Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutStaff Report 08/01/2011 PRESENTATION i . . , __ t. , , re „ r' 50'N0MA. COUNTY � B, ' ,.. � . n ® " ® Wa ste . , , st ®q '^ .71 ® e 4' . � ® ® wi Ageng mM :... _ difuswid 1140 I i . , PAPER, PLASTIC, ' [d40 at .cS COMPOSTABLE, . REUSABLE, OR NO BAG? WASTE SYSTEM, LITTER, AND WATERWAY IMPACTS: Even,when placed in proper bins for disposal or recycling, carryout bags, ' WHAT DO 'YOU THINK . especially those made of plastic, can become airborne. From there they often SHOULD BE DONE ABOUT become litter or get entangled with landfill and recycling center equipment, .. , SINGLE -USE CARRYOUT requiring costly equipment repairs or workstoppage to clear the entanglement. • BAGS IN SONOMA ' Litter is unsightly, contributes to urban bl -storm drains „adds to.increas -• COUNTY? r ing municipal.costs, and is a threat to wildlife: Inaddition, trash in urban creeks , and water bodies is defined,by the, federal Clean Water Act as impairing beneficial •'' > ''� t , uses such as recreation and wildlife habitat. r� _ -� �'°` i o� , I 18 e 2 I LLION In Sonoma ma C ounty, waterways drain to thePacific Ocean, either directly or 'th the San Francisco Bay. The California Ocean Protection Council (OPC) , Estimated;2008' ' recently finalized its Implementation Strategy for the OPC Resolution to Reduce. California plastic carryputbag and Prevent; Ocean Litter. The strategy cites the elimination of packaging wastes use that contribute to litter, including single -use carryout bags, as a priority, and recommends a fee on paper and plastic bags as an incentive for using reusable 232 MILLION Estimated bags. 2008 Sonoma County plastic bag The 201 O •International Coastal tal Cleanup (ICC) report, produced by the Ocean 1.3 Plastic bags per 'Sonoma collected'worldwidedur1ng plastic bags werethe second most common debris item Conser.vancy,,found that pl gs p the annual one day coastal cleanup event. Cigarettes County resident, per day and cigarette filters were the most common item littered; paper bags were the tenth most common debris item collected. '9.8%3 2008 US • plastic bag recoverrate PAPER OR PLASTIC ?: 1 Most discussions about single-use carryout bags involve the question of which , 4 • \ - -' l', is better for the environment, paper or plastic.. According to the Green Cities , W . . . , , California Master Environmental Assessment on °the subject of carryout bags; * a paper bs. nerall e respects (e. a p g ,generally g' y have fewer environmental impacts in some res s) and others (e.g. ir aesthetics, biolo ical resources, resources) greater impactsin.ot 3 B 1 LLIO Estimated 2008 quality, water consumption, and mineral' q , , resources) when compared y p pared to plastic, California paper carryout bag use. bags.` However, in all areas wheresignificant data. existed, the MEA;found that” 46 MILLION Estimated 2008 reu were; associated. with fewer negative environmental impacts er, plastic, , than p p p ic, and compostable plastic carryout bags. Sonoma County pap bag use.. ° ' : 25' Paperbags per' t' Sonoma County Resident per How DO WE A WIDESPREAD day. CONSUMER SHIFT FROM DISPOSABLE, Si NGLE -USE BAGS' TO REUSABLE BAGS? 3 Z6% 2008 US EPA estimated paper bag recovery rate I leali 0 2 Estimated n EMAIL OR MAIL IDS' BY ARCH , 2011 © f t imes t es Sono na County s - SonomaCounty Waste Management Agency bags w ar Attn: Patrick Carter • artle a v- p „ea ea �f 2300 County Center Drive, Suite B-100 arranged ti 6 e by side Santo a Rosa, CA 95403 ca t @sonoma- countyorg : ¢, � � Y 4 ''' ECO- DES , K3565 DESK(3375) .: NVV W R ECYCLE?NOVV®OI G ,�' III n�lll I :Ii -a7 ,” .,�3` f'.k�t „ „,; ,,, , Sonoma County Waste Management Agency '• 2300 County Center Drive, Ste. B -100 • Santa Rosa, CA I r ai , I II ' � l I o I h i 40 i p ro I II II n �I l N I , , • j u�r j r l af) 1 �0,1 0 I I .F� ,u I��iPlu ',1, :Klkv ,E �dm0�4111 n ul . I 115 pp ��y a .� r ,� I1lI� • ';',',1' i I V • 7Yq d I I ^Ili i MI, �.d �'Y, V� `` ' � x� yl'„ 1��'�hll j1. PS 'A 1 P� � I „ o p 1 Ih1, 11 ■ IC 1 I�r IIIi!iNdl' �' 9�IJI^ �l •• � II�IU I P �I'' • 4 ro �d��pIl' �IiiIIh „ ; " II I IIII� � I�I�I I �gIII, . �illlji'�I,:; i111d��i�l1;l 0 IP '-rya iol � ,II ' .uI q II q Q/gy�p1 0 W ai 1 II 1 I. , W =0 o I II a) °> c. to 4.....J Q) 1 . U ...• . • (0 ■ - V) c X1 O 4J '4J. ® O • u 0 U • O . 4J 4J . ® (n >. . ® a.) 01 j E ....c H M. Ed r. 9 ur, p„ II" II N. • • n. 11IGYI , r u • � � I �I 11 I Iw III I I+li� v • 1 � I � 1 l ,,,,,�ll l l u 9 , kl pp I e 1 ' � I ;I {i f al l �71 I e 1 4-+ II b � { { I I Itl M l� In �� Y id l 1�� l 'il' u . W' O N E w �1', IV w d1 i 0 v I ' ,iii 3 r a. '14,',11'.. ` lY li 0 u r h 1 o 1 �� I > x a PI 1 9ri „ II I V L •Vf = = , , , �I Q .. L u , ) , •,i, , ,,,,,,, i I ' a '1I1Il \yl Q cu 0 • EL � �� , I � � � � d � d.a 4J 4 G ` ! , C I ' _ L ..±•+ l�r e • � I � , - - i• lis dI��I ' 1 141 111 I�{ fe E �� 0 "I ;9� plll` } V, 0• L I I II 'I I.. _ 1 • ? {, a ( L O A � _ — IX W • t r0 € � W W u, Q 'V 0I U, I' c a L ‘ ,, .,�� t ,; ro ' 0 1_0 _ ,„ O r 1 O Ct . L \E V CL L.) W a_ a —I 1 , N aJ c o .} I ” _ :a, a) .aJ ' 1 v W . V t ( ' s cCrl - �. i I a1, ,� O. iv : �, C �0. ' aJ O �� o V 0 a! • Il i II,Inliil �' � � , I,pd�i I II� � i 1 1 1 1 I I I II a Ildi I, I ,T. e Ii�II hill Ii III � , _ I I I I I ICI I i I I I 4, , _• , s '','A',\ ■',,,;,,, ,', I t i e lt I 4 i 10 4 01, r■ ,, I • ') "It 1 ■ I • 1 Ot1,11 i'l$\• I # I6 I t. " f,'■ tll Oii 2 Ttg g '01, ' 03 Nq I f....la X ..:C I W ,thillV , Ln 154' '4,Ww A l''' 1,. . ■ , ...4C lia IN +nj • ''•"• 1./1 itilri,1 I% t 1 , , •• > U -- cy10,11,11, ,1,.'i:1,41■1 a) a) r° ( .-i- C . . _... h■,,; 44.„.y. )0 ,;,,,„'01%, E ...._ 0 Q) < C --4. 0 a) a) .- a L.) >. c.) ull , c.:7) •c — 0 L C (Y) (D to r13 _ c L- C ‘... 0 -0 (0 0 D to Li—, ro 1/4„.) " w 4-1 r0 -t:i ' c l.) 0 C) C3 c co 1_ 4-1 E°r° O c 'na) ..._. • ›.... ,2 (r3 ro ._ 4- -C3 1- r-'- - o W (1) C 0 0.) a) - C3 4-) ,_ C CU n 0 c - C3 1 _ - _., l..) 2 • r .— a.- (i) LA , 4....i N. ro 0 0 - .... - V rrt -C 0 .... 4 _, C rti . —, , a) < -r3 u D C (NI _C • „_— 0 C LA U C (A, 0 2 0 c E 0 ,... 4--J a.) +.• - — (0 ,..0 4- , c 0-) f2e ›-E 0 _ r D Ili w . c_ 0 c Q U ) D , cu < o Li) 1:3 , 7:3 ...r. 0 • ...... 0 . ,,c -- ...0 • - 1 a.) EEC , U C ... 0 2 › fp CY) -----. CL 1-- C 8 _. ....,_ _., _ „ ca) 1- 4 _, co f -- %-, Li— a) 0 3 g _ o u cLo , ori) .... EcL. i c < ---- a) ‘Lo --- %.), CL U r .x ..... ...... %...... (1) m m U r�� i1,�lf l����l4 IIIU I�19�V 1�� 1 11 jd . � ,,I�� ,, i'��pIII,RIIN ��� , JII � II�� q II ' � '! IVl'ilp "I'klhvi.„�.,,,,, II I q1 F m, hl,� � �� '''' I � 6 F I III I I I A L...3f. ' k II�I 1 1 '� ° 'l l � 1„11„6416,1, l I CL rt n , 4— c � I�IP I I' °. �p� l l l�l1 U C tri 4pV {, II ip „ \ + � u Di J�Ij O W +�� 'f 4l l I l N ll l po l aili t.�. 4 ra Gi� I p l I �;��h�� F� 111 C V1 • III„ III �,IpryM1� I�(hl�q.,� 0 � L 0 �. u , . �„ c - C3 CU V III CI 4- -9--i ® �' U ' c 4 CD cu - 0 0 4- ' -c) 4J ” _ I ro . >' CU PB A ., „� 0 til Q cu 4-I rO LI-11 CCU ' F/j rO '4- - O V lJ a C s a) Q o. � . u 0 u Q ' � I w � , im■ ti) a . o _, " 4= � > . CI) a) ��vw o " 0 L7i ka,..) Lf) CD.. 0 FA f LA , s Y 1111 I I "II Il y l I I � l , 1 1 11 r • • • • •1 � iI UI 11 rzpu I A I , • �II In Illn!I�1�;le �' a , P FiI 0114kiq *6 �fi(1 a t l I ,� ∎, qi �I x1 r� I uji .g z ::: I " ' 4'' I ` texp ' 00,,k' d ,,, z ' 19 e= � I1 011 c'' (1.) �I 4� a a q I I ,�! 7�i1 . W I I hhhh u' u � I y 4 1 - I �I I � � �� l�,1 W �B 11I1 po Ilm I�h�il! I �I,� I v 'Il il u „ ��I h' Nj 1u; �I h ..... �� ' ��ui ii � t ° + 1 i� 4 D , II 1 I L. I ' ���I i,l ' ii ,k,,, ��41� � D di 11 I � �i X 141 ��I'I�! I I �'I ' ,I Ilt 9 11 1 �I i�;llllll j "�I q II I l. A�,ol1 {,'Ii Iu I i' u �� V I U I� I I IIII „lu a.) 0 0 4-0 ro u V1 L/ �/p�� q = ' to _ , III v) 4......J E c ra u cu Li— u vl ti) E (1.) a) ' 4-1:) -1:3 LLI C • u , V tili rci C tri 0 " C 0 u • L (1.) . .. 0 • > ......= • C cu E Do .� 0 ® Imp. Q � )' `u . ® COO // W u u u (� L.) f 0) 0 o II I I,. I 111 i h hln���u 4 I � b I u r '1 ,1 4 1 lu' i {iiJI la''I 1 I illuld,�l plll "NITl� IY116�1�it 'yslied�y'1i011I 1 1 MN� ; q 1 \I l ;.;'V1 "��Ilh i 0 ,,l,""'lli ",,,' Iihnf� �l� 1 4 0 3 i a � I y / /1 "� II -.cc �� 1r; � i dl II q ^ ., � c � 111 4• � l il�� 1911�I q �' r 0 0 L) �Q� j y l l } � l p ll c u � II �� p � q l III il l (� f o �y g�l P l il 'I I < ' c! W 0 � u u ih I I, �I� pll q ���l 4 -`� - ���� 0 T f I I I l ,, u E v, t C ,( . 43 . : „. ... D 0 C rts u to cu > rcs „I./#.1, I-- 0 E 0) ro 0 4 . I 0 D � v O sci.) f D � ® 1 ° 1 ll T / IA � _ F u ,.... U • l I II. i I I I II i I I dF 164 I • �I I � � I � 1 , 1 9�I II� d � �� "�f IfI +pVI � 14 'I N 7m l 'b , If d I � i t ��� N �h� � ry � p i i ��l P I 'IY�� � I lyfll ��}�i �I N Il l���I '� �14 IpiiPI�NII I ,y I I I !�rdy�G + � V � ll ���� t �4 1'Cflbl I II ' ��, 4P 'I'l t �Vi YI' ,JI l 4Tr f.III�11Y� , t\l 1 ,0,'b I\If 1 ; l.' • 4 IN' 11111,, 1 In 11q; � • Ir �' �� Nk �1 �I�fµ �I li ��I U IA pI�C H.1.„14,41,411111011I ll � � �0 a` %lN I� ' 1 II • • V 41 �f l I w!I l + }� I °I 1df '14'1, � I' gyp' �� 1 ���� 1, ���l I WI N II!,��'�I� T u I illI Id�Pulil�i� I �I�Ill I I'�I I a1 calf l' „" V IA, ,,�I� I �U �o l ' ,�� illy NY,74 ,„,ip1,,iik � ,,,,, .t 11 (' ��'I � �� { (�� GI II ����1 II�I,� I I ii° t � {III III�IIN . - �� N �� I' "ui�ll�l� I��' Il I f� ��� li �� I I �I 11 ��Ih l � Il I �i 'I �p�lyll II II Ill III f 01 �. n J�uI I�Vf�G .ul�Y ,l IIV� II Uq Y In� ,, QIy4 fI,, l�hl1,,,,, l,ltll�ll��1,0l�I,i .. iPPP d it U ( n ��III UPIINN I '�IfI�'�l l �hI 11 IA �, 1 l n U�l4h „ II' r hl Ilr I 41 1 Ih hhllhll, Ild Il 11l ,,l I',Itl�, In„ „1, „„ i�l4 l l,,,1 ^I ll lf�l .. ��l�� l �l I �Y l l�lil'iPll i rl4 � 11 � � 1 ll I� pP�� lil r id d �I llill� , :a . IiiII�P ill ll I ' I II III I�I'..III l �d'�- I-1 �, d io VII �h: I I I ICI I Ill PI �41V I? p 1�u +li I 1 4 I u r a Gi (1°) , 'I III II.I i6 - Q n , p� 0 (/1. > p 4 :� (1.) . ■ W (.1-.3 a 0 01020.1 1 11010. ,41 it . O • �+ il {” a l l1 u H • p • C Q 01 I li W • • i • II 0... ,, (11 kij 4r �C 4J 4JI u < 4J 4a . „, ; , ,, ... , , r ,, 4.....) 2 , I • 1 a.) E E u ' l� U 4J 4) d --0 • ....... • ",,,, ., 4J ,„ ,, .,, (. ., „ , qi • 3; • • U III Ilil 14 II I I l d I P 1�1 p l� I1 y � �11 1 M� i 6161 IpI 1j111� itl III � P if 1 III 51111 l� »' 11 NI n } ✓ I�Ph � rl l�r, I I A II �III I I l I I I . m 1 1 � °1 �1�1 N 1 ,� � NI �lh 1111� i S y ib � � I� � I� Il II l �� 11 �' � 1;,f I I�i 19II � I II I�� ��� 1 �� 4 i� � 1 ��1 1 P ! �I P I � 1 1�II, � \ I f' 111�1 II� A iilP�� ,I1 I (1 P 1flb �ll Iv I YIu III uhf \ 4 I P ) .-II �' 4�{ 1 • 1 , j� �p i PI 1 P ,' II r4� i fl 1 1 I 111 ' l e ll'Iw P1u III r IP' pp0 l'g I, I III ° N ' F 1 1 1 I 11,i I` i PPI 1 Illlt' 1 1�I Of � II laW � I �� Illd�l f�l 1 �IQili q � l 01 °.l 1J �h�v1 iy 0 i. / III 1 �� I l�l I 11I, 1 1 1 i�i� ll I 4 , I I�I I' >h 1I h m I q I � 4 p M I ��� pI��1�P � � 6I I 1 hlQl m i l � �d 1 I P, 1 1 JI 1 1 1 + ' 1 I i � II I Ill M yy � �1 �11 I ii 1� 1 III I dl hdl i1 p �1 I II I1 vo 1n u l � R 1 lu lu yl 1111 1 1� I �111� dN l�B�lu ll lo � �III � II p1 1 11 111 ��M I rb i ql l � ' . Yl ih. �" V 4 � II II �l u l . �p � I 1' 1 I 111 �11 al�l �� � l611 Iu � I��I I� I11�y1 �I �V III Il tl I 111 � I �� li �li it Pj 1 ��1 II h I� m II i1, 1 � I I 1II Ilhl I� q 1i 1111 I ;II 1 �1 i1� '�III� 11 I� IIn II d1 hP1 h III I ,, I H 1 i 1 11 11 1I 1 � 1 i ��1� +` ,�I�11Id1 ° Ilp I� ll �il V 11VII11�1'i�i ��; IIi If l ilir I�I I 1 i 1 77 1 11�1�� II I dP � 11 i Jh P�11 l �Ih'I� 4 11111 it � I I� Z, d I uiil 1,1 � 1 u � ' n 1 .: " d��1 1 1p' 1 1 1 1�i�ll�l� 11..I�I IlilIl 1111di11�.. ° 1IOI 111 .fluia 11r111�1� 111111111111 111111' 11111 II ��II��. 111 1 I II n111 III I �qi 1 '�i � 11�, c® 1 Ildl V, Ill II ICI 1 'q r I� 11 1 u I q 1 III�IU F Y I luk I 111I11�Il�lllll I � Iili 1 i 1 u LL 7 q „ " 11111111 'JI il� 1 1 il; 16 Idi, Illfli i " 1 ..;PI ii'I 'gill 1 1 II II . P V 1 ll 0 00 1 , uP' I M ell 0 a E E Lc, IIII V' ....... V cy.) c (I.) 0 L #..1.... • 11111191111119 2 4...; fo 0 N c tfl 0 (1: @,#) r.......... c:i.... lJ 2 VI ry,1 • 1 I ' 1 11 �h 1.,111 11 11�h,r. ,d „1 0 ll U11' I ” III I ; 1 � pd o ld 9 1111, ”: I1 dl? 1 P 1 1 I 1' hiI ��LI� Ii 11 11�!I. 1 :1 P IJ ° j I Illll�