preservation, Technical Assistance Series,,,no. 5 (Sacramento, CA: California Deparfinent of Parks and Recreation,ndd,j, 1.) xix it - V , . ' Instructions for Recording, HistoricalResources.ii (Sacramento, Office of Historic Preservation,1995) References Biographical ofma ,Cal fo ilesi by, an.Bo'iwin and L-ee:Torhatt, Petaluma Historical Library and Museum," ,e , California. Regis"ter and NationalRegisie"r.: A"Cornparison, California Office of'Histoiie Preservation .Technical Assistance Series; no:,6.,(Sacramento, CA:'California,Department of Parks and Recreation,2601;). Cal forniarRegister of Historical, Resources; TheL-isting Process;.,CaliforniaOffice of Historic. Preservation Technical Assistance`Series; no 5. ;(Sacramento, CA: California Department of:Parks" and Recreation; md'.) Central Petal"oma Specific,Plai1, Final Draft. February2003, City, of Petaluma Plarining De,partn-ent, Petaluma, California;.. Heig;Adair. History of�Petoluma: a California river town. (Petaluma, CA:,,ScottwalLAssoc ates, 1"982): ' How to Applythe `National.Register- Crit&igd for, Evaluation, National Register" Bulletin, no ,15., f Washington, D.C.." United States Department of the Interior, 1.997), How to' Coinp'lete the National Register Registration, Form, National Register' Bulletin; no.,16A. ,(Washington, D.C. United States -Department of the In_'terior, 1997).: Illustrated . -- f y ' f (.: CA.Reynolds; &Proctor;1897)� Atlas o Sonoma°Count California. Santa Rosa, Instructions. for Recording Historical Resources. (Sacramento, CA California Office..of Historic Preservation, 1995). Johnson, Katherine. "A. Walking Tour. of Petaluma's South Central,'R verfront Neighborhood," October' 2001. Johnson, Katherine. "425 First, Street," 'State, of Californina, Department of Parks and -Recreation, 'Primary Record 523A),and Building Structure and Oblect: Record a(523B), December 1997. Kyle, Douglas E., Mildred Brooke Hoover,,Hero'Eugene`Rensch, Ethel Grace Rensch, and Willian N. Abeloe Historic,Spots'in C iliforn-ia. °(Stanford; CA: Stanford University,P' 'ss, -2002,): DPR523L (:1195)r •Requiredin`formation esourc CREATION Primary #„ . a—The R y. State of Cali form �� "r � DEPARTRAENT,OF PARKS ANDRE HRItl, C®N_iGNUATI®N SHEE; g 2 Resour �e or�; Assi red ce Nam � � � Trinomial ae12of1_ erd lames Grimes Liver. 0 'Recorded by: KimberlY,504'and Connor Turnbull. :! , 'Date: A rtl 2,003, O'Continuation 0, Update Milliken, James for the P 'Dernocrat Publishing Company. Si noma County Illustrated. (Los Angeles, CA: ress George Rice &„Sons, 1901). Napoli, Don. "Petaluma Commercial District National. Re' ister Nomination,” National. Park Service, 1994. I g .. New Historical Atlas of,Sonoma:County California. (Oakland, CA: TbQs. H. Thompson, 1877). Permit,Files; City of:Petaluma:Community Development Department Building Division, Petaluma, California-. Petaluma 'City Directories, 19.14-54, .Petaluma History Room',Petaluma Regional Branch Library, Petaluma, California. Peterson, Dan. "Histor"ic Resource Inventory of Petaluma;" 1976.' Photo Binders, Petaluma :Historical' Library and Museum,,,Petaluma,.'California. Sanborn"Firelnsurance Company Map -of Petaluma, CA,. July 1°883; - September 1949, Earth Sciences and Map Library, University of California at Berkeley. Torliatt, Lee. Voices of A/ne.rica GoldekMe- movies of the Redwood Empire. Chicago,.1L: Arcadia. Publishers, 2001. u - I �w I,' h , Al I I i 4 DPR'523L (1/95) 'Required information, State -of California —•The. Resources Agency Primary fi DEPARTMENT OF'PARKS AND RECREATION HRI tl. PRIMARY RECORD Trinomial NRNP Status Code 5 Other Listings — Review, Code, Reviewer Date Page 1 of Al " Resource Name or #n209. First,, - Street PI :other, ldehtjftr:; Bar Ale. Feed ,Co:, Warehouse-J, °P2 Loci aton: O Not fr P.oublication IRUnrestricted' °a: County:;Sonoma •, ,and (P2bvand Plc orP2d.. Attach a Location Map as necessary.) °b. USES ,7 5- Quad: Date:T R '7. of '/: ofiSec c. Address 209 First Street City: Petaluma Zip- 94952 d. UM Zone 10 mE/ e. Other Locational Data:, (e.g.,,parcel 0, directions4o resource, elevation, etc., as appropriate) Elevation: Assessors Parcel.Number 008-121; 007 * - .. design, Th s one setor tl, ndusI allwa ehouse strulct:re is feet n tular ntl Ian anci stands ISeroen1dioculare�a't'ions„size,•setting, and boundaries) p (major y _ g p p p , ane Pefaluma ;River. The building .consists of wood frame construction with corrugated metal cladding and a rusted corrugated! metal elad;ndouble-gable. roof. Windows include one„corrugated' fiberglass,•..ribbon`wtndow below, each First,Street; south gaple end wall and.one.horizontal opening filled with"si'x, six -;lite wire mesh -covered, fixed wood -'framed •aligned windows in poorgondition,below each,riverside, north; gable end'wall' Large ,corrugated;metal.slidi'ng barn;doors,at'First'Street, as well as a,largeVoid at the south end of the east elevation allow.access to the4n.terior ,A.corrugated metal clad awning-projects,from,the east elevation, partially'protecting-the :north end of the void in the wall below. Corrugated metal patching, visible on the exterior dadding,, indicates where former, openings have beer!• nfilled. Other features include;various signage,•,and wall mounted projecting indusirial=type light fixtures. The overall condition of the warehouse exterior is,poor. The interior of Warehouse a, used primanly;fo r-,siorage,;featu'res'.a large volume wiWexposed timber framing d'i ided by a wood frame painted plywood -clad': wall runnin&east'-fo=west"in the:structur' southern portion. One north south row of?wood posts stands exposed beneath the°roofvalley.•Poured concrete floors ;;the southernhalf of"the'warehou"se; while'a haphazard combination, covered with eorru afed metap Fiiur o sheets cover the northern section of,the,floor. The ceilingtconsists•of exposed wood tru! of as halt wood boards and; 1 woo ' g y rectangular corrugated.f�berglass panelssef:'in the roof, plane;ofter natural.lig}it to the spa in conjunction .with the windows at the rear. No,nterior electric light has ever been installed. The';interior° wall,surfaces,are Unfinished" and reveal the exposed wood frame stud'wall construction. The w"alehouse inferioris in'overall'poor condition. 'P3b. 'P4: Resource Attributes: (List attributes and codes) HP8 — Industrial Building (Warehouse). Resources, Present: ®Building, OStruciure OObject OSite' 1IDistrict OElemerit of District i0Qther°(Isolates, etc.) F15b. Description'of Photo: (View; date accession #) Yew of the Southeast Corner April ,3003 `,P6. 'Date :Constructed/Age and 'Sources:,[RlHistoric r 0Prehistorc 0l3oth 1918;,Ciiy of ';Petaluma Parcel' Information Report °P7., Ownerta id Address: James MacNab Ill, 3570 Ridgeview.Dr' Santa Rosa,. CA, .954042 P'oded by:' (Name, affiliation, and address') Kimberly'ButVand Connor Turnbull Carey &Co; Inc., 460 Bush St.jI$ah.Francisco; SCA=941'08 'P9. bate'. ecorded Aprii 2003 °P%— Survey Type: (Describe) Project Relate&I, iricl`uswe of 10 properties *P -TI: ReportCitation: '(Cite ,survey ,eport and other -sources, or "enter c 'none!") *Attachments: 13NONE OLocation Map OSketch Map 'MContinuaitioni Sheet ElBuilding, Structure andObject Record . pArchaeological Record ODistrict Record OLinear Feature, Record, OM )ling Station Record 13%dk Amort Record' OArtifact Record, OPhotograph Record O Other (Listp: State of, California - The Resources Agency Primary #' , DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION ARM tONTINUATION SHEET Page 3, of 11, 'Resource, Name or!:f-(Assgned;by recorder)' ;209'Ficst Street: 'Recorded';byKirnb"erl"Butt and Connor Turnbull *Date: April -2003. ® Continua#ion ❑;lJpdate ------------- a I- a' - 25 Q ro a . ! k_ C r'e e k C2 m .TTM:-- 0 - ._. 1• At: VON tfN ! p Ci i 0 o The,1923 Sanborn m' i5 s.the warehouse.at 209 First The 1949`1Sanbor-n map shows�the addition ,of a, shed Street being used for"feed, and' grain storage: by M awning on7the east sid'e:of the warehouse at 209 FJrst., Vonsen &Co. Street, as. well as�a .greater development gf'the .' surrounding;properties: ,DPR 523L (1195) • ° Required information ornla — The,.RPeniire" e"A,:.. -_ - v. ,r,Mr�na'r�ryv RCI.RCA1;lUN HRW BUILDING, STRU'CTURE, AND- OBJECTRECORD Page., 4 ;of 11 *NR HP' Status Code 5. *Resource Name or #(Assigned,by recorder)209 Firsf`Street' 8.1. Historic Name- 82. Common Name: Bar�Feed Ale - Co. Warhouse 1 83. Original Use: Agricultural _Warehouse 84.Pres6nt`Use:'.Agr i ultu al Warehouse 'B5. Architectural style: 'Vernacular, Warehouse °136: Construction History: (Construction;date, alterations, and date of alterations) The warehouse,was built in 1918: °B7. Moved? l]No ❑Yes ❑Unknown Date: Original Location: 'B8. Related Features: N/A 89a.'Architect: Unknown b. Builder., Unknown. Period of Significance 1 Agricultural Commerce .Are.. Discuss im ortance m term . pp 91 Property Type Warehousealuma Applicable Criteria: A 0. Significance Theme Rlverfront A architectural context as defined b <theme, period, and geographic scope. Also address integrity.) (See Continuation Sheet y' < p s o �stoncal or B11. Additional Resource Atfributes: (List,attribuies and codes) none °812. References: ,(See Contimsation.Sheet) B,13. Remarks: *B14. Evaluator: -.Kimberly Buti�and Connor Turnbull `Date of Evaluation: Apri1;2003 '(This space-resenred'forofficial com'menw) T LU`1A RIVER SUBJECT, r 1 PE PROPERTY qt! r ,�A�. STREET _-----...... �- N 2ND STREET-_— � I 'Required information Stateof California =TFie Resources Agency P.rimary.# DEPARTMENT,°OF PARKS,AND RECREATION HRIX CONTIG. dJATION ;SHEET" Trinomial Page ;5 of T_l. Resource;Name or #`(Assigned by recorder) 209 Fust;5treet 'Recorded bY Kimberly. Butt.and Connor Turnbull 'Date- Apr2003 . © ;Continuation 0 Update Criterion" (our a)st. Ma R us Vo s The property at 209 First Street is' not associated with the 'lives -of persons si ificant a owner.of de":M. Vonsen Co. was a local'businessman and 8n p gn_ en, operated several warehouses in the area. He, is one of a' numbe"r of Petaluma businessmen involved in the grain and, feed business: R : The ro e " , at 209 Fust Street does no,t_emb y � , distinctive; characteristics of a type, period,P P �, riterion C� NRHP 3 .CRH P P rtY od the of a. master, possess high artisticova uesi odr epr sent a siignificant and distingu shablet represent the work entity' whose components lack individual distinction. The,property is characteristic of the warehouse type found in this area of Petaluma. ;Criterion D. (NRHP) / 4 (CRH R)- The: property 010.9" First Street has not yielded, nor is rt likely to yield, information, important to prehistory or history. While this criterion_is generally applied to archeological resources, it applies to any building, structure, or°object whose physical fabric ;itself can be,conside ed' an artifact. The; 201 First Street property, contains, no visually -observable, above -ground elements whose Physical fabric includes unique materials, provides information on special building te-hniques,.or'has the potential to 4provide information about; our past. Since.209 First Street, althoughnoteligible for,hst g as indivually significant;.coiild be'listed as a contributing property to a potential local historic district, 'it is. important to evaluate its integrity. His tori photographs 'located at the Petaluma,Museum and the,Petaluma Library indicate that: Location: -209 First Street is in„its original location., Demgh. Although anot Qua potential local histo d stinal, style, and plan contribute'to. its significance `as a, g� gnthe con trnbuhn -;remain. Setting. The building is one of several buildings -that are part of a potential local„histonc district: Although other buildings that.once,stood nearby are:no longer extant, there,are still,enough buildings`to maintain the overall physical environment: Materials: The w, arehouse,material,is: extant, and in'its original configuration Workmanship. Not, applicable. Feeling; This building together with' its neighbors continue to express the industrial nature of the area as related_ to the grain and feed business. Association, The warehouse, continues to be associated .with other similar uses that,characteri'- the industrial complex ofproperties.important to Petaluma s history. - We find,'that the buil'dung continues o possess sufficient integrity"such that itis able 'ta convey:its: significance as areoritnbII resource to,a potential°Local historic district, howeverwe_:4id not, find the warehouse to: be eligible,for ind'ividual`listing • 11 Stateof'Califdrriia.— The Resources -Agency Primary # .DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Page ( of 11 'Resource' Name or # (Assigned by'recorder) 209. First Street *Recorded by: Kimberlj Butt and Connor Tumbull *Date: Al2ril 2003 O Continuation O Update 'relates to its role within a specific historic context, its integrity" refers to "a property's physical features and how they relate to its significance.!"', Todetermine if a property retauis the physical characteristics corresponding to its historic,contezkt; the National Register has�identified seven aspects of. integrity. These are: "Location is the placewhere.the historic property was constructed or the place where the historic 'event occurred.:. "Design is the combination of elements that create the form, plan,"space, structure, and style of a property... "Setting is the physical environment of a historic property... "Materials is the physical,elements that were combined. or deposited during a particular period of time and in a articular attern pr confi" " ration to, form a.historic" ro eirf P P..... P 1u .. P P Y... "Workmanship is the physicalevidence of the crafts of a particular culture or people during any given period" in history' or prehistory... "Feeling is a property's expression of the aesthetic or historic sense of a particular period of time... "Association'is.the direct linkbetween an important historic, event or person and a historic: property."' Since integrity is based: on a property's significance, within a specific historic context, an evaluation of a property's integrity can only occur after historic significance has been established." California Office of Historic Preservation's Technical Assistance Series,#6, California Register and National Register::.A Comparison,, outlines the differences between the federal and state processes. The context types to be used when, establishing the significance of a property for listing on the California Register are very similar,: with emphasis on local and state significance. They are: "1: It is associated with events that.have'made a, significant contribution to the broad patterns of local or. regional history,; or the, culturalheritage, of .California or the United States; or "2. 'It is associated`with the lives of persons)iinportant to'local, California, or national history; or "3 It embod esthe distinctive "characteristics of a type, period, onnethod of construction or represents the :work of.a master_, or possesses high artistic values. or . " 4 It,has yielded, or is likely to yield, information important to `prehistory or history of the local;a "rea, California, orLL& natibm"XII 6P'523L (1195) *Required information State of California — The Resources Agency Primary,r# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Page 7 of 11 -*Resource Name or # (Assigned by recorder) 209 First Street 'Recorded by Kimberly Butt and Connor Turnbull . 'Date: A ril 2 O Continuation ❑ Update Like the NRHP, evaluation :for eligibility to the California Register require an establishment of:hstoric significance before integrity is considered. California's integrity threshold 'is slightly lower than'the federal level. As a result, some resources .that are historically significant but do not meet NRH:P integrity standards may eligible for listing on the California Register:""' California's list of secial considerations is shorter and more lenient than the NRHP. at includes some P allowances -for moved�buildings, structures, or objects; as well as lower requirerrients for proving'the significance of, resources that are less' than. 50 years -old and, a more elaborate discussion of the eligibility of reconstructed buildingsx' In addition to:se.parate, evaluations for eligibility to the California Register, the state will automatically list resources if they are listed or determined eligible,for the NRHP through a, complete evaluation process." The loca g local.. ister,relevant to this,hstoric resource evaluation is, Pe:taluma's list of city'landmarks. The city government has formally adopted the CRHR criteria, with emphasis on.local significance for use in . determining local; landmark status. findings We have; assigned the property at 209 First Street a NRNP Status Code of' 5, which indicates, in our, opinion, that the property is: ineligible for the. National Register but is still of local interest as part of a potential locally designated historic district.X"' The warehouse does not ind'ividuallypossess historic significance and is therefore ineligible for individual .listing in the NRNP.. Because the property, is over 50' y, ears old arid is not one of the property types that are generally automatically disqualified from listing on the,NRHP, this property has been evaluated under the:standard National Register Criteria for Evaluation. Itis also our opinion that the property does not possess individual historic significance and -istherefore not eligible for individual listing on :the California: Register. of Historic Resources. The property has not been. automatically listed on the CRHR because' it is=.not listed on the NRHP and has not been determined :individually eligible through a complete evaluation process.. Asa result., -this property has been evaluated under the standard state criteria: However, the 209.First Street was identified during this, and. previous evaluationsx"" as belonging toa group of warehouses that. might constitute a focal historic district °if "ffurther. documentation and research. were undertaken. As.a group, the warehouses located along First Street are similar buildings, typically featuring corrugated.metal claddingwith.eithersingle or double gable roofs and large openings. "These blocks of predominantly gabled metal buildings, specifically bounded by First -Street and the river are unified by their industrial use and style.'`x""' Criterion A (NRHP) / I (.CRHR)*: The property at 209 First Street is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to'the'broad patterns :of Petaluma's history. The warehouse was used to store grain and feed along with several other buildings along First Street and in neighboring' streets that serve this and ,related, purposes. Although;not eligible for, listing in either the national or:. state registers, together these properties�could potentially form a local historic district. DPR 523L (1/95) *Required information e of California.— The Resources Agency ARTMENT OF,PARKS AND RECREATION INTINUATION SHEET° 'I of 1_l Resource Name, Primary'# HRI# (Assigned by recorder) *:Recorded by: Kimberly Butt`and Connor Turnbull, *Date A rif 2003 I] Continuation ❑Update Criterion B (NRHP) / 2 (CRHR)- The property at 209 First Street is not associated with the .lives of persons significant in our°past,'Magnus. Vonsen, the owner of the A Vonsen .Co. was a .local businessman and operated several warehouses in the area: He is one of a number of Petaluma'businessmen involved in the grain, and feed business. Criterion C (NRNP) / 3 (CRH -R,)':, The property at 209 First Street does not embody the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or method of construction. The roe also, does not.re resent the work of.a master,. possess high. artistic values, or represent a significa t and. a tiriguishable entity whose components lack individual distinction. The property is characteristic i0f the warehouse type found in this area of Petaluma. Criterion D (NRNP) / 4 (CRHR): Theproperty.,at 209 First Street has 1,not.yielded,nor-is it likely to yield, information important octant to prehistory or histo . While this criterion is generally applie tIo archeological P rY P � 1 , resources it applies to P pm ystru contains no visuall, .-obse``physical fabric itself can`•be considered an ose n T ert cont rvable;:above-ground elements whose a tune, or ob'ect wh h sical fabric includes _ e i ro mforrnatio' on " q y s , ecial',bildin tech ni artifact. a 09 First Struru ue�matenals,. royides ' ue P - P g q s, or h'as the potential to provide information 'about -our past. Since 209 First -Street, although not eligible for listing as indivuall si contnbutin property to w y gnificant, could. be fisted as a g p p ty a potential local' historic.district, itis unportant to'e valuate its integrity. Historic photographs located at the Petaluma Museum and the Petaluma Library >ndicate,that: Location. 209 First Street is',in its,ornguallocation. contributing resource to a potential g he form st le and Desi Although not outstandin ,m its design, t y plan contribute to its significance as a g p ial local historic district remain. g• g veral Setting. The building is one: of se buildings that are. part of:a potential local historic: district. Although b physical y g g - gs to maintain .other -buildings that .once stood nearb .are no°lon er',eztant there are: still eriou h build;in the overall h sical environment. is The, Material warehouse°;material.is extanf and in its original configuration.' anshi - Workrn p Not applicable. Feeling. This, builduig together With its neighbors conti related to the,grain and fnue to. express .the industrial nature of the area as eed ' business. Association. The warehouse continues to be,associated with other similar uses that characterize the industrial complex of properties important to Petaluma's history. �e find that the building continues to possess sufficient integrity such that if -is able to convey its `!'significance as a contributing resource to a potential local historic district. „DPR5231_ (1/95) - *Required information State, oft i alifornia— The Resources,,Agenc,Y Primary # DEPARTMENT OF PARKSAND RECREATION POINTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Page_ 2-of,11 *kesour' co Name or ,# (Assigned by recorder) 204 FirsfSireg *Recorded, by kKimberly.BUtt and Conhor Tumbull *Date! April 2003 0 Continuati . 0 Updatp Endnotes �'Adair 14 eig, History of -Petaluma. -'A Califoinia, River Townw(petalum' ai, CA: ScottwallAss6ci Associates, 82.):1 123, Mildred Brooke Hoover, Hero Eugene.Reftsch.,Eth6l Grace Rens�ch, William N. Abeloejevised,by Douglas E. Kyle, Historic ic Spots, in:Califomi-'14 (.Stai0oidj,Ck',S niversity-Tressi 2002)�:51 3 tahf6rd U Sanborn Fire1risurance, Company maps of Petaluma, CA, of California, Berkeley, Earth Sciences and Map library,, online, Sanborn Fire, Insurance,map reference. Katherine Johnson,; "A Walking Tour ofPet,alu_rna's!S6utfi 0 11tr al Riverfront Neighboihood",(.Qcfober:200'1.) Sherman Bolvin and Lee Torliatt (unfitled',publication, pp. 12-13), Petaluma Museum IS -"" iogfophjcal� files�,M.,Vonsen. vi. .How toApply the, NdtiodalRegister Criteria for Evaluation, National Register Bulletin rim 16 (yVashington,, D.C.-.'United States Department, of,the: Interipf, 1997), 3. vii...Howlo Conipletb'the National. Regi ster:Registrationr Form, Na'iqn..al Reqister,806tin, no%1 6A(Washington, D;!C.: United States Dep artrnent of the, I nterior, 1997 . 75.. viii. How to.-App!y4he Nal0oal.,604ister Criteria for Evaluation, 3. ix Ibid, 44., x. Ibid, 4445.. xi..'Ibid, 45. xii. Califdrnii§.Regrsi&r-ai7t('National R&gWdr-,A C4rrfp#rfs6n,,.Ca1ifo ri Offide of Historic - Technical Assistance 0 !a Preservation' I Series, n6;..6,(Satramento,1 CA.'Califorriib Department of Parks and, Recreation, 2001), 1. xiii. Ibid, 1. xiv. Ibid, 2. ,xv.',,A1l.State Historica1 Landmarks*_6m nu rrider770 onward are, also automatically listed Californiaon'4_he,- Register. (California , Register�of Historical Resburces:'The Listing Process, California 0,ffice; of'Historic Fire 1- Recreation, . 1 11 stirvation Technical Assistance Series" no. 5 .[Sacramento, CVC61ifornia Department of Parks and Recreation, n.d.],;l.) Xv"'Instruciions'for Recording fcb ding Historical Resources" (Sacramento, Office offfistoric Preservation, 1995) iV, Riverfront, Warehouse District, Chapter 9 Historic,.'Preservation,, Central, Petaluma Specific Plan; Final,,.Draft..,Februar.y`2003,: xV ,1,0 9. lbid, 1'1 0. DPR ML (1195) -Re4uired inf6rination R 'State of California — TheRe-sburces, Agency Primary ,DEPARTMENT OF PARKSAND RECREATIOR' HRI#. CONTINUATI"ON'Sl- HEET Trino'miaV Page 10-16f"11 *Resource, Name ot#',(Assignedbyrecordbr) 209'FirsfStiee *Recorded by: Kiinberly. pi4t2arid'Cronhor Tiatib -1 El Continuation 0 Upd'ate ul e. Al2ril'2003 ,References Biographical files by Sherman BoiVM*' and, Lee Torliatt, Petal'uma, Historical Lib iary and Museum, Petaluma, California. California Register and Nati,ohal`Reg1'ster,:;A Coinporison t,C,AI'lifbmiaOffice rb'i, Historic Preseivation Technical Assistance Series, no. 6. (Sacramento .-CA: :Calif6rniaDepartment of Parks arid Recreation, 2001). California Register of HistoticaI Resources: The. Listing Process, Callifornia'Office of Historic Preservation Technical Assistance Series, no., 5. (Sacramento, CA: California Department of Parks and Recreation, n.d.). Central Petaluma Specif4c:Plqn.jinAl'Qraff.•February 2003; City. of Petaluma Planning Department, Petaluma, California. Heig, Adair. History of Petaluma-a'Califi6mia.; river town., (Petaluma, 'CA - e Scottwall Associates, 1982). How to Apply the National Register- Criteria, Or Evaludtion, NationalRegister Bulletin, no. 15. (Washington, DC.:, United States Der�arfrrf�hi of,, the Interior, 1097). How to Dplethealeiskegistration Form National' RegisterBulletin, no. 16A. (Washington, C.:,,,United States,D6pdrtment.dihe Interior; 1997)., Illustrated, Atlas of Sonoma County California. (Santa Rosa, CA: Reynolds & Proctor, 1897). instructionsfior Recordi?tg:,Historical"Res6urces'. (Sacramento, CA: California Office of Historic Preservation, 1995). Johnson,Kath&ine."'A" alkin�g Tour of P'et.aluma-sSouth Ce'ntrai• l&erfront Neighborhood," October 2001.) J 06 P Street�'�'State of �Californja,,Deparftmeftt of Parks and' s0r� Katherine. "425 First Recreation, Primary. Record (523A) and-Btilding Structure and ObjectRecord (523B),, December1997. Ky'le, Douglas E..,, Mildred Brooke HQover,Hero Eugene Ren h, -sch, Ethel.,Grace Rensc and'Willian N. Abeloe. Historic Spots ,in Calif6rnid.-(Stanford'. CA: Stanford University Press, 2602). Milliken, James for the Press -Democrat Publishing Company. Sonoma County. Illustrated.,(Los Angeles, CA: George Rice & Sons, 1901). Napoli, Don. "Petaluma Commercial District National Register N.Qniihafiohi" National . Park Service, 1994. New Historical Atlas of Sonoma --County California. (Oakland, CA- Thos, H. Thompson, 1877). DPR 523L,(1/95) *Required inforrhation State o- California —The Resources;Agency Priniary.4 DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND;RECREATION HRI#'i 1CONTINUATION'SHEET Trinomial Page 11 of l 1 *Resource: Name or,'# (Assigned by rewrder) .209 First Stieet. 'Recorded by: Kimberly Buff and Coiunor Tumbull, 'Date:'April 2 iM, Continuation. 0 Update Pemut Files, City of Petaluma Community Development Department Building Diyision, Petaluma; Califorcmia'. Petalum6 City Directories, 19.14-54,:Petaluma History Room,: Petaluma -Regional., Branch Library, Petaluma, California. Peterson; Dan.'';Historic,M source' Inventory of Petaluma'," 1975: - Photo Binders,,Petal`unia Historical .Library• and.Museum,.Petalurna, California.. Sanbom.Fire Insurance Company 1Vlap;of Petaluma; CA, July 1$83 -September 1'949, Earth Science"s and Map Library., University of California at. Berkeley. [7 11 State Of C-a'kornia — The Resources, Agency I!kF!CY DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION State RECORD Page I oUll 'Other Listings Resource Name. i Primary,# HRI # Trinomial ,NRHP Status Code'5 r Date P1 Other Identifier:113ar Ale Feed Co'; Warehouse *P2. Location: 0 Not forPu6ildatidni , It Unrettricted `°a. County: Sonoma and ' �2b,and P2c or P2d. , Attach �1ocation�'Map as'.necessary.) Date: T R, Y. Of *b�. �USGS'7.5'Quad: % of Sec M.D. B.M. c. Address: 219 First Street City. "Petaluma Zip: 94952 d. UTM: Zone: 10 ME/: mN (G.P.,S.) e. Other Locational Data: teig.,(p6rce�IAVdirections to resource, elevation, etc., asapp oOr iate) Elevation: ASsessore'is Parcel Number 006-421=008 *P3a. Description: (Pescribe,resource andv-it'&'maj9r elements. Include design, mat - erials; condition, alterations, size, setting, and boundaries) This one -story -plus -three-story tower, industrial Warehouse structure is,r I ectiAngtila - r�:. in 0 lan, and'stands perpendicular to the Petaluma River. It is of womtKc6rrugat d metal cladding J,�rusted corrugated metal -clad, double -gable roof. The single -story structure 'stands ,sixteen height and the tower s'tands'thirty-fi%,c--'feet<tall. Windows include one, corrugated f i bergl A ss,ribbori, w i rid ow.,bel 6%�uthe'.'ft'orthFirst Streef - gableini&w"'a''l one horizontal window opening filled with,eight six -light wire mesh, covered :fixed 'wood trameawindows beio'w,'thi2*east ri"`efs; I e,, north, -;gable end wall, and one horizontal window opening with no'remaining.,,rr'a'm'e's!'�'D-'e"iow-'I'th'e'��west�ri,v,ersi e,,norifi"�`- 16 end 11.1 . , I I . I wall: Pa�ired large corrugated metal -clad -h Al both S' sficlihg.barn doors with exposed',extenOT metal'tri '&s,hafigat.b the south' 66t elevationand o I n the east�elevatidn. A irst Street hollow -core wood door and -a smallerMi.dirig,door 6 west on the southelevation ialso, allow access to the interior. Corrugated metal patching, visible at the;&t6fi6r . rcl , adding, indicates� I wheie ' Street, openi ' hgs ha ' ve.beeninfi I I I led. Other features include various signage, particUlArly,a large the� lower gable, end 4tFeist- :and wall -mounted projecting industrial;type light fixtures.?The overall conclition�6f. tke,W.zi-rC-h.b."use,;exteri6r'is�poor. The open interior features anexposed,wood-frame 'sfrutture�subdivided �only by the,'Wo0 d; structure supporting the two upper floors of the tower in ihe,southieAst,,c6rnei,,-.:The walls consist of exposed wood'framing With corrugated metal on. the,exterior. Exposed wood trusses clad -with co'r*rugated'-,miifala6n.theiekteri f6rm the -;ceiling. A Wood plank,,system�combines the two gable roofs:at the valley. Twelve corruga'ted fiberglass skylightsifflurninate the Warehouse with natural light in conjunction with the Window opening in the.n6rth and -south -walls: No electric lights have been -.installed at: the builcling's interior. A thin slab of - poured concrete on earth covers the�floonThe concreteis in pour ccinclidon;aficl,exhibits cracki'ng'and'spalli . ngi and supports areas of standing Water. A modern concrete ramp provides access from the . interior floor leveIrto the main.southern entry. Themood- framed,tower structure in the. southeast corner foatures.two open trea&staits dgroove floors, and _1 I i ' lapiclated wood tongueand- small wood enclosures. The waiehoti§e;interior�isl in overall poor condition. *P3b. 'Resource. Attributes: (List attributes, and d6d6i) HP8 - Industrial Building,- (Warehouse) *P4.: Resources Present:, HIguild'irig b0bj' ect DSite Obistildl: - Mi-ement'of District 00thev(lsolates, etc.) P5b. Description cription of Photo: (View, date, accession #) View of'the South Elevation, April 2003 P6. DatwConstructed/A§e and Sources: :-IHl Historic OPrehist6ric, 01.13c.th 018; City ,of,Petaluma Parcel I n to t ma tion, , Report. 'P7,. ,Owner.and,Address: ..)AmesNAcNab III, 3570'Ridgeview Dr T Santa: R6sA;.CA, '95404 ,*P,8'. Recorded by: (Name, affiliation, Kimberly, Butt and. Connor Turnbull ";Carey -&,Co, Inc:,.. 46013ush�St., San Francisco,' CA 94108 Date Recorded: April'2003 ey Type:, (Describe) oj,ctRel"dte'd,'inclusive oflO "properties *P11. Report, Citation:., (Cite survey -reobrt. and, othdr,sburces, or ent er I "none -1 none 'Attachmiints: ONONE, QLocation Map .0SkiJtdh'Mip NlContinua�iion Sheet, 91BUil I dihg,.-Structure, and Object Record OArchaeological Record' Record OLihear :Feature Record . OMilling Statio I n, Record [3Rock Art Record oArtifact Record OPhotcigraph Record 0 0ther,(List): OR 523A (1/95) *Required information State of "California The Res DEPARTMENT OF PARK'S.AND RECR gencY P'r`imary't �. RECREATION HRI# CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Page 2' of``ll. 'Resource ,Name-or,#a (Assigned by recorder) 219 Fist Stieet *Recorded by: K%'mberT `Bu#t and Connor.'Tur biffl' *Date: Apri12003EYConfinuatian O Up* Rear (north) eleuatiofrrof!219 First Street April'2003 photo. I it Stati4, California'The` Resources Agency" Primary #'. ,I DEPARTANEPIT�OF PARKS All RECREATION - HRlftIt °. 6} , �r n ,' ), Pae 3`.of 1.1 Resource Name or # (Assigned by recorder 219`First ®NTIMU/�1'0®i�' SHEET ,.'I" Trinomial .n 9 Street i� iRk6eded by: Kiri berl �Bit' A d Connor.Turnbull °Date A �' n12003 V , p O Continuation 0 Update.' r' The 191"O Sanbo rn;�map°shows the same structure at 219 First.Sfr'eet;as;in M6itismall addition to the:east side. Notice the,surrounding area is beginning to develop, C C r e e k 2 FYI w r ' WL � f N1 O �VONiEN n 1 Y The 191"O Sanbo rn;�map°shows the same structure at 219 First.Sfr'eet;as;in M6itismall addition to the:east side. Notice the,surrounding area is beginning to develop, 1. The 1'923'Sanborn map shows the hay,barn hasbeen The 1949 Sanborn map shows the present structure at 219 removed and 219 First Street'remained a vacant lot at this First Street•being used by`the; Poultry Producers of time. Central California for feed'.andgrain storage. DOR 523L (1/95) *Required information C r e e k 2 � f N1 O �VONiEN Lj 1. The 1'923'Sanborn map shows the hay,barn hasbeen The 1949 Sanborn map shows the present structure at 219 removed and 219 First Street'remained a vacant lot at this First Street•being used by`the; Poultry Producers of time. Central California for feed'.andgrain storage. DOR 523L (1/95) *Required information State of•California The Resources Agency 'Primary # .> DEPARTMENT OF ,PARKS AND RECREATION BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD Page 4 of 11 - *NRHP-Status`Code.S 'Resource Name or # (Assigned by recorder), 219 First«Street Bt: Historic Name: B2: Common Name:1, Bar' Feed -Ale Co. Warehouse 2 83: Oriinal Use: A' ral Werehoia a 64, 'Present' Use:,. Agriculturat Warehouse:' B5. Ar hitectural'St e: ,riculco Style- Vernacular Warehouse '136. Construction Hstory;,(Coristruction date, alterations; and date of.alterations) The warehouse ;was built in 1918. - 67: Moved? x ❑ No OyesD _ lJnkno ln Date:. O'rig inallocationc B8. f Related 'Features:.N/.A 89a. Architect:, nknown, b.";Builder. UiiknoWn *BI.O. Significance: Theme:- _Rweifront Agricultural- Commerce Area: Petaluma; , Pei nce 1. 1 Pro ert Type:. Warehouse .. Applicable `Criteria:i:A nod of Signific n terms' ofhistorical or architectural con e* s, defined by iheme,-penod, and (Discuss importancei aphic scope. geoge (See Continuation Sheet) Also, address ,integrity:) 611. Additiona..l`:Resource,Attributes:, (List attributes and codes),,'None °B1'2. References:' '(See Continuation Sheet); 1313.. Remarks: C p TALUMA R� SUBJECT PROPERTY.. I — I L °614. Evaluator:Kimberly_Buttand Connor'Turnbuli ;1 i; "! I. �a k `*Date of.Evalua'tion'. April,2003 1 1 , zl h I t L ` reservedoroficial comments.) space I ' I' _ ..'.' ISN a•I, �, N 1 " DPR 523Ei (1195) 'Required mforinatign , I 7 California -- The 'DEPAR Agency Primary# TAflENT OF PARKSAND RECREATION HRI# I., CONTINUATION SHEET . Trinomia , Page _ of 11 °Res,ource Name,or'# (As'signed'by'recorder) 219 FirstrStieet *Recorded by: Kimberly Butt and Connor Turnbull *Date: Aril 2 M Continuation 0 Update Background early P a' r mmerce., The river attracted early California The ttlers and hunter's ecam s a- luma� evolved around, river'co became a popular source of anricultu ag Produ tion includ'mostsWereed. along its ,banks -in 1849. The Petaluma area p p g p g grain, feedand vegetables. It later became renowned. for its poultrybusinesses`which thrived until -the m d,1950s."Cargo boats traveled up the Petaluma River from San Pablo Bay and cargo was,stored at warehouses ;that stood, -and still stand, along the river's edge. River commerce continued to thrive until 1950 when the1ast steamer was permanently moored near McNear Canal?" The warehouse at 219 First Street stands at,the riverside edge of First Street,.near the juncture of D Street and adjacent to 209 First�Street..'It is one of'a,series of warehouses that,were constructed between First Street and the Petaluma River iin theearly twentieth century. Assessor's.records available at the Petaluma Community Development Department list the. date of construction of 'the warehouse as 1918, but Sanborn maps indicate a later date of construction,: A 19Q6 SanbornFire Insurance in' shows a small one story hay barn labeled "private." The same building with. a small addition appears in the 1910 Sanborn map. In 1923, when the adjacentVonsen ware .pp a p , .a irsi Street is shown vacant. houses a ears; on Sanborn ma st the 219 F However, in a,1.1949 update of the same 1923 Sanborn Fire Insurance.rnap, ^ warehouse ;building. is shown at that location and: is labeled "Poultry, Producers of Central California, Feed & Grain W.Ho.," and features a wood posts, tru) ses and• the,tl reg story° tower at the First Street facade The Poultry Producers of ��Q p f Petaluma poultry farmers begun in; 1916: The PPCC also owned coo erative o o operated a wa ehou' " .Calif and op se at 425 First%street, nearthe foot of P and' G Streets, The warehouse continues to serve as a storage#acility. Evaluation Criteria,. Nat'ional.:Register.Bullet in Number 15 How,'to Apply the, National Register Criteria for Evaluation, describes p text,be'ing�c 1 mposed of two factors First, the property must be "associated with the Criteria for Evaluatio an important hist" The National Register'identifies four possible context types, of which at least one rnust'beoric con , applicable at the national, state,,or'local level: As listed under Section 8, "Statement of Significance, of' the National 'Registe.r"'of Historic Places Registration. Form, these are: A Property is a t broad patterns o ssociated ry . sign ficanf-,contribution".to the h' events thathave made a f ourhisto "B. Property is associated with the lives, of persons significant in our ,past. "C. Property embodies -the distinctive characteristics of. a type,. period, or°:method of construction or represents the work of;a:master, orposses seshigh, artistic"values, ior "represents a significant and distinguishable. entity whose components lack individual distinction: "D. Property has yielded, or is likely to yield, information important to prehistory or history."" DPR,5231_ (1/95) 'Required information State of California —The 'Resou c"L q,Age"cy � DEPARTMENT ET 'CONTINUATION "S17ILC Page 6.0f 11 `Resource Name 6r'#;(Assigr *Recorded� by; Kimberly Butt aiid�ConnofTumbull� Primary # HR1# byr(ecor __ der) 'Date: ci 2 [DCbn . tinUaitibri. 1111W.1 13 Update 'Second, for a property to qualify 'under- the Natibn-alRezi-s,-t,e.r, s Criteria for Evaluation; , jtm, istalsoretainIhist6iif.ihtegzityof those Convey its significance:"`'" icance.Whilezpzpper.y & signni icance; telafes tojts.rble witj#,a specific hist&'nc-k: - ritext, its integrity tegrity refers to ""a propert 'Is. ph UeAf -ysiO bres and how theyrglite toits sfiznificance."`TotdetermMelfaprqperty retaihs,t'e physical- characteristics; gotrospondi'ng,,,-t.o,its.,L'bi.stbric,�poiitext,,the NAti"orial"Regst,er, has 4dentified!sevem aspects s t f - o , in egrity., These are: locationisthe,place where "the. historic proTert was constructed, therplace,wh erelne historic event'OCCUrred"..' "Design .is -is thecombinatio ofelemehfs thatxreate the form, structure; -and style e of property... "Setting Is the ,pbysical environment of -a historic property... "Materials is: the.phy4cal W , elem nts, th t, , e i ere, combined or deposited during ap atticular , 0 -;of time;andln a particularpaftern or configigAtion t -pr9pefty..... peti d, ofbrm,a�historic, "Workmanship -is thephysical evidence of the,,crafts,.of a particular eopleduring anygiven,pq iry.. riodin_bi t tehgio .is ory Qrp Teeeling is s z, property's 'expres'sion of the aesthetic or,h istotic:sen§e of d o particular of time... "Association,'s the direct link�befween an important istoric event or, person and ,alhistone propWy,. Since integrity is based on a, property's sigAa-speci'fic,historli'�-.context,,' I fkang in e within - I , T an, n- of a ,Property sihtegrityyt4n .only Occur after historic significance has been estAblished." California Office of "i��tor-i-"c'.Pr-eEetvat-ioh,s?Techniical, Assistance Serie #6, California, ft.ister and National. Re inters A Comparison, outlines the :differences between the federal -and ,state processe's..711e; context types tbibe'used when es tablishii-ig the significance�o a.pro. .I* - perty for listing -oft the-CAllifomia Re aster are V'ery, s.iinilar,w.ithemphasis��on,loc-al�and state sij�hifica:nte. They:orp, 'T.It-is associated with events -that have made,a'aig.pifitant,.contiibution to the,'broad patterns of",IocAlorregional 'hi'8tory"I or the cultural heritage bf-Califo -i-ni'a , 'or the United, States* or "2.,I,t is associated with the 'lives of 'persons im poftanf to local, California; or national history;br 3. It embodies .the. distinctive,charactenstics. of stype, period' or method' -of construction or, represents thework of :a master, or -possesses high. artistic values; DOR 5123LI(1/95) Requleed inf.6mlatio.n' State of California — The Resounes Agency DEPARTMENT OF PARKS.AND RECREATION Primary # THRI • P — ice Name or # (Assig ° rm mial first . *Resou r 21,9 F i 9 I1 ) II rage ned by, order Street Y nnor Turnbull , p e b Kiinberl 'Butt and Co *Recorded ate A n120 D Continuation O lJpdat y „ local area, California. o lh ' 4. It has yielded, oris y.'to yield,'information important to'prehistory orrhistory, of the � � , ' r.;thenation. %' � ' . � � • Like the N_RHP,,evaluation for eligibility to the California Register require an establishment of historic 3 significance`',before integrity,is consideredyCali'fornix's,integ_r-ity,threshold is slightly lower than the federal_ level -As aresult; some'resources that are'historicall_y significant`butdo not meetNRHP integrity standards may be eligible for listing on the California Register; California's list of specal'considerations' is,shorter and more l' It includes some g 1 lenient than tthe -N-RHP. algowances for moved buildin s, structures or ob'ects,: as well as low.enre uirements, for proving the si ificance of resources_that are less than 50 years old, and a more elaborate discussion of the eligibility of %"!- L _ . •_ reconstructed build -Trigs: • -'.. - In additionao separate•evaluaf ons.for eligibility to the California 'R'egistet, thestafe will automatically list resources if they are -listed or determined eligible4or the NRNP through a -complete evaluation process.x'" The local register relevant to thY sliisforic resource evaluation,is Petaluma,s�list of city landmarks. The -city government has formally ado t�d the CRHR criteria with emphasis on local significance for use indeterminirlocal landmarksta r: Findings Pe have assigned the ry ert, a�219 Fir"s�herN t gnarl Register bu os still o which indicates, in our o inion, that.t'he ro ert is'ineI able• for P Y' %V de of 5 f local interest as part of a potential s ll desi ated historic di g ividually possess historic otentra locally , gn strict.. The warehouse .does not find "fie' and is; theref o for jn s vi ural listin in the RHP ''Because the property is over 50 sip §b d and is not? one of the .pilo i ert y N: earn of ore m p y type lvlat are genera'll, automatically disqualified from listing on the, NRHP, this property has :been evaluated" under the standard Nai`onaL Register Criteria for Evaluation. It is au lso or opinion that the pr'ope'rty does,iiot possess:indiuidual historic:significance and is therefore not eligible„for uidivid tal listing on ih,e California ,Register of Historici Resources. The property has not been autornaticallylistedl; on the CRHR because it is not listed on the; NRNP and has not been determined. k� uidrviduallyiiehgible`through a ciomplete,evaluation process. As a result, this property..has been evaluated d under the standard istate criteria UT d However the „ reet was identified%� g g roup, of hwarehouses ” t mi ht `wrist during this, and previous evaluations as :beton m to 'a eri A' ute a•local historic district if. further- documentation an_d research g p g, �t were u cork . A metal; add warehouses 1- cated, along First Street are; similar buildings, typically were underta s a rou , th blocks of° redominantl abled g Tug ing with either single or double gable roofs and large openings "These unified • P y' g,. g P ' Y' y First Street and the river are d by their'industrial use and style.uzldin s, s ecificall bounded., b Criterion A ,(NRNP) / 1 (CRHR). The property at -219 First Street is associated with events that have made a signifcanf contribution to the broad..patterns of Petaluma's history. `The Warehouse was used to store • grain and feed along with several other buildings along First Street, and, in g nei hborin streets that served neighboring DPR 5231 (1/95) 'Required information Statebf, California The, Resources Agency. Primary #, DEPARTMENT OF-IPARKSANDRECREATION HRIX CONTINUATION SHEET'Trinomial Page 8 of 11L lb I.. I - kesouIrce Name dr ,# (Astignedby recoraer)"'219 Firsi,.8[reet "Recqrdield by: kinibMy'Butt-and Connor Turnbull *Date:, 1 Aprif, 2003®Continuation 13 Update Criterion B, (NRHP), 2,(CRHR)t The pioperty'at -219 is not associated With, the,h-es of persons significant in our past: Although, the Poultry Producem oi,Centr -rative, Central California Wa`84 vital locilc6b.pL no clear links. between any, sign, ificantpprsons andthis, ar,tic-,ular�"'warehotisei;�.Lrts f6_L "' d. p un Criterion C (NRNP) (Q9IiR),:Iheprqperty 0,219, First-5treet does not eniboclythe distinctive char-aderistics of a' pe, period,. or method of construction: The petty'also .does:A6t represent the work of a imast&,, possess'highartistit values. or,represent, a si-&'ificant sting n and,di uishabl enfity� hosL components lack individual distinction: The property,46 characteristicwarehouse type f of the wareh - Und.in this t o .Area of'Petalu ma. ,Criterion D,(.NRHP),/ 4 (CRHRY. The: property at 21.91F.i.tst,'St.re-et,h-as,not yielded,, nor is.ithkely to yield, m informatibimportaritto prehistory or,history.- While this criterion ,is,generally �appli!E-cil,t6 archeological; , ., resources; it,ap plies*to any building; structu-re, o_r object Whose physical i-4bricit- S'elf-c_anbe,tonsi ere an artifacf.-TheliN First Sireot property.�coritains;no. visuilly-blIset-vable, above-groUnd,elemertis- whose, physical fabric includes uniq _materials, t rials,. provides information, on special'build" - techniques,or has the. ipng, potential to provide, information about Our past. Since 219First.-Street; although, not eligible for listing ag,ind'ivuaUy sign o' ificant, could be listedas a contrihufihgproperty to .a potential local historic. distrkt,,, it'is; important toeviluate its ihtezri photographs; I ocated at. the Petalum& Museum, and the Petaluma m ..a v indicate Ihat- Locationt.'219 First Street is in i8,,,original-location.�- Desigp'. Afthough,noto 's1y'le,�;and plancoptril�utp. to:,its, 5- if, ce as -a, tifstanding in:its design, tbeforhi, �gn can 'contributing resource to a potentiAlIl cal historic "district remain'. o -,historic ,Setting.,,, The" building is, ori.e of, sever,al. Opilding that. are part, of a pot6nfial.local historic district; "Although other b,Wldi,hgsthat once, stood,,pearby are no I extant, there are still enough buildings to -_ maintain 0" longer L the overall physical 61: environment: phy ic Materials. The warehouse materialis extant and M` its, oIrliginalcohfiguradon. Workinanchi NTr%+,n h Mp Feeling-. Thi��biiildihg-,tbge,therwith �4,its: neighbors, . conftfiiiib, to express the -industrial nature of. thearea 'as related ',to the, grain andleed business, Association The warehbuse�, continue§16, be �associated with other similar u characterize uses ihe, industrial complex bf,proper-ties important. to Petal'uma's history,-.. We find thatlhe,, huild"" g�eontinues t in to ,h -it is'abl- -to integrity such at. e con,veyl S - signifiaince,as, a, cofitributin resource, potential local district�_ho however' did �not, find the '&m . ce-tIpApoten we War'e;house,'to'be.'efigiblefqrind'i.��'dii'a,l',I'isting, State of California — The R esouI A rECR' gency. Primary'# 4, TMEMT OF,PARKS AND.'R s DEPAR � EATIUNr HRI#= C0NTIN.UATION SHEET. Trinomial- Page I of 11 'Resource Nameaor'# (Assigned by recorder) 21.9�First .Sti• et °Recorded by: Kimberly Butt and: Connor Turnbull *Date: Al2ril-2003, 0 Continuation D Update Endnotes 'Adair Heig, History of Petaluma A California River Town (Petaluma, CA: Scottwall.Associates, 1982): 123 Mildred Brooke Hoover, Hero.EugeneRensch, Ethel Grace Rensch, William; N. Abeloe, revised by Douglas E. Kyle, Historic Spots in California (Stanford, CA, Stanford University Press, 2002):513 Heig, 120. ,, Katherine Johnson425 First StreetState of `" California, Department of Parks and Recreation,. Primary Record (523A) and Building.Structure and Object Record (523B),(December,1997)' ` V. How to Apply the National Register Criteria for; Evaluation, National Register BUlletin, no. 15 (Washington; D.C.: United States Department of the Interior; 1997):.3. vi. How to Complete the National, Register -Registration Form, National Register Bulletin, no. 1.6A (Washington, D.C.: United States Department of the Interior, 1997). 75: Vii. How toApply 'the NationalRegister,CMdna'for,'Evaluation, 3. . viii. Ibid, 44. 'ix.lbid,44-45. x. Ibid, 45. zi. California Re ister and National Re ( 9 CaliforniaDepartmen "of Parkqnss"and rnia Office of liistoric'Preservation Technical Assistance Series, 9 P no. 6 Sacramento, CA: Recreation, 20(01);1. xii. Ibid, 1. xiii. Ibid, 2. xiv. All State Historical Landmarks from. number 770-onward'rare°:also automatically listed;on the. California Register. (California Register of Historical Resources The: Listing Process; California Office of'Histo ric Preservation Technical Assistance Series, no. 5 [Sacramento, CkCalifornia;Department ofParks and'Recreafion;_n.d.), 1..) " "Instructions' for Recording Historical Resources" (Sacramento, Office of Historic Preservation; 1995), iRiverfront`Waiehouse;District, Chapter 9 Historic Preservation; Central' Petaluma Specific Plan, Firial Draft. February 2001: 1.09. X.ii, Ibid, 110. DM523L (1/95) 'Required information Statti of California;"— Th.eAe*10UrqesA§ed&y Primary # DEPARTMENTOF PARKSAND RECREATION HR1# CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Page 1Q.1of Li ResourceName,or iAsslianed by ri-rrinelprl .?TQ Pirif r4r..# *Record.e.d.'by'� Kirnbe4m ft, and Connoft Tumbull Date•. April.20 - 03 2), Continuation C1 Updat* I References Biographicalfilesb,rSherman Bdivin and' Lee" Tofliatt,,Petaluma. Historical Lihratl and M' Y, useurn,,, Petaluma, California. Calif6rnia,-Rei,zste'ri.and ,Na'tionaI Register :�-A,Cb?�iph-tiso)i,'Ca:lifom* -Tre�etVadTechnical ia Office of Historic ion A§si8tance, Series, no. 6. Sacramento CA-'CA11forhia Department of Parks 'and, RecreA66- n,,2001). California Register. q Historical `ical Resources:,The Li.�tiilgProcess, '-� Californiaia:Offi of Historic, Preservation, fH Technical Assist Department. bf'Parks: 'and j�nge, Series, no. CA: California Departm, Recreation, -n.d;). Central Petaluma Specific,Plan; f :of 'umaAzining, Draft.ebruaq 2003, Cit, Petal Department, Petaluma, California: Heig, Adair.Kistory of 'Petaluma: aCalfornza river town:(Petaluma; CA: Scot' alf.AssocIat es.', 1982). How to..Applythe Nqtional'Register Criteriafor Ez)alutiiion,. National Register Bull6fin, no. 15. (Washington* D.C..- United States Departmenfbithe Interior, 1997). HowloComplete ,theNatimat-RegisierR egistration Form, National, Registe Bulletin,,no,16A.' W, .. C Ashington; D.C!UniiedSta,tes� Depatim-'e- fit of the Interior, 1997).; Illustrated Atlas of, Sonoma C uhty,California. (SantRosIa CA-. Reynolds & Prdictor.1,897). Instructions for Recording Historical Resourcesi �(8, acramento, CA, California .Office of Historic Preservation 1995; Johnson, Katherine. "A Wdlk.in,g Tbuk;of PetzilurhA's Souih-Ceritrail'Rlver'f-tontNeighborhood ," Oc'tober 2001. Johnson, KAtherine. "425.First:Street"State .of Californ a,, Department of '.-Par and Recreation, Primary Record (523A) and Building Structure:and'Object Rec6rd,(523B),'December 1997 Kyle, Douglas E.,�Mildrecl; Brooke fl6f6 Eugene,Rensch�.Etbel -Grace Re-h'sth,,,and With `N, Y With Abeloe. Histbric,Sp6ts. -in California: (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2602') - Milliken, jar.ries4dr the Pie8s-Dernocrat,PUbl'ishing, Company. Sonoma C601 tkIll'ustr,ateld. (Los :Angetes,,CA: George -Rice &Sons, 1901.). Napoli,'bon.. .'Petaluma Conu-nercial District National Register Nomination," NationAITArk.5erVice, 19 91* Netv Historicdl Atlas of Son -oma County—California: (Oakland, CA: Tho' s. 1. Thompson,,- 1877), DPR,523L(1/.9'5) *Riquired information 'State of California —The Re sources:. Agency Prima # DEPARTMENT OF PARKSAND RECREATION ry, FIRI# ZONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Page Il of 11 "Resource'Name or4,(AssigneC byr.ecorder) 219'First treet . 'Recorded" b Kimber ' y:. , Kimberly Buttand Connor Turnbull 'Date: ,4 ril'2 6 21 Continuation' ❑ Update. C 'unity. Development De art Permit Files; City of Petaluma Co y p g fent Building Division, Petaluma, California. Petaluma City Directories, 1914 54,;Pet alums Histo California. ry Room-:Retal'uma Regional Branch Library, Petaluma,. Peterson Dan. Historic; Resource: " Inventory" of Petaluma," 1976. Photo Binders, Petaluma ,Hist oncal Library and Museum,.Petalur' a, California. Sanborn Fire Insurance Company Map of Petaluma; CA,, July 1883, - September 1949, Earth Sciences and Map Library, University of California, at Berkeley. DPR"523L(1/95) . *Required information State of California— The ResbUecels,Ag*hcy Primary #.- DEPARTMENT OF PA0'Kq,,, AND RECREATION HRL#, PRIMARY RECORD Trinomial al NRNP Status Codw5 Other Listings 1 of 11., 'Ftesourte, Naffe-orI: 301 First Street Pl,., Other Identifier:'Bar Ale-Feed,Cb. Warehojuse'l P2. Location:,O Notrfdr:PUblicaticin 6K]Unrestricted, 'ta.,County: Sonbrii a and (02b and!?2c or'P2d: Attach,,a.Locition,Map as necessary;) *b.USGS t.W4u.ad: Date: . 'T R o f '/4 of'sez, M.D. B.M. c. Address- 301 First'StrOet City: Petaluma Zio:,94952 d.UTk ZoqTO Zone mE/ mN (G P'S'.); - _: Other er Locaticinail Data: (6.g., parcel ;;directions to resource: elevation, etc.; as appropriate) Elevation:. Assess.of's,Parcel Number ,008-121,,,009 *P3a- 7,bescriptidr (Desc'rbe resource and i& major elements. InclUde-designi, nate,nal%, conditidn,alt&ationssize, se" .t -i rg,,a ni d boundaries) This one-story industrial warehouse structureis rectangular plan and; sian&perpendicular to4he Petaluma,River. It is ofwood frame, construction With corrugated meta 1; cladd i n&and arusfed' corrugated, m.eta-l-clad'dotible�,gab-le roof. Windows-includethree bands of ifi'Xed wood -framed tfiree,71ite-bver-three4ite units.a.r - rangecl� in.,,groups of three:ancl six afthe, riverside, north,gabit end wallas well<asifive'horizontal,openings,with,thr'ee%Wood,-f m Ies,filled with; wire mesh and side walls. A pair of wood --frar-he corrugated rhetalchd sliding barn dodrhang from metal track at the,ceeite"rijoi, the-soiahi, 4*1Stree elevation. Two smaller wood frarne,metal-clad"sliding.doors' flank the large,cehtrafdbdrs, on th-esdufh4gaoe. The,sarrte.sl I idiri�-- door-§°alsQ punctuate bbtfi� the iiast..and,W.es,televitions�,With five in ea I ch.-C6rrugated' metal patching,, visibleon the,exter,ibr�c1laddin&, indicates where4ormer'openings have been infilled.'Many. of 'the corrugated metal panels connections have,detached1rom thewall plane and much 'of the ex teribr, surface is covered,in graffiti. The overalfconclition of'the warehouk exterior is,poor. A canted partial -height plywoo&clad, wall divides-thO. open in , terior ,pace at the cen ter4be]OW the roof valley. Two rows of exp6sed wood posts running north to -south support the, structure beneath the West gable, and the (fen tral valley Pairs of ' si x -inch tallmetal vir)es,.fise,out4rom the floor in-between the western roW,of-posts. The pe'riitt6ter,Wallsicbn-sist,of,&xpbsed,Wppd framin with,xorhigated metal on ti-feext-erior.,Exposed, wood trusses clad With corrugated metal on theexterior formthe".ceilh g L plane T r- he: roof iSInot very- well sealed and allows a significant amount ofwdier'penetration. Tfie�%,Vindbw, openings illU.min.ate-'t) interior with natural light: 'No electrical lightirig'has been instaffed in the: warehouse., A,combina 6omof,poured'concrefie and asphalt on earth imppor,cond tion covers `the; floor. The undulating floor surface exhibits<severecracking Andsfanding water. The warehouse interior is in overall poor condition; irf6rit'dItDistrict 00ther'(1solate&,etc:) PSb. Descriptioncif Pfioio-- (View, ,oate,, accession Yie* oftheSdUth -Elevation,.April `.2003'- *P6.D , at6 Const ^ ructbid/Acieand Sources: ElHistoric E.Prehi-'st,orid O.Bot,h 1 918 `-Cify,of,Petaluma Parcel Information; Report *P7. Owner andAddress.-f, James ,Mdc-'Nk ffI 31570-RidgeViewDr Santii:Rbs4 -CA954`042 PB'..,,Reclord6d�by: '(Name, affiliation, .,krid.-pid-d-ress) Kimberly :Bu'ft.and'Connor'Turnbtill. Carey & Co,Jnc., -46.0 Bush St., San, Francisco !CA 94108 '-P§. Date,,Redordbd:, April. -2003 SONd-y'Type: (Describe) ,Properties 'Pll. :Wepdrt' Citation: (Cite survey report and cth"dr'soUrces, or enter "none.") *AtiaC'hmdn.tt:. ONONE O.Location 'Map ClSketch Map , CK Continuation SheeL OBuilding; Structure,. and, Object Record OArchaeological Record CIDistrict, Rbcard OLinear - Feature Record EiMillin-g Station- Record ElRodk, Art Retdrd ElArtifact Record 'qPhotograph, Record 0 Other"(List). DPR 523A,(1/95), 116quiir4d information E�DEPARTMENT OF p The Resources Agency Primary N't1AT�ONSSHEET AND EaTionll TRnomiaG Page '2 of 11 'Resource Name or # (Assigned by recorder) 301 'First,SCree 0 'Recorded b Kimberly Butt arid ConnorlTu'mbi ll " *Date. Apn1,2003 y' Continuation 11 Update PI i 0. �DP.R523L,(1%95) 'Required information State of.California.— The Resources Agency ,Primary)#' DEPARTMENT DPPARKS AN_D _RECREATION HRI# CONTINUATION_ SHEET Trinomial Page,3 of 1S _ •Resource (dame or # (Assigned tiy, recorder),,, 301 Fist Street, ` °Recorded by >ki P- 001 mberli! Butt,and;Connor Turnbull. `Date: A rth2 ®Cont ' inuation ❑ Upda, P[TacuMA A" WAWA w 0` rM „z' 6 4, Trp -w- :41 -.i, _ -=FIRST' 1906;Sanboin",Map shows'asrnall hay.storage-structure. 1910;,Sanborn Map shows,the first section of,the Warehouse. On the Warehouse at301 First=Stieet-site at 301'Firs't Sireet,'a one -and -one. hAf4tory grain warehouse' connected'to.a.plank' wharf 1.923 Sahbom Mapashows the:addlhon of a , one -and' -one -half -story flay warehouse on the east side of the warehouse DPR 523L..(1795), p ,.1,949 Sanborn.lNa shows the°Warehouse remaingfon site, w . p haveibeeri the warehouse to; the west and the lank whart removed 'Required. information.. -rcesource.Nanl #'(Assigned ( ssigned by recorder) 301 First Street B1: Historic Name:. B2. • Common _Name: Bar Feed Ale$Co. Warehouse B4g 63 Original Use Agricultural Warehouse . Present Use A ricultural'Warehouse *B5 AI tchitectural Style: Vernacular,'WareFouse., ° ry( - B6 Th`e warehouse wasbuilt nn191gtion date, alterations,„and date of alterations) 67. ,Moved? ONo'❑Yes ❑Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8. Related Features: none. 39a. Architect: 'Unknownb. `Builder nknown 61.0. Si9nificanCe' Theme:• RverfrontAgr iculhiral°Commerce Area: Petaluma'• - Des od �mSignifi in terms of 0istoncal or acct rtectura Property Type: Warehouse a Applicable Criteria: A ( P _ I context as defined by theme period, and,geographic scope. Also address integrity:) (See. Continuation,Sheet) J B•11. Additional Resouree Attributes ((,•ist attribUtes and codes) None- °B1_2. References:, (See 'ontin'uationrSheet:)' \:sus�ecr L B11 Remarks' \ ALMA RAVER PROPERTY ' ' r ,III , � ,d, • \ ".” —' / � � � _ e Buttaand^Connor Tu' rl,� F i• I • �mberly rnbult B14. Evacuator K — II Eval °Date of nation April-- I„ i � l5 SIRE i t ' I' �IWI �' I • (This space-,reserved for official comments.). • I 1 i N , -- -- 2tiD STREET ___•--. -� / -- — o ' DPR:523B (1/95)' 'Requiredinformation. d. ' State,bi'Cali'fornia �The'Resources Agency Primary'# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS'AND-RECREATION HMO, CO'NTII\I'l` ATfOWSHEET , Tcinorr iai Page 5 of Ii 'Resource Namerror # (Assigned by,'recorder) 301 First Street *Recorded by: Kim beily,Butfand:ConnorTurnbull *Date- Aril 200 ; 1K Coritnuatibn 11 Update: Background' The early develo " merit: of Peta p � luma revolved around river commerce. The river attracted early California,. settle and'' hunter's,carnps,and. trading posts were established along its banks.in 1,,, "he Petaluma area ,became A enowned.foris poult Cebusinesses�which,tthrived until t e mid 950se Carno boats bavelet dater became Popular .g' P including grain g ry g d, up the ; Petaluma River from Sari Pablo Bay and cargo, was stored atwarehouses that stood; and stillatand, along the river's edge R `ver:corrunerce continuedto thrive until 1950 when the faststearrier'was permanently moored near McNear Canal:" The warehouse at 301 'First Sireet;stands ,at the :riverside, -edge of First (Street, near the Puncture :of E, Street, It is one of •a series 'of warehouses -that were constructed between. First Street and, the Petaluma Riyerin the. early'hwentieth.century.: A-1906 Sanbom,'F:ire 'Insurance -map shows two smallstructures'ori'the'301 First° ;Street lot. These are'labeled-"'stable,".and "'hay stg." A,.feed warehouse-starnds adiacerit: In a 19f0'Sanborn Ig map,, the first bay :of, the double, gable warehouse. appears and, is' labeled Hickey & Von sen Grain WHO." By'1923; the building is shown with the two• bays which i,xts current configuration. The building is labeled n.Co H'ay W. HO, Feed W: Ho" in'the 1.923 Sariborn"map. Additionally>, the hay warehouse: features a wood floor while the feed warehouse has axoncrete floor. "' Assessor's. records available at `the Petaluma Community Development'Department'llst the d'ate' of construction of the warehouse as 1918: The building.may, `have been rebuilt in 191'8'. They1 . Vonsen.Company occupled 'the building acid neighboring warehouses at 209:First Street; and 201 First Street (destroyed: by fire'in.2000) until 1959, w the companybeca_.me the:Bar Ale.i`The IVI. Vonsen.Company began ,as Wrisen-a11 rid HickE, .- iagnus Vonsen 'orfeinall , partnered; with a grocer named "Will Hickey in 1904, but he bought, out Hickey in' 1913:.`'` The°warehouse continues to serve as.a storage facility. Evaluation Criteria National Register_ Bulletin Number 15,,How. to Apply, the-,Nationdl Register Criteria for Eva`lubtion describes the,Criteria for Evaluation as being composed of two factors. First; the property must=be'"associated with an:important;historic con"text.""''The:Nationa'1 Register identifies four possible contezt,types,;of.which at least one: must be, applicable, at 'the national,'state, or local level. As, listed, under Section 8; "Statement of Significance,",of 'the: National Register of Historic: Places Registration Form, these;are:: . ''A. Pio erty' sassociated with eventsthat.`have•made.. stgnificant contribution to`the P broad, patterns ofounhisto y. - B. Property is associated' -with the lives of persons significant m o,ur, past: Property r ca sPhmethod scnstruction, orepresents thewrk of master,or, posese: hi arh'caloe, or represents a significant and dist'ingu'ishable entifywhose corr►porients,lack irtdividual .. distinction. "D. Prop :. I as yielded, or is.ikely to. yield,. information; important to prehistory or 'history, , DPR 523E'Required `information 19 Stafe,of California The`Resou&es Agency ncy Primary #r DEPARTMENT OF PARKS,AND RECREAN HRI# CONTINUATION'SHEET Trinomial; Page;:, of`1_l 'Resource Name or,# (Assigned by recorder)! 301 First Street `Recorded b.Y: Kimberly Butt and ConnorTumbull *Date ri12 0 O Continuation ❑Update Second, for a property to qualify under the',National:Register's; Criteria for Evaluation, it must also retain "historic integrity of those features necessary to convey its significance."""' While a property's significance relates'to its role within -a-specifichistoric.context, its integrityrefers:to "a property's physical features and -how they relate to its significance."'x To determine if a property retains the physical characteristics corresponding to its historic _context; the National Register has: identified seven aspects of integrity. These are: Location is the e,place where thel historicproperty was, constructed or the place where the historic eventoccurred.-.. "Design i the: combination of;elements that create the formi,plan,'space,.structure, and style of a property... "Setting is the physical environment of a historic property "Materials is the physical elements that were combined or'deposited during a particular period of time and in a particular pattern or configuration to, form a historic property::. "Workmanship is, the physical evidence of.' -the crafts of, a particular culture or people during any given period in history or. prehistory... "Feeling is a property's'expression of the,aesthefic orh stone°sense:of aarticular p period of time... "Association is ihe-d-"`"l` ",l-. k between an important historic event or, person and a historic property. Since, integrity is based on, a property's significance within..a specific historic context, an evaluation of a property's integrity can only occur after historic significance has'been.established.x' California Office of Historic Preservation's Technical Assistance _Series .#,6, California -Register and. National Register.A Comparison, outlines the differences between the federal:and,state processes. The, context types to be u"sed whenpestablishing ,the significance :of a property for listingCalifornia Register are very. gn on the Cal similar, with em hasis on local and state significance. The y are: pa It 1s,:assoclaal or rth events that have made a signs ica a of Cahfotrnlatorthe broad ted w"di oufion f loc 1 States,�o g ry, or, the cultural .herit' g: the United items re ional histo 0 r P 2. It°is associated °with the lives of ersons'imp ortant to;Joeal,;Calfornia, or national history, or represents lresents dthe work of a m ve characteristics of.a type, period, or method of construction',or p aster, or`possesses high artistic values; or DP,R'5231. (1/95) j *Required information State of'California — The.Resodrees Agency Primary#: DEPARTMENT OF"�PAR KSAND RECREATION- �HRI# CONTIIVUATLOIdSHEET Trinomial Page 7 ,of T1' Resource Name "or'`# (Assigned`by recorder) ,301 First Street 'Recorded by: Ki ribei 1y'Butt°and.Connor°Turnbull *Date.- A fil 200 IF]Continuation: 1' l "4. Ithas-yielded, or'islikely,to yield, information important to prehistory or;history of the localarea, California, _,or the nation:""" Like the NRHP, evaluation for eligibility tothe California Register. require an establrshrnent of,historic g Y g ' y Id is slightly lower' than `the federal significance before inte rrt :: is:considered. California suite rit thresho Y x;;; level. -As a :result some resources that are;historicall si ihcant but do not meet NRNP mtegnty standards may be eligible for listing on the California Reg-'ster. California''s'list-.of'special considerations shorter more -lenient than the `NRHP. It includes --some' allowances for moved buildings, structures, or objects as well as lower requirements for pi`oving he x," Y n of the eligibility of reconstructed build* ss that:are:less than,, 50. ears o Id and a, more elaborate discussion g- Tn addition'to separate.evaluat ons for elig'ib'ility to the.Califomia. Registers the state will.au"tomatically list' Y or'the NRNP through a' complete evaluation process.X" resources if the are listed or_determined.eligible f The local register relevant to this liistonc, resource evaluation isPetaluma's list -of city, landmarks..The city governmenf'has formally adopted the CR1-1R criteria with emphasis on,local significance for'''use in determining'local landmark status. Findings .: we have assigned the,.property at 3,01 Firsf�Stre'& a NRHP'Status Code of 5,:which indica tes„in our opinion, `that. the property Js ineligible fot the National Register but is still. of loeal •interest as part .of a potential locally d' 'ated'historic distriet.x'i The warehouse does not,.individ'ually possess historic significance; and is ,therefore ineligible for individual .listing in'the NR.HP. Because the property is over 50 Years, old and istinot.one of the properfy'types that are generally automatically�disqual fieri=fro r►;listing-on; the NRHP,.ahis property has been evaluated, under the standard National: Register'Critena ;for Evaluation,. It is also,our Opinion that the property does not possess individual,historicsignificance and is'#herefore not eligible for individual listing on :the Cahforriia Register of Histonc.Resource_s Tle,property'has not been, automatically listed on the CRHRbecause itis not listed on, the NRH°P and: has not -been' determined, individually, eligible through a complete eevaliiationprocess, As a result, this propertyhas been evaluated... under 'the standard state, criteria: However; the 801 First Street, was identified during this, and previous evaluationsx"'' as belon -in to a. g P , - ' , Iocal.Histori' -$ g rou of warehouses that rrught>constitute.a c district if further documentation and• research . g were undertaken. As a group, the warehouses located Aon Frrst.Street are similar buildings, typically featurin cor g rugated metal cladding with either single or double gable roofs, and large openings. "These blocks 'of predominantly gabled<metal buildings, specifically, bounded' by First Street and the river are unified by their -industrial use and Criterion A.(NRHP•) ./ 1 (CRHR) The pro pert 3Q1' First Street is associated with events that;have mad edik p. = talurna's history..`The.warehouse was used toatore a si ifrcant contribution to the broad attems gf Pe g gra and feed. along with several other buildin salon First Street and in neighboring -streets that. served this and, 'related purposes: Although not eligible for,listing. in either,the national.or state registers,. together these properties couldpotentially forma local historic district. 'DPR124 (1195) 'Required' iriformati_on State'. California:—The Resources Agency Primary#';, DEPARTMENT OF PARKS 'AND RECREATIONAll HRI# _ �.®IVTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Pae 8: of ii e',or# (Awigned'6y recorder) 301 First Street 1i g Resource Nam 'Recorded by- Kimberly Butt and Connor Turnbull' *Date:' Apra 2003 ©Continuation ❑ Update Criterion B NRHP significant m our past. MaR uR) The: property,at 301 First Street-- is not associated with the; lives of persons p gnus, bnsen, the owner of the M. Vonsen Co. was a local businessman and operated several warehousegrain and feed business: s,,in', the area. He is one of a number of'Petaluma businessmeninvolvedin the Criterion C (NRNP) /3' (CRHR) . The property af..301 First Street does not embody the distinctive ethod,of construction. The prcperty'al Y cent characteristics of a t e, enod; or me so does not represent the work yP P of a master, possess"high';;arhstie valu s, or.represent a significant and, distinguishable entity whose components lack individual distinction. The'P roPerty is'characteristie of the warehouse type found in this area of Petaluma. Criterion D NRHP , 4'(CRHR-)- TheTroperty at'301 FirstxStreet has not yielded, nor is it likely to yield, resources, .# applies to any building,• structure • or object whose h sica Y - o archeological : - PP .. iterion is enerall applied t p y al"� fabric itself can be considered information important to: rehistor or history : While this cr an h sical fabric incl Street erty,,contains no visually=observable, above -ground elements whose artifact. e is i First, s unique materials, provides information on'special buildingtechni` ues or h potential to provide information"�ab'out� our' past. 9 as the Since 301 First!Street, althg g proper y ouotent�al locallhis� it is iml ortant to evaluated listed as a diva Y sign be p toric, district contributint to a r s as m P its integrity. Historic photographs located at the Petaluma: Museum and the Petaluma Library indicate that: Location. 301 First Street is in its original location: Design: Although not outstanding in its design, the form, style,, and plan contribute to its significance as a 'Contributing resource to a.,potential local-historicdistrict remain. g Setting.The. building is one of several•buildings that are part of;a potential local historic. district. Although Y the overall physical environment-. alre - ", .ger extant, there are still enough buildings to maintain other buildin s that once,stood nearb IVlatenals: The .� Ouse mater h ial is ezt`anf and in its original configuration. e ware Workmanship. Not applicable. Feelin :.This buildin to ether with its>neighbors continue to express the industrial nature of th g g=g e area as related to, the grain;and feed business. industrial complex of° ro erties important1° � dated with. oth Association. The warehouse continues to be associated _er similar uses that. characterize the. P p p to Petaluma's history. tend that tfie�building continues to .possess sufficient integrity such that it is 'able to convey its warehouse to be eligib a for contributing, dvresoidual .., a, potential local historic district, however we did not find the listing..., did' , State of California.— The'Resources;Agency; , Primary,# )EPARTMENdT"OF-PARKS,AND RECREATION, HRI_# CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial, gage `9,of 1_h° 'Resouree,Name or # (Assigned by recorder] 301:Firs4°5treet. *Recorded by Kimberly Butt and Connor Tumbt ll *Date: A1261 2Continuation , Updat Endrio,tes` „ ' Adair,Heig,,History. ofPetdluma: ACalifornia R yer'Town" (Petaluma; CA: S'aoitwall Associates, 1;9,82]: 123 " -Mildred Brooke Hoover; Hero Eugene Rensch, Ethel Grace Rensch, William N. Abeloe;;revi ed by, Douglas. E .Kyle; Historic Spots in Califomia (Sianford;, CA, Stanford,Univers'ity. Press; 2002);.5`13 Sanborn Fire Insurance Companyrpaps of Petaluma, CA, University of.California, Berkeley, Earth Sciences lili rary, online' S,anboriiFire.Insurance map reference. _ Katherine:Johnson;, "A W.alking`Tour df Petaluma's South,Central Ri'verfront Neighborhood" (0ctober'2001) Sherman Boivm and Lee Totliatt:(untitled'publication, pp: 12-13), Petaluma Museum biographical files; "M.`Vonsen." Department _ply t Intention19Register' Criteria or'E,valuation, National Register Bulletin ,r o 1'5 (Washington D' G.: Uh*ied,Staies vi. How to A .• 1 t Vn. How to Cornp/ete'the National`R, egister,Reg"istrationaForen,.National ;Register,Bulletiii, no 16A.;(W,'ashington, p C United StatesWDepartment oflhO Interior, 1997)` 75. to Apply,the,National'Register-Criteria"forEvaluatiori 3: yni;, How , ;ix. Ibid, 44:. x. !bid, 4445. xi.Ibid.45. Series, :no. 6' (Sacramento, CA: California Departh e'nt of Parks andrri'ia Officesof Histonc.Preservation Technical A§s stance xn , CaliforNa Registerand National Register, A Comparison,, Califo Recreation, 2001), : t•, xiii. Ibid. 1 xiv. Ibid, 2. xv. Alf State Hisiorica L Landmarks from number 77Q.onward,are also,automatically listed on', hwCkarnia Register (California Regrster of Histoncal'Resources. The•Listing Process, California Offce of°H storic Preservation Te. Series; no':.5 . ;[Sacramento, CA'California Department of Parks and Recreatioh; n;d.J, 1,.) :XV1"Instructionsi.for.-Recording,: Historical: Resources" (Sacramento, Office of Historic Preservation, 1.995,) River frdntVarehouse Dist 1ct,•Chapter 9 Historic Preservation, Central'Petaluma Specific Plan, Final Draft. Februa y`2003: 109.. x°"''Ibid, 110.. ,State of California — The Resources Agenc Y Primary # DEPARTMENT OF PARKS:AND RECREATIQN HRI# C,ONTINUATI'ON 'S HI -'ET , Pa9e 1Q of'11 Resource Name or. ned b reco omial Tri #�(Assig y eder)" 301' First Street° *Recorded"_by .KimberlyButt�and Connor"Tumbull *Date: A ri1,2 0 . _p Q� • ;0 Continuation ❑Update References Bio ra hical.. files b Sherman g p y Boivin'and'Lee Torliatt; Petaluma, Historical, Library and Museum, Petaluma, California. California Register and NationalRegister: A Comparison, California Office of Historic Preservation Technical Assistance Series no. 6.Sacramento CA: California Depart" i , , meet of'Parks ,and Recreation, 2001). California Register of I- listorical,Resources T„he:-Listing:Process; Califomia,Office,of Historic Preservation Technical Assistance Series; no. 5. (Sacramento, CA: California Department of Parks and Recreation, n;d.). Central Petaluma Specific Plan, Final Draft. February 2003, City of Petaluma, Planning Department, Petaluma, California Hei Adair. Histo o Petaluma,. ,a Cali ornia g� �y f f river town. (Petaluma;CA. Scoftwall, Associates, 1982). f Evaluation, TonalReiHowto Apply tgstgster,Bulletin, no. 15. (Washington, .C: United States DePartment of the Interiorl97) How to Complete the National Register Registration Form,'National Register Bulletin, no. 16A. (Washington, D.C.: United States Department of. the Interior, 19.97). Illustrated Atlas of Sonoma County: California. (Santa Rosa, CA: Reynolds & Proctor; 1897). f g) ( of Historic Instructions Preservation, .istorical Resources. Sacramento CA: Office. Johnson; Katherine. A Walking .Tour of "Petalumas South Central:Riverfront,Neighborhood,” October 2001. �. Johnson, Katherine. "425' First Street," State of California, Record 523A and -Building Structure. and Object Record"Department of Parks and Recreation, Primary ( )'(523B), December 1997. Kyle, Abeloe. History Spotsoin California.,(Stanford, CA: Stanford Univers t Pensch, and`, W llian N. YDouglasHe 1 y � ress, ,2002). Milliken arises for the Democrat PublishingCompany. Sonora George Rice &.So P Y a Couniyallustrated. (Los Angeles, CA: J e Press r g ns,'1901). i; *Napoli, Don. "Petaluma Commercial District National Register Nomination," National Park, Service, 1994. New.Historical Atlas of Sonoma County California. (Oakland, CA: Thos. H.'Thompson, 1877). DPR 523L (1/95) *Required information it. State'of California The Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OP PARKS AND RECREATION IiRI# CONTINUATION, SHEET Trinomial Page 11 of`l'i "R@SOUCC@ Name or*;(A"ssigned by recorder) 301 First Street °Recorded"by: Kimberly 'Bu ft, 'arid^Connor Turnbull *Date: April 2 O Continuation.0 lJpdafe l. Permit Files, City of Petaluma Community Development Department Building Division, `Petaluma, California: Petaluma-City.D'iectories,.1914-54; Pe Cal forntaluma_ History Room, Petaluma Regional. Branch Library,'Petaluma, a. Peterson, Dan. "Historic: Resource Inventory" of Petaluma," 1976. ' Photo Binders, Petaluma Historical Library and Museum, Petaluma California: Sanborn Fire Insurance Company Map ofPetaluma; CA, July, 1883 - September `1949; Earth Sciences and Map: Library, University of California at Berkeley. DPR.523L (1/95)' 'Required information • 0 State bf',Calif ofhia —The Resources� j DEPAO,MONITI& PARKS AND RECR PRIMARY RECORD Other Listings Review 'Cod6 HRI 9 Trinomial ` ,-. NRHP, Status Code 5 fewer Date P1. Other Identifier: Bar Aie Feed Co'Warehbus'e4l' "P2. 'Location': 0 Not for Publication' •ElUnre's''tric't6d *a. County: Sonoma, and '(P2b and Plc or Ptd. Attach a Location, M60, as necessary.). *b.,, USGS 7:5' Quad: Date: T R'/,:of '/4 of Sec M.D; B. M. c. Address: 317 First Street City:, Petalumar Zip: 94952 d. UTM: Zone: 10 rnE/ MN,(O.P.S.) e. Other Locational Data: (e.g., parcel#,directiohs'taresource, elevation 'etc.,avapproppqte) Elevation. Assessor's Parcel Number 008-1217011 *P3a. Description: (Describe resource and,its major elements. include ,des ig q-, mat rials. condition;, alterations, size, setting, and boundaries) This single -story, corrugateda concrete pad,,p'erpendicular to the Petaluma River facing 1" Street and is rectangular 4it' in plan. The woodrne structure; cture, eigh'teen-f6e in height, features a ra corrugated metalo-clad gable roof with extensive rusting and'an,awning eztendin' west1rbm the center of the west W elevation. The site feattires:thain-lirik'feric6s,,,aiong.,Firsi:Siriee�t on either'si'de.of;'the,�,war'ehouse.This simple structure, features no windows, however. two rectangularlo-tivered, vients,pierce.�th6�l§otiii�,gable ,'e"'h"d wall allowing ventilation. A , large metal clad sl southern ;1Street,,l!'eleVAon"h n&s fiom a metal track. A narrow hinged door piE,-. th stand at the to an Asl, Aal i",'r'a'mp� leading to the street. Ad�.:,: Corrugated -etal'! atc ing, visible on the e�,,6&qs �,ffbm the: west'�eteva tion. --f d' exiy of t Vlcbrrugated metal panels ie ormer openings, �ave; I eerri'm*fqled.'an connections have detached: fry --' , r., -,pJane. and much of ihe�exl:6rior.. surface Is c f 9,;Veted.in graffiti. On the south faqade wood boards infill a, rectangu, ari-opening in the eas6end,dthe wally The overall condition of the warehouse exterior is poor. *P3b. Resource Attributes: (List attributes�and codes H118-Inclustrial'Buildin SIWareh(Ais6 *P4;,,- Resources Present,: Ex ui ing� r6`10Object 0�ite,jpbi'stftt ctu -J W"v:x [3 Eiemen't 1 of District 00ther (isolates, etc.) P5b. Description of Photo: (View, date, accession #) .!Yi-e,w of the South Elevation Date Constructed/Age and ' Sources: ElHistoric OPrdhistoric 013oth •1935; City of Petaluma Parcel 'Informa tion, T4f. RepQ Owner and Address:, 3. J�arh s,MacNab III," 1 9r 3570r,`Riclgevi6v Dr ]Santa Rosa 4042' a Recorded by: .(Name, affiliation. :and,6ddibss) k, imb6fly"BLitt and. Connor Turnbull ,Carey &C6 Inc., 460 B'us'h SL, San Francisco, CA 94108 'P9: -'Date Recorded: Apri 12003' P1 0.. Survey Type: (Describe) 'Pr6*c.t R61atedjnclusive of ten properties Report 'Citation: (Cite survey ............ re0ort and other sources, or enter "none.") 1 1 I . , , it, Wtachmehii: 01�16it_ 01-6catiori M . a p 13 1 Sketch Map !]Continuation I I IRecord ®Building, Structure, and Object -Record DArchaeological Record ElDistrict Record OLin6ar Feature, e,,cor ''Sheet Station Record []Rock Art Record l� Mrtifap��Record, 0 to§rap" c ,,OMilling Ph6 h,Re ord 0 Other List DPR 523A (1/95) *Required information .. HRI# ry State of California— The Resources A enc . 9 _ Y Prima # DEPARTMENT OF:PARKS AND RECREATION' CONTINV ATION4SHEET Trinomial Pae 3 of Tl 9 'ResOurce`Name or, (Assigried by recorder) ;317 First Street;_. Recordedby: Kimberly'Butt ;and ConnorTurribull*Date: Apiil 2003'; ;D Continuation C'Upda*,*'